fine wine auction 2012

76

Upload: upper-canada-college

Post on 28-Mar-2016

229 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Upper Canada College Fine Wine Auction

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Fine Wine Auction 2012
Page 2: Fine Wine Auction 2012

LOT #44

PHOTO: JANE SOUTHEY

Page 3: Fine Wine Auction 2012

U p p e r C a n a d a C o l l e g e

p r e s e n t s

FINE WINE AUCTION

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Registration,Wine Tasting & Hors d’oeuvres 6:30 p.m.

Live Auction 7:30 p.m.

Auctioneers Albert Schultz and Arron Barberian

Upper Canada CollegeGeorge Weston Hall

Prepatory School 200 Lonsdale Road

Toronto

Proceeds from the Believe in Blue Fine Wine Auction will support upgrading the Upper School science wing, increasing needs-based scholarships and enhancing boarding facilites.

BELIEVE IN BOYS BELIEVE IN OPPORTUNITIES BELIEVE IN THE FUTURE

1

Page 4: Fine Wine Auction 2012

TABLE OF CONTENTS

MESSAGE FROM THE...

GALA CO-CHAIRS 4

FINE WINE AUCTION CO-CHAIRS 5

NORMAN HARDIE WINE TASTING 6

ENTERTAINMENT 7

AUCTIONEERS 9

INVENTORY MANAGEMENT 10

WINE DONORS 11

LEVEL/ULLAGE DESCRIPTIONS 13

BIDDING PROCEDURE 14

FINE WINE AUCTION LOTS 16

TERMS & CONDITIONS 61

ABSENTEE BID FORM 62

THANK YOU TO OUR SPONSORS 64

FINE WINE AUCTION COMMITTEE 71

FINANCIAL BENEFITS - PURCHASING AT OUR AUCTION 12

FINE WINE DIRECTORY

AUSTRALIA 16

CANADA 19

FRANCE 19

LEBANON 46

ITALY 47

PORTUGAL 50

SCOTLAND 51

USA 51

PHOTO: JANE SOUTHEY

Page 5: Fine Wine Auction 2012

TABLE OF CONTENTS

MESSAGE FROM THE...

GALA CO-CHAIRS 4

FINE WINE AUCTION CO-CHAIRS 5

NORMAN HARDIE WINE TASTING 6

ENTERTAINMENT 7

AUCTIONEERS 9

INVENTORY MANAGEMENT 10

WINE DONORS 11

LEVEL/ULLAGE DESCRIPTIONS 13

BIDDING PROCEDURE 14

FINE WINE AUCTION LOTS 16

TERMS & CONDITIONS 61

ABSENTEE BID FORM 62

THANK YOU TO OUR SPONSORS 64

FINE WINE AUCTION COMMITTEE 71

FINANCIAL BENEFITS - PURCHASING AT OUR AUCTION 12

FINE WINE DIRECTORY

AUSTRALIA 16

CANADA 19

FRANCE 19

LEBANON 46

ITALY 47

PORTUGAL 50

SCOTLAND 51

USA 51

PHOTO: JANE SOUTHEY

Page 6: Fine Wine Auction 2012

A MESSAGE FROM THEBELIEVE IN BLUE CO-CHAIRS

April 18, 2012

As co-chairs of the Believe in Blue Gala, Michelle and I are overwhelmed by the energy of the volunteers and by the generosity of the UCC community. Both are evident in abundance at the Mad for Blue Fine Wine Auction.

The acquisitions committee sourced some fantastic vintages, while the Fine Wine Auction committee has put together a wonderful program for the evening.We’ll celebrate a love for fine wine, with all proceeds supporting important initiatives at UCC.

So please enjoy and bid enthusiastically. It’s for the boys.

Cheers,

Pat and Michelle MeneleyParents of Daniel ‘11, Ryan ‘13, Liam ‘16 and Declan ‘22

PAT AND MICHELLE MENELEY

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

4

Page 7: Fine Wine Auction 2012

A MESSAGE FROM THEFINE WINE AUCTION CO-CHAIRS

April 18, 2012

On behalf of the UCC fine wine and advisory com-mittee, we’re delighted to welcome you to the Mad for Blue Fine Wine Auction. This spectacular evening will include an array of activities and experiences

that will delight the five senses and offer special treats for the taste buds and pal-ate. This precursor event to the Believe in Blue Gala is destined to benefit future generations of UCC boys, as well as to provide opportunities to boys who deserve to get the best education from our elite institute.

An event such as this is about much more than money. This is about coming to-gether as a community to celebrate the success of UCC and to attain our common vision.

We offer heartfelt thanks to the extraordinary generosity shown by those who made donations to this auction. We also sincerely thank Albert Schultz and Arron Barberian for donating their time, expertise and enthusiasm as our auctioneers for the evening. This is the third time this dynamic duo has taken on these key roles for the UCC Fine Wine Auction.

Michelle and Pat Meneley deserve special recognition and a huge thank you, along with the gala committee members, for their inspiring leadership. Looking back, we had so much fun working with a team of talented and dedicated individuals and volunteers who’ve applied their skills and energy to create this Mad Men-themed event. Looking forward, we have a memorable and enchanting evening before us in which we’ll be able to stock up our cellars and enjoy this time with good friends of the College who are united towards a good cause.

Cheers,

Frances and Edward Lee

FRANCES AND EDWARD LEE

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

5

Page 8: Fine Wine Auction 2012

NORMAN HARDIE

Norman’s insatiable thirst for old world Pinot Noir and

Chardonnay was cultivated during his wine studies at

the University of Dijon before he worked as a som-

melier for seven years with Four Seasons Hotels and

Resorts. He then apprenticed with the finest Pinot

Noir and Chardonnay producers in the United States,

France, South Africa and New Zealand for six years. He put down roots in the promising

limestone soils of Ontario’s Prince Edward County in 2001, and his wines have since re-

ceived stunning reviews and can be found in top restaurants and shops around the world.

Chardonnay 2009 VQA Niagara Peninsula – 90+, Stephen Tanzer, IWC

Pinot Noir 2009 VQA Niagara Peninsula – 4 1/2 stars, Chris Waters, Vines

County Pinot Noir 2009 – 92 points, John Szabo, Master Sommelier

Riesling 2010 VQA Ontario – 4 1/2 stars, Michael Pinkus, Ontario Wine Review

Cuvee L Chardonnay 2008 VQA Ontario – 94, Natalie McClean

Cuvee L Pinot Noir 2009 VQA Ontario – 91+, Steven Tanzer, IWC

NORMAN HARDIE WINERY AND VINEYARDMAD FOR BLUE | WINE TASTING MENU

6

Page 9: Fine Wine Auction 2012

EVENING ENTERTAINMENT

UCC’s SENIOR JAZZ ENSEMBLE

The Senior Jazz Ensemble, one of UCC’s premium ensembles, recently won a double gold award at the GTA Musicfest Jazz Festival at York University. The win earned the band, under the direction of Peter Smith, an invitation to the MusicFest Canada national final atOttawa’s National Arts Centre in May. This much-in-demand ensemble has entertained at UCC assemblies, Fall Music Night and Spring Arts Festival.

The ensemble’s Oliver Clark ’12 (keyboards), Alex Rand ’12 (bass guitar) and Dean Ricci ’12 (drums), accompanied by friend Kyle Rosnick of Northern Secondary School (guitar), have played at UCC’s Association Day and The Bishop Strachan School Father-Daughter Dance. They’ll perform during the reception at the Mad for Blue Fine Wine Auction.

ELEANOR McCAIN

Singer and recording artist Eleanor McCain brings a melting pot of musical styles to her music – classical, Celtic, folk, ballad and pop. Her singing can be categorized in one word: intimate.

The Florenceville, N.B. native has recorded four CDs: Inti-mate, her classical crossover debut; Bundle of Joy, a lullaby album which was nominated for a 2009 East Coast Music Award for best children’s recording; Green Hills of Home, a collection of Celtic ballads which was nominated for a 2011

East Coast Music Award for best roots/traditional solo recording; and Holiday, a two-disc set of Christmas music that was released last November

Eleanor has worked with such notable artists as David Foster, John McDermott, Chantal Kreviazuk and the Elmer Iseler Singers. In addition to her recording career, Eleanor contin-ues to focus on raising her daughter Laura.

