exhibits in patterson ethics report, pt 2

8/2/2019 Exhibits in Patterson ethics report, Pt 2

1/96

EXHIBIT 13


2/96

Declaration of Representative Amanda Reeve

I, Amanda Reeve, hereby declare:

1. I am a Republican member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the"House"), I have been a member of the House since 2010, I represent Legislative District 6.

2. Unless otherwise stated herein, I make this Declaration based on my personalknowledge and/or observations.

3. I am presently a member of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee andHigher Education. Innovation and Reform Committee. and serve as the Chairman of theEnvironment Committee.

4. I have had many interactions with Representative Daniel Patterson and observedhim interact with constituents, other legislators. and staff members.

5. I have personally observed Representative Daniel Patterson display a pattern ofdisorderly, aggressive, unprofessional, counterproductive, and disrespectful conduct that isinconsistent with the professional atmosphere at the Legislature.

6. On March 17, 20 I0, I witnessed Representative Patterson impugn Senator Pearceduring a presentation on legislation proposed by former Senator Pearce in a Military Affairs andPublic Safety ("MAPS") Committee hearing during which Representative Patterson wasaggressive, red faced, and extremely worked up. Representative Patterson refused to calmdown despite Chairman Weiers' several warnings, Representative Patterson eventually stormedout of the Committee hearing and was subsequently removed from the Committee.

7. On February 6, 2012, during a meeting of the ENR Committee, RepresentativePatterson and I had a discussionconcerning some legislation he was supporting before theCommittee.

8. Following adjournment of the hearing, as I gathered my materials to leave thecommittee hearing room. Representative Patterson stepped in front of me, blocking me from

080


3/96

exiting the hearing room, He drew uncomfortably close to me and asked whether Iwould hearhis bill. When he continued to block my path, I walked directly for the exit door, Only whenhe saw that I was determined to move past him, and I explained for the second time that I WJ!llate for another appointment, did he step slightly aside to let me pass,

9. The next day, on the floor Representative Patterson approached me and asked meagain if I would hear his bill, During this conversation Representative Patterson wasuncomfortably close to me and when I attempted to leave the conversation he obstructed mypath.

J O . The following week, Representative Patterson approached me on the I-louse floorto again ask if I was going to hear his bill. "When I declined to do so he became agitated andstated that I "had no integrity."

11. I regard Representative Patterson's behavior toward me after the cornmittee :hearing and on the two occasions on the House floor-which is detailed in paragraphs 8throughlO-as unprof essional and discourteous. I believe that in each of these instances I gave

. Representative Patterson a fair opportunity to explain his position and only sought to end theconversations after they became unproductive, or I had to leave for another appointment.

Dated this t't day of March, 2012_

DB041J 59M327 ,1


4/96

, EXHIBIT 14


5/96

Declaration of Representative David Gowan

I, David Gowan, hereby declare:

1. I am a member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the "House"). 1 havebeen a member of the House since 2009. I represent Legislative District 30.


J. I am presently a member of the Government Committee and Military Affairs andPublic Safety ("MAPS") Committee.

4. On March 17, 2010, at a MAPS hearing, I witnessed Representative Pattersonimpugn former Senator Pearce in connection with SB1027. Representative Patterson disagreedwith the bill and became increasingly angry and inappropriately aggressive toward formerSenator Pearce as he testified about SBI027. Even though Chairman Weiers attempted to gaveldown Representative Patterson in attempt to stop his inappropriate behavior, RepresentativePatterson refused to heed Chairman Weiers' warnings. As a result of this incident and others,Representative Patterson was removed from the MAPS Committee.

S. In another incident around February 20, 2010. Representative Patterson came tomy office to see if 1 would hear a certain bill he sponsored regarding bicycles. I toldRepresentative Patterson that I was not inclined to have the Committee heal' it. My decisionupset Representative Patterson so he proceeded to badger me for several minutes to try tochange my mind. He became louder and tried to intimidate mc. Whcn he found out he couldn'tintimidate me he backed down. After the disagreement, Representative Patterson approachedm e at lunch and apologized.

6. On another occasion in early March 2012, as I exited the Caucus hearing room 1overheard part of a heated exchange between Representative Patterson and Representative Jerry

I )U 0 3 /. /9 8 0 92 J 4 .1


6/96

Representative David Gowan

Weiers, I could hear Representative Patterson shouting at Representative Weiers from the endof the hallway,

7 . Based on my observations and interactions with Representative Patterson, I find :. tha t sometimes Representative Patterson ha s failed to observe the most basic standards ofmember etiquette and decorum. On occasion, he has behaved aggressively and unprofessionallytoward other members.

1Q ~ h .DATED this6J_da y of March, 2012.

DBO J/ .I 9 8( )9 2 H I


7/96

EXHIBIT 15


8/96


9/96

EXHIBIT 16


10/96

Declaration of Representative Ruben Gallego

I, Ruben Gallego, hereby declare:L I am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the

"House"). I have been a member of the House since 2011. I represent Legislative District 16.2. Unless otherwise stated herein, I make this Declaration based on my personal

knowledge andlor observations.3. I am presently a member of the Agriculture and Water Committee, Military

Affairs and Public Safety Committee, and Ways and Means Committee.4. I have had many personal interactions with Representative Patterson and observedhim interact with constituents, other legislators, and staff members.5; . I have personally observed Representative Patterson display a pattern of

disorderly, mean-spirited, aggressive, unprofessional, counterproductive, intimidating, anddisrespectful conduct that, at minimum, violated the House's Code of Conduct.

6. Most recently for example, I witnessed, on two separate occasions,Representative Patterson act in an inappropriate and aggressive manner toward RepresentativeReeve on the House floor. The first occasion I witnessed from a distance. RepresentativePatterson approached Representative Reeve and appeared to intentionally bump into her in anaggressive and otherwise intimidating manner. Representative Patterson appeared tointentionally invade Representative Reeve's personal space. On a separate occasion, whilesitting at .rny desk on the House floor, I overheard Representative Patterson get verballyaggressive with Representative Reeve and angrily tell her she had "no integrity." Thisexchange caused me to stop what I was otherwise doing to ask Representative Reeve what thatwas about and apologize for Representative Patterson's actions. In my opinion his acts againstRepresentative Reeve were intentional and confrontational.

7. I witnessed Representative Patterson get angry with Representative Pancrazi andturn red in a closed Democratic Caucus meeting.

DB041 .159815 r 8. 1


11/96

8. Inmy opinion Representative Patterson has an inability to let issues gowhen he isworked up or otherwise angry.

9. Following the latest allegations against Representative Patterson and seeing whatIelieve to be a pattern of intimidating actions against female Representatives, r asked female.Representatives who sit next to Representative Patterson on the House floor if they wanted tochange seats with me.

10. I have concerns for the safety of others and have requested additional security be.enforced and have sometime brought m y weapon to work.

1 L My personal observations of Representative Patterson have led me to concludethat Representative Patterson has engaged in a long pattern of disorderly and unprofessionalmisconduct that reflects poorly on himself, his party, the House, th e State of Arizona, and worstof all, those who elected Representative Patterson to office.

DATED this l1lL day of March, 2012.

2DB04 1 J 5 9 8 J 5 J 8 . r


12/96

EXHIBIT 17


13/96

Declaration ofRepresentative Anna Tovar

I, Anna Tovar, hereby declare:1, I am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the

"House") and serve as Minority Whip, I have been a member of the House since 2009, Irepresent Legislative District 13.


3. I am presently a member of the House Appropriations Committee, EducationCommittee, Judiciary Committee, and Sub Appropriations on Multi Year BudgetingCommittee,

4. When I first began my tenure at the Legislature others cautioned me aboutRepresentative Daniel Patterson, stating "watch out for Daniel" and describing RepresentativePatterson as one who is known to "fly off the handle."

5. I have had many personal interactions with Representative Patterson and observedhim interact with constituents, other legislators, and staff members.

6. I have personally observed Representative Patterson display a pattern ofdisorderly, mean-spirited, aggressive, unprofessional, counterproductive, intimidating, anddisrespectful conduct that, at minimum, violated the House's Code of Conduct

7. For example, on March 29, 2011, after a closed caucus meeting adjourned, Iwitnessed Representative Patterson in a heated discussion with Representative Steve Farley, Irecall that Representative Bruce Wheeler was also present during this heated discussion. I wasstanding about 4-5 feet away from the heated discussion and recall that Representative Wheelerwas trying to pull Representative Patterson away from Representative Farley. Eventually,Representative Wheeler walked away, but Representative Patterson continued to exchangewords with Representative Farley, At that time, I was trying to get through the aisle, I was

DB04/832887.0002/602482&.1 PF06


14/96

about 3 feet behind Representative Farley, and I heard Representative Patterson state toRepresentative Farley that he should stop spreading lies about Representative Patterson.Representative Patterson continued that, if Representative Farley did not stop spreading liesabout Representative Patterson, Representative Farley would regret his actions. This commentappeared to cause Representative Farley concern. Representative Patterson's tone anddemeanor (finger pointing) was intimidating, quite shocking to witness and, in my opinion,scary. Based on my observation of this incident, I took Representative Patterson's comments toRepresentative Farley as a verbal threat. In fact, I was so alarmed by Representative Patterson'sconduct that, after I witnessed this incident, I made notes of what I had observed. A true andcorrect copy of my Incident Notes is attached at Exhibit A.

8. On another occasion, in April, 2011, during a floor debate, there was a veryheated discussion between Representative Patterson and Representative Eddie Farnsworth. Iobserved the two of them go toward the back of the House chambers to have this heateddiscussion. This discussion quickly deteriorated and, as the only member of the HouseDemocratic leadership on the floor at the time, I had to address Representative Patterson'sconduct. During this same debate, Representative Patterson also acted combatively and veryunprofessionally toward Representative Lynne Pnacrazi by raising his voice at, and.pointing hisfinger toward, her. Speaker of the House, Representative Kirk Adams, informed me thatRepresentative Patterson had become out of control and he was considering removingRepresentative Patterson from the House floor. Because the custom,. with regard toRepresentative Patterson, is to always speak with him with at least one other witness present, Ihad the Chief of Staff locate Representative Patterson so we could speak with him about hismisconduct. Typical of Representative Patterson when confronted with his behavioraloutbursts, he denied doing anything inappropriate and appeared not to understand why hismisconduct was inappropriate. We convinced Representative Patterson to leave thefloor.

