MNOPQRS.T+,UI5)+VWXY

"

2 3 4

;<=>

#

^�de Zc�Í¡K

#

de ¡�¢a�7£ós

#

¤æ²ê¥:�K

9è

$

¦§è�<=èP�7£¨©

%

|XZªí«c¬­®

#

 ¡7£¯��e�Z

[°ù�rKQP�ݱ²³

#

´µXYc

'

��%&¶

(

²³

$

�·c

'

üý%&¶

(

²³

#

}`µXYÞ�·c

'

¸^%&¶

(

²³

%

¾¤ÃÄÅ}¹

#

de ¡7£¯�

�e�Z[°ùc��%&½�º]»¼]�l½�k�7�

#

¾Ílæ¯�d¿À

ÁÍÂÃè

$

ÄÅè�¸Þè]ÆcÏÝÇÈ

%

%&de ¡7£ÕÉû¯��e�

Z[°ù

#

]ÊårÍXZªíc

'

ˤ

(

»ÌÍÉ ¡7£ósc¯�³½

#

ÎrÐ

�dXZªí�]cUWÏ[�ݱÐ�T^

#

"ÍÉXZªí

'

˨

(

»Ìc·Ñ�

ÒÓ

#

ÔÕÖùÍ]��k�ͯ�°×cKز

#

���%ή¯��ÏÅ�e��

ÙÕ?i½cÚÛ�<=

%

?@A

#

de ¡

!

 ¡7£

!

e�Z[

!

Z[°ù

!

XZªí

»S-./0*¯-.jüe&Ály¼5�E

'

-.¬b×ØfgMN

!

Õ`�Ì

$

-.MN

% "

ª?¿\²OPî955sMNvV

'

Tª$�:r-..¨5)©MNG

á

(

�qà!�1R@8ña*Å`8

$

'åÜþ#ßÒ��£5e:Èk¯vM³M6

Ó

% '

7Ò

$

�¥jz¤R­é�E

'

x�VW�~

&

5s�Õ

&

ø°­U5MNvV

'

VXÙ

`4.×ØfgMNOI�

%

!

(

*5�^¤*-aØ^ªR@¨>ÿ

$

�4.MNOP^é

QRS.T+,UI

%

"

5$),k

(

P#VO>1ÒÅXRÿMNÈH5,>+�

'

TS

�6.T+,vVmRÿN3�L

(

$�¨.¨Ñ*¨¼y5ÌÍ`

'

JwÖ�Ça�n�

Ü-.MNOP

0

µE�ÇMéMNOPL.T+,UIQR5Álo+

0

P�x�:`

¯ÃÜ¥5²�,>¯®Á�?

(

q#ß��Õn

'

s�O$E�i3°ÿaÂy@

'

¤P

6\]f8g-$�rÌÍ

&

?@8g

&

ÎÏ�xÑ53³xöz

&

õ�+,^_<LÈ+;

)'))

"

!

"

,¤S.T×Ø5s���¥

$

jklI�rÄ­(ók»�óPAÖ¶³M\]

% !'#d8H"%%"

5\]�E

(

�qà

#*

åxaD��"u×Ø

'

áâ��r-.¬b×Øfg2�xè

,,,

$-./0*"�^za.rå�Ø

Å5}o

+ '

"

'"

i

'

jü>j×

''#"+

2j

(

*

-./0*"�^¤-�,òØ"*zavØC¤�D«

+ '

"

+

i

'

jü>j×

''#"%

2j

(

"

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

OD

!

'

Þ¶ã�ÇQR

&

�ÇõÁ<XOz�?ͪª«ß�XY

(

,¤�ã)+VW>5h

�

'

¶-.MN5OPî9»>VWXY

'

çLÀÂîÈODÄRMNOPQRS.T+,UI

5?$��

'

3Þ¨>Á®QR5)+VW+;

'

Õ&S53��r.T+,vV¯+,IJ®

rR£és,*õ

(

%

%

9:;<

#

34mnZ(9¾Ðéê

MNOP

'

»S)+sÕ«

'

�âo®.T­6MN5�ì

&

�x¯ø°RS<ODå®>

n5�%óPÑ­è(P

'

äf86ÜMN5ÎÏOP¯$°OPCÕÚ®

"

(

-.MN»S

jzMN¤RVÅ52�[¬

'

ª��:r-..¨AÁ�

'

çI(º�.TML<Ô

&

üýM

LÏÒ5%3MNvV

'

ä?¿­ûA­�5÷¬�OP

(

¶ë

'

-/�^¤*-aØÂ��Ñ

�D»>å�

(

P#![¯å�ÒÅS*õ

$

-.o+

%

¯Ö¶

$

�roy

%

¨KÿMN+�

#

'

TS¥Y-.MN5÷¬OPÿ$¨Kÿúv�¦§

'

®-.MN5ÍmOP,SŪ#Ñ�

p\²OPî9P�±ý

&

P�)355sMNvV

(

®rVW5s5h�$

'

î9±ª´�

VWúv5�,8�

'

Tå�­VW5�SÑäÙÚML

(

8Ü¥-.MN5OP

$

/�

%'

ç

R@äQRS.T+,UI5?$��

'

b%Ö�ãVW5sh�¶ä\²OPî9»>��

XY

(

®¦¬S

'

ÂPsOPî9$-.MN¯.T+,vV-5�nÑ仼$

'

ï�äå�

S��

&

ø°�¯A«��OOP§x

(

!

%

"

34mnZ'%9¾Ð

#

±À«¾Ð

��OP

'

®-.MNã·Ù-v®>n5,ÐÑ+¯�OP

(

ÿ=�Ð

'

®�¾¯+

Ð

'

ä$.T5MN�x¯ÙÚ-

'

I(Ù`8²�Ab��5¼�ÎÏ

(

P#ODïÕÂ,

>�

&

UV�d�OPî9n�Ü

(

ä-,>�OPî9ªx�-.MNOP5+,?î

(

#�D

'

5s×Øfg,>SÌÍ-.MNOP¨Kÿ+,�5,>Í&

(

�$

"%

��-

°

'

cde¯e(f$

*

/0**â

+

-ü�¶q,fgMN»>ÜXYæ�

'

q0¾¿§õ�

ÿNÿm­5×Ø·0J

'

¤T��ÿj]

$

þÿ±²û¨5

.

®�±1

/ '

üóT"­HÇy

50Vÿ

%

$

5³bËø

(

�ãUVæ`fgh<

'

¥]õ¡ÿ5s×Øfg,>vV

'

¶q,

fg\ÝMLxùÕÑ×Øfg\ÝâCxè5-È��»>5sÄR

(

cdefg,>5

5s�¯ÞI�

'

x�ÿ-.MN5+,OPÐÖ

(

r#�D

'

cdefg-.R5,>�

E

'

§äª�qà��r-.¬b×Øfge:S3#ÂÌÍ-.MNOP¨Kÿkl,>

qÐ

(

�qà��r-.¬b×Øfge:R@ÿ��r-./0*j5UVÊË

'

¶��

r-.¬b×Øfg5UV�n

&

f8jk

&

�,�h

&

Uhý�¯)+Ax<3°ÿa�n

55s´À

'

x���r'a¯ÙÚ-.¬b×Øfg55s�£>

'

PüSÒ�ÌÍ-.M

)$))

MNOPQRS.T+,UI5)+VWXY

!