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

7

Page 10: Fine Wine Auction 2012

LOT #19

PHOTO: JANE SOUTHEY

Page 11: Fine Wine Auction 2012

AUCTIONEERS

ALBERT SCHULTZ

Albert trained at York University and the London Academy of Music and Dramatic Art before joining the Stratford Festival Young Company under Robin Phillips.

Albert is the founding artistic director of Soulpepper Theatre Company and general director of the Young Centre for the Performing Arts. He regularly directs and appears on stage with Soulpepper and leads the Soulpepper Academy.

Albert spent time on CBC’s hit television series’ Street Legal and Side Effects, and was the lead in CTV’s 2006 film Shades of Black (a biography of Conrad Black).

Albert’s many honours include The City of Toronto Barbara Hamilton Memorial Award, the Joan Chalmers National Award for Artistic Direction and honorary degrees from Queen’s and Bishop’s universities in recognition of his contributions to Canadian theatre.

ARRON BARBERIAN

Arron is the managing partner of his family’s internation-ally renowned restaurant. Barberian’s Steak House has built a reputation for the finest quality food, exceptional service and a spectacular wine list over the past 53 years.

Arron is an alumnus of Culver Military Academy’s Black Horse Troop ’82, as well as the University of South Florida. He’s the former chair of the Downtown Yonge Business Improvement Area and is well known in the downtown core as one of the

people who conceived of Yonge Dundas Square and the neighbourhood’s revitalization.

Arron is an avid collector of Canadian art, vintage photography, fine wine and books. He’s married to Linda Rodeck, the managing director of Sotheby’s Canada, and has two chil-dren: Madeleine and Harrison.

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

9

Page 12: Fine Wine Auction 2012

INVENTORY MANAGEMENT

APPRAISAL AND LOTTING – ROBERT JULL

Rob is a wine appraiser, consultant and owner of Vinifera Wine Services, which imports and distributes fine wines throughout Ontario. Vinifera represents a unique portfolio of limited production, family-run Domaines and Chateaux from France that are carefully selected from among the top producers of each region. Vinifera also purveys the broadest and most tasteful array of wine accessories assembled anywhere.

Rob has been active as an appraiser for charity auctions since 1990. This is his third UCC Fine Wine Auction.

WINE STORAGE – WARREN PORTER

Wines for this year’s auction have been professionally stored at Iron Gate - Private Wine Management. This is the second UCC Fine Wine Auction that Warren has supported.

With two locations and 10,000 square feet of high security, environmentally controlled storage, Iron Gate is the largest provider of fine wine storage in Canada. Iron Gate also provides home cellar inventory and management services to discerning collectors everywhere.

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

10

Page 13: Fine Wine Auction 2012

WINE DONORS

Upper Canada College and the Fine Wine Auction Committee gratefully acknowledge the wine donations of the following individuals:

James Archer-Shee

Barrel Select

Arron Barberian

David. M. Beatty ’77

Allan Bramson

Fred Bruun ’94

Don Carlisle ’59

Kim Cheesbrough

Andy Chisholm ’77 and Laurie Thomson

Mark Cohon ’85

Harris Davidson

David Dime and Elisa Nuyten

Dr. Grant Farrow

In Memory of Ian E. Finlayson ’67 by his family

Fleisher Family

David Fuller

Stephen Grant

Donald Guloien and Irene Boychuk

Richard and Nancy Hamm

Christopher J. Hickman

Blake Hutcheson ’80

David G. Jarvis

Dr. Josh Josephson

Bruce Kagan

Kassum Family

Steven D. Kaszas

Douglas Keller-Hobson

Charles E. Kennedy

Gary Luftspring

Patrick Lumbers

Dougal MacDonald

Stephen Marshall

Scot Martin

Douglas McCallum

Sean McCowan ’88

Jim McGovern

Mark McQueen

Bradley and Jacqueline Meiers

Pat Meneley

Stephen Miao

Raymond Mo

Amit Monga

Joseph Orozco

Alfred Page

Ken Priestman

Andy M. Pringle ’69

Robbie Pryde

Steven and Robyn Scott

Charlie Sims ’80

Alex Squires ’65

Steven Tennyson

David Tompkins

George Vesely and Mary Porjes

Geoff Wilson ’86

and anonymous donors

We also acknowledge donors whose names were not available at time of printing.

11

Page 14: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FINANCIAL BENEFITS OF PURCHASING WINE AT A CHARITY EVENT

There are significant cost savings to be realized when purchasing wine at charity versus commercial wine auctions.

When purchasing wine at the UCC Fine Wine Auction (a charity wine auction),the purchaser pays only the hammer price.

There is no buyer’s premium or additional taxes (HST) charged.

When purchasing wine at a commercial auction:

The purchaser pays the hammer plus approximately 30% in additional fees, which includes a buyer’s premium of approximately 17% as well as 13% tax (HST) payable on both the hammer price & buyer’s premium.

Approximate Cost Comparison on a $1,000 Wine Purchase

Hammer Price:

Buyer’s Premium:HST on Hammer Price:HST on Buyer’s Premium:Total Cost to Purchaser:

$1,000

N/AN/AN/A$1,000

$1,000

$170$130$22$1,322

UCC FINE WINE AUCTION COMMERCIAL WINE AUCTION

$ Savings% Difference

$322.0032.2 %

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

12

Page 15: Fine Wine Auction 2012

58 • TORONTO SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA

BORDEAUX

bn.

ts.hs.

ms.

ls.

bs.

vts.

BURGUNDY

3 cm

5 cm

7 cm

Level/Ullage Description and Interpretations

Bordeaux Levels

For wines in bottles with defined shoulders including Bordeaux,

Port and other wines, the level is measured and catalogued as follows:

bn. - BASE NECK: Perfectly good for any age of wine.

Outstandingly good for a wine of 10 years in bottle,

or longer.

vts. - VERY TOP SHOULDER

ts. - TOP SHOULDER: Normal for any Bordeaux 15 years old or

older.

hs. - HIGH SHOULDER: Slight natural reduction through the

easing of the cork and evaporation through cork and capsule.

Usually no problem. Acceptable for any wine over 20 years old.

Exceptional for pre-1950 wines.

ms. - MID SHOULDER: Probably some weakening of the cork

and some risk. Not abnormal for wines 30-40 years of age.

Estimates usually take this into account.

ls. - LOW SHOULDER: Risky and usually only accepted for sale if

wine or label exceptionally rare or interesting. Always offered

with low estimate.

bs. - BOTTOM SHOULDER: Not acceptable for sale unless

a rare sort of bottle. Wine will usually be undrinkable.

u. - ULLAGE: Level.

Example: (u. 2ts) means 2 bottles ullaged to top shoulder.

oc. - ORIGINAL CARTON

owc. - ORIGINAL WOODEN CASE

RC - RESERVE CHATEAU

Burgundy Levels

For wines in bottles with sloping necks, including Burgundy, German

and other wines, the level between the cork and wine is measured and

catalogued in centimetres.

The condition and drinkability of Burgundy is less affected by ullage

than its equivalent from Bordeaux. A 5-7-cm. ullage in a 50-year-old

Burgundy can be considered normal, indeed good for age; 3.5-4 cm.

excellent for age; 7cm. rarely a risk.

Example: (u. 3x5cm) means 3 bottles ullaged 5 cm.

Bottle Sizes

hf. bt. - half bottle = 0.375 litres

bt(s). - bottle(s) = 0.75 litres

ltr. - litre

mag. - magnum = 1.5 litres, or two regular bottles

d. mag. - double magnum (Bordeaux, Port) = 3 litres

jero. - jeroboam (Burgundy, Champagne) = 3 litres

jero. - jeroboam (Bordeaux) = 5 litres*

imp. - impériale (Bordeaux) = 6 litres

meth. - methuselah (Burgundy, Champagne) = 6 litres

salm. - salmanazar = 9 litres

*Up to 1978, jeroboams were generally bottled in 4.5-ltr. bottles.

Tasting Note Sources

AM - Allen Meadows CC - Clive Coates WA - Wine Advocate

WS - Wine Spectator IWC - International Wine Cellar

Level/Ullage Description and Interpretations

WA - Wine AdvocateRP - Robert Parker

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

13

Page 16: Fine Wine Auction 2012

BIDDING PROCEDURE

*The auctioneer may vary the increments during the course of the auction at his own discretion.

