ethics & professionalism - texas land title associationethics and professionalism 33...
TRANSCRIPT
Ethics &
Professionalism: A Proposed Journey
2013 Texas Land Title Institute
Professor L. Wayne Scott St. Mary’s University School of Law
11/18/2013
1
Ethics and Professionalism:A Proposed Journey
By Prof. L. Wayne Scott
Roscoe Pound said that “... [professionalism] refers to a group ... pursuing a learned art as a common calling in the spirit of public service — no less a public service because it may incidentally be a means of livelihood. Pursuit of the learned art in the spirit of public service is the primary purpose.”
Ethics and Professionalism
2
11/18/2013
2
“Whereas legal ethics defines what every lawyer must do, legal professionalism takes on the more difficult task of defining the core values that the very best lawyers should aspire to in their practice.”
Comment: Brooks A. Suttle, Reframing “Professionalism”: An Integral View of Lawyering’s Lofty Ideals, 61 Emory L. J. 161 (2011).
Ethics and Professionalism
3
Has professionalism disappeared from our profession? Have we become nothing but business/craft/trade persons? So argues Tom Morgan in The Vanishing American Lawyer(2010).
Ethics and Professionalism
4
11/18/2013
3
Morgan argues that lawyers “are economic actors, specially trained, but driven by all the vices and virtues of a capitalist economic system.” And that “[U]se of the idea of a ‘profession’ to understand the world of lawyers obstructs clear thinking about what lawyers actually do and how they have to respond to the world they face.”
Ethics and Professionalism
5
“... [W]e should not let the label ‘profession’ weaken the response to the realities that the future likely holds for legally trained persons.”
Is this true?
Ethics and Professionalism
6
11/18/2013
4
Is there a floor, below which those in our profession may not go, or are we all economic actors. Would the public benefit from our discarding a self-regulated profession? This would allow the market and the government to control our actions. Or, does society benefit from an autonomous, self-regulating, profession? Do we live out the social contract that we claim exists, allowing us to call ourselves professionals?
Ethics and Professionalism
7
One author “examines the options for restructuring legal ethics if the American legal profession changes in fundamental ways that make it difficult or impossible for negligence and fiduciary-duty malpractice principles and legal ethics codes to play the same important roles they currently perform.”
Prof. Vincent R. Johnson, MALPRACTICE IN A CHANGING PROFESSION: THE ROLE OF CONTRACT PRINCIPLES, 61 Clev. St. L. Rev. 489, 495 (2013).
Professionalism –Dead or Dying?
8
11/18/2013
5
“If legal services are increasingly provided to clients by nonlawyers, or by lawyers who are not fully licensed, it will be ever more difficult for the legal system to rely on disciplinary codes and malpractice actions to hold those who provide legal services accountable and to deter improper practices. And, if ethics rules or the legal principles governing negligence and fiduciary duty are rendered less operative than they are today, it may be necessary to find a substitute legal regime for protecting clients from harm and facilitating the proper operation of the justice system.” Id, at 526.
A Fragmented Profession?
9
This seems to be more of an academic argument, with few examples of the fragmentation discussed in the article.
Professor Johnson’s arguments are directed at the regulated ethics of the “legal profession,’ more than the “professionalism” of the “legal profession.”
The Focus of Professionalism
10
11/18/2013
6
Renewed Professionalism may save the Profession.
“We cannot save our system of laws or the legal profession from the commercialism of multi-disciplinary practice by regulation. We must save our profession and the system of laws by re-injecting and rebuilding moral values into the profession. . . .[I]n many cases those values have faded. Rebuilding can only be injected back into the heart, the spirit of the practice of law; that is re-inject a strong sense of service, values, and pride.”
Douglas S. Lang, Professionalism and Civility, 63 Tex.B.J. 552 (2000).
Rebuilding Professionalism
11
Reviewing the common concepts of what makes a professional demonstrates that professionalism aims higher than ethics. It focuses not only on exterior actions and conduct, but also interior values. Professionalism recognizes group expectations and minimums, but also emphasizes individual internal morality and individual external conduct.
12
Professionalism – Actions/Values
11/18/2013
7
Questions that Each Must Answer:
Are you ethical?
Are you professional?
Are you an ethical professional?
Ethics and Professionalism
13
Definitions
Ethics is “the study of moral standards and how they affect conduct”; it is “a system of moral principles governing the appropriate conduct for a person or group” Merriam-Webster dictionary
Your ethics reflect your principles, morals, beliefs; your ethics reflect your moral code; they dictate your conduct.
