fioljuu bl - nber

46
CLcqW 11CJflqU © UO1CC ! ACIJ O ipc 20111CC jcxj uo o cxcccq iio bbp uivA pc dnorcq iiirporn cxbJ!c!1 bcI.w!ou bi.oiqqcq qrnr njj © 1ÔÔ2 PA D!CI 2 HUJCUJJG2P vuq D11!C1 j 2IUJCF VIILJJi2 W2CLACq 21J0L1 CO1J2 O O I4BEI LC2C91JJ bLow JU fOL 2U1IC2 ucwbjoAwcui COl J!OIJ OL M1!OII B11Lfl O ECOUOUJTC KCCLCJJ jJJ bbci j qic owc!! bo!ou OL bo11cX o fl2 DbI4uu o yqAoI COflUC!1 OU ou ucwbjoAwcui Cowbcuiiou Obiwoua awcq lu ipi2 qOCniJJCiU qo UO IJcCC21L!JX LCbLC2CU yacp ØujcL o. LOW ipc f DcbmuJcu o f9por qoz.A COHUC!! pcjbnj counucur vuq 1cuIcL cuibpcjj OL LCCVICp v awucc jpi bLolccl th2 nuqcq cwqci. N WIJJC flL!C B! bI BI1C Cq vqqou 2W14 r'Oii uq 21cbPcu Jooqpm.A OL OCi0PCL j cwpI.q NV on iOO 4W2VCfl2CU2 VACUflC MVIIOI4VT BflBEVfl Oh ECOMOV'HC KE2EVKCH fiOLJUU bL D9IJTCI j 2IGUIC DJ!GI 2 HWCUJJCIJ EAIDEI4CE Th80-ô3 HOf12EHOFD MErhVBE NICKOECOI4ONIC flJ4ENbFOANEtL 1142fl1VI4CE VI4D 4BEK iOKICIW3 bVbEK 2EIflE2

Upload: others

Post on 23-Oct-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

CLcqW 11CJflqU © UO1CC ! ACIJ O ipc 20111CCjcxj uo o cxcccq iio bbp uivA pc dnorcq iiirporn cxbJ!c!1 bcI.w!ou bi.oiqqcq qrnr njj© 1ÔÔ2 PA D!CI 2 HUJCUJJG2P vuq D11!C1 j 2IUJCF VIILJJi2 W2CLACq 21J0L1 CO1J2 O

O I4BEI LC2C91JJ bLow JU fOL 2U1IC2ucwbjoAwcuiCOl J!OIJ OL M1!OII B11Lfl O ECOUOUJTC KCCLCJJ jJJ bbci jqic owc!! bo!ou OL bo11cX o fl2 DbI4uu o yqAoI COflUC!1 OUou ucwbjoAwcui Cowbcuiiou Obiwoua awcq lu ipi2 qOCniJJCiU qo UO IJcCC21L!JX LCbLC2CUyacp ØujcL o. LOW ipc f DcbmuJcu o f9por qoz.A COHUC!!pcjbnj counucur vuq 1cuIcL cuibpcjj OL LCCVICp v awucc jpibLolccl th2 nuqcq cwqci.N WIJJC flL!C B! bI BI1C Cq vqqou 2W14 r'Oii uq 21cbPcu Jooqpm.A OL

OCi0PCL jcwpI.q NV on

iOO 4W2VCfl2CU2 VACUflCMVIIOI4VT BflBEVfl Oh ECOMOV'HC KE2EVKCH

fiOLJUU bL

D9IJTCI j 2IGUICDJ!GI 2 HWCUJJCIJ

EAIDEI4CE Th80-ô3HOf12EHOFD MErhVBE NICKOECOI4ONIC

flJ4ENbFOANEtL 1142fl1�VI4CE VI4D

4BEK iOKICIW3 bVbEK 2EIflE2

Page 2: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

uq j,ijVP' IX X8XI3 Vfl21TU IX 8I5flU!ACL2U) 01, jCW2 flUIACL2I 01, ICXDCbUwCu1 01, EC0UUflC Dcbn.1uJcu oj, cououmcDIJ!CI 2 HU3C1WP DJ1CJ j 2ICWICIC

bo2u0u 01, IJJC 1ACLC fl LCC!b!CUI 1,LOW qc1c4oIz1u

bLourw cucq qmju LGCC2a!0u2 izjq boicuivj qmou nWc!cu1J? jo bx.CAGUI pc ccouounc

ni bLo1.uw2 qq 1!c1oLA lop o wmiuiu pc Mcff-pcIu 01, m Lcc!b!cu EwcLcucA

poncpojq cowb9l.cq o opcL jpc juqu iwbj? 19 qm.u 1jJC Igo uq crLj) jj

vuq ) jpcI.c uo cXcjcvj LVIOU !U qJc LCjAC MCfl-pCiu 01, ni LCcthICIU

IUJC iJJC CCOUOUJTC Mc!J-pcw 01, poncpojqa qrn LCCCACq f[j pcuqj M V JC JIV01, OIPCL

iqcupcj poncpojqa (qCbcuqu ou ipc MCftøW wcv'm.c ncq) )Dciuu 2np2WIu9J bm.i 01, 1p

CCOUOUJJC MCJJ-pCIJ JJ M2 0U LAC1C pc1ccu iiuq bCJ.CCIU iJJVt 01, orpciiiic

cpcCuc MC uq: j) jpc ACLC flj IcJb!ciu ponpoq qnuu rpi bcuoq jrnq jCACJ 01,

MCJ1,1LC 01, JJC 1M0 tAbC 01, ponpojq qrI1J 1,OL qIICLCUCC iu pc ponacpojq

ccp drniuci. qrau ip bcuoq MC 0WU gic bcL-cvbiw vuq Jzjcucc-cJjc vqncq ccouowjc

u1,oLumqou OIJ jJ0II2CJ3OJq 2bcuqpJ !U Ipc coimnujcx. EXbCIXflUILC 2IJLACA2 1,LOW I2O- I EOL

nucwbjo)wciu UIU.IJCC (flj) pCUCJi2 wcmq p? counwbiou uoma ipi i.c qcAcq 1,1.0w

11112 2U1q? CX1UJTIJC2 iJJC LQJVPAC ccouowic #AcJJ-pc1u 01, poncpojq iJV LCCCIAC

VBLKVCI

EAIDEI4CE IÔSO-ô1HOIT12EHOFD RErhvKE: NICKOECOMOYIIC

f1I#1ENbTOANE,tL 1142fl1�VI4CE VI.ID

OC0PLIffi J04UIJ BL I2

Page 3: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

noibuboitnl .1

nisinism ifln8d oth !1w wofi bits atii3nsd inmoIqmnu ,idt bnq Irnjbivibni woH

15i31fl3 th aqsthq 315 bo1qm3nu i idmm '1imsI s n3rlw 23mii niiub 3fflO3fli b1orIuor1

di oi &dms3lq 3rIi ,Lqmsx iol .33fl51u2ffl !si3o 10 rrnol ls!uoiiisq iiIflo 2i2'IE115 3flt fit anoUup

3dt 3isiv3IIs oT" asw oquq au isth buon Q1 b 13A tiiu 1si3o2 3du 3m&d isilu hid 3auoH

griinistnism b3w3iv amsoiq a3r1u o a-r3bnuo'I i1T "..,.un3rno1qm3nu blo b abisxsrl

idio thiw u1sb asrl nsiuani in3mo1qm3nu no daisai iaom aichi uiqasU .lsiinsa as noiiqmiienoo

aaiuH d )howomsIl aniunuo £ itI h!th81sa bonimsx3 nsd voworI asrI oiqou airiT .auaai

gnibn3qa b3rlimsx3 morlwbo Its Q1) ninwoia bas (O8f) 1J bns 13bb1 (8VI) notaniA bits

nd asH 3uaai ouT .unom'o1qmonubo hloqa borsaffoqmo3 tiodmom orro aiwb ablorloauod cr1 aotsda

bns bLaisn'U 8Q I) daomiornsH 'd noiuqmuerloo Io 'ioodr obso-ouiI our 1o rxoinoo oth cr1 boosfq

ninisrnoo abloiIoauoiI rbirlw oi inolxo odu no bo2uQo1 oriw QQ1) ioduriD bns (V8QI) nh11or1

.-iooufr our 'd boroiboiq flrsq nibnoqa ofir mofi tisqob aiohow booIqmonu

10fflU2fI03 Ismio ofir cr1 bobriuoi nood ion asri ii rsth ai oiursioiil airli rhiw tIuarnib odT

iousdIIouM bns noisoG d bohsmmua as o) uIoisoaoi1o bod oijd A .blorloauorl srlflo ioodt

ni'buia floliW 'Iauonoa 'ioorU lomuarlo3 ni)fsi b aonIdhiuI oth borsiranomob asH (08Q1

anoaiisqrno3 oAsrn or rioiw air! .aiodrnom btorloauorfIo niod-IIow odu bns eoiutibnoqxs 'ablodoauorl

won aoia inoioThb b abtorloauonl isoii ol won oIqmsxo idi nrIobiano3 ruoduiw abfonloauont aaois

o aonq oth cr1 aonsnIa iob inuoo3s or won bits aomii inoioThb rs btorloauonl omsa orlt osqmo or