"

#

$

P6rå�>¤ïË¿µ�J

#*

Õ

$

MNOP

% $

+,UI

%

Ö¶

$

��r

% $

�y�

% + '*

cdefgA®Á

+ ''#'#

2

"

"

&

-

_sx

#*

�MNOPQRS+,UI

,,,

.T+,®rR567Rí

+ '*

,>y@

+ ''#'#

2"

"

&

-

¶ô

ÿ

#*

MN

&

)BAUI

#

.T+,yÐ

,,,

R>-.MNOPÑUIQR

+ '*

)+s\]

+ ''#'#

2"

'

&

-

+Í+

#

*

7Ò)34.MNOPQRS+,UI

+ '*

,>Aöz

+ ''#'#

2"

"

&

-

·¸[

#*

*¯.T³xözA)+vMI

J²`

#

MNOPQRS+,UI5-.��

+ '*

Mï×Ø5s

+ ''#'#

2"

'

&

'

<<

(

Ë¿¬Ro

&

�¹

#*

�-.¬b×ØfgMNOPQRS+,UI5Á®��

+ '*

e:,>ÝÞ

+ ''#'#

2"

+

&

(

Ë¿µ�J

#*

Õ

$

MNOP

% $

+,UI

%

Ö¶

$

��r

% $

�y�

% + '*

cdefgA®Á

+ ''#'#

2"

"

&

(

*

cdee(fGg

+ '

"

"

h

'

"

)#$

i

'

jü>j×

''#"'

2j

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

N5OPºÁÿ,>+�

(

UV�OPî9ªx�-.MNOP5,vî9

(

UV»S»ð5-È8$

'

񁻮L

ùó5��3D

'

Tªjz¤R57-¯FÂ

!

(

¶ãMN��Þâ

'

UVªx�ä�£�5?

$+Ð

(

�$

"%'"

2

'

-/#�ü¨>wxq,Tí­M¯8¬û0¾¿s)5zËH�

'

S

-.zË5­æÚÇmRÿN3�L

(

-(jü/¯.�¡®

'

*�KjüÁÂ�¡ÿ��4

..¨5×Øfg)+MN¯B´MN

'

SÖ×û0¾¿s)ºÁÿ+�

(

özÇ÷Õ®

'

D¶

f¼Ïþ5®rR��H�

'

!"à�MN��¼$a/n�

'

çÙ>ÿ

$

Â-.5Á�>Ù

%'

$

��­-.¬b5×Øfg

%

"

52�<Æ

(

$¥$n

#$

×Øfg5,Sª¥÷·0J

'

ÙÚ

·0J

'

wxàá

'

wþdÒXR

'

)ItJ/;<=

%

#

(

$P#,k5ù`

'

-.MN5�x

­ÿ^ÓVW5s5e+¯��

(

ë®

'

*-�¨>

$

�Ñrå

%

²8e:Ñ5sÙÚÈ

'

S-

.MN5XRÙÚ¨Kÿ,>mº

(

�%�Õn

'

$Õ�qà;�Sa/5*-�5'Ô�K

`

'

.T+,vV¯+,IJÒ�ML®rR

'

3#Â53ÿ-.MN5�¤¯�Î

(

T®

'

-

.MNOP5(�Òª#½®�5

'

Þª$e&y¼-{Ï¢¿(�5

'

×ØfgMNê­OI

�

'

ªBÜUVìG55s[>

(

*512y¼�Vÿ-.MN5UVFÂ�

'

S'�MNÈH

¨KÿÔ�5UV�ùJ

'

çS-.MNOP53#ÂÌͨKÿ'Á+�

(

!

$

"

34mnZ'$9¾Ð

#

=>«¾Ð

ø°�OP

'

®-.MNãøQA$°-v®>n5ÜDÑÙÚ�OP

(

f8��¤R

�OPî9¯×Ø�OPî9d�z

(

¤R�OPî9ªx�-.MN­æ¯­Uø°5

?F,kùî

(

¤RªMNø°5?$�½

(

q�

)

��ª

!<5SE7 K-R0.-0"

¬S

'

¤Rªâ

$

�Õ

% $

�<

% $

ÎÏÈ

%

<x�5úv

$

(

ï¿

'

MNæ­;¤R¯Ä­(óP[�

'

#I^

é�Ù`ºK¯�ÕÎÏ

(

#�D

'

-(üý5O�iW¤RS-.MNOP5VXÌͨ

KÿëÝ5#X

(

û>ª¶

$

ëj�#

%

,:S�5Añ

'

�ª¶ü,Èk5s%

'

��pÿ

-.Èj¶ðé×Ø5¾ß&¿

'

T�S-.MNQæø°5À®

(

¤Ri8­~ãa-Î

Ï/­

'

ÎÏ/­�I(~5MNÈH5ÔR

'

PsÐS-.J#

&

-.C'5xÁ¯a-¨

Kÿ?$*õ

(

r#�D

'

zˤRA×Øfg%3¤R�SÌÍ-.MNOP¨Kÿkl

5,k+�

(

*512ñ¼ÒÅ(�ÿÈ�÷¬5MNvV

'

Tx�ÿÒS9<5C'¯¤

RqÐ

'

��C'

&

FGC'

&$

dÂ#Ã

%

C'¯�^C'

'

<<

'

PsC'¤Rx�-.M

N­Uø°5?$�î

(

�ãë

'

-/�^¤*-aؤRi85�N>Ù

'

=>Ô{-

.MN$)3jüC'u[�D5ÍmOP

(

×Ø�OPî9�ªx�-.MN­æ¯­Uø°5!FRSÍÏ

(

MN5Qæø°�

ÒÇäé5!$RS

(

p(Äf

),)

ªf

!<-LJ@511,OC-4/>"

¬S

'

MN,�ªâ£�

&

�v

<5

$

ï_vw

%

¯â�Å

&

­,�Õ<5

$

Øï_vw

%

x�5­³úv

'

Øï_vwõØï

_vw5

$

ÚÆ

% '

Þªx�

$

e&×ØyG©Â�5²8nÐ

%

%

(

;��MNÕq0¾¿è

éSa/ÚÇø»Ò;

'

-.MNr²jü5bõC'

(

�qà!�1{ÏÔ{

#$

jüª�ï

))))

)+s\]

'#'"

2"

$

&

!

"

#

$

%

Ë¿ö¨

&

esÇ

#*

UVñs

+ '

"

*

i

'

×Ø5s¤þ>j×

''##&

2j

(

-/-�.�mP��q�K

#*

!"à>*5��

+ '

"

'#%

i

'

jü>j×

'"%%#

2j

(

*

!"à¤G

+ '

"

$

h

'

"

$+$

i

'

jü>j×

'"%%$

2j

(

Ë¿q�

)

��ª

#*

×Øs

+ !

"

"#

j

" '

"

((,+#

i

'

-.jü�s>j×

'"%%%

2j

(

p(Äf

),)

ªf

#*

MN

&

MNyGAB´�U

+ '

"

*",*'

i

'

(�>j×

&

Åajü>j×

''##&

2j

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

5£È

%

!

