fee schedule review · 2016-05-26 · finland slovakia france spain germany sweden hungary united...

28
San Francisco’s Safe Drug Disposal Stewardship Ordinance Fee Schedule Review for the Operations Committee, SF Commission on the Environment May 11, 2016

Upload: others

Post on 14-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

San Francisco’s Safe Drug Disposal Stewardship Ordinance

Fee Schedule Review for the Operations Committee, SF Commission on the Environment

May 11, 2016

Page 2: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Environmental Need

Page 3: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Public Safety Need

Page 4: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Where Does Medicine Go?

Page 5: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Home Disposal is Not a Safe Option

Page 6: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Previous Medicine Collection Efforts

Page 7: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

2010 Proposed EPR Ordinance for

Pharmaceuticals

Page 8: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

SF Pilot Program launched April 2012

Page 9: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

12 Independent Pharmacies

Page 10: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

One Community Center

Page 11: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Two-key Collection Bins

Page 12: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

All 10 SF Police Stations Accept All Meds

“Over The Counter”

Page 13: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

71,667 Pounds Collected – Four Years

Page 14: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Local Governments Lead the Way

Alameda County, CA

• Ordinance passed July 2012

• Court challenge by 3 trade groups

• Supreme Court declined to hear case May 2015

• Pharmacy collection to start this month

King County, WA

• Regulations passed June 2013

• Program resumed after Alameda Appeal ruling

• 2 stewardship plans approved

• Pharmacy collection to start in June

Page 15: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

The Same Companies Provide This Program

in Many Other Countries

CANADA

British Columbia

Manitoba

Alberta

Nova Scotia

Prince Edward Island

Saskatchewan Source: Environment Canada

EUROPEAN UNION

Austria Italy

Belgium Lithuania

Czech Republic Netherlands

Denmark Poland

Estonia Portugal

Finland Slovakia

France Spain

Germany Sweden

Hungary United Kingdom

Ireland Source: European Federation of Pharmaceutical

Industries and Associations

Page 16: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

A New Ordinance is Introduced in SF

Page 17: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Double Collection Sites to 55

Page 18: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Voluntary participation as drop-off site

You’re invited!

To all SF

Pharmacies

Page 19: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Mail-back Envelope Alternative

Page 20: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

No Point-of Sale Fee to Consumers

Page 21: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Producer Outreach Responsibilities

Toll free telephone number and

website

Readily-recognizable, consistent

designof drop boxes and signage

Bi-annual surveys of residents and

Healthcare professionals on

awareness, convenience, and

consumer attitudes

All outreach materials must be in

English, Spanish, Chinese, Russian,

and Tagalog

Page 22: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

2015 Ordinance: Responsible Parties’ Roles

Local Government

Producers

Retailers

Wholesalers

Repackagers

Identify

Producers

(Manufacturers)

Submit

Stewardship

Plan and

operate

Program

Review and

approve Plan

Annual

oversight

Enforcement

Page 23: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

2015 Ordinance – What’s Next

Effective

Date

April 25, 2015

Producers Notify

DOE

of Plan Operator

Name

Producers

Submit

Stewardship

Plan

DOE Reviews

and Approves

Plan

Stewardship

Plan is

Operational (if approved on first

submittal)

1. Producers Notify DOE

of Intent to participate

2. Retailers & Repackagers

Notify DOE of Producers

Wholesalers

Notify DOE of

Producers

2m 6m 9m 12m 15m 18m . June 25,

2015

Extended

Nov 28,

2015

Jan 25,

2016

April 25,

2016

July 25,

2016

Oct 25,

2016

Page 24: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Implementation & Oversight Costs

One new temporary FTE at Dept of the

Environment

Contact management and mailings to

Wholesalers, Repackagers, Retailers &

Producers

Review and oversight costs to City will be

recovered through Plan Review Fee and

Annual Operating Fee

Schedule of Fees must be approved by

Commission On The Environment

Page 25: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Plan Review Fee

$70.00/hour - proposed

Initial review of

Stewardship Plans

Review of resubmitted

Plans

Review of applications to

use an Alternative

Disposal Technology

Page 26: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Annual Operating Fee

$35,000/yr per Plan - proposed

Annual Report review

Participant database

maintenance

Identification and follow-up with

“Free Riders”

Enforcement Warning Letters

Random Inspections

Page 27: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

Working with Controller’s Office

Controller’s Office will provide

annual Fee Certification Letter

for both Fees

Page 28: Fee Schedule Review · 2016-05-26 · Finland Slovakia France Spain Germany Sweden Hungary United Kingdom Ireland Source ... 2015 Extended Nov 28, April 25, 2015 Jan 25, 2016 2016

© 2013 SF Environment All Rights Reserved The author of this document has secured the necessary

permission to use all the images depicted in this presentation.

Permission to reuse or repurpose the graphics in this document

should not be assumed nor is it transferable for any other use.

Please do not reproduce or broadcast any content from this

document without written permission from the holder of copyright.

Maggie Johnson

Residential Toxics Reduction Coordinator

[email protected]

415-355-5006