film, television and traditional folk culture in bye bye brazil

Upload: luis-r-cortes

Post on 02-Jun-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    1/12

    Brazilian Cinema Novo [New Cinema] has produced a number of films

    that have circulated

    in

    the United States but perhaps the most familiar to

    American audiences is Carlos Diegues Bye Bye Brasil(l980). In his article,

    Randal Johnson focuses on this i lm which presents Brazil as a country in a

    process of rapid transformation, an agro-pastoral economy giving way to

    rapid industrialization. He notes that running throughout [the work] is a

    subtext which constitutes a good-humored yet critical retrospective of the

    trajectory o Brazilian cinema over the last twenty years and its

    relationship to other conscious-forming media, notably television.

    Johnson examines this subject as well as the complex relationship between

    cinema, television and popular culture as developed through the device of

    the Caravana Rolidei, a small-time circus troupe. Each of i ts characters

    represents a dif ferent aspect of contemporary Brazilian society, and the

    film as a whole presents the panoply of Brazilian culture, a mixture of

    elements from diverse sources, both foreign and domestic.

    Randal Johnson teaches literature and film at the University of

    Florida. He is the co-author of Brazilian Cinema 1982).

    Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture

    in Bye Bye Brasill

    Randal Johnson

    In 1974 Luis Carlos Barreto produced his son Brunos A Estrela Sobe

    The Star Rises),

    the story of the career of

    a

    radio and television performer

    featuring television s ta r Betty Faria. The film was intended

    as

    a means of

    bringing the padrzo Globo de qualidade (the globo standard of quality) into

    Brazilian cinema. The following year Daniel Filho, a well-known television

    producer and direc%r, made the film

    Casal The Couple),

    stamng

    television actors Jose Wilker and Sonia Braga. In tha t same year 1975),

    Jorge Bodansky and Orlando Senas docu-dramaIracema tookup the fallen

    banner of Cinema Nouo [New Cinema] and drew a parallel between the

    prostitution of a young Indian girl and the rape of the Amazon region by the

    Brazilian military government and multinational interests. In 1978 Xavier

    de Oliveiras

    Gargalhada Final [Last Laugh]

    presented

    a

    pair of circus

    performers who find themselves marginalized and unemployed in an age of

    mass communication.

    Carlos Diegues eighth feature film, Bye Bye Brasil 1980),combines

    elements from all of these films into a vast mural of Brazil which isas vaned

    as the country itself. As Diegues himself has observed, his film presents a

    country that is beginning

    to

    disappear, giving way to one that

    is

    just

    beginning to take form.2

    It

    is a Brazil in a process of rapid transformation.

    An agro-pastoral economy

    is

    giving way

    to

    industrialization; the Amazon

    jungle is occupied by multinational corporations while its original Indian

    inhabitants are on the verge of extinction. Television antennas sprout in

    every village. The Elm develops metaphors of prostitution and penetration

    as

    it

    reveals the pollution and destruction of the countrys natural resources

    and the homogenization of its indigenous and folk cultures. It denounces

    the decharacterization wrought by internal and external cultural

    dependence.It includes contraband, Indian chants and the disco beat, rural

    121

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    2/12

    122 Journal

    of

    Popular Culture

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    3/12

    Film, Television and

    Traditional Folk

    Culture

    23

    Brazilian music and Frank Sina tra, an accordian and

    a

    rock band; snow in

    the sertgo [the arid backlands of the Northeast].