01oIolorIi ow sbuia airli ii! .noiqboi IIJ oIqmsxo idi d bodaiuniraib ablonloauod 'd rnIuod aboo

ofit 1o ioonIr ofir ni niod-IIow 'ainioiqi3ol no aiftonod IU 1o 2i3ofl3 orb 1o aia'Isris orb bnuoi

Page 4: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

3iuani aill3n3d oa3fh ob 113w woH :noiiaup 11in33 dt iowans ol au ni1dsn3 auth b1od3auod

cin3mo1qm3nuo albqa i2nis amiia noilqmuanoo

Anti to3lib ia-ill 3d1 nibivoiq auth 2ffi3n3d ITJIo ai3fl3 81s113w 3r11 no 23au3c11 aia'1sn 3dT

2i3fl3 &1i1o noiiBulsv3 3r11 325d 3W .io3r1i 3im0fl0330131m ol '3sup3bs 1113n3d no 31u1s13111 3di!Io

w3iv ni bns elsog e'mingrnq diIo idail ni 2u3o1 3isrlqolqqs sf11 noiiqmuanoo no l3sqmi cii no liflo

iIT .nisd-11sw 'eblodocuorl asnimisrsb tsdi 3ffiO3ffl tori noiiqmu2f1o3 ci ii isrli 131fi sth b

saw19tho oi bssieni luci nibnsgc insmo1gmsnu-g e'blorfseuorl in3ig Dl sdi 01 ion 21 nothsqmoo

no bnuod isqqu riB 21 buia snltbo i1ui t'snul-rnoflod" oriT .sl6w 3imonos 'abiodseuod lsoitn3bi

isdio bns etilsnsd IU nivissi eblodsauorl ocodi nsswisd siiIbw oimonos flu 33r1313Thb odi

ieniss ablodsauod i3eiolq 01 11S1 effisnod JU rbidw or tn3txs srIr 3lUCESffl ur1i 3W '.ablod3auorl

ob isdi eblodsauod is3iin3bi sciwisdio oi belsqmo3 es inomso1qm3rIu ff1011 nuiiuoi asacol omo3fli

.csaeol rbua luDril ion

smii lo bohsq Islinsiedue s svo abiodsauorflo anoii3sc-aeo1a htisup sviisinsc5Iqsl SCU sW

53n5-weni rn3moiqm3r1u 113w wod lo noiisnimsx tail! srii i&fio audi a3lsmuias i1T .(EQ-O8l)

noliesup srlt 01 a)lssqa sansbivo fbu .313'3 eeonieud srltbo ainioq irisisthb is noiiqrriuanoo anisiriisrn

svsd affisnsd b noiisiub Isiinsioq di bsbn3txs svsd isdt amsioiq IU 3nsioms dt l3disdw b

bso1qmsnu r1inisino3 ablodsauorl lo 8nisd-Ilsw sf11 ni 23n!k)sb 1s3i13'3 insv3lq 01 in9i3iIIua nosd

.213)110W

sislIsW' imonoI1o iut,I'1I .11

nisd-IIsw snli no SDnsluani tnsrn'o1qmsnu 10 iosqrni sf11 niaaibbs flu qsra iaill 1siinca nA

sis as-iuassm insisThb nsm duor1iIA •sis'uiow isubivibni b 31u253ffl s qolsvob 01 ci 2in31q1351 b

srlt or bsisls-i s11sinsmsbnth ci nisd-119w Isnsism isdi ssis bluow aio'nsado iaorn s3i13siq ni bsau

Page 5: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

"Isnoitsi" s -iomtjnoo odh3ob mibB1q Lsoitoiooth blsbnni2 odT .fBubivibni d bomu2no3 thoo

oiii oi iojdu2 iiIiiu oimixJ$m tzdi O3iv13 bn thoog Io noisnidmoo izrli ooorIo oilw inoi oth ioni ot oldiaaoq olqi3nnq nI i i howomsi1 2idi iobnU .ooiuoaoi IBi3nBflfi boiimiFlo inisli&io3

.bornuno3 aoiiiinEup or!i mofi oisllow 1ubivibni1o Ivo1

iobud s ot 133 jdua noiianth ii!iiu (3it13t) s oirnix&n Iubivibni lEfli omu 11s3IIi33q

Isubivibni io &dEnisfl tifiiu mumix&ri offi a oaoiqoi ( )' ffOfi3ffLh ii1iiu ioiibni orfT Jnzsiiarlo3

q ao3nq ni1 k oiuiibnoqxo Isioi bns A aoiudiifl duiw 1

(A k = ( )"1

bits aboo 1o noiiqrnuerio3 orli molt boviiob oiállow orli ainoaoiqoi noit3nLuI 'iifiiu i3oiibrn ouT

ow ow oaoqiuq isdi ioI .nid-I1ow1o oiuasom isionorn oviiiuini its obivoiq ion aoob lud 2331v102

nisiis 01 boiiupoi ouiibnoqxo lsioi lo lovol mijmirrim orb ai claidw noiionth oiuiibnoqxo oth

:q aonq is 1 Iovol iiIiiu

.(1A qjA' i3oiibni odi niw oiáulow b oiuasom 'isionorn £ oniob ol au awolls nOLi3nüI oitnibnoqxo ofiT

Isubivibni idb boiiupoi oiuiibnoqxo muminim oth od 01 boniIb ai aifiT .noiionxfi 'iifiiu 3niom onom

:( A q)M tovol iiIiiu nisiis ol 1q ao3iiq ao3s1 odw ! (I .) .(A ( A q) (A q ;A 1q)q

tIsnibio ai isiti niod-1fow bo oluasom vjisionom s aobivoiq noilorufi ii1iiu aiiiom 'onom i3Olibni odT

noit3nth 'iitiiu 3ntom 'onom orti aonq boxiI o1 .noiiorith iiIitu a'!subivibni orli 01 inotsviupo

.oth rud-I1w bits tifiiu !1 s1no bits 11 aoasoioni

oaodw b!odoauod sb oisILow orli aniisrniia&bo ansom s aobivoiq (1 .) noii3nth oiáulow suiT

oth oisqmoo 01 ilaiw ow isril ai iovewod inotdoiq iuO .onsuI3 ion aoob noiliaoqrno3 aiflqsiomob

Page 6: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

iuo! rftiw blorbeuocl n3iqi3i-IU I .b1orfwor1 woonood 1o 8n13d-Ifow b a!3v31 vitI31

oT VOOO rliiw o!quoa iniqb31non £ sfio lbw s OOOO1r1o bv3I 9miibnqx B bnB adrnm

s s b3iEu!Bvo d ium noir3nth iiIitu 3i1irn 'nom rh noioup bs3i1qdno3 iom eidt 13W&IS

:s noii3nüI 31u1w dt 3thw31 na W .1A 23i2i1i3B1Bfb 3xdqsornb bo 3n31I3I

(A 1'A q ;.,A 'q)i =

() [CA '1 'q)0rn( 'q q)k]\A. =

virsE3i rfi a b3nibb xebni iiq 3iui33q2-b1od2uorf B k sIbwbo noisiniq visrriiI irti nI

:'bvi13qI 1q bnB q o3flq i L3vf 'iLiu 8ninisnBbO O3

CA 1 'q)M\igA q)M = (1 'q q) ot viiBb1 O3 i bns ab1of1uod O13E bn ni 3ni1Iib iuqs3 0rn 1s on31viup3 dT

:1 bv3I 'iiIiiu iniBflto bfoituorf niI31 d bbri iirh

(1A 1 CA 1 1q)0rn

.noiqmuno3 n3IBviups qbo 19v31 3dt s b31q13tni d flS3 ni iueom eisw ouT

bnB iiI Vgniod-1!3w oiuaom o bow I1Baiq smie3 b32Ed-mo3ni mrn'I i&fiib ir1 oob woH

omo3ni ns no nsrli ioultin noilqmu2no3 b1odowod oth no bo2Bd i oiusem oisIow oth omoio1

bodiioob tEth a rbu *iowOmEiI boiioq-oIni £ nirliiW .orno3ni x61-oq 10 riimio as uloua iqo3no3

oth moil bviwtoxo boviiob ai 'ii1ihi o3nia qono oIsrlqolqqB oth hBo!3 i noiqmueno3 ovodE

.bomuarioo aoaivioa bns eboo

s o1 i ii iud 91iflOw b oiusom "iorI2qsn" s oI aiascl b5noo1q oth i noiqmu2noD

isrh omuaA .ai2odioqd ornooni-nonErn18q odi o bos1i anosoi idb ocno3ni miio1i1 io1 'xoiq

.omooni nonsmioq iith no bosd omit uIuoidi noiqmuano3 o thq otdsa oaood3 alsubivibni