OB04 /832887.0002 / 6 024828 .1 PF06


15/96

the House floor following a meeting of the Environment Committee. Afterwards,9. Approximately two and a half weeks ago, Representative Amanda Reeve wason

Representative Patterson walked up to Representative Reeve, very upset, confronted her aboutallegedly holding up his bill, and then stormed off. I consider Representative Patterson'sconduct in this regard disorderly, unprofessional,and nothing short of a verbal assault onRepresentative Reeve. Having witnessed the interaction, on behalf of the Democratic Caucus, Iapologized to Representative Reeve for Representative Patterson's misconduct.

10. Others have expressed to me fears for their personal safety with regard toRepresentative Patterson and have told. me they consider Representative Patterson out ofcontrol.

11. On February 27, 2012, at approximately 7:02 p.m., Representative Patterson leftme a voice mail wherein he apologized for "all this BS going on" and stated that he has "beenfearful" for his "safety." I consider this voice mail a part of Representative Patterson's patternof refusing to take responsibility for his actions.

12. As a member of House Democratic leadership, I can say that the DemocraticHouse members are routinely having to apologize for Representative Patterson's actions anddisorderly conduct In fact, Democratic leadership has had many meetings to discuss how toaddress and handle Representative Patterson's misconduct toward his fellow House membersand constituents.

IJ. My personal observations of Representative Patterson have led me to conclude..that Representative Patterson has engaged in a long pattern of disorderly and unprofessional.misconduct that reflects poorly on himself, his party, the House, the State of Arizona, and worstof all, those who elected Representative Patterson to office.

DATED this _30_ day of March, 2012.

Representative Anna Tovar

D804/832887.0002/6024828.1 PF06


16/96

EXHIBIT 18 .


17/96

Declaration of Representative Bruce Wheeler

I, Bruce Wheeler, hereby declare:1. I am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the

"House"). I have been a member of the House since 2011. I represent Legislative District 28. Ihave also previously served in the House from 1975 through 1977.


3. I am presently a member of the Energy and Natural Resources ("ENR")Committee and Technology and Infrastructure Committee.

4. I have had many personal interactions with Representative Daniel Patterson andobserved him interact with constituents, other legislators, and staff members.

5. I have personally observed Representative Patterson display a pattern ofdisorderly, mean-spirited, aggressive, unprofessional, counterproductive, and disrespectfulconduct that, I believe, violated the House's Code of Conduct.

6. For example, during an ENR hearing on February 14, 201 I, RepresentativePatterson introduced a bill, HB2122, but had failed to obtain a fiscal note for the bill. When Iquestioned whether he had obtained a fiscal note, he responded in the negative. RepresentativePatterson proceeded to glare at me during the remainder of the hearing. After the hearing,Representative Patterson followed me to my office where we engaged in a heated discussion.Representative Patterson was extremely angry with me because I questioned the bill.Representative Patterson became red in the face and raised his voice at me.

7. On another occasion at an ENR hearing on February 13, 2012, RepresentativePatterson inappropriately intimated that Chairman Frank Pratt had a conflict of interestregarding HB2775, a bill about swimming pool pumps, which Chairman Pratt sponsored.Representative Patterson essentially cross-examined Chairman Pratt during the committee

DB03/ . f9809199,[


18/96


19/96

'

11. Representative Patterson has constantly displayed behavior that is arrogant anddelusional. Representative Patterson tells me what he thinks I want to hear. For example, afterthe allegations concerning Ms. Escobar began to surface, Representative Patterson asked to talkto me in private. He assured me that nothing had occurred between him and Ms. Escobar. Yet,within days, the media released a police report where the incident was confirmed and showedotherwise.

I2. Other members of the House have refused to meet with Representative Pattersonalone for fear of their safety. For example, Representative Farley asked me to be an arbiter andsit in a meeting between him and Representative Patterson. I agreed, but the meeting neveroccurred.

13.. '. My personal observations of Representative Patterson have led me to concludethat he is ineffective, an embarrassmentto the caucus, and has engaged in a long pattern ofdisorderly and unprofessional misconduct that reflects poorly on himself, his party, the House,the State of Arizona, and worst of all, those who elected Representative Patterson to office.

Dated this 2 : 1 _ day of March, 2012.L/Iau(~

Representative Bruce Wheeler

D BO JIJ 9M 09 19 9 .1


20/96


21/96

Declaration ofRepresentative Macario Saldate IV

I, Macario Saldate IV, hereby declare:1. 1 am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the

"House"): I have been a member of the House since 2011. I represent Legislative District 27.2. Unless otherwise stated herein, I make this Declaration based on my personal

knowledge and/or observations.3. I am presently a member of the Energy and Natural Resources ("ENR")

Committee and Higher Education, Innovation and Reform Committee.4. I have had many personal interactions with Representative Daniel Patterson and

observed him interact with constituents, other legislators, and staff members.5. I have personally observed Representative Patterson display a pattern of


6. For example, at an ENR hearing on February 14,2011, Representative Patterson.became visibly upset and angry when Representative Wheeler and I questioned one of his bills.Representative Patterson was incensed when Representative Wheeler asked whetherRepresentative Patterson had obtained a fiscal note on the bill. Representative Patterson said noand glared at Representative Wheeler. After the hearing, he followed us into RepresentativeWheeler's.roffice, He raised his voice at Representative Wheeler and became extremelyaggressive and red in the face. I thought to myself, this could be a situation where theconfrontation could become physical.

7. Also on February 17,2012, Ms. Escobar called me and told me to watch my backand be careful because Representative Patterson might get physical with me. She also told methat Representative Patterson accused me of being racist because I had previously told

OB031.19809140.1


22/96

Representative Patterson that he might have trouble securing the Mexican-American vote incertain southern legislative districts.

8. During a more recent telephone call, Ms. Escobar told me that RepresentativePatterson had hit her, had weapons in the home they were sharing, and had a short temper. Ms.Escobar shared concerning information about the well-being and safety of RepresentativePatterson's daughter.

9. After my conversation with Ms. Escobar, I informed the Speaker of the House,Representative Andy Tobin, about my concerns. Representative Tobin requested Imake areport to Capitol Police, which I did, and thereafter security was tightened at the Capito] for aperiod of time.

.10. 1have confronted Representative Patterson about his behavior, and RepresentativePatterson simply denies that he has done anything wrong.

1L M y personal observations of Representative Patterson have led me to concludethat he is disingenuous, constantly putting on a facade, and has engaged in a long pattern ofdisorderly and unprofessional misconduct that reflects poorly on himself, his party, the House,the State of Arizona, and worst of all, those who elected Representative Patterson to office.

1 f ADated this _2j_ day of March, 2 0 1 2 .

D8031.198091 IjQ. 1


23/96

EXHIBIT 20


24/96

Declaration of Representative Sally Ann Gonzales

I, Sally Ann Gonzales, hereby declare:1. I am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the

"House"). 1 have been a member of the House since 2011. I represent Legislative District 27. Ihave also previously served in the House from 1996 through 2000.


3. I am presently a member of the Employment and Regulatory Affairs Committee,Health and Human Services Committee, and Technology and Infrastructure Committee.

4. I have had many personal interactions with Representative Daniel Patterson andobserved him interact with constituents, other legislators, and staff members.

5. I have personally observed Representative Patterson display a pattern ofdisorderly, mean-spirited, aggressive, unprofessional, counterproductive, intimidating, anddisrespectful conduct that, at minimum, violated the House's Code of Conduct.

6. For example, in Spring of last year, I witnessed Representative Patterson initiate aheated discussion with Representatives Wheeler and Saldate following an Energy and NaturalResources Committee hearing. I could hear Representative Patterson yelling and shoutingthrough the walls of my office.

7. Also during a closed caucus last session, I witnessed Representative Pattersonbecome angry and upset toward Representative Pancrazi after Representative Pancrazi broughtup the domestic violence allegations against Representative Patterson. He spoke loudly, wavedhis arms up and down, and accused Representative Pancrazi of not knowing what she wastalking about. At one point, I thought he would jump out of his chair toward Representative. Pancrazi. Ialso saw Representative Farley try to stop Representative Patterson from yelling at

D804/832887.0002/6025645.1 PF06


25/96

8. I have also witnessed Representative Patterson exhibit loud and passionatebehavior on the floor.

Representative Pancrazi, but Representative Farley was unable to stop Representative Patterson.The whole incident felt like it lasted at least five minutes.

9. After learning that Representative Patterson owned guns, I became worried aboutthe safety> of all Members. On February 17, 2012, Representative Saldate told me that Ms ..Escobar requested that he tell Representative Patterson that she was staying at RepresentativeSaldate's property in Guadalajara, Mexico. I expressed my concern that Representative Saldateshould contact the proper authorities and Ibecame concerned for his safety.

10. More recently, 1poke to Representative Patterson at length the day he came backto the House after the ethics complaint was filed. Representative Patterson told me thateverything in the media was all "lies." Based on my intuition and prior observations ofRepresentative Patterson, I had doubts about what he said.

11. My personal observations of Representative Patterson have led me to concludethat Representative Patterson has engaged in a long pattern of disorderly and unprofessionalmisconduct that reflects poorly on himself, his party, the House, the State of Arizona, and worstof all, those who elected Representative Patterson to office.

Dated this 30th day of March. 2012. //111Representative Sally Ann Gonzales ---

DB 0 4 /8 3 2 8 87 .0 0 0 2 /6 0 2 56 4 5. 1 P F0 6


26/96

EXHIBIT 21


27/96

Declaration ofRepresentative Margaret "Lynne" Pancrazi

I, Margaret "Lynne" Pancrazi, hereby declare:1. I am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the

"House"). I have been a member of the House since 2007. I represent Legislative District 24.2. . Unless otherwise stated herein, I make this Declaration based on my personal

knowledge andlor observations.3. I am presently a member of the House Agriculture and Water Committee,

EducationCommittee, and Employment and Regulatory Affairs Committee.4. r have had many personal interactions with Representative Daniel Patterson and

observed him interact with constituents, other legislators, and staff members.5. I have personally observed Representative Patterson display a pattern of


6. As Tbegan my tenure as a Representative, I had a productive relationship withRepresentative Patterson and would often give h im rides because we lived in close proximityand he rode his bike everywhere.