Information for Prospective Bidders

If this is your first time attending a wine auction, the procedure is straightforward. After registering, you will be given a numbered paddle. To bid, raise your paddle until the bidding reaches your spending limit. Bids will not be subject to HST. If you have any questions about bidding, please ask a UCC Fine Wine Auction volunteer.

Live Auction Rules: Bidding Procedure

1. The Live Fine Wine Auction will commence at George Weston Hall, Upper Canada College Preparatory School at 7:30 p.m. on Wednesday, April 18, 2012.

2. Bidding is per lot and the highest bidder acknowledged by the auctioneer determines the final buyer. 3. Bidding will be in increments determined by the auctioneer (see below for bidding increments) and will be announced during the auction.

4. Absentee bids will be placed in advance of the auction and will be kept strictly confidential until the evening of the auction. The auctioneer may commence bidding at the second highest bid registered in his possession.

5. When bidding, hold the paddle high so spotters can see your number.

6. If you are the successful bidder on a lot, the auctioneer will acknowledge your paddle number.

Bidding Increments*

Bidding generally advances in increments of up to 10%, subject to the auctioneer’s discre-tion. Absentee bids that do not conform to the increments set out below may be lowered to the next bidding interval:

$0 to $100 by $5$100 to $200 by $10 $200 to $300 by $20$300 to $500 by $25$500 to $1,000 by $50$1,000 to $2,000 by $100$2,000 to $3,000 by $200$3,000 to $5,000 by $250$5,000 to $10,000 by $500

14

Page 17: Fine Wine Auction 2012

LOT #24

FINE WINE AUCTION LOTS

PHOTO: JANE SOUTHEY

Page 18: Fine Wine Auction 2012

AUSTRALIA

Lot #1

MITOLO, SAVITAR 2004 (12)MCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

Lot #2

MITOLO, SAVITAR 2004 (12)MCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

16

Bordering on perfection is the 2004 Shiraz Savitar. Made from 30- to 50-year-old vines, and aged 18 months in 100% new French hogsheads as well as smaller barriques, it boasts an opaque purple color, and an extraordinary nose of acacia flowers, blueberries, raspberries, and blacker fruits, melted licorice, and graphite. It possesses amazing intensity, great equilibrium, a fabulous, multi-layered mid-palate, and a blockbuster finish. This extraordinary Shiraz should prove to be one of the legends of southern Australia’s great 2004 vintage.

Score 98, WA #161 October 2005

Page 19: Fine Wine Auction 2012

AUSTRALIA

Lot #3

MITOLO, SAVITAR 2004 (6)MCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

TWO HANDS, BELLAS GARDEN 2002 (2)BAROSSA, AUSTRALIA

TORBRECK, RUNRIG 2001 (1)BAROSSA, AUSTRALIA

9 bottles Appraisal Value $1,500

Torbreck’s flagship wine, the Run Rig, is made from 40- to 120-year-old Shiraz vines with some co-fermented Viognier (usually around 3%), tips the scales between 14-15% alco-hol, and is aged 30 months in French oak. The youngest Run Rig, the 2001, should equal the 1998 as it is almost a clone aromatically, texturally, and flavor-wise, just much younger. This opaque purple-colored beauty should flirt with perfection over the next 10-15 years.

Score 99, WA #183, June 2009

Lot #4

D’ARENBERG, THE DEAD ARM 2002 (12)MCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,800

Lot #5

D’ARENBERG, THE DEAD ARM 2002 (3)MCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

D’ARENBERG, THE IRONSTONE PRESSING 2002 (3)MCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

WOLF BLASS, BLACK LABEL 1994 (2)SOUTH AUSTRALIA

8 bottles Appraisal Value $1,200

17

Page 20: Fine Wine Auction 2012

AUSTRALIA

Lot #6

MITOLO, GAM 2004 (12) 375MLMCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

12 bottles Appraisal Value $700

Lot #6a

MITOLO, GAM 2004 (12) 375MLMCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

12 bottles Appraisal Value $700

Lot #6b

MITOLO, GAM 2004 (11) 375MLMCLAREN VALE, AUSTRALIA

11 bottles Appraisal Value $650

Aged 18 months in primarily French oak, the 2004 Shiraz G.A.M. is an exceptional example of a precise yet full-flavored, concentrated Shiraz. Its gorgeous perfume of blueberries, blackberries, camphor, licorice, and pain grille is followed by an inky/blue/purple-colored wine offering superb purity, full-bodied richness, and gorgeous depth as well as texture. This fabulous effort is another example of Ben Glaetzer’s brilliant talents. It should drink well for 15 years.

Score 97, WA #161, October 2005

18

Page 21: Fine Wine Auction 2012

CANADA

Lot #7

CAVE SPRING, INDIAN SUMMER LATE HARVEST RIESLING 1999 (1) 375MLNIAGARA, ONTARIO

INNISKILLIN, RIESLING ICEWINE 1997 (4) 375MLNIAGARA, ONTARIO

NORMAN HARDIE, RIESLING 2004 (12)P.E.C., ONTARIO

VINELAND ESTATES, VIDAL ICEWINE 1994 (1) 375MLNIAGARA, ONTARIO

18 bottles Appraisal Value $1,350

FRANCE

Lot #8

ROLLY GASSMANN, GEWURZTRAMINER CUVEE ANNE MARIE 1993 (6)ALSACE, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $700

19

Page 22: Fine Wine Auction 2012

Lot #8a

WOLF BLASS, BLACK LABEL 1998 (1)BAROSSA, AUSTRALIA

CHEVAL BLANC, ST. EMILION 1979 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

TERTRE ROTEBOEUF, ST. EMILION 2000 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

MERRYVALE, “PROFILE” 2004 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

DOMAINE DE LA MOTTE, COTEAUX DU LAYON ROCHEFORT 1989 (2)LOIRE, FRANCE

GUSTOV ADOLF SCHMIDT, NIERSTEINER PFEFFENKAPP ORTEGA BEERENAUSLESE 1983 (1) 375MLRHEINHESSEN, GERMANY

8 bottles Appraisal Value $3,000

Lot #9

ANGELUS, ST. EMILION 1990 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

CALON SEGUR, ST. ESTEPHE 1990 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

CALON SEGUR, ST. ESTEPHE 1985 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

CALON SEGUR, ST. ESTEPHE 1996 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

5 bottles Appraisal Value $2,400

FRANCE

20

Page 23: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #10

BATAILLEY, PAUILLAC 1989 (9) 4TS, 5BNBORDEAUX, FRANCE

9 bottles Appraisal Value $2,500

Lot #10a

MOUTON-ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1995 (1) 1500MLBORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $2,600

Lot #11

BEYCHEVELLE, ST. JULIEN 1975 (8) 375ML, 6VHS, 2HSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

BRANAIRE, DULUC-DUCRU 1990 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

9 bottles Appraisal Value $1,700

21

Bottled in June, 1997, this profound Mouton is more accessible than the more muscular 1996. A blend of 72% Cabernet Sauvignon, 9% Cabernet Franc, and 19% Merlot, it reveals an opaque purple color, and reluctant aromas of cassis, truffles, coffee, licorice, and spice. In the mouth, the wine is “great stuff,” with superb density, a full-bodied personality, rich mid-palate, and a layered, profound finish that lasts for 40+ seconds. There is outstanding purity and high tannin, but my instincts suggest this wine is lower in acidity and slightly fleshier than the brawnier, bigger 1996. Both are great efforts from Mouton-Rothschild.