'$

jü¶ðé·45Lzüª4]5,u¥�

%

"

(

PsÐ$-ÈÅÉDjü5fv

Èó�¯Iù�

'

3Þõ�>�oãq,fgMNø°^ÓQó

&

7Ò5×ØRS¯¬;ª�

(

åÞâo

'

PsOPî9?pü.¶-.MN5HHJ

&

*aJ

'

ÕÑâë}Ù5��ËA:N

'

<<

(

×Ø�OPî9+#ã*R5×ØVW

'

­­ëÝ5ÈÙ�

&

�4�

'

ä$X�DNÅÒ

Åx�-.MNOP57Ò�E

'

TSMNø°OP5Ù`¨Kÿ!$A«

(

!

(

"

34mnZ'(9¾Ð

#

]Æ«¾Ð

A«�OP

'

®-.MNãÙÚ¯õÁ-v®>n5[äÑ�L�OP

(

P#OD5OP

î9+,Åüv®$-./0*5�K¯$)Å

(

MN»S×Ø5ÊË��

'

;�­­?$5

f�

( d)

PÌ

)

ÍCf

!dOML9K0/041"

ü�¬S

#$

MN5(�^\ÐÈ°S¦o�5±�

»¼

%

#

(

ÏfÎ

)

�,­

!e>-41/0E. N03@0."

��MN��S

$

Ñjz×ض­65Ss6Vz

Ss»¼5#Ãe:�t

%

$

(

ï¿

'

MN5øQ¯õÁ�ÒÇ!$J#5fK¯L�

(

$��

)+vM`

'

)+VW±�,SŪ#«

$

±1

%'

n

$

Ô¦Ñé

'

¢¦Ï,

%

%

'

Px�äMÕd

%5?$6Ó

(

Þ-./0*5aD�K¯e&$)

'

�ÍÝx�ÿ-.MN$Sü¯�ÁÅ

5Ô�A«J#

(

-./0*»S$)*

'

ä�K�nõØA·ín

'

Þª$et125y¼-

âUV¯jü»>5ï@Gá

(

ïªîS*5'Ô�K¯aD�K

'

-.jü#Á®ÿâ<J

Ô5+,Qy

'

TïªîS*55s$)

&

üf$)¯Í£$ú

'

-.jü#Ç¡>ÿ-.¬b

×Øfgp+

'

Á®üýÏÒ5UV2¹#­ÿ®Áï°�

(

�ãë

'

*5�^��-./0*

5�K��S-.¬b×ØfgÑäMN5),S¬�¯)�OP

(

�­*$)+�5Öׯ

e&$)IJÒ�CJ¨�

'

-.MN5Ím�OP\�3#ÂÌͯÙ`>n

(

$

%

;¡?@

#

mn¾ÐAGH4lW[ÑÒZ(XõB

-.MN5�OOP§xÑä?¿5$�OPî9

'

P�0V

&

�S)3

'

ä-�Ð�OP

Oª%$N¨

'

ø°�OPOª²8*Ð

'

A«�OPO�x�ÿ+,ÍÏ

(

¶P#Oz§x5

��XY

'

ïS7@�ÜMNOP¨K��¦§

'

TS)äÁ®+,UIQRmRÿVW��

L

(

Â,>ÅA

'

MN�xª.T+,ÑäUI¨�5�,N¨

'

¤MN»Scó57�

'

,�

ÒØÈ°Ù`¨¼

(

5ùMNOPQRS.T+,UI

'

\Ãê~#s�,W�

#

ä#

'

Âfv5�N$

'

\Ã(�a�n5ÙùJ¯$°J

( $

£�MN5·ËJ$ã$

°

%

&

(

5ùMNOPQRS.T+,UI

'

Û8MN,�ê~ïæ»�

'

O�ÉMN$°fv

8è¡MNÈH

'

ßÁrsMN

'

âë#I@AMN55­U¯��·%

(

äy

'

ÂÜD5�N

$

'

\Ã@AMNvV5¶{R

(

-.MNª#Ñ?¿+,MN

&

�,MN¯²8MN5\²M

NvV

'

8)3äOPQRS.T+,UI

'

üÛ8$E�MN�¢J²l­J¯¶{­N

'

â

)*))

MNOPQRS.T+,UI5)+VWXY

!

"

#

$

%

&

-/-�*V¯¤þ\](

&

-�

$

Ò-./

&

01ÊË

%

f?ÝÞ�K"´.�K

#*

�qà6ã

$

Ò-./

&

01Ê

Ë

%

>1Ñ«

+ '

"

")*

i

'

*�_`>j×

&

-�¤þ>j×

''#"%

2j

(

-/-�¤þ\]K

#*

�qà6ãaDÂ'+*>1Ñ«

+ '

"

("

i

'

-�¤þ>j×

''#"(

2j

(

d)

PÌ

)

ÍCf

#*

)+5s-5MN,>

#$

�MNfg

%+'

"

%&

i

'

Åa��>jgu

&

Åajü>j×

''#""

2j

(

�,­

#*

­�¾¿>

,,,

6ãMN5B´\]

+ '

"

")&

i

'

��À�Ç

''#"%

2j

(

Î.¹

)

j¹

#*

q,fg¤Rjk

+ '

"

$#$

i

'

·4

)

_�

)

�¦�0�Ã

'"%&%

2j

(

-/-���ìJ,òØ

&

-/-�¤þ\]K

#*

�qà6ã'R*5��¯�ò>1Ñ«

+ '

"

&&

i

'

-�¤þ>

j×

&

-.�ï>j×

''#"(

2j

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

ë#I$MNvVÁ®

$

¯Ò/¥

%

-

'

`n�OOP§xÑäî9»¼5)�Ù`

(

ä�

'

Â

¶�5�N$

'

\Ã53.T+,5MNR

(

.T+,5+,¥�$Á®.T5ÙÚ¯Óæ5

Q�

(

û>ªMNª¾YzMNOPî9ª¾

'

ÐÒI`n

$

ä£6+

%

5,:¥�

'

æ­Á®

OPMNA.T+,5 /²l

'

#I$.T+,Ál-0·£aUÖ

(

ä*

'

Â[E5�N

$

'

\ÃÁ®+,UI5ï#R

(

UIX�DNŪ���8$5

'

èÑ�à

&

U᯲�<

\ÑÕ«

'

POå�$y@MNOP5QR��-

'

�Ö¶.T+,UI50>ò©»>ÔÕt

?

'

âë#I¶MNOPÑäÁlÎÏ»>^ÓR@5��

(

MNOPQRS.T+,UI5Å1W�

'

-ÈÅåRÿä?$QRÜD5Ïþ�

(

85

ù�OOP§xÁ®5sQR

'

ç`n.T+,UI¨�

'

\Ã�ã)+VW>h�

'

¶MN5

\²OPî9;.T+,Ál»>C7naD5ú�

'

âë#I`n.T+,UI5)�R

(

VWe��£ªjzy]��,гP5²8XY�£

'

ÈIÖ5%ñ��׳f

!e>5@01"&

\

�

!K@5/-"

¯ÚZÇ\Å

!24E1/-/@0"

<

'

$ÄÀö`x�¯öÐ+,³M53D-

'

Ðø¼ÿV

W�5XY,k

(

ÝÞ

'

»SVWe��£�ÕnÐ5VW5s5�ï�·ª$

'#

��o®

(

'#

��

$#

2r

'

³�è·`sT+Å�I

)

{

)

jÄØÙ

!cON-.Od04/5@5.UU9"

¨>ÿ#ÃVW

>

!M0.045@H91/0Ge>0-49"'

��­®rVW5s5�ï�·

!

