evolution of digital reinstatement methods within private ... · evolution of digital reinstatement...
TRANSCRIPT
Evolution of Digital Reinstatement Methods Within Private Cadastral
Organisations
A thesis
submitted in fulfilment of
the requirement for
the Degree of Master of Applied Science (Research)
by
Stephen William Steggall,
Bachelor of Surveying (UQ)
Graduate Diploma of Surveying Practice (QUT)
Queensland University of Technology
Faculty of Built Environment and Engineering
School of Design and Built Environment
in association with the
Research Centre for
Design and Construction Studies
October 2001
Page i
Keywords
surveying, cadastral surveying, reinstatement, digital, digital lodgment, land
information systems, geographic information systems, total station, electronic data
recorder, reinstatement calculations
Page ii
Abstract Cadastral reinstatement methods within Queensland involve the use of modern digital
surveying techniques in combination with traditional non-digital methods of recording
and reporting information. This leads to the need to manually enter and re-enter data
into a digital format at different stages of a survey. The requirement to lodge survey
information with government organisations in a non-digital survey plan format also
forces a break in digital data flow throughout the cadastral surveying system, which
can only be updated by changes in the lodgement regulations.
The private cadastral organisations are predominantly responsible for carrying out the
cadastral surveys and the government agencies are primarily responsible for the
examination, verification and administration of the cadastral data. These organisations
will have no communication link for digital cadastral data until the introduction of
digital data lodgement. The digital system within the private cadastral surveying
organisations can therefore be considered to be an independent system with
consideration needed to be given to the future introduction of a digital lodgement
system at some undefined time in the future.
Cadastral surveyors hold large amounts of digital information that is suitable for
digital reinstatement systems. This information, if appropriately archived and
distributed, has the capacity to meet the needs of reinstatement systems including as
an alternative source of digital information that will eventually be obtained from
digital lodgement systems. The existing technology and the private organisation
structures are capable of supporting continuous digital data flow and automated
systems.
This research proposes a process of development for private cadastral organisations to
advance from traditional systems to continuous digital data flow and automated
processes within their cadastral reinstatement systems. The development process is
linked to existing legislation and technology taking into consideration likely future
Page iii
directions. The current legislative and technological environments within Queensland
allow for development towards automated digital systems that will enhance most
current cadastral reinstatement systems.
Page iv
Table of Contents
Keywords ............................................................................................................... i Abstract .............................................................................................................. ii Table of Contents.................................................................................................... iv List of Tables .......................................................................................................... vi List of Acronyms ................................................................................................... vii Statement of Original Authorship......................................................................... viii Acknowledgements................................................................................................. ix
Chapter 1 Introduction ........................................................................................ 2
1 Problem Statement ............................................................................... 2 2 Aim and Scope ..................................................................................... 3 3 Overview of the Study.......................................................................... 3
Chapter 2 The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland..................... 7
1 Cadastral Surveying ............................................................................. 9 2 The Queensland Cadastral Surveying System ................................... 14 3 Digital Technology Development in Queensland’s Cadastral Surveying
System ................................................................................................ 16 4 Summary ............................................................................................ 20
Chapter 3 Modern Surveying Technology ....................................................... 23
1 Hardware ............................................................................................ 24 2 Software ............................................................................................. 27 3 Methods.............................................................................................. 29 4 Summary ............................................................................................ 36
Chapter 4 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution.......... 39
1 Motivation for Technical Change and Commercial Considerations.. 39 2 Existing Organisational Structures..................................................... 42 3 The Structure of Private Cadastral Surveying Organisations............. 44 4 Summary ............................................................................................ 47
Chapter 5 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution .................. 50
1 Historical Data.................................................................................... 50 2 Field Data Collection ......................................................................... 51 3 Reinstatement Calculations ................................................................ 62 4 Data Base Development ..................................................................... 71 5 Summary ............................................................................................ 73
Page v
Chapter 6 Digital System Evolution in Private Cadastral Surveying Organisations.................................................................................... 76
1 The Digital Cadastral System............................................................. 76 2 Incremental System Development ..................................................... 83 3 Implementation................................................................................... 98 4 Summary ............................................................................................ 99
Chapter 7 Conclusions and Implications ....................................................... 102
1 Conclusions ...................................................................................... 102 2 Implications...................................................................................... 105
Appendix 1 107
Bibliography 110
Page vi
List of Tables
Table 2.1 Queensland Cadastral Surveying System .......................................... 15 Table 2.2 Cook's Alternative Technological Scenarios ..................................... 18 Table 4.1 Traditional Digital Flow Chart........................................................... 45 Table 6.1 Cadastral Reinstatement Flow Chart.................................................. 83 Table 6.2 Traditional System Flow Chart .......................................................... 85 Table 6.3 Internal Digital Data Flow.................................................................. 93 Table 6.4 External Data Flow............................................................................. 94
Page vii
List of Acronyms
ASCII American Standard Code for Information Interchange CAD Computer Aided Design and Drafting Systems CSD Cadastral Survey Group DXF Digital Exchange Format EDM Electronic Distance Measuring Equipment GIS Geographic Information Systems ICDISG Information Collection and Data Interchange Standardisation Group LIS Land Information System NPDP National Procurement Development Program SDTS Spatial Data Transfer System
Page viii
Statement of Original Authorship
The work contained in this thesis has not been previously submitted for a degree or diploma at any other higher education institution. To the best of my knowledge and belief, the thesis contains no material previously published or written by another person except where due reference is made.
Signed: Date:
Page ix
Acknowledgements I acknowledge the contribution and guidance of my supervisors: Associate Professor Brian Hannigan Principal Supervisor (Retired) Dr. John Hayes Principal Supervisor Dr. John Cook Associate Supervisor
Page 1 Chapter 1: Introduction
Chapter 1
Introduction
Page 2 Chapter 1: Introduction
Chapter 1 Introduction 1 Problem Statement
Current cadastral reinstatement methods within Queensland involve the use of modern
digital surveying equipment in combination with manual recording and reporting
techniques. This leads to the need to manually enter and re-enter data into a digital
format at different stages of a survey. The process of re-entering data into a digital
format is inefficient and creates an additional source of errors.
The private cadastral organisations are predominantly responsible for carrying out the
cadastral surveys and the government agencies are primarily responsible for the
examination, verification and administration of the cadastral information. The
requirement for private cadastral organisations to lodge survey information with
government organisations in survey plan format forces a break in digital data flow
throughout the cadastral surveying system, which can only be updated by changes in
the lodgement regulations. The digital data flow within the private cadastral surveying
organisations are therefore independent of the digital data flow within the government
agencies. The introduction of a digital lodgement system at some undefined time in
the future will create a digital link between the private organisations and government
agencies.
Private cadastral surveying organisations are capable of collecting and distributing
digital cadastral data with appropriate content and format that is suitable for use in
digital cadastral reinstatement systems. The coverage area and content of databases
produced outside compulsory legislative processes is restricted by the ability of
cadastral surveyors to share information. Private cadastral surveying organisations
can benefit by the introduction of continuos digital data flow and automated processes
within their organisations and can be enhanced by the availability of appropriate
digital cadastral data.
Page 3 Chapter 1: Introduction
2 Aim and Scope
This research proposes a process of development to introduce continuous digital data
flow and automated systems within the cadastral reinstatement systems of private
cadastral organisations. The process will be compatible with the technical and
organisational issues existing in the current cadastral surveying environment in
Queensland.
The scope of this research is based on the digital data flow within the cadastral
reinstatement systems of private surveying organisations in Queensland. The focus
will be on reinstatement systems within the environment, particularly the legislative
environment in Queensland although it is acknowledged that reinstatement systems
within New Zealand and the states and territories of Australia are similar. Some
experiences and references will be drawn from the international and national levels
but the conclusions will be restricted to the cadastral reinstatement system in
Queensland.
The focus will also be restricted to the private surveying organisations. It will be
shown that the reinstatement system within private cadastral organisations can be
considered in isolation to the broader digital cadastral surveying system at state level.
It will also be shown that these elements have different input and output requirements.
The overall cadastral system in Queensland including digital lodgement and cadastral
mapping will not be the focus of this research.
3 Overview of the Study
This dissertation describes the existing cadastral surveying system and analyses the
issues relevant to the development from traditional reinstatement to digital
reinstatement systems. The particular issues are discussed in terms of problems raised
and the possible solutions to the individual issues. The individual solutions are
combined into a flexible system of development that deals with the identified issues.
The incremental development system is reviewed in terms of the technical and
commercial benefits to the private cadastral surveyor.
Page 4 Chapter 1: Introduction
Chapter 1 introduces the subject to be studied and the overall aim of the research
followed by an overview of the study.
Chapter 2 provides an introduction and analysis of the existing cadastral surveying
system in Queensland and the development of digital systems. The analysis identifies
that reinstatement procedures are based on a set of flexible guidelines rather than
fixed rules of reinstatement and determines that the digital systems within private
cadastral organisations are digitally independent of the Queensland Government
cadastral system.
Chapter 3 identifies modern technology and methods that have applications to the
development of digital systems within the Queensland cadastral surveying system.
Digital technology being used and tested in associated fields provides options for
direct application to cadastral reinstatement systems.
Chapter 4 examines the organisational issues that effect digital system development.
The digital system operates within a changing environment where it is essential for
the cadastral surveying organisations to react to the changes as they occur. Where
private or government organisations do not react to change, there is a window of
opportunity for the more flexible organisations to take commercial advantage.
Structural change, including forming associations with other organisations, provides
for sharing and distribution of digital data.
Chapter 5 examines the separate technical issues that effect digital system
development. These issues are analysed in terms of providing automated processes
and continuous digital data flow between elements of the system. The analysis
identifies elements that can proceed on a stand-alone basis, need to be developed in
parallel with other system elements and those that require development beyond the
available commercial products.
Page 5 Chapter 1: Introduction
Chapter 6 describes a system of incremental development of the digital reinstatement
process and an evaluation of the commercial benefits of the digital system. The
incremental development process deals with the issues raised in earlier chapters as it
sets out a flexible system of development. The process describes the transition from
traditional reinstatement systems to a digital system containing automated processes
and continuous digital data flow. The process includes the development of digital
reinstatement procedures and encompasses the flow and distribution of digital
cadastral data. The incremental development process is shown to provide commercial
advantages to the private cadastral surveying organisation.
Chapter 7 identifies the principal conclusions and discusses the implications for
private cadastral organisations.
Page 6 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
Chapter 2
The Cadastral Reinstatement System in
Queensland
Page 7 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
Chapter 2 The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
Cadastral reinstatement as part of the cadastral surveying process is predominantly
undertaken by private cadastral surveying agencies but is controlled to some extent by
government legislation. Legislation covers the gathering of historic information, the
collection of field data, the methods used to calculate the reinstatement and methods
of presenting the data to the government agencies. The private cadastral
organisations, although operating in the legislative environment have the freedom to
use traditional methods, digital methods or a combination of both to meet their goals.
The government agency’s roles within the cadastral surveying process include setting
standards and regulations, examination and verification of cadastral information,
mapping of cadastral information, administration of the cadastral information and the
output of cadastral information to interested parties. The role of government agencies
is dependent on political policy and the perception of this policy within the
government agencies.
The cadastral process relies on private cadastral surveyors supplying cadastral
information to government agencies in the format specified by these agencies. The
format currently required for cadastral data transfer is the survey plan but this is
expected to evolve into a digital data transfer system at some unspecified time in the
future.
The development of digital processes within the private surveying organisations will
remain mainly independent of the government agency’s level of digital development
as long as the communication link between the government and private sectors
remains as
Page 8 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
the traditional survey plan. Any new systems being developed by private
surveying organisations will need to operate in the current environment and where
possible also function within the digital transfer systems of the future. The motivation
for digital development within the private organisations will be dominated by internal
considerations until changes in the communication link are made.
The factors that control the way reinstatement surveys are carried out within private
cadastral organisations include government legislation, client requirements and
commercial considerations. The client normally expects the surveyor carrying out a
reinstatement survey to meet the legislative requirements for an acceptable price. The
process involved in changing government legislation is time-consuming and uncertain
and is therefore out of the control of the surveyor in the short-term. This leaves the
commercial considerations as the main controlling influence on reinstatement
surveying systems.
The motivation for digital systems to develop is primarily an economic one from the
point of view of the private surveying organisations. Private organisations need to
improve efficiency or create new markets to make changes to digital systems viable.
The amount of resources required to make the change also has to be balanced against
the benefit of making the change. The digital systems will develop within private
surveying organisations if the person in authority can see a perceived economic
advantage that outweighs the cost of implementing the change.
Rapid changes in available technology require systems to be used that work in the
current environment but also function in environments that may develop in the future.
This not only affects the way we carry out tasks, but also what tasks are required to be
undertaken. Much of the technology that has applications to the reinstatement of
cadastral boundaries has been developed and applied in other areas of the land
information industry.
Page 9 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
The leaders amongst the private cadastral surveying organisations can take
commercial advantage over their competitors by applying new technology in an
efficient and timely manner. Once the new systems become standard procedure and
are generally practised by most surveyors then the opportunity for commercial
advantage within individual surveying organisations passes. At this point the
resultant commercial benefits of the new technology passes on to the clients or end
users of the product.
1 Cadastral Surveying
Cadastral surveying is the process of determination of boundaries of a piece of land or
water and is defined in Queensland by the Surveyors Act 1977 as follows:
“cadastral survey” means any process of determining, mapping or planning the boundaries of a piece of land or waters required or authorised-
(a) under any Act dealing with the alienation, leasing, and occupation of Crown lands or with mining, or affecting titles to land; or
(b) by the proprietor, lessee or mortgagee under any Act affecting titles to land; or (c) by the owner, proprietor, lessee, mortgagee or occupier of, or any person holding a
registered interest in, any land for the re-establishment of, or identification of, or adjustment of any boundary of such land; or
(d) under any Act to be made or certified by a Licensed Surveyor.
The process of the cadastral surveying system in Queensland is described as follows: The process includes:
• The determination and marking of the position of the boundaries of a parcel/parcels of land by a Licensed Surveyor in accordance with the Surveyors Act 1977, Surveyors Regulations 1992 and other relevant legislation,
• The presentation and lodgement of the Licensed Surveyors determination of the boundaries in a format (usually plotted on a fixed format plan form in accordance with standards as shown in the Survey Plan Manual) for examination by registering authority, and
• The examination and verification of the information shown on the plan by registering authority before registration of the surveyor’s work by amendment of the cadastre.
This definition of the cadastral surveying process identifies three elements. The first
identified is the role of the Licensed Surveyors who are predominantly private sector
surveyors. The second element refers to the registration process that is the
communication link between the private sector surveyors and the government sector
Page 10 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
registering authorities. The third element of the definition defines the role of the
registering authorities.
1.1 Reinstatement Surveying – Determining the Position of the Boundary
The reinstatement of cadastral boundaries is the process of determining the position of
boundaries, as they exist at the time of survey. The surveyor must take into
consideration the legal rights of all people who have rights and interests in the subject
piece of land and adjoining properties. The results of these surveys are required to be
lodged with the appropriate registering authorities to maintain the public record of
land boundaries.
The surveyor firstly collects the evidence of the position of the boundary and then
applying the principles of reinstatement, forms an opinion on the reinstated position
of the cadastral boundary. The surveyor does not have the power to determine the
boundary but in most cases the surveyors opinion is not challenged.
As Hannigan said: the surveyor has no judicial powers to say where a boundary is. Only the courts have that power. The surveyor collects evidence as if preparing a case for a court. In almost all cases the surveyor’s determination is not challenged and so the position of the reinstatement stands by public acceptance;
1.1.1 Collecting the evidence.
Collecting the evidence for a cadastral survey comprises firstly establishing the
historical evidence (search) and then determining the facts, as they exist on the ground
(field Survey).
The surveyor searches for historical data by examining all the existing recorded
evidence relative to the survey including title documents, registered plans and
identification surveys. The search provides evidence regarding the rights and
entitlements of the
Page 11 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
people that have an interest in the property and the spatial relationships between
property boundaries and other recorded survey marks that existed at the time of each
individual survey. The search provides the first indication of the intentions of the
parties involved in establishing the original boundaries.