Score 95, WA #115, February 1998

Page 24: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #11a

CALON SEGUR, ST. ESTEPHE 1989 (2) 1TSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

CLOS DU MARQUIS, ST. JULIEN 1989 (3)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

5 bottles Appraisal Value $1,200

Lot #12

CANON, ST. EMILION 1947 (2) 375ML, 1BN, 1 VTSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

CHEVAL BLANC, ST. EMILION 2001 (1) 1500MLBORDEAUX, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $4,700

Lot #12a

MOUTON-ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 2000 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 2000 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

LATOUR, PAUILLAC 2000 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

HAUT BRION, GRAVES 2000 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

MARGAUX, MARGAUX 2000 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

5 bottles Appraisal Value $15,000

22

Page 25: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #13

CLERC MILON, PAUILLAC 1986 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

CLERC MILON, PAUILLAC 1989 (3)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

COS D’ESTOURNEL, SAINT ESTEPHE 1986 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

COS D’ESTOURNEL, SAINT ESTEPHE 1996 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $2,000

Lot #14

D’ANGLUDET, MARGAUX 1978 (2) 2VHSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

D’ANGLUDET, MARGAUX 1979 (2) 2BNBORDEAUX, FRANCE

D’ANGLUDET, MARGAUX 1983 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

DUCRU BEAUCAILLOU, ST. JULIEN 1994 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

DURFORT-VIVENS, MARGAUX 1975 (1) VHSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

8 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

Lot #15

CHATEAU D’YQUEM, “Y” 2000 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

CHATEAU D’YQUEM, LUR SALUCES 1988 (3) 375MLBORDEAUX, FRANCE

5 bottles Appraisal Value $3,100

23

Page 26: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #16

CHATEAU D’YQUEM, LUR SALUCES 1967 (1) TOP OFF CAPSULEBORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $2,000

Lot #17

FAIYAN, CADILLAC 1982 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

GAZIN, POMEROL 1978 (4)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

GAZIN, POMEROL 1997 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

GISCOURS, MARGAUX 1975 (2) 2TSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

GRAUD-LAROSE, ST. JULIEN 1978 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

11 bottles Appraisal Value $2,000

Lot #18

GUIRAUD, 1ER CRU 1959 (1) VTSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $500

24

Page 27: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #19

HAUT BRION GRAVES 1988 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

HAUT BRION GRAVES 2001 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $3,500

Lot #19a

HAUT BRION, GRAVES 1990 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $3,500

Lot #20

HAUT BRION, GRAVES 1989 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $6,800

In terms of the brilliant complexity and nobility of the aromatics, scorched earth, black currants, plums, charcoal, cedar, and spices, the 1990 offers an aromatic explosion that is unparalleled. It is always fascinating to taste this wine next to the 1989, which is a monumental effort, but much more backward and denser, without the aromatic complexity of the 1990. The 1990 put on weight after bottling, and is currently rich, full-bodied, opulent, even flamboyant by Haut Brion’s standards. It is an incredible expression of a noble terroir in a top vintage. While it has been fully mature for a number of years, it does not reveal any bricking at the edge, and I suspect it will stay at this level for another 10-15 years ... but why wait? It is irresistible now.

Score 98, WA #183 June 2009

25

Page 28: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #21

HAUT BRION, GRAVES 1989 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $6,800

Lot #22

LA MISSION HAUT BRION, GRAVES 1990 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $2,500

Lot #23

LA MISSION HAUT BRION, GRAVES 1994 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $700

Much like its nearby rival, Haut Brion, the 1990 La Mission has always been rela-tively evolved, complex, and supple-textured. Even at age 3-4 it performed beauti-fully. The tannins are sweet, the acidity low, and the high levels of glycerin and concentrated fruit have always been present, and they show no signs of abating. A dark plum/blue/garnet color is followed by a sweet perfume of chocolate, rich, jammy, berry fruit, and hints of smoked herbs as well as meat juices. It remains a full-bodied, opulent, even ostentatious wine that should drink beautifully for two more decades. It really has not changed much over the last 6-7 years.

Score 96, WA #183 June 2009

26

Page 29: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #24

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1986 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $8,000

Lot #25

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1989 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $2,500

Lot #26

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1989 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $2,500

27

The 1986 possesses outstanding richness, a deep color, medium body, a graceful, harmonious texture, and superb length. The penetrating fragrance of cedar, chestnuts, minerals, and rich fruit is a hallmark of this wine. Powerful, dense, rich, and tannic, as well as medium to full-bodied, with awesome extraction of fruit, this Lafite has immense potential.

Score 100, Robert Parker, Bordeaux Book, 3rd Edition Jan 1998

Page 30: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #27

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1989 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $2,500

Lot #28

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1993 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $4,300

Lot #29

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1999 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $5,000

28

Page 31: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #30

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 2001 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $4,600

Lot #31

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 2001 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $4,600

Lot #32

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 2001 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $4,600

29

Page 32: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #33

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 2001 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 2004 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $5,000

Lot #34

LAGRANGE, ST. JULIEN 1990 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

LATOUR À POMEROL, POMEROL 1978 (2) 1TS, 1HSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $700

Lot #34a

LATOUR, PAUILLAC 1988 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $2,800

30

Page 33: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #35

LEOVILLE, LAS CASES 1966 (1) TSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

LEOVILLE, LAS CASES 1989 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

LEOVILLE, MARQUIS DE LAS CASES 1996 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

5 bottles Appraisal Value $3,300

Lot #36

MARGAUX, MARGAUX 1982 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

MARGAUX, MARGAUX 1986 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

MARGAUX, MARGAUX 1998 (1) 1500MLBORDEAUX, FRANCE

4 bottles Appraisal Value $8,800

Consistently scoring between 98-100, the superb 1982 Margaux may be slightly bigger, bolder, and more masculine than vintages produced over the last 15-20 years. Its dark plum/purple color is followed by notes of melted tar intermixed with sweet cassis and floral underpinnings. Very full-bodied and dense for a Chateau Margaux, with a slight rusticity to the tannins, it boasts blockbuster power, richness, and impressive aromatics. It appears set for another 30-40 years of life.

Score 98, WA #183 June 2009

A magnificent example of Chateau Margaux and one of the most tannic, back-ward Margauxs of the last 50 years, the 1986 continues to evolve at a glacial pace. The color is still a dense ruby/purple with just a hint of lightening at the rim. With several hours of aeration, the aromatics become striking, with notes of smoke, toast, creme de cassis, mineral, and white flowers. Very full-bodied, with high but sweet tannin, great purity, and a very masculine, full-bodied style, this wine should prove nearly immortal in terms of its aging potential. It is beginning to budge from its infantile stage and approach adolescence.

Score 98, Bordeaux Book 4th edition 2003.

31

Page 34: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #36a

MARGAUX, MARGAUX 1988 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

Lot #37

MONTROSE, ST.ESTEPHE 1990 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

MONTROSE, ST.ESTEPHE 1994 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

MONTROSE, ST.ESTEPHE 1997 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

MONTROSE, ST.ESTEPHE 2005 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

5 bottles Appraisal Value $2,500

Lot #38

MOUTON ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1966 (1) 1TSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

MOUTON ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1970 (2) 2TSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $3,500

32

Page 35: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #39

MOUTON ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1986 (2) 1TSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $5,000

Lot #40

MOUTON ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1986 (1) 1TSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

MOUTON ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1987 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $3,400

Lot #41

PALMER, MARGAUX 1986 (6) 2BNBORDEAUX, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $3,100

Deep garnet-black colour. An incredible array of aromas on the nose: black-berry, black cherry, tobacco, espresso, leather, black olive and loam. The pal-ate is absolutely seamless from first impression to finish, effortlessly building layers of complexity in the mouth and leading to a very long, earth and spice finish. I can’t see how this could possibly be improved so have no alternative but concede perfection.