7. In the spring of 20 10, I become aware of media reports regarding Ms. JeneieneSchaffer's. domestic violence allegations against Representative Patterson. Concerned that aMember of the House was accused of such a serious matter, I raised my concerns in a closedHouse Democratic Caucus meeting. During this discussion, Representative Patterson becameextremely defensive, angry, belligerent, and directed his anger at me by loudly screaming "Youdo not know what you are talking about" and that I was "uninformed." He invaded my personalspace and got in my face during this discussion. Representative Farley attempted to interjectand diffuse Representative Patterson's anger; however, Representative Patterson pushed

D8041159&4195 . [


28/96

Representative Farley away and continued his tirade against me. Representative Pattersonattempted to threaten and intimidate me, but I refused to back down.

8. Now, as a result of the pattern of Representative Patterson'saggressive behaviorand after having been the subject of one of his outbursts, I go out of my way to avoidinteractions with him and use e-mail whenever possible to avoid confrontations or engagementswith him. This approach is contrary to how I deal with other members because m y personalphilosophy is to directly confront all matters with those impacted and not back down from anyissue.

9. 1have often described Representative Patterson as "Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde" as aresult of his unpredictable mood changes from calm to explosive. For example, I have observedRepresentative Patterson act ina manner intended to intentionally intimidate those with whomhe disagrees, or otherwise does not get along, based on his facial expressions and changes in hisvoice which are distinctively different when he is angry.

10. I observed Representative Patterson engage in inappropriate actions on the Housefloor in which I believe he crossed the line of impugning another Representative.

11. I believe Representative Patterson is paranoid due to all the recent events, mostrecently exemplified at a legislative luncheon during which I was conversing with a fellowmember through handwritten notes regarding the quality of the food, yet asIooked up and sawRepresentative Patterson, he was glaring at us because he clearly thought we were exchangingnotes about him.

12. I have observed Representative Patterson engage in heated discussions anddebates with other Representatives to a level I consider inappropriate and disrespectful. Ibelieve that Representative Patterson engages in actions intended to bully and intimidate thosewi th whom he interacts.

13. I have heard allegations from others that Representative Patterson has gotten intopeople's faces and threatened those that he does not like and that many are known to avoid himlike the plague.

DB 0 41 ./ 59 ~ 41 9 5 . 1


29/96

14. I have requested that Representative Patterson resign from the House based on hisconduct and the allegations made against him.

15. Other members and I fear for our safety. For example, following the filing of theethics complaint, I returned to my home and found the front door and screen door swung open.Based on the timing of this occurrence and the fact that Mr. Patterson and I shared the samelandlord and used to live in close proximity to each other, that night and since, 1 have made a .habit of keeping a weapon near me when I sleep.

16. Along with other members, I fear for my safety at the Capitol and have requestedadditional security. I have also escorted other members to their vehicles after hours.

17. My personal observations of and interactions with Representative Patterson haveled me to conclude that Representative Patterson has engaged in a long pattern of disorderly andunprofessional misconduct that reflects poorly on himself, his party, the House, the State ofArizona, and worst of all, those who elected Representative Patterson to office.

DATED thi~ day of March, 2012.

DB041 . 15984 J 9 5. J


30/96

EXHIBIT 22


31/96

Declaration of Representative Katie Hobbs

1 . Katie Hobbs, hereby declare:

L I am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the"House"), I have been a member ofthe House since 2011. I represent Legislative District 15.


3. I am presently a member of the Government Committee, Health and HumanServices Committee, and Transportation Committee.

4. I bring a unique perspective to the House by virtue of being a professional social. worker since 1992. I have been an advocate for domestic violence victims for at least It years.

5. In the fall of 2010, r became aware of Ms. Schaffer's domestic violenceallegations against Representative Patterson. When I learned that Ms. Escobar had also madedomestic violence allegations against Representative Patterson, I became concerned thatRepresentative Patterson was not being held accountable for his actions.

6. In the spring of 2011, following a caucus meeting, J witnessed RepresentativePatterson and Representative Farley engage in a heated shouting match. RepresentativePatterson had turned bright red and was yelling and screaming at Representative Farley. I wasunable to determine the Cause of this fierce disagreement, but Representative Patterson got rightinto Representative Farley's face with complete disregard for Representative Farley's personalspace.

7. In addition to the incident with Representative Farley, in April 2011 while on thefloor, Representative Patterson impugned the character of another member who sponsored aparticular bill. Representative Farnsworth called for a point of order, which angeredRepresentative Patterson even more. Representative Patterson approached Representative

DHIlJU


32/96

Farnsworth afterward to justify himself, but I interpreted the manner in which he approachedRepresentative Farnsworth as intimidating and threatening.

8 . Based on Representative Patterson's past behavior, I am concerned for mypersonal safety as well as the safety of my fellow members. Ihave been told thatRepresentative Patterson is a gun owner.

9. Because of Representative Patterson's pattern of erratic behavior and failure tothink about the consequences of his actions, Iook the lead in filing the ethics complaint againsthim.

10. After I filed the ethics complaint, Representative Patterson attempted to broker aquid pro quo with me. He told me that if I withdrew the ethics complaint, he would "considernot running again." Representative Patterson then further threatened me and said that.because itis an election year, the ethics complaint will. make the Democratic caucus look bad, I respondedthat this was not about making the Democratic caucus look good or bad, but that this was aboutholding him accountable for the pattern of domestic violence allegations against him and thepattern or his unethical behavior in the Legislature. Representative Patterson admitted to methat he has problems with his temper and that he is "working on it."

11. My personal observations of Representative Patterson have led me to concludethat Representative Patterson has engaged in a long pattern of disorderly and unprofessionalmisconduct that reflects poorly On himself, his party, the House, the State of Arizona, and worstof all, those who elected Representative Patterson to office.

DATED this 1 ) day of March, 2012.

DB03f .19809209 .1


33/96

EXHIBIT 23


34/96

Declaration of Representative Lela Alston

I, Lela Alston, hereby declare:1. T am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the

"House"). I have been a member of the House since 2011. I represent Legislative District 15. Ihave also previously served in the Legislature from 1977 until 1995.

. 2. Unless otherwise stated herein, I make this Declaration based on my personalknowledge and/or observations.

3. I am presently on the Appropriations Committee, Commerce Committee,Environment Committee, and the Sub Appropriations on Multi-Year Budgeting Committee.

4. I have had limited personal interactions with Representative Daniel Pattersonbecause when I first began my most recent tenure at the Legislature, others cautioned me aboutRepresentative Patterson's aggressive tendencies and behavior.

5. I have heard that Representative Patterson has engaged in inappropriateinteractions with other members that I believe, if true, were inappropriate and have caused me tofear for other members' safety.

6. Based on my personal observations, I believe Representative Patterson ispassionate, intimidating, and inappropriately forceful in his arguments.

Dated this . J i i day of March, 2012.

0904//5984325.1


35/96

EXHIBIT24


36/96

Declaration of Representative Tom Chabin

1,Tom Chabin, hereby declare:I. 1 am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the

"Bouse"). 1have been a member of the House since 2007. I represent Legislative District 2.2. Unless otherwise stated herein, I make this Declaration based on my personal

knowledge and/or observations.3. 1 am presently a member of the Higher Education, Innovation and Reform

Committee, the Judiciary Committee, the Rules Committee, and the Ways and MeansCommittee.

4. I have had many personal interactions with Representative Daniel Patterson andobserved him iriteraet with constituents, other legislators, and staff members. I have consideredRepresentative Patterson a friend and have had him as a guest in my home. Prior to the filing ofthe ethics complaint against Representative Patterson, I had several civil interactions with him.

5. However, I have also personally observed Representative Patterson display apattern of disorderly, mean-spirited, aggressive, unprofessional, counterproductive,intimidating, and disrespectful conduct that, at minimum, violated the House's Code ofConduct.

6. For example, based on my Concerns over Representative Patterson's inappropriatebehaviors, I prepared an ethics complaint against him in May 20 II, in which I was prepared toask the House Ethics Committee to investigate Representative Patterson's violation of theHouse Rules, specifically Rule I regarding disorderly behavior and breach of the House Rules.A copy of the draft complaint is attached asExhibit A (the "Complaint").

7. As set forth in the draft Complaint, my concerns over Representative Patterson'sbehavior were based upon a pattern of inappropriate behavior, beginning with his criminal

DB 0 4 /. fS 9 8 4J 1 2 .]


37/96

history and specific inappropriate encounters with other Representatives, includingRepresentative Farley and Representative Farnsworth.

8. Because of the concerns of those involved in the altercations with RepresentativePatterson, I ultimately chose not to file the Complaint

9. Since drafting the Complaint, I have become aware of two additional altercationsinvolving Representative Patterson and other Representatives, including Representative Weiersand Representative Reeve, in which Representative Patterson acted in an inappropriate, violent,andlor threatening and intimidating manner.

] O . Victims of Representative Patterson's outbursts and temper have told me thatduring the exchanges with Representative Patterson, they were fearful that RepresentativePatterson was going to strike them. These individuals noted that he intentionally stands in amanner to intimidate them by holding his hands to the side of his body with his fists clenched.

11. I have also witnessed Representative Patterson lose control on the House Floor anumber oftimes while making his comments. I have often warned him to be careful about whathe says, to stick to the issue, and to avoid turning the issue into something personal. whichwould violate the House Rules.

12. On at least one occasion I found Representative Patterson to be.dishonest with meregarding legislation. Representative Patterson represented to me that the presidents of the threemain Arizona Universities supported a bill Representative Patterson sponsored that would allowthe sale of alcohol on university campuses. I trusted Representative Patterson's representationand agreed to co-sponsor the bill. However, J found out that Representative Patterson'srepresentations were untruthful and that it was actually only university faculty who supportedthe proposed bill. 1would not have co-sponsored the bill had I know the University Presidentsdid not support it. At the time, I did not question Representative Patterson's representations, butin hindsight, I was naive and should have known better.

13. At the end of February of this year, Representative Macario Saldate informed meabout Ms. Escobar's allegations of Representative Patterson's drug use and allegations that

D8041J598~3J 2.!


