findings presentation - lancaster city alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · findings presentation. project...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Agenda• Project Goals & Methodology
• Parking Inventory & Occupancy
• Land Use-based Demand
• Online Questionnaire
• Development Projections
• Future Forecasting
• Future Demand under Emerging Trends
Findings Presentation
![Page 2: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Project Goals
• Analyze existing parking supply and demand
• Model land-use based parking demand
• Forecast future parking surplus or deficit
• Consider impact of current and future transportation alternatives and technologies
• Engage the community in dialogue about parking challenges and opportunities
![Page 3: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Assessment of Existing Conditions
• Study Area Boundary & Block Coding
• Inventory of Public and Private On- and Off-
Street Spaces
• Peak Weekday Parking Utilization during a
typical day
• Lancaster Parking Authority Utilization without
a Special Event
• Parking Utilization versus Parking Demand
• Sample of Online Questionnaire Findings
![Page 4: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Figure 2: Study Area Boundary and Block CodingDowntown Core, Lancaster, PA
Block Number#
N Q
uee
n S
t
N M
arke
t St
N P
rin
ce S
t
N W
ater
St
N A
rch
St
N M
ulb
erry
St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
N D
uke
St
N C
he
rry
St
N L
ime
St
S Q
uee
n S
t
Be
aver
St
S P
rin
ce S
t
S W
ater
St
S M
ulb
erry
St
S C
hri
stia
n S
t
S D
uke
St
S Li
me
St
W Lemon St
W Walnut St
W Chestnut St
W Orange St
W King St
W Vine St
E Lemon St
E Walnut St
E Chestnut St
E Orange St
E King St
E Vine St
W Farnum St E Farnum St
E Madison St
E Marion StE Marion StW Marion StW Marion St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
E Grant StW Grant St
N M
arke
t St
E Mifflin StW Mifflin St
S A
rch
St
Washington St
Study Area Boundary
![Page 5: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Block NumberOff-Street Spaces in BlockOff-Street Parking LotLPA Lot
#
#Figure 4: Public and Private Off-Street
Parking Locations and InventoryDowntown Core, Lancaster, PA
N Q
uee
n S
t
N M
arke
t St
N P
rin
ce S
t
N W
ater
St
N A
rch
St
N M
ulb
erry
St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
N D
uke
St
N C
he
rry
St
N L
ime
St
S Q
uee
n S
t
Be
aver
St
S P
rin
ce S
t
S W
ater
St
S M
ulb
erry
St
S C
hri
stia
n S
t
S D
uke
St
S Li
me
St
W Lemon St
W Walnut St
W Chestnut St
W Orange St
W King St
W Vine St
E Lemon St
E Walnut St
E Chestnut St
E Orange St
E King St
E Vine St
W Farnum St E Farnum St
E Madison St
E Marion StE Marion StW Marion StW Marion St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
E Grant StW Grant St
N M
arke
t St
E Mifflin StW Mifflin St
S A
rch
St
Washington St
North Cherry Street Lot
(44 spaces)
South Cherry Street Lot
(67 spaces)
Water Street Garage
(609 spaces)
Duke Street Garage(519 spaces)
Prince Street Garage
(1,126 spaces)
Penn Square Garage(759 spaces)
East King Street Garage(487 spaces)
Mifflin Lot(39 spaces)
Central Garage(755 spaces)
Study Area Boundary
![Page 6: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Figure 9: Peak Public and Private Off-Street Parking Occupancy
Downtown Core, Lancaster, PA
Off-Street Spaces Occupied0-49% 50-69%
70-84% 85-100%>100% LPA Lot
Block No.#
N Q
uee
n S
t
N M
arke
t St
N P
rin
ce S
t
N W
ater
St
N A
rch
St
N M
ulb
erry
St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
N D
uke
St
N C
he
rry
St
N L
ime
St
S Q
uee
n S
t
Be
aver
St
S P
rin
ce S
t
S W
ater
St
S M
ulb
erry
St
S C
hri
stia
n S
t
S D
uke
St
S Li
me
St
W Lemon St
W Walnut St
W Chestnut St
W Orange St
W King St
W Vine St
E Lemon St
E Walnut St
E Chestnut St
E Orange St
E King St
E Vine St
W Farnum St E Farnum St
E Madison St
E Marion StE Marion StW Marion StW Marion St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