Ethics and Professionalism
14
11/18/2013
8
Definitions (cont.)
The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines professionalism as "the conduct, aims, or qualities that characterize or mark a profession or a professional person"; and it defines a profession as "a calling requiring specialized knowledge and often long and intensive academic preparation."
Ethics and Professionalism
15
Definitions
A profession is "a vocation requiring knowledge of some department of learning or science."
A professional is one who follows "an occupation as a means of livelihood or gain," or one who is "engaged in one of the learned professions."
Professionalism is exhibited by one of the "professional character, spirit or methods" or the "standing, practice, or methods of a professional as distinguished from an amateur."
American College Dictionary
Ethics and Professionalism
16
11/18/2013
9
One lay writer list ten characteristics of professionalism:
Appearance – Be neat
Demeanor – Polite confidence
Reliability – Get the job done
Competence – Be an expert in your field
Ethics – Never walk the ethical line
Lay View of Professionalism
17
Lay Characteristics of professionalism:
Maintain your poise –Be an adult Phone Etiquette – Identify , don’t dominate
Written Correspondence – Polite and brief
Organizational Skills – Neat and organized
Accountability –Accept responsibility
Chris Joseph: ttp://smallbusiness.chron.com/1characteristics-professionalism-708.html
Lay View (Cont.)
18
11/18/2013
10
MindTools lists these attributes:
Specialized Knowledge
Honest and Integrity
Accountability
Self-Regulation
Image – Look the Part
http://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/professionalism.htm, MindTools
Professionalism – Attributes
19
But
“Professionalism does not mean wearing a suit or carrying a briefcase; rather, it means conducting oneself with responsibility, integrity, accountability, and excellence. It means communicating effectively and appropriately and always finding a way to be productive. “
http://www.dol.gov/odep/topics/youth/softskills/Professionalism.pdf
Ethics and Professionalism
20
11/18/2013
11
Analogizing to Robert Fulghum’s, All I Really Need to Know I Learned in Kindergarten, and at the risk of seeming to list the attributes of a Boy Scout, here is a simple list of items that can be the focus of re-igniting professionalism in each one of us:
Honesty, Integrity, Knowledge, Competence, Humility, Civility, Altruism, Accountability
Re-Igniting Professionalism
21
Honesty
“The quality of being fair and truthful : the quality of being honest [including].
a : fairness and straightforwardness of conduct.
b : adherence to the facts.”
Merriam-Webster Dictionary
Ethics and Professionalism
22
11/18/2013
12
Honesty
President, Thomas Jefferson, once said, “Honesty is the first chapter in the book of wisdom.” First Inaugural Address, March 4, 1801 (Washington, D.C.).
Ethics and Professionalism
23
Integrity
“ [T]he quality of being honest and fair : the state of being complete or whole - firm
adherence to a code of especially moral or artistic values : incorruptibility an unimpaired condition : soundness
: the quality or state of being complete or undivided . . . .”
Ethics and Professionalism
24
11/18/2013
13
Integrity
"Integrity is a personal choice, an uncompromising and predictably consistent commitment to honourmoral, ethical. spiritual and artistic values and principles.“
Barbara Killinger,(2010). Integrity, Doing the Right Thing for the Right Reason. McGill-Queen's University Press. p. 12
Ethics and Professionalism
25
Integrity
“[F]irm adherence to a code of especially moral or artistic values: incorruptibility”
Ones actions, beliefs, methods, measures and principles must derive from a single set of core value. Texas Lawyer's Creed-A Mandate for Professionalism, (adopted by the Supreme Court of Texas and the Court of Criminal Appeals, Nov. 7, 1989),
Professionals should be committed to being fair, truthful and straightforward in their interactions with patients and the profession.
26
Ethics and Professionalism
11/18/2013
14
Knowledge
“[F]acts, information, and skills acquired by a person through experience or education; the theoretical or practical understanding of a subject: a thirst for knowledge…
what is known in a particular field or in total; facts and information. . . .” Oxford Dictionary.
Professionals are obligated to make a commitment to life-long learning.
Ethics and Professionalism
27
Competence
(different from knowledge)
“[T]he ability to do something well . . . .” Merriam-Webster Dictionary.
There are levels of competence:
28
Ethics and Professionalism
11/18/2013
15
Levels of Competence
Novice: Rule-based behavior, strongly limited and inflexible
Experienced Beginner: Incorporates aspects of the situation
Practitioner: Acting consciously from long-term goals and plans
Knowledgeable practitioner: Sees the situation as a whole and acts from personal conviction
Expert: Has an intuitive understanding of the situation and zooms in on the central aspects
Dreyfus, Stuart E.; Dreyfus, Hubert L. (February 1980). A Five-Stage Model of the Mental Activities Involved in Directed Skill Acquisition:
Ethics and Professionalism
29
Humility
Humility is the understanding of your place in the context of the group to which you adhere, such as the legal profession.