The field survey is undertaken to establish the facts on the ground at the time of the
survey with all the evidence being located, measured and recorded in the field notes.
The Surveyors Regulation 1992 states:
26. (1) When a cadastral survey (including an identification survey) is required to
determine the position of an existing boundary, a Licensed Surveyor must—
(a) ascertain the positions and descriptions of the existing survey marks and occupation that provide evidence of the boundary;
The field survey consists of the spatial record of information which normally consists
of an open or closed traverse with radiations taken to points of interest, descriptions of
these points of interest uniquely identifying them with respect to historical marks
where appropriate, and additional notes describing the condition and relevance of any
other evidence.
1.1.2 Reinstatement Principles
The surveyor examines the historical evidence in relation to what exists. The location
of the reinstated boundaries is then determined considering the evidence and the
principles of reinstatement.
The Surveyors Regulation 1992 sets out directions in regard to reinstatement in
Section 26. Reinstatement of existing boundaries
26. (1) When a cadastral survey (including an identification survey) is required to determine the position of an existing boundary, a Licensed Surveyor must—
Page 12 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
(a) ascertain the positions and descriptions of the existing survey marks and
occupation that provide evidence of the boundary; and
(b) give primary consideration to the existing survey marks, unless other evidence (including original measurements, the position of improvements or statements by occupiers) suggests that the existing marks were incorrectly placed or have been disturbed; and
(c) if it is positively determined that a survey mark has not been placed as
originally intended, reset the mark according to the original intentions, after recording the position of the mark being reset; and
(d) determine whether or not the position of an ambulatory boundary is
significantly different from the position marked on the registered plan; and
(e) record whether an encroachment, within the meaning of section 183 of the Property Law Act 1974, has arisen; and
(f) ascertain and record the position of any occupation that affects or is
affected by the reinstatement of a boundary.
(2) If a surveyor determines that an owner may be adversely affected by the reinstatement of a boundary (except in the case of an identification survey), the surveyor must—
(a) without delay take all reasonable steps to give written notice to the owner
of the intention to seek registration of the plan with the reinstated boundary; and
(b) advise the registering authority of the steps taken to notify the owner.
The Surveyors Regulation 1992 establishes the guiding principles that must be used to
determine reinstated boundaries within Queensland. Additional principles of
reinstatement have been developed through a process of legislation and interpretation
by the courts to supplement the guiding principles.
A surveyor called on to locate and certify to the corners and boundaries of land, whether on a new subdivision or by way of remarking an old one, and whether the “old” one be one year old or 100, will find himself in the position of a Court faced with the interpretation of the deed, and bound by the same rules.
A commonly referred to “hierarchy of reinstatement evidence” has been established
by Brown based on Australian cases and American cases that can be applied here.
The hierarchy of reinstatement evidence appears to set out a clear set of rules that may
Page 13 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
be used for the reinstatement of cadastral boundaries. This must be seen in the
context of two of the statements included within the hierarchy of evidence.
In making a survey to re-establish the boundaries of land, the first and over-riding aim is to arrive at the intention of the parties expressed in the original documents establishing those boundaries.
And 10. Finally, but most important of all, any one of these rules may be of more (or less) weight in one case than another. The rules set out are for cases of conflict, they are general rules, to be used as a guide but not as a straitjacket.
These statements emphasise the fact that the surveyor at some time in the process is
expected to make a value judgement to arrive at an opinion. It is also possible that two
different surveyors may from time to time arrive at different opinions given the same
information.
The principles of reinstatement rely on a combination of guidelines offered by
legislation and flexible rules from the hierarchy of reinstatement evidence from which
qualified and experienced surveyors are required to make judgments. There are no set
rules that can be followed to the letter to arrive at a unique solution to all
reinstatement problems.
1.2 Traditional Measuring Methods
Before 1880 accurate measurement in both direction and distance was considered a
low priority. The use of the theodolite became mandatory for all surveys in New
South Wales in 1868 and steel tape was introduced to Queensland in 1877.
The next major improvements in technology came in the 1970’s with the introduction
of electronic computers, electronic calculators and electronic distance measuring
equipment (EDM). These developments caused a marked decrease in the time taken
to carry out calculations and improved the accuracy achievable in measuring
distances. The introduction of efficient electronic calculators not only improved the
speed of calculations but also had an effect on the way surveys were carried out.
Page 14 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
2 The Queensland Cadastral Surveying System
Queensland’s cadastral surveying system exists as a part of a hierarchal system, being
part of the broader land information industry. Cook identifies four organisational
levels:
• Land information industry
• Surveying and mapping industry
• Cadastral surveying and mapping system
• Government and private agencies involved in cadastral survey
Cook’s Table 4.3, reproduced below (Table 2.1) identifies the systems involved
within the cadastral surveying and mapping system in Queensland and makes some
comment on the performance of their roles.
The Queensland cadastral surveying system consists of predominately private
cadastral surveying organisations carrying out the work of cadastral reinstatement
with the resultant information being lodged with local and state government
authorities. The state government agencies have the responsibility for cadastral
mapping and records management.
The control network for cadastral surveys, being the network of connections to survey
monuments and reference marks, is supplied by the private agencies as part of the
cadastral survey. This information is supplied to the registering authorities in
the
required standard survey plan format. It is the responsibility of the state government
to maintain the geodetic control network. The integration of the cadastral survey
control and geodetic control networks is also the responsibility of the state
government in their role as cadastral mapping and digital land boundary information
supplier.
Page 15 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
Table 2.1 Queensland Cadastral Surveying System
This table is unavailable online.
Please consult the hardcopy thesis
available at the QUT Library.
Page 16 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
Surveying equipment suppliers provide not only the hardware required for surveyors
to carry out their tasks but also the software. With computer-based technology being
a part of almost every surveying function, it is the sophistication of the software that
determines how efficiently a particular process can be carried out.
The promotion and marketing of surveying services is carried out on a local level by
private surveying organisations and in the wider more generic context by the
professional associations aligned with the private surveying organisations.
Tertiary education institutions provide undergraduate and postgraduate surveying
education. The majority of postgraduate training takes place in the surveyor’s place
of work where specific training can be given in the systems in use. With the dynamic
technology environment that exists it is important for the private agencies to establish
a culture of learning within their organisations.
3 Digital Technology Development in Queensland’s Cadastral Surveying
System
The introduction of new technology into cadastral reinstatement surveying has made
it possible for the development of digital and automated systems. The development of
advanced digital cadastral systems is partly technical and partly organisational. The
technical development relies on the availability of new technology and new software
systems that are capable of upgrading the previous system. The organisational
development required to install new systems can often be the most difficult to
overcome. Introducing new technology can have an effect on more than one level of
a system thus requiring re-organisation to take into consideration not only each
element of the system but also the communication links between those elements.
Page 17 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
Organisational development can also require economic and structural changes to the
entities requiring change and also changes in the legislation controlling the functions
of the system. Legislation and government policy changes to enable the use of new
technology where possible but the wider ramifications in surrounding systems affect
the timeframe at which legislation can react.
It is also possible to describe the technical change as either radical or incremental.
Radical change is the type of change that involves a number of incremental steps
simultaneously or changes in a completely new direction that bypasses the previous
envisaged advancement. Organisational development is more likely to lead to radical
change. Incremental change can occur as required when new technology becomes
available and economic and legislative conditions are favourable.
Cook identified three levels of technical development central to the surveying and
mapping functions summarised by the table reproduced below (Table 2.2).
The current level of technical development within Queensland is part way between
scenario 1 and scenario 2. This current system is a traditional system with the flow of
data controlled by traditional methods and with elements of digital technology being
used within the system.
The first three elements in each of the scenarios in table 2.2 describe the responsibility
of the private cadastral surveying organisations, with the fourth and fifth elements
being the communication link between the private and government agencies. The
remaining elements are generally the role of government agencies. The development
of these three levels is initially considered independently.
Page 18 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
Table 2.2 Cook's Alternative Technological Scenarios
This table is unavailable online.
Please consult the hardcopy thesis
available at the QUT Library.
The private surveying organisations require information in an appropriate format to
carry out computer analysis of historical data. The traditional format of data
exchange is the registered survey plan supplied by government agencies. This
traditional data remains as the only official record of historical surveying data but
digital data is sometimes available from within private organisations. The digital data
is not generally available and the quality and completeness of the data is uncertain.
The Scenario 3 solution requires data to be of the required format, content and
completeness.
Page 19 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
The field survey and computation of survey data is the responsibility of the private
surveying organisation with some higher level legislative control mainly with respect
to record-keeping, quality requirements and the principles for reinstatement surveys.
The communications between the levels of responsibility are the elements that require
most attention. The formats of data transfer impacts on the roles and responsibilities
of the two major players in the system. The private organisation’s systems will be
affected by change in the format of data required and the greater the change the more
drastic effect on the system. The government agencies are required to reformat the
data to suit their internal requirements and customer needs.
The processes within the communication link are dependent on both the private
surveyors and government organisations working together to achieve the best possible
outcomes. It is the responsibility of the private surveyors to translate the data from
the digital format into the graphical format required for registration, but it is the
registering authority that decides what is suitable for registration. Similarly the
quality control measures are the responsibility of the private surveyors with the
registering authorities setting the standards and controlling the format.
Survey plans remain as the communication link, regardless of whether the data has
been at some stage of the process held in a digital format. The change to total digital
transfer of data is dependent on the technology being available to meet all the
requirements of the government agencies and standards being developed to allow the
process to happen. Given the present system of titles based on traditional methods, it
is likely that the survey plan will remain as part of the communication link in parallel
with some form of digital lodgement.
The technology on both sides of the communication link is developing beyond what
can be handled by the link itself. Private surveyors require digital data from outside
sources at different stages of the production process and are required to produce
survey plans as the end product of the cadastral process. The survey plan is the only
method of communicating cadastral data with the government agencies. The
government agencies require digital data, and are therefore transferring information
from the survey plans back into the digital format. Until the communication link can
Page 20 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
be improved, further development of digital systems within the private and
government sectors will be independent of each other.
4 Summary
Cadastral reinstatement is a process of collecting evidence and applying the principles
of reinstatement to arrive at a reinstated position of the property boundary. The
principles of reinstatement are flexible guidelines that are applied by cadastral
surveyors and not a set of fixed rules that can be programmed into a computer to
obtain a solution.
The Queensland cadastral system consists of private surveying agencies that are
predominantly responsible for carrying out of cadastral surveys and the government
agencies responsible for the mapping and administration of cadastral information.
Technology development within the cadastral system is moving towards automated
systems using digital data. The development of digital technology and products
within private cadastral and government organisations are moving beyond the means
of communicating data between them. This data communication is currently by
means of survey plan only and is expected to evolve at some undefined time in the
future to include digital data transfer.
The private surveying and government organisation’s digital systems will continue to
develop independently until digital data exchange is introduced. The introduction of
digital data exchange will not however automatically integrate the system as the
digital data requirements of the different organisations are changing. The private
cadastral organisations are developing digital technology that is improving the
efficiency of their processes. For the two systems to again be the one integrated
system, not only must the private organisations present survey information in a format
required by the government sector, but the government sector must also provide data
to the private sector in the format that they require. To remain within the stated aim
and scope of this research, the private digital reinstatement systems will be considered
to be independent of the lodgement process and the government sector’s digital
cadastral system.
Page 21 Chapter 2: The Cadastral Reinstatement System in Queensland
For traditional cadastral reinstatement systems to develop into innovative digital
systems the private surveying organisations need to consider the viability of the
available technology, the structure of their organisations and technical issues effecting
the development.
Page 22 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
Chapter 3
Modern Surveying Technology
Page 23 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
Chapter 3 Modern Surveying Technology Modern technology such as data base systems, total station theodolites, global
positioning systems, electronic field books, computer calculation applications and
Computer Aided Design and Drafting systems (CAD) are being tested and used in
Queensland’s cadastral surveying and related industries. There is continuous change
to the technological environment as advancements and development occurs.
The technological environment within private cadastral surveying organisations in
Queensland is dynamic in nature. The digital processes of the private cadastral
surveying organisations are independent of government systems. These digital
processes import cadastral information from the registered survey plans and produce
survey plans as the end product. There is ample opportunity within this definition to
develop efficient systems based on digital technology and further opportunity to
develop beyond this definition as the technical and legislative environments develop.
An efficient digital system requires data to be entered into a digital format at the
earliest possible opportunity and be maintained and used in a digital format
throughout the entire process. For these conditions to be met, each element of the
system must be able to communicate digitally with other elements with no loss of data
content at the communication links.
The concept of a “surveying system” implies that the tasks accomplished - whether in the field or office - are a product of a cohesive unit.
The individual elements of the digital surveying system’s technology can be
considered in isolation but it is also important to consider the systems and methods
that hold these elements together as a cohesive unit.
Page 24 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
1 Hardware
Modern equipment commonly used in cadastral surveying systems includes total
station theodolites, electronic field books and computers.
1.1 Total Station Theodolite
Total station theodolites are a combination of an electronic theodolite and electronic
distance measuring equipment, which operates as an integrated unit. Modern total
stations often include some or all the functions of the electronic field book built into
the theodolite system. The total station is often used independently of the electronic
field book so each total station must include at least some of the basic measurement
and calculation applications. These applications usually include coordinate
calculation, angle calculations, coordinate geometry functions, traverse calculations,
resections and set out functions.
The purpose of an electronic total station is to measure the horizontal and vertical
angles and the slope distance to a target. From the basic information, additional
values including coordinates and horizontal distances may be calculated and
displayed. This information along with other information held in the total station
including instrument settings, atmospheric corrections and prism constants could be
transmitted to the electronic field book for further processing.
Instrument manufacturers are continuously improving the efficiency and accuracy of
their equipment and adding additional functions in an attempt to improve their service
and build up their market share. Some improvements include inbuilt programmes for
the calculation of curvature and refraction, single and dual axis tilt corrections,
automatic focusing, motorised systems and reflector-less measuring. Some of these
improvements have not only affected the efficiency and accuracy of existing systems
but have allowed for changes in the methods used that add additional efficiencies to
the system.
Page 25 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
1.2 Electronic Field Books
The electronic field book consists of a data-recording device and programming
functions. The data-recording device needs to record an adequate amount of
information in the format required. It is the flexibility of the programming that
determines whether an electronic field book is suitable for a particular purpose. The
physical structure of the system is of less importance then the functionality.
The structure of the electronic field book can be either: an independent device; a
device incorporated into the total station theodolite; or a combination of both. The
independent devices contain both the data recording and programming functions of
the data recorder and can be used in conjunction with a number of different total
stations from different manufacturers. It is more common among instrument
manufacturers to use data recording devices built into the total station or data
recording cards with the programming functions being maintained within the total
station.
The functions of the electronic field book include the storage of data uploaded from
existing computerised information, storage of raw data gathered in the field and the
data processing ability to manipulate this data in the manner required. The electronic
field book systems were initially designed for topographic surveying so it is necessary
to analyse these systems to ensure that they are compatible with the requirements of
cadastral surveying.
It is the programme’s flexibility that limits or enables a data recorder’s use within the
cadastral surveying system. Some data recording systems include the ability for users
to develop their own programmes, but if this is not an option then the existing
programmes must be able to suit the user’s purpose. The more modern field book
Page 26 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
programmes include improvements in their flexibility especially with regard to
traversing options.
Manufacturers of measuring equipment are investing considerable efforts in improving equipment, with new models being built around convenience of use and automated recording of observations.
Each instrument manufacturer has their own proprietary system with their own
applications and data structures. Data flow is one of the most crucial aspects of
electronic data collection. The data flow within a proprietary system is designed to
facilitate the use of equipment manufactured or recommended by the specific
manufacturer. The data flow is therefore not only dependent upon whether the system
can facilitate the movement of the specific data required but also whether the
upstream and downstream equipment is compatible with the data recorder and its data
structures.
1.3 Computers
The growth in computer technology has made the standard desktop computer capable
of running most of the applications relevant to cadastral surveying. Desktop
applications are available for calculating and adjusting data, CAD systems, and
Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and data base environments.
Field computing technology has developed significantly in recent years including the
field data recorders, hand held calculators, palmtop and laptop computers. These
developments have allowed for the increase in field applications being developed.
