exhibit 7 part 2 of 9 - kcc class actionclassaction.kccllc.net/documents/nwd0001/576-8 -...

EXHIBIT 7 Part 2 of 9

Case 1:13-cv-06802-WHP Document 576-8 Filed 07/13/16 of 16

01/19/11 SFB

01/20/11 SFB

01/21/11 SFB

01/24/11 SFB

01/25/11 SFB

01/26/11 SFB

Gustafew (General Mills) regardingNews case; check Insignia casedocket; prepare and send detaileddamages memoranda to M. Simonette(Schwans), D. Lofty (SC Johnson),and M. Gustafero (General Mills),compile Unilever and Alberto-Culver News trade spend for 2007-2010; conference with J. Min andT. Monroe regarding Kellogg tradespend with News from 2007-2010.

Edit News case engagement letter;conferences with S. Berry;conference with D. Cofoy regardingSC Johnson and News trade spend.

Meet with Deborah Majoras, ChiefLegal Officer Procter & Gambleregarding News case; conferencewith D. Lofty regarding SC Johnson2006-2007 News trade spend.

Review Valassis transcripts forNews, SC Johnson, and clientreferences; conferences with B.Conyngham regarding same;conference with D. Shaw regarding2010 Heinz trade spend; conferencewith A. Gulati and M. Gustaferoregarding General Mills News tradespend; conference with J. Minregarding Kellogg news tradespend.

Conferences with E. Sagehornregarding Tysons News trade spend;conference with C. Signorelloregarding Henkel News trade spend;conference with D. Lafoy regardingSC Johnson trade spend; updateNews case clients trade spendchart; conference with D. Shawregarding Heinz trade spend.

Check Insignia V. News docket;review Insignia case motions inlimine.

Conference with E. Sagehornregarding Tysons' News trade

Page 17

0.75

2.00

2.00

2.00

0.50

1.00

SC JohnsonHenkel/Dial, et al. v. News America

August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


01/27/11 SFB

01/28/11 SFB

01/29/11 SFB

01/31/11 SFB

02/01/11 SFB

02/02/11 SFB

spend; edit News case engagementletters and joint representationagreement.

Call to Cliff Wilkins at Colgateregarding News case; edit revisedfee and cost sharing agreement;prepare for News expert meetingwith C. Bamberberger and H. Sider(Lexecon), Conferences with S.Berry and B. O'Bleness regardingexperts for News case.

Review and edit cost-sharingagreement for News case;conferences with S. Berry, D.Everson, and B. O'blenessregarding the Same; check insigniav. News case docket and settlementstatus; conference with ColgateAssistant General Counsel CliffWilson.

Conferences with J. Mackie-Masonand P. Farris regarding serving asNews Case relevant market andcompetitive exclusion experts;finalize and circulate jointprosecution cost agreement andbudget estimate to News in housecounsel.

Calls to experts for News Casecase (Lexecon, NAM); conferenceswith S. Berry and B. O'blenessregarding experts.

Conference with S. Berry and B.O'Bleness regarding News caseexperts; conference with C.Wilkins (Colgate) regarding Newsdamages; conference with clientsregarding joint prosecution andcost sharing agreement; Conferencewith P. Fams, J. McKie Mason(exper ts)regarding retention; sendfee agreement to A. Gulati(General Mills)

Expert call with S. Berry, D.Stinson and B. O'bleniss; Send

Page 18

2.75

2.00

2.00

1.25

1.50

3.00


August 1, 2014Invoice =H= 2008217379


02/03/11 SFB

02/04/11 SFB

02/07/11 SFB

02/08/11 SFB

02/09/11 SFB

News supplemental memorandum to D.Majoras (Procter & Gamble),conference with P. Farris and J.Mackie-Mason regarding expertretention in News case (damages);work on client engagement letters;check Insignia case docket;provide damages analysis andmaterials for C. Wilkins (Colgate-Palmolive)

Conference with J. Finocharo(Procter & Gamble) regarding Newscase; conference with J. Heraldand D. Majoras regarding Procter &Gamble News claims; check Insigniav. News case docket; conferencewith NAM (potential News caseexperts); check P. Farris (expert)background and publications.