(

ë®

'

$

?ObO

ÚdÛ¹

!?-364/

bOI56>-@"&_O_O

ÈÅ

!_5449_OM--70"

<s¦55ù`

'

VW5sÒ�CÕXR¯°Ú

'

$5

ùjz5µ5ÙÚ-DJÿ7Ò»¼

(

�­VW5s¸¹J5Ò�Æ�

'

ä$Ál-OÇHL×Ø5sF«

( '#

��

*#

2r®

'

Õq�

)

ÌfÉ

!<5SE7 b51/-."&

ÓýZ�¹

)2)

عÜÅ

!M534E0@2O2@G-.7"

<Srå5)

+VW>

!K-@E/E65@H91/0Ge>0-49"

D�

'

$53®r)+\]-0·ÿ¼�¸¹

(

�ÌfÉüm

>

'

)+·4,SŪâ.T

&

)*<x�5­³VW

'

ÒÅê­Oz�

&

ùó�<?$¬�

'

Þ

nµ­QR5!$Ç÷�

(

!FRS6Ü

$

Ûñ

% ! 70G5.71"

¯

$

*a

% !1LRR-4/"

稦)+V

W

$

m�

%!E.RL/1"'

ÕëSN¨

'

)+VWÚÇ?F

$

5,

% ! R4-6011E.J"'

ç6ÜåBF}��V

W5

$

m>

%!-L/RL/1"

¯

$

{Ý

%!U007356F"(

$ÌfÉ$n

'

)+VW�Ç�£Á®aÂ�5Ù

Ú

'

x�

$

)+·4XY5-/�?

%

"

(

عÜŬS

'

®r)+´À¯)+vV,SŪ

$

#

Ñê­RÍ)+¥55[x

%

#

'

)+vV6ÜÜD

&

)BÑä¥�<ÓÕÚ®

'

�S

$

­Ä­�

M�¯Añgv¥�5kê

%

$

(

âë

'

عÜÅ�)+ÙÚ��S)+¨I5ÙÚ

'

3Þ¨>

ÿ[x¨Ifg)+XY,>

'

S®r)+ÙÚ¨Kÿ#Ñ�5¥À¦§

(

ÖEÆ

'

)+VW>¶×Ø)+·45XY

'

±ª�/åB�?Å5²8=Ü

'

Tª:r)

+5s\]5#zÞT

(

Â9ßkê,�h�$

'

äXY¦§OSÄÀ-.MNOP¯.T+

,UI5QR��¨KÿîÈ,+

(

-/�^¤$-aØOR@¨>

$

'aVWÈk

%

%

5$)

8ñ

'

PTS.T+,5VW�ÚǨKÿ)Bmº

(

Â)+VW>5XYh�$

'

-.MN5

OPî9,SÅx�ÿ)+VWm�5å8�y#

!1LGG549S54E53@01"'

{é5ª)+VW,�

5®Á�Ûñ

'

nÙ`­¼�5kê�ÎÏ

(

)+VW¶\²MNOPî95��

&

ú�¯5

)())

)+s\]

'#'"

2"

$

&

!

"

#

%

Ë¿°àá

#*

VW5så8

+ '

"

"%,'#

i

'

Oï*;s(>j×

''###

2j

(

q�

)

ÌfÉ

#*

)+·45VWXY

+ '

"

)*"

i

'

jü>j×

''#"'

2j

(

$

!

ÓýZ�¹

)2)

عÜÅ

&

"

M)

âãä

)

å%¹

#*

��)+s

,,,

vV

&

ÜD¯)B

+ '

"

**

i

'

"

+

i

'

�>

j×

''##+

2j

(

*

-/-�6ãM�.üB´¯×ØÙÚ"�*Ñ$2�í¯yæ�$2ùÍ¥�5�C

+ '

"

+

i

'

jü>j×

'

'#'#

2j

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

,

'

�)�ÿ)+VW5+,�Q�

'

3Þ$Ál-t�¶.T+,UI5ú%�m>

!5L/>-4E/5/ES0-L/RL/"

¯P6�m>

!511-6E5/07 -L/RL/"'

�3°ÎÏX�

&

¨Kvw�5åBçÚ

Çêv°ù<

(

$ë�2Å

'

)+VW6Ü

$

{Ýçß

% !U007356F 1/EGL@E"

¯

$

{Ý{Ö

%

!U007356F 401R-.10"'

3#Â53MN\²OPî95�6A¨�

(

ï¿

'

)+VW>ÁSŨKÿ#Ñ­6MNOPQRS.T+,UI5?$ùóR+

'

ä

-

'

MNOPî95)+VWm�ªb8N¨

'

)+VW¶\²OPî95��¯5,ª?$a

/

'

ÞP6)B¯)+°S5VWm>�x�ìG.T+,UI567

'

P#ø»ÜD-HÇ#

ÑRí5ã�¯r�

'

ÐïIMv.T+,UI5Ù`

(

$)+fv;!$RSÚÇ�ù-

'

Á

lÛñª5ùMNOPî9m�)+VW5+,�î

'

îë

'

8)äÁ®­Uø»

'

ü837¯

R@MN\²OPî95m�¯��fv

'

æë#I(�)+VWø°5aÂ�ùJ

'

3Þt�

?$QRÜD5­UÁ®

(

ÂŤï¿

'

-.MN5OPî9§?¿\Ñ�X

'

¤äOPî9f

8nÈã$)*¯ü.d��D

(

ä--.MN$�K�D¯,>�DOPî9

'

ª$$)*

55s$)

&

üf$)¯Í£$)`�xÞn5

'

-.MN5×Ø�OPî9�+,ÅSjü�

.ÿ�Ü

'

Û8$ü.5��ËA-CÕ0·

(

AëP¶Ö

'

-.MN5¤R�

&

UV�OPî

9

'

�ÍÝÛ86Ü$)*;ü.5ä��ù#IÁ®

(

�ãë

'

4]äïè�>#Ñ6ã5ù

-.MNOPQRS.T+,UI5a�,>^Î

!

�

""(

!

C

!"

34mn¾ÐAGH4lW[ÑÒZD°õö

!

âë^Îï¿

'

-.MNOPQRS.T+,UI5��Á®f86Ü�²^_ÚÇ

#

#ª$)*»S+,�*afv5

$

fK5ùÎ

%

QR^_

(

$E^_-

'

$)*x�-.

MNOPî9QR5+,ùJfv

'

@PÿE¿*´À¶-.MNOPî95)+VWm�

'

.

T+,-éà©$$)*5�K`ÚÇ5?Fú�A5,

'

�/)B5)+VWm>A{é$

×ØB´¤R·ó<VW?5.T+,UIÌÍ

'

Ñ$¶.T+,UIt?çA5�2Å

'

53

P6H¸{Ý<ùóR+

(

5ùMN5OPî9L.T+,UI3°QR

'

$)*b%8Õ�

»�

'

S5ù-.MNEOPî95)+VWm�¨KÔ�*aJ#

'

���OPO5,>�

)+))

MNOPQRS.T+,UI5)+VWXY

! �-5UV�OPî9/

&

¤R�OPî9/»S)+VW5?·OP

'

ªâ$)*$fK5ùzË

&

��¯öz5

3D-(�5

'

ÞUV�OPî90

&

¤R�OPî90�+Ðãjü�.e&5×Ø·0¯·4Ál

'

y¦,SÅ

ªPBP�

&

�S V5

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

OPî9

&

A«�OPO5�K�OPî9

'

<<

(

ª«PsOPî95VWm�

'

.T+,U

I�MÕ�D

(

$)*�ãÈ�5aD�K¯e&$)ïSMNOPL.T+,UI5QR¨

KQ��¯a��5*aJ¯5ùJ

'

Þ6Ü)+VW5ú�

&

m>¯H¸{Ý

'

�S$)*ö3

¯�6MNOP¨KÿH¸*õ

(

3���rÕn

'

�­-./0*5�K¯$)IJ5Ò�Ô

R

'

-.MNêÙ>Nÿm­5·ËJ

'

SÁ®.T+,UI5¨�¨Kÿ^Ó'Á5+�

(

yªü.»SËA�*afv5

$

ËA5ùÎ

%

QR^_

(

$)+VW5ø°-

'

þÿ)

*

&

.T!