    Bye Bye Brasil, dedicated to Brazilians of the twenty-first century,

    juxtapose Brazil of the past, the present and perhaps

    the

    future

    as

    seen

    through

    the

    travels of

    a

    small-time circus troupe,

    the

    Caravana Rolidei (a

    Brazilianization of holiday). The troupe is comprised of yagici an and

    clairvoyant Lord Cigano (Jos6 W i l y ) , exotic dancer Salome (Betty Faria)

    and the strongman Andorinha (Pnncipe Na;bor). In

    a

    small Northeastern

    town they are joined by accordianist Cico (FabioJr.)and

    his

    pregnant wife

    Dasdo (Zaira Zambelli). Like the circus performers in Garg alhada Final,

    the troupe represents

    a

    form of spectacle which finds itself less and less

    viable and on the verge of extinction i n a n

    age

    of mass communications,

    as

    through their travels they experience what Robert Stam calls the

    aftershocks of multinationalization of the Brazil-ian subcontinent., In

    this film of the road, the troupe goes from the

    sertao

    to the sea, then along

    the Trans-Amazonian highway to Altamira in the depths of the Amazon

    jungle, presenting their show to small towns not yet contaminated by

    television. In Altamira Lorde Cigano an d Andorinha lose their truck and

    belongings to

    a

    local hustler-in the service of

    a

    multinational

    corporation-and the trpupe, now in dissolution, catches a boat down-river

    to

    the bordellos of Belem. There they separate, only to meet again some

    time

    later

    in Brasilia, the nations ultra-modern capital.

    Running throughout B ye B ye B r a d is a subtext which constitutes

    a

    good-humored yet critical retrospective of the trajectory of Brazilian cinema

    over the

    last

    twenty years and

    its

    relationship to other consciousness-

    forming media, notably television. Critics have tended to see Diegues film

    as a denunciation of television and its effect on Brazilian ~ u l t u r e . ~close

    reading of the film, however, renders t ha t denunciat ion ambiguous at best.

    Bye B ye Brasi l in fact incorporates television into its diegesis and

    is a

    result

    of a decision on the part of its producer (Luis Carlos Barreto) to incorporate

    elements of television into Brazilian cinema. My purpose in this study is,

    first, to disengage the subtext concerning the development

    of

    Brazilian

    cinema and, secondly,

    to

    examine the relationship between cinema,

    television a nd traditional folk culture as they a re articulated through the

    internal and external conflicts of the Caravana Rolidei.

    Bye Bye Brasil

    rests on

    a

    number of contradictions which, ra ther than invalidat ing it,

    make it a complex and rich discussion of contemporary Brazilian society.

    Throughout his career, Carlos Diegues has shown

    a

    concern with

    different forms of cultural communication and spectacle and with the

    film/spectator relationship, t hat is, how

    a

    film

    is

    perceived and understood

    by the spectator and what mode of cinematic discourse is most conducive to

    that understanding. Such a concern has led him to experiment with

    different cinematic styles an d genres. His preoccupation with spectacle and

    rommunication is often internalized in the films as they self-reflexively

    discuss modes and forms of representation. In

    a

    sequence of

    Ganga

    Zumba

    (1963), for example, slaves act out masterlslave relationships. A Grande

    C idade [The B ig C i t y , 19651which many consider Diegues masterpiece,

    is

    a

    veritable collage of such cinematic styles and genres

    as

    the Western, silent

    melodrama, documentary and police thriller. At the end of the film,

    Calunga its meneur de j eu [narrator] reenacts the films action in a n open-

    air arena. In s Herdeiros The Heirs, 19701,

    a

    mural of Brazilian political

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    4/12

    24

    Jou rna l of Popular Culture

    and cultural history from

    1930

    to

    1964

    seen through the trajetory of

    a

    single,

    bourgeois family, the focus

    is

    on radio, more specifically on the role of the

    Raio Nacional [National Radio] as a consciousness-forming medium

    during the period in question. Quando of Carnaval Chegar When Carnival

    Comes,

    19721

    deals explicitly with spectacle and implicitly with the

    relationship between art and politics as it focuses on

    a

    musical troupe-not

    so different from the Caravana Rolidei-that travels in a gaudily-colored

    bus but that refuses

    to

    play for the King. In this homage to the

    chanchada

    [light musical comedy15 the immediacy of musical spectacle

    is

    questioned as

    it is frequently removed from its context by Gordardian jump cuts and

    is

    distanced from the spectator. The underlying theme of all of Diegues

    films

    is

    in fact Brazilian cinema itself in its multiplicity of themes and

    styles.