E Grant StW Grant St
N M
arke
t St
E Mifflin StW Mifflin St
S A
rch
St
Washington St
North Cherry Street Lot
(44 spaces)
South Cherry Street Lot
(67 spaces)
Water Street Garage
(609 spaces)
Duke Street Garage(519 spaces)
Prince Street Garage
(1,126 spaces)
Penn Square Garage(759 spaces)
East King Street Garage(487 spaces)
Mifflin Lot(39 spaces)
Central Garage(755 spaces)
Study Area Boundary
![Page 7: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
On-Street Spaces Occupied0-49% 50-69%
70-84% 85-100%>100% No Parking
Block No.#
Figure 10: Peak On-Street Parking OccupancyDowntown Core, Lancaster, PA
N Q
uee
n S
t
N M
arke
t St
N P
rin
ce S
t
N W
ater
St
N A
rch
St
N M
ulb
erry
St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
N D
uke
St
N C
he
rry
St
N L
ime
St
S Q
uee
n S
t
Be
aver
St
S P
rin
ce S
t
S W
ater
St
S M
ulb
erry
St
S C
hri
stia
n S
t
S D
uke
St
S Li
me
St
W Lemon St
W Walnut St
W Chestnut St
W Orange St
W King St
W Vine St
E Lemon St
E Walnut St
E Chestnut St
E Orange St
E King St
E Vine St
W Farnum St E Farnum St
E Madison St
E Marion StE Marion StW Marion StW Marion St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
E Grant StW Grant St
N M
arke
t St
E Mifflin StW Mifflin St
S A
rch
St
Washington St
Study Area Boundary
![Page 8: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Figure 11: Peak Combined (Off-Street and On-Street) Parking Occupancy
Downtown Core, Lancaster, PA
Total Spaces Occupied0-49% 50-69%
70-84% 85-100%>100%
Block No.#
N Q
uee
n S
t
N M
arke
t St
N P
rin
ce S
t
N W
ater
St
N A
rch
St
N M
ulb
erry
St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
N D
uke
St
N C
he
rry
St
N L
ime
St
S Q
uee
n S
t
Be
aver
St
S P
rin
ce S
t
S W
ater
St
S M
ulb
erry
St
S C
hri
stia
n S
t
S D
uke
St
S Li
me
St
W Lemon St
W Walnut St
W Chestnut St
W Orange St
W King St
W Vine St
E Lemon St
E Walnut St
E Chestnut St
E Orange St
E King St
E Vine St
W Farnum St E Farnum St
E Madison St
E Marion StE Marion StW Marion StW Marion St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
E Grant StW Grant St
N M
arke
t St
E Mifflin StW Mifflin St
S A
rch
St
Washington St
Study Area Boundary
![Page 9: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Figure 15: Estimated Existing Peak Parking Surplus/Deficit based on Land-Use Demand
Downtown Core, Lancaster, PA
Demand / Available Spaces0-49% 50-69%
70-84% 85-100%>100% Surplus Spaces
Block No. Deficit Spaces#
#
#
N Q
uee
n S
t
N M
arke
t St
N P
rin
ce S
t
N W
ater
St
N A
rch
St
N M
ulb
erry
St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
N D
uke
St N C
he
rry
St
N L
ime
St
S Q
uee
n S
t
Be
aver
St
S P
rin
ce S
t
S W
ater
St
S M
ulb
erry
St
S C
hri
stia
n S
t
S D
uke
St
S Li
me
St
W Lemon St
W Walnut St
W Chestnut St
W Orange St
W King St
W Vine St
E Lemon St
E Walnut St
E Chestnut St
E Orange St
E King St
E Vine St
W Farnum St E Farnum St
E Madison St
E Marion StE Marion StW Marion StW Marion St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
E Grant StW Grant St
N M
arke
t St
E Mifflin StW Mifflin St
S A
rch
St
Washington St
Study Area BoundaryLPA Parking Facilities500-ft Radius from LPA Facilities
![Page 10: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Public Off-Street Parking Occupancy
![Page 11: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
46%
7%
25%
22%
Mostly adequate; occasionallyit can be tough to find a spotquickly.
Never adequate; every time I come to this neighborhood, it’s difficult to park.
Rarely adequate; I usuallydrive around before I findparking.
Very adequate; I never have ahard time finding a reasonableparking spot.
17%
29%
34%
17%
3%Excellent – no significant problemsGood
Average
Bad
Terrible – I avoid coming to that area.
“Overall, how would you rate the parking?"
“In general, how adequate is the parking supply?"
23%
40%
31%
6%
I am able to find parkingimmediately.