'

ü.Ox�ÒïJh5²8fv

!

(

jüüfs)5.T�S

'

å�ÿ4.5#ß

úJ¼ãjü

(

ü.ËAÒÅ­~ã$)*$.T+,-¢JÑ�Ù®�?ç¥å�?

'

Þn

I(5ùMNvV^ÓX��M3Ál

'

ÂÞ$ÔRMN$°J5�2Å

'

S@AMNOPî9

QRS.T+,UIºÁ×Ø+�

(

$E^_-

'

ü.»SËAfv6Ü�MN5×Ø�OP

î9m�)+VW

'

+,-éà©6Ü��Aú�Á®)Bm>

'

ÕS.T+,UI¨�¨K×

Ø+�

(

Þn­yã$)*5

$

fK5ùÎ

%

QR^_

'

ü.5*a¯ËA5ùX�DNŪÈ

Ù3°5

'

îÞ^ê�U�

&

-�

'

­~ã5ùMNOPî9QRUá53#¨�

(

�ª$)*;ü.»S0��*afv5

$

¶»5ùÎ

%

QR^_

(

$E^_-

'

$)*¯

ü.$5ùMNOPQRS.T+,UI5ÜD-

'

Á®ÿ�ù0�¯ /¶;

'

/;*aç5

ùMNOPî95úvÙ`

(

ÂVW5s5�N$

'

úvAFXê­

$

ӯ�

%

¯

$

ØÓ¯�

%

ç

85¬�

'

@Aúv¨I�ãFX

'

�ÒÇÔRVWúv5´ÀRDN

"

(

-./0*¯*�j

ü-.$e&5zË

&

��¯öz3D-(�5 /0V

'

Sy¦�x0�

&

�ù¯ /¶»¨

Kÿ'Á5UV+�¯®ÁïI�

(

�6Üy¦5�ù¶;

'

5ù*�K¯�x5UV�OP

î9/

!

�zËV<

"&

¤R�OPî9/

!

�×Øfga/ÎÏÈ<

"

¯âü.õ�5UV�O

Pî90

!

�Ý1V<

"

¯¤R�OPî90

!

�O�iW¤R<

"

5ý�m�

'

Õ@AMNOP

î95ú�¯[x¨I5)�R

(

-./0*»Sjü5*

'

þÿ-.)*�jü+,èéo

!ûÈ�¬½èé

'

PSä�x¯Á®;ü.5H¸06¯¨I� ¨Kÿõ©W�

(

�oã

��q,fgMN`)*P�±ë¯)�:V^ÛK�MN¾�¯+,¾U5-Èò©Þâ

'

PÍÝx�ÿ-./0*3°.T+,5÷¬OP

(

E^_5ÚÇïÕÆS5ùMNOPQR

S.T+,UI¨Kÿ¬²�A«

(

(

%

EËEF

#

mn¾ÐAGH4lW[ÑÒZµGHI

¶-.MN�OOP§xÑäî95VW��

'

Ñ�ã)+VW^ζä?$QR��5

ùóì,

'

­~ã-/E¿´À»SfK5ùfvR@�H

&

Ò�í7VWø°«kÕÑÔR?

FQR5*aùJ

(

¤8@AMNOPî9$)+VW?FÁ®L.T+,UI5­æ­UQ

R

'

Û3#ÂÂÁlODÅ»>XY¯\�

(

!

%

"

mn¾ÐAGH4lW[ÑÒZ¶µJ±

"O

��r-./0*mKe:5õ�¯aDÂ'+*LÆXÙÚ

'

S-.MN\ÑODO

Pî95)+VWm�_�Ô�5fK*aJ¯5ùJ

(

Pf8g-$�Ð�OPO¯A«�

OPOd�D

'

=>å®S,>�¯�K�OPî95VW87Å

(

Âbz>Ñ

$

-.#

%

J

)&))

)+s\]

'#'"

2"

$

&

!

"

Ë¿¬�¡

#*

)+VWs

+ '

"

$

i

'

¦­0ú>j×

''#"$

2j

(

Ë¿îïü

&

Ä�ð

&

+ôÊ

&

 Yñ

&

cêò

&

óu+

#*

VW5s

+ '

"

%),%*

i

'

Åajü>j×

'"%&+

2j

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

,JÁ®

$

dÑ#12

%

,u¥�

'

ÂW"53

$

$n#v

%

5!vý�J¶{53

$

*ÑaD

%

5Uhý�

'

Âõ���¨>�ÙÚ,kJ»>��r×Øf8jkyR5�>�

'

�%�Õ

n

'

-/-�$E�DÒ�Á®ÙÚõ�

'

çâëõ¡ÿ�qà��r-.¬b×Øfge

:

(

-/-�¶��r'aAÙÚ���5-.¬b×Øfg

'

Ñ��'aAÙÚ-.¬b

×ØfgPѲ��?»>ÿVW�5¥³

(

$P#e:5mK`

'

Õ�qà;�Sa/5

*-��aDÂ'+*¼$ÿa/n�

'

�qà!�1R@m>

#$

¸¹ÙÚÏû´S

'

/0*

j5./ÏùÒIöy

%

!

(

ïª�ãÔY5ÊËÄ­¯�Hé:

'

3���rÕn-./0*

5$)IJCJ¼�¨�

'

S5ù-.MN$,>¯�K�DOPî95Ò�87¨Kÿ+,

�5A«¯*aJ#

(

'O

��rÕn-./0*�K.T��5²�=ܯUV��ü

'

S5ù-.MNOPQ

RS.T+,UI`�ÿõ©5!FRS

(

)+VWõØô¡8$

'

\Ý8;qÿ55RSÙ

·H¸¯I#±�

'

ä±

$

ÂPsRS-

'

0·ÿE«¸¹

%'$

µ¶)+VW��ÿïI5Ü

J

%

"

(

3���rÕn

'

-.×ØB´¤R·ó<E�iÙÚ5²�=Ü

'

3#ÂS5ù-.

MN5OPî9L.T+,UI5ßÁQR`�ÿäé5LÈRS

(

#�D

'

��r.T��

5²�=Ü

'

S5ù-.MNOPQRS.T+,UI¨Kÿ^ÓÔ�5ïL*a

( $

*a

%

»

S)+VWøQ5²8y#

'

��ÿ

$

wÒ*a

% ! .0J5/ES01LRR-4/1"

¯

$

7Ò*a

% ! R511ES0

1LRR-4/1"(

N¦�k)+VWø°

'

®¦�)3)+VW5È4ÙÚ

'

$*5aD�K`

'

��

r-.B´5Q-ñ3

&

e&Lé

'

üf£+5Ò�3Â

&

·óRSò©5RÍö6

&

jü·4ß

à5Ò�¨�

'

<<

'

Ò�ÔRÿ-.MN5$°J

'

TSMNOPî96Ü)+VWQRS.