    The Caravana Rolideis itinerary recalls Cinema Novos trajectory

    from the early sixties until today.

    Cinema Novo

    initially revealed

    a

    strong

    documentary tendency. Bye Bye B r a d opens with a brief sequence which

    lends it a documentary tone: an extreme long shot of a primitive ferry boat

    crossing the muddy Siib Francisco River, followed by several shots of

    people and merchandise in a small Northeastern river towns open market.

    The Northeast was one of early Cinema NOVOSreferred scenarios. Groups

    of local musicians stroll through the crowds and, to one side, an

    accordianist (Ciso) plays regional music for handouts. After seeing the

    Caravana Rolidei, and infatuated with Salomk, Ci o decides to leave the

    Vidas Secas [Barren Lives,

    1963),

    Cigo tells his father tha t he can nolonger

    live in the sertgo. Just a s Fabian0 and his family in Vidas Secas are forced

    to leave their land, Cico must leave his as well, albeit for different reasons.

    From the sertao the troupe goes to the sea in a geographical

    visualization of the slogan in Glauber Rochas

    Deus e o Diabo nu Terrado

    Sol Black God, White Devil,

    1964

    which prophesies that the sertao will

    become the sea, the sea sertao. But the mythical, utopian sea of Rochas

    film has changed; it is M W polluted with industrial and human wastes.

    Cinema Novo

    arose initially as part of the cultural euphoria of the

    developmentalist period, the ultimate symbol of which was the ultra-

    modern architecture of Brasilia. But the Brasilia seen in

    Bye Bye Br a d

    does not correspond to its original ideal. The democratic hopes of socialist

    architect Oscar Niemeyer and of the developmentalist period have been

    dashed, as the capital itself has become the exclusive residence of

    government bureaucrats while the people who built

    it

    are, like Cico and

    Dasdo, shunted off to outlying satellite slums.

    Cinema Novo initially had difficulty in communicating with a broad

    public. The public that supported the

    chanchada

    in the forties and fifties

    preferred to stay home and watch television. The troupe also has a difficulty

    in finding large audiences to perform to and must also compete against

    television, which has become an audio-visual totem for Brazilians of small

    towns

    as

    well as of the cities. Faced with a market dominated by American

    films: Cinema Novo increasingly turned toward the state for protection,

    subsidies and production financing. The Caravana Roleidei depends on the

    largess of local mayors to be able to perform. Cinema Novo evolved from a

    stance of critical realism to the often hermetic, allegorical discourse of

    tropicalism. The documentary tone of Bye Bye

    Brasils

    initial sequence is

    Northeast and go with them. In a sequence whos f mise en sdne recalls

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    5/12

    Film, Televis ion

    and Traditional Folk

    Culture

    125

    disrupted

    as

    the Caravana rolls into town, loudspeakers blaring

    a

    pop song.

    With the entrance of the Caravana, the film moves to an allegorical register

    tempered by a carnivalesque atyosphere reminiscent of Joaquim Pedro de

    Andrades tropicalist

    Macunazma 1969)

    and Diegues own

    Quando o

    Carnaval Chegar .

    The relationship Lorde Cigano creates with his audience

    is

    analogous

    to that

    between cinema and

    its

    public: sometimes fascinating, sometimes

    tedious, sometimes participatory, other times passive. The link between the

    Caravana R51idei and cinema is rendered explicit when Lorde Cigano

    encounters

    Ze

    da Luz in

    a

    small Northeastern town plagued by drought. Ze

    da

    Luz (Joe of the Light, literally) offers

    a

    form of entertainment

    something like the Caravana: cinema. He travels through the nterior of

    Brazil showing old copies of Gilda de Abreus

    1946

    classic

    Ebrio

    [The

    Drunkard],

    starring her husband, singer Vicente Celestino. Like the

    Caravana, Zgde Luz (played by Jofre Soares)

    is

    marginalized by television

    and by the impoverished econoyic conditions of Brazils interior. The

    situation of Lorde Cigano and Ze da Luz, two sides

    of

    the same coin, is

    analogous once again

    to

    that of Brazilian cinema

    as

    a whole, which has

    historically been marginalized within

    its

    own market.