38/96

ineffective and inappropriate means to conduct our work at the Legislature and a clear violation

Representative Patterson's daughter may be in danger. Rather than taking the risk that Ms.Escobar's allegations might not be truthful, 1 encouraged Representative Saldateto report theallegations to the appropriate authorities because of the seriousness of the allegations.

14. I have witnessed Representative Patterson engage in a pattern of confronting othermembers in a manner that is intended to incite fear and intimidation, which I believe is an

of the House Rules.15. I believe Representative Patterson has refused to be accountable for his behavior.16. My personal observations of Representative Patterson have led me to conclude

that he has engaged in a long pattern of disorderly and unprofessional misconduct that reflectspoorly on himself, his party, the House, and the State of Arizona.

Dated this..:l r day of March, 2012._d~~.Representative Tom Chabin

D BIl4 U 59 84 3! 2 .1


39/96

EXHIBIT A


40/96

, .. .

I am very concerned about behavior inappropriate of a Member of the ArizonaLegislature demonstrated by Representative Daniel Patterson. Attached is a complaint Ihereby file (attached to this letter) against Representative Daniel Patterson listing threeseparate incidents.I believe the first complaint is a clear violation of the Rules of the House, The secondand third incidents center on confrontations that Mr. Patterson had with two separateMembers of the House. These confrontations are my greatest concern. In bothinstances, Members and observers feared that Mr. Patterson would become violent.

Case Number: M-1041-CR-95002945 Filed Jan. 11, 1995Guilty of Criminal TrespassGuilty of False Reporting to Law Enforcement

In an article written in the Tucson Citizen Online, I learned that Mr. Patterson has beenarrested involving two incidents and that, according to the article, a Restraining Order isnow, or was recently enforced against him. According to Public records from theArizona Supreme Court internet site, Representative Patterson has been charged inTucson Municipal Court and convicted of crimes involving his conduct. They are:

Case Number; M-1041-CR-81391Guilty of Criminal TrespassGuilty of Disorderly ConductFiled Sept. 27,2000

Case nurn ber: M-1041CR4027896Guilty of Criminal Trespass

Filed Apr. 9,2004

These records might conclude a pattern of violent behavior. Therefore, RepresentativePatterson's documented behavior (contained in my complaint) and his public record ofarrests and convictions is the basis for my concern and the compelling reason for fil inga complaint.Spirited debate, formidable argument and political posturing is "fair game" in theconduct of House Members. One Member impugning Members for their motives andconfrontations borderingon violence is not appropriate.Please note that I consider Mr. Patterson a friend. He was a guest in my home inFlagstaff last year and he visited my apartment in Phoenix just a few months ago towatch sports on television. I find him knowledgeable on the issues, articulate, and hisvoting record is nearly identical to mine. He has a good nature. I believe he has servedhis constituents well. I like Daniel Patterson.


41/96

Drafted May 12, 2011

I If

Therefore, reluctantly. please accept my complaint against Mr. Patterson.


42/96


43/96

Declaratfon of Representative Chad Campbell .

I, Chad Campbell, hereby declare:

I. r am a Democratic member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the"House") and serve as Minority Leader. r have been a member of the House since 2007. rrepresent Legislative District 14.

2. Unless otherwise stated herein, I make this Declaration based on my personalknowledge and lo r observations.

3. I am presently a member of the Appropriations Committee, Rules Committee, andSub Appropriations on Debt Committee.

4. As part of'the Democratic leadership in the House, I have had to adpionishRepresentative Patterson for his unbecoming and unprofessional conduct on several separateoccasions and to request that he make appropriate apologies to this Legislature, staff, andlobbyists. For example, Democratic leadership has had to talk to Representative Pattersonabout (1) his unprofessional and threatening behavior toward lobbyists, (ii) unbecomingbehavior on the floor, including impugning another member, and (iii) his removal from theMilitary Affairs and Public Safety ("MAPS") Committee as a result of Representative Pattersonimpugning another member, refusing to be gaveled down, and storming out of the MAPShearing.

5. I have also spoken to Representative Patterson about his failure to follow memberprotocol and procedure. For example, House Rules strictly prohibit a House member to leaveduring voting; leaving during voting on the floor is highly unusual. Yet, I have witnessed andheard about Representative Patterson repeatedly leaving during voting on the floor. On oneoccasion, Representative Patterson left the floor during voting, got into his car, and drove home.

6. Representative Patterson has also displayed unbecoming and unprofessionalconduct during caucuses. On more than one occasion, I have witnessed him yell and scream

0 13 03 1 . 1 98 09 20 5, I


44/96

about non-policy related issues. Representative Patterson habitually makes his argumentsvitriolic and personal. I am unable to keep track of all of these confrontations because theyoccur on such a frequent basis.

7. Representative Patterson has failed to listen to leadership when it comes to staffcommunications. Since Ms. Escobar's allegations of domestic violence against RepresentativePatterson have surfaced, I have asked Representative Patterson not to contact staff about theissue, yet he continues to do so.

8, Representative Patterson also has a history of "quid pro quo." I am aware ofoccasions where Representative Patterson has offered his vote on a certain bill in exchange foranother member to vote a certain way for one of his bills.

9. Over the course of my time in leadership, I have attempted to engage inconversations with Representative Patterson but they often devolve into heated confrontations.For example, after Ms. Escobar's allegations of domestic violence against RepresentativePatterson surfaced, I gave Representative Patterson two hours to tell Olewhy he should not haveto resign. Representative Patterson denied all of the allegations and repeatedly said the situationwas not his fault. We fought over the phone and were unable to come to an agreement aboutwhat Representative Patterson should do. Despite Representative Patterson's denial of theallegations, the public records have shown me otherwise.

10. Representative Patterson's conduct, without a doubt, reflects poorly on the House.Democratic leadership and I have had tomanage him since his first day in the Legislature. Eachtime Representative Patterson sits down with leadership to discuss his unbecoming andunprofessional behavior, he has promised to change. However, his pattern of behavior hasshown me that he is incapable of correcting his behavior.

11. As a member of Democratic leadership, I can say that the Democratic Housemembers are routinely having to apologize for Representative Patterson's actions and disorderlyconduct

DBO)1 . I 9809205 . 1


45/96

' \ . : _ _ _ J \,i '.

12, My personal observations of Representative Patterson have led me to concludethat Representative Patterson has engaged in a long pattern of disorderly and unprofessionalmisconduct that reflects poorly on himself, his party, the House, the State of Arizona, and worstof all, those who elected Representative Patterson to office,

DATED this _._ day of March, 2012,r

Representative Chad Campbell

D803/.19809205,1


46/96

EXHIBIT 26


47/96

DANIEL PATTERSON1700WEST WASH!NGTON. SUITE HPHOENIX. AR!~ONA 850072844CAPITOL PfJONE: (602) 9265342CAPITOL FAX (602) 417-3169TOLL FREE; 'aC0.3S208404dpatterson@az(eg.gov

COMMITTEES:MILITARV AFFAIRS ANDPUBLIC SAFETYWATER AND ENERGY

TUCSON LEGISLATIVE OFFICE4 0 0 W E ST CONGRESS. SUITE 20 1TUCSON. ARIZONA 85701TUCSON PHONE: (520) 398-6000TUCSON FAX. (520) 398-6028

DISTRICT 29

April 7, 2009

Coach Tom IzzoMichigan State UniversityBerkowitz Complex, Suite 150Athletics Department-Men's BasketballEast Lansing, MI 48824Coach Tom Izzo, staff and MSU men's basketball team:I was born and raised in Lansing and went to games with my dad Dave Patterson atJenison Field House as a young kid, including the 1979 championship season.As a lifetime MSU fan and alumnus ('94), I am very proud of the team this year.Due to my workload at the State Capitol, I could not make it to Detroit for the FinalFour. I did have the honor of gathering with hundreds of Spartan basketball fans inArizona at a big party to cheer, sing the fight song, watch the finals and have a greattime.You guys did great! MSU is a top-notch, class-act basketball program. My familyand I are very proud of your great season and can hardly wait until next season. Youhave every reason to be proud and hold your heads high.I am also proud of the women's team. Wherever I go, T wear my Spartan greenproudly and promote MSU.Iwould love to display some MSU basketball memorabilia in my capitol office,perhaps an autographed ball or team photo, if you can.I thank you for your great leadership and achievements. Keep up the great work.

Thanks, and go green!

REPRESENTATIVE DANIEL R. PATTERSONDistrict 29, Tucson


48/96

DANIEL PATTERSON1700WEST WASHINGTON. SUITE HPHO~NI)(, ARIZONA a~007'2S4'CAPITO~ PHONE; (602) !l:26S342CAPiTOL FA A (S OZI 417.3168TO~L FREE: 1.aCC-:l52-6404dpatterson@azleg,gov

COMMITTEE:WATER AND ENERGY

TUCSON LEGISLATIVE OFFICE400 WEST CONGRESS, SUITE 201TUCSON, ARIZONA 65701TUCSON PHONE. ISlO) 398-6000TUCSON FAX; IS201 398,j;028

DISTRICT 29

April 15, 2010

Coach Tom IzzoMichigan State UniversityBerkowitz Complex, Suite 150Athletics Department-Men's BasketballEast Lansing, MI 48824Coach Izzo, staff and MSU men's basketball team:I was born and raised in Lansing and went to games with my dad Dave Patterson atJenison Field House as a young kid, including the 1979 championship season.As a lifetime MSU fan and alumnus (,94), I am very proud ofthe team this year.Due to my workload at the State Capitol, I could not make it to Indianapolis for theFinal Four. But I did have the honor and pleasure of gathering with other Spartanbasketball fans in Arizona to cheer, sing the fight song, watch the Final Four andhave a great time. .You guys did great! MSU is a top-notch, class-act basketball program. My familyand I are very proud of your great season and can hardly wait until next season. 'Youhave every reason to be proud and hold your heads high. .I am also proud of the women's team. Wherever I go, I wear my Spartan greenproudly and promote MSU,I would love to display more MSU basketball memorabilia in my capitol office,perhaps an autographed team photo or Final Four T-shirt, if you can, . .I thank you for your great leadership and achievements. Keep up the great work.

Thanks, and go green!