The recent development of more robust field computers and wearable computers will
bring even more desktop solutions to the field.
Page 27 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
2 Software
The increase in sophisticated hardware has promoted the development and
improvement of software applications. Areas of improvement in software
applications that are relevant to cadastral surveying include field surveying
applications, CAD systems and GIS and data base technology. Modern cadastral
software is more flexible and includes improvements in each element of the cadastral
system and the data communication between these elements.
2.1 Field Surveying Applications
Software development within field surveying applications has been left mainly to the
instrument manufacturers. Major developments within one manufacturer’s software
are generally independent of developments by other manufacturers. Each instrument
manufacturer has their strengths and weaknesses but progress is being made towards
more flexible software.
The improvement in the traversing software within electronic field books is making
the application of these programmes to cadastral surveying easier. There are about as
many methods of cadastral traversing as there are cadastral surveyors so it is unlikely
that the traversing programmes within each different system will suit all surveyors.
The additional flexibility of the modern applications allows surveyors to
electronically record their surveys by modifying their field methods without
necessarily affecting the standards of the survey.
Manufacturers are offering the ability to adjust traverses and reduce the fieldwork
either in the field through the electronic data recorder or post-processing in
compatible office systems. The ability to sort and adjust the traverse information and
reduce the remainder of the survey information with minimal input from the system
operator is a major improvement in the software. The ability to transform data from
one coordinate system to the other also has applications in a preliminary field
reinstatement.
Page 28 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
There are no standards for the electronic transfer of field data within the cadastral
surveying system. This lack of standards has allowed the different instrument
manufacturers to operate independently without giving adequate thought to data
integration. There is however systems available that provide for the handling of
“mixed field observations”.
The new solution for processing field-surveyed data is independent of the routine procedures and customs of the surveyors and is fairly transparent to the user. The process efficiently handles raw field surveying data collected by different collectors and no known order of measuring steps. The system enables fully automated transfer of field measurements into defined spatial databases.
Systems such as those developed for use in topographic surveying can be applied to
the collection of cadastral field information.
2.2 CAD Systems
CAD systems have developed from initial drafting and design packages to
sophisticated, often modular systems that handle a number of different functions. The
modular type systems allow surveyors to purchase only the functions that are relevant
to the objectives they want to achieve. Surveyors not only use the CAD system to
prepare their plans but also commonly to download and translate data from the field
surveying system into an appropriate format for further work, carry out coordinate
geometry calculations, input information directly from paper based plans, store
information as a form of spatial data base and transform information into different
formats for digital transfer to other users.
The value of a CAD system depends on it being able to perform all the required
functions in an efficient and user-friendly manner.
Page 29 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
2.3 GIS and Data Base Systems
GIS and database systems are now readily available to prospective users within the
private cadastral surveying organisations.
With the advent of powerful desktop PCs, GIS applications have migrated to the same desktop environment as the rest of their enterprise counterparts. Relational database technology has been enhanced to include spatial data types and operators. And, at the same time, the information technology world has moved to standardised product development environments and graphical user interface that provide performance and versatility once only available to GIS developers using proprietary tools.
The cadastral surveying system has been a provider of information to geographic
information systems and other data base technology rather than a user of the systems
themselves. Traditionally databases within the cadastral surveying system have been
either paper based or CAD systems. Data base systems add additional functionality
particularly with respect to the amount of attribute information that can be stored with
the basic spatial data.
3 Methods
The increased use of modern technology within the surveying industry does not only
effect the way we carry out our tasks, but also what tasks are required to be
undertaken. The surveyor will be required to maintain standards while at the same
time take a flexible approach to what can be achieved with the use of modern
technology.
3.1 Field Surveying Methods
Modern total stations include improved sophistication in the surveying software,
allowing alternative methods of traversing and also improved accuracy achievable in
the reading of horizontal and vertical angles and distances. Each instrument
manufacturer has different data formats and a variety of conditions that are required to
Page 30 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
be fulfilled while traversing. It is important to be aware of the limitations of the
software that is being used and the capabilities of other software types.
Traditional surveying techniques using manual recording methods provide the
surveyor with a very flexible system of recording observations where the surveyor can
choose the system of traversing using either angle reading or directions, record the
readings in any order and take as many observations as required. The early total
station software provided the surveyor with a very limited range of reading and
recording methods. Modern traversing software allows surveyors to automatically
record and reduce traverses using either one face or two face readings with backsights
and multiple foresights. Modern total stations have much more flexibility but it is still
the available software that determines the methods that can be used. Surveyors are
required to adjust their methods to suit the available software while still maintaining
the required standards.
Surveyors have the option of using either one face or two face angle reading system.
In the past, surveyors have been restricted to using two face observations to improve
the accuracy of angle readings, but mainly to record a redundant reading to guard
against transcription errors. Modern total stations, particularly those with dual axis
compensation are capable of meeting cadastral traversing standards with single face
observations and automatic recording of electronic data is carried out without any
transcription necessary thus reducing the need for two face observations. It can be
argued that closed traverses with single face readings provide enough redundant
information to validate the traverse. Pointing error is one possible significant error
that can be reduced by taking multiple observations.
It is the individual surveyor's decision to select a field surveying method that suits the
instrument being used and is capable of meeting cadastral standards without
introducing significant sources of error.
Page 31 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
3.2 Data Structure and Coding
Automated and digital surveying systems rely on the unique identification of objects
within the system to ensure that as data is passed from one element of the system to
the next there is no loss of integrity in the data structure.
The weakest link in many automatic-surveying systems is the structure that supports the data flow throughout the system. As the field coding system is a major component of that structure, the efficiency of a system depends to a large extent on coding system used.
The collection, storage and exchange of digital data within cadastral systems requires
standard elements including a standard file structure, field coding system and a field
note format that is capable of being interpreted by other surveyors.
3.2.1 Data Structure
The flow of data through the system is a critical aspect of the system. Without the
efficient communication of data from one element of the system to the next the
system becomes less efficient. A well-organized data structure is essential for
sustaining efficient communication within the system and also satisfying external
communication with a wide variety of software and hardware.
Communication between different levels of the digital reinstatement system and
between different instrument types relies on each element of the system being able to
interpret the data structure presented by the previous instrument or level. The data
structure is often dependent on the instrument used to create the data and the
functionality required for processing the data. If the format of the data produced at
each step in the process does not suit the format required at the following step, a
process of converting or translating the data to the new structure is required.
Page 32 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
Most direct data translators are fairly simple programmes that rely on having
sufficient information about the formats of the source file and the destination file.
This method of direct data translation breaks down when there is a large number of
source files and destination files requiring translation. A translator is required for
each destination file from the source files, and similarly for reverse data
communication a different translator is required for each source file from the
destination file.
A more efficient system of file converters is available to convert the system data into
an appropriate format for use when required. Koo and Lim recommended a neutral
file format when discussing data collector translators. This system reduces the
number of direct translations required by introducing a new standard neutral file
format that acts as a focus into which all existing formats can be translated. The use of
a neutral file format can reduce the number of direct translators required from 50 to
10 when considering reversible transformations from five data recorders to five
software packages.
The application of neutral file formats or standard formats on an industry wide basis
will provide significant efficiencies. Significant headway has been made in applying
neutral file formats to CAD and GIS databases, but no similar interest has been
expressed for data collectors. With the lack of interest shown on an industry wide
basis it is possible to apply this concept at the system level by using a standard format
within the system thus reducing the number of translations required particularly when
communicating with outside devices.
When an application requires multiple formats within the system it makes sense to
convert all the input files into a neutral format as soon as possible. The new
application is then able to operate on the one standard format within each level of the
system and when required to export the data can then apply direct translations back
Page 33 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
into the required format. This system does not have the universal application of an
industry wide standard but can be applied in this lesser degree without waiting for
industry standards to be developed and implemented.
There are a number of standard formats that have application to Queensland cadastral
data collection and exchange systems that provide standard formats and in some cases
also provide many of the required direct transformation software. Most CAD systems
provide a pseudo neutral file format in that the CAD programme will accept many
field data recorder formats by transforming the raw data files into a standard format
before processing the data into the CAD format. An example of this is the Civilcad
programme that converts raw data files into a format called the “neutral file format”.
There are alternatives to relying on the CAD systems that from time to time require
considerable user intervention in the combination of files, checking and filtering
redundant information from the field data and processing adjustments and reductions,
particularly when those files are not of the same raw data format. Gelbman and
Doytsher describe a system of combining, filtering and reducing the raw field
surveying data into a format suitable for spatial databases. This system takes
advantage of the neutral file format by transforming data into a standard format at the
earliest possible opportunity. The system processes data into the one job from any
number of data recording devices taken in no particular order of measurement and
with any number of files.
3.2.2 Coding of Survey Data
The coding of survey data is the shorthand method used for field surveyors to transfer
descriptions of the survey and points located during the survey to the software that
interprets the field information and produces the model of the survey or other file
formats required for further processing.
Page 34 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
The standard field coding system described by Dowling and McDougall incorporates
three types of codes: the operational codes; point type codes; and feature codes.
Point Type codes: These describe the following characteristics of a point: whether it is contourable, whether it is on a string, whether it is a graphic line feature, or whether it is a break line.
Operational codes: These codes are used to record the following types of information: administrative data, start of survey data; survey datum type; type of survey data; station set up data; measurement correction data; string data; line geometry data; point attribute data; survey quality data, and miscellaneous data.
Feature codes: these codes are used to record information about the following features: general descriptions, boundaries, fences, survey marks, harbour facilities, roads, buildings, structures, utilities, mining installations, vegetation and tree species.
This type of coding combined with standard feature code libraries is typical of the
coding systems available to the cadastral surveyor. The coding systems were initially
intended for the recording of general survey data but can be applied to the specific
needs of the cadastral survey.
Coding and descriptions of survey data is easier to apply on the desktop size
keyboards then in field instruments therefore the amount of coding required in the
field should be reduced to a minimum. The majority of information gathered in a
cadastral survey is the re-measuring of existing points that can be coded before the
field survey. Any additional marks placed or information gathered would need to be
coded in the field along with re-coding of existing points that cannot be uniquely
related to previously coded information.
There is no standard field coding system available for cadastral surveys within
Queensland although there are a number of different coding systems available for use.
The Australian Standard for the Interchange of Spatial Data is not considered to be
suitable for field coding of survey data as it does not provide the level of detail
required.
Page 35 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
3.3 Digital Lodgement of Survey Data
Registering authorities in Queensland do not require digital lodgement of cadastral
survey data but this is expected to change. Public agencies mainly have undertaken
research into the development of digital lodgement processes including:
In Queensland, there have been a number of initiatives commenced towards the development of digital processes for dealing with cadastral and as constructed survey data including:
1 research being undertaken within the Department of Natural Resources and Mines
2 commencement of a collaborative public and private agency research project with funding under the National Procurement Development Programme (NPDP) Project entitled the Electronic Survey Plan Lodgement and Registration Research Project
3 the development by officers of the now defunct Albert Shire Council of the Standard Electronic Format for As Constructed Data utilising a .DXF exchange format
4 the establishment of the Information Collection and Data Interchange Standardisation Group (ICDISG).
Initiatives commenced or undertaken in other Australian jurisdictions include:
1 the creation of the cadastral data base in NSW utilising the Neutral Cadastral File Format
2 the establishment of an infrastructure to facilitate the lodgement of cadastral survey data in the Northern Territory
3 a system for the lodgement of cadastral plans in Western Australia utilising the Cadastral Survey Data (CSD) digital data format
4 the adoption of the Spatial Data Transfers Standard (SDTS) as an Australasian Standard on 5th January 1995 as AS/NZ 4270 for the distribution of spatial data primarily from one agency to another.
Page 36 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
The exchange of cadastral data has mainly been in the form of proprietary software
and ASCII format such as .DXF. The .DXF has been the defacto local government
standard for the exchange of digital data. The fact that many CAD systems can
manipulate and present cadastral data in a variety of forms has led to the extensive use
of these systems for cadastral calculations and presentation. There is considerable
investment in CAD systems in terms of software and the skills developed by operators
within the surveying industry in Queensland.
Hayes has demonstrated that the information stored within CAD systems can be
processed to provide point, line and polygon data to populate a LIS/GIS. The
prototype system demonstrated that low-cost software could be used to provide digital
lodgement of cadastral data from CAD systems.
Research by the Department of Natural Resources and Mines includes the
development of processes for the electronic lodgement of survey information. The
intention is to improve the supply of digital information from surveyors to the
Department of Natural Resources and Mines and to also provide the surveyors with
digital information suitable for use in reinstatement from the Department of Natural
Resources and Mines.
4 Summary
Modern surveying technology provides many of the tools required to develop an
efficient digital reinstatement system. Although the technical environment is
dynamic, the systems already developed provide many options for surveyors who
choose to use digital methods. These options have been tried and tested in related
fields or in isolation within the cadastral reinstatement system.
Total Stations have the capacity, in conjunction with electronic field books, to accept
digital data to carry out the functions required by cadastral surveyors and to pass on
the data in a digital format to the next stage of the process. Desktop and field
Page 37 Chapter 3: Modern Surveying Technology
computers are capable of running most applications relevant to cadastral surveying.
Much of the software available for use by cadastral surveyors was designed for other
purposes. This software has the capacity to be applied directly to cadastral
reinstatement or to be applied with minimal modification.
The use of this technology relies on the cadastral organisations applying the
technology within their own organisational structures while taking into consideration
the technical issues of digital system implementation.
Page 38 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
Chapter 4
Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System
Evolution
Page 39 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
Chapter 4 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
The development of digital systems in private cadastral organisations relies on the
managers of these organisations having the motivation to make changes. Apart from
the reluctance to change existing working systems there are a number of issues that
effect the development of digital systems within private surveying organisations. It is
the responsibility of the managers of these organisations to weigh up the effects of the
development issues and instigate change when it is justified.
1 Motivation for Technical Change and Commercial Considerations
Digital systems will develop when people in authority have the motivation to proceed.
In the private sector the motivation for change is either commercial or legislative. A
higher level of authority introduces legislative change with compliance being a
condition of continuing in the commercial marketplace. Changes made for
commercial reasons rely on the perceived economic gains covering the costs of the
change by increases in efficiency or the provision of new markets to give a
competitive advantage over business rivals.
1.1 Motivation
The motivation for managers to make changes relies on a combination of the
manager’s attitudes to achievement, financial remuneration and the performance of
the organisation balanced by the desire for security both for the individual mangers
and the organisation. This leads to the suggestion that managers will make growth of
the organisation the most important objective.
Page 40 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
1.2 Commercial Considerations
When introducing digital technology, it is important that there will be future gains in
efficiency and that these gains in efficiency will provide a commercial benefit.
Commercial benefit will flow not only to the producers of surveying products but also
the consumers. The benefits of readily available and commonly used technology will
tend to produce a commercial benefit for the consumers rather than the producers and
impose a commercial disadvantage on producers not using this technology. An
important function of management is to balance the technical perspective where
technical improvement may be justified for its own sake against the marketing and
commercial perspective.
The incremental development of new technology can produce savings in the
introduction of new equipment and training and commercial advantage with timely
introduction of new methods and systems. There are savings to be made in the
development of existing hardware and software to carry out additional tasks reducing
the need for the initial capital outlays. The introduction of new methods allows
individual organisations to move ahead of their competitors, taking advantage of the
commercial benefit before this benefit is passed on to the consumer. Radical changes
to systems provide the advantage of moving ahead of competitors but these changes
also have a requirement for significant capital expenditure and training.
The introduction of new technology providing efficiencies in production is imposed
on producers either by legislation or the requirement to not be at a commercial
disadvantage. The new processes often require substantial outlays in new equipment
and training leaving poor short-term returns on the money invested.
There is really no doubt that surveying will become increasingly less viable overtime unless it can engage in some level of product innovation.
Page 41 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
Innovation in the form of the production, distribution and brokerage of information
products requires the development of digital systems and possible changes to the
structure of the cadastral surveying organisations.
Products such as technical knowledge and information are difficult to market because
they can be consumed by many users without preventing other users from consuming
them, and sellers are unable to restrict use to those people who pay for the service.