    The opposition between the Caravana and television, symbolized by

    the ubiquitous fishbones (antennas), would seem

    to

    suggest that

    television

    is

    responsible for the destruction of Brazilian indigenous and folk

    cultures as well as for the homogenization of cultural expression in Brazil.

    We

    see

    the inhabitan -of

    a

    Northeastern village, including the priest and

    mayor, narcotized by Sonia Braga in the

    telenovela

    [television soap opera].

    (Dancin Days (the original title was in English),

    a

    tale of intertwined

    affairs

    among Rio de Janeiros disco crowd. Regional cultures lose out in the

    face of the massive penetration of television images

    as

    the s tandards of

    powerful commercial television networks (especially TV Globo), geared

    largely toward urban audeinces of the south, are imposed upon Brazilians

    throughout the country, with no reciprocity possible.

    Since the military

    coup d etat

    of

    1964

    and especially since the

    implementation of satellite transmission in the late sixties, television has

    become a major instrument in the governments policy of national

    integration. But the integrative goals of s tate communications policy has

    been less than successful, resulting in what Carlos Diegues refers to as

    internal cultural imperialism.? According to

    Dov

    Shinar and Marco

    Antonio Rodrigues Dias, 77 per cent of the total television broadcasting

    power

    is

    located in state capitals with

    45

    per cent concentrated in the

    prosperous States of Rio de Janeiro a nd Sao Paulo.a They continue:

    A few integrative sideeffects of broadcasting n Brazil can be observed. Because

    of radio and television, a standardized Brazilian Portuguese language is replacing

    the different accents and regional expressions which predominated until the 1940s

    and

    1950s.

    The carioca Rio de Janeiro) way of speaking has been adopted in all

    corners

    o

    Brazil, probably thanks to the electronic media and

    t

    the fact that Rio has

    been traditionally considered the culture center of the country.9

    The result of the pattern of growth

    of

    television over the last twenty years

    ha s been

    a

    one-sided flow of communication, which inevitably results in the

    homogenization of cultural expression.

    The

    process

    of cultural decharacterization and homogenization

    is

    most

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    6/12

    26 J o u r n a l of Popula r Cul tu re

    strikingly poignant in the sequence where Lorde Cigano an d he Caravana

    meet

    a

    group of Cruari Indians along the Trans-Amazonian highway. This

    sequence calls into question highly ideological interpretations of Brazil and

    its

    culture.

    The

    Indians are no longer the noble savages of Jose de

    Alencars Romantic novels, nor the proud cannibals of Oswald de

    Andrades cannibalist movement of Brazilian literary modernism (and

    subsequently of Nelson Pereira dos Santos 1972 film, H ow T a s ty w a s m y

    Li t tl e F renchman) .Rather, they are sickly

    and

    poverty-stricken, much like

    the Indians pictured in such recent Brazilian documentaries

    as Raoni

    1978), by Luis Carlos Saldanha and Je an Pierre Dutilleux and Terra

    dos

    Indios Land

    of

    the Indians, 1979 by Zelito Viana.