Conference with John Finocharo(Proctor & Gamble) antitrustassociate general counselregarding News case; conferencewith J. Mackie-Mason and P. Farris(expert) regarding Valassis marketand Floorgraphics damagestestimony in News case; review andcirculate Farris expert testimony;review P. Farris Floorgraphicsdamages testimony.

Conference with P. Farris (expert)regarding News Floorgraphics trialtestimony.

Check Insignia V. News casedocket; review News case budget;edit joint prosecution and costsharing agreement; conference withD. Shaw (Heinz); conference withM. Baye (NERA) regarding expertretention.

Conference with P. Farris and T.Fazzone (experts) at Spectrumregarding budget and retention;prepare revised budget; editengagement letters and jointprosecution and cost sharing

Page 19

2.75

3.00

0.25

2.50

2.75

SC JohnsonHenkel/Dial, et al. V. News America

August 1 2014Invoice =H= 2008217379


02/10/11 SFB

02/14/11 SFB

02/16/11 SFB

02/17/11 SFB

02/18/11 SFB

02/20/11 SFB

02/22/11 SFB

02/23/11 SFB

agreement; conference with M. Baye(expert) regarding NERA retention.

Finalize and send budget and jointprosecution and cost sharingagreement to clients; circulateInsignia-News settlement materialsto clients; conference with C.Wikins (Colgate), M. Simonett(Schwan's) and J. Rinocharo(Proctor & Gamble)

Conference with J. Mackie-Masonregarding News expert budget andplan of work.

Conference with C. Bamberger andH. Sider (Lexecon experts)regarding News case; conferencewith C. Signorello regardingHenkel and Dial participation.

Conference with H. Sider and C.Bamberger (Lexecon) regarding Newscase retention; conferences withD. Lofty (Schwan), C. Wilkins(Colgate), J. Min (Kellogg), andJ. Finochare (Proctor & Gamble)

Conference with B. O'Bleniss andS. Berry regarding expertretention Lerner index damages inNews case; prepare News compositedamages analysis.

Calls with all potential clientsregarding Kraft damages and needto file complaint; conference withC. Wilkins (Colgate), J. Finocharo(Procter & Gamble), A. Gulati, andM. Gustaferro regarding the Same.

Conference with clients to set upconference call regarding Newscase; conference with J. Finocaro(Procter & Gamble) and C. Wilkinsregarding News case.

Conference with M. Simonett(SChwan's) regarding News case;begin drafting News complaint.

Page 20

1.50

0.50

0.50

2.00

1.25

1.25

0.50

2.00


August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379


Conference with J. Finocharo (P&G)

02/24/11

03/01/11

03/02/11

03/04/11

03/07/11

04/01/11

05/03/11

05/31/11

06/07/11

06/08/11

08/22/11

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

AJC

JHM

JHM

SFB

Draf t News complaint; conferencewith Finocharo (Procter & Gamble)and C. Wilkins (Colgate).

regarding News damages.

Conference with J. Finocharo(Procter & Gamble) and J. Min(Kellogg) regarding News damagesand bundling.

Conference with J. Finocharo(Proctor & Gamble) regarding Newscase damages; conference with C.Walkins regarding Colgate Newsdamages; conference with J. Minregarding Kellogg News damages.

Send Kellogg News case damagesanalysis to J. Min; prepareProcter & Gamble and Colgatedamages memoranda .

Conference with J. Finocharo(Proctor & Gamble) regarding Newscase; conference with C. Wilkins(Colgate) regarding News case.

Conferences with D. Everson and S.Berry regarding Reckittfor News case.

damages

Purchase 2 hard drives fromStaples; burn all Valassisdocuments to each hard drive; mailone copy to R. Pfau; deliver theother copy to Berry Law.

Legal research on classand in-house counsel ofmember News Corp.