1.3 Control and Implementation
Organisations that take the lead in technology development may find the variety of
choices of alternative products are extensive and difficult to choose between. These
decisions need to be made carefully considering the current situation within the
organisation and the direction that management sees the industry taking in the future.
As the development process matures the choice of alternative products converges
from numerous options originally available to fewer working systems and remaining
options.
1.4 Legislation
The legislative authority level provides advantages in sharing resources and
developing standard systems. The advantages are passed on to the industry as a
whole, with the resultant economic gains being passed on to the client and general
public.
The exact nature, extent and timing of future legislation changes cannot be predicted
which provides a window of opportunity for private surveying organisations or groups
of organisations to establish markets or develop products in fields that may be seen as
the domain of government agencies.
Page 42 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
1.5 Education and Training
Tertiary education institutions are responsible for surveying education and the private
surveying organisations are responsible for the majority of training in the form of
workplace training. The education institutions provide a broad background in current
surveying skills and prepare the students for changes in surveying systems that may
appear in the foreseeable future. Workplace training provides surveyors with the
specific skills required to complete their daily work.
The training provided in the workplace depends on the commitment of management
to a well-trained staff. Even with commitment within a particular organisation,
training can become focused on existing internal requirements without a view to the
future. It is important to not only develop the skills of the staff but it is equally
important to be aware of the staff members existing skills.
Education and training can require considerable resources when developing new
systems. Sufficient planning by managers is required to maintain adequate training
levels in a developing environment. Single organisations may need to bring in
specialist staff or to consider sharing resources with other organisations that are
developing in similar directions.
2 Existing Organisational Structures
The Queensland cadastral surveying and mapping system’s cadastral functions can be
divided into the responsibilities of predominantly private cadastral organisations and
the state government. The state government's responsibilities include cadastral
control, records management, cadastral mapping and digital land boundary
information. The private cadastral organisations are responsible for the carrying out
of cadastral surveys.
Page 43 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
The private cadastral surveying organisations rely on the state government for supply
of the historical cadastral information in an appropriate format. Due to the
compulsory lodgements of cadastral surveys, the state government holds a complete
database of the registered survey plans that are distributed to the private cadastral
surveying organisations for a fee. The introduction of digital technology has changed
the expectations of cadastral surveyors to expect the lodgement and distribution of
cadastral information at least in part in a digital format.
The development of a digital link between private cadastral surveyors and the state
government requires the solution of a number of technical and organisational issues
particularly within the state government departments. Until this digital link is
established the development of digital systems within private cadastral organisations
will be independent of similar systems within the state government. This separation
of digital development and automated systems is not a preferred situation but will be
the case until the appropriate legislation is in place. Problems will arise when
attempts are made to amalgamate the separate automated systems and digital formats.
Under existing organisational structures the private cadastral surveyor will be required
to not only carry out cadastral surveys, but will also be required to collect, archive and
distribute the digital data in the format required for their own systems. Each surveyor
will collect data in their own operational area that will not necessarily be complete or
related to any specific quality standard. The initial specification requires this data to
be suitable for the purpose for which it will be used.
Page 44 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
3 The Structure of Private Cadastral Surveying Organisations
The private cadastral surveying organisation exists in an environment that has
changed from a relatively stable traditional environment to a modern environment of
continually changing conditions. The traditional organisational structures are not
necessarily the best structures in a modern environment to the extent that some of the
traditional structures are now ineffective, particularly with reference to the
distribution of digital information.
3.1 The Cadastral Surveying Environment
The cadastral surveying environment at any one point in time defines the entry-level
conditions that must be met before an organisation can participate at a competitive
level with those organisations already in the marketplace. These conditions include
being able to meet any legislative requirements and to have the basic technology and
training in place that allows for the efficient completion of the cadastral surveying
tasks. Once the basic entry-level requirements are met the environment is not only
effected by external conditions but also the changes in internal conditions due to
development of the internal processes.
The external conditions effecting the cadastral surveying environment include
changes in legislation, competitor’s actions, cost pressures, product compatibility,
social and political influences and future scientific and technical developments. The
internal conditions that effect the environment relate mainly to process innovation.
The environment is continuously changing and from time to time is redefined by
legislative change that often follows the environmental changes that occur as part of
the development process. Major changes in legislation redefine the entry-level
requirements that must be met.
Page 45 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
Table 4.1 Traditional Digital Flow Chart
This Table is unavailable online.
Please consult the hardcopy thesis
available at the QUT Library.
3.2 Single Cadastral Surveying Organisation
The single organisation provides an elementary structure that allows these
organisations to analyse their processes and react quickly to any perceived need to
change. The single organisation predominantly controls the internal development
process allowing changes to be made while developing at its own pace. The ability to
react to change and a willingness to make these changes defines the progressive
organisations.
Page 46 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
The reinstatement process provides a well-defined product with few opportunities for
product innovation at this level of organisation. The development from traditional
systems to digital and automated processes is the development of efficiencies in the
production of a single product or process innovation. The decision to make changes
in the process depends on the economy of the efficiencies outweighing the costs of
making the change as perceived by management.
3.3 Associations of Private Surveying Organisations
Alliances of private cadastral organisations can vary from loose agreements between
organisations operating in a particular local area to alliances instigated through
professional associations covering a large number of organisations in a much wider
geographical area. The content of agreements can vary from sharing copies of
registered cadastral plans to reduce search fees to sharing expertise, resources and
digital data for the exploitation of existing and new surveying products. The
advantages of shared resources have led to the types of agreements common with
traditional data and resource sharing.
There are obstacles to be overcome in combining independently developed systems
but these obstacles can often be outweighed by the advantages of shared resources.
The obstacles will be both organisational and technical but can be overcome by
incremental development and strategic planning. As with issues of efficiency, the
process of development will proceed if there is sufficient perceived advantage to
encourage management to make changes.
The advantage of shared resources allows for further development in process
development and also product innovation. The sharing of expertise and previous
development experience provides more information enabling groups of organisations
to make better-informed choices in strategic development. Groups of organisations
have the opportunity to develop new information products that would normally be
limited within the single organisation structure.
Page 47 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
The sharing of digital data between organisations requires the information to be
processed and placed in a format that is suitable for sharing. This information is a by-
product of the digital systems within the external cadastral process, particularly when
the information is required to the shared with other organisations. The development
of lodgement, archiving and distribution systems by private surveying organisations
will provide information in a format that can be used for number of purposes.
The development of the process of lodgement, archiving and distribution provides
experience and skills that can be useful in information brokerage. The ability to add
value to gathered information with the inclusion of cadastral surveying information is
an advantage that may not be provided by other brokers in the marketplace.
4 Summary
Private surveying organisations entering the system must attain an entry-level at
which they are capable of meeting legislative requirements and competing with
existing organisations already in the marketplace. As the system progresses, the
technical, legislative and economic conditions required to be met at this level change.
Single private surveying organisations provide the elementary structure that can best
react to changes in the environment.
Associations of private surveying organisations allow firms to share resources,
particularly expertise and digital data that can lead to additional efficiencies and the
exploitation of new surveying markets. There are resource-sharing agreements in
place for the sharing of traditional data and technical information. These
organisational structures will not have to change to include digital data and innovative
technology exchange. The change to include digital data exchange will occur when
the organisations decide the advantages of the shared data out-weighs the advantages
of maintaining the ownership of digital data in-house.
Page 48 Organisational Issues Effecting Digital System Evolution
The capacity to exploit digital data markets may be limited by the perception of what
the government agencies will provide when there is a requirement to lodge digital
data. The exact nature, extent and timing of future legislation changes cannot be
predicted. This provides a window of opportunity for private surveying organisations
or groups of organisations to establish markets or develop products in fields that may
be seen as the domain of government agencies.
Page 49 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
Chapter 5
Technical Issues Effecting Digital System
Evolution
Page 50 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
Chapter 5 Technical Issues Effecting Digital
Systems Evolution
Solutions to a number of technical issues are required for progression from traditional
to digital reinstatement systems. The relevant technical issues are identified within
the context of the traditional system. Alternative solutions for the development of
digital systems are considered, including commercially available solutions, while also
identifying the merits of the different options available.
1 Historical Data
Historical data is information that can be gathered and used by the surveyor for the
production of cadastral information.
The major source of spatial data used for the reinstatement of cadastral boundaries in
Queensland is the Department of Natural Resources and Mines. This data is held in
the form of registered survey plans, identification surveys and title documents and can
be described as legal cadastral information. Other information such as Computer
Aided Design and Drafting (CAD) files of cadastral boundaries; subdivision designs
and “As Constructed” plans do not have the same legal standing as information
lodged with the Department of Natural Resources and Mines. This information is
therefore secondary cadastral information that needs to be confirmed at some stage by
comparison with the legal cadastral information. Traditionally legal cadastral
information is stored in the written format and this provides the only method of
transferring legal cadastral information from one surveyor to another, normally via the
Department of Natural Resources and Mines.
Page 51 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
Modern technology has allowed for spatial data to be stored not only in the paper
format but also as digital data that can be displayed as spatial images in computer
applications. Applications that are used for the storage and manipulation of digital
spatial data include CAD packages and GIS.
The source information format and the format best suited for the proposed use needs
to be considered when determining the appropriate applications to be used for the
manipulation of historical data. The primary information source for cadastral
surveyors is paper based plans with some data, normally available from inside the
organisation involved, in a CAD format. There is no digital data available from the
Department of Natural Resources and Mines that is suitable for use in cadastral
reinstatement. The proposed uses of historical data within the system includes its use
as a source of information for searching for the cadastral marks in the field and its use
as a source of information of reinstatement data.
The Licensed Surveyor is responsible for the correctness and completeness of
information on the face of registered plans. This is even more critical than before as
the Department of Natural Resources and Mines are not regularly examining the
reinstatement of surveys. It is possible for Licensed Surveyors to certify data in a
digital format that may not be “legal data” but still carries the same weight as the
Licensed Surveyors certification.
2 Field Data Collection
The traditional method for field data collection is to use paper based systems backed
up with electronic calculators to assist in the calculations required. Cadastral
surveyors still commonly use this system. Surveyors have made some improvements
Page 52 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
to the systems due to the available technology but this is often in a piecemeal fashion
without improvements to the system as a whole.
The technologies available to surveyors today that offer possible improvements to the
system include total station theodolites, electronic field books, database systems,
computers and software programmes.
The field surveying system is a combination of the use of historical data to locate the
survey marks in the field, the collection of field information and the adjustment and
reduction of the field information. Each of these elements can be upgraded separately
to digital systems but this will not necessarily improve the system as a whole. It is the
communication between the elements of the system that is required to be in place to
provide an integrated system.
Much of the technologies used for field data collection depend on proprietary systems
that are normally designed to be compatible with their own choice of software and
hardware. It is often the case that once a specific surveying total station is being used
then it is necessary to select electronic field books and CAD systems that are
compatible. The integration of the system is then normally dependent on the system
provided by the manufacturer. The combination of different equipment in the one
system often causes compatibility problems.
2.1 Location of Field Marks
To assist in the location of existing survey marks in the field the electronic field book
can be uploaded with coordinates from a compatible database that the electronic field
book’s programmed functions can interrogate and provide information to the surveyor
in the field. This process can provide new efficiencies on a stand-alone basis and is
already commonly being used by cadastral surveyors.
Page 53 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
The minimum requirements for the field mark searching process need data to be input
into a CAD system from registered survey plans, a sketch plot to be produced
showing cadastral structure and coded point descriptions. The digital data should also
be able to be exported to the electronic field book and the field book should be
capable of allowing the operator to edit the data in the field. The field operator should
also be able to carry out the basic calculations required such as resection, bearing and
distance calculations and traversing calculations.
The CAD system should be capable of importing and exporting data electronically
from a variety of other systems and should have an efficient user interface when data
is required to be input manually. The user interface is particularly important as it has
often semiskilled or unskilled personnel required to manually enter this data. The
ability to be able to edit and adjust traverse data prior to entry into the CAD
coordinates system is a particularly useful function.
Most electronic field books are capable of carrying out the standard calculations
required in the field. The programming functions of the electronic field book can
often affect the field system used by the surveyor. The calculation and field search
programmes should also be compatible with the traversing programmes as these
functions are often carried out in parallel. The field search function can be enhanced
with the use of coordinate system transformations and preliminary reinstatement
calculations.
The digital tools available to assist in the location of existing field information
include: a CAD system used to convert historical data to a digital format; the field
recording device into which the data can be transferred; software solutions capable of
carrying out the basic calculations required; and a total station theodolite. These tools
must be considered separately before the problems of integration are faced.
Page 54 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
CAD systems vary from the very simple systems often designed for a specific purpose
to general-purpose systems that are capable of handling most tasks. The selection of a
CAD system is often an economic decision balancing cost against the tasks that are
required from the system. For this purpose the CAD system is required to import data
from other CAD systems, plot sketch plans, have an efficient method of inputting
existing data from cadastral plans and be able to transmit data in the required format
to the available field-recording device.
The field recording device can vary from elementary data cards capable of holding
simple coordinate files to sophisticated electronic field books that include multiple
data input formats and data processing functions. The field-recording device must be
able to interact with the available programmes in the field to present information as
required. The basic calculation functions required include a resection programme
bearing and distance calculations to the next point and traverse calculations. This part
of the operation can initially be considered as an independent function where the
location of field mark operations are required to be independent of the data gathering
functions in the field. More sophisticated digital systems will require these files to
interact. For example the input data file can be transformed to be consistent with the
field traversing information allowing preliminary reinstatement and corner pegging.
Preliminary reinstatement in the field or real-time reinstatement can only be a
preliminary function that needs to be repeated once the field survey is completed.
The preliminary information obtained by these types of programmes is useful for
more precise information on the location of existing survey marks and for preliminary
pegging of some lot corners. It should be noted that the reinstated corner’s location
often depends on information that is obtained at a later stage of the survey and that the
final reinstatement is dependent on the adjusted traverse information that often cannot
be obtained until after the traverse has been completed.
Page 55 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
2.2 The Collection of Field Information
Field survey recording is commonly carried out in traditional field books, using the
traditional methods in preference to electronic data recording. The traditional
methods have the advantage of recording the data in a standard format where the data
is easily accessible at all times during the survey. The standard format is familiar to
all surveyors and is readily accepted by registering authorities when field notes are
lodged.
The use of electronic recording of survey data will not necessarily make the process
more efficient, or easier without the development of other procedures that take
advantage of the digital data. The electronic recording of field data compared to hand
booking tends to make data less accessible, coding more difficult and field sketches
unlikely in the electronic format. There is no standard format for electronic data
recording, which causes problems when separating data types and combining
information from different sources and when field notes are required to be lodged
with government authorities.
The end result of the field surveying process includes the record of the relative
location of all the cadastral points relevant to the survey, so the field survey
component can be said to include not only the recording of the information in the field
but also the traverse adjustment and reduction of field data to obtain the final relative
location of the cadastral points. The traditional process that is commonly used
transfers data from a written format where calculations are carried out to adjust and
reduce the data, normally in a digital format, and then record it in a written format that
can be later entered back into a digital format for the reinstatement stage of the
process often done within a CAD system.
Field information required to be collected is normally in the format of traverse with
radiations to points of interest. This format is similar to the format used to collect
topographic information with the notable exceptions of the accuracy and the quantity
Page 56 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
of data required. Most of the standard field book programmes were designed for the
recording of topographic information.
The method of collection of field information is dependent on the software available
and the method used in the field. There is often very little choice in the software once
an instrument configuration has been chosen so it is therefore very important to
ensure that the equipment being used has the capability to carry out the functions
required. The surveyor has a choice of using a number of different methods in
carrying out the field survey so it is often possible to adapt the methods used to the
instrument and software available. It is important not to sacrifice the standards of the
survey in an attempt to use hardware and software that is not up to the task.
The cadastral survey is required to meet certain accuracy standards, use measuring
systems that are consistent with the Surveyors Regulation 1992 and standard practices
and to record the field survey in field notes that meet the regulations. The use of total
station systems for the electronic field recording and calculations can reduce the
amount of field checks required and reduce the time spent in the field by up to 50%.