    The Indians village has been destroyed and,

    as

    the chief says, they

    want to go to town to pacify the whites, a remark which ironizes genocidal

    pacification programs of the Brazilian government. Their society has been

    decimated and their culture decharacterized. The children carry toy

    airplanes and television sets carved out of wood. Their grandmother listens

    to the Everley Brothers version of Bye Bye Love on the transistor radio

    glued to her wr . They go to town and discover ice cream, Coca Cola and

    color television, which, significantly, transmits nothing but the pre-

    program color pattern. Television, however, is only par t of a larger process

    of the gradual extinction of indigenous cultures. It is only one of the more

    visible components of the advanced technology which ha s brought isolated

    an d feudal regions

    of

    Brazil into the space

    age

    (it s significant that Brazils

    final link-up to international satellite transmission systems occurred in

    1969

    shortly before the f irs t moon landing). iiThile television may have had

    a negative effect on the Indians , so too does Lorde Cigano. Upon seeing

    them along the road, he takes from the chief the only natural thing they

    possess: a monkey. The monkey, in Lorde Ciganos hands, becomes jus t

    another commodity which he loses, together with the truck, to the hustler in

    Altamira. While he is concerned with his own marginalization, he

    symbolically participates in the increased marginalization of the Indians

    by expropriating what is theirs.

    Bye B ye Brasils critique of television, however, is rendered ambiguous

    in the diegesis an d also-and perhaps more importantly-in its mode of

    production. If,

    as

    I

    have suggested, the Caravana Rolidei allegorically

    represents Brazilian cinema itself, then it is in

    a

    sense equated with

    television. The entertainment offered by the Caravana is neither better nor

    worse than that offered by television. If TV Globo offers a n Americanized

    telenovela (Dancin Days), then the Caravana offers visions of snow in

    the sertz-the dream of all Brazilians,

    says

    Lorde Cigano-to the

    sounds of Bing Crosbys White Christmas.: If television presents false or

    spurious values, promising a paradise of consumerism, so too does Lorde

    Cigano offer the credulous

    a

    vision of an earthly utopia. Like Dancin

    Days, B ye Bye B r a d also has a title in English. Its soundtrack is a

    veritable pot-pourri of national and international music, including Frank

    Sinat ra singing the Brazilian classic Aquarela do Brasil (Brazil, in i ts

    English version). The difference between the two forms of spectacle is the

    degree of penetration achieved by each and in this sense the Caravana-

    and Brazilian cinema-cannot Compete.

    There are Some 15 million television sets in use in Brazil by some 60

    million telespectators.10 The Globo organization has been the

    tnost

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    7/12

    Film, Television an d Traditional Folk Culture

    27

    successful of the Brazilian teIevision networks, accounting for up to 90

    percent of the viewing audience. The penetration of television on a nation-

    wide basis

    is

    on a scale unprecedented in Brazilian cultural history. While

    some 30 to 4 million people may watch a Globo

    telenovela

    on any given

    weekday night, in

    its first

    year of exhibition

    B ye B ye

    Brasil the

    fifth most

    popular national film exhibited in Brazil in 1980-drew only 1,335,000

    spectators. The total number of spectators for all of Brazilian cinema

    is

    on

    the order of 60

    to

    70 million per year,12a figure easily reached by Globos

    eight oclock novela in less than a week.

    The problem is not that television has achieved a high degree of

    penetration, but rather t ha t it

    is

    controlled, through advertising and other

    economic imperatives, by multinational intersts. Fifty-seven percent of all

    Brazilian television programming consists of foreign (read United States)

    series and films. As Jog0 Silveira Raoul notes, television acts as an

    instrument in the substitution of Brazilian cultural standards through the

    massive importation of canned program^. '^ Bye B ye Bras i l ,however, does

    not so much criticize television as it implicity calls for its democratization

    and

    its

    integration with other national forms of expression such as cinema.

    Television in Brazil deveioped independently of cinema. When

    television was inaugurated in Sao Paulo in 1950, other entrepreneurs from

    this industrial city were engaged in the creation, with capital from the

    Matarazzo group, of the ill-fated Vera Cruz Film Studios.14 Since cinema

    had not been able to establish itself with the countrys potential audience as

    a

    strong audio-visual tradition, television had to depend on its own

    resources and on certain forms of presentation that

    it

    borrowed from radio.