Page 7: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

r03T1U3 d b3rsral3bnu 21 8rno3fll rn3fuirrrl3q amooni Isunas lsuau risth i9woI vsr1 orlw aor1i nomA

3253 (13s3 nI 213V31 3ffl0311i Isuau iI&Ir 18d1ft 3vsd orlw alsubivibni io1 8&Jlr 21 3218V31 ouT .8ff103111

rnii1i1 aorsmixotqqs noirqmuano3 isdi 02 8ffl03 rnonsrfnoq or ISIJpO OsiOVS no ai flOirqlTlIJaflO3

8fflO3fI1 inoTwo aoob nsth 'brs1u3s oiom ois1bw

nhuesorn nsth iodisi eiaoflo ooilq 3ft133q2-bIorloeuorI aoistoqioani oats xobni oiuilow mO

idirn airlr dw ooa oT ND out as rfaua xobni oariq 8r585IS ff2 u1urnr1i rtsu1o ohq'1o i33flo oth

bits boot or 283iu0281 ati 1o noir3sul sis1 s asrovob b1oduod iooq £ rsth saoqqua insrioqmi od

b 2O3fl Ofti ni 2025313111 aitsrnsib ois oioulr1I 'flo ioflod ai isrir btodoauorf £ ot boisqrno3 niuod

ni3s1 rsth or ovirsbi '11sirnstadua noah ovsd 111w looq out ni3tI nivi1 b tao3 oth niauout bns bodI

ot 1is 111w IT) odt d asiutibnoqxs io omoani lo noitsflob 1suu ouT .noirsluqoq oth bo iaoi oth

.8nsft3 83fl £ ulaua bo iasqrni lsiirioioThb oth olutqs3

ois oth rsdi obulanoa or oldsnoasoi ii ai noitqmuano3 omsa odi ovsrl abfodoauorl owl 11

iiorlr bns abtouloauoul owr orirlo noiriaoqmoa out no abnoqob iowans oth tsiono nI Sfio-1bw '1Isupo

rtiiw btorloauorl s as noiiqunuanoa b lovol ounsa out boon ron aoob Esubivibni otnia A .aboon ovitsbi

oanolsviupo oth r1uoiu1i () ni boiuiqsa 21 inomoluasoun ois'IIowbo iaoqas aidT .aiodrnom novoa

o3no1oboi £ riias1 tsth ot Iovol oisllow novi £ 8ninisric bo raoa ovitsloi oth oisqmoa rbirlw ao1s3a

.b1or1oauod

£t11J .111

-lornuauIO3 odi fli2U aifloiqiOOl IU bo niod-Itow out niiuasom or rnonoqmoa Isaitiia A

bits IUbo aoibuia omo .noitqmuanoa no sisb ovianor1oiqmoobo ba sal II noiio iii lobom 3115100db

'8V1U2 30(1 bs '(IOV no io rtibnoqa bo arnonoqmoa W01 5 10 0110 bO aoiuasom no bi1t ovsrl riibnoqa

Istot 011J253(1I or ono wo11 ot '(IseaoaorI 'tt1sup dibo sisb otsi8no or l3)1ifnU 812 isutt aoarioqaoi

Page 8: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

'1no di no sbi ioIirIr oW QQ! riinwoifl ;V8f hTId bilE b[21nrrU ffOiqmu2flO3

(X3D) ic1 isco odi oiEi2 biinU orli ru LiEb ruibnoqa IOi3áIadE&IO $31U02

as1qms Isnoiisn oviisinoaoiqoi sbivoiq a'oviua oaorlT aoiiaiial2 iod&J 1o usoiuH oth d bodailduq

iuO .xsbnl 3311q ismuanoD 'k1inom orb loino Isdi aidiow oiuiibnoqxo orb oisfu1s3 ol boau sis isdi

duoiñi ruibnotxo bna 08Q1 Ioioiisup bno3ea orb ni ninniod anol dohoiisup aobuI3ni olqmse

EQQ I 1o ior1sup dfluo1 orb

o quo-is £ as uorbio borutIob "tinu 18fflu2f103" odi ai XEID orb ni noiisvioado 3iasd odT

odw afsubivibni as anoiai3ob nibnoqa iniol olsm ol aoaiuoaoi isionorn iloth !ooq odw Isubivibni

.alsubivibni boisloinu lnobnoqobni 'f1si3nsni1 as io inomonwns 1soI io boold d boisloi ols

Io owl iaso[ is ith asq tsubivibrui orb iodiorfw1o aiasd orb no boriirrrioiob ai o3nobnoqobrri lsf3rtEnfI

b "bsod" io noaioq 'oruoioboi" oriT aoanoqxo 8nivil bns uiauor1 booi :amoii ooirli aniwolfdI orb

fl53 2'OV1U2 orliIo osievoa odT 3rIobiaol orb ainoi uo ariwo oriw noaisq orb ai elirtu lOfflLJ2flO3 orb

fbo niviI Ionrioaioq 'isiiliM .noiisluqoq r15111v13 boi1snoiiuIiianinon orb as bodh3aob od 1IE1onO8

iioth obiatuo ruivi1 atnobula oolloD .bsbu!oxo ols oasd no grilvif oaoth oliriw bobuI3ni os oasd

orfiIo flsq oxs bsrnds eowiibnoqxo IovsT .aiinu omuano3 oismqoe as boisoi ois aomorf 'atnolsq

.lOfI 21 253210V0 boruoiisie aruxi1i3 2.U d nibnoqe iud a!siot borioqoi

21 tiflu lOfflLl2flO3 f1350 fl3ifIW (Ii tsmio1 lorisq flhiEiOi £ ifi nood ovsrl a'oviua orb 08Q1 33fl1

ois ablodoauorl orb bo inooloq 'inowt lorlsup viovH •aiotisup oviiu3oanO3 ovil idi bowoi'riotni

3ir{qsiOmob 21331103 wivioini iaia oriT .atinu iornuanoa lo quoi won s 'd boaslqoi bns boqqoib

2WSI'notni ihotinup iuot ruinismoi orb nI .eo1diub iomuanoo b 'ioXrtovrui lsiiisq s bits noitsrrricftni

'horIELJp ff353 .b31331!o3 al arliriorri ooirf I auoivolq orb flFI3VO3 noitsmidmni oiuiibnoqxo bofislob

Page 9: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

LcbLc2cIucq pA qic f1L9JC ooq

(j) iu iipicp pc 2GWCC2 LGCGLAC couc2bouq o fC obbo14r1urA co o pojqw pc 972Cr

2GLAICC U0P12 j0W COIJ2fIWCL (1L9C2 (12!U 9 wcpoq qcAcobcq pA CP LJ2GU 9uq lOLCU2OU

2JucC pc c2!w9Gq 1.cu9j A9JflC oupc powc 12 Lcboucq lu jjpn /io oupe 2flLACA2Q MC C9JCflj9C

GUCL9C pA OL cx9uJbjc JnuJbiuc22 Eu bnl.cp92c2 EOL p0f12!U P!2 12 9 2P9Xpf0LM9Lq CXGLCi2C

LCLU9J cdnrA9Jdu2 20 JJ9i M opi9ru j0i o cou2r1wbiou °L IQ2C ,cwa uq 9AOJq bLOpJcw2

ExbcuqnLc2 ou 0MUGL-occrlbicq JJOfl2iu 9uq COU2nUJCI. flL9C2 9LC I.cbJ9ccq pA jJC 9bbL0bLi9C

ccnuA 9XC2 i.C 9120 qcjccq 2IUCG pcA i.c cowboucu2 o 29Aiu L9flJCL qJ&U cou2nwbfiou

j0w pc p9212 0W02 2u1q1C2 0)uq!Aiqn9 MGIL9L bdu2!0u2 tCiLCUJCu C0IUUflP0U2 9uq OCi9

(&uq qi2Cfl22 jiGW 2Gb9L91C1A J9GL ou) eiucc uJ1.ni2W LcdflILc2 9 couccbW9j OLUJflJ9P0IJ 1J19i qJpL2

couccb 9bbLobu9c 0L lpG woqcj qccupcq iu CcJ0U Jf MC qcjcc !2 9uq C92 c0uL!pn!ou2

MC woqiQ pc qcuiiou o c0u2rIuJbi0u o coLLc2bouq 92 cJo2cjA 92 bo22ipjc o pc

9LC Lcbo4cq ccnicjA

ooq 2Wwb2 9uq mcrj uq LCU I.GCG1AG 92 bA i.c b oj i09J 6xbcuqinLc o pc cxcu p9 pcA