2.3 The Electronic Field Book
The electronic field book consists of a data-recording device and programming
functions. The data-recording device needs to record sufficient information in the
format required. It is the flexibility of the programming that determines whether an
electronic field book is suitable for a particular purpose. The physical structure of the
system is of less importance then the functionality.
When selecting an electronic field book, it is essential to analyse the system to ensure
that the required functions are achievable and the digital data can be exploited to its
best effect. The efficient processing of digital data requires data to be entered at the
Page 57 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
earliest possible opportunity and be maintained in a digital format throughout the
process. As an example, when considering the field recording of cadastral traverses
the raw field data must be able to be transformed into an appropriate format for field
notes. The traverses and radiation information should be able to be adjusted and
reduced with minimum additional input from the user. The final results should be
able to be automatically transformed into a format suitable for the CAD or data base
format that will be used in the next stage of cadastral reinstatement.
Survey data taken directly from observations on the total station, with the inclusion of
field codes input in the field, can be efficiently recorded electronically. This is the
traverse, radiation and point identification data that records the position of the
identified points. This information is very similar to information recorded in standard
topographic surveys for which much of the surveying software and hardware is
designed.
The structure of the electronic field book can consist of an independent device, be
incorporated into the total station theodolite or a combination of both. Independent
devices such as the Sokkia SDR 33 (Sokkia data recorder, model number SDR 33)
contain both the data recording and programming functions of the data recorder. This
type of data recorder can be used in conjunction with a number of different total
stations from different manufacturers. It is more common among instrument
manufacturers to use data recording devices built into the total station or simple data
recording cards with the programming functions being maintained within the total
station.
The functions of the electronic field book include: the storage of data uploaded from
existing information; storage of raw data gathered in the field; and the data processing
ability to manipulate this data in the manner required. As the electronic field book
systems were initially designed for topographic surveying, it is necessary to analyse
the systems to ensure that they are compatible with the requirements of cadastral
surveying.
Page 58 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
It is the programme’s flexibility that limits or enables a data recorder’s use within the
cadastral surveying system. Some data recording systems include the ability for users
to develop their own programmes, but if this is not an option, then the existing
programmes must be able to suit the user’s purpose.
Each instrument manufacturer has their own proprietary system with their own
systems and data structures.
2.4 Field Note Format
Surveyors are required to lodge field notes with registering authorities and are also
required to keep any survey records that are not lodged. The survey records lodged
with the registering authority are required to “be in a form suitable as a record of the
cadastral survey”. The Department of Natural Resources and Mines requires field
notes to be lodged with the survey plan to supplement information on the lodged plan.
This is necessary in cases of ambulatory boundaries, encroachments and when
additional explanation is necessary.
The registering authorities monitor the format of lodged field notes by a process of
accepting or rejecting the documents submitted. The traditional format of notes
drawn in pencil on A5 sheets of high-grade paper are still acceptable and form a basis
from which any variations can be compared. The registering authorities will accept
documents that can be readily archived within their existing systems and will not
deteriorate or be unable to be interpreted over a long archival period. Printouts of
electronic files are acceptable whereas disks holding the electronic file itself would
not be acceptable.
Page 59 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
The Licensed Surveyor is responsible for the format of field records that are kept.
The registering authorities do not normally examine these documents and therefore do
not provide a standard format. The format of these records is more flexible than that
of the lodged records as the surveyor has a number of choices in the system of
archiving. These records may be required to be used as evidence in court proceedings
at any time in the future so the surveyor has similar responsibilities as the registering
authorities in assuring that the archived information is long lasting and retrievable.
The majority of field notes and field records are not lodged with registering
authorities so it can be seen that the emphasis for the format of field notes has shifted
from the registering authorities to the surveyors themselves. The advantage of having
a central authority setting a standard format for field notes is that all surveyors are
aware of what that standard is, the standard can be monitored by examination and the
standard can be taught by the education institutions. As there is no definitive standard
or checking process it is possible, even likely, that each surveyor will develop their
own interpretation of what is acceptable as far as the format and content of the field
records are concerned.
Surveyors should maintain the field records in such a manner that they are complete,
readily understandable by other surveyors and able to be archived for long periods.
These conditions apply whether the field notes are in the traditional format, an
electronically recorded format or a combination of the both. Information recorded
electronically would normally be required to be printed from the digital files and
paper copies kept for archiving purposes. The printed digital information forms only
part of the survey field notes and as such does not have to fully describe the survey.
The complete survey records may also contain additional printed digital information
or traditional style handwritten notes.
Page 60 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
The printed digital information is required to be understandable by other surveyors
therefore consideration needs to be given to the format of the digital information that
is to be printed. The raw data files from some particular instruments may not be able
to be easily understood by a surveyor not familiar with that particular brand of
instrument. If this is the case, then the raw data file will need to be translated into a
generic format that can readily interpreted by other surveyors.
2.5 Traverse Adjustments and Reductions
The adjustment and reduction of field observations is an integral part of the field
surveying process. The majority of these calculations can be completed in the office
on the desktop computer system but it is sometimes essential to have the capability to
at least calculate the traverse misclose in the field. This misclose could be calculated
using an electronic calculator programme by reviewing the field data and re-entering
this information into the calculator but it is more efficient to use electronic field books
with the capacity to calculate this information directly from the recorded data.
When using electronic field recording devices it is first necessary to sort the traverse
information from the radiations. This process can be time consuming if the software
is not configured to carry out this task automatically or if data is obtained from
different instrument types in the one project. Savings of more than 40% in the data
processing time have been reported when comparing automated procedures to
traditional methods.
Page 61 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
2.6 Preliminary Field Reinstatement
The reinstatement of cadastral boundaries carried out in the field as the survey
progresses can be considered to be only a preliminary field reinstatement. Except in
only the simplest cases, the reinstated position of a boundary point will depend on
information that is gathered once the survey moves on from the boundary point of
interest. The final reinstatement can normally not be undertaken until the traverse is
completed and the appropriate adjustments and reductions are finalised. It is
important not to confuse the final reinstatement when carried out in the field at the
completion of the field survey with the preliminary field reinstatement carried out as
the survey progresses.
The purpose of a preliminary field reinstatement is normally to assist in the location
of existing field marks, analyse encroachments and place marks as the survey
progresses. The importance of these types of functions often depends on the size of
the survey and the time expected to complete it. The preliminary reinstatement may
reduce the need to occupy all the stations a second time for pegging purposes.
Electronic field books with the capability to calculate traverse adjustments and also to
transform coordinates from one system to another are useful for field reinstatement.
The ability for the user to develop a traversing and reinstatement programme within
the field book environment adds another dimension to the flexibility of the system.
2.7 Pegging Lot Boundaries
The pegging of lot boundaries is a similar process to the set out of any other structure
or set out point. The electronic field book will be required to upload the design
information, have an efficient onboard set out programme and to record the results of
the set out for confirmation purposes.
Page 62 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
3 Reinstatement Calculations
Reinstated cadastral boundaries are determined by applying the hierarchy of
reinstatement evidence to the historical data and field data. The rules of reinstatement
are subjective in nature and require the expertise of an experienced Licensed Surveyor
to determine the correct application of the rules. The historical data supplies the
boundary structure, the position of recorded survey marks relative to the known
boundaries and descriptive codes for the marks included in the database. The field
data supplies the spatial relationship between recorded survey marks, occupation and
any other facts relevant to the survey, as they exist at the time of survey.
The reinstatement rules are guidelines only and require subjective decisions to be
made by the Licensed Surveyor. Reinstatement calculation programmes will require
some option for user interaction allowing the Licensed Surveyor to make the
appropriate professional judgments and record this information as additional input to
the calculation programme. The calculation process can therefore not be fully
automated.
The reinstatement calculation process requires the system to be able to import the
historical survey data and the reduced field data. The calculation process will include
interaction with the Licensed Surveyor and the combination of information from both
the imported files. The process output requires information to be exported to CAD
systems for the preparation of the survey report. Additional digital data may be
required to be exported to internal or external systems at some time in the future.
The traditional system of reinstating cadastral boundaries requires the surveyor to
calculate the bearings and distances between the marks as they exist in the field and
compare these to those calculated from the original survey plans. This process
requires a large number of calculations often requiring the same information to be
input into the calculator more than once as different combinations of attempts are
tried and compared to determine the final solution. The uses of CAD systems with
Page 63 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
their coordinate geometry and database functions have helped streamline the
traditional approach. The CAD-based reinstatement system is still the traditional
approach, with the advantage of using the improved calculating power of the modern
CAD programmes.
3.1 The Reinstatement Calculation Process
The reinstatement calculations are carried out a number of times during the
reinstatement process. These times include:
1 Initial Reinstatement - the analysis of historical data
2 Field Reinstatement - determination of the facts on the ground as the survey
progresses
3 Final Reinstatement - determination of boundaries considering all the relevant
facts
The emphasis on each reinstatement depends on the level of development of the
reinstatement system. The traditional reinstatement methods rely completely on the
final reinstatement for the determination of the reinstated cadastral boundaries. The
final analysis in these cases relies on all the relevant information being available
before the calculations can be carried out.
In a legal coordinated cadastre the boundaries are known before the commencement
of the survey and are therefore determined at the initial reinstatement stage. The field
and final reinstatements are used for checking and confirmation of the initial
reinstatement. The development of reinstatement systems are moving from the
traditional methods to a coordinated approach with automated systems developing
within the transitional period.
Page 64 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
3.1.1 Traditional Reinstatement
The traditional reinstatement systems use the initial reinstatement as an initial analysis
tool where the surveyor gathers the information required for the next step in the field.
The surveyor gets a feel for the history of the job while placing the data in an
appropriate format for the next step. The main purpose of the initial reinstatement is
to allow the surveyor to go into the field with enough information at an appropriate
accuracy to locate existing survey marks. It is essential that the information provided
by the initial reinstatement be organised in an easily accessible format and that the
information is complete.
The field survey provides the surveyor with the facts, as they exist at the time of the
survey. The information from the field survey includes:
1 Checking the positional accuracy and relevance of historical data.
2 Locating and describing any other relevant information.
3 Field analysis to ensure the data is correct and accurate.
It is the field survey that defines the spatial relationship of the data, as it exists at the
time of the survey. The field survey also completes the record of all the relevant
cadastral information.
The final reinstatement is a combination of the facts established in the field survey
with historical information provided from initial search information. The initial
search information provides the structure of the boundaries and a record of the type
and location of original survey marks placed in relationship to the boundaries. The
Page 65 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
field survey provides the actual relative locations of all marks significant to the survey
including historical marks and occupation.
The traditional reinstatement method is an iterative process that analyses the facts on
the ground with the historical information allowing the surveyor to make a subjective
decision as to the location of the boundaries. Under current legislation the final
reinstatement can only be completed once all the relevant evidence has been
considered. This includes information from the completed field survey, including the
adjusted traverse information that is often not available until after the final traverse
station has been occupied. Any reinstatement carried out before this point can only be
considered to be preliminary information.
3.1.2 Reinstatement Based on Legal Coordinates
It should be stressed that Queensland has not moved to a legal coordinated cadastre.
The nature and extent of any future legislation cannot be accurately determined. A
Queensland Department of Natural Resources and Mines discussion paper about an
enhanced survey observation management environment for Queensland includes
reference to a previous paper in which it was stated that until previous levels of
maturity were addressed it is inappropriate to consider, in any detail, any issues
associated with the legal cadastre. The time frame for any changes are uncertain and
could take several years to consider.
In a system of legal coordinates proposed by some surveyors, coordinates sit at the
top of the hierarchy of evidence above evidence of original intention in a legal
coordinated cadastre. With this form of reinstatement the emphasis is reversed from
the traditional system so that the main emphasis is on the initial reinstatement and
field reinstatement rather than the final analysis.
Page 66 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
The initial reinstatement or analysis of historical data is reduced to the function of
obtaining the legal cadastral coordinates for the property corners and the reference
system marks. This information fully defines the legal position of the cadastral
boundaries.
The minimum field reinstatement will require the surveyor to establish the data by
reference to the defined reference system marks and then to mark the location of
property corners in the supplied coordinated position. Any additional work required
would be a function of the amount of quality assurance or checking required in the
specific legislation. Any final reinstatement required again will also be a function of
the amount of quality assurance or checking required under the specific legislation.
3.2 Current Systems
The current cadastral reinstatement systems are a combination of the traditional
system incorporating some digital methods. These digital methods include the use of
CAD systems in the analysis of historical data and electronic field books for the
location of existing survey marks in the field. CAD is often used for the reduction
and analysis of the field information, reinstatement calculations and presentation of
the survey information.
The information collected in the CAD system and used for the location of historical
data is not used extensively in further stages of the reinstatement process. The field
data is normally recorded in field books with the traverse information reduced in
handheld calculators or on in-house computer programmes. The field information is
recorded into the field books, entered into calculators for field calculations, and again
into calculations systems for the traverse reduction and finally entered back into the
CAD package for further processing. The entering and re-entering of data from the
written format to the digital format is only sustainable because of the relatively small
amounts of data involved.
Page 67 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
3.3 Advanced Surveying Systems
Advanced reinstatement systems introduce the concept of continuous digital data flow
and integration of multiple equipment configurations. The aim is to develop a system
that enters digital information at the earliest possible opportunity without the need to
re-enter data and that can communicate digitally with equipment using a number of
different data structures.
These systems can still operate in a CAD based environment but require additional
software and methods for the integration of existing systems into advanced systems
containing standard or neutral file formats. Additional software is also required when
specific information is required to be extracted from CAD files to be integrated with
other CAD files at later stages in the process.
3.4 Automated Calculations Systems
Total automation of reinstatement calculation systems is not possible under current
legislation due to the subjective nature of the rules of reinstatement. Some suggested
legislative changes to the rules of reinstatement might allow for the introduction of
fully automated systems but changes to legislation are uncertain in content and
timing. Legislative reform is dependent on government innovation whereas the
development of automated systems within the existing legislative environment
depends on innovation in private cadastral surveying organisations.
Innovative reinstatement systems require automated processes to be linked with an
efficient system of interaction with the Licensed Surveyor. This interaction must
provide information in the appropriate format to assist in the making of the subjective
decisions required to determine the reinstated boundaries. The system of interaction
should also provide efficient data entry and automated logging of decisions made.
The different approaches include using a system of interactive coordinate geometry
programmes or vector systems.
Page 68 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
3.4.1 Automation
The automation of cadastral reinstatement calculations is taking the calculation
process a step beyond the use of CAD and coordinate geometry calculation
programmes. These CAD and coordinate geometry calculation programmes are
calculation tools used by the surveyor to carry out calculations. An automated
reinstatement calculation programme will determine a preliminary solution based on a
simplified hierarchy of evidence. The surveyor is then in a position to interact with
this information, making changes as required in the specific circumstances to
determine the final solution.
The extent of automation and the quality of the preliminary solution depends on the
simplified hierarchy of evidence and the circumstances in which a valid solution can
be determined. In circumstances where the measured distances are equivalent to the
original distances within the specified accuracy of the survey a simple mathematical
distribution of shortage or excess may be appropriate as the final solution. The
simplified hierarchy of evidence can be expanded from initial simple mathematical
solutions to more complex algorithms that will handle a wide variety of reinstatement
problems. An example of this is the analytical approach to shortage and excess
developed by Stuart Sprott to handle a variety of different situations. The preliminary
solution can only apply in limited cases and have limited application to specific
reinstatement problems especially where gross errors exist. There will always be a
need for the judgment of a professional surveyor to examine the validity of the
preliminary solution and to determine the final reinstatement solution.
The automation process requires continuous data flow throughout the system, which
requires the amalgamation of data from different sources and often in different data
structures. Historical digital data is normally held in coordinate based systems
Page 69 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
(structural data format) and field data is collected in vector format. The condition of
continuous data flow must be maintained irrespective of the data structures used at
any stage of the process. In automated procedures, the data structure is often
transparent to the user and the choice of coordinate or vector based calculations is a
matter of personal choice for the system developer.
