engineered rebar for concrete structures distribution presentation 04... · typical initial cost of...

36
ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Made in Canada

Upload: others

Post on 30-Apr-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

ENGINEERED REBAR

FOR

CONCRETE STRUCTURES

Made in Canada

Page 2: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

OUTLINE

i. Why Corrosion is a problem & Typical examplesii. What is an alternative solution (use GFRP Bar)iii. Mechanical & physical properties of MST-BAR™iv. Main advantages of MST-BAR™ over Black Steelv. Approvals & Certificatesvi. Codes, Designs & Standardsvii. Typical Applicationsviii. Cost Analysisix. MST-BAR™ Physical Properties Test Results

Page 3: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

• Why Corrosion is a problem?

What justifies the use of MST-BAR™ in today's infrastructures

• Governments & Taxpayers can no longer afford to pay concurrently for replacing, maintenance and expansion of infrastructure

• Corrosion is a dangerous and extremely costly problem and is draining the economy silently

• Safety of infrastructures can become problematic when subjected to harsh environmental conditions

• Steel is an old material, it’s great but often does not fit some applications!

Page 4: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

• Typical example of Corrosion on bridges & Seawalls

Page 5: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

• Typical example of corrosion on bridge decks

Page 6: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

• Typical example of corrosion on Marine Structures

Page 7: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

• Typical example of corrosion on Marine Structures

Page 8: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

MST-BAR™ -Mega Strength Bar

Mechanical & Physical Properties of Straight GFRP

Page 9: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Stress-Strain Curves

Steel’s maximum stress level is 500MPa and GFRP is above 1000MPa for the same diameter. That is twice the load capacity of steel.

Page 10: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Stress-Strain Chart

Comparison of MST-BAR with Steel and Carbon bar

Actual Test Curve of MST-BAR for 16mm diameter bar

Page 11: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Fatigue Comparison GFRP/CFRP/STEEL

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

100 1,000 10,000 100,000 1,000,000

No. of Cycles (Nos.)

Cra

ck

Wid

th (

mm

)

Comparison of GFRP, CFRP and STEEL Reinforced Slabs

Cycles toFailure @ 60 t

23,162

198,863Cycles

420,684Cycles

Failur

e @ 60 t

23,162Cycles

STEEL

Punching Shear Failure Mode

STEELSTEEL

CFRP

GFRP

Fatigue under 60 t Load Fatigue under 60 t Load Punching Shear Failure Mode

STEEL

GFRP

CFRP

Page 12: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Zero corrosion: 100% resistance to any & all harsh environmental factors, No rusting High chemical resistance: Impervious to salt and other chemical attacks High tensile strength: 2 x stronger than steel with tensile strength of 1000MPa Light weight: 4 x (i.e. 73%) lighter than steel, (2100 Kg/m3 vs.7800 Kg/m3), Ease of transportation Long life span: over 100 years life span (GFRP) vs 25 years (Black Steel) High fatigue life: 20 x higher resistance under cyclic loading (440,000 cycle vs. 40,000 cycle) Non Conductive, & Non-Electromagnetic: Ideal for high electrical field, e.g. power stations Non Magnetic: Ideal for hospitals, MRI rooms, laboratories & other uses Radar Transparent: ideal for Airport Low thermal conductivity: Makes it suitable for use in hot and cold environments, power plants Low thermal expansion: Very low thermal expansion factor results in compatibility with concrete High bonding strength: Much greater bonding strength to concrete (20 Mpa) Ease of cutting & handling: Faster & cheaper installation and site handling Fire rated: Capacity to stand for more than 3 hours in direct fire with minimum concrete cover Sustainable to environment: Environmentally friendly, less Green House Gases while transporting High durability & performance: No maintenance required, No additional project cost, Major savings Min. concrete cover: requires minimum concrete cover i.e. 38mm, (2 ½ x less cracking of concrete) Detection by GPR : Easily detected by GPR No waterproofing: For bridge decks, unique saving for future

Advantages of MST-BAR™ Over Steel Rebar

Page 13: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Dis-advantages of MST-BAR™ Over Steel Rebar

