federal acquisition service u.s. general services administration december 2007 airline briefing city...
TRANSCRIPT
Federal Acquisition Service
U.S. General Services Administration
December 2007December 2007
Airline Briefing City Pair Program
Airline Industry Desired Changes and Government Findings
FY 2009 Solicitation
2
Federal Acquisition Service
2
Discussion Topics – Considered Pre-Determination
Outline desired changes and action items identified at November 1, 2007 Airline Industry and Customer Forum
Present findings Discuss and evaluate findings Next Steps
3
Federal Acquisition Service
Background
November 1, 2007 Airline Industry Forum Airlines represented: American, United, Delta, Northwest, AirTran,
Mesa, and Midwest Government represented: NSF, VA, HUD, GSA, SSA, DOI, NASA,
State, Treasury, Coast Guard, NBC, EPA, DHS, DOE, PBGC, Ed, DOD, AMC, TRANSCOM
Discussed desired changes the airline industry would like made to the FY 2009 City Pair Program (CPP) solicitation and contract
Requested changes that align with commercial practices Ticketing Time Limits (TTL) be applied to CPP tickets
– Reduces spoilage Implement Penalty Fees
– For changes, cancellations or re-issuing of tickets
4
Federal Acquisition Service
Ticketing Time Limits (TTL)1. Evaluate the impact TTL would have on current booking and
ticketing practices including financial impact2. Develop a standard definition for TTL3. Impact of Continuing Resolutions on Government’s ability to
purchase tickets if TTL is implemented4. Evaluate ticket refund/reimbursement cycle-timeline along with
SmartPay card refund cycle-timeline and the impact on individually billed account card holders
5. Assess programming requirements for Defense Travel System and E-Gov Travel Service to accommodate TTL
6. Identify impacts of increased changes/cancellations to reservations and re-issued tickets i.e. travel agency fees
7. Assess overall cost impact Implement Penalty Fees
1. Assess overall cost impact
Action Items to Evaluate
5
Federal Acquisition Service
Ticketing Time Limit Findings
6
Federal Acquisition Service
6
Typical government practice: Hold ticketing to retain flexibility and change w/o fee Tickets are issued a mean of 4 days prior to departure *86% are purchased 7 days or less prior to departure
12% issued day of departure 14% issued 1 day prior to departure 9% issued 2 days prior to departure 12% issued 3 days prior to departure 19% issued 4 days prior to departure 14% issued 5 days prior to departure 4% issued 6 days prior to departure 2% issued 7 days prior to departure
1. Evaluate the impact TTL would have on current booking and ticketing practices including financial impacts
7
Federal Acquisition Service
1. Evaluate the impact, continued
Behavior – Book _CA as far in advance as possible Day 7 Determination or opt for YCA with in 7 Days
Unable to forecast traveler response to TTL It is expected the transaction costs would rise to cover costs
of changes made to tickets after issuance Explore the possibility of a TTL test at one or more Agencies
Assess traveler and financial impacts
8
Federal Acquisition Service
8
2. Develop a standard definition for TTL
TTL – Airline goal to get seats back in inventory with time to resell
TTL - May be based either on a set amount of time before flight departure or a set amount of time after a reservation is made
Regardless of the type of time limit, reservations for flights in
YCA or _CA may be made up to the time of flight departure subject to seat availability
9
Federal Acquisition Service
9
Assuming a 7 day TTL ACTION
Reservation made months priorto departure
Issue ticket 7 days prior to departure
Reservation made 10 days priorto departure
Issue ticket 7 days prior to departure
Reservation made 7 days priorto departure
Issue ticket immediately or within 24 hours after reservation is made
Reservation made 6 days or less priorto departure
Issue ticket immediately or within 24 hours after reservation is made
Reservations not ticketed 7 Days prior are automatically cancelled
2. Develop a standard definition for TTL, continued
10
Federal Acquisition Service
10
The Government’s use of Continuing Resolutions to fund its operations appears to have minimal impact on proposed TTL
The Government funds essential travel under a Continuing Resolution
A number of Agencies are funded differently The last Government shut down occurred in
1995-96 intermittently for total of 18 business days
3. Impact of Continuing Resolution on Government’s ability to purchase tickets if TTL is implemented
11
Federal Acquisition Service
11
Background: Airfare is booked through Defense Travel System, E-Gov Travel Service
or travel agencies (CTOs, TMCs) Domestic airfare paid for by the SmartPay card SmartPay cards can be:
Centrally Billed Accounts (CBA)– Refunds are returned directly to the agency’s CBA
Individually Billed Accounts (IBA)– Individuals are responsible for on-time payment in full of their
account– Ticket refunds are credited to the traveler’s IBA
Agencies receive incentives for timely payment of SmartPay accounts
4. Evaluate ticket refund/reimbursement cycle-timeline along with SmartPay card refund cycle-timeline and impact on individually billed account card holders