3.4.2 Coordinate Based Reinstatement Calculations
The Queensland Department of Natural Resources and Mines is developing a survey
accurate coordinated cadastral database. Development beyond this point to some
form of legal coordinates is uncertain and legislation to introduce legal coordinates
will not be considered until “some point well into the future”. Under the existing
legislative environment it is important to note that the coordinates do not have a
substantial legal footing so that coordinated systems can only serve as a tool used by
the surveyor to analyse the survey data within the current rules of evidence.
The automation of traditional methods of reinstatement using coordinate geometry
programmes and CAD packages requires the development of additional software to
enhance the flow of data and the analytical power of the base systems. The
reinstatement process requires the combination of information from the digital
historical data files and the results of the field survey before the analytical processes
can be considered.
The concept of least squares reinstatement developed by Stuart Sprott provides an
example of an application of automated procedures using coordinate geometry
calculation programmes on a hand-held calculator platform. The least squares
programme develops a preliminary solution based on a set of assumptions. The
Page 70 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
programme then provides for interaction with the Licensed Surveyor by providing
statistical information and the ability to refine the preliminary solution based on the
information provided and professional judgment of the surveyor.
The least squares reinstatement programme also demonstrates how the initial
assumptions could be varied incrementally with the development of more
sophisticated algorithms and methods. The initial programme was expanded to take
into consideration further automation of specific elements of the reinstatement
calculation process. The additional development expanded the number of cases and
applications where the initial solution can provide a good approximation of the final
result.
Hayes demonstrates a digital lodgement system of cadastral data collection primarily
created as a tool for the creation and maintenance of a survey accurate database that
can also be used for the reinstatement of cadastral boundaries to meet current titling
legislation. An initial “most likely” solution based on historical information is created
in a CAD format. The initial solution is then updated to a “field calibrated”
preliminary solution using software developed to operate on electronic field data
recorders. The final reinstated boundaries are determined in a CAD environment by
comparison of the most likely solution and the field calibrated solution with the
original cadastral information. The digital lodgement system demonstrates
continuous data flow in a CAD based system using specifically developed software
for the combination of the historical data and field data in the reinstatement process.
Page 71 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
3.4.3 Vector Based Reinstatement Calculations
Traditional reinstatement calculations are carried out in vector-based format with
calculations and comparisons to the original information described in terms of vector
information giving relative positions. These vectors describing relative positions are
of more consequence when determining reinstated boundaries then the absolute
position described by coordinates. Coordinate geometry is a tool used for the
determination of these vectors.
Field surveys are normally recorded in vector format totally describing the spatial
survey information. It is common to transform this information from a vector format
from the field survey to a coordinate format in CAD before reinstatement calculations
are carried out. It is possible to carry out the reinstatement calculations in a vector
style format before transforming the final data to coordinated CAD systems for plan
and data presentation.
4 Data Base Development
4.1 Queensland Department of Natural Resources and Mines Data
The Department of Natural Resources and Mines provides surveyors with survey
plans containing the spatial information and content required in the process of
reinstating cadastral boundaries. An essential element of the data required by
surveyors for reinstatement purposes are the references to the cadastral reference
marks. This information is not compiled digitally by the Department of Natural
Resources and Mines and it is not expected that it will be in the near future. Digital
Page 72 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
compilation of reference mark data may be possible under an “enhanced
environment” discussed within the Department of Natural Resources and Mines. The
existing cadastral databases tend to concentrate on the representation of property
boundaries themselves without any included data on the historical cadastral marks.
The lodgement of digital survey data in parallel with the cadastral survey plans may
provide an opportunity to include cadastral reference marks in a general database of
cadastral information. The format and timing of any such developments are uncertain
so the cadastral surveyor has an opportunity to put in place systems of their own to
provide this information.
4.2 Existing Digital Field Data
Private surveyors normally prepare their survey plans in a CAD environment.
Depending on the sophistication of the individual systems used, parts of the plans are
drawn in CAD with final details being added by hand drafting. At the completion of
the drafting the surveyor is left with a survey plan completed and ready for
registration and a digital CAD file that contains a representation of up to 90 percent of
the data from the survey plan. The data often omitted within the digital format is
normally text, tables or diagrams leaving the spatial representations of the cadastral
data complete. This digital data is then often stored away and not used to its full
potential or not used at all.
This digital data is often used within individual firms when other surveys are required
in the same area. This existing information can be merged with other digital data or
supplemented with additional information input from survey plans to become the
database for the commencement of the new survey.
Page 73 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
This extensive source of digital cadastral data has limited use due to storage within a
large number of independent surveying organisations that have not attempted to index
or use the data in the production of local area databases.
4.3 Private Data Bases
Cadastral surveyors are left with the option of providing their own digital data or
waiting for the introduction of useful state government supplied digital cadastral data.
The cadastral surveyors can obtain this data by using existing digital information or
inputting digital data by direct entry from survey plans.
The technology is available for private cadastral firms to create and maintain their
own working databases. Natural Resources and Mines have demonstrated that
databases can be set up over pilot areas using both Acres and Mimika software.
4 Summary
The Queensland Department of Natural Resources and Mines does not supply
appropriate digital data for the reinstatement of cadastral boundaries. The private
surveyors have the opportunity to use existing CAD information and future cadastral
boundary information, as it becomes available, for the production of digital databases
containing suitable information for reinstatement of cadastral boundaries. Private
digital data cannot carry the same weight as the registered cadastral information but
can carry Licensed Surveyor certification of more complete data sets.
Cadastral surveyors tend to prefer field books to record and calculate the fieldwork,
even though they may use the total station and electronic field book while in the field
to measure the traverse and hold the historical data. This can still be efficient because
Page 74 Technical Issues Effecting Digital Systems Evolution
of the small amounts of data normally involved. For the use of electronic field books
to be worthwhile the surveyor must first develop an automatic system of sorting,
reducing and adjusting the field information which can be directly uploaded to CAD
or other data base files.
Development of automated reinstatement calculation systems requires enhancement
beyond the systems commercially available and development in parallel with field
recording procedures. The development of CAD databases of historical data and
systems for the location of existing cadastral field marks can be considered separately.
Each technical issue considered on an individual basis has solutions that provide
options for continuos digital data flow and automated systems. These solutions now
need to be considered in the context of a flexible development process that leads to an
integrated digital system.
Page 75 Digital System Evolution
Chapter 6
Digital System Evolution in Private Cadastral
Surveying Organisations
Page 76 Digital System Evolution
Chapter 6 Digital System Evolution in Private
Cadastral Surveying Organisations
Technology is changing within a dynamic environment with new discoveries and
applications opening up new approaches to the solution of cadastral reinstatement
problems. Existing technology is being tested and used within other similar
environments and it is this existing technology that can be immediately applied to
enhance cadastral surveying systems. The process for the development of digital
systems is partly organisational and partly technical and the change can be managed
in either incremental or radical steps.
Within the existing technical and organisational environment the incremental
approach to digital cadastral system development process will be discussed in the
context of the individual elements of the traditional reinstatement systems. One of the
first decisions to be made when considering the introduction of digital methods is
whether to take a completely new approach or to apply digital methods to the
traditional systems. There are advantages and disadvantages to each approach,
including technical and implementation matters that will be considered. Conclusions
will be drawn in Chapter 7.
1 The Digital Cadastral System
The role of cadastral systems within private surveying organisations is to gather
information for the reinstatement of property boundaries, to reinstate the boundaries
and then to distribute the results. Digital processes incorporated within the cadastral
systems allow continuous data flow with input of data at the earliest possible
opportunity and the introduction of automated systems wherever possible.
Page 77 Digital System Evolution
1.1 Reinstatement Methods
The level of maturity of the reinstatement system is defined by where the emphasis of
the reinstatement is positioned. The traditional reinstatement systems place the
majority of emphasis on the field and final reinstatement whereas coordinate based
reinstatement places emphasis on the initial reinstatement and the field reinstatement.
1.1.1 Transitional Reinstatement Systems
The transitional period between traditional reinstatement systems and a coordinated
cadastre offers challenges where some emphasis is being placed on the coordinated
approach but the traditional rules still apply. The transitional process starts with the
use of coordinates as a tool in the traditional calculation process, with the possibility
of moving towards a survey accurate coordinated cadastre and then to some form of
legal coordinates as described earlier.
The professionalism of the cadastral surveyor is demonstrated through the ability to “discover” all the relevant evidence, to apply professional judgment to this information, and to reinstate corners in accordance with the present law of the land.
Throughout the transitional process it is important to be aware of the current laws and
regulations regardless of the tools used to obtain a solution.
The initial reinstatement process from the traditional systems can be enhanced using
digital coordinated methods. The development of coordinate based CAD technology
for the analysis of historical data can be a simple process of preparing sketches for the
field stage of reinstatement or an elaborate reinstatement process designed to prepare
a local coordinated cadastre. The level of sophistication required is a factor of not
only the current legislation but also the use to which the data will be put in subsequent
stages of the reinstatement.
Page 78 Digital System Evolution
The field reinstatement ranges from the traditional approach where completeness and
spatial accuracy are the only consideration, to the coordinated approach where the
reinstatement can be completed as the field survey progresses. The legal coordinates
approach can be completed as the survey progresses because all the information
required to fix a property corner is known when the surveyor arrives at the corner.
Under the existing rules of reinstatement, when the surveyor arrives at the property
corner that corner may not be able to be fixed because points that have not yet been
surveyed may have a bearing on the position of that corner. Unless the hierarchy of
reinstatement evidence is changed then the progressive field reinstatement can be no
more than a preliminary reinstatement used to obtain a better estimate of a boundary
corner during the process of the field survey.
The final reinstatement process has no real transitional properties. The final
reinstatement under traditional methods and current legislation cannot be determined
until all the facts from the field survey have been gathered. This will not change
unless significant changes are made to the legislation, at which time the process will
need to the reassessed. As stated earlier, if priority legal status is given to coordinates
then the reinstatement can be completed as the field survey progresses and the final
reinstatement will be a check on quality if required.
1.2 Data Structure
Cadastral data describes the spatial relationship between objects in the cadastral
system. This data can be of two main types:
1 Vector Format - objects are linked by bearing and distance to adjacent points
2 Structure Format - the spatial relationship is defined by structure using either a
4GL language or by an interactive coordinate geometry programme.
Page 79 Digital System Evolution
The vector data format is typical of the format used in the gathering of field survey
data and represents the actual measurements taken in the field. The structure format
data is typical of CAD data where the raw data is first adjusted to remove any
misclose and all dimensions are calculated from the adjusted data.
1.2.1 Existing Data Structure Applications
Different data structures tend to be better suited to and therefore more commonly used
at different stages of the cadastral system. The appropriate data format for an
integrated system requires assessment of whether it is easier to use one format
throughout or whether it is more efficient to change the data format as required.
The digital storage of historical survey data is almost exclusively structural with large
amounts of CAD data and coordinated digital cadastral databases. Both vector and
structure data will continue to exist therefore digital cadastral systems must be able to
process both forms of cadastral data.
Field survey information is typically recorded in the vector format either in traditional
field books or electronic field books. This information is often adjusted and
transferred directly into a structural coordinate for processing within the CAD system.
In the traditional reinstatement systems the data was first adjusted and maintained for
processing in the vector format.
The reinstatement calculations under current legislation is suited to the vector
approach regardless of whether the data is held in a structural CAD format or
maintained in traditional vector format. The comparison of vector data rather than the
comparison of position indicated by the coordinates are more appropriate in these
calculations when considering the hierarchy of evidence.
Page 80 Digital System Evolution
Structural data format is best suited to the presentation of survey data through the
CAD system and storage into coordinated databases.
1.2.2 Structural Data System (Coordinates)
The structural data system based around the CAD environment allows for a standard
data structure throughout. Older cadastral information that was recorded in vector
format can be adjusted on digital data entry and modern historical data is more likely
to be in a structural format. Field survey information normally collected in the vector
format is almost routinely converted to a structural format. This occurs on entry into
a CAD package either by digital conversion from electronic field books or manual
entry from traditional field books. From this point on the data can be maintained in
the structural data format.
The process of cadastral reinstatement calculations, although better suited to vector
style calculations is commonly carried out in the CAD environment.
1.2.3 Vector Data System
The vector data system is suited to the collection of field survey data and the
processing of cadastral reinstatement calculations. It will be necessary to convert the
data from one system to the other because of the almost exclusive use of structural
data systems for the storage of historical survey data and the presentation of survey
information.
The vector data gathered in the field collection process can be adjusted and
maintained in the vector format for further cadastral reinstatement processing. It
should be possible to use the same conversion programme that would normally be
used to convert the field information to CAD, to convert this data into CAD format. It
Page 81 Digital System Evolution
is more difficult to convert the data from the structure format back into the vector
format if this is required for automatically comparing historical and the field data.
1.3 Data Coding
The coding of survey data is the method used to not only transfer descriptions of field
survey points into the database but to maintain a unique description of data
throughout the cadastral process. Like all other data it is preferable to enter this
information at the first opportunity and then to maintain this data throughout the
entire system. With the coding of survey data it is easier and sometimes more
efficient to enter as much of the data as possible in the office environment because of
the small size of the field data entry units.
Cadastral data as opposed to general surveying data has a high content of historical
reference to information recorded from previous surveys. This allows the relative
position of the survey points in reference to the cadastral boundaries to be part of the
description of the point in question and can reduce the amount of coding required in
the field. As the majority of information gathered in a cadastral field survey consists
of the remeasuring of original survey points, an integrated system can be previously
coded and carried through to the field survey. This also reduces the extent of coding
necessary in the field.
The other source, apart from the field survey, of coded survey information is data held
in historical databases. The majority of this information is held on registered survey
plans in a non-digital format and is entered manually into the system during the initial
digital compilation of historical data.
Page 82 Digital System Evolution
The two main sources of digital cadastral information are the government maintained
digital cadastral database and private CAD files available from within each private
organisation. The private digital CAD databases normally hold up to 90 percent of
the information on the survey plan but this does not include the use of standard codes.
The digital cadastral database holds no reference to the reference marks that form a
large extent of the data required for cadastral surveys. It is therefore necessary to
enter codes manually into the system in most cases, with the possible exception of
using converting programmes to obtain previously coded information from within the
CAD files.
1.4 Alternative Digital Systems
A digital cadastral system can take a variety of different forms depending on
decisions taken as the system develops. These decisions include whether to adopt a
traditional reinstatement system, what data format to use and which coding method is
best.
When considering the development of a digital system, these decisions can be
considered to be part of the process, but will not necessarily be considered as separate
items. Whether the structural or vector approach is adopted, it does not change the
fact that a development process is necessary with the decision on what method to use
being left to the individual.
The reinstatement method that will be considered in the system development process
will be the traditional approach with the emphasis on the final reinstatement rather
than the preliminary historical or field reinstatements. This approach is compatible
with the existing legislative environment. The style and structure of the methods used
can vary as long as the conditions of continuous digital data flow without loss of data
are maintained.
Page 83 Digital System Evolution
Table 6.1 Cadastral Reinstatement Flow Chart
This Table is unavailable online.
Please consult the hardcopy thesis
available at the QUT Library.
2 Incremental System Development
Incremental development describes a process that may be considered as the way
progress is normally made but with an element of forward planning. Incremental
digital system development is a step-by-step process starting with the introduction of
easy to integrate digital methods followed by the more complex procedures.
Page 84 Digital System Evolution
The development process can be broken into a number of development levels
including:
1 Applying digital methods to the traditional process
2 Applying automated procedures to the reinstatement calculation process
3 Developing continuous data flow.
2.1 Applying Digital Methods to the Traditional Systems
Queensland cadastral surveyors currently use a reinstatement system where the flow
of data is controlled by traditional methods with some elements of digital technology
being used within the system. The amount of digital technology being applied
depends on the individual organisations level of commitment to digital development.
The introduction of some digital methods into the traditional system are more
effective initially than with others. Some methods require development of other
elements of the system and the digital links between them before that particular
element can be effective. Cadastral surveyors already commonly use some digital
methods that indicate that these methods can operate efficiently on a stand-alone
basis. As an example, the use of electronic field books for the location of field marks
and the pegging of lot boundaries indicate that cadastral surveyors have developed
skills in the use of this technology and that these methods can exist independently of
an integrated data structure. Although the technology for electronic field books is
commonly used within these methods the use of electronic field books for collection
of field information is not common.