T+,UI¨Kÿ^\57Ò*a

(

r#�D

'

��r.T��5²�=Ü

'

TSõ¥)+VW

5ø°ÜJ¨Kÿ!$A«

(

§äª�­aD��×Øfg®rR.T��D5Çø

'

O$Ô

R)+VW�HJ5�2Å

'

S5ù-.MNOPßÁQRS.T+,UIíþÿ®Á«k

(

!

$

"

mn¾ÐAGH4lW[ÑÒZ¶µKL

��r-./0*mKe:5õ�`ù.T��5²�=Ü

'

S5ùMNOPQRS.T

+,UI¨KÿÔ�5)+VW*a

'

¤\Ãm>

'

:NÙÚ-ÍÝ8$#s®Á£¤%° 

¡

'

¶5ùMNOPî9L.T+,UI5QRO`nÿ®ÁMv

(

"O

Â+,�fv5h�$

'

$)*­6MNOPQRS.T+,UI5fK*aJ§Ò�

ÔR

'

¤ä5ùÜD­°3#¨�C7�

(

-./0*5�KJ

&

*aJ¯5ùJê­å��

Äg

(

q2n

'

-/-�$9*+*Å�UÍm

'

¤:N*5$)RS��SÏþ

'

ä$)+V

W?fK5ùMNOPQRS.T+,UI5ÜD�8$´\5£¤

'

f8v®$MNOPî

95N&ÌÍÑ.T+,UI5®&QRd��D

#

ä#

'

ÂN&5ù$

'

ëìfg¯(_fg

�?ªf8+Ð

(

&-��,.Tt,5)�Wì

''#'#

2

"

�

"'

Å5

'

a./J5Ó{-

�%���C'�?

"$('#$

D

'

ä-ëìfg¯(_fg�?tJ

+&+""

D

'

6JaF�?!

ç5

*+O&P'

��Á�¯��-.

&

¤KØa{²RÕÑÜN¿¼<�Sf8�?

#

(

Ps�

)%))

MNOPQRS.T+,UI5)+VWXY

!

"

#

-/-�*V¯¤þ\](

&

-�

$

Ò-./

&

01ÊË

%

f?ÝÞ�K"´.�K

#*

�qà6ã

$

Ò-./

&

01Ê

Ë

%

>1Ñ«

+ '

"

")

i

(

q�

)

ÌfÉ

#*

)+·45VWXY

+ '

"

'"

i

(

P6ç&+&-��,.Tt,�ýH¸3°ì@ÿC

'

êvË¿-��,.Tt,

#*'#'#

2

"'

Åa.J5Ó{-�

%���C'�?

"&*#*

D

+''#'"

2

"

Å

'(

X

'>//R#QQ:::O667EOJ-SO6.Q/-L/E5-Q'#'"#"Q/'#'"#"'(W'$)&#%O>/G@''#'"

2

'

Å

$

X

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

?ÒÅ�k)+VW­Uø°

'

TÒ1w¥MN5,>�¯�K�<OPî95Ù`

(

äy

'

Â

®&QR$

'

vM¯³MOD5«kªx�MNOPî9L.T+,UIQR5®Á�C

(

P

#OD5£¤å®$vMÅüª¸¹.T+,UIÙ`5E«ö0%m­U7þ

'

å®$³M

Å)=>5üªa�n5UIçγM%m��5s�x

'

K�MNOPî9A.T+,Ál

>®�P�í5t³

'

ÕÑ)+VW>®

$

�FªQ

%

5Ó�

'

\Ã6Ü3#ÂÔR*fK5ù

5C7JÓÕÜ¥

(

'O

ÂËA�fv5h�$

'

ü.ËA*aMNOPQRS.T+,UI5Ä9¯7Ò�§

Ò�¨�

'

¤ä$ËA5ù5ÜDůÃ3#ÂÓÔ�Õ�

(

�ü5)+IJ¯ËA»Süf

pg5a/

'

¸¹J)+VW5�£�

!

(

¸ÁÅ

'

ü.5ËA*aX�DNÅTªx�MN5

×Ø�

&

¤R�OPî9Ò�87

'

3Þ~5.T+,UI¨�5!$A«

(

�%�Õn

'

-/

-�'ajü¡Ç¯jü�Å5ÙÚ,k

'

�jü¶ðé·45LzhS,u¥�

'

Êjü·4

ßàCJÿÍmö6¯¨�

(

q2n

'

ü.5ËAÄ9Ò�ÔR

'

ÝÞ

'

ü.ËAÜD5�Õ�

�ͪ­°¨�

'

f8å®$dÑ�D

#

#ª´À�ÒÔ

(

×Ø6V5r�

&

×ØîÈm]5ô

¡RÕÑÑv;.T©l5¢R

"

'

¶MN5×Ø�OPî95Ù`¯QRª#«�C

(

yª

Óæ�£ª

(

�${û��i

'

MN�x¯�6ª��r-/-�¯)+,5�,+;

'

¤ü.

5¯)ËA#�DNÅ�÷øãMN�ÕvV!?

'

�3°I¿Å}¯gvÅ}

&

ûæ�5ù

}

&

ú}��ML-v�"=

'

<<

#

(

ÍÝ

'

PzËA^_¶MN�HJ

&

$°JÑ­æËA:

N5�xЪÒè5

'

\Ã3#ÂÔRü.ËAÜD5�Õ���

(

$O

Â0��fv5h�$

'

$)*;ü.$5ùMNOPQRS.T+,UI-Ù·±�

»¼5��AÕ?§Ò�Á®èÚ

'

¤y¦5±�Úǯ°3#ÂXR¶;�

(

$)*;ü.

5�ùA0�

'

ª5ù-.MN\OOPî9VW�­æ�QRS.T+,UI5¬²*aJ

#

(

:`P#OD5£¤Of8å®$d�D

#

#ª�ù�£�ª

(

�-.k»�_m#

'

ô¯

J¯�4�Ò°

'

ªæ¶-.Ûñ5ß/v^

&

¶-.M?5¥åÐ/<

$

'

Ps�?Òèã*

-¯E-6V5¯ùR

'

TK�y¦$5ù.T+,UI¨�Å>®¶;JÕ¾5-Èû©

(

yªH¸�ÇC®

(

5ù$)*;jü-.Á® /�ùA¶;��

'

Û8)+VW?F»S

QR-é5.T+,à©5H¸�Ç

'

Pª@Aü.ËAUáÁ®¨�5²8N¨

'

¤¥N$5

3�O*�Ñ)��Ç53D-

'

ÍÝ8$�ÇDæÒ�Õ

&

��_�Sm#

&

�ÇþvÒ(

9<<®Á£¤

%

'

�k$)*;ü.�ù5XRÙÚ

(

îë

'

5ùMNOPßÁQRS.T+

,UI

'

\Ã3#¨�y¦�ù5¶;�

(

É

%

GMHN

#

mn¾ÐAGH4lW[ÑÒZSO¾G

ÂÅ1XYï¦

'

Â)+VW>5h�$

'

:N85ù-.MNOPÒ�QRS.T+,U

I

'

4]Ö¶ä?$QRERí»>úv�OR

'

ÕLJÁ®R�Sr

'

âë#I$Ò��6[

)#*)

)+s\]

'#'"

2"

$

&

!