30
Ethics and Professionalism
11/18/2013
16
Civility
Texas Lawyer's Creed-A Mandate for Professionalism, (adopted by the Supreme Court of Texas and the Court of Criminal Appeals, Nov. 7, 1989),
“I am a lawyer. I am entrusted by the People of Texas to preserve and improve our legal system. I am licensed by the Supreme Court of Texas. I must therefore abide by the Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct, but I know that professionalism requires more than merely avoiding the violation of laws and rules.”
31
Ethics and Professionalism
Civility
“Civility is a broad term, but most legal professionals would describe it as professional courtesy.” Catherine M. Stone, Kimberly S. Keller, Shane J. Stolarczyk, Civility in the Legal Profession: A Survey of the Texas Judiciary, 36 Civility in the Legal Profession: A Survey of the Texas Judiciary (2004).
32
Ethics and Professionalism
11/18/2013
17
Altruism
A professional is obligated to attend to the best interest of their clients (the community, and the public), rather than to their own self-interest.
A Professionals should accept a commitment to service within the profession and the community.
Ethics and Professionalism
33
Accountability
Professionals are accountable to their clients, to society on issues of public health, and to their profession.
Individually, each one of us is the only entity that can control, change, direct and re-direct us.
Ethics and Professionalism
34
11/18/2013
18
In order to particularize what professionalism is, it is useful to go though the Lawyers’ Creed, promulgated by the Texas Supreme Court and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals in 1999.
While this document is aimed at lawyers, many of the precepts contained therein are applicable to any professional.
35
Professionalism – The Creed
The conduct of a lawyer should be characterized at all times by honesty, candor, and fairness. In fulfilling his or her primary duty to a client, a lawyer must be ever mindful of the profession's broader duty to the legal system
Professionalism – The Creed
36
11/18/2013
19
I. Our Legal System
1. I am passionately proud of my profession. Therefore, "My word is my bond.“
2. I am responsible to assure that all persons have access to competent representation regardless of wealth or position in life.
Professionalism – The Creed
37
3. I commit myself to an adequate and effective pro bono program.
4. I am obligated to educate my clients, the public, and other lawyers regarding the spirit and letter of this Creed.
5. I will always be conscious of my duty to the judicial system.
Professionalism – The Creed
38
11/18/2013
20
II. Lawyer to Client
1. I will advise my client of the contents of this creed when undertaking representation.
Professionalism – The Creed
39
2. I will endeavor to achieve my client's lawful objectives in legal transactions and in litigation as quickly and economically as possible.
3. I will be loyal and committed to my client's lawful objectives, but I will not permit that loyalty and commitment to interfere with my duty to provide objective and independent advice.
Professionalism – The Creed
40
11/18/2013
21
4. I will advise my client that civility and courtesy are expected and are not a sign of weakness.
5. I will advise my client of proper and expected behavior.
6. I will treat adverse parties and witnesses with fairness and due consideration. A client has no right to demand that I abuse anyone or indulge in any offensive conduct.
Professionalism – The Creed
41
7. I will advise my client that we will not pursue conduct which is intended primarily to harass or drain the financial resources of the opposing party.
8. I will advise my client that we will not pursue tactics which are intended primarily for delay.
Professionalism – The Creed
42
11/18/2013
22
9. I will advise my client that we will not pursue any course of action which is without merit.
10. I will advise my client that I reserve the right to determine whether to grant accommodations to opposing counsel in all matters that do not adversely affect my client's lawful objectives. A client has no right to instruct me to refuse reasonable requests made by other counsel.
Professionalism – The Creed
43
11. I will advise my client regarding the availability of mediation, arbitration, and other alternative methods of resolving and settling disputes.
III. Lawyer to Judge
1. I will be courteous, civil, and prompt in oral and written communications.
2. I will not quarrel over matters of form or style, but I will concentrate on matters of substance.
Professionalism – The Creed
44
11/18/2013
23
3. I will identify for other counsel or parties all changes I have made in documents submitted for review.
4. I will attempt to prepare documents which correctly reflect the agreement of the parties. I will not include provisions which have not been agreed upon or omit provisions which are necessary to reflect the agreement of the parties.