92 cwboAcL-b9iq !u2flL9uCC uq 1JC911P C9LC jcqcq uq 0ACL1JWCLJ1 JJ0r1211J 9LC uoç

o bcu21ou LCaCWCU puq uq ocJ91 2ccnufA i.c 9jao iucjr1qcq Mp!Jc WO2 w-jciuq L9U2CL2 2fIC}J

orl2qc c poncpoq 92 ThCJJ 92 2bcuqiu ou oMucL-occnbicq p0fl2i1J 9Uq qr1L9pJC2 C0U4PfU0u2

iu pc qcuiiou °L 09I cxbcuqirn.c iU2 uq C92JJ COUWPfWOU2 0 bcJ.2ou2 (uq 019ui9!0u2)

jpc CEX LcboLl2 ou fC oni-o-bocjcc cxbcuqwac2 OflJC COU2IIIUCL flU1 IPC BF2

0L1pC f1 bobnj9pou

21fl.AGA bLoAtqc2 2gwbJc o,pcMccu tooo uq e000 2Cb9L9G COU2ITUJCL fl1JU2 11191 12 LGbLC2C1J491!AC

Page 10: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

b 2drnom 1 2uoiv3lq 3th 8nnub rnooni bnidmoo r1i d or bniI3b i X1D 3rIr iii 3moorII

1no b12s mo3rii oi biflb1 2noiisuQ 10 e1' I 1vo iinu lornu2no3 9drbo 2l3dmom 118

ñffll edt ni tinu iemunoo edt ni iedmem wert i eiedr II .eweivietni rlflfl bn bno32 edt ni

b 2inenoqmo3 edT .2leilsup woiveiq edt ioI bsiou1tno391 21 (IOi2id 3ffl03f11 bernse efit weivietni

iedto bnfl 'tnU332 IE13o erno3ni inernolqme-1e 28i1BlB2 briE aesW :ei bebubni 3mo3ni

tiehow eans1ueni iriern'o1qmenu emooni lsinei 2bnebivib t2eietni erno3ni tnemeiitoi

ierlto bcis tIoqqu2 iol anoztudrzlrxo3 wluex 3nfli2i22s 3ilchJq aiftened 2'ns1i3v noiiE2neqm03

3ff103f1i edt ot enoqeeinon iol berrnoheq 31B 2noitsiuqmi on eeiutibneqxe elikiU .emo3ru

briE 23BW 2E fI3LJ2 ffl03fIilO 231U02 iom id! eulsv ebivoiq ron bib rnebnoq2ol erlibI .2noiteup

riB as befti2asf3 2SW tifw 11TW2fl03 erli tfltJ33 Isio 10 3frloOni inemoIqme-bIe2 2f1EIS2

".lei-Ioqel emooni eielqfnooniH

ew e3ni .8QI briE 8QI ni belqmfle aEw noitsluqoq nsdiu edt 'lno ario2ei '(1si3bud ioT

edt ni XD edt mo-il ablodeauorf lsiui Ifs eteleb ew O8 I iii ninnied aenea emit uounuirioo S IfIEW

r1ou atilened IU bevieoei ô es ievo bserl £ ritiw ablorleaijod web (13V eausoeH .aise' ierlto

ii'li tneiqioei IU £ 25 beiliaaslo asw blodewod A .elqmsa edt moil bebuloxe oats eiow ablomleauod

-elqitlum nI .arltnorn evbwt taB1 edt 8nhub emit emoa ts aillenedlo level eviriaoq s nvieoei belioqei

on ni bns tneiqi33i edt b tiinebi edt gninimieteb wolls tori aeob XD edt ablodeauofl noaieq

Satilened edtbo noitiub Iflutofi edt ertimieteb ew no blodeauorl

edt mon adtnom evlowt tneoei iaom edt ai boiieq nitnuo33s edt buta airli i1J0d1J01flT

ot eno moil elqmsa edt ni ed nso blorleauorl rls3 .noiauoaib edt io aeiui1 edt iti beisoibni ierisup

edt grthub bevieoei atiboned bns aemno3ni IsunnE no auodl edT .noithfls no nibneqeb a1efIsup iuob

.amnEio1q tnemnievo Iii bisbnsia eis isrft aboneq nitnuooos dtiw tnetaianoo 21 erliriom evtewi iafiq

8

Page 11: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

s arIw abow (wI Idiaaoq) 3th no u3o1 1h2e39n OflfW3 w i&D ivwori (nm aob aidT

1am twm no 'fio-3bs1 li aniqi Enu3s1 t&IT .bo1qm,nu nd 3v&I tdgirn i3drn8rn bIoduod

d3zriw ni 'w 3di rhiw ini2noo sis r&It alsvrnini srni isvo 2woft nibnsqe no stib boos nisido 01

.noiiqmunoo siuasm '1fsuw aiaimonoao

.slq(nsa sth ni 518 aiirni ismueno3 Q8óeQflo Isiol s ;EQI 01 :O8I mofi isrisup srft nI

rnioq 1s131rn iIT .sIqms2 XHD srIi ni issqqs ii ff3rfIw ni lsnsup riass ni bebubni ei btortsauorl r1as

10 2 .U edi ni 2bIor1suoi1 lo svitsinss1qs1 IIsisns i elqmse sf11 istisup visvs ni isdi €i isvswor1

•isvo siinstadu asisulauft noitioqolq silt tud insiqbsi JU sis (insaisq .ô) QQQ! blorfsauod silt

eth 2woIldI noiisqiaiti&T .isrlsup riass iii noirroqolq 2irlt 21nssiq I iui1 ziS3 neettuol eth

silt bnuois atilened bevisasi elqmse silt b tnsaisq . lb ssisvs nA :'b2ol3 'hijI s1a'a sniaud

-sniaud eth arihub oe bib insaisq VA lno lirlw :8QI bits 8I neewied rluoii

.t:Q8Qf bits :V8QI neowied bohsq Issq SIas(3

iaellsi sisb silt b teoM .noits1uqoq lU-non bits ITJ odtlo noiiieoqmoa edt eslsqmoa I eldsT

no 2u3o1 srfi tud ishow isilto ot atnsiqiasi lIflo noansqmoa uoivsiq ni bsvisdo need sr1 tsdw

siiq2sb smoani bits esiuiibnsqxs Istot ssiovs-woIed svsd atnsiqtaSl IU bvon 'lidi1a al b1oileuorl

io1 Isaitnebi ai blocbeuod silt b bssrl edflo ss esisvs edT .bIodsuod sill ni iemss eiom nivsr1

ieisl IIsiinsiadu i blorlsauod sift lb ssia esisvs eth duorlt1 a1nsiqiasinon bna atneiqiasi rltod

noms betrrsaeiqeriebnu sis ablorlseuorl bebssd-slsrns1 bits etic1wnoM .ablodeauod insiqiasi noms

IU isilt 135!! silt i insaiuirii teom eqsdis .dtuo2 sift ni 8nivil eblodecuorl sis es atnsiqiaei IU

IIJ-non lb ineaieq £ elidW .einsiqiasrnon nsdt noitsaubs esI esisvs no svsd eb!odeeuoif

islimie evsrl eblodseuorl ITJ lb tns3leq V 1no noilsaubs easlloa emoc less! is svsil eblodseuorl

V& dtiw bsisqmoa estsubsi ssI1oa sis eblodeeuorl IUlo tnsaieq f1 'lno bits ;elevsl Isnoitsaubs

Page 12: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

a-mcc0mI—

.1680 .1685AEVB

.'88e .1888

2

.ieao

8

8

a

.10EIGflBE .1- bbObObJJOI1 fli bECIbIEVJ2

ft BECIbIEI&L2

Page 13: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

140 CLUCL 0'0 0'03 0,08

op 005 0'OS 005bon2c c 01i2 0'OJ 001 0'OIbonac oos oos oosHqOIpCL2 Ø•J5 O'JQ 0,J5Hq bon ' 01JiC12 0•0ô 0.13 0'0

rc 2bon2c 08 034 050'38 o'so

EUJG C0mb0!0U

aiGq O'QX oMCI Ø•5Q

2°l1J 05ô 0'SS 050'SQ 030 0SQ

140t4IC 0,51 0'SS 0.5J

0.15 002 013Ø'J4 008 O'J4

20UJ6 COJJGG 052 054 0'5HP P°°I L116 0'30 0'40 0'30

0'JS 0'J? 0'JJ

I - 8 0'OQ 0'08 0'OQ140 CJJOOf 000 0'OO 0'OO

qflCOU ojicq

ecuqci oj,pcq: vi 0'85 0'W

14OUMpic 0J 014 O'JQMP 084 0'8Q 084

jçcc oj,pGq(oQ) (oo)

14rIWpGL 0LGBLUGL I QJ I 'ôø JRÔ

Or0Jq 2ISC 3• 14

(J5.fl)v8copcq 3ÔQ8 3ó'31

(zsss) (z188J?) (zsfsi)BCLOLG-X IUCOIJJC Z5540 Z5QQ35

(zuoJ3) (1sJJ) (I2I8Q)10IJ GxbCuqiInLC 51J35 Z53042

nu

jpj j wbic (nJqLq qc w

Page 14: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

cDod 3vd of 1Ii1 iom i.s thIodwod in3iqi33l-IU I1sniJ .abIorI3wocI LU-non noms fn33I8q