    With

    C inema Novo there was no question about participating with

    television, since the new medium was not taken particularly seriously by

    filmmakers. The result has been a total lack of integration of cinema and

    television in Brazil. In 1975 of 1,329 films exhibited by Rio de Janeiro

    television stations, only six were Brazilian.15

    While national cinema has largely been unable to penetrate television

    (with some exceptions), in the last few years television has exerted a

    considerable influence on cinema.

    B ye B ye B r a d

    is one of a number of

    recent films which explicitly discuss the role of television in mdoern

    Brazilian society (others: Arnaldo Jabors

    Eu te Amo

    [I Love You, 19811and

    Antonio Calmons

    Novela das Oi to [Eight OClock Novela ,

    19811, u s t as it

    is

    one of a number of films that borrow elements from television in its

    production.

    It is

    the latest in

    a

    line of production developed since the mid-

    1970s

    by producer Luis Carlos Barreto and.others which takes advantage of

    the popularity of television star s (in this case Jose Wilker, Betty Faria and

    Fib io Jr.). This line of production began in 1974 with Bruno Barretos A

    Estrela Sobe Th eStar Rises),

    a story of a radio and television star played by

    Betty Faria and continues with the same directors Dona Flor e seus Dois

    Maridos Dona Flor and Her Two Hu sband s) , 1976. Dona Flor, the most

    successful Brazilian film in history, not only starred television actress

    S h i a Braga (fresh from the novela Gabriela) and JosQWilker, but was

    also based on a massive television advertising campaign. Like these others,

    Bye B ye B r a d

    depends at least in part on television for its success.

    The films discussion of television continues and perhaps deepens

    through a conflict within the Caravana Rolidei between Lorde Cigano and

    Cico.

    The oppos t on between them is aprt of a larger opposition between

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    8/12

    28 Journal of Popular Culture

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    9/12

    Film, Televis ion and Traditional Folk Culture

    129

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    10/12

    130

    Journal of

    Popula r Cul tu re

    traditional artisan culture (Cigos regional music) and industrialized

    culture (cinema and television). The Caravana Rolidei would at first glance

    seem to be a n intermediary cultural form which atttempts to incorporate

    elements of both traditional and industrialized culture. In the films first

    sequence, the Caravana rolls into town, loudspeakers blaring and drowns

    out Cisos music with

    a

    pop song. When Cigo asks Lorde Cigano to let him

    join the troupe, claiming tha t he can play the accordian, Lorde Cigano

    responds condescendingly, we have

    a

    record player.

    Lord Cigano and h is Caravana , like cinema and television, represent a

    predominantly urban phenomenon trying to impose itself on the

    predominantly rura l space of the small villages they visit. Cifo, on the other

    hand,

    is a

    rural musician. Although

    it

    ha s never aimed

    at a

    rural audience,

    Cinema Novo

    was also an urban phenomenon th at frequently took rural

    topics as its subject. The opposition between urban, rural, industr ial and

    traditional,

    is

    developed through what might be called the films embedded

    detail: scenes of

    Rio de

    Janeiro and o aulo painted on the t rucks doors;

    continued references

    to

    the troupes itinerary (after a n extended tour in Sao

    Paulo and the rest of the South of the country.. .); Lorde Ciganos

    Copacabana T-shirts.

    Lorde Ciganos dream

    is

    to find

    a

    place without television, not because

    he is concerned about its impact on Brazilian culture, but rather because it

    is

    a

    factor in his economic marginalization. He ha s a utopian vision of the

    world and longs for the place where pineapples are the size

    of

    watermelons. He dreams of wealth and finally achieves it-not through

    his magic performances, but rather through contraband and Salomes

    prostitution. He is not afraid of change and adventure and he realizes that

    he must go forward at all costs. We have to keep rolling, he says, or we

    will fal l off and screw ourselves. He

    is

    the eternal artistic gypsy

    cigano,

    n

    Portuguese) in search of the perfect spectacle an d the perfect audience. At

    the same time, he continues to be the huckster who promises hi s audiences

    the undeliverable.

