EuthanasiaEuthanasia

Parveen Kaur (11)Parveen Kaur (11)

Phuah Zhi Yi (12)Phuah Zhi Yi (12)

Yeoh Ee Ping (21)Yeoh Ee Ping (21)

Najmah Abd. Razak (09)Najmah Abd. Razak (09)

What is Euthanasia?

• Practice of the painless killing of someone who is suffering a painful

illness that cannot be cured or someone who is very old

• Omission of a dependent human being for his/her alleged benefit

• Simply, it can be known as mercy killing in laymen’s term

4 types of EuthanasiaVoluntary and direct: Chosen and carried

out with patient’s request

Voluntary but indirect: Decision had been chosen in advance by the patient before any complications happens. If something goes wrong, and they become terminally, the decision on whether to let them live or die would be up to their advanced agreement

4 types of EuthanasiaDirect but in voluntary: Done for the

patient without his/her request

Indirect and involuntary: The hospital decides whether it is time to remove life support from the patient because they feel that the patient has no more or little chance of surviving

What is the main issue with euthanasia?There are always two sides to a debate; People who

feel that lives of human-beings cannot be taken away because it is unethical and immoral will take a

pro-life standPro-life1. Devalues human life.2. Can become a means of healthcare costs

containment. 3. Physicians and other medical care people should

not be involved in directly causing death.4. “Slippery Slope” effect that has occurred where

euthanasia has been first legalised for only the terminally ill. Now, laws are changed to allow it for other people or to be done non-voluntarily.

What is the main issue with euthanasia?

There are always two sides to a debate; People who feel that freedom of choice is being oppressed will take a pro-choice stand

Pro-choice1. Provides a way to relieve extreme pain.2. Provides a way of relief when the person’s quality

of life is low.3. Frees up medical funds to help other people.4. Freedom of choice.

Ethical Issues of Euthanasia• Religious groups find it outrageous for people to

kill themselves just because they find it hard to live

• Perseverance is key (God only helps those who help themselves)• Religious parties believe that life is precious

and is given by God, therefore only God should determine when it is time for us to die

Why forbid Euthanasia?Fear of the misuse/abuse of

Euthanasia in future• Patients are killed although they did

not choose to die• Fear of people using Euthanasia to

end their lives deliberately without good reason

Fact: In the UK, killing a person with any form is considered murder.

PRO-CHOICENetherlands (Green), Belgium (Red), Oregon and Washington (Yellow)

Countries in which assisted suicide or euthanasia are

legal:

Provides a way to relieve extreme pain:

• Argue that a civilized society should be allowed to die with dignity and without pain

• Allow others to assist in euthanasia

PRO-CHOICE

Provides a way of relief when the person’s quality of life is

low• People who have a low quality of

life should be given the rights to end their life

• They should not be forced to stay alive and suffer because it is inhumane and cruel

• Making people go on to live suffering, violates a person’s freedom of rights

Euthanasia and Suicide

HOWEVER

• There is a difference between Euthanasia and suicide

• Some religions allow the use of Euthanasia as it helps one relieve the pain of incurable illnesses (belief that it is no use making a person live when we already know that no hope is left)

• Suicide is the deliberate killing of one’s-self

Singapore’s View on Euthanasia (People)

• Many still believe in living to the fullest of life• Only about 10,000 have signed on to the Advance

Medical Directive Act (AMD) instilled in 1996, to indicate that they will not want to be subjected to any special life-support when they are already dying

• Many avoid talking about death (taboo)• However there is no right or wrong in the issue.

Singapore’s Decision (Governmental)• To allow or to disallow,

Euthanasia still remains as question mark in Singapore.

• Debates are still on going about this controversial issue which touches on morals and determines life and death

Singapore, an ageing population• By 2030, one in five Singaporeans will reach

60 years• Majority will face terminal illnesses at some

point which even modern technology may not be able to guarantee cure but only reduce the symptoms

• With Singaporeans feeling that there is no right or wrong, many remain as fence- sitters: They are not 100% sure that there is no more value to their life anymore

Acknowledgement

• http://www.world-faiths.com/GCSE%20Short%20course/euthanasia.JPG

• http://www.lifeissues.net/writers/pol/pol_01euthimpactfamily.html

• http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/euthanasia/ • http://www.hsc.usc.edu/~mbernste/

ethics.euthanasia.html • http://blogs.straitstimes.com/2008/12/12/the-great-e

uthanasia-debate• http://www.euthanasia.com/proscons.html