Score 100, Lisa Perrotti-Brown on eRobertParker, June 2009

33

Page 36: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #42

PALMER, MARGAUX 1989 (4)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

4 bottles Appraisal Value $3,600

Lot #43

PAVIE, ST.EMILION 1978 (4) 4BNBORDEAUX, FRANCE

4 bottles Appraisal Value $800

Lot #44

PETRUS, POMEROL 1981 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $3,000

34

Page 37: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #45

PETRUS, POMEROL 1983 (1) 1BNBORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $3,000

Lot #46

PICHON-LONGUEVILLE, BARON 1989 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

PICHON-LONGUEVILLE, BARON 1996 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

PICHON-LONGUEVILLE, BARON 2006 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

Lot #47

PICHON-LONGUEVILLE, COMTESSE DE LALANDE 1989 (2) 1TSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

PICHON-LONGUEVILLE, BARON 1989 (4)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $2,400

35

Page 38: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #48

PIPEAU, ST. EMILION 2000 (2) 1500MLBORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $250

Lot #49

PONTET CANET, PAUILLAC 2005 (2) 1500MLBORDEAUX, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

Lot #50

PRIEURE LACHINE, MARGAUX 1978 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

RAUSAN-SEGLA, MARGAUX 1978 (2)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

RIEUSSEC, SAUTERNES 1986 (4)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

ROC DE CALON, ST. EMILION 1975 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

TROTANOY, POMEROL 1996 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

9 bottles Appraisal Value $2,000

36

Page 39: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #50a

TERTRE ROTEBOEUF, ST. EMILION 2000 (6) OWCBORDEAUX, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $3,900

Lot #51

ALEX GAMBAL, MEURSAULT LES GENEVRIERES 2009 (1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

BONNEAU DU MARTRAY, CORTON CHARLEMAGNE 2002(1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

BOUCHARD, ECHEZEAUX 1999 (1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

BOUCHARD, NUITS-SAINT-GEORGES ‘LES CAILLES’ 2003 (1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

BOUCHARD, VOSNE-ROMANEE ‘LES SUCHOTS’ 2004 (1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

5 bottles Appraisal Value $1,600

Lot #52

BACHELET, CHARMES CHAMBERTIN 2000 (3)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $1,000

My all-time favorite vintage of Tertre-Roteboeuf, the 2000 should age much more consistently than the rather irregular 1990 or the top-notch 1989. The 2005 should give it a run for its money down the road, but at present, this wine is performing fabulously well. It boasts a dense ruby/purple color along with notes of kirsch liqueur and licorice. This St.-Emilion could pass for a great Chateauneuf du Pape or top-notch Musigny, although it has more power and depth than a burgundy, and none of the peppery/garrigue characteristics of a Rhone. Nevertheless, there is a sweet character from the high glycerin level as I suspect the alcohol content exceeds 14%. Velvety textured and full-bodied, but surprisingly youthful, this stunningly rich wine can be drunk now, but promises to last another two decades.

Score 98, WA #198, June 2010

37

Page 40: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #53

BONNEAU DU MARTRAY, CORTON CHARLEMAGNE 1999 (4)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

BONNEAU DU MARTRAY, CORTON CHARLEMAGNE 2000 (6) OWCBURGUNDY, FRANCE

10 bottles Appraisal Value $2,900

Lot #54

DOMAINE DE LA VOUGERAIE, COTE DE BEAUNE LES PIERRES BLANCHES 2002 (3)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

DOMAINE DE LA VOUGERAIE, VOUGEOT CLOS DU PRIEURE 1999 (3)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $800

Lot #55

DOMINIQUE LAURENT, NUITS-SAINT-GEORGES, LA RICHEMONE 1996 (6)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $1,100

38

Page 41: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #56

E. SAUZET, BATARD MONTRACHET 2002 (2)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

LEFLAIVE, CHEVALIER MONTRACHET 1999 (1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

LES HERTIERS DU COMTES LAFON, MACON-MILLY-LAMARTINE 2001 (6)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

9 bottles Appraisal Value $2,400

Lot #57

GASTON & PIERRE RAVAUT, LADOIX LE BOIS ROUSSOT 2001 (1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

MICHEL COUVREUR, MONTHELIE LES HAUTS BRUNS 1985 (8)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

PRINCE DE MERODE, ALOXE-CORTON 1962 (1) 5CMBURGUNDY, FRANCE

10 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

Lot #58

HOSPICES DE BEAUNE, CORTON CUVEE DOCTEUR PESTE 1972 (2) 2 STAINED, 1 3CMBURGUNDY, FRANCE

PIERRE PONELLE, GEVREY CHAMBERTIN PETITE CHAPELLE 1964 (2) 2 3CMBURGUNDY, FRANCE

4 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

39

Page 42: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #59

LOUIS JADOT, BEAUNE AVAUX 2005 (6)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

LOUIS JADOT, SAVIGNY-LES-BEAUNE CLOS DES GUETTES 2005 (6)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

Lot #60

LOUIS JADOT, CHABLIS GRENOUILLES 1996 (3)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

LOUIS JADOT, MEURSAULT GENEVRIERES 1998 (4)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

LOUIS JADOT, CHASSAGNE-MONTRACHET LES CAILLERETS 1996 (2)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

9 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

Lot #61

REMOISSENET, CORTON CHARLEMAGNE DIAMOND JUBILEE 2000 (2)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

VINCENT GIRARDIN, CHEVELIER MONTRACHET 2002 (1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

VINCENT GIRARDIN, PULIGNY MONTRACHET LES PUCELLES 2002 (1)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

4 bottles Appraisal Value $1,200

40

Page 43: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #62

VINCENT GIRADIN, BATARD MONTRACHET 2002 (8)BURGUNDY, FRANCE

8 bottles Appraisal Value $3,100

Lot #63

MOET & CHANDON, DOM PERIGNON 2002 (1)CHAMPAGNE, FRANCE

VEUVE CLICQUOT PONSARDIN, VINTAGE RESERVE 1988 (1) 1500MLCHAMPAGNE, FRANCE

2 bottles Appraisal Value $800

Lot #64

PETRUS, POMEROL 1978 BNBORDEAUX, FRANCE

1 bottle Appraisal Value $2,200

41

Page 44: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #65

CLOS ST. MAGDELEINE, CASSIS 1997 (11)PROVENCE, FRANCE

11 bottles Appraisal Value $650

Lot #66

BEAUCASTEL, CHATEAUNEUF DU PAPE 1997 (1) 1500MLRHONE, FRANCE

CHATEAU DE BEAUCASTEL, CHATEAUNEUF DU PAPE 1998 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $750

Lot #67

BEAUCASTEL, CHATEAUNEUF DU PAPE 1998 (6)RHONE, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $1,200

42

Page 45: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #68

CHATEAU DE BEAUCASTEL, CHATEAUNEUF DU PAPE 1990 (3)RHONE, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

Lot #69

CHATEAU FORTIA, CUVEE DU BARON CDP 2001 (12)RHONE, FRANCE

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,500

Lot #70

CHATEAU FORTIA, CUVEE DU BARON CDP 2003 (12)RHONE, FRANCE

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

Two great back-to-back vintages are the 1990 and 1989. The more developed 1990 boasts an incredible perfume of hickory wood, coffee, smoked meat, Asian spices, black cherries, and blackberries. Lush, opulent, and full-bodied, it is a fully mature, profound Beaucastel that will last another 15-20 years.

Score 96, Robert Parker 2003.

43

Page 46: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #71

CHATEAU FORTIA, CUVEE DU BARON CDP 2003 (12)RHONE, FRANCE

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,300

Lot #72

E. GUIGAL, COTE ROTIE LA MOULINE 1998 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

E. GUIGAL, COTE ROTIE LA TURQUE 1998 (1)RHONE, FRANCE

3 bottles Appraisal Value $3,900

Lot #73

JEAN-LOUIS CHAVE, HERMITAGE BLANC 1999 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

JEAN-LOUIS CHAVE, HERMITAGE BLANC 2002 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

JEAN-LOUIS CHAVE, HERMITAGE BLANC 2003 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

6 bottles Appraisal Value $2,400

The 1998 Cote Rotie La Turque may end up being a perfect wine. Its smoky black fruits intermixed with licorice, roasted meats, cassis, and flowers create an explosive, exotic perfume. The wine reveals considerable tannin, immense structure, and potentially legendary depth as well as intensity.