Legal research on classand in-house counsel ofmember News Corp.

actionsclass

actionsclass

Update cost-sharing table for News

1

0.

0.

0

0

0.

0

3.

6.

8

0.

25

25

50

.75

.75

50

.25

00

25

.25

75


August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379

case

Page 21


08/23/11

08/30/11

08/31/11

10/10/11

10/21/11

10/24/11

11/15/11

11/17/11

11/18/11

12/14/11

01/10/12

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

AJC

AJC

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

Finalize and send Merck damagesanalysis to S. Cipolla for NewsC8SG

Conference with K. May, GeneralCounsel at Pinnacle Foodsregarding News case participation.

Conference with K. May and J.Kroeger (General Counsel PinnacleFoods, BirdsEye, and Aurora Foods)regarding News case.

Conference with G. Curtner and S.Berry regarding retention lettersfor News Case.

Assist A. Woehler inNewsCorp/Valassis case documentSearch.

Go to Berry Law to pick upexternal for Valassis/NewsCorpcase; make all transcripts wordsearchable; perform ConAgra/Nestlesearch; burn CD for delivery to A.Woehler.

Conferences with M. Murray(assistant General counsel, SaraLee) regarding News case.

Conference with S. Berry and R.Grossman regarding News Caseclients.

Conferences with S. Berry and G.Curtner regarding rollingagreement draft and retentionagreement for News case.

Conference with assistant GeneralCounsels for SC Johnson, Heinz,Schwan's, Sara Lee, and Henkelregarding News case.

Conference with S. Berry and R.Grossman regarding Nestle, SCJohnson and other retentions inNews case.

Page 22

0

0.

0.

0.

1.

0

1.

0.

0.

.50

50

50

25

00

75

.50

00

50

00

50


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


SC JohnsonHenkel/Dial,

01/11/12

01/12/12

01/13/12

01/19/12

02/12/12

02/13/12

02/14/12

02/15/12

02/16/12

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

August 1, 2014

Conference with SC Johnson Generalcounsel regarding SC Johnson Newsclaims; finalize and send SCJohnson damages memorandum;conference with C. Signorello(Henkel), D. Shaw (Heinz), M.Simonett (Schwans) regarding Newscase and pre-complaint mediation;edit News co-counsel agreement;conference with S. Berry regardingthe foregoing.

Edit News Co-counsel agreements;conferences with S. Berry and G.Cur tner regarding the foregoing.

Edit News case co-counselagreements; conferences with S.Berry and G. Curtner regarding theforegoing.

Conference with G. Grunbaum(General Counsel SC Johnson)regarding News Case retention.

Revise Heinz retention agreementfor News case; conferences with S.Berry.

Prepare News tolling agreement forHeinz; conferences with D. Shawand S. Berry regarding Newsmedication; conference with R.Grossman regarding Butterballretention.

Conference with R. Grossmanregarding News case Butterballretention; conference with M.Simonett regarding Schwannretention for News case; prepareButterball retention letter androlling agreement.

Conference regarding News casewith B. Sattler (Schwanns) and G.Grunbaum with J. Metzler(ApplEcon) regarding Newsovercharge model.

Conference with C. Signorello

Page 23

3.25

1.00

0.75

0.25

0.50

1.50

1.50

1.50

1.50

et al. v. News America Invoice # 2008217379



02/28/12 SFB

02/29/12 SFB

03/01/12 SFB

03/02/12 SFB

03/03/12 SFB

03/07/12 SFB

03/09/12 SFB

August 1, 2014

(Henkel and Dial) regarding Newsretention; review Schwan's damageswith J. Metzler (Applecon) forNews case; review News caseovercharges model; conference withG. Grunbaum regarding SC JohnsonNews damages.

Conferences with C. Signorello(Henkel and Dial) and D. Shaw(Heinz), send common interestagreement to G. Grunbaum (SCJohnson)

Conference with G. Grunbaum and S.Berry regarding News retention andengagement letter.