    Ci$o, on the other hand, dreams of the sea and he departs with the

    Caravana as if on

    a

    magic carpet

    to

    the land of h is fantasy. He represents

    an essentially conservative ideology based on tradition and the

    permanence of values. His name

    is

    that of the Northeasts b,eloved Padre

    Clcero, Cifo for short. While Lorde Cigano pimps for Salome throughout,

    Cifo refuses to follow his example with Dasd8. At the end of the film, the

    contrast between the two becomes even clearer when g c o refuses to

    accompany the new, improved Caravana Rolidey (now w t h y) to the

    territory of Rondonia in search of new audiences. Rather, he decides to stay

    in Brazilia with his wife and daughter, playing

    at a

    local

    forro

    [dance hall]

    and billed

    as

    the accordianist of the plateau.

    Both Lorde Cigano and Ciqo have by this time incorporated television

    into their acts. h r d e Ciganos new truck has two screens on one side and

    Ci5o an d his band play on

    a

    stage behind six television sets which transmit

    their image to the immediate public. The Caravana Rolidey, advertising

    itself with neon lights an d sexual imagery (reflective of the current luxury

    an d sex phase of Brazilian cinema?) ha s also incorporated

    a

    troupe of go-

    go

    girls a nd become

    a

    rolling bordello. Ci50, in contrast, has incorporated

    his wife an d child into his band. His advertising, in opposition to the gaudy

    neon lights of the Caravans,

    is

    drawn from the traditional wood carvings of

    the Brazilian interior. ci s use of television, in sharp contrast to the

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    11/12

    Film.

    Television

    and Traditional Folk Culture

    3

    earlier mesmerization of villagers by the

    telenovela

    Dancin Days seems

    to exemplify

    a

    democratization of television itself. Despite the fact that

    CiFo, like Lorde Cigano, has transformed his appearance, he remains

    closer,

    so

    to speak,

    to

    the roots. His music

    is

    for a melting-pot of workers

    from all over Brazil,

    a

    fact seen in the different dancing styles (not disco)

    revealed in the dance hall.

    If Ci2o represents traditional popular culture (i.e., of the people), then

    what does the film s ay about him and popular culture in general?

    First

    of

    all, By e Bye Brasil seems to reject the notion

    that

    there exists somehow a

    pure, untainted Brazilian culture. Ci o is not without

    his

    own elements of

    make-up, his use of television, even hi s use of a n accordian,which

    is

    in itself

    the product of a culture industry. Brazilian culture, rather, is a mixture of

    elements from diverse sources, both foreign and domestic. The cultural

    formation of Brazilians includes Bing Crosby, Frank Sinatra ,disco an d the

    Everley Brothers, just

    to

    mention those in the film.

    It

    also includes strong

    Indian and Black contributions. It

    is

    both urban and rural, both national

    and international, both positive an d negative.

    B ye Bye B r a d

    thus rightly

    proposes

    a salutary

    form of cultural anthropophagy in which the origin of

    cuItural elements is

    less

    important than the way they are assimilated and

    re-elaborated.

    It would

    be

    erroneous to say that the directors sympathies lie

    exclusively with Cico and his traditional values. Such a position would

    contradict the very nature of filmmaking in Brazil. Lorde Cigano is Carlos

    Diegues, or

    at

    least his alter-ego: a n urban artist who has travelled the long

    roads of Brazil in search of the perfect audience an d the optimum form of

    spectacle. He knows the frustration of empty theatres, the difficulty of

    economic survival based on his

    art

    alone, the contradictions of his art . His

    cinema has evolved from the relative poverty of Ganga

    Zumba to

    the

    relative luxury of Bye B ye Brasil , from the esthetic of hunger to a more

    commercially oriented and more communicative esthetic of artistic

    pluralism. Like Lorde Cigano, Carlos Diegues ha s been figuratively run out

    of town by critics, but more importantly, like Lord Cigano, Diegues knows

    that the only choice

    is to

    go forward in search of the artists utopia.

    hucksterism: the show-business clo hes he wears in Brasilia, his stage

    Notes

    Bye Bye Brasil

    is

    distributed in the United States by New Yorker.