•thfod3euod fn8iqio3l-non & nsrlf &ffnom svI3wf fq 31ff ru rxbhow euoq

3fl0 fn8iqi331non o i&It wol8d 'ffsiinsf2dua i affl3iqi33l LU 1o 8morni 3813V 31ff fir1W

nmu1o3 owi i2111 31ff nI .noitluqoq 3rff1o quoidua oiaa an31fiib 3d of 313th fa3qx3 bluow

as s d b3flias13 aquoi ioI a13v81 3luiibru3qx3 bnfi 3mo3ni 3viiEI3l 8111 3nimBx3 w 3IdsT b

Isnoiisoub3 l3woI diiw or1i bns 2in3iqi33l l38nuoY .83n3b1231 'b noix bn noif3ub3 ex3

31S a3mO3fli 3813VS 3111 31111w 2fn3iqi331non 8IdBlRqrnO3 of 3vifafsi amoru 13r1icf 3vB1I fn3lnniBfls

bn.& fn3iqi331 n33wi3d qE 3(1103111 3ff I .thfod3worl b3bB3d-3fBm81 iol me rf I '1r1uoi

3(11 2n0i31 1Jn3D iuo'I 3rlr nomA .aiir1w flOf11B n&1f 3fir1wnon 311OB 13ll&ru i efn8iqia3lnon

.b31n3231q8113b11u sis LU niVi3331 orf I isrIf wsa 3W 81311w rffuo 31ff ni i31s1 i qs 1s13n3 nI 3moani b bs8fni emfibn3qx8 1sof 8nimsx3 ew nerlw worisn 2n313fbib r1f oU

Isiof 3B13VB 111 83fl318'fiib 31ff isrIl a3is3ibni £ 31(1ST bo nrrtuloa rfiiuo1 3dT i iwrrs df

risrtf aonO3is3 3s ovib 3d i b iuo1 ni ioob 315 eirl3iqbolnon bits ef1131q1331 LU n33wi3d e3luiibn3qx3

2bIorI32uod LU-non 31311w 1ô- 3s bsr1 s 1111w bIoduod norris 1nO .3mo3ni ni 233n313Thb 315

iob bnuoI o215 i 2irIT .31111 ion 21111 i 2231 rnvsa sd 2urlf bns 28311181 n ino3 of l3)h1 iom sis

!B13rI3 nI °'.28i1o3fE3 IsrlOflS3ub3 i2om brw 2bfor13wod b3bs3rI-315m bns 2iir1wnon 23iidw

.3mo3ni 10 3luiibn3qx3 Isiof is aIoo1 8110 l3rftsdw 3(1152 31ff 315 2tfua1 3vtfsfiIBup sift 13v3wor1

as fnsiqi331non of 8v115131 23lufibn3qxs lafof 131fr11 3v811 2blorIsauod insiqf3ol b31&ub3nu nuoY

31ff 111 nivi1 2in3iqio5l 2flOi31 2tJ2f13D nism iLJO1 3(11 niisqmoD .ablorl3auod b3b5311-315m3'I ob

thloifswoH .noiisluqoq 8(11 'bo i1 3111 of 3v11518) sluiibn3qx8 Isiof 8B13VE fa3woI 31ff 8vsrl rffuo

1o 2slufibnsqx&bo oifsi 128wo1 31ff 3v511 2diruorn 8v13w1 125q 31ff 8nnub ni*uow 23WO2 dfocl rlfiw

.21311153 o 2noifsnidmo3 in8loThb ninisf 1103 2blorf8euoi1 noms 2131110 of bslsqmo3 21n31qi381 LU

0I

Page 15: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

J40GUiCI2 ZX440 080 JJ840 001

OWGL2 Z10Q4 118 0403 TO?

3bonG'copCL 0?1 00 ZQJ? 080

3borwc joo o zioiot o0WGL Z840? ff01 ff88

bon ' 0IJJGL 40?40 ff84 ZO1QO ff8?

2bonc 30g OX 383 081

Hq 1Q008 08 Z1?4 0.8.X

ELUCL C0Wb02!1!0U

MG2 000 ZXO ff03

30111jJ Z41Q ff84 ZT0\0 080.0 J00QQ 00

14OLpC 30 003 004jçciou °LLc2rqcUCc

QLF1CC}J00J 3Q11 08? OJ?J ff00

COIIG&qniG Z33348 08? ?00 ff0130WCC0j!CC 8013 101 83 103H!I CP00J Lqnc ?08J ff0 00Q0 ff0?

0-TI Z40Q 11 Jg)JQJ 110I - 8 O8O? ZJ18? 100

140 2CJJOOI I?81 000 ZT?T\ 00ojJcq

ECW1C 1Q88? 100 1?8? 1OZ8838 ff82 S3J0 08.

Gq opcq

14OUM}J!1C 00? 140 00ff80 Z31Q88 001

jçcc ojcq22

-4 8Q40 ff08 23 ff02

42-

24 3J4OJ 084 44Q O8Q3? - 44 58QX? ff81 3430 08Q2-34 3080 ff88 18?1Q 005TQ4 ZIQflO 130 1300X

v opsq

ØAGL 000 0.o

11! flI \ 140U-flI fhl III \ 140U-flI

IUCOWG ZbGUqlIILG

ll0flGIJ0P1L5PIG flO0GOJ LUCOWG iuq XbGUqflLG fG16JZ iuq K!0 LOL KGC!b!GUt uq 041'"

Page 16: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

ri,dIO bna ztn9iqiil ITJ b noziiiqmoD uiuI3W .VI

£ nn(ui33qe d bstfimita9 3d bluo3 () ni noitxith 31ll9w 9th 3onst2muo1i3 lB9bi isbnU

bits anq ot noitonth bn&n3b b3ilqmi 3rlt gniflhl noit3nth ii1iiu ta3iibni silt ioI nnoI 3rIisfnBlEq

bstsmita3 3rlt moil abisw±sd nits'istni d nOit3nhjI siuiibrtsqxs Silt nnSvO3S1 bits stsb bnsrnsb

bits (aiss' M) tioifa 'hiI al bohsq elqrnsa sift S3fli .(18Q1 nsmausH ni as) anoii3nLft bnsmsb

S3nqIo tsmitas saisiq nistdo ot tIu3iflib sisv ai ti XID r1t ni bstioqsi ton sm asnq sasrlQluq

.sisrl la3ii3SlqfrIi 1135o'lqqs iosiib aidt sAam asitlu3iflib sasriT .ai3fi3

bits sxsbni sanq niw noiiarith siiitlsw r1i stsrnixolqqs sw svitsnisils tasd-bnosa s aA

blodsauod thss io1 .bnsmsb 'lo Isborn 3rltsfnOflOos Isinidi s sliupsi ton ob tsth asLsoa nslsviups

:as bsriflsb xsbni 3d5 5 SW SW

1 & =( q q) f=n

.'tibornmo3 th'n silt 'lo s3FIq silt ai bits ! b!orlsauod io'1 it boos b sisria ibud srlt ai sistfw

silt bits blorlsworf doss io'I XECI) silt ni bstioqsi asisria silt aniau bsts1uo1 ei xsbni soilq audi

touboi bits smoonl IsrtoitsM silt iii asiuiibnsqxs noitqmuanoa lanoaisq b aioisfIsb sonq tioifqmi

sd 111w noitsflni bsx1t s-Is atdisw sift isilt asmuaas xbni sifaassq sift 33flt 2tfIUO33A

arnsttsq nibnsqa iii atnsmtaujbs 'ablodsauod asis-Ioq-Io3ni tsdt xsbni its ot svttslsi btsmitasisbnu

sfqmsxs iol) "asid noitutitadua" sift lo astscnftas auoivsiq .asorrq vits1i iii anrI moib saris tsrlt

.llsrna (IsV at ti isth etsorbiti isvsworl (88Q I bLsnoUa.sM bits isnsM bits O81 etISwLliiSla

s1s3a sorislsvwps blorfsauod sift ai (IOttoflLft sis'l1w sill lb tnsnoqmoa Isoitho bitoosa silT

£ )howsmi1 aith rudflW .ab1oa-lauod 2uosflso1si3cf b abe8n sift stuassm 01 bsniasb 21 rloidw

anzdt isifto isift 02 nid-Ilsw lo 1vsl 9(1152 3111 iiisinism 01 2531U0851 som 2311Up51 blodsauorf

sbuflnsm 3111 snicrnsisb 01 ai 31221 lsornqms silT .sisulsw asoubsi sia 'lims'1 iii sassioni its Isups

II

Page 17: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

Iior in2nO3 £ is 13dmtf1 b!oiIswod 1&ioiiibbs r1 IIriW 3aa313b nid-!!3w (I3IfIW d 1drn3m 'Iimt Lsnoitibbs r13s8 rsdr emijeas In3i1qm! in3rnl2ulbn £riqs3-lsq A .noitqmuenoa

oi 9IidW .inuornB ema 3di d b1odwod 9th lo 2b99n 8th aini io s o 31b1s,

a3mu2iq ii 3nia bon 1o noii fl3131 isup8bs ns 3bivolq oi s13AiInu i fI3srnqqB ir1l rn8fn9Iqmi

noiiqmu2no3 a, 31532 1o 23im0n033 .rluba n&o eoth as ms 9th 315 blirl3 sb 2rn3m3liup3l 9th isdi