Revise draft News tollingagreement and send to G. Grunbaum,D. Shaw, and C. Signorello; sendNews tolling agreement to M.Simonett, B. Sattler, and D. Bock(Schwan's)

News case conference with S. Berryand G. Cur tner regarding SCJohnson bundling; revise commoninterest and joint prosecutionagreements with G. Grunbaum (SCJohnson), circulate draft tollingagreement; trade spend analysis.

Conferences with D. Shaw and G.Grunbaum (SC Johnson) regardingtrade spend; review Henkel/Dialtrade spend; conference with C.Signorello regarding theforegoing.

Edit SC Johnson retention letterfor News case; conference with G.Grunbaum and S. Berry regardingthe foregoing.

Conference with G. Grunbaum, C.Signorello, D. Shaw, and S. Berryregarding News case call; reviewSC Johnson spend figures;conference with D. Shaw regardingHeinz engagement letter.

Page 24

.25

.25

.75

.25

.00

.75

.00



03/12/12

03/13/12

03/14/12

03/15/12

03/16/12

03/19/12

03/19/12

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

S FB

DAN

Reviese Heinz retention letter forNews case.

Finalize demand letter to News andtolling agreement; conference callwith G. Grunbaum, C. Signorello,D. Shaw, and S. Berry; reviseengagement letter for Heinz.

Finalize and send tollingagreement and request formediation to News General Counsel,L. Manzo and President Mixson;copy set to clients.

Send e-mails to potentialadditional companies to join case(Schwans, Barilla, DelMonte,Colgate-Palmolive, Pepsi Co., andNovarris)

Conference with J. Liebling(Barilla) regarding standstill;conference with L. Manzo (NewsAssistant General counsel)regarding tolling and standstillagreement; conference with clientsand S. Berry regarding Newsresponse; conference with M.Richards, assistant to R. Wulf(mediator), send mediationmaterials to F. Greenfield atCampbell soup.

Conferences with C. Signorelloregarding Dial trade spend;conference with D. Shaw regardingHeinz 2011 trade spend; researchRoll Global (potential client);conference with D. Bock regardingSchwann's participation; revisememorandum on severability of jurytrial waiver clause in some Newscontracts; finalize and senddocument retention notices andcommon interest agreement toclients.

Draf t memorandum regarding theeffect of contractual waivers of

Page 25

0.

0.

1

1.

2.

2

2

25

75

.00

00

00

00

.25


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379



03/20/12

03/20/12

03/21/12

03/22/12

03/22/12

03/23/12

03/23/12

03/24/12

SFB

DAN

S FB

S FB

DAN

S FB

DAN

DAN

August 1, 2014

treble damages.

Research treble damages and jurywaiver contract issues for clientmemoranda; library researchregarding the foregoing;conference with J. Metzker (expertfrom ApplEcon); edit PowerPointdemand presentation.

Research and draft memorandum oncontractual waivers of jury trial;edit case summary presentationslide deck for S.C. Johnson.

Conferences with S. Berry and D.Navikas; library reserach; revisejury waiver memorandum; editdamages Power Point for mediationwith News; compile Henkel and Dialtrade spend numbers; review Henkeland Dial contacts.

Library research; edit jury waiverand treble damages memoranda forclients; review Henkel and Dialcontracts; send standbill andtolling agreement and letter tocounsel for Pfizer and Schwan's.

Cite-check and revise memorandumregarding treble damages waiver;research and draft memorandum onwaiver of jury trial.

Edit jury waiver memorandum forclients; prepare for SC Johnsonmeeting; conferences with D.Navikas and S. Berry; reviewclient contracts.

Research advisory jury asapplicable to co-plaintiffs withvarying rights to jury trial.

Research advisory jury asapplicable to co-plaintiffs withvarying rights to jury trial;revise memo on contractual waiversof jury trial.

Page 26

2.00

5.00

2

1.

10

1.

0.

3.