REPRE SENTATIVE DAN IE L R . P ATTERSONDistrict 29, Tucson


49/96

EXHIBIT 27


50/96

Tom Izzo Autographed Basketball Auction Page I of 1

CBSSPORTS .COMOFFICIAL ONLINE AUCTION NETWORK

s r ch :L . .. 1 L @ O J = O

B IlO WS E B Y S CH OO L B RO WS E B Y C AT EG OR YTom luo Autogn "he d 5a .blb all Il.latinl l # ~SU-11 0810-2S7SS'

CUI lRENT HIGH BID: I

ADDlTION"l IMAG~5 {CLICK TO I I lEW tARGERVERSION}

5360.00 NEXT BIO: INUMBER OF IlIDS: I 18~$380 . 0 0BI O INCReMENT: I S20 . 0 0

TIME IlEMAINrNG: IEND DATE/TIME: I Auc :t i on Has End f' l dNovember 19, 2010. 12-09 PM ET

ReseNe Price Auction. The reSoNe price has been met. l 'MlaljsIhi"1O erlptlen;M i -c hi gs n S la b ~ H e ad C o a- cn , T o m InoAu ! .C g r ap h od cN k o B a 5 k B lb a 'Auction Type: OpenShipping & Handling: $20.00~I' iibi~ ~$plOlCft ld~rirlO 1i,1!'bs I 31111~ldc r: i oren Open or R e se rv e P r lc e Ah[,U~n. the auc~fQ" will be ;ioJlom..tkiil l !y DI:{-tI1d:edrOt < 1 ' 1" l jd i tl om i: l 3 : .. . I111 .111 ' :! l 1 r(Jm.,Il' lul"l" uiltle l id e " bl::!. lnilii Wcl l-o - l1 . . .11 c ! Q: . .. . e r e e ; 1 ~1bi~liin! l.aCU'/[ly 113.'i ' IQPp~11 to'.g ~lilJ 'd 01:Jminult!' ~

Walch this ne m

More About Michigan State Auctions:Shipping 'nformationWnne rS rlD; Idi ng w lhn t tua Unit ed St~! es wi ll ac cruB a $20 .00 ! hI ppi ng me. Tha: se i rems w~1n o( be sh lp pt ld t o oOtr- lJ_$. snippng adctreS9a"s. Some shi pp ll 1"g se-vees do nol~h i.p to p _ O .Boxes, 10 p)e8M be $lJt& ~u r prafer! l' !d .sh~ping ac"dr~s.{esJ CDmply. P lea se a f t. ow2- . 4W8 f 3ks fO t'd t! h "l l er y a f le r the ; a ut J :u ; ln do. sas a rn :i n o t. t h at sa le s lalll will be a d de d 10 'W in "~ n 9 b d s f rom~~~~~~~~~~~~q~~~~~Mm_~~W~~~~N~mR~~_~~-~Paym.n! InlcrmallonMIcl l~B f1 Sl al e ac~Pl :S Vi sa , MaSl er ~r d. Di sco ve r. an d Ame f (; !Jn Exp re ss onty, we do-no t B~p t chE lCkS, rnoneyo rders. PayPa l, c r any o lh~r pB: ,.mBnl rt1f1l ~hods. if you see~he -whn ragb id de r, I he c am y ou en te ra d 1 0 b id w l! I a ut om a ~f ca Dy b e ch;arged br thiS curehase. "you a r e a r e 11 1 rn ng u s er please-make sure that your aedll csl 'd ( lformalbn i$ updated ho1orH btldngWe wKI anElmp~Locon l.a -c l ;you II' yoor C(edjl c ar d I sna t p r0C '8 s sa d s u tc c $s fu ~ y 6S a e o ur te sy , b ul ,ho\.ll:;i it f ai l w e r e: sa rv e ! he r ig ht t o c an ce l the tr;a"s-ad~on.Cuslomer S.NI".If y ou h aw '.8 question about proc:kJd, P&)'I"I'Ift.rt1,Of iI i~pphg status :please eliek here CoCOf\ t a , l us , Mi chig an St at e CU !il ome ( SafYi ce f epr os ent at ves e re f tva il abt e t o as si st yw Mondaythrough F r i : : : l a y ; 9 AM - 6 PM PST. if y ou h a~ qlJe5tIQfI:I b l d o ' " J " l - g . l J k I f Ht rB C 'Q n. q ue li on r en na , o r r eg is tr at io n p le as e O Jn su fl o ur E re g~ 8 nU y A Sk ed Q ye sl iO ns s oc :t io n w h ic .h m a y h spB Mwe r ) Ou r Q U B st io ns a nd d i3 r~ fy m a ny O f o ur polides.

C8SSPORlS.


51/96

EXHIBIT 28


52/96

Declaration of Representative Terri Proud

1. I am a Republican member of the Arizona House of Representatives (the"House"). I have been a member of the House since January of 2010. I represent LegislativeDistrict 26.

2. Unless otherwise stated herein, I make this Declaration based on my personalknowledge based on my research of publicly available information and/or observations.

3. I am presently a member of the Education Committee and Technology andInfrastructure Committee and Vice-Chairwoman of the Military Affairs and Public SafetyCommittee.

4. I believe that Representative Daniel Patterson has displayed a pattern ofdisorderly, mean-spirited, aggressive, unprofessional, counterproductive, intimidating, anddisrespectful conduct toward others.

5. For example, when I first arrived at the House 1had met Representative Pattersonat a social function, We had discussed co-sponsoring an anti-domestic violence bill. I agreed toco-sponsor such a bill with Representative Patterson. That bill became known as "HB2588."

6, After co-sponsoring HB2588 with Representative Patterson, T began 1 0 hear thatRepresentative Patterson had himself engaged in a pattern of domestic violence toward his exwife. Upon hearing about this, 1 decided to investigate whether these allegations of domesticviolence had merit.

7. My investigation revealed that Representative Patterson had engaged in a patternof disorderly and violent conduct toward others, including one or more acts of domesticviolence toward his ex wife. As a result, I determined that co-sponsoring HB2588 withRepresentative Patterson would be unwise and I decided to "kill" HB2588. An email reflectingmy concerns in that regard is attached as Exhibit A (April 6, 2011 email chain). In fact, when I

I, Terri Proud, hereby declare:

D8041 .15951127 .1


53/96

decided to "kill" HB2588, Ms. Lindsay Simmons, who represents the Arizona DomesticViolence Coalition, contacted m e and stated: "I n light of the circumstances, please be carefuland mindful of your safety." See Exhibit A.

8. My investigation led m e to draft an ethics complaint against RepresentativePatterson (the "Proud Complaint") on or around April 4,2011. A true and correct copy of theProud Complaint, and Exhibits 1 through 3 thereto, are attached as Exhibit B . I believe that theProud Complaint was warranted, supported by verifiable fact, and I stand by everything statedtherein.

9 . Ultimately, however, J decided not to file the Proud Complaint because r believedthat Representative Patterson's caucus is the appropriate group to address his disorderlymisconduct.

lO. My investigation into Representative Patterson has led me to conclude that he hasengaged in a long pattern of disorderly, aggressive, and violent misconduct toward others thatreflects poorly on himself, his party, the House, the State of Arizona, and worst of all, thosewho elected Representative Patterson to office.

11. On two separate occasions the Arizona Coalition Against Domestic Violence hascalled fOT the resignation of Representative Patterson. The two press releases from theCoalition are attached as Exhibit C.

' 1 ; ! : -DATED this 1!1:_ day of March, 2012.

Representative Terri Proud.

D0041 . 1 5 9 5 7 1 2 7 . 1


54/96

EXHIBIT A


55/96

Page 10f2

Terri ProudFrom: Lindsay Simmons 1 1 1Sent: Wednesday, April 06, 2011 7:03 AMTo: Terri ProudSubject: Re: Why I'm KUling HB2588Thank you for your courage on this, Rep. Proud. In light of the circumstances, please be carefuland mindful of your safety.Very sincerely,Lindsay SimmonsSent from my Vcrizon Wireless BlackBerry

From: Terri Proud Date: Wed, 6 Apr 2011 01 :20:47 -0700To: Lela Alston; Vic Williams;TedVQgt; Carl Seel; SteveMontencgro; Katie Hobbs; DavidGowanCc: Daniel PattersonSubject: Why I'm Killing HB2S88Members ,I wanted to thank you for jo ining m e in sponsoring HB25 88 . I know you share m ycon ce rn fo r victim s o f d om estic viole nce an d sta lk in g, a nd I'm g la d th at th is b ill w asable to enjo y b ip artis an s uppo rt.H ow ev er, I h av e le arn ed s in ce in tro du cin g th e b ill th at o ne o f o ur fe llo w s po nso rs ,R epre senta tiv e Danie l Pa tte rs on , a ctu ally h as a repeated h is to ry o f d omestic v io le nc ea nd p hysica l a ssa ult. T his h as b ee n a g re at so urce o f a nxie ty fo r m e rece ntly, a nd I n owkn ow th at m embe rs from b oth p artie s h ave b ee n p riva te ly voca l to D emocra t a ndRepublic an le aders hip about M r. Pa tte rs on . J us t la st month , th e A riz ona Coalitio nAgain st D omes tic V io le nc e c alle d on M r. Pa tte rs on to re sig n, c itin g law enfo rc ementrepor ts documen ting a llegat ions o f domestic V io lence .The bottom line for m e is that as som eone w ho know s the im pacts of dom estic vio lencep ers on ally I c an no t in g oo d c on sc ie nc e a llow M r. P atte rs on to g et c re dit fo r h elp in g top ro te ct v ic tim s b y le ttin g th is b ill m o ve fo rw ard , M r. P atte rs on 's in vo lv ement w ith th isb ill is n ot ju st iro nic - it's e xtremely tro ub lin g a nd d is re sp ec tfu l to th e in divid ua ls th is b ills eeks t o p ro tect .I fin d it creepy, to be com plete ly frank, A nd I a lso feel m islead. S o I am left w ith noc ho ic e o th er th an to k ill th is b ill.

3116/2012


56/96

Page 2 of2

I am working, however, with another member, (J.D. Mesnard) to make sure the content of2588 becomes law as an amendment to another bill - without Mr. Patterson's name attached.I hope you understand and can forgive me for not being aware of this when Mr. Pattersonasked to signed onto the bill in January.Pleaselet me know if you have any questions.Representative Terri Proud

3 / 1 6 / 2 0 1 2


57/96

EXHIBITB


58/96

S ta te Repr esen ta tiv e Te rri P roud1 70 0 W . Wash in gto n S tre et S te 30 9Phoenix , Ari zona 85007

D ate : A pril 4h, 2011Subject: E th ic s comp la in t aga inst S ta te Represen ta tiv e Danie l Pa tte rsonDear E th ic s Chairman S ta te Representativ e Ted Vogt,Im re fe rrin g my comp la in t to y ou aga in st S ta te Rep re senta tiv e Dan ie l Patte rs onfo r p os sIb le v io la tio n o f p ub lic tru st a nd impro pe r co nd uct a s a ca nd id ate a nd /o ra ctin g a s a S ta te Rep re senta tiv e o f L eg Is la tiv e D is tric t 2 9.The Ethics Comm ittee has the authority to address conduct alleged to beun ethical. U nd er comm ittee ru les, tha t w ould in clu de vio latin g state or fede rallaw, vio lating the public trust or any Im proper conduct that adversely reflectsup on the H ou se as a lawma ker a cco rdin g to A .R .S .32 D efinition of u nethica l a ndunprofess ional conduct

S ta temen t o f F ac tsState Representative Daniel Patterson has an ongoing history of uneth icalbehavior. Resulting from charges of crim inal actiV ity, a pattern of disorderlyconduct, dom estic violence, assault, resisting arrest, false reporting to lawen forcem ent an d e vad ing se rvice. .S in ce h is s erv ice a s a S ta te R ep re se nta tive , D an ie l P atte rs on h as b ee n fo un d b ythe Court to have com mitted an act of domestic violence. RepresentativeP atte rso n h as a ls o e va de d s erv ice from a p olice o ffice r a nd h as b ee n remo ve d a s. a m embe r of a S tate H ou se comm itte e du e to disord erly con duct a gain st an oth erle gis la to r. D ue to th e s ta te d a bo ve a ctio ns , a nd a ny o th er a ctio ns th is c omm ltte efin ds a s a V io la tio n, R ep re se nta tive P atte rso n sh ou ld b e remo ve d from se rvin g a sa Lawmake r.Enc lo sed p le as e fin d a ll d oc uments a lle ged to s uppo rt th is c omp la in t.Court Documents : EXHIBIT 1M inute Entry date d 8 /2 7/2 01 0O rder o f P ro te ctio n date d 8 /2 7/2 01 0Petitio n fo r O rder o f P ro te ctio n date d 8 /2 7/2 01 0A ffid av it o f A ttempted Serv ic e date d 9 /1 3/2 01 0Ce rtific ate o f Se rv ic e da ted 10 /4 /2 010Respons e to Petitio n fo r O rder o f P ro te ctio n date d 1 0/6 /2 01 0E th ic s comp la in t against S ta te Represen ta tiv e Danie l Pa tte rson


59/96

Hea rin g Req ue st a nd Hea rin g O rd er 1 0/6 /2 010M in ute E ntlY (C ou rt's ru ling re: O rde r o f P ro tectio n) da ted 1 0/2 5/2 01 0IMAGES: Domes tic V io le nc e in Democ ra tic P arty : EXHIB IT 22 00 3 - UA arres t fo r a ssa ult (inclu din g res isting arres t)2 00 4 -D isorderly C onduct at G am e and F ish2006-Domestic V io lence2010-Domestic V io lenceVario us Newspaper A rtic le s: EXHIB IT 3"T he F am ily M an " d ate d 9 /3 0/2 01 0"W here in the w orld I S Danie l Patte rson " dated 10 /01 /2010"Domestic Coalitio n Aga in st Domes tic V io lence Ca lls fo r Senato rBundgaa rd and Rep. Oanle l Patte rson Resigna tio ns " dated

3/10/11 ."S ta te Rep 's W ife A tc uc es Thre ats & Mariju ana" dated 10 /25 /2010"Pueblo Politic s" Da ted 3 /07 /2011EXH IB IT 4 : H is to ry o f p atte rn ed u ne th ica l b eh av io r

Ter ri P roudState Representa ti ve

c c: Rep re se nta tiv e Ted VOgti C ha irmancc: H ouse C lerk

State of Arizona )) 55.County o f Marico pa )

Sworn to and subscribed before m e on the 4th day of April, 2011, byRepresenta tive Terr i P roud .

No ta ry Public 's S ignature

E th ic s c omp la in t aqa ln st S ta te Representa tive Danie l Patte rson


60/96

C ourt D ocum ents: EXH IB IT 1\

M in ute EntJ y d ate d 8 /2 7/2 010O rd er o f P ro te ctio n d ate d 8 /2 7/2 010Petitio n fo r O rd er o f P ro te ctio n d ate d 8 /2 7/2 010A ffid av it o f A ttemp te d Serv lc e d ate d 9 /1 3/2 010Ce rtific ate o f Ser vic e dated 10 /4 /2010Response to Petitio n fo r O rd er o f P ro te ctio n d ate d 10/6 /2 010Hea rin g Req ue st a nd Hea rin g O rd er 1 0/6 /2 010M inute E ntry (C ourt's ruling re: O rder of P rotection) dated 1 0/2 5/2 01 0 .

E th ic s comp la in t agains t'S ta te Represen ta tive Danie l Pa tterson


61/96

ARIZO NA SU PERIO R C OU RT. PIM A C OuN rYAU o P 7 2 0 1 0

FILEDP A T RlC IA A . N OL AN DC LER K, SU PER IO R C QU RT8 / 2 7 / 2 0 1 0By: H.Rivera

H01':1 .K.C. STANFORD.cO uR T R EP O RT ER : D ig ita lly R eco rd edC ourtroom : 7 74 C ASE N O. D V2 01 01 69 7

DATE: 8 /27 /2 010JENEIENE SCHAFFERPlaintiff In P r op e r Pe rs on

DANIEL PATfERSONDefendantMINUTE ENTR Y

HEARING ONEX PARTE:PETITIONFOR ORDER OF PROTECTION:P la in tiff is p re se nt. D efe nd an t is n ot p re se nt.JENEIENE SCHAFFER issw orn a nd q ues tio ned b y th e C ou rt.T I IE COURT F ,l NDS t: l) .a tt he d ef en da n t:[8l H a s co m m itted a n a ct o f d om e stic v io len ce a ga in st th e p la in tiff w i t h i n th e la st y ea r.o Ma y comm it a n a ct o f d om e stic v io le nce a ga in st- th e p la in tiff.o Has co m m itted a n a ct o f d om estic v io len ce a ga in st the m i no r c hil d/ ch il dr en o f t he p a rt ie s.o May comm it a n a ct o f d om e stic v io len ce a ga in st th e- m in or c hild /ch ild re n o f th e p artie s.o HA S NO T co m m itted a n a ct o f d om estic v io len ce a ga icst th e p la in tiff,o T HE CO URT F IN 1 )S th at it is a pp ro pria te to ren ew th e ex istin g- O rd er o f P ro tectio n.~ ORDER IS SIG N ED .o O lillE R IS D EN IED .o R EN EW AL O RD ER IS SIG N ED .o D ISM ISSA L O RD ER IS S IG N ED .D D ISM iSS AL O RD ER IS D EN IED

H.RiveraDeputy Clerk

2 /08

"J ~ - - -: op--,.- _ ,! ~_,,__ _:-t '+ ft ' " ," r ._..~.> .. P -:- "'.;r-.- ,._.r- ' ~. _........ ~~ I ' __ " __ T" ~ __ ._


62/96

[ 1 Am end ed O rderCaseNo.~~~~~~~~~ ~Court OR] No ..County L - I . . . l , ; g Q 1 ' \ = . o . . o . . : . P c , - , - - , 1 Slate ~Former Case No.

ORDER OF PROTECTION

PLA1NTIFF PLAINTIFF IDENTIFIERS. I :Jevte:eV\e r o a r ; / . S~k ~FIrst Middle . Las! Date of Birth of PlaintiffAndror on behalf of minor fa.m lly m em ber{s ) an d other P ro tec ted Person(s): (List name an d OOB,)

DEFENDANT DEF ENDANT ID EN TIF IE RSv .

MiddleIrst LastDefendantJPlalntlff Relationship: _ _ . _ y y . ~ a . r - = ; . . . ; r , - , i c . . : : e : : . . : . J . : ; . . : . . . . . . _ _

CAUTION: !0weapon Alleged in Petition[ 1 E stim ated D ate of B irth

W ARNIN GS TO D EF EN DA NT : T his O rd er sh all b e en force d, e ven w Ith ou t reg Is tra tio n, by I he c ou rt s o f an y. s ta te, t heO is tr ic t of Columbia, a ny U ,S , Territory, andmay be en fo rc ed by Tribal Land s ( 18 U .S .C . 2265) .CrossIng s ta te , terrilorial, o r t ri ba l bounda ri es 1 0 violate this Order may resu l t i n federa l impr isonment(18 U,S.C, 2262) . Fede ra l l aw providas pena lt ies for possessing, Iranspor'tlng, sh ipp Ing , o r r ece iv in g any t ir ea rm orammunition (18 U.S.C. 9~2(g)(6)), Only thu CQurt, In wrIting. " 0 1 " changu this Order.This Order Is effective for one .earfrom tlate of servIce. VERIFY VALIDITY cal! Holder of Record:

PIma County Sh er if f5 O ft ic a, P .h on a! (520) 351-4625'THECOURT HEREBY FINDS:Tha t It has JurIsdIction over the pa rt ies an d sub jec t ma t te r ,{ J De fe n dant r ec eiv ed a ctu al n oU ce o f th is Hea ri ng and ha d an oppor tun it y t o pa rt ic ipa te .AddItional findings 6f this Order and warnings are sat 1Qrth on the next pag a(s).THE COURT; FINDING REASONABLE CAUSE. HEREB,Y ORDERS:'-.. NO CRIMES. De fe nd an ! s h. dl n ot c omm it an y c rimes again s t P la in tif f o r P ro te c te d Pe rsont s) ,NNO COt -r r ACT . D efen da nt sh all h~ e no contac~ith P latn tr ff excep t through attorneys, legal precess, courthearlngs, an d as c he ck ed : { I Phone " M Em611~ M Ma! l t- 'J Other : .s ' "< ; ! ' 1 1 . . P,' !:49~:L.-[ ) N O C ON TAC T, D efendant shall have no contact w ith Protected Personts) excep't1hfough at to rneys , lega lp ro ce ss , c ou rt h ea rin gs e nd a s c he ok ed -] IP ho ne [ IEma lVFax [ IMall I lather: -..:Effective; January 2006 Page 1 012 AdOpte9 by Administrat]ve D i rec ti vo No . 2 007 .0 3


63/96

Case N a l l Y 2 -0 1 Q 16 9 7

""-. '#". .... , -.++ "_ . l !A_ ": ~~. ~: ': :- . .: -: ;,

THE COURT FUR TH ER OR DER S: :!)RES IDENCE. P la In tiff I s g ra nte d e xc lu 5! ve u se a nd p cs se ss lc n 0 1 th e r es id en ~e iis te db elow.11 LAW E NFORCEMEN T S TA ND BY . D efendant may r etu rn o nc e w ith - a la w e nf orc eme nt officer t o obt ai nn ec es sa ry p er so na l b elo ng In gs . N eith er la w enforcement n or t his p rc te eflv e o rd er ca n resolve conflicts overproperty, t it le , furn itu re , f inances, real estate, or o ther owne~h lp i ssue s.

PROTECTED LOCATIONS. Oe fe nd an t s ha ll n ot go to o r n ea r: th e P lakn ti ff~ o r o the r P rotected Pe rson' s:'i.tl ResIdence ( le ave b la nk i f confidential): l O ~ O S , ~ o , ; h C Q c V A\& - r L t t E C { J / J l' 1?'i,J.;& cb~( 1 Workp lace ( leave

~) 8chool'~

[ J F IR EARMS. B ec au se D efe nd an t p os es a c re dib le th re at o f b od ily In ju ry to P la ln tlff o r Protected Person(s),De fe ndan t sha ll n ot p ossess, receIve, o r p ur ch as e fire arm s o r ammunit io n a nd s ha ll s urre nd er s ame w it hin 2 4h ou rs o f s er vic e to : .,.---.--,,....,..-.....,--------......,.""


64/96

. N AM E: J e : V 1 - e - i eVle. "S c . . . k " ,++~ADDRESS' ; " 10fo SI K'o.;lro&d AVGCITY & STATE: Tu.c,;


65/96

, r

0\1 2 0'1 0 1 6 9 lCase No. ~ __ "':':'-_~_~~

Order. As stated I n number 4, the Defendant Is a danger to them:---..... (_I_/~Date B ir th Da la_____~----_--(~~...-j -.....,._--~:...._--LJ_" _"~

Birth Date Birth'D?te,6 . Yefendant s ho uld b e o rd ere d to stay away' f rom these locations, at al i t imes, even when I a m not present[- f Home 10 L f '0 5, R Q ; [ CCli2J f : . . ve.. =J"!


66/96

AFFIDAVIT AND RETURNUNSERVED

STATE OF ARIZONACOUNTY OF PIMAOFFICE OF THE SHERIFF

I hereby certify that I received the within and foregoing Protectiveorder on August 27 2010 to be served on the Defendant, DANIEL RYANPATTERSON and that after diligent search and inquiry, I am returningthe protective Order unserved with the following explanation(s):Service attempted on 10:30:00 Oe/30/10Location: PO BoX#172Contacted the defendant by telephone. I explained to the defendantthat I needed to meet wi.th him to serve an Order-af-Protection. Thedefendant advised me that he needed to speak to his attorney and thenhe would call me back.Service attempted on 15:25:00 08/30/10Location: PO Box#172Called the defendant and left a phone message for him to contact mereference this matter. Defendant called back a few moments later andadvised that he would meet with me on 09/02 at 1130 AM at 32 N. Stoneto accept service of this Order. I told the defendant that 1 willmeet with him at the agreed time and date.S er vi ce a tt em pt ed On 1 1: 37 :0 0 0 9/ 02 /1 0Location; PO Box#172Received a telephone call from the defendant who stated t.hat, at theadvice of his attorney. he is not to meet with me to accept service.I advised the defendant that 1 consider his failure to meet with meas evasion, The defendant stated that it is not evasion, it is theadvice of his attorney.! then asked the defendant "Are you refusingto meet with me to accept service?" The defendant again. stated thathe is following the advice of his attorney. I advised the defendantthat 1 would return the Order to the courts noting that the defendantwas evading service. I then ended the telephone conversation.

.I!I1i

Returned on 09/07/10

Clarence W. DupnikSheriff of Pima County/'~Y:P. cvn...R I I- 73 3; DEPUTV


67/96

lIN THE SUPERIOR COURT OFTHE STATE OF ARIZONAIN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF PIMA

lnv, #95016

JENIENE MARIE SCHAFFER NO . ,DV 2 01 9 J. Q" 9! _. .Plaintiff I Petitioner,

VS. CERTIFICATE OF ~ \ 0SERVICE .~~1 J .: ' ;

Defendant I Respondent .., . )~ :- :: :- :':" :" ___ :'':::: :''''- ::: :::= ':==_ ''~T .H. .. .. .~ __. ~ . ~ .:. :. :. .. .:. .:. .. :. ._...r: > _ .~~ .. . _~ : . . . _. :* . . .~~~I, _JnsenhPlc . '. d . h . I'"" I'fi .-~ ~.~.~...'..... "':,' :-',' ...... _:--:-.. .._-:-_~. ,b.emg, u ly s wa m , = = t at s/he l~ d u Y ,iU ~ 1 led ,se,~process in this cause within the county m which It was served, having been so appointed ~ the COl I th~ ~~s/he s/he received the following documents in this action:. ~;:; ~"'7~'

. ~ ~~Petition for Order of Proteetlon, Order of Protection, Blank Request &Order Forms~efendalHls ~QGuide Sheet "c;:l ~ sr;

~,.';r..~ ':~. .:)...(,'

DANlEL RYAN PATTERSON

from .... ..__ .J.,ENORE TSJ\.~~IKAS, l:.!,AWOF:;!!'ICE, . 011 . .. .. .. . _lO /l!l!L ._ . .;that s/hepersonally served copies of these documents on those named below in the manner and time and placeshown; and except where noted, all services were made in Pima County, Arizona,NAME: DANIEL RYAN PATTERSONDATE & TIME: October 4,2010 at 2:45 pmPLACE & 7 38 N . 5 TH AVE., # 21 0, TU CSO N, A2 8 57 01 , w hich is his/her place of business.MANNER: In person.

Stutement pf Cpsl~.5.,,1. 116.00Mlle.g. S 1 8 . 0 0LOC :RE I !WII .Fc .CI" '~ ID'-7~(DDp e,l'u~. S IO .ODO l h , , - , = r - - .,._-Tot~1 $44 .00

T he a bov e is c ov ered b y A .R ,S . a s a m e nde d 4 1 3 1 4 & lJ 4 5 a nd Rules 4 , 5 and 4 5.._~..l[f~ONTl~g..?RQg~SS~By'~ql.:..85r~ Sequeya~St~ - TU~~?_l],.-'\Z 85719

. ' IiIII'IIijj!,,i~


68/96

15161718

Respondent/Defendant Daniel R.Patterson, through counsel undersigned,

FILED "PIlTRICI.' ! .. 1 : . . t.llJ\ h '.,_~~",i\1 . " n , J L ~1 d:;_"\ . .. . _; . .. . 1 LAW OFFICE of

2 DAVID LIPARTITO, P.c. l U ! O O C T ~ 6 A H 1 0 : 2 5\0.(0 '108 Y : E . B R AD FO R D ,D E P U T Y

3 177 N. Church, Ste. 700TUCSON,ARIZONA 857014 T!:LE?HONE (520) 622-1944FAX (520) 624-4796

5 [email protected] County Computer No. 347566 Arlzona State Bar No. 010048Attorney for Respondent78910 JENEIENE MARIE SCHAFFER1

IN T H E SUPE R IO R C O UR T O F THE STATE O F ARIZONAIN AND FO R THE C OUNTY O F PIMA

Respondent/Defendant.

. . R E - _ . - - . _. ._. ._ - . . . . - - E T I T l C l ' N -HfRO R D ER O F PR O T E C TIO NAssigned to: Han, Margaret MaxwellHon -.Irene Masters

_ .._._.~I?etltloner/Plaintlff,,


69/96

l A Temporary Orders hearing has been set In the Dissolution actlon (Case2 #D20103300) for 9:00 e.rn. on October 251 2010 before the Han. Margaret3 Maxwell. Respondent/Defendant requests that the hearing on the Petltion for4 Order of Protectlon be set on that same date and time.S DATED this _ day of October, 2010.6 DAVID UPARTITO/ P.C.78910

.. 11.

. ~ " r , < _ _ , _ _ , , - , . _ . . . . . , I,' .-- ..- ~ \ ~ _ ..,,_

1213 Copy of the fore~g14 delivered this 47'" ayof October, 201Q, to:15 Han, Margaret Maxwell16 PIma County Superior Court

"...._ . . . .17 Lenore.Tsakap-tkas239 . ..N : Ch l .11 th Ave" Ste. 10118 T~Ift.son 7 . . _." %:

19~~--'--_'2021222324252627


70/96

JENE IENE MARIE SCHAFFER DV20101697 1 2 9 HEARINGD01SMISS ORDERoCANCEL HEARING AND ORDER

oPt IAHI IAWH Issue Date: OB-27-2010fMM-DD-YYYYJ

~_~_" '.0 ..,.._ ~ ~.~_ "- ",___.~~ ._". ___ ~ ..L _ .___ _

Plaintif!II.DANIEL RYAN PATIERSON

C ase N o.

Defendant

~ De fe nd an t re qu es ts a h ea rin g.I f t he P la in ti ff I s: a current or form er spouse, orsomeone with whom yo u l ive l[ jved , o r the chJrd of an Intimate partner, or

a parent ofyour "hildAND th e O rd er re ma in s In e ff ec t o r is changed a tt er t he hear in g .You will be prohIbIted from possessing or purchasing firearms or ammuni t ion until thet Order explreson e year after the service of the or iginal Order.By making this request, If yo u fail to appear for the hearing, tile prohIbitIon against you pcssesslnq orpUrchasing firearms o r ammun it io n will apply.o PlaintIff requests:o t he p ro te ct iv e o rd er lis te d a bo ve b e d ism is se d,O th Bt th e C ou rt c an ce l th e h ea rin g s et p rio r to th e is su an ce o f t h e p ro te ctiv e o rd er in th is c as e.Othat the Court continue the s cheduled hearing o n (Date).

L is t th e r ea so ns f or y ou r r eq ue st~..?a:~azL~10-06-2010Date

A t to rney fo r DefendantAdd re ss and tel ephone number if De fendan t i s the r eques ti ng pa r ty .

CERTIFICATE OF TRANSMIITALCop y m aile d/d eliv ere d to ~ P la in tiff DOe re nd an t o n by _Ef fec ti ve : January 2007 Page 1 of 1 Adopted by Admin is t ra t ive D i rec t ive No . 20D6-01


71/96

.... ' ~ .,..,_..- ,_ ~. ._~I _ _ ""L.' __ _ _ _ _ . ..... "no

ARIZONA SUPERIOR COURT IN PIMA COUNTY, 110 W CONGRESS, TUCSON, AZ 85701CIVi l DEPARTMENT, ROOM 131A (520) 7403210J E N E IE N E M A R IE S C H A F F E R D V 2 0 1 0 1 6 9 7 HEARING ORDERPlalntiff~ Case No.Birth Date: .. .. . 1 R I Order of Protect]ono Injunction Against Harassmentv. o Injunction Against Workplace HarassmentD A N IE L R Y A N P A TT E RS O N Issued Date: _ _ 1_ _ 1- (mmldd/ccyy)Defenda-ntPrior to Hearing:o The requested relTefIs denied, Date requested: _-_,~ Based on.request, this matter is set for hearing:

Date: II; IriS, fOTime:~PM " ,Parties are to present testimony and evidence whether the Court should continue, rev:r.!ii_~~~

protective order listed above, "1o The Court cancels the hearing set for __ '__j (Date).o On PJainliffs motion, the Court dismisses the protective order l isted above.At tim!! of HGar lng ;Plaintiff:Defendant: OAppearedoAppeared oFai led to Appear but did not have NoticeDFailed to Appear but did no t have Notice OFailed to Appear but had NoticeOFai led to Appear but had Noticeo The hearing prevlously set is canceled.o The Court d ls rnl sses ths protective order l isted above.o The protective order l isted above remains In effect 0Brady applies.o As attached.jhe Court modif ies the protective order l isted above. 0rady applies.JO- f o - IO JUdiclalO~ate

CERTI FI CATE OF TRANSM I TTALCopymalledlde!lvered to0Plaintiff 0Defendant 0Sheri ff on _ __j_f __ by ~-:-:-----:----,---c-:---:---:-:,--------:::--:---,,-----:--;-----==--Effective: January 2007 P'lgB 1of 1 Adopted by Administrative DirectiveNo.200601


72/96

A RIZO N A.sU PERlO R C OU RT, P IM A C OU N TY D e p u t y

OCT 36 20 10 F I LED/D-'dS-/b:::r~IpAA.i O L A N D , Clerk

:zf.4doA4z_H ON . M ARG ARET L . M AX W EL LJU D G E PR O T EM PO RE C ASE N O . 020103300[PV20 101691lC OU R T R EPO RTE R: D igita lly R ecordedC ourtro om - 68 0 DATE : O c to be r 2 5 ,2 0 1 0

D20103300JE N EI N E MARIE S CHA FF ERPetitionerLenore Tsakanikas, Esq.Couns el f or P e tit io n er

andDAN IEL R YA N PA TT ER SO NRespondent David Lipartito, Esq.Couns el f or Re sp onden tDV20101697JENE IENE :MARIE SCHAFFERPlaintiffVS .D AN IE L R YA N P AT TE RSO NDefendant

MINUTE ENTRYPETITIONER'S MOTION FOR PRE-DECREE TEMPORARY ORDERS PURSUANT TO RULE47(A) ARFLP; RESPONDENPS EMERGENCY PETITION FOR TKMPORARY ORDERS;RESPONDENT'S CROSS-PETITON FOR TEMPORARY ORDERS (as to D20103300);DEFENDANT'S REQUEST FOR HEARING (DV20101697)

Bo th p a rti es are present.P etitio ne r's E xh ib its 1 th ro ug h 7 are i den ti fi ed a s fo llows :

1 C op y o f c ale nd ar fo rJ un e th ro ug h September201 02 Color c opy 8 x 1 0 c ol or p ho to gr ap h o f d es k d ra w er c on te nts3 C opy o fT U SD T hird G ra de P rogress report fo r Q ua rter 1 of2 01 0 -2 0 11 sch ool y ea r4 Copy of Super S ta r aw a rd da ted 1 0 -8 1 05 Copy of A riz ona Sta te C redit U nion paym ents to AZ DES U IB

Loretta Gutierrez;Depu ty C le rk


73/96

Page 2MINUTE ENTRYDate: October 25, 2010 Case No.: D20l03300DV20101697

6 Copy Geico letter dated October 5,20107 Copy of Ohio National Financial Services application dated 09/13/108 Copy ofJeneine Marie Patterson's Financial Affidavit dated August27, 2010

Respondent's Exhibits A through G are identified as follows:A Copy of Daniel Ryan Patterson's Affidavit ofFinanciallnforrnation dated 10/22110B Copy of E-mail dated August 25, 2010 from DanielJeneine Schaffer to JillC Copy of E-mail dated October 22,2010 from Daniel Patterson re: Jeneine's facebookD Copy of E-mail dated October 11,2010 from Daniel Patterson to Jeneine SchafferE Copy of numerous E-mails dated August 29,2010 through October 20,2010 between the

partiesF Copy of Petition and Order of Protection in DV20l01697G Copy of checks dated 8/20/10 through 10 / 20 / 1 O 'payable to Jeneine Schaffer

AS TO DV20101697:JE N EIN E MARJE SCHAFFER and DANIEL RYAN PATTERSON are sworn and questioned by the

Court.IT IS ORDERED that the Order of Protection issued August 27. 2010 remains in full force and eff~ct..HEARING ORDER, BRADY INDICATOR, ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE (2) SIGNEDFILED IN COURT: Hearing Order, Brady Indicator, Acceptance Of Service (2)

AS TO D20103300:The Court contacts Judicial Supervision Program and speaks to Lisa informally ..Ms. Tsakanikas makes an opening statement.

FOR THE PETITIONER:JENElNE 1v1ARIE SCHAFFER, previously sworn, is examined.Petitioner's Exhibit 1, is admittedPetitioner's Exhibit 2. is admitted over objection.p'etitiorier's Exhibit 5 , 3, 4, 6, 8, are admitted.The time for hearing having been exhausted,IT IS ORDERED that the hearing set this date is continued to November 15, 2010, at 9:00AM, in

Division 51. Estimated t ime for hearing is one (l ) hour.

Loretta GutierrezDeputy Clerk


74/96

Page 3MINUTE ENTR YD ate: O ctober 2 5 , 2 01 0 C ase N o. : D 20 10 33 00DV201 0 16 9 7

----- ... _ - - .-------~. . - - .

LATER, SAME DAY, IN CHAMBERSIT I S ORDE RED th at th e P etitioner a nd R esp ondent sh all subm it to ra ndom drug testing . A s ep ara te

O r de r to is su e.Both parties a re a dmon is h ed t~ c omp l ete t he p a re nt e du ca tio n c la s s.[Clerk's note: Exhibits will be required/or hearing]

/~ ON . ARET L. MAXWELL

cc: Han. Margaret L. MaxwellDa v id L ip a rtito , E sq .L e no re T sa k an ik a s, E sq .J ud icia l S up erv is ion P ro gra m - C a sa d e los NinosT AS C, 2 44 W . D ra chm a n, Tucson, A Z 8 57 05

Lo ret ta G u ti er re zDep uty C le rk


75/96

by J !, ll 'e !?Sono ra n s on Ma r , 09,2011, u nd er H ea dli ne n ew s~~: 116 peopl e l ik e t hi s.

IMAGES: Domestic violence in Democratic Party with Tucson southside legislator, DanielPatterson

Sen. Ron Gould, R~Lake Havasu City, also called for Bundgaard to resign his leadershipposition,

Republicans and Democrats in Arizona have finally found something to agree on, and Three Sonoransis even applauding Ron Gould for his stance against domestic violence amongst state legislators suchas Scott Bundgaard.

"Getting in a fistf ightwith your girlfriend on the side of the freeway is behavior unbecorninqa senator,' Gould said Monday."I won't be led by somebody who does those kinds of things:

What about other cases of domestic violence with current members of the state legislature?Will Republicans and Democrats stand strong against this horrif ic violence against women, or violenceagainst humans in general? .lhave been investigat ing a case for some time now, and with both the Scott Bundgaard case makingheadlines, and the video of Aubry Ballard being released, and finally with today (when this is beingwritten) being International Women's Day, the time has now come to write about this story,A few months ago the Tucson Weekly wrote about Daniel Patterson, Democrat from LD29 on Tucson'ssouthside. It appears that sometime around August of 2 01 0 , Daniel Patterson moved out of his homeand moved in with his new female friend.Jam not interested in personal issues here. Relationships come and go.However, a few issues of concern to the public were raised. It began with a restraining order due toallegations of domestic violence. Usually some credible evidence [s needed to get such an order, andindeed this was the case. But the restraining order could not be served on the LD29 representativebecause he was no longer Jiving at home. .The police tried to f ind out his new address, but the Democrats stuc~ together and would not reveal hisnew home. It was not too diff icult to get pictures of his car being parked outside his new address (notby me but by previous writers on this story) and to this day everyone in the party that J have talked toknows that he is living near the Glenn and Oracle intersection, and has been for many months now.This raises issues first of aUof him vot ing in a precinct in which he does not live in, wh1chis a felony,but furthermore running for off ice in a district the candidate does not live In, and continuing to live


76/96


77/96

, Violation: ASSAULTIn 2003 Daniel Patterson wa