    LFrom the press book of Bye Bye Brasil.

    3Robert Stam, Bye Bye Brasil, Cineaste, XI, ,o.

    1

    (Winter 1980-1981),pp. 34-36.

    See

    for example, Reinaldo da Costa, Transicao, Transitivo, Televisivo, Filme Cultura,

    XIV, no. 37 (January-March 1981), pp, 70-72.

    5The chanchada is a light musical comeciy which began i n the mid-1930s with Adhemar

    Gonzagas A16 A16Brasil(1935)and

    A 6

    lo

    Carnaual(1936), both of which featured Carmen

    Miranda. It was

    a

    very popular cinematic genre through the forties and into the fifties before it

    began

    to

    lose its audience to television.

    6BeCause of foreign domination of the domestic film market, the Brazilian government ha s

    imposed, since the 1930s, screen quotas for national films. As of today all theatres in the country

    must program Brazilian films for at least 140 days per year.

    7Jornaldo Brasil,

    5

    August 1979.

    n D ~ ~hinar and Marco Andnio Rodrigues Dias, Communications Policy in Brazil, in

    Teheranian, Hakimzadeh and Vidale, eds. Communications Policy for National Development:

    Comparative Perspective (London: Routledge Kegan Pau l, 1977), p. 233.

  • 8/10/2019 Film, Television and Traditional Folk Culture in Bye Bye Brazil

    12/12

    132

    Journal

    of

    Popular Culture

    yIbid.

    Decio Eignatari, oder global e o fim do improviso,

    Jornal

    da Tarde,5 anuary 1980.

    Embrafilme: Relatorio da Directoria,

    Gazeta Mercantil, 2527

    April

    1981.

    1ZLei B&ca do Cinema Brasileiro,

    Filme Cultura,

    no. 33 (May

    1979),

    .

    114.

    1 J J o ~ kilveira Raou1,;O Desenvolvimento da Televisao no Brasil,

    Suplemento do

    Centenario, Estado de Sao Paulo,

    4

    October

    1975.

    *Vera Cruz attempted to create

    a

    studio system based on the MGM studios in Hollywood.

    While it managed to improve the technical quality of Brazilian cinema, it made many errors. It

    gauged its production for the international market and left distribution in the hands of Columbia

    Pictures. It inflated productions costa way above the lucrative potential of the Brazilian market.

    Vera Cruz went bankrupt in 1954afterproducing

    8

    eatures, the most famous of which was Lime

    Barretos Cangaceiro. For a discussion of Vera Cruz see Maria Rita Galv&, Vera Cruz: A

    Brazilian Hollywood, in Randal Johnson and Robert Stam, ed.,Brazilian Cinema (Rutherford,

    N.J.: Fairleigh Dickinson Univ. Press, 1982),pp. 270-280.

    15Estat&icas

    76,

    Cinemateca do Museu de Arte Moderna, Ria de Janeiro, n.d.

    Randal Johnson, a frequent visitor to Brazil, teaches literature and film at the University of

    Florida. He

    is

    the author of

    Cinema

    N O V O

    5:

    Masters

    o f

    Contemporary Brazilian Film,

    1984)

    and

    Literatura e Cinema: Macunaima

    do

    Moderniamo nu Literatura ao Cinema, 1982).

    ogether

    with Robert Stam he is coeditor of

    Brazilian Cinema 1982).