"

#

$

%

Ë¿ÓýZ�¹

)2)

عÜÅ

&

�Å.

)

��

#*

�ü¤R

,,,

$Ñ.T5)+óN¯üfM

+ '

"

'"$

i

'

�>j

×

''##&

2j

(

Ë¿Éjü

#*

®mn�&×Ø5�YRùLÑä¶�O¶�5¸¹

+ '*

Mï×Ø5s

+ ''#"*

2"

(

&

(

˿_�

&

�Ú7

#*

ÎükØMNR)+ËA-ýþ5®Á��¯w¥+;

+ '*

÷asÃ

+ ''#"+

2"

$

&

(

Ë¿ÿ!Ï

#*

-.k»IJ5[xA¨�+;

+ '*

-.*)EF>"

+ ''#'#

2"

"'

&

(

Ë¿eÇd

#*

53*��Ç\ÃQy,k

+ '*

-.�ìt^}

+ ''#"&

2

"

Å

"&

X

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

x¯ÔRVW¨I5�2ÅtJÖ­5ÎÏ¥�

(

!

%

"

PVWD°Z

'

Qq

( !+,-./0"

«RST

&

NUmn¾ÐpµAGH4lW[ÑÒ

&

V

WX>\]34mn(9¾Ð;<µ¶YZ«b<U[\«�ª

&

H=æ4lW[ÑÒ=]L

M^®�U�J±

VWùJs

!191/0G79.5GE61"

¬S

'

HÇVW?F�8$­µ±Ïþ5

$

·d

%

6V

'

R@ù

JnЯMvî9ªÁ®VW�R¯ÙÚ5²8N¨

!

(

$:r-.)+vM`

'

-./0*

5fK5ùªMNOPî95a/ÐÖ

'

Þü.5ËA5ùÁSÅx�ÿMNOP5!$*a

'

æ­$)+VW5m�Rí�ÜéPdµ

'

#IS.T+,UI5QR¨KùJA«

(

8tJ

P#¥�üâéd�Dk»

(

"O

¶ã$)*fK5ù`(�5MNOPî9

'

Ö7Ò¢é

$

ÇÐ

%

k»

(

5ùMNOPQ

RS.T+,UI

'

$)*b%ü87Òfù»S

'

6ÜÒ�¨��Kßà¯$)IJ

'

SMN

OPî95Ò�87¯QRb�

(

#�

'

ٶ-.MN5��OPO

'

:N$Á®,>�OP

î95aÂ87!

'

Ö3#¢é¶-.MN5UV�OPî95XN$z

'

âë#ISÌÍ-

.MNOP¯Á®)+VWm�¨K^S'Á5?$*a

(

Ù¶-.MN5A«�OPO

'

-

./0*»S$)*OÖ�­Jú+ëìfg

&

(_fg¯XR*;¯)��¼$=>n�

'

â

ë#I$Ò�¨�*5��S#5ÜD-

'

ßÁ¢JÒ-./

&

%�N°

'

3ÞSÁ®-.MN

OPî9875)�R¨K'Á5fKJ#

(

'O

¶ãü.ËA5ù`(�5MNOPî9

'

ÖÒ�¢é

$

íÕ

%

k»

(

ü.5ËA*aª

@AMNOPQRS.T+,UI5×Ø+�

(

ÝÞ

'

ü.$ËAÜD-SMN5�x¯ø°

`�5×Ø�OPî9

'

(ó\�nê­��5Õy�

(

8Ò�ºÁ-.MNø°5×Ø*a

+�

'

�Ö­J{|ü.ËA5ùÎMNOPî95Õ¾

(

#8Ò�ÔRü.5)+HH

(

)

+HHª)+VW­æ¯­Uø°5�,N¨

(

)+HHÜÓ

'

)+VWüØ3¾ü.5*a

'

)BM�¯$°üØ�>^�5×Ø�,

"

(

$P«¨©`

'

MNOPî95ÌÍÑäQR\

ݺ~²²Mv

(

Æ�-.MN5×Ø�OPî9

'

±86Ü)+×ØRÒ�9<ü.5)+

¦­

'

T8­J£3ü.Ñ&

'

âë#I$Ò�ÔR)+HH5;�53)+¬;J5¨�

(

y

8Ò�53ü.5­æ¯�ÕËA

(

�6ÜÙÚ�ü×Ø´À

'

Ò�ÔRü.ËA�Õ�¯­

æ�

'

Á®MNø°×Ø*aJ5)�R

(

!

$

"

PVWD°;ëZ

'

_[

(!-123400+,5"

«RST

&

NUmn¾ÐpµAGH4lW[

ÑÒ

&

X>\]34mn(9¾Ð;<µ¶U`«abUcd«AG

&

H=æ4lW[ÑÒ=]

3e«Z^f

?FQRª)+VWÁ®ú%�m>5a/Rí

(

¶ë

'

Ö­²Â��DÚÇ

(

"O

Â.T+,-éà©5ø»�2$

'

\íJ(�Èf�¯VW�e�,k

(

,kª°

ù5%K

'

ÌfÉ�,k¯ÈkhS)+VWXY5²8N¨

'

¬Sä

$

­~ã@¡#Ñ�7

'

&ë

'

4]ï��P�D5ÖJªK|£

%

#

(

5ùMNOP$)+VW?FL.T+,UIÁ

®­æ­UQR

'

;�âJ,kõ�%°

(

#�D

'

¶ã)+VW5LÈø°Þâ

'

8è¡È

f�5ÙÚ,k

(

»SMNOPî9Á®QR5ª�þv

'

)+VW5?$x�ÒêÏþ�¯

)"*)

MNOPQRS.T+,UI5)+VWXY

!

"

#

Ë¿eä'

#*

Ä¿VWùJs

+ '

"

$

i

'

7(�s>j×

'"%%*

2j

(

Ë¿cC·

#*

)+HHÑäDÐ

,,,

¶ÚÊ

&

Ñ.T¯�g5��\]

+ '*

B´×ØvM��

+ ''##+

2"

*

&

(

q�

)

ÌfÉ

#*

)+·45VWXY

+ '

"

)

i

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

÷¬�

'

n$Ò;5.T¯�g­­Ò;5[x¨I

&

,>�2¯ÎÏvV

(

5ù-.MNOP

QRS.T+,UI

'

Û8¡°-.Á�(�Èf�5ÙÚ,k

'

âë#I$$�:r-.)+

VWø°��5�2Å

'

S5ùMNOP55sQR¨Kúv�A«

(

r#�D

'

¶ãMNOP

î95îÈ��Þâ

'

�Öè¡VW�56�,k

(

)+VW5ÛñTõØ(û¥5

'

ÞªS­

èã»>ú%�åB¨K%�

'

PO8ñ.T+,-éà©$ø»-

'

±8¶MNOP5¨I¯

�n(�VW�¬­

'

T86ãÂ[xÅ�ÜEOzOPî95?$��6V

'

âë#IS@A

MNOP5a�nÙ`ºÁ+�

(

'O

Â.T+,-éà©5!FRS$

'

\íJ(�Ç÷_+,³M

'

Õ@A-éà©Á

®Qóø°

(

®rVW5s5ûi[x,>

!e>0-49-U<E11ER5/ES0H/4L6/L40"

¬S

'

ù�àµó5

Ç÷VW6ÜÒ�;!�5H¸±�

'

ïÂ�%5ûæòóL¨Iz�ªÅ5­æòóQy

!