Page 85 Digital System Evolution
Table 6.2 Traditional System Flow Chart
This Table is unavailable online.
Please consult the hardcopy thesis
available at the QUT Library.
The process for introducing digital methods starts with the introduction of the
methods that can operate efficiently on a stand-alone basis followed by the operations
that require some integration with other methods
2.1.1 CAD Database of Historical Data
CAD files are the digital representation of the survey plan. The traditional database
of historical data is registered survey plans that are prepared by Licensed Surveyors,
submitted to the Department of Natural Resources and Mines for registration,
archiving and distribution as required. CAD systems have been used to prepare
Page 86 Digital System Evolution
survey plans for a number of years with the CAD file containing up to 90 percent of
the information on the survey plan. These files are normally discarded or archived by
the private surveyors for future use within their own organisation.
A CAD database can be prepared at the start of each cadastral project by either
collecting existing CAD information or manually entering data from the survey plans
directly into the CAD database.
The purpose for which the data is to be used defines the content and format of the data
that is required to be compiled. As the digital system develops and the database is
used for additional applications, these requirements change and tend to become more
onerous. The initial purpose of the database may be to provide a digital file that can
be used to assist the field surveyor in the location of existing cadastral marks. For this
purpose file contents need to be to a relative accuracy standard of about 100 mm to
allow for the location of buried survey marks, to contain a point number description
of each coordinated point that can be related to the original survey marks on a sketch
and be in a format that can be uploaded from the computer system to the relevant
electronic field book. As the database information is applied to more applications the
coding, format and the content will need to be more sophisticated. With the
incremental introduction of digital systems it is important to keep in mind possible
future uses particularly when upgrading the format and content of existing digital data
files.
The first stage of development of a CAD database is to build a single CAD file that
represents the survey area containing the cadastral boundary structure and references
to all the cadastral information shown on existing survey plans. The file can be used
for the purpose of a preliminary reinstatement analysis, preparation of a sketch
consolidating the existing cadastral information and for the purpose of locating
existing cadastral marks in the field. The preliminary reinstatement does not need
to be an exhaustive process, as much of the information required to carry out
the reinstatement will be gathered later during the field survey. The preliminary
Page 87 Digital System Evolution
reinstatement is no more than a familiarisation process of existing information that
can be carried out while combining existing survey plans into a single CAD file
format.
The second stage of development requires the CAD file to contain standard
descriptive coding that can be used to uniquely identify the cadastral point types
within the file.
The final stage of development of the CAD file requires the spatial information to be
survey accurate for the purpose of checking the final reinstated boundaries against the
previously surveyed locations. This stage is likely to be incorporated with additional
database development or legislation changes with regard to the coordinated cadastre.
2.1.2 The Location of Existing Cadastral Field Marks
The location of existing cadastral marks using electronic field books is a process that
is commonly used by surveyors and can exist on a stand-alone basis given the
existence of a CAD file containing the relevant digital information. This process uses
a field sketch produced from the CAD file and annotated with point numbers and
descriptive codes that can be related to the simple point number and coordinate file
uploaded from the CAD file to the electronic field book.
2.1.3 CAD Production of Survey Plans
The CAD production of survey plans is another process that is already commonly
used by cadastral surveyors. The amount of automation of the plan drafting process
varies from direct transfer of boundary lines with the re-entering of all text, tables and
diagrams to an almost fully automatic process with the drafter required to direct the
formatting and final presentation.
Page 88 Digital System Evolution
2.1.4 Pegging Lot Boundaries
The pegging of lot boundaries can be carried out by transferring the point number and
coordinate listing, from an existing CAD file of the reinstated cadastral boundaries
and additional reference marks required to be placed, to a standard electronic field
book. This data is then used in combination with a standard pegging programme and
the field sketch. This process is similar to the system used for location of existing
field marks.
2.1.5 Reinstatement Calculations
The reinstatement of cadastral boundaries has traditionally been carried out using
electronic calculators to determine a comparison between original and measured data.
The use of CAD systems to carry out these calculations provides the user with a
coordinated database and some additional calculation routines but the system remains
much the same as with the calculator-based methods. The surveyor is still required to
make the reinstatement decisions as well as to carry out a number of repetitive
calculations.
2.1.6 Electronic Field Book Field Data Collection
The development of electronic field book recording systems requires firstly the
existence of an efficient traverse sorting, adjustment and reduction programme and
secondly open access to the data file during the surveying process. There is also a
condition that the electronic field information is to be printed into a standard legible
field notes format.
2.2 Automated Reinstatement Procedures
It is important to ensure that the current system is compatible with existing legislation
as well as having some thought given to possible future developments. These systems
Page 89 Digital System Evolution
need to first establish the process for final reinstatement before considering the
preliminary reinstatements carried out at the data collection stage.
The total automation of cadastral reinstatement calculations is not possible due to the
necessity for the surveyor's judgment in determining a solution to the reinstatement
problem. There are a number of the processes used in determining the reinstatement
solution that can be improved using digital methods including programme
development and data integration.
2.2.1 The Reinstatement Calculation Process
The existing digital method used for reinstatement calculations is for the surveyor to
use a standard CAD programme to assist in the calculations required. While this is an
efficiency improvement on traditional methods using handheld calculators the CAD
programmes only offer additional data storage, a visual image and some additional
coordinate geometry functions to the standard calculator methods. Without the
addition of personalised add-on programmes the surveyor is still required to carry out
a number of repetitive calculations when comparing possible solutions to the original
survey information.
The alternative to the traditional CAD methods is the development of programmes
designed specifically for the reinstatement process. These types of programmes
include the coordinate based least square reinstatement programmes and the
preliminary field calibration method or the vector analysis method.
Page 90 Digital System Evolution
2.2.2 Integration with Field Data Collection
Cadastral field information is electronically collected using dedicated electronic field
books or electronic recording programmes within total station theodolites. The format
of the data collected is not only dependent on the type of instrument used to collect
the data but also the manufacturing company's software configurations. The data
collected can be in a numerically coded format that is only decipherable by surveyors
familiar with that particular system, such as the Geodimeter raw data file.
Alternatively the data collector can be in an alpha coded ordered format similar to the
Sokkia raw data file that would be expected to be interpreted by most surveyors.
The field data in a cadastral survey is required to be in a format suitable for survey
records and also be able to be adjusted and transformed into a format suitable for
direct entry into a CAD system. With modern software this process can be automatic.
An example of this is the Civilcad programme where data from most data recorders
can first be reduced into the neutral file format, that is vector style data format and
that would be suitable as a record for field surveys. Adjustments using either
Bowditch or least squares are possible before the data is transformed into CAD
format.
The cadastral reinstatement calculations can be carried out while the data is still in the
vector format of the neutral file format or in the coordinated format derived from the
CAD file.
2.2.3 Integration with Historical Data Collection
The reinstatement process combines the data from the field survey and historical
cadastral information to determine the cadastral boundaries. The historical cadastral
information compiled into a digital format at the start of the reinstatement process is
Page 91 Digital System Evolution
an adjusted copy of information held in the registered survey plans which is not
necessarily a true or exact record of the information on the survey plans. The
reinstatement process therefore requires the surveyor to, at some stage, refer again to
the registered survey plans that are the legal documents describing the original
boundaries.
The digital information compiled from the survey plans at the historical data analysis
stage in the reinstatement is often used during the field survey to assist in the location
of original marks and subsequently archived or discarded. This information is
effectively superseded by the field survey redefining the location of the original marks
and the original survey information requiring the certainty of the original legal
document as opposed to the copied and adjusted digital information. Within a CAD
reinstatement environment it is necessary to re-enter the original information into the
new spatial model defined by the field survey.
It will always be necessary to carry out a comparison of the reinstated boundaries with
the boundaries shown in the registered survey plans, unless there is a change in the
legislation giving legal status to the digital data. The original historical information in
the digital format may be used in an automated preliminary reinstatement. These
automated procedures have been demonstrated to some extent by the least square
reinstatement method and the field calibration method. The digital historical file is
required to hold the correct structure for the cadastral boundaries as well as the
original references to cadastral reference marks. This information can be digitally
combined with the dimensions from the field survey to obtain a preliminary solution
to the reinstatement problem.
2.3 Digital Data Flow and Distribution
The efficiency and automation of a digital system rely on the flow of data through the
system. The data is entered into a digital format at the earliest possible opportunity
and maintained in the digital format without needing to be re-entered. There should
be no loss of integrity of the data regardless of the format and individual content
Page 92 Digital System Evolution
required at specific stages of the process. Individual data elements will be uniquely
identifiable by a combination of their standard codes and spatial relationships. The
original survey data within the cadastral reinstatement process will be updated and
completely replaced by the final survey data.
2.3.1 Internal Data Flow
The internal data flow from the input information to the automated reinstatement
process depends on the format of the input data and the format required for the
specific reinstatement process to be used. The automated reinstatement process
requires the data to be in specific formats for the reinstatement to continue. These
formats are dependent on the system of reinstatement chosen. The format of the input
data depends on the level of system development.
Data will be split into three different formats on entry to the system, regardless of the
level of system development and database or process choices. These formats allow for
suitable data required for the field surveying processes, the digital format of original
data and an option for transferring the remainder of the original database information
not required in the previous two formats. The flow of data is illustrated in Table 6.3.
The updated database should contain all the input information as updated by the field
surveying and reinstatement process in a format that is similar to the original
information.
Page 93 Digital System Evolution
Table 6.3 Internal Digital Data Flow
This Table is unavailable online.
Please consult the hardcopy thesis
available at the QUT Library.
2.3.2 External System Data Flow
The external data flow relates to the process of lodgement, examination and archiving
of the final product of the reinstatement system and the preparation of this data for
input back into the reinstatement system. The surveyor carrying out the survey does
not have control of this process and is required to meet conditions set by the outside
agencies that collect and distribute the data. The outside agency determines the
content and format of this data.
Page 94 Digital System Evolution
Table 6.4 External Data Flow
This Table is unavailable online.
Please consult the hardcopy thesis
available at the QUT Library.
The traditional reinstatement process’s external data flow consists of the single output
of a cadastral survey plan that was required to be lodged with the Department of
Natural Resources and Mines. The surveyor was also required to submit additional
supplementary information including field notes and cadastral reinstatement reports
depending on the legislation of the day. The survey plans once lodged with the
department were examined with reference to the appropriate legislation and were
either rejected or registered. The archive of registered survey plans with additional
supplementary survey information including title documents, identification surveys,
field notes and cadastral reinstatement reports forms a complete record of the
cadastre.
Page 95 Digital System Evolution
This process is essentially the same today with the registered survey plan being the
controlling instrument in the transfer of all legal cadastral data between surveyors.
Digital data transfer is not recognised by legislation and the quality of the data within
any particular digital database is the responsibility of the entity or surveyor
maintaining that particular database. The changes in legislation and government
procedures have meant that the majority of survey plans lodged with the department
are now not examined. The correctness and completeness of survey plans has always
been the responsibility of Licensed Surveyors. The reduction in examination
resources at the Department of Natural Resources and Mines has now placed the
responsibility completely on the Licensed Surveyors.
The existing cadastral reinstatement process not only provides registered survey plans
but also the CAD files that are the digital representation of the survey plans. The
CAD file is a by-product of the process that produces the survey plan. These files
contain more than 90 percent of the plan data in the digital format. The CAD file may
also contain the additional 10 percent of data that can be extracted digitally if
required. As a by-product of the production process, the CAD file is often discarded
or archived for future uses within the organisation that produced the file.
The CAD files as a by-product of the system have no standard formats or coding that
allow for the lodging of data into a standard digital database. Data from these existing
files are of undetermined quality and completeness. It is possible that this information
is of acceptable quality and the contents are suitable for the purpose of obtaining
preliminary digital information required for the reinstatement process when used in
conjunction with registered survey plans.
The use of standard formats and codes within the reinstatement process will produce
standard CAD files. The process of digital lodgement can include the extraction and
validation of digital data from these standard CAD files in formats suitable for
Page 96 Digital System Evolution
inclusion in existing databases. Digital lodgement may provide data of equivalent
standard as the traditional databases (certified by Licensed Surveyors) but unless
changes are made to the legislation ensuring compulsory digital lodgement the
completeness and maintenance of the digital database cannot be guaranteed.
To complete the circle of digital data flow throughout the system, it is necessary to
convert data from the external database back into a format that is suitable for entry
into the start of the reinstatement process. At the early stages of development of the
digital reinstatement process this information is required in the CAD format. This
format is essential for inclusion into existing systems and it has been demonstrated by
the digital lodgement process that digital data acceptable to other database systems
can be extracted from the CAD files using programmes developed on a Microsoft
Office platform.
2.3.3 Data Distribution
The distribution of traditional survey data revolves around the process of compulsory
lodgement of survey plans with the Department of Natural Resources and Mines. The
department provides a database that is essentially complete and up-to-date. This data
is then distributed to the public at a fee.
There are also voluntary forms of data distribution where surveyors distribute copies
of their own registered plans to other associated companies in exchange for the
reciprocating companies registered plans. This reciprocal system is used to bypass
the need to pay for each survey plan and to extend their database in their local area.
These voluntary arrangements can also cover the sharing of information not lodged
with the department. There are large amounts of data and knowledge held exclusively
by private surveying firms.
Page 97 Digital System Evolution
The distribution of digital surveying data also depends on either compulsory or
voluntary agreements. It is unlikely in the short-term that the government will
provide digital information that is suitable for use by cadastral surveyors to determine
the property boundaries. It is possible that the digital information to be provided will
include survey accurate coordinates for the property boundaries that may assist in the
location of property corners in the field but to hold no information on reference marks
and occupation that is essential to surveyors for the reinstatement of property
boundaries. This is similar to the process in New Zealand with the survey accurate
coordinated cadastre forming a summary of the survey information with the approved
survey plans remaining the core evidence of boundary location.
It is essential that the voluntary agreements for sharing data extend to the sharing of
digital cadastral data, so surveyors can maintain a circular flow of digital data. Until a
network of surveyors can provide adequate coverage of the local area there will be a
reliance on possible future developments in the government or the constant need to
convert registered survey plans to digital format.
Page 98 Digital System Evolution
3 Implementation
The evaluation of digital processes designed to replace traditional elements within the
cadastral reinstatement system almost invariably report an improvement in the
efficiency of the process. In some cases reported efficiencies have not been sufficient
motivation for changes to occur and in other cases the changes to the digital processes
have occurred on an almost industry wide basis.
The first type of process to progress to a digital system is when the digital technology
is commercially available and commonly used in other surveying processes. In these
cases the surveyors may already be using the technology for other surveying methods
leaving little requirement for additional capital purchases or training. This is typical
of the introduction of the use of CAD databases and electronic field data recorders to
assist in the location of cadastral marks in the field and the pegging of lot boundaries.
Change is less likely to occur when there is a requirement for some adaptation to
available technology or existing methods. This is the case in the application of the
electronic field book for the recording of cadastral field information. Significant
savings in production time can be achieved with the introduction of the electronic
field books in gathering cadastral field data but practitioners are reluctant to make the
changes.
Page 99 Digital System Evolution
Recent research shows the introduction of totally new technology provides additional
development costs associated with product development and staff training. The
digital lodgement system incorporating automated reinstatement and quality assurance
procedures is a result of extensive product development by a cadastral surveying
organisation that has reported efficiency improvements of between – 15% to +10 %
over the traditional cadastral reinstatement methods. Poor performance in some cases
was related to the experience of the surveyor and the quality of training received.
Reduction in costs accrued after adequate training and the availability of certified
digital data. The development of new technology can provide surveyors with a
commercial advantage over their competitors but the motivation to change relies on
that commercial advantage outweighing the development costs, including staff
training.
4 Summary
The digital cadastral system’s development process does not significantly change
although the individual elements of development may progress using different
methods. The style of reinstatement may vary from the traditional where the
emphasis is on the final reinstatement calculations to a co-ordinated cadastre
approach where the reinstatement emphasis is on the initial historical analysis. The
data structure may change from the co-ordinated structural approach to the vector
method and back again at different stages of the development. The style and structure
of the methods used can vary as long as the conditions of continuous digital data flow
without loss of data are maintained.