Score 98, WA #140, April 2002

44

Page 47: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #74

PAUL JABOULET ALINE, COTE ROTIE ‘LES JUMELLES’ 1985 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

PAUL JABOULET ALINE, HERMITAGE ‘LA CHAPELLE’ 1985 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

PAUL JABOULET ALINE, HERMITAGE ‘LA CHAPELLE’ 1995 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

PAUL JABOULET ALINE, MUSCAT DE BEAUMES-DE-VENISE 1998 (1)RHONE, FRANCE

7 bottles Appraisal Value $1,600

Lot #75

MONTUS, MADIRAN 1998 (12)SOUTHWEST, FRANCE

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

Lot #76

MONTUS, MADIRAN 1998 (12)SOUTHWEST, FRANCE

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

45

Page 48: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FRANCE

Lot #76a

ST. GEORGES, PETRUS DESBOIS 2000 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

ST. GEORGES, PETRUS DESBOIS 2003 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

ST. GEORGES, PETRUS DESBOIS 2006 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

LUCIEN BARROT, CHATEAUNEUF DU PAPE 2001 (2)RHONE, FRANCE

LAFITE ROTHSCHILD, PAUILLAC 1966 (1) VTSBORDEAUX, FRANCE

PAUL BOUCHARD, GEVREY CHAMBERTIN 1966 (1) 5CMBURGUNDY, FRANCE

LYNCH BAGES, PAUILLAC 1998 (1)BORDEAUX, FRANCE

8 bottles Appraisal Value $2,700

Lot #77

MUSAR, 1981 (1) HSBEKAA VALLEY, LEBANON

MUSAR, 1987 (1)BEKAA VALLEY, LEBANON

MUSAR, 1988 (1)BEKAA VALLEY, LEBANON

3 bottles Appraisal Value $1,000

LEBANON

46

Page 49: Fine Wine Auction 2012

ITALY

Lot #78

GAJA, CONTEISA 1999 (3)PIEDMONTE, ITALY

3 bottles Appraisal Value $1,100

Lot #79

ALTESINO, MONTESOLI BDM 2001 (2)TUSCANY, ITALY

ANTINORI, SOLAIA 1997 (1)TUSCANY, ITALY

FONTODI, FLACCIANELLO DELLA PIEVE 2008 (1)TUSCANY, ITALY

4 bottles Appraisal Value $1,700

Lot #80

D’ALESSANDRO, IL BOSCO 1999 (12)TUSCANY, ITALY

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

The 1997 Solaia is awesome. Sweet, open aromatics lead to a rich, full-bodied expression of dark cherries, plums, menthol and spices. This sensual, full-bodied wine remains youthful and full of life. The 1997 is a great Solaia.

Score 96, WA #127, February 2000.

47

Page 50: Fine Wine Auction 2012

ITALY

Lot #81

D’ALESSANDRO, IL BOSCO 1999 (12)TUSCANY, ITALY

12 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

Lot #82

LE MACCHIOLE, MESSORIO 2005 (4)TUSCANY, ITALY

4 bottles Appraisal Value $2,900

Lot #83

MACULAN, ACININOBILI 1999 (3) 375MLTUSCANY, ITALY

3 bottles Appraisal Value $600

48

Page 51: Fine Wine Auction 2012

ITALY

Lot #84

QUINTARELLI, AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO SUPERIORE 1995 (3) 1500MLVENETO, ITALY

3 bottles Appraisal Value $5,000

Lot #85

QUINTARELLI, AMARONE DELLA VALPOLICELLA CLASSICO SUPERIORE 1995 (2) 1500MLVENETO, ITALY

2 bottles Appraisal Value $3,300

Lot #86

TENUTA SAN GUIDO, SASSICAIA 1986 (2)TUSCANY, ITALY

2 bottles Appraisal Value $1,200

49

Page 52: Fine Wine Auction 2012

PORTUGAL

Lot #87

GRAHAMS, VINTAGE 2000 (1)OPORTO, PORTUGAL

OFFLEY, BOA VISTA 1982 (1)OPORTO, PORTUGAL

QUINTA DO NOVAL, VINTAGE 1980 (1)OPORTO, PORTUGAL

TAYLOR FLADGATE, VINTAGE 1977 (1) 1500MLOPORTO, PORTUGAL

4 bottles Appraisal Value $1,500

Lot #88

FONSECA, VINTAGE 1975 (2)OPORTO, PORTUGAL

GRAHAMS, VINTAGE 1975 (5)OPORTO, PORTUGAL

7 bottles Appraisal Value $1,200

Lot #89

TAYLOR FLADGATE, VINTAGE 1994 (4)OPORTO, PORTUGAL

4 bottles Appraisal Value $1,700

50

When tasting young vintage ports, Taylor is always the most backward. Yet poten-tially, it has the capability to be the most majestic. This classically made, opaque purple-colored wine is crammed with black fruits (blueberries and cassis). It reveals high tannin and a reserved style, but it is enormously constituted with massive body, a formidable mid-palate, and exceptional length. It is a young, rich, powerful Taylor that will require 10-15 years of aging. Compared to the more flashy, forward style of the 1992, the 1994 has more in common with such vintages as 1977 and 1970

Score 97, WA #107, October 1996.

Page 53: Fine Wine Auction 2012

PORTUGAL

Lot #89a

DOWS, VINTAGE 1994 (6)OPORTO, PORTUGAL

6 bottles Appraisal Value $1,600

Lot #90

TAMNAVULIN, 27 YEAR OLD (1)SPEYSIDE, SCOTLAND

1 bottle Appraisal Value $375

Lot #91

BARNETT VINEYARDS, RATTLESNAKE HILL CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2000 (8)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

8 bottles Appraisal Value $1,600

SCOTLAND

USA

51

Page 54: Fine Wine Auction 2012

USA

Lot #92

BARNETT VINEYARDS, RATTLESNAKE HILL CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2000 (7)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

7 bottles Appraisal Value $1,400

Lot #93

CAYMUS, NAPA VALLEY CABERNET SAUVIGNON 1988 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

CAYMUS, ‘SPECIAL SELECTION’ CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2004 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

2 bottles Appraisal Value $500

Lot #94

ARAUJO ESTATE, EISELE VINEYARD CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2002 (6)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

6 bottles Appraisal Value $3,900

52

Page 55: Fine Wine Auction 2012

USA

Lot #94a

ARAUJO ESTATE, EISELE VINEYARD CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2002 (6)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

6 bottles Appraisal Value $3,900

Lot #95

CAYMUS, ‘SPECIAL SELECTION’ CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2001 (6) OWCNAPA, CALIFORNIA

6 bottles Appraisal Value $2,500

53

Page 56: Fine Wine Auction 2012

USA

Lot #96

CHATEAU ST. JEAN, JOHANNISBERG RIESLING LATE HARVEST 1989 (1) 375MLNAPA, CALIFORNIA

JOSEPH PHELPS, INSIGNIA 2001 (1) 1500MLNAPA, CALIFORNIA

JOSEPH PHELPS, CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2004 (1) 1500MLNAPA, CALIFORNIA

KISTLER, LES NOISETIERS, CHARDONNAY 2008 (3)SONOMA, CALIFORNIA

MONTELENA, NAPA VALLEY 1985 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

ROBERT MONDAVI, RESERVE CABERNET SAUVIGNON 1987 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

SILVER OAK, NAPA CABERNET SAUVIGNON 1989 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

9 bottles Appraisal Value $2,600

Lot #97

DOMINUS, NAPANOOK VINEYARD 1994 (1) 1500MLNAPA, CALIFORNIA

DUCKHORN, ESTATE MERLOT 1997 (1) 1500MLNAPA, CALIFORNIA

DUCKHORN, THREE PALMS VINEYARD MERLOT 1990 (1) BNNAPA, CALIFORNIA

3 bottles Appraisal Value $1,700

The sensational, prodigious2001 Insignia Proprietary Red Wine (89% Cabernet Sauvignon, 8% Petit Verdot and 3% Malbec) has never performed better. Still extremely youthful with a dense purple color as well as a beautiful bouquet of cedar, charcoal, incense, creme de cassis and black cherry jam, fabulous intensity, a multidimensional mouthfeel and a skyscraper-like texture, it is a Napa classic that is stillvery youthful and belies its age of ten years. It should age impeccably for 35 or more years.

Score 99, WA #195, June 2011.