".b3lon8i 0215 315

rrl3lsviup3-rIubsIo isdmun 3dfto rsrniio its d 21)33(1 tn9s1q31 or si rlasoiqqs 3vii&nr1s nA

Isnoithrun 3(11 no 31532 33n315v1up9 3rfi 3asd 01 21 2iflt 8niobIo 'sw 3n0 .b1oduod 3(11 ni 213dm3m

3(11 ioI 2ln3illun a3r1i ni2sif31uq 'b ataoa di qu anibbA .noithrunf&n biovs or b31iupI 3)151(11

b q'i 323r1T .2b33n 3v115131 li9rIt niisqrno lob Eiasd 3r11 a9bivolq ab1oduodbo q'r 1n313Thb

1snoisn 3(11 3151u3153 oX 2u2n9D 3rIrbo usiuH 3r11 'd beau 2bIorle3lrIi ytt3voq 3(11 ni n3ilqrrn 315 231632

.Xsi 'X13voq

33n315v1up3 3r11 (111w nibn3qa blorbworl or in3mIwlbs stiqsa-ieq sdr isqmoo oiuiI

ii3ilqrni li9fli'bo 2fnlol (II 23m9flx3 inloq 1n3231q31 sismiX owl erfT .2u2n3D 3(11 'd b32u fs IsdI muass rn3rnr2uibs sriqsa-ioq 31'IT .noirqmu2noo I'ti 31532 b 23imono3 ncr1s3no3 anoirqmuass

b 19v31 311152 3(11 nisfls oX Isubivibni sL8ni2 sbo 3luiibn9qx3 9th 29mi1 iuob 2311up31 iuoYbo 1irns1 s

fl3V32 lo iirns1 s ioI .Q8. 1 i 1so2 n91sviup9 2u2n33 8th ioi 13v91 nibnoq25rto3 3dT .fli3d-ll3w

3bivolq dr 1diaus1q 21 23ismi123bo 132 13d113n 811(1W 1no 21 31532 9th 2Isubivibni iom 10

in3miaulbs siiqs3-13q 311T .3libI3w 1o 231smi123 iuo no 2bnuod i3wol bits iqqu 81d5no2531

33n315v1up3 '2uen3D 9th 3lidw 31iIJ3w bo 18v91 3r11 23lsmila8lsbnu bns noilqmu2no3 a3rsfl3bl8vo

or 2blod92uod 1n31q1331 ITJbo 2bisbrlsie niviI 81S03 w awollol lsdw nI .3liaoqqo 3r11 ob a31sa

,ern3mreuibs b e3qr drod fti2u aln3iqi39lnon b 3aodr

Page 18: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

wm

0rr:i:0Ct)mI01m0

EIGflBE 5-- H0fl2EH0D EOnIAVrELICE 2CVE2

.1 5 3H0fl2EH0D 2IE

2 eT0

.1

5

3

2

e

8

a

C6U2 Edfl!AI6UC6 2C6?b6L CSb!9

Page 19: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

afn3iqiael IU rt8wi3d 1á113w 31ffl0fl033 iii 233f19181hb (sfn13q) 3trnf1frI8O1 sivs dT

3fsmifas ris as rlo!iqmuano3 zftqs3-q rtiau 1dsT1o nmuIo3 taifi sdi ni btn3as1q is i&Iio bris

ai idT .'arn3iqboulon 1o in3313q 4. E8 ai afn8iqi38l LU !Io 31a11w rff 513VB nO .nid-U3w lo

b noii bits noifs3ub3 xa si a d b311i22513 aquodua aaoias noifsnsv Isiicmiedua ivwod

fn31q . ai fsdf 1v3I iiilw aivs ifs vsr1 -ô1 s bsd a rlfiw abIorI3auod JIJ .33nbia31

I .1 ai s bad a fhiw 3201ff io1 3iuiI nibnoqa1io3 3dT .ain3iqi33lnon b tarlf wol3d

idi 25 113w 25 a3flflwnon io1 l3wonsn 21 ain3iqia3lnon bits efn3iqi33l n33wf3d qag 3dT .in3313q

213v31 311113w avs 3vsd fn3fnnsna lsnoiis3ub3 wol rIJiw 2frE31q1351 1U .abIoc1auor1 b3bs-1am1

.noifs3ub3 siom iliiw ab1odauorI noms qa 31ff of b3lsqmo3 afn3iqb3lnorlbo saodf of l3aob rbum

as noifqmuano3 in3Iaviupe-13q aniau anoifsludsf 3aiff aiaqs1 3IdsTbo nmuloo bno3s2 3rlT

2fn31q1331 LU riwiod '3nsq3-I3aib if ni3d-ff3w bo noifain3a1qi ai1ff niaU .3luaR3cif 5tiul3w 31ff

IU moiI afiuai sIhsmhq aidT .bau 21 noiiqmueno3 £flqsa-loq n3rIw nsrli -I3worIsn 21 al3flfo bits

lii 315321o a3imono33 tsifnsfadua 3rIf'bo 32u533d bodainimib ai jfi rh fud iis1 ani3d abIorI3auod

isrf f 19v31 315113w £ 3v5d 2fn3Lq1381 IU 3B13VE nO .231a32 33n315v1up3 r1f ni ii3ilqini noifqmuanoa

3vitsflIzup 31ff ivwoH .ni3d-1bw1o noifsfn3a3lq3l aith niau 'ain3iqbslnonIo if13313q I .IQ ai

233r1313Thb 3dT .b3va31q is (I) nmulo3 ni nworla 313W fsth quo 3idqs1om3b 'd a3on31flib

abforl3euod b3bs3rf-31sm31 23flrfwnon io'I l3Ilsrna niss sis atn3iqi33lnon bits afn3iqb5t LU n33wi3d

13118111 nisfla IU 3v1333I orlw abs3rI blorl3auod nuoY .8nbhow ai b5311 i1f '1no 31311w 3201ff bits

1ooda dgirf a nnrff 2231 fud noiiaoub3 moa dfiw aodt ob as afn9iqi331fxon of 3vifsf5i 213v91 5111113W

.smolqib

rf I Isflf I 3ldsT ni waa w iud ;afn3iqi33lnon ndff1o 3aiow 33513V5 no 315 afn3iqi33l IU

31o1 rIi 3nimsx3 oT .213v31 311113w l3woI if I nisIqx3 bluoo fsrIt 23i12i1813815113 fn3l3Thb 3v511 oals

El

Page 20: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

J.4OCLIJGL -11'O

OPCL 58 -J'2bonG % O}JCI2 -J? -83bon2c 32'ct J38 14'8

-JO'O -43 -20boncc OJJGI2 -J8'.X -4' -Q'O

184 ?'8Hq -JQQ -1JQ -V4

ELUCL C0Wb0!0U

MG -123 -8'X -VIOrnp -3'3 J?'S JS'4 -8'J

-Q'? -4'g -I'S4OLJG2 -J4 -Q'Q -,X.

KC!0U of..

-13'3 1.8 -13'4 -105-J4'X 18'I -14'S

2OWGCO1JCC ?' -l'4 -3'O

H!P CJJOOJ Lqrwc -J5'o -VS -ó8134 J•

J-gLqc -5'J QO -5'5 3'4J4O2CpOOJ J?'3 -ÔÔ -JS'Q 10'4

EqflCOU oj pcq

EGWJC -ÔJ 00 -Fl-13'8 -4'S

QGUCL ojjJCq

I.4OUMjJ!C -J1'l -3'8 -Q'I -58-18'3 -J0'4 -8'O -38

ICG oipcq

2? - Q4 -JôQ -10.1 -1O'ô -3'?10'3

3? 44 J.'à -J?S X'432 - 34 J? -J0'.X ó'XJQ-54 -3'Q S1'4 JO'?

yc opcq

OAGLIt -8' -3 'Q

jor fluGxbJ9luGq

15P1' T 'II."' D!U$LGUCG - iiii L4ou-nI (bGLcGu qcLucc)

Page 21: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

a3n813'fiib 3!mf1tfloI wivs th iimsm 8w aquoi owi 8th r1wi3d 33n5I81Iib I&ioiti2oqmof1o

U83rl8bt31 to noii bnfi noil3ubo xe 33S1 3E n es3n3lsThb idi flitf1uo33S a18v81 81!I9w ni

anocna 3an31811ib 3!fIqs1om8b rho 3d1 11 ioI atwjbE will () bn () wmulO3 iii iuft d3I

isdi ni b812i1 3iin3i3sThfl3 isluitisq 8rli bns 'limsTl 8111 o noi1ioqmo3 13n-! 8th lqox8 eb1odauod