Less than 5 minutes
5 to 10 minutes
More than 10 minutes
"How much time do you typically spend looking for a parking space as a driver or passenger of a car?"
Online QuestionnaireOnline Questionnaire
![Page 12: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Forecasting of Future Conditions
• Known, Proposed, & Potential Development
Activity
• Future Block Surplus or Deficit Estimates
• Future Block Surplus or Deficit with Potential
Reductions in Demand
![Page 13: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Marriott Expansion / Hotel Lancaster
Bulova Site (101NQ)
Hotel Lancaster / Holiday Inn renovation
Prince Street Park retail pop-up
Prince Street Garage site
Fulton Financial Corporation expansion
Excelsior Building
City Crossing Lot
Lancaster Marriott at Penn Square:
East Tower
Swan BnB
Southern Market
North Queen Street retail
North Prince residential/retail mixed use
Queen & Vine Site
Market District sites
Queen & Chestnut infill
Figure 17: Known, Proposed, and Potential Development Impact
Downtown Core, Lancaster, PA
Block Number#
Development
Library & LPA Garage
N Q
uee
n S
t
N M
arke
t St
N P
rin
ce S
t
N W
ater
St
N A
rch
St
N M
ulb
erry
St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
N D
uke
St
N C
he
rry
St
N L
ime
St
S Q
uee
n S
t
Be
aver
St
S P
rin
ce S
t
S W
ater
St
S M
ulb
erry
St
S C
hri
stia
n S
t
S D
uke
St
S Li
me
St
W Lemon St
W Walnut St
W Chestnut St
W Orange St
W King St
W Vine St
E Lemon St
E Walnut St
E Chestnut St
E Orange St
E King St
E Vine St
W Farnum St E Farnum St
E Madison St
E Marion StE Marion StW Marion StW Marion St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
E Grant StW Grant St
N M
arke
t St
E Mifflin StW Mifflin St
S A
rch
St
Washington St
Study Area Boundary
![Page 14: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
- Figure 19: Known, Proposed, and Potential Development Impact
- Downtown Core, Lancaster, PA
Demand / Available Spaces0-49% 50-69%
70-84% 85-100%>100% Surplus Spaces
Block No. Deficit Spaces#
#
#
N Q
uee
n S
t
N M
arke
t St
N P
rin
ce S
t
N W
ater
St
N A
rch
St
N M
ulb
erry
St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
N D
uke
St N C
he
rry
St
N L
ime
St
S Q
uee
n S
t
Be
aver
St
S P
rin
ce S
t
S W
ater
St
S M
ulb
erry
St
S C
hri
stia
n S
t
S D
uke
St
S Li
me
St
W Lemon St
W Walnut St
W Chestnut St
W Orange St
W King St
W Vine St
E Lemon St
E Walnut St
E Chestnut St
E Orange St
E King St
E Vine St
W Farnum St E Farnum St
E Madison St
E Marion StE Marion StW Marion StW Marion St
N C
hri
stia
n S
t
E Grant StW Grant St
N M
arke
t St
E Mifflin StW Mifflin St
S A
rch
St
Washington St
Study Area BoundaryLPA Parking Facilities500-ft Radius from LPA Facilities
![Page 15: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
LPA Off-Street Parking Inventory w/out Central Garage = 3.736
LPA Off-Street Parking Inventory w/out Central but with Proposed Lancaster Square Garage = 4,036
LPA Public Off-Street Capture with Future Development
![Page 16: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
LPA Off-Street Parking Inventory w/out Central Garage = 3.736
LPA Off-Street Parking Inventory w/out Central but with Proposed Lancaster Square Garage = 4,036
LPA Public Off-Street Capture with Future Development and a Large Convention Center Event
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
4,500
6 a.m. 7 a.m. 8 a.m. 9 a.m. 10 a.m.11 a.m. 12p.m.
1 p.m. 2 p.m. 3 p.m. 4 p.m. 5 p.m. 6 p.m. 7 p.m. 8 p.m. 9 p.m. 10p.m.
11p.m.
12 a.m.
LPA Total Occupancy Convention Center Event Future Development Demand
LPA Capacity w/out Proposed
Lancaster Square Garage = 3,736
spaces
LPA Capacity = 4,036 spaces
![Page 17: Findings Presentation - Lancaster City Alliance · 2019. 8. 2. · Findings Presentation. Project Goals •Analyze existing parking supply and demand •Model land-use based parking](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022081400/60a1113c9286410df4530c5b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Public Comments & Questions