.75

75

.25

50

75

25



03/25/12 SFB

03/25/12 DAN

03/26/12 SFB

03/27/12 SFB

03/27/12 DAN

03/28/12 SFB

03/28/12 DAN

03/29/12 SFB

Revise presentation for SCJohnson; review competitor casetranscripts; travel fromWashington, DC to Chicago with S.Berry.

Research advisory jury asapplicable to co-plaintiffs withvarying rights to jury trial;revise memo on contractual waiversof jury trial.

Meet with G. Grunbaum, L. Crowley(SC Johnson General Counsel) at SCJohnson in Racine, Wisconsin withS. Berry; review Floorgraphicspleadings for Mayer Brown counsel;conferences with D. Shaw and C.Signorello regarding scheduling;update memos on jury waiver andtreble damages.

Prepare for meeting withHenkel/Dial with C. Signorello;update jury waiver and tabledamages memoranda for clients;conference with D. Navikasregarding research.

Research class conflict andrepresentation of opt-plaintiffs as well as

outclass.

Meet with C. Signorello (assistantGeneral Counsel Henkel/Dial) andS. Berry; conferences with L.Manzo (News General Counsel)regarding standstill, tolling, andmediation; edit response to L.Manzo; send materialsButterball counsel.

to

Revise stand~still agreement.

Revise response to News and L.Manzo; conferences with D. Shaw,C. Signorello, and G.regarding coordinatedNews; Conference withregarding Heinz spendmeet with R. Grossman

Grunbaumresponse toD. Shawinformation;(Butterball

Page 27

4.75

4.00

6.25

2.00

5.00

3.00

0.50

2.25


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


03/30/12

03/31/12

04/02/12

04/02/12

04/03/12

04/03/12

04/04/12

04/04/12

04/05/12

04/10/12

SFB

SFB

SFB

DAN

S FB

DAN

S FB

DAN

DAN

S FB

counsel), review S. Scottdeposition transcript.

Church & Dwight research; reviewS. Scott transcript; conferencecall with D. Shaw, S. Berry, andS. Scott regarding trade spend.

Edit SC Johnson demand letter toNews; conference with S. Berry.

Edit SC Johnson demand letter callto L. Manzo regarding NewsAgreement to tolling andstandstill; circulate News editsto tolling standstill.

Research conflict of intereststandard for class counsel; revisedraft SCJ demand letter.

Conference with C. Signorelloregarding Dial demand to News;circulate L. Manzo, News responseand rejection of mediation; reviewand circulate Butterballstandstill and tolling agreementsas sent to News; edit SC Johnsondemand letter; conference with D.Navikas regarding the foregoing.

Researchstandard

confclit of interestfor class counsel.

Execute standstill and tollingagreements; send the same to L.Manzo; send the foregoing toclients.

ResearchStandard

Researchstandard

Conflict of interestfor class counsel.

conf clit of interestfor class counsel.

Conference with G. Grunbaumregarding SC Johnson demand onNews; conference with D. Shawregarding Heinz demand on Newsnegotiation strategy.

Page 28

and

.25

.75

.75

.00

.00

.75

.00

.50

.50

.00


August 1, 2014Invoice # 2008217379



04/11/12 SFB

August 1, 2014et al. V. News America Invoice # 2008217379

Conference with D. Shaw regarding 1.00trade spend and FSI-instorepercentages; send Butterballstandstill agreement to clients;conference with C. Signorelloregarding Dial demand; send casesummary materials to M. Forrest(Barilla General Counsel)

Conference with D. Shaw and S.

04/12/12

04/13/12

SFB

SFB

Send damages e-mail to ConAgracounsel (L. Knowles)~

04/16/12 SFB

04/18/12 SFB

04/20/12 SFB

04/20/12 DAN

Berry regarding Heinz damages;review and circulate News legalthreat article.

Prepare power point presentationregarding Heinzconference withBerry regarding

Conference call

damages;D. Shaw and S.the foregoing.

with D. Shaw, M.Testa, and S. Berry regardingHeinz damages and counter offer;research class representationissues and cases; conference withD. Navikas regarding theforegoing; sendto S. Berry.