CONCLUSION:

MST-BAR® it is proven for its long-term saving with life of over 100 years vs Black steel of 25 years

MST-BAR® with its proven higher performance not only will not add additional costs to the project; it will certainly result in major savings

Page 14: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Approvals

American Concrete Institution (ACI-440.3)

ASTM D7957

Canadian Standard Association (CSA-S807)

ISO 9001:2008 Quality Control BSI-British Standard Institution

MTO qualified for Grade III(DSM)

FDOT Approved GFRP manufacturing plant

Page 15: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Canadian Design Guide for use of GFRP Bar

Canada -Highway Bridge Design Code Canada – FRP design guide

Page 16: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

USA Design Guide for use of GFRP Bar

AASHTO design guide ACI design guide

Page 17: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Standards & CodesInternational

ASTM D7957-17 “Standard Specification for Solid Round Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymer Bars for Concrete

Reinforcement”

Canada

CAN/CSA-S807 (R2015) “Specification for fibre-reinforced polymers” Canadian Standards Association

CAN/CSA-S6-06 (2006) Fibre Reinforced Structures, “Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code” Canadian Standards

Association, pg.693-728

CAN/CSA-S806-02 (R2007) “Design and Construction of Building Components with Fibre-Reinforced Polymers” Canadian

Standards Association

The Structural Innovation & Monitoring Technologies Resource Centre (SIMTReC):

Manual No. 3 (Version 2) ”Reinforcing Concrete Structures with Fibre Reinforced Polymers (FRPs)”, Dr. Sami Rizkalla, Dr.

Aftab Mufti

Manual No. 4 “Strengthening Reinforced Concrete Structures with Externally-Bonded Fibre Reinforced Polymers (FRPs)”,

Dr. Kenneth Neale

Manual No. 5 ”Prestressing Concrete Structures with FRPs” Dr. Ivan Campbell

USA

ACI 440.1R-06 (2006) ”Report on Fiber Reinforced Poly. (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures”, ACI Committee

440, American Concrete Institute

ACI 440R-07 (2007) ”Report on Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures” ACI Committee

440, American Concrete Institute

ACI 440.5-08 (2008) ”Specification for Construction with Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Reinforcing Bar” ACI Committee 440,

American Concrete Institute

ACI 440.6-08 (2008) “Specification for Carbon and Glass Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Bar Materials for Concrete

Reinforcement,” ACI Committee 440, American Concrete Institute

AASHTO GFRP-1 (2019) ” AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Guide Specifications for GFRP-Reinforced Concrete Bridge

Decks and Traffic Railings”, American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials

Page 18: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Applications

Bridge Decks & infrastructures, Transportation, Highway paving Road side Barriers, Bridge parapets, Paving, Concrete slabs Precast structural elements; e.g. deck panels, culverts, piles, columns, Pipe rings Retaining walls, Box culverts Marine & waterfront Structures, e.g. seawalls, docks, ports, dams, coastal etc. Tunneling; e.g. TBM ring precast segments; Soft eye LRT’s & Heavy Rail (electrical mitigations), rail traverse (plinth) 100% GFRP Bars Structural Strengthening & rehabilitation, bridge Deck replacement Waste water treatment plants Multi-story RC Parkades slabs Nuclear Power Plants & Electrical power plants & Chemical Plants MRI Rooms & Hospitals Airport runway Mining

Page 19: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Typical applications for use of GFRP Bars

Bridge Decks Power Plant Marine & Waterfront Structures

Tunneling (Soft eye)

Hospitals & MRI Rooms

Page 20: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Application of GFRP on RC bridge decks & road paving

Page 21: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Application of GFRP use on RC bridge decks

Page 22: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Application of GFRP use on RC Seawalls & RC Bridge

Page 23: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Application of GFRP use on RC Piles

Page 24: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Application of GFRP use on RC Precast elements

Page 25: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Application of GFRP use on Various RC projects

Page 26: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Application of GFRP use on RC parkade & footings

Page 27: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Use of MST- BAR on bridge rehabilitation in Panama

Page 28: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Other Applications: RC Walls, Floors, Paving

Power Plant

Page 29: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Cost Study: BLACK STEEL

Chloride ions, moisture and salts will penetrate through the membrane and begin corroding its top reinforcement

CONCLUSION: 25 years after the road construction, its asphalt surface will have to be rehabilitated, the membrane would require replacement and the upper reinforcement would corrode needing to be replaced. Considering the life span of MST-BAR® at well over 100 years, the savings that it brings to any and all construction projects is undoubtedly substantial.

Deck with use of Black Steel Rebar

Page 30: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Reducing Your Corrosion Protection by MST-BAR

When using MST-BAR the following protection can be removed by

CSA Code

Membrane

Reducing concrete cover from 70mm to 40mm

Removing C.N.I.

Reducing or Removing Asphalt completely

With Steel With MST-BAR

Page 31: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

COST SAVINGS OF MST-BAR™

Transportation Costs, 4 times lower due to its 73% lighter weight

Minimum required concrete cover, 38mm for bars #2 -5 and 50mm for bars #6 -8, (the regular steel bar concrete requires 65mm)

Increase in labor performance and less fatigue for labors during placing the bar result in faster installation

MST-BAR® price with its proven higher performance will not add any extra cost to the project however it will result in saving.

40-60% less expensive than stainless steel rebar while MST-BAR® has much higher performance than the most expensive Stainless-Steel

No water proofing membrane, a unique cost-saving feature

NEVER Epoxy coat paint, re-patch the concrete or replace the rusted bars is no longer needed

MST-BAR, does not required any maintenance

Page 32: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Initial Cost Comparison

Black Steel Galvanized/Epoxy Coated

Stainless-Steel

MST-BAR

Size #5(16mm) #5(16mm) #5(16mm) #5(16mm)

Corrosion Resistance

Extremely weak in corrosive

environment

weak in corrosive environment

Very Good in corrosive

environment

Excellent in corrosive

environment

Strength 450 MPa 450 MPa 500MPa >1000MPa

Weight 7850 kg/m3 7850 kg/m3 8400 kg/m3 2100 kg/m3

Corrosion protection

options requirement

MUST MUST Optional Optional

Price $1.57/m-Not installed

$2.82/m -installed

$2.9/m-Not installed

$3.77/minstalled

$9.5/m Not installed

$12.56/minstalled

$3.1 /m to $4/mNot installed

$4/m installed

Required maintenance every 15-20 years

>75 years >100 years

Page 33: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length

With Black Steel With MST-BAR

Unit Cost Per Slab

Concrete with

inhibitor250$/m3 406$

Formwork 120$/m2 780$

Topping

60$/m2 Membrane +35$/m2 Asphalt

618

rebar1850

$/Tons260

Sub Total 1804 Note: All the prices are Including installation

Unit CostPer Slab

Concrete with no inhibitor

220$/m3 315$

Formwork 120$/m2 780$

ToppingSingle Membrane:

25$/m2Asphalt Optional

150$

rebar #5 @ 3.1$/m 578$

Sub Total 1823

Required maintenanceafter 10-15 years

Doesn’t Required major maintenancefor over 75 years

Page 34: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

• MST-BAR™ - Advantages For Fabricators?

Why use of MST-BAR™ in today's infrastructures

1. MST Bar FRP Manufacturing strong relation with our customer

2. Working hand to hand & in parallel with our customer during estimation to ensure the minimum error

3. Engineering and Testing Report

4. No Minimum quantity!

5. Any size and shape available

6. Ease of handling & installation because of fully ribbed profile

7. Competitive and Flexible pricing

8. Strong QC/QA program

9. Many years of experience in composite industry

Page 35: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete

BENT MST-BAR™

All sizes of bent MST-BAR may be produced only in the production plant and not at the construction

site, in a specifically dedicated machinery, with an entirely different

process in accordance with the engineering specifications &

drawings.

35

Page 36: ENGINEERED REBAR FOR CONCRETE STRUCTURES Distribution presentation 04... · Typical Initial Cost of Slab with 6.5m length With Black Steel With MST-BAR Unit Cost Per Slab Concrete