.31d51 dh1o noiis

3(11 b noitioqoiq isl £ 3ldsT ni j) bus () io (E) bus (1) enmulo3 nhiisqmoD

d bnis1qx 3(1 nsa 231qms lU-non bus lU 3111 b 13v81 311118w 313VS rl1 nsswl3d 23an318fhb

oluas3m 311118w sflqsa-13q 8(11 ui 33n318flib "bonislqx3nu't 3dT .2oiIanoloBlsrb 113111111 233fl0l3Thb

ol l3tlsup moiI noilsiisv 1511111 du2 i 319th f1uodi1s itisup 3(11 ivo lflOal3q V.V- 23B13VE

-nsmuul dl ui 233n313Thb 3111 3n813Thb b8rwjbs 8th 315313 01 b3buIani 1dshsv 311110 .l3rrsup

id! gf11111u0335 ioflA .213v31 311113w ui 23i3f15q3132ib di 'lo tom nislqx8 3nols 23i 313515113 [Bliqsa

ni2u bon3q 81qms2 8th iVO 1113313q OX- 8513vE 1no 23311313Thb b3nislqx3nu 8th noilsaub8 bus gE

2i1ua31 lB3ilrI3bi 'l3vits11lsup 2b13i W 31u2s3m 3is'l18w 111315v1up3-13q 8th anilwjbA .1W31us3m

iol lflLJO33s w ono isth i l1uai lsln3rnsbnth 3rIT .1311srn2 113v3 is an313Thb b8nislqx3nu 8(11 lud

r1wi3d 315113w 111 233n318flib 3111 'lb 'lisrI nsrll iom lid s 23il2n313s1Efl3 '2b1o11321Jo11 ui 233fl3i3'fiib

.2ls3qqs2ib 2131110 bus 2blod32uod 11131q1331 JU

lsilnst2du2 21 313(11 hE3lD .3mit 13V0 (IEV 233fl313Thb b3nislqx3nu 3111 wod 2wo112 E 3iUiI

b8iwjbs 3(11 i3r1sup Q ui lsrli bull w 1W niw (b33b111 .311J253111 2tffl 111 fl01IEI1BV i3nsup-oM3tlsup

2noflsupo 311T '.2b1orl3worl lfI3iqia3lnon b IsdI 12S81 is 'l1shJi3s i 2b10132uor1 inoiqiasibo 815'113W

.231U253111 328(11 111 fIOiiSflEV 151102532 011 21 318111 02 23flSd3 151102532 io'l lnuoaos ot b3lsmul23 815

stsb 3viisll2inimbS r1uoth n3VJ ion ob 'rll lud noiiEi1Sv lsi1 W0112 13V3WOd b1uoa 8f1T

31$ 2ffi3f13d 82011w 2i3)hOW 3SW-13f1if1 32us33d) 21101223331 (Ii us'! 28151 tfl3ffls3SIq3i Isili I23U2

M

Page 22: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

AEVb.1a80 .1e85 4888 .1880 .1885

-so

-.12

-.10-U-mccC)mF-

-2-

0

2EIGflBE 3- flL1EXbrvIvED MEEVBE DIEEEBE ViCE fli A2 VOItlfll

IbEB EOflIAVEktL

bEB CVbLLV

Page 23: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

isdr 31911 33n3biv3 9th tn3iqi331 b nOiI3EiI 131B1 B 3flJI!12n03 srnixsm oiste 'd brimi1

.tntaixsnon 10 IIsfn sis 2bforI3wod in gioiiion bo orti oi 3V115131 ni3d-113w rn o1 1sai1a3

ol b3o1fiu aOSQ f oth fit anoi2.23331 nhub 33s1q fri &rrsioiq 3fI313m9 3111113111 11U231 ir1T

•2blod3auod in3iqi33lnon o IsdI wolsd isrltnft niI!âI ff011 311113W b1od3woil 1f19iq1331 RJ in3v3lq

1r131q1331 IIJ 3B13VB 9rli 1133w13d on31flib no 3d bluod2 bns si1 2u3o1 1511n33 9th 31111W

bn3 iwo1 3111 is ILflo iosqmi 3111 no 001 2U3d1 ol nii2313ini i ii b1od92uor1 131110 bins b1odouod

ii13n3d lUlo 1oi orIi nh13biano3 'd noi1332 airII SbuI3fIoo wrli sW .3fnoonibo noitudillaib 3d11o

11BiinSi2du2 i atniqioi b 9llIbw B13VB 3(11 slidW .2blorl32uorflo 2u1s12 'fl3voq 3111 01 n01113191 ru

13W2fl5 oT 9ni1 'i19voq 9th wol3d ariillsYlo 12h 191E31 is di 3113 2in9iqi391nonbo isrIl nsdt 1wo1

i18voq" B 213 EQI ni OOOM rliiw iuoYlo '1imi1 &bo 5IsIbw 3111 3200(13 1i1ffutidiB 3W noii23up 21111

rn3tqioolnon bo 1n3318q ó .Q 91U2B3ff 3llIbw 9(11 28 LW noilqmu2no3 ln3Isviup9-13q rIi2U ".b1o1123111i

t19voq 3dT .affi3n3d fliVi3331 320r11bo 1r133-13q ol b3u$qmoa blorI23lrli 3(11 wobd 9113 2bIorl3woII

wriT .'l3vii33q231 1113313q t.OI bns 1fl3313q ô 315 1W 31U2E3ffl 315113w 511q53-13q 9(11 fIi2U 23151

113111 W013d 1f13313q 1 01 01 1rfuoi 21 21n31q1331 idi noirudiniib 3rlfIO nsorn 9111 isd 13113(11 3nqe3b

11Bitrisi2dua Is ion sis effion3d anivi33i 320(11 (31u2s9m 311113W 9111 rio rnibn9qob) 2in3iqb9lnonbo

illiw 3lqo9q 23bu13ni 'IflS22333f1 noiisluqoq HJ 9th 32u533d ilioH .\tIovoq olfnl gniIIifIo )12r1 131531

11sf3sqe3 tn3Alow 3sW-woI 1o 23(1103111 3rD nistaism 21113113d IU 32LIS39d bins 23110121ff *10w 1(13391

315 r13voq ni grnsd 2blorlseuorI fn3iqi33l-IU b 233n5113 3111 srnixsm 1113n3d '231512 01 31Jb 113w

.2bIod3anJocl 19(110 ni311 320111 25 0(1152 3(11 11sitn3223

2n19Jts 3-luiibII9qxa .v

2111 iud ;2tn3iqb9i lUlo f1i3d-lL3w 3513vB 8111 (10 b9isfln33noo 3W 11011392 2LJO1V31 3111 nI

110(11 hI b3133ft91 21 ein3iqi3olnon bns fn3fIl n3swi3d 83r1913Thb 3111 won 3n1m5x3 01 instnoqmi 0215

Page 24: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

JQ

GXJJ!P!2 1!ff1C LGUq OACI. JJG dnu.€L'

ooq CXpIpJ coirnj bcLu pn cowbu wjj LLCPOU o io cxbcuqwuc uq

jcicxcu qnspjc uq cOuanwci. GL/ CC itG OAGL pG wbjc bGuoq bcuqiu ou counwc

bcuoq qoca pc bLoboL!ou o cxbcuq!nLc occq o ooq bcuqiu ou Of12W uq fO

9'wG OL f pc wo acla o poncpojq jpc jJLG oj 2bcuqiu ou cucLA qGcLcc oici. pc wb1c

OL pc flj uq uou-çj poncpojq pc LCU2 iu pc AGLC 2JLG o cowwoqiA &onb Lc

EflLC2 pO pc AGLG jrnt.c ojJc cxbcuqirnLc onb2 OAGL pG bcLioq :C9LC cIUcI4!IJWcIJ uq O OW

' 2CLAICC2 -- GXbGUqiUTLc2 OU CO1JI1WGL 2CWCC 2fTCJJ CL LGbJI2

uj1oi.bbjiucc2' DflLPI 2GIJiCG2 -- JJG 2G1.AICC JOhP 4LOIJJ COJJJ1WCL qraspjc flCJJ CL uq

' -onu -- pc ciiicc oi .ouJ oMucL-occnbicq uq LCUWJ poniu'

COIJnwcL cxbcuqirac3' conwc ooq -- cxbcuqunLc ou oqJci. uouqnipc ooq ucjnqcq ni

' Eooq -- cxbcJqinLc ou jj ooq bLoqnct wcjnqiu opcco 9'uq jcopoj'

