enhancing the human phenotype ontology for use by the … · 2016. 4. 11. · enhancing the human...

1
Enhancing the Human Phenotype Ontology for use by the Layperson Introduction Nicole Vasilevsky 1 , Mark Engelstad 1 , Erin Foster 1 , Chris Mungall 3 , Peter Robinson 2 , Sebastian Köhler 2 , Melissa Haendel 1 1 Ontology Development Group, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR, USA 2 Charité - Universitätsmedizin, Berlin, Germany, 3 Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA Enhancing the Human Phenotype Ontology for Use by the Layperson Human Phenotype Ontology Workflow Outcomes Many diseases present with distinct phenotypes, making computational description critical for diagnostics Patients are a good source of phenotypic information and need to participate in their diagnostic odyssey The Human Phenotype Ontology can be used to capture structured information about patient phenotypes § Contains over 12,000 classes describing human phenotypic features § Used for clinical “deep phenotyping” § HPO annotations utilized in semantic similarity analysis within and across species for rare disease diagnostics 4 | Synonym classification Exact synonyms: precise alternatives to the HPO term Broad synonyms: more general than the HPO term Narrow synonyms: more specific than HPO term Related synonyms: associated with the HPO term. 3 | Assign synonyms Assign synonyms to existing classes or mark existing synonyms as layperson § Wikipedia § MedlinePlus § Mayo Clinic § OMIM § Uberon § Elements of Morphology § SNOMED CT Browsers § Specialty texts 1 | Systematic review of HPO classes Challenges Use of HPO The inclusion of plain language synonyms will support patient-driven applications for deep phenotyping, that can be utilized clinical and computationally 44% of synonyms in HPO are layperson HPO can be integrated into patient registries and other platforms such as the following: § Recognizing when an HPO class did not have an equivalent layperson synonym e.g., joint contracture § Aligning synonyms with definition of HPO classes e.g., Neoplasm of breast Breast cancer § Applying synonyms consistently across HPO classes and subclasses e.g., “Yellowing of skin” à Jaundice, Intermittent jaundice, Prolonged neonatal jaundice § Continuous review of HPO OWL file for quality assurance § Valid character-encoding § Check for duplicated synonyms § Title case forma?ng § Check annotation consistency between similar terms § Reviewed by 3 curators 6 | Quality Assurance All synonyms in HPO Synonyms marked as lay All synonyms 14,253 6,240 Exact 12,167 5,357 Broad 441 298 Related 1,236 419 Narrow 409 166 On the left is a mouse phenotypic profile using the Mammalian Phenotype Ontology; on the right, a disease profile using HPO. In the center are shown the phenotypes in common based semantic similarity matching. Goal Add new layperson synonyms to terms to increase the usability of the HPO, and make it useful for data interoperability for patients, clinicians, and researchers 5 | Script in new synonyms to HPO OWL file § Initial review in HPO OWL files in the ontology editing tool, Protégé § HPO terms and synonyms were downloaded to a spreadsheet to allow sorting and grouping of terms § HPO curation team, with clinical and biocuration expertise, cross-reviewed each class 2 | Search for synonyms Acknowledgements This work is supported by NIH Office of Director grant: 1R24OD011883. Thank you to Tudor Groza and Julie McMurry for their help. Apert’s syndrome image credits available from monarchinitiative.org Contact Nicole Vasilevsky: [email protected] , @N_Vasilevsky Sebastian Köhler: [email protected] Monarch Initiative: @MonarchInit File available at: www.purl.obolibrary.org/obo/hp.owl Community contributions welcome! https://github.com/obophenotype/human- phenotype-ontology @hp_ontology

Upload: others

Post on 11-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Enhancing the Human Phenotype Ontology for Use by the … · 2016. 4. 11. · Enhancing the Human Phenotype Ontology for use by the Layperson Introduction Nicole Vasilevsky1, Mark

EnhancingtheHumanPhenotypeOntologyforusebytheLayperson

Introduction

Nicole Vasilevsky1, Mark Engelstad1, Erin Foster1, Chris Mungall3, Peter Robinson2, Sebastian Köhler2, Melissa Haendel1

1Ontology Development Group, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR, USA 2Charité - Universitätsmedizin, Berlin, Germany, 3Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA

Enhancing the Human Phenotype Ontology for Use by the Layperson

Human Phenotype Ontology

Workflow Outcomes

Many diseases present with distinct phenotypes, making computational description critical for diagnostics

Patients are a good source of phenotypic information and need to participate in their diagnostic odyssey

The Human Phenotype Ontology can be used to capture structured information about patient phenotypes

§  Contains over 12,000 classes describing human phenotypic features

§  Used for clinical “deep phenotyping” §  HPO annotations utilized in semantic

similarity analysis within and across species for rare disease diagnostics 4 | Synonym classification

Exact synonyms: precise alternatives to the HPO term Broad synonyms: more general than the HPO term Narrow synonyms: more specific than HPO term Related synonyms: associated with the HPO term.

3 | Assign synonyms Assign synonyms to existing classes or mark existing synonyms as layperson

§  Wikipedia §  MedlinePlus §  Mayo Clinic §  OMIM §  Uberon

§  Elements of Morphology

§  SNOMED CT Browsers

§  Specialty texts

1 | Systematic review of HPO classes

Challenges

Use of HPO

The inclusion of plain language synonyms will support patient-driven applications for deep phenotyping, that can be utilized clinical and computationally

44% of synonyms in HPO are layperson

HPO can be integrated into patient registries and other platforms such as the following:

§  Recognizing when an HPO class did not have an equivalent layperson synonym

e.g., joint contracture

§  Aligning synonyms with definition of HPO classes

e.g., Neoplasm of breast ≠ Breast cancer

§  Applying synonyms consistently across HPO classes and subclasses

e.g., “Yellowing of skin” à Jaundice, Intermittent jaundice, Prolonged neonatal jaundice

§  Continuous review of HPO OWL file for quality assurance § Validcharacter-encoding§ Checkforduplicatedsynonyms§ Titlecaseforma?ng

§  Check annotation consistency between similar terms

§  Reviewed by 3 curators

6 | Quality Assurance

  All synonyms

in HPO Synonyms

marked as lay

All synonyms 14,253 6,240

Exact 12,167 5,357

Broad 441 298

Related 1,236 419

Narrow 409 166

On the left is a mouse phenotypic profile using the Mammalian Phenotype Ontology; on the right, a disease profile using HPO. In the center are shown the phenotypes in common based semantic similarity matching.

Goal Add new layperson synonyms to terms to increase the usability of the HPO, and make it useful for data interoperability for patients, clinicians, and researchers

5 | Script in new synonyms to HPO OWL file

§  Initial review in HPO OWL files in the ontology editing tool, Protégé

§  HPO terms and synonyms were downloaded to a spreadsheet to allow sorting and grouping of terms

§  HPO curation team, with clinical and biocuration expertise, cross-reviewed each class

2 | Search for synonyms

Acknowledgements

This work is supported by NIH Office of Director grant: 1R24OD011883. Thank you to Tudor Groza and Julie McMurry for their help. Apert’s syndrome image credits available from monarchinitiative.org

Contact

Nicole Vasilevsky: [email protected], @N_Vasilevsky Sebastian Köhler: [email protected] Monarch Initiative: @MonarchInit

File available at: www.purl.obolibrary.org/obo/hp.owl

Community contributions welcome! https://github.com/obophenotype/human-

phenotype-ontology

@hp_ontology