(

¶ã)+VWÞâ

'

:ä

$

>��SJ�Aa#«�µòó�

%'

;�T

$

\Ý8)�RS¸¹5

8$

%

"

(

PÄä­8@AMN\²OPî9$)+VW?FÁ®­U��

'

3Þ6Ü+,-é

L.T+,UI3°ÁlQR

'

�$)*»S.T+,5a/ü\Ã�x¯(�Ç÷_+,³

M

'

âë#I�{MNOPî9$?FQR-ïI>®5*iRt³

'

O#I$@AMNOPî

9;!FRS3°VX±�5�2Å

'

)äL.T+,UIÁ®­UQR

(

$O

Â.T+,-éà©5?F+,$

'

\Ã�x¯(�ùó5s5¶{ÙÚ³M¯Ál²

l³M

'

Õ5ùMNOPî9;.T+,Ál¢Ja�n5»l

(

êvÞâ

'

#8Õ.T+,5

ùóø»¯)©QRSKL

'

(�MNOPî9$)+VW?F5¶{ÙÚ³M

(

¶ã.T+

,Þâ

'

HÇODHÇî95Ò°zª¾

'

ÐïI¶UIQRx�?$Mv

(

îë

'

+,-é»

S)+VW5

$

/+

%'

8+&MNEODOPî95m�ò©¢é

$

 £¤

%

5k»

'

�

'

.ÿ¢

¦

'

��rÕn$*-�ÄN²h`-.MN5�K�OPî9�CJÿÍmÌÍ

'

Þ�­.T

+,Ál5Ò�õ�

'

­6ø°�OPO-5¤R�¯×Ø�OPî9

'

�ÍÝ�­°Á®3#

ÂÔR

(

æ­(�-.MN�OOP§x5ùó൯Eî9P�Ò�5ä�ÙÚóP

'

#I

@A)+VW[x¨I5)�R¯+,-éø°5­UR

(

y8Õ.T+,5®Á�?¯Uh

¥�SKL

'

(�MNOPî9;.T+,5Ál²l³M

(

ä-±8ÂUhÄNR@.T+

,¥�

'

SMNOP5QR¨K5smL

'

T8$.T+,Ál-Ò�Ù®¯![�?

'

SMN

OPî95QR¨KÁlÍ&

'

ÂÞ${|ûUm>5�2Ũ�?$QRÜD55s�¯­

U�

(

!

(

"

PVWD°Z

'

Qu

(!2./-./0"

«RST

&

NUmn¾ÐpµAGH4lW[ÑÒ

&

>

ghijVWD°QuklZ�mUno01

&

B\]mn¾ÐéêøùµGAG�pËGÑ

q

&

H=æ4lW[ÑÒ=]O%rZsÇ«SO

»S)+VWm>5�/)B{é­

$

åB0,&J5×Ø[E

%'

ÕÑ

$

�Kj¬Sï¼

ÕâCPs[E5Þß

%

#

(

ï¿

'

5ùMNOPL.T+,UI3°QR

'

¶

$

m>

%

Rí5+

,;�²8

(

êvÞâ

#

ä#

'

S¨�úvQRÜD5­æ�

'

Ö�x(�)+VW5H¸{Ý

³M

(

»S)+VW>5a/Õ«

'$

{Ý

%

­~ã)+fv

$

{íz

.

îï

/

ä°S

%'$

ÂÞÇ

Hr#�M{R

%

$

(

5ùMNOPî9^é�QRS.T+,UI

'

\Ã$)+VW?(�

)'*)

)+s\]

'#'"

2"

$

&

!

"

#

Ë¿îïü

&

Ä�ð

&

+ôÊ

&

 Yñ

&

cêò

&

óu+

#*

VW5s

+ '

"

$%'

i

(

$

!

q�

)

ÌfÉ

#*

)+·45VWXY

+ '

"

"&

i

'

"

$)(

i

(

ÓýZ�¹

)2)

عÜÅ

&

"

M)

âãä

)

å%¹

#*

��)+s

,,,

vV

&

ÜD¯)B

+ '

"

'%+

i

(

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE

e6û�5

$

{ÝR+

%!U007356F @--R"'

ä-ÒÅ86Ü

$

{Ýçß

%'

@A$)*I(¶MN\

²OPî95VWm�¯QRÁ®²x¯ÕDó�

'

T8+&

$

{Ý{Ö

%'

5ù)+VW3#

¨�m>ÜD5­U�¯aÂ�

'

âëS?$QR��Ò�OR¨K©-Òõ5H¸*a

(

äy

'

S¨�úvQRÜD5­U�

'

Ö�x(�)+VW5�UçA³M

(

�¶MNEODO

Pî9587Am�ò©

&

+,-é5QRò©ÕÑ)+VW5m>ò©<»>�UçA

'

äï

SMNOPî95QR¯.T+,UI5)�R¨K^Ó'Á5µt*a

(

$çAÜD-

'

$

)*ÒÅ8�Lú%�

'

T87Ò±ñ\]ËA�Ä¿

'

âë#IÔR�UçA³M5aD�¯

5s�

'

3Þ5ù)+VWø°¯MNOPî9QRUá5Ò�ö3¯¨�

(

t

%

uÎ

HI'�MNÈH

&

·ãé:»S

'

3Þ5ù-.MNOPßÁQRS.T+,UI

'

±ª

ÇøaD��×Øfg®rR.T��D5?$8ñ

'

TªÁ®.T+,vV¯+,IJ®r

R5\âo+

(

,¤5ýþ$ã6Ü)+VWXY

'

è�ÿ#Ñ6ã-.MNOPî9QRS

.T+,UI5VWXY¦§

'

3Þ$ë�2ÅR@ÿä?$5QR��

(

5ùMNOPßÁ

QRS.T+,UI

'

±8ÔR¶MN5\²OPî95��ú�¯VWm�

'

µ8$)+VW

?F¶MNOPî9ÚÇ5s5,¯ÁlQR

'

^�ÒÇ)+VWm>RíÅ5H¸{ݯ�

UçA

'

âë#I$Ò�

$

87

%

¯

$

�

%

-.MNOPî95�2Å

'

5ù.T+,UIÒ�

Á®

$

OR

%

¯

$

�¿

%(

)+VW>§Ðã��)+s�

'

¤»S#«XYkêÒ«}üÄg

(

VWe�ª®r5s\]5²8�£

'

û>ª$cdefgBÍ»T5,>vV-

'

�ª$-.

Rcdefg5)�,>�E-

'

��p­9<5VW>e:

(

îë

'

è�MNOPßÁQRS

.T+,UI5,®R)+VW,>^Î

'

çÕ-.MN\²OPî95ú�m�

&

VW5,A

Álm><Sß�¢nÚÇùóXY

'

Ò¾S#W�5\]+;

'

ïSXRE�i5\]Ñ?h

êvQRUE¨Ks,*õ¯Álmº

(

LM

$

���

%

bc��SHXYZ[\HU

"

bc#op]

%$"##"&#

!

Ø'ÙÚ

&

ÜÝÞ

"

)$*)

MNOPQRS.T+,UI5)+VWXY

政治学研究

CASS JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE