exclusion of pregnant women

17
Exclusion of Pregnant Women Henry D. Royal, M.D. Associate Director Division of Nuclear Medicine Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology Professor of Radiology Washington University School of Medicine St. Louis, MO FDA Meeting 11/16/04

Upload: kamran

Post on 11-Feb-2016

52 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Exclusion of Pregnant Women. Henry D. Royal, M.D. Associate Director Division of Nuclear Medicine Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology Professor of Radiology Washington University School of Medicine St. Louis, MO. FDA Meeting 11/16/04. Overview. Radiation Risks During Pregnancy - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Henry D. Royal, M.D.

Associate DirectorDivision of Nuclear Medicine

Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology

Professor of RadiologyWashington University School of Medicine

St. Louis, MOFDA Meeting 11/16/04

Page 2: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Overview

Radiation Risks During PregnancyPregnancy TestsMutagenesis

Page 3: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Radiation Effects in Pregnancy

Dose to Embryo and FetusStage of GestationCongenital Abnormalities are

Deterministic EffectsChildhood Cancer is a

Stochastic Effect

Page 4: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

BEIR V Figure 6-1Fetal Dose (Gy)0 1.00.50.2 0.3

00.1 1.5

10

20

30

40

50

60

70Se

vere

Men

tal R

etar

dati

on (

%)

8-15 Weeks

All Gestational Ages

16-25 weeks

Page 5: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

BEIR V Figure 6-1

Page 6: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

BEIR V Figure 6-1

Page 7: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Teratogenesis

Mental Retardation is the Greatest Effect 0.4% per Rem

Decrease in IQ0.3 Units per Rem

Risk is Greatest at 8-15 Weeks Threshold May Exists at 20-40 Rem

Page 8: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Childhood Cancer2.2 per 1,000 (0-15 years)Relative Risk: 1.4 per RemAbsolute Risk: 0.06% per Rem

(1 Cancer per 1700 children)Controversial

ICRP 84 page 11, 2000

Page 9: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

0 10 20 30Cases per 1,000 Births

GrowthRetardation

DevelopmentalAbnormalities

Viral Infections

ChromosomalAbnormalities

Risks of Pregnancy

Page 10: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Occupational Exposure During Pregnancy

0.5 Rem During Entire Pregnancy 0.05 Rem/Month Once Pregnancy Declared

NCRP Report 91, 1987

Page 11: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Pregnancy Testing

Given That The Risk is Small With Fetal Doses in the Few 100 mRem Range, Written Attestation Should Suffice

For Fetal Doses > 1 Rem, a Pregnancy Test Would be Prudent

Pregnancy Tests Are Not Perfect

Page 12: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Mutagenesis

Somatic vs Germ Cells

Page 13: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Mutagenesis

38,000 Parents75,000 BirthsNo Significant Differences in:1. Still Births2. Birth Weights3. Congenital

Abnormalities

4. Infant Mortality5. Child Mortality6. Leukemia7. Sex Ratio

Page 14: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Rare Electrophorectic Variants

Mutagenesis

ExposedThree Probable Mutations in 667,404 Loci

ControlThree Probable Mutations in 466,881 Loci

No Significant Difference

Page 15: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Not Demonstrated in HumansAbundant Evidence in Plants and Animals

at High Doses

Mutagenesis

Page 16: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

10 20 30 40 500

0.05

0.1

0.15

NEJM 328:114-120, 1993Maternal Age

Prob

abili

tyGenetic Effects

All

Down’s

Page 17: Exclusion of Pregnant Women

Conclusions About Mutagenesis

Immeasurable RiskPregnancy Should Only be Delayed If It is

Expected That the Health of the Mother Will Improve With Time