The incremental system of development allows for the introduction of additional
digital elements as the system progresses. The development process moves from the
introduction of digital methods from within the traditional system to the selection of
an appropriate automated reinstatement procedure. This is followed by ensuring a
continuous flow of data firstly from within the private cadastral surveying
Page 100 Digital System Evolution
organisation and then through the external system including the distribution of data to
outside agencies.
The external distribution and flow of data is traditionally controlled by the
government agencies, but this does not have to be the case. The technology exists for
surveyors to share digital data, certified by Licensed Surveyors independent of
government policies. The opportunity to obtain complete data sets is only limited by
the surveyor’s ability to share data.
The incremental system of development provides the surveyor with an opportunity to
introduce digital technology progressively thus reducing the initial set up costs
associated with radical change and still providing a degree of commercial advantage
at each incremental step.
Page 101 Chapter 7: Conclusions and Implications
Chapter 7
Conclusions and Implications
Page 102 Chapter 7: Conclusions and Implications
Chapter 7 Conclusions and Implications 1 Conclusions
1.1 Independent Systems
The digital reinstatement systems within private cadastral organisations are
independent from the digital cadastral systems within the Queensland
Government.
The private cadastral organisations currently operate their digital systems independent
of the government system with the product of their surveys being lodged with the
government in the format specified by the government. The government sets the
specification for lodgement primarily in the format that suits their own requirements,
with the needs for digital reinstatement information taking a secondary role. Even
with digital lodgement of surveying information it will be some time before the
present requirements for digital reinstatement information is met, especially in terms
of network coverage.
The move towards uniting the digital systems of private and government
organisations through the introduction of digital lodgement has merit, but it does not
mean that the digital system within private cadastral organisations cannot operate
efficiently, meet the current data requirements within its own system and still produce
the cadastral reinstatement output in the format currently specified for lodgement.
The development of internal digital reinstatement systems within private cadastral
organisations is mostly within the control of the private organisations with each
Page 103 Chapter 7: Conclusions and Implications
individual organisation setting the pace of development. Government agencies that
traditionally control the external flow of cadastral data require this information in a
non-digital format. Surveyors have the option of collecting and distributing digital
cadastral data, certified by Licensed Surveyors, independent of government policy.
1.2 Existing Technology and Organisation Structures
The existing technology and organisational structures are suitable for the
development of digital reinstatement systems within private cadastral
organisations.
Modern surveying technology that is suitable for digital reinstatement systems with
continuous data flow has been tried and tested in related fields or in isolation within
the current cadastral reinstatement processes. The surveying organisation structures
and agreements that currently exist to share non-digital resources are also suitable for
sharing digital information.
1.3 Digital Cadastral Information
Digital cadastral information is available for the development of digital
reinstatement systems.
It is necessary to have a supply of easily accessible and relevant digital information
for digital reinstatement systems to reach their full potential. This information may be
supplied at some time in the future by the cadastral registering authorities but private
cadastral surveyors already hold large amounts of digital cadastral information that is
Page 104 Chapter 7: Conclusions and Implications
suitable for many of the uses required in digital reinstatement systems. The
availability of suitable digital information is limited by the private surveyors’ ability
to archive their own information in a format suitable for distribution and to share this
resource with other organisations providing digital cadastral data.
The digital cadastral files used by surveyors for the preparation of registered survey
plans is of a similar spatial quality as the paper plan, though not in the format required
by the registering authority. The only value added to this spatial information by the
registering authorities is the legal status of the registered survey plan. The existing
digital information will be easier to collect and archive for redistribution, without the
registering authorities’ legal, format and authorisation restrictions. This data has the
capacity to not only meet the internal reinstatement requirements of the private
cadastral organisations, but to also serve as an unregistered spatial record of the
property boundaries themselves.
1.4 Incremental Development
An incremental system of development allows for the introduction of additional
digital elements as the system progresses towards complete digital data flow and
automated systems.
The cadastral reinstatement system is a well-defined process that does not
significantly change regardless of the methods and data structures adopted. The
incremental approach to development allows private surveying organisations to
introduce digital systems incrementally, first allowing for continuous digital data flow
throughout their own internal reinstatement processes followed by the full circular
flow of digital data through the external lodgement and distribution of digital data.
Page 105 Chapter 7: Conclusions and Implications
The introduction of the full digital data flow through external lodgement is dependent
on the development and maturity of systems within the lodging authorities. At some
time in the future digital lodgement will provide the registering authorities with digital
information in a format that their systems require. The registering authorities will
then be in a position to distribute the registered digital data. The amount and extent of
registered digital data to be distributed will depend on the policies of the registering
authorities.
Continuous digital data flow and automated systems within the private cadastral
organisations is dependent on the private organisations themselves. The organisations
have the technology, organisational structures and the access to existing digital data to
develop these systems independent of outside agencies. This includes the possibility
of using existing digital information as a source of unregistered boundary information
for reinstatement purposes until the registering authorities collect and supply
appropriate registered information through the digital lodgement process.
2 Implications
The process of incremental development of digital cadastral reinstatement systems
provides surveyors with the means of developing efficient and sustainable digital
cadastral systems within the existing legislative and technical environments. The
development of these systems does not rely on external conditions such as relevant
legislation and industry standards. Incremental development allows surveyors to
choose the extent and timing of development to take advantage of opportunities for
economic gain when the opportunities arise.
The limit of development within private cadastral organisations depends to some
extent on the ability to share the digital information existing within these
organisations and the quality of the information collected. The information available
Page 106 Chapter 7: Conclusions and Implications
is suitable for organisations to go beyond the existing level of development to
improve the digital data flow and include automated elements into their own systems.
The private organisations have the capacity to not only implement their own internal
systems but to also develop beyond this through the use of local area databases of
existing digital unregistered boundary information. The unregistered digital boundary
information can be used as an alternative to the information that will eventually be
supplied by the digital lodgement process.
The process of digital data storage and retrieval will develop the skills of surveyors as
digital information managers allowing them to not only supply digital information to
other surveyors and government institutions, but also to provide private clients with
digital spatial information. Along with the skills required to manage spatial
information, surveyors will also possess local area digital information gathered
throughout the process of cadastral reinstatement in a format that is possible to sell as
a spatial information product. The coverage area and amount of data available to the
surveyor is limited by the ability to share resources with other producers of similar
data.
Page 107 Appendix
Appendix 1
Surveyors Act 1977
Surveyors Act 1977 No. 18 - date of assent 21 April 1977; commenced 29 April 1978 (proc pubd gaz 29 April 1978 p 1739)
as amended by— Surveyors Act Amendment Act 1978 No. 33 - date of assent 8 June 1978; commenced
29 April 1978 (see s 2)
Surveyors Act Amendment Act 1978 (No. 2) No.69 - date of assent 8 December 1978; commenced on date of assent
Surveyors Act Amendment Act 1980 No. 23 - date of assent 12 May 1980; commenced
26 February 1981 (proc pubd gaz 28 February 1981 p 659) Surveyors Act Amendment Act 1983 No. 5 - date of assent 10 March 1983; ss 1—2
commenced on date of assent (see s 2(1)); remaining provisions commenced 6 October 1983 (see s 2(2) and proc pubd gaz 8 October 1983 p 552)
Surveyors Act Amendment Act 1987 No. 86 - date of assent 1 December 1987;
commenced on date of assent Surveyors Act Amendment Act 1989 No. 115 - date of assent 31 October 1989; ss 1—2
commenced on date of assent (see s 2(1)); remaining provisions commenced 1 April 1990 (see s 2(2) and proc pubd gaz 31 March 1990 p 1537)
Surveyors Amendment Act 1991 No. 59 - date of assent 18 September 1991; s 12
commenced 1 April 1992 (1991 SL No. 148); remaining provisions commenced on date of assent
Lands Legislation Amendment Act 1992 No.64 ss 1—2, ch 2 pt 4,s 3 sch 1 - date of
assent 7 December 1992; ss 1—2 commenced on date of assent; remaining provisions commenced 26 March 1993 (1993 SL No. 88)
Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1993 No. 32 ss 1—3 sch 1 - date of assent
3 June 1993; commenced on date of assent (see s 2)
Page 108 Appendix
Anti-Discrimination Amendment Act 1994 No. 29 ss 1—3 sch - date of assent 28 June
1994; ss 1—2 commenced on date of assent; remaining provisions commenced 1 July 1994 (see s 2)
Land Act 1994 No. 81 ss 1—2, 525 sch 3 - date of assent 1 December 1994;
commenced on date of assent (see s 2(1)) Statute Law Revision Act 1995 No. 57 ss 1—2,4 sch 1 - date of assent 28 November
1995; commenced on date of assent (see s 2) Statutory Bodies Financial Arrangements Amendment Act 1996 No. 54 ss 1—2, 9 sch
- date of assent 20 November 1996; ss 1—2 commenced on date of assent; remaining provisions commenced 1 June 1997 (1997 SL No. 128)
Valuation of Land and Other Legislation Amendment Act 1998 No. 48 pt 1 s 17 sch -
date of assent 27 November 1998; ss 1—2 commenced on date of assent; remaining provisions commenced 18 December 1998 (1998 SL No. 364)
Surveyors Regulation, 1992 Surveyors Regulation 1992 SL No.72 - made by the Governor in Council on 9 April
1992; pubd gaz 10 April 1992 pp 2053—73; commenced on date of publication; exp 1 September 2002 (see SIA s 54)
as amended by— Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No. 1) 1992 SL No. 266 - notfd gaz 21 August
1992 pp 2949—51; commenced on date of notification Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No.2) 1992 SL No. 293 - notfd gaz 9 October 1992
pp 446—7; commenced on date of notification Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No. 1) 1993 SL No. 389 - notfd gaz 22 October
1993 pp 695—7; commenced on date of notification Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No. 1) 1994 SL No. 346 - notfd gaz 23 September
1994 pp 355—6; commenced on date of notification Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No. 1) 1995 SL No. 205 - notfd gaz 22 June 1995
pp 1281A—1281D; ss 1, 3 commenced on date of notification; remaining provisions commenced 1 July 1995 (see s 3)
Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No. 1) 1996 SL No. 133 - notfd gaz 14 June 1996 pp 987—9; ss 1—2 commenced on date of notification; remaining provisions commenced 1 July 1996 (see s 2)
Page 109 Appendix
Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No. 1) 1997 SL No. 190 - notfd gaz 27 June 1997
pp 1004—1010; ss 1—2 commenced on date of notification; remaining provisions commenced 1 July 1997 (see s 2)
Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No. 1) 1998 SL No. 208 - notfd gaz 17 July 1998
pp 1404—6; commenced on date of notification (see s 2) Natural Resources Legislation Amendment Regulation (No. 2) 1999 SL No. 228 pts 1,
3 - notfd gaz 8 October 1999 pp 559—60; commenced on date of notification Surveyors Amendment Regulation (No. 1) 2000 SL No. 121 - notfd gaz 16 June 2000
pp 555—6; commenced on date of notification Natural Resources Legislation Amendment Regulation (No. 2) 2000 SL No. 168 ss l,
2 (2) pt3 - notfd gaz 30 June 2000 pp 736-48; ss 1—2 commenced on date of notification; remaining provisions commenced 1 July 2000 (see s 2(2))
Page 110 Bibliography
Bibliography
Barrie, J.K. "The Surveying Profession in Australia: A Personal Interpretation of Its Historical Development, Current and Future Trends." The Australian Surveyor 28, no. 1 (1976): 6-56.
Blair, Graham. "Mathematical Checks." In Reinstatement Principles and Practice, ed.
Surveyors Board of Queensland, Brisbane: Association of Consulting Surveyors, 1996.
Brown, A.G. Law Relating to Land Boundaries & Surveying. Brisbane: Association of
Consulting Surveyors, Queensland, 1980. Cook, John S. "Some Policy Issues Involved in Digital Land Boundary Information." In
"Management of Cadastral Information, Proceedings of Winter School 91, School of Surveying, Queensland University of Technology (25-6 July 1991)". QUT, Brisbane, 1991.
Cook, John S. "A Cybernetic Approach to Land Management Issues." PhD. Dissertation,
Queensland University of Technology, 1994. Coombs, Rod, Paolo Saviotti, and Vivien Walsh. Economic and Technological Change. 1
vols. 10 ed. New York: Rowman and Littlefield, 1987. Dowling, David G., and Kevin McDougall. "The Development of a Standard Digital
Survey Data System." In Networking Into The 21st Century. Proceedings of the 5th South East Asian and 36th Australian Surveyors Congress held at Singapore (16-20 July 1995), 1, 121-133. Singapore, 1995.
Durgiss, Ken. Advancing Field Data Collection with Wearable Computers. The
Professional Surveyor, 2001. Accessed 14/6/2001 2001. Internet. Available from http://www.profsurv.com/ps_scripts/article.idc.
Elfick, M.H. "Electronic Lodgement of Plans." The Australian Surveyor 37, no. 3
(September) (1992): 199. Elfick, M.H. "A Cadastral Geometry Management System." The Australian Surveyor 40,
no. 1 (1995): 35-40. Elfick, M.H. and Fryer, J.G. Cost Benefit Study on Management of Cadastral Data, 1992.
Page 111 Bibliography
Gelbman, Eytan, and Yerahmiel Doytsher. "Automatic Filtering and Classification of
Raw Field Surveying Data." Surveying and Land Information Systems 59, no. 4 (1999): 231-240.
Grant, Don, Tadeusz Dawidowski, and Ralph Winmill. "New Zealand Land Tenure
Beyond 2000: Full Integration and Automation of the New Zealand Survey and Title System." In 1st Trans Tasman Surveyors Conference, 1, 3.1 - 3.10. Newcastle, 1997.
Ham, R.A. "Advantages of Automated Surveying in Cadastral Surveys." Queensland
Surveyors Bulletin 1998, no. 5 (1998): 56. Hannigan, Brian. "Why Is It Necessary to Re-Instate Boundaries?" In Reinstatement
Principles and Practice, ed. Surveyors Board of Queensland, Brisbane: Association of Consulting Surveyors, 1996.
Hayes, John F. "A Prototype System for the Digital Lodgement of Spatial Data." PhD.
Dissertation, Queensland University of Technology, 1997. Koo, T.K., and M.K. Lim. "Entity-Coded Neutral-File Format for Integrating Data
Collectors." Journal of Surveying Engineering 116, no. 2 (1990): 93-103. McMahon, G., Jordan, G., Keays, J. and Oates, W. "The Moreton Model - a Blueprint for
Local Government." Paper - Source Unknown, (1995). Paiva, Joseph V.R. "Critical Aspects of a Modern Surveying System." Journal of
Surveying Engineering 116, no. 1 (1990): 47-56. Queensland Spatial Information Industry Group. Spatial Strategy Forum;Queensland.
Queensland Spatial Information Industry Group, 26/6/1998 1998. Accessed 16/7/2001 2001. Internet. Available from http:\\www.surveying-q.
Rush, Graeme. "Have We Adopted Legal Co-Ordinates?" The Queensland Surveyor
2000, no. 6 (2000): 8-9. Spatial Data Standards Project Team. "Enhancing the Surveying Industry's Participation
in Opportunities Afforded by Spatial Information." The Queensland Surveyor 2001, no. 2 (2001): 35-48.
Sprott, J.S. "Least Squares Reinstatement." The Australian Surveyor 31, no. 8 (1983):
543-556. Sprott, J.S. "The Significance of Scale Factors in Cadastral Surveying." The Australian
Surveyor 34, no. 1, March (1988): 68-82.
Page 112 Bibliography
Sprott, J.S. "Shortage and Excess." The Australian Surveyor 34, no. 8 (December, 1989):
819-827. Sprott, J.S. "Maintaining Deed Angles." The Australian Surveyor 38, no. 1 (March,
1993): 50-53. Todd, Peter, Matt Higgins, and George Williams. Discussion Paper: An Enhanced
Survey Observations Management Environment. Brisbane: DNR, 2000. Discussion Paper.
Topcon Australia. Civilcad User Manual - Surveying and Engineering Software. Vol. 2. 2
vols, 1998. Topcon Corporation. User Manual - Topcon GTS 600 Application Software. 1 vols.
Tokyo, 2000.