54

Page 57: Fine Wine Auction 2012

USA

Lot #98

HARLAN ESTATE, 1993 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

HEITZ CELLARS, CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2001 (2)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

3 bottles Appraisal Value $1,500

Lot #99

HUNDRED ACRE, ‘KAYLI MORGAN VINEYARD’ CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2003 (6) OWCNAPA, CALIFORNIA,

6 bottles Appraisal Value $3,900

Lot #100

OPUS ONE, MONDAVI ROTHSCHILD 1987 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

OPUS ONE, MONDAVI ROTHSCHILD 2001 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

OPUS ONE, MONDAVI ROTHSCHILD 2004 (1) 1500MLNAPA, CALIFORNIA

3 bottles Appraisal Value $2,000

55

Page 58: Fine Wine Auction 2012

USA

Lot #101

PAHLMEYER, 2006 (6)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

6 bottles Appraisal Value $1,500

Lot #102

SMALL VINES, ‘MK VINEYARD’ PINOT NOIR 2008 (4)SONOMA COAST, CALIFORNIA

4 bottles Appraisal Value $400

Lot #103

CAYMUS, ‘SPECIAL SELECTION’ 2001 CABERNET SAUVIGNON (6) OWCNAPA, CALIFORNIA

6 bottles Appraisal Value $2,500

There are 7,000 cases of the prodigious 2006 Proprietary Red Wine (a blend of 80% Cabernet Sauvignon, 10% Merlot, and the rest Cabernet Franc, Petit Verdot, and Malbec). Most of the fruit comes from the Stage-coach Vineyard and the Waters Ranch. Sweet, smoky, meaty aromas interwoven with melted asphalt, camphor, blackberry, cassis, and char-coal scents emerge from the complex aromatics. In the mouth, the wine is full-bodied, displaying sweet tannin, a concentrated mouthfeel, and a long, heady finish with substantial fruit, glycerin, and extract. It should drink beautifully for 20+ years.

Score 98, WA #180, December 2008

56

Page 59: Fine Wine Auction 2012

USA

Lot #104

OPUS ONE, MONDAVI ROTHSCHILD 1995 (6) OWCNAPA, CALIFORNIA

6 bottles Appraisal Value $3,500

Lot #105

SHAFER, HILLSIDE SELECT CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2005 (6) OWCNAPA, CALIFORNIA

6 bottles Appraisal Value $3,400

Lot #106

JOSEPH PHELPS, INSIGNIA 2003 (12)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

12 bottles Appraisal Value $4,300

57

Page 60: Fine Wine Auction 2012

USA

Lot #107

HARLAN ESTATE, 1996 (1) OWC 1500MLNAPA, CALIFORNIA

1 bottle Appraisal Value $2,600

Lot #108

SCREAMING EAGLE, 2001 (1)NAPA, CALIFORNIA

1 bottle Appraisal Value $4,600

58

The last time I had this wine, it seemed much more developed, youthful and approachable. This particular bottle, which was pulled from my cellar, was super-powerful, dense and concentrated, as well as structured and backward. Aeration helped somewhat, but this looks like a very long-lived wine, and my initial suggestion of an anticipated maturity date (2010-2025) should be changed to 2015-2035. Only 450 cases were made of this blend of 88% Cabernet Sauvignon, 10% Merlot and 2% Cabernet Franc from former proprietor Jean Phillips’ vineyards just south of the Oakville crossroads. The spectacular dense blue/purple color remains opaque. The wine displays the hallmark creme de cassis, floral and licorice notes that are so pure, vivid and intense, and which have always been part of this vineyard’s classic trademark. With great purity, a full-bodied mouthfeel and even more thickness, power and density than I remember, this wine has put on weight, developed more struc-ture, and looks like a candidate for 30 more years of aging potential. This is a brilliant wine, much in keeping with the legendary status of this producer.

Score 99, WA #195, June 2011

Page 61: Fine Wine Auction 2012

“WINE EXPERIENCE” LOTS

Lot #109

NORMAN HARDIE WINERY & VINEYARD TOUR WITH LUNCH

Come join Norman Hardie ’85 in Prince Edward County, Ont. for a private vineyard tour, barrel tasting and

lunch for eight cooked by Norman. Prince Edward County is home to the newest wine region in Canada.

After working as a winemaker all over the world, Norman decided to make this magical part of Canada his

home. It’s where he grows and crafts Pinot Noirs and Chardonnays which have been highly acclaimed by

some of the world’s top wine experts and writers.

DONATED BY: NORMAN HARDIE WINERYVALUE: $PRICELESSMINIMUM BID: $1,000

Lot #110

UNIQUE WINE COUNTRY EXPERIENCE IN BEAUTIFUL NAPA VALLEY

The experience begins with business class airfare for two from Toronto to San Francisco, where you’ll be

whisked from the airport to Napa Valley by limousine. Your home for three nights will be the beautiful

Meadowood Resort, located in the heart of Napa Valley. You’ll have a dinner reservation at French Laun-

dry, rumoured to be the toughest restaurant in America to get into (cost of dinner isn’t included), on one

evening. You’ll also have a private tour at three boutique Napa wineries, including the Napa Valley Reserve

private wine club. This is a fabulous and unique experience for any wine lover.

DONATED BY: ROB PRYDE AND PAT MENELEYVALUE: $15,000MINIMUM BID: $5,000

59

Page 62: Fine Wine Auction 2012

LOT #47

PHOTO: JANE SOUTHEY

Page 63: Fine Wine Auction 2012

TERMS & CONDITIONS

REGISTRATION

Please check in at the Upper Canada College Preparatory School, at 6:30 p.m. on Wednesday April 18, 2012 to receive your assigned paddle/bid number and to meet other auction guests for a pre-auction reception.

At the time of registration you will sign a waiver to acknowledge that you are aware that the wine for sale through the UCC. auction may not have been tested by the Liquor Control Board of Ontario (LCBO).

CONDITION OF WINE

All wines sold will be at the buyer’s risk. The Upper Canada College Fine Wine Auction sells all wines ‘as is’, and gives no warranty of any kind, and shall not be liable for any error in description, faults or defects. No person shall have recourse against Upper Canada College and/or persons in the auction process for any irregularity or illegality in the sale or in the conduct of the sale of the wine. The wine offered for sale at the auction may not have been tested by the Liquor Control Board of Ontario (LCBO). The purchaser of the wine, by way of the auction, is required by law to acknowledge, in writing, his or her understanding of these terms at the time of registration.

PAYMENT

Payment is made in Canadian Dollars (CAD) on Wednesday, April 18, 2012. Payment can be made at the treasury desk with Cash, Amex, Visa or Mastercard, outside the venue. The desk will be staffed throughout the evening for your convenience. Maria Karakoulas is the UCC contact. The winners of absentee bids will be contacted the week following the Fine Wine Auction April 23 -27, 2012.

COLLECTING YOUR PURCHASED WINE

Pick-up of wine will be made once full payment has been received at the Fine Wine Auction by the College.

Successful bidders can call Anik Pelletier, Iron Gate Private Wine Management, at 416-234-9500 for pick up or delivery information. Delivery costs are $20 per lot to a maximum of $60 anywhere in the GTA. Pick up is available at no cost at Iron Gate’s offices at 532 Front Street West, Toronto, M5V1B8. Please allow at least one week from payment for organization.

*Every effort has been made to ensure that the information printed in this catalogue is current and correct.

We apologize for any errors or omissions.

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

61

Page 64: Fine Wine Auction 2012

Fine Wine Auction

Absentee Bid Form

Deadline for Absentee bids is 5:00 p.m. EST, Monday, April 16, 2012

Page 1 of 2

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

62

Page 65: Fine Wine Auction 2012

Fine Wine Auction

Absentee Bid Form

Deadline for Absentee bids is 5:00 p.m. EST, Monday, April 16, 2012

Please submit completed form to: Maria Karakoulas, Manager, Events E-mail: [email protected] Upper Canada College Fax: 416-484-8612 200 Lonsdale Rd. Tel: 416-488-1125 ext. 2231 Toronto, ON M4V 1W6

Page 2 of 2

MAD FOR BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION

63

Page 66: Fine Wine Auction 2012

THANK YOU TO OUR SPONSORS

190 Baldwin St. Kensington MarketJust west of Spadina – 1hr. Free Parking with purchaseM-W 10-6 · Th-F 10-7 · Sat 9-6 · Sun 12-5

www.toms-place.com416-596-0297

CONGRATULATIONS UCC!from Tom Mihalik & Tom's Place

MASTER SOMMELIER

SOMMELIER GRAND CRU

THE TENNYSON FAMILY

LEAD IN-KIND SPONSORS

ARRON BARBERIANBARBERIAN’S STEAKHOUSE

PATMENELEY

ALBERT SCHULTZ SOULPEPPER THEATRE COMPANY

FA,THE FLOWER SHOP

ELEANOR MCCAIN

ROBPRYDE

IN-KIND SPONSORSBMW- PARKVIEW

MERCEDES BENZ MIDTOWN

LAND ROVER JAGUAR THORNHILL

THE WINE SISTERS

GRANITE GOLF CLUB

DOWNTOWN MOOSE

FIRST RECOGNITION INC.