12
Federal Acquisition Service
4. Airline ticket refund/reimbursement cycle and timeline
Payment for cancelled ticket may be due to SmartPay before refund is processed
Travelers must pay their IBA in full, even if the refund for the cancelled ticket has not been credited
Day 1-7 CTO’s/TMC’s process sales daily
Charges on IBA and CBA within
hours of ticket issueDay 7 Refunds processed by CTO’s/TMC’s
weekly – batched and sent to Airline Reporting Corporation (ARC)
Day 7-14 ARC validates refundsDay 14 Refunds batched and sent to
Visa/MasterCardDay 14-17 3 Day Process at Visa/MasterCard
Day 17 Refunds sent to banksDay 17-18 Refunds provided to IBA/CBA
13
Federal Acquisition Service
13
4. SmartPay billing and payment cycle
IBA holders have 21 days from billing date to pay account in full
Refund Process takes 17-18 Days Minimally Assuming CTO/TMC Process Weekly
No. of Calendar Days from Closing Date
Suspension Procedure
30 Days Billing Cycle
0 Bill Released
21 Days Payment Cycle
46 Days Request payment from the individual cardholder on past
due account
55 Days Begin suspension process
61 Days Account may be suspended, unless otherwise directed by
the A/OPC
Source: Smart Pay Contract
14
Federal Acquisition Service
4. Scenario of Transactions and Contractor Actions regarding account Combined Refund and Billing / Payment Cycles
DAYS CURRENT PROCESS 7 Day TTL
30 Days Billing Cycle Billing Cycle
21 Days Payment Cycle Payment Cycle
-7 Days Not Applicable Ticket Issued – CTO/TMC Transaction Fee charged
-5 Days SmartPay bill is sent to IBA SmartPay Bill is sent to IBA - Includes Ticket Charges and Transaction Fee
-4 Days Normally Ticketed - Trip Canceled(no impact with current practice)
Trip Canceled – Advise CTO / TMC to begin refund process. Transaction Fee still applies
0 Days IBA Holder receives Bill IBA Holder receives bill Ticket Charges and Transaction Fee included on bill IBA holder cannot dispute chargesBegin Voucher Process for Transaction Fee
+16 Days Bill due to Visa/MasterCard Bill due to Visa/MasterCard IBA holder must pay for ticket that is being refunded or be in default Pay Transaction Fee and Voucher Fee
+30 Days Next Billing Cycle closes new bill issued for current charges
Next Billing Cycle closes new bill issued for current chargesPrevious bill Past Due
+46 Days Not Applicable Request Payment from IBA holder on Past Due Account
+55 Days Not Applicable Begin Suspension Process
+61 Days Not Applicable Account may be suspended, unless otherwise directed by the A/OPC Suspension must be initiated
15
Federal Acquisition Service
4. Corporate Practices Model: Negotiated Air Programs
Fare Buckets Discount percentages Tier 1 F, B, Full coach XX% Tier 2 B,H,M Range: Low XX% to X% Tier 3 Lower bucket non-refundable
Range: Low X% to none*• The more restrictive and lower in cost the fare – the smaller the percentage of
corporate discount• Tickets purchased based on fare rules
Refund process If using corporate card on a refundable ticket and trip is cancelled, traveler requests a
charge suspension until refund is issued Traveler has been provided an advance, must refund company and company takes on
administrative job to track Few corporations require the traveler to float the expense For non refundable tickets company must manage the inventory – most common
situation Need information on refund process for BSP and Non-ARC airlines
16
Federal Acquisition Service
16
5. Assess programming requirements for Defense Travel System and E-Gov Travel Service to accommodate TTL
Defense Travel System still evaluating the impact CTO – May Require Contract Modification DTS – System Change – Impact unknown at this time
E-Gov Travel Service - TTL will have minimal impact
CTO/TMC – minimal impact as TTL is loaded into Fare Rules for auto cancellation
17
Federal Acquisition Service
Data is not available to compute financial impact, estimates are:
CTO/TMC fees
CTO/TMC fees to issue a new ticket – average fee $27.36 (domestic)
DTMO - $20.00 Full Service - $10.00 Self Service
Voucher fees
Average voucher cost is $12.63 (domestic)
YCA_CA shift
$157 average savings from YCA to _CA
6. Identify impacts of increased changes/cancellations to reservations and re-issued tickets i.e. travel agency fees (CTO/TMC)
18
Federal Acquisition Service
Implement Penalty Fee Findings
19
Federal Acquisition Service
19
1. Assess overall cost impact of penalty fees - Notional
Assume
5% tickets
Assume
10 % tickets
200,000 tickets 400,000 tickets
@ $50 fee $10,000,000
Cost to Gov’t
@ $50 fee $20,000,000
Cost to Gov’t
@ $100 fee $20,000,000
Cost to Gov’t
@ $100 fee
$40,000,000
Cost to Gov’t
Penalties Assume 4,000,000 round trip
tickets are issued
Estimate for $50 and $100 per ticket penalty fee
Consider - No Show Fee vs Cancellation Fee
20
Federal Acquisition Service
20
Impact of TTL and Penalties
CTO/TMC Fees Voucher fees YCA-CA shift Change and Cancellation Penalties
Additional considerations: Administrative and traveler time costs – undetermined Delinquency impact on agencies and IBA holders
21
Federal Acquisition Service
Discuss findings
Next Steps