Professionalism – The Creed
45
5. I will notify opposing counsel, and, if appropriate, the Court or other persons, as soon as practicable, when hearings, depositions, meetings, conferences or closings are cancelled.
6. I will agree to reasonable requests for extensions of time and for waiver of procedural formalities, provided legitimate objectives of my client will not be adversely affected.
Professionalism – The Creed
46
11/18/2013
24
7. I will not serve motions or pleadings in any manner that unfairly limits another party's opportunity to respond.
8. I will attempt to resolve by agreement my objections to matters contained in pleadings and discovery requests and responses.
Professionalism – The Creed
47
9. I can disagree without being disagreeable. I recognize that effective representation does not require antagonistic or obnoxious behavior. I will neither encourage nor knowingly permit my client or anyone under my control to do anything which would be unethical or improper if done by me.
Professionalism – The Creed
48
11/18/2013
25
10. I will not, without good cause, attribute bad motives or unethical conduct to opposing counsel nor bring the profession into disrepute by unfounded accusations or impropriety. I will avoid disparaging personal remarks or acrimony towards opposing counsel, parties and witnesses. I will not be influenced by any ill feeling between clients. I will abstain from any allusion to personal peculiarities or idiosyncrasies of opposing counsel.
Professionalism – The Creed
49
11. I will not take advantage, by causing any default or dismissal to be rendered, when I know the identity of an opposing counsel, without first inquiring about the counsel's intention to proceed.
Professionalism – The Creed
50
11/18/2013
26
12. I will promptly submit orders to the Court. I will deliver copies to opposing counsel before or contemporaneously with submission to the Court. I will promptly approve the form of orders which accurately reflect the substance of the rulings of the Court.
Professionalism – The Creed
51
13. I will not attempt to gain an unfair advantage by sending the Court or its staff correspondence or copies of correspondence.
14. I will not arbitrarily schedule a deposition, court appearance, or hearing until a good faith effort has been made to schedule it by agreement.
15. I will readily stipulate to undisputed facts in order to avoid needless costs or inconvenience for any party.
Professionalism – The Creed
52
11/18/2013
27
16. I will refrain from excessive and abusive discovery.
17. I will comply with all reasonable discovery requests. I will not resist discovery requests which are not objectionable. I will not make objections nor give instructions to a witness for the purpose of delaying or obstructing the discovery process. I will encourage witnesses to respond to all deposition questions which are reasonably understandable. I will neither encourage nor permit my witness to quibble about words where their meaning is reasonably clear.
Professionalism – The Creed
53
18. I will not seek Court intervention to obtain discovery which is clearly improper and not discoverable.
19. I will not seek sanctions or disqualifications unless it is necessary for protection of my client's lawful objectives or is fully justified by the circumstances.
Professionalism – The Creed
54
11/18/2013
28
IV. Lawyer and Judge
1. I will always recognize that the position of judge is the symbol of both the judicial system and administration of justice. I will refrain from conduct that degrades this symbol.
Professionalism – The Creed
55
2. I will conduct myself in Court in a professional manner and demonstrate my respect for the Court and the law.
3. I will not engage in any conduct which offends the dignity and decorum of proceedings.
4. I will treat counsel, opposing parties, the Court, and members of the Court staff with courtesy and civility.
Professionalism – The Creed
56
11/18/2013
29
5. I will be punctual.
6. I will not knowingly misrepresent, mischaracterize, misquote or miscite facts or authorities to gain an advantage.
7. I will respect the rulings of the Court.
8. I will give the issues in controversy deliberate, impartial and studied analysis and consideration.
Professionalism – The Creed
57
9. I will be considerate of the time constraints and pressures imposed upon the Court, Court staff and counsel in efforts to administer justice and resolve disputes.
Professionalism – The Creed
58
11/18/2013
30
“ . . .’[T]he professionalism campaign is destined to fail so long as it focuses on “‘vague . . . invocations of shared values that really aren't shared.’ [We must acknowledge that professionalism is not a destination, but rather, a journey during which we all must critically evaluate the effects of our conduct - not just on our clients and on our income - but also on our profession, on our society, and on our relationships with one another.”
Dane S. Ciolino, Redefining Professionalism as Seeking, 49 Loy. L. Rev. 229 (2003)
59
Professionalism as a Journey
Conclusion
Whether you are a lawyer or a business person, or both, the ethics guiding your conduct are the minimum standards required of you in your dealings with others. They provide the outer limits beyond which you cannot go.
Mainly, leave anywhere you go better than you found it – that includes your profession.
Professionalism – Conclusion
60