U EIL -- cxbGuqrrmc2 ou c1ccucrA urnsj 9'2 pC9TrIJ oij uq vaoiuc

pLoq ccOuc ocouanwbiou:

pOfl2cpOq jO RJMC1. pcc dnciou MG CXUJWG 4pC IJOC!OU O 1O CXbGIJqU1LG ¶1CLO2 IX

qicLcpou& oi. boboupjc 11CW2 OL !UtUCce bnLcpc O qf1Lpc OL I'2 ID bcobjc on'2xqG pc

iu cxbcuqintc bcLu2 D°62 nucwbjo?wcu qcccc 2bcuqiu OU Mp ouc UJ}U /4GM 92

OpG!L priqc OIJ IJCCG2JjJG2 D° nucuibjo?wci uq pc Lcccib oç pcucp Lcnp iu cpau8c

9IIO!OU O LGOflLCG 9CL022 qJTJ,GLGuI ooq D° IPO MJJO LCCGIAG PCUGW2 thGIJq 9 f9.GL 9CI!0U

Page 25: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

AEVb.1680

O•O.h

008

000

0•.1

cri

a0mI—

C')IcEm

0.13

0.1t

0.12klOWflI

fli BECIbIEV1J.2

0..1 eEIOflBE cf- BflDCEJ.. 2HVBE OE EL'IEUOA

.1085 .108't .168eT

.1088 .1800 .1863I I

Page 26: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

aOOR RO 2RAH2 T2OU8 -e BRUDIR

I I I I I I 82.0

C2.O

I C)

22.0 —1 w 0 C

2.0

er.o

I I I I

peer seer oeer 88SF a8er er o8er RA3Y

2Tk12II32R IU IU-L1OV

Page 27: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

AEVB1680

002

ooe

o.o.h

008

ciQmI— 00C')IIIm 04

011

03kiOki-fli

fli bECIbIEV1J2

043I I I

EIGflbE e- BflDCEI 2HVbE OE COV2flVJEB COOD2

4685 468 168eI I

4688 4660I I

466'*

U

Page 28: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

e.o

8.O

a.o w

I C) -1 w r.) 0 C

c.o

2TM2lIO3fl IU IU-kiOki

OkiI2UOH RO 2RAH2 T3OGU8 - 2FIUDIR

peer seer oeer 88er acer RA3Y

48 r er oer

Page 29: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

22J8ARU RO 2F1AH2 T3OGUB -8 BRUOIR e r.o

2Th31C1132R IU IU-voI*1

8r.O

r.o

aro

I C)

et.o —i w 0 0 C

r.o

cr.o

r.o

I I I I rr.o peer seer oeer 88er acer er oer

RA2Y

A

Page 30: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

0.18

0.10

05

05.1

055

053

052

059

.1680AEVB

EIOflBE 0- BflDGEI 2HVUE OE COL'121WIEB 2EBAICE2

.1685 .1088 .1088 .1660 .1605

w00mI-C')IIIm

fli BECIbIEkIJ2

Page 31: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

fl33wt3d 2nl3nEq 31uibn3qx3 iii aanifiib ioj&n o 33n32dE 3di 2i J1 nii1q1u 311T

.t38bUd li3rWIo 2noilloqolq iis1 bn8q ilt3n3d nvioi 2b1of1auoH .1n3iqb5Inon briE 2in3iqi3ei

boh3q oIqrn iitns 311t 13v0 .IIEm 31S 33n313'fitb &1 iud bodI briE '13ri3 as r13tJ aitiasn 110

3Bi3vB r1i Iir1w ii1iñ inn3q ô.1 ei b1or13auor! in31q1331-IU 'd 'i3ri3 no nibn3qe1o 31Efl2 311i

iv-i sidElub briE a33iv13 i3ffUJflO3 niworI no 1uribn3qxa .l3dairl tn3313q 8.1 i 31.sd2 bodi

3rlio buiinsm edi rud it1Eup iomts iii nibn3qe Isrorlo 2noirosfi 13115m2 hqmo3

atflS!q1391 ioI 3(1152 3rD 1riuoi is 2boo 19U21103 no nibrzq lb ir1 i29bom 315 233r13i3fiib

.2in3iqi33lnon bns

b1oduod lb quoi owr 3rD nwI3d isIimi2 O3V 3is 2nl3rrsq 3iuribn3qx3 3S19VE 31111W

13Isf I!siqr 315 2bIori32uod IU 1fs3ffl33q .21331f3 Isnoziiaoqmoo grrifl3ifto 3d bfuo3 31311t

233f1313Thb e3dr bns oW bris re3wbiM 3rD ni b8in323lqon3vo bns &srn ridw 'd b3bs3d

3rsIoai oT .eiv-i bns 2boo ois noirqmuano3 Isror b fl0i53oI15 iieth r33T15 'Ib3rduobnu

ew 2rn3iqi33lnon bns 2in&qio3i rnsIsviup3 'IIEnoirsvI32do n33wr3d 2trioflsq gnibn3q2 ni 2on313Thb

s-in quoi ribommo3 X12 rh to rbs id! 2315d2 ibua .boo f1353 id! 23V1u3 13r1 3rsmir23

e3Idsnsv rnmub1o 21oiov bns 3luribn3qx3 Isrorlo mdiiisoI oil ni airslbsup s rniss booioi

ni boin8o1q S1S 211u231 orIT .2uiEr IU bns loilsup 153' CX32 3351 flOI31 togs sie blorfowori ioI

. oldsT

iovo -ioI .2ursie irioiqboi-IU no tnof3ffb303 3f1ilO nia bris oburrnsm orb 21 OUI [511133 OIIT

.IIsm2 iov lud rnsaiIinai2 '11sairaiisia 21 r113131fi303 rsdr eboo3 131111J21103 1q33X3 '(IOois3 nibn3q2

iiodilo oiom inO3lOq 3110 bnoqa sifionod ITJ n1vioooi ebtor1ouori 2rnoiqbo1rion 1s3iinObi oi viis151

.2boo 13111U21103 bns bool no oiom irIo3ioq ono nsth 2231 rf3um bns ion3 no 2robud Istot

orb r1uorIi1 2331'fl32 lOiriU2iiO3 bris sot dsiub nisuod no 2231 btsnoirioqoiq bnoqs srnoiqt3oSI

VI

Page 32: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

drti.uvi° wcjrtqcq iu pG LCC2iOITh iuqiCOi. OL poncpojq 2GX Acsi? uq

M =

0iQ4 03t 00t3 0JXQ 0Ió4 00833

(oooo) (ooooo) (oooo) (oooo) (oooo) (oooio)Ill KCC!b!C1U 00J0Ô 00033 0000 000J 000t0 -00038

(oooo) (o0003) (oooo) (o0003) (o0005) (o0003)(foxbcuqww) -0OJ 00108 00J -00t 0008? 0OJ8

(ooo3) (ooo) (oooix) (ooo?) (ooo3l) (ooot)roExbcuqIwLc 0JJ4 -05. -038 09J 0J84 -0330Q

EIJGL Eooq ooq HOJI!U 2GI.1!CG GIJ4CG2COUflWGL DflLPIG COU2flWGL

(i) () () (i) () (Q)

1"pIG j zbGuqInLc jflJLG Edut!on Iogo: -

Page 33: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

nibnoqa oth sdt al noiaubno3 1siono odT inonoq ono iobnu flow 018 ao3noloTuib odflo aobuiinsm

oth ni esonoioThb io nuO33B ow iofls '11si3oqao is1imia to'i ols aquoi ow 329th lo arnoflsq

.ablodoauoil orlilo noiliaOqmoo 3ifIqs1Ofn3b

ai ri eiotho bits affioiqi3ol IU noowod '11siinsiadua ioftib on ob anisflsq oiutibnoqxo oliufW

odw eiodmom asd blodoauort our Ion io iodIdw 'd bonouftni 016 amori iodro no a'sfiuo isth oldiaaoq

01 IoliI aaol ois atilonod IU niviooi ablorfsauorl Isrit nong s 13$qxo Idim onO .boo1qmonu 318

lo aoasd3luq as d3u2 amori "oldsnoqraoq" as bow&v od Idgim Isdw biswoi aoiuiibnoqxo oIsaoIIs

alsubivibiti ol (daso lo midt orf ni io bnit-ni -rorltio) afi obtvoiq 01 8nhlliw ai bits aboo oldsiub

aoasd3luq iii noilsiisv oth r1idi13aob 2olsrnilao iido lnoaoiq ow oldsT nI '.btodoauod orh obiaitjo

mmub lo 21o130v bits oiuribnoqxo Islol lo mdthso1 oth d bortimioob as afli bits atdsiub lo

bits -torisup -iso' xoa o351 oonobiaoi lo rtotoi bsouI lo os osia b!orloeuort niInoa31qoi aoldsnsv

.aiflsla IIJ

oviis8orl ei afli1o noiivoiq oth bits aotds-tublo aoasrI3luq thod no auisa lUlo t3sqmi odT

ors a3ttanolos15r13 3fdqs1omob iotho 33f10 .bo1oqxo as oio moil lnoi9Thb linnaftinia bits

1209151 oil I isl d asri 3fflO3fl1 tflorIsrnloq iol 'xrnq s oiuIibnoqxo Islollo lovol ouil io1 bolrwo33s

aoasrbiuq iliiw aA .9nivi9-fii9 no b1Io ogisi oriup £ bits aolcisiub oaBrloluq ol noiai3ob oth no isqