farinas vs exec (2).doc

7/25/2019 farinas vs exec (2).doc

1/22

EN BANC

[G.R. No. 147387. December 10, 2003]

RODOLFO C. FARIA, !AN"EL !. GARCIA, FRANCI G. EC"DERO, #$%

AGA&I'O A. A("INO, A !E!BER OF ')E )O"E OF RE&REEN'A'I*EAND ALO A 'A+&AER, IN ')EIR O-N BE)ALF AND INRE&REEN'A'ION OF ')E !E!BER OF ')E !INORI' IN ')E )O"E OFRE&REEN'A'I*E,petitioners, vs. ')E E+EC"'I*E ECRE'AR,CO!!IION ON ELEC'ION, )ON. FELICIANO R. BEL!ON'E, R.,ECRE'AR OF ')E IN'ERIOR AND LOCAL GO*ERN!EN', ECRE'AR OF')E ENA'E, AND ECRE'AR GENERAL OF ')E )O"E OFRE&REEN'A'I*E, respondents.

[G.R. No. 1/211. December 10, 2003]

CONG. GERR A. ALA&"DDIN,petitioner, vs. CO!!IION ON ELEC'ION,respondent.

D E C I I O N

CALLEO, R.,J.

Beore e Co5r #re 6o &eo$ 5$%er R59e / o e R59e o Co5r, # #me$%e%,ee:$; o %ec9#re # 5$co$5o$#9 eco$ 14 o Re'e F#rE9eco$ Ac?, $o#r # e@


2/22

Re


3/22

)o5e %eerre% e #


4/22

E9eco$ Co%e, 9e#$; $#c eco$ ereo 6c m


5/22

#e $o o6$ # e #e 5ere% #rm # # re59 o e


6/22


7/22

member o e e$#e, o$e% b oer


8/22

co$e5e$ce, e r


9/22

'e Co5r co$$ce% # e 9e #$% e obece o Re


10/22

o I 6o59% 6#$ o be; e )o5e co$$;e$, 9eK ;e oer 6. 'o me, #, K $o #er o5c 5e. For me, K ee$ # er correc EN. ROCO?

e. A$6#, 9eK 9e$ o Co$;rem#$ !#rco.

RE&. !ARCO

!r. C#rm#$, m# I 5 m#:e e ober#o$ # #9o5; r5e # e b59: o


11/22

!#be 6e o59% $o c#99 $# 9m#o$ o$ e9ece% oc#9. !#be 6e o59% # eEN. ROCO?

- %o$K 6e remoe #rH #$% e$ #99 be ce% # E9eco$ &r#cce AcQH

RE&. &IC)A

'#K $o #$ e9eco$ EN. ROCO?

A ##6 mo o$; EN. ROCO?

O, F#r E9eco$ Ac.

RE&. !ACARA!BON


12/22

N#;bbr#$orm #o %o, e. )o6 #bo5 6e c#$;e e 9e o e$#$ce e o9%$;o ree, or%er9, o$e, EN. ROCO?

Do$e. o, o:# $# o$. 'e 9e 699 be F#r E9eco$ Ac.H

'e re 6#9# $#$;


13/22

-#9# $#, 6#9# $#. !#$# #o # EN. ROCO?

'e or 9e, ' Ac ...H

')E C)AIR!AN >RE&. "CO?

o5Kre b#c: o o5r No. 21 #9re#%.

RE&. !ARCO

'e 599 9e, e #meQ

')E C)AIR!AN >EN. ROCO?

Io$ $# $;#. 'e 599 9e A$ Ac o e$#$ce e o9%$; ...H '#K e )o5eero$, e, %#9


14/22

!oreoer, e #o6e%


15/22

A%m$r#e Co%e o 1=87 >E@ec5e Or%er No. 2=2?, #


16/22

;. 'e EffectivityH c9#5e o B No. 1741 #$% )B No. =000, # 6e99 # #o e com


17/22

com


18/22

A$$e@ B,H id.

e$#or R#59 . Roco, Fr#$cco . '##%, *ce$e C. oo III, Gre;oro B. )o$##$,Rober . #6or:, 'ere# A5$oOre#, Lore$ Le;#r%#Lee #$% er;o Ome# III.

Re


19/22

24/ CRA 2/3 >1==/?.

23/ CRA 30 >1==4?.

51==4?.

23/ CRA /0 >1==4?.

17/ CRA 24 >1=8=?.

24 CRA 334 >1==/?.

51==?.

#mo$ . A;5rre, 31/ CRA /3 >1===?.

&n re $uarina, 24 &9. 37 >1=13?.

'##% . ecre#r o De1=87?.
http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/1999/sept99/133076.htmhttp://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/1999/sept99/133076.htm


20/22

Recor% o e Bc#mer#9 Co$ere$ce Commee o$ e D#;ree$; &roo$ oe$#e B99 No. 1742 #$% )o5e B99 No. =000 >Commee o$ E9ecor#9 Reorm?,Noember 23, 2000, 1=74? !ore . !55c, 22 CRA 424>1=8?.

51=/7?.

No


21/22


22/22

farinas vs exec (2).doc

Documents