NICA DISTRIBUTION

ROSSO’S BESPOKE CUSTOM TAILORS

BARBERIAN’S STEAKHOUSE

LUCAS ATKINS ‘98

CHAIRMAN MILLS, GEORGE CROTHERS’91

BAY BLOOR RADIO

IT’S MY PARTY

GERVAIS PARTY AND TENT RENTALS, GEORGE OGSTON & TERRY GERVAIS ‘67

PETER MIELZYNSKI AGENCIES LTD.

FRANCESCA SALON & SPA

IL MULINO RESTAURANT

BANFI RESTAURANT

A CATERING & EVENTS COMPANY

ED

64

Page 67: Fine Wine Auction 2012

Kingston RoadGerrard Stre

et

Queen St East

Lake Shore Blvd East

Eastern Ave

Wo

od

bin

e A

ve

Vic

tori

a P

ark

Ave

Ha

sle

tt

Co

xw

ell

Ave

Lake Ontario

N

PRESENTATION CENTRE NOW OPEN303 Kingston Road, just east of WoodbineSAT + SUN 1–6 PM or by appointment

BeachClubLOFTS.com416.901.7333

RENDERINGS ARE AN ARTIST’S IMPRESSION. ALL PRICES, SIZES AND SPECIFICATIONS ARE SUBJECT TO CHANGE WITHOUT NOTICE. E.&O.E.

NEW SUITESJUST RELEASED!

The Beach Club is a boutique residence steps from The Beach offering one and two storey modern lofts with soaring 9 to 17 ft. ceiling, floor-to-ceiling windows and exquisite finishes from 457 sq.ft. to 1,375 sq.ft. with oversized patios, terraces, balconies, juliets providing spectacular lake and city skyline views.

Suite selections include two-storey townhomes, studios, one bedroom to two bedroom + den, and duplex penthouse suites.

DEVELOPER BROKER

Page 68: Fine Wine Auction 2012

190 Baldwin St. Kensington MarketJust west of Spadina – 1hr. Free Parking with purchaseM-W 10-6 · Th-F 10-7 · Sat 9-6 · Sun 12-5

www.toms-place.com416-596-0297

CONGRATULATIONS UCC!from Tom Mihalik & Tom's Place

Page 69: Fine Wine Auction 2012

• Offsite Storage • Home Cellar Inventory & Organization • eSommelier & Cellartracker Sales & Installation • Estate and Charity Wine Auctions • Cellar Maintenance • Appraisals • Purchase Consulting • SommelierService.com

Visit us on the web at IronGateWine.com or call us at 416.234.9500. We are located at 532 Front Street West near The Globe and Mail. Come in for a tour!

Caring for CollectorsIron Gate - Private Wine Management specializes in a host of products and services specifically for wine collectors, including:

• Offsite Storage • Home Cellar Inventory & Organization • eSommelier & Cellartracker Sales & Installation • Estate and Charity Wine Auctions • Cellar Maintenance • Appraisals • Purchase Consulting • SommelierService.com

Visit us on the web at IronGateWine.com or call us at 416.234.9500. We are located at 532 Front Street West near The Globe and Mail. Come in for a tour!

Caring for CollectorsIron Gate - Private Wine Management specializes in a host of products and services specifically for wine collectors, including:

Caring for CollectorsCaring for CollectorsCaring for Collectors

416.234.9500. We are located at 532 Front Street West near The Globe and Mail. Come in for a tour!

Toronto’s legendary steak house proudly supportsthe Upper Canada College fine wine auction

BE A WINNER BID STRONG!

Serving great steaks & fine wine since 1959 Open until midnight seven days a week

Page 70: Fine Wine Auction 2012

THE WINE ESTABLISHMENT &THE WINE ESTABLISHMENT

CONTRACTORS LIMITED

We are proud to support Upper Canada College

Fine Wine Auction

The Wine Establishment your source for all things inspired by wine!

» Wine Cellars and Accessories «» Custom Cellar Design and Construction «

» Stemware and Decanters «

thewineestablishment.com

[email protected]

Visit our showroom at Berkeley Castle in the St. Lawrence Market neighbourhood

and steps from the Distillery District250 The Esplanade Courtyard Suite 204

Page 71: Fine Wine Auction 2012

FOR THE ULTIMATE IN FLEXIBILTY CHOOSE THE FLEX-PACK AND SAVE • 4 TICKETS TO USE ANYWAY YOU LIKE• BOOK YOUR DATES NOW OR CHOOSE LATER

THE SUNSHINE BOYSNEIL SIMON

THE ROYAL COMEDIANS (MOLIÈRE)MIKHAIL BULGAKOV. TRANSLATED BYCARL & ELLENDEA PROFFER

YOU CAN’T TAKE IT WITH YOUMOSS HART & GEORGE S. KAUFMAN

HOMEDAVID STOREY

ENDGAMESAMUEL BECKETT

A CHRISTMASCAROLCHARLES DICKENS ADAPTED BY MICHAEL SHAMATA

THE CRUCIBLEARTHUR MILLER

DEATH OF A SALESMANARTHUR MILLER

KIM’S CONVENIENCEINS CHOI

SPEED-THE-PLOWDAVID MAMET

“THE MOST CONSISTENTLY EXCITING THEATRE COMPANY IN CANADA” –

���� :

Page 72: Fine Wine Auction 2012

LOT #16

PHOTO: JANE SOUTHEY

Page 73: Fine Wine Auction 2012

WITH THANKS

A SPECIAL THANK YOU TO ALL OF OUR VOLUNTEERS FOR ALL YOUR SUPPORT AND ENTHUSIASM

BELIEVE IN BLUE CO-CHAIRSMICHELLE AND PATRICK MENELEY

BELIEVE IN BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION CO-CHAIRSFRANCES AND EDWARD LEE

BELIEVE IN BLUE FINE WINE AUCTION COMMITTEE

TREASURER: ANN HASTIE SECRETARY/VOLUNTEER COORDINATOR: MARYANNA LUICOMMUNICATIONS: NEERA CHOPRA EVENT PRODUCTION/ SILENT AUCTION: TYIECE OTTEY, KAREN ARNONE DECOR: JOHANNE DOTSIKAS, ASTRID PLAYER MARKETING, CATALOGUE: LISA LECHNER, BRYN CURRIE, CARITA SHEEHY

FINE WINE ACQUISITION COMMITTEECHAIR - PATRICK MENELEY

CREATIVE BETHANY HARPER WILLIAMS

PHOTOGRAPHERJANE SOUTHEY

UPPER CANADA COLLEGE

ADVANCEMENT OFFICEJANICE BISHOP, CRISTINA CORAGGIO, JODY JACOBSON, MARIA KARAKOULAS, SAMANTHA KERBEL,

SANDI LAINE, STEVE MCLEAN, VICTORIA PULLEN

FINANCECYNTHIA CAMPBELL , PATTI MACNICOL, ANGIE SCISCI

FWA TREASURYDOUG KELLER-HOBSON, CARM ROMEO

CATALOGUE PRODUCTION JIMMY MACHADO, UCC PRESS

ANDY PRINGLEFRED BRUUN

DAVID BEAUROY

ALEX SQUIRESGRANT FARROW

BLAKE HUTCHESON

MICHAEL MACMILLANANDREW BARNICKE

LESLIE GIRODAY

TREASURER:SECRETARY/VOLUNTEER COORDINATOR:

COMMUNICATIONS:EVENT PRODUCTION/ SILENT AUCTION:

DECOR:MARKETING, CATALOGUE:

71

Page 74: Fine Wine Auction 2012

NotesNOTES

Notes

72

Page 75: Fine Wine Auction 2012

THANKSFOR BELIEVINGIN BLUEThe April 18 Fine Wine Auction and May 12 Believe in Blue Gala will support UCC’s unprecedented campaign to position the school as a global leader in the education of boys. The money raised will support these priorities:

science wing

scholarships

Please visit ucc.on.ca/galaauction, where you’ll find dozens of fabulous items that will be up for bids.

Page 76: Fine Wine Auction 2012