Edit SC Johnson

summary analysis

demand letter toNews; conference with G. Grunbaumregarding the foregoing; call withHeinz (D. Shaw and others)regarding settlement demand;conference with C. Signorelloregarding Henkel demand amount.

Conference call with Heinz, S.Benz and S. Berry.

04/21/12

04/23/12

SFB

SFB

Send e-mails to D. Bock (Schwans)and M. Forrest (Biersdorf)regarding potential par ticipation;edit and send Heinz draft firstdemand to D. Shaw.

Revise SC Johnson demand letter;conference with S. Berry and G.Grunbaum regarding the foregoing.

Page 29

0.25

1.00

1.75

1.00

2.00

0.75

1.00

1.25


04/24/12

04/26/12

04/30/12

05/02/12

05/02/12

05/03/12

05/04/12

05/11/12

05/13/12

05/14/12

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

DAN

S FB

S FB

S FB

S FB

SFB

Conferences with G. Grunbaum andS. Berry; edit and finalize SCJohnson letter to News; conferencewith R. Grossman regarding theforegoing; conference with C.Signorello regarding Dial demand.

Finalize and send Henkel-Dialdemand letter.

Conference with D. Shaw; editHeinz demand letter; circulateNews scandal article to G.Grunbaum, C. Signorello, and D.Shaw; send News hacking article toBarilla, ConAgra, Glaxo,SmithKlein, Roll Corp. and DelMonte.

Research representation issues;conference with D. Navikas;conference with L. Manzo and S.Berry regarding News response todemand letters; conference with G.Grunbaum, C. Signorello, and D.Shaw regarding response to L.Manzo; discussion of News demandto Barilla, Proctor & Gamble andG. Curtner.

Revise memo on class conflict toreflect Newberg research.

Meet with S. Berry and R. Sutton(Bentham Capital).

Circulate News hacking ar ticle toclients.

Review and circulate News responseto demand letter.

Review and circulate Newsresponses to demand from SCJohnson, Heinz, and Heinkel-Dial;conference with s. Berry regardingthe foregoing.

Conferences with G. Grunbaum, C.Signorello, and D. Shaw regarding

Page 30

1.00

1.00

2.00

2.00

3.75

1.00

0.25

0.75

1.00

0.50

SC JohnsonHenkel/Dial, et al. V. News America

August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


05/15/12

05/16/12

05/22/12

05/23/12

05/24/12

05/26/12

05/29/12

05/29/12

05/30/12

05/30/12

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

SFB

DAN

S FB

DAN

News rejection of separate clientdemands.

Conference with K. Mazio(Campbell's Soup).

Review tolling agreement;conference with K. Mazio (CampbellSoup) and Barbara Sopko;conferences with clients regardingNews demands; check tollingagreement.

Conference with G. Grunbaum and S.Berry regarding response strategy.

Conferences with P. Shaw, G.Grunbaum, and C. Signorelloregarding response to News; draftresponse to News; conference withB. Subkow (Campbell Soup).

Separate conferences with D. Shaw,G. Grunbaum, and C. Signorelloregarding response to News;conference with R. Grossman; callto K. Miazzo (Campbells' Soup).

Edit SC Johnson counter-offer toNews; conferences with G. Grunbaumand S. Berry regarding theforeqoing.

Conference with C. Signorello andS. Berry; conference with R.Grossman regarding Butterball;corporate class representativeresearch.

Research antitrust class inactions in which the classrepresentative was a corporation.

Conference with K. Mazzeo(Campbells Soup), conference withG. Grunhaum regarding Newscounter-offer; counter-offerdiscussions with D. Shaw, S.Berry, and D. Navikas.

Review status of negotiations;

Page 31

.25

.00

.50

.00

.00

.50

.00

.00

.00

.50


August 1 2014Invoice # 2008217379


exhibit 7 part 2 of 9 - kcc class actionclassaction.kccllc.net/documents/nwd0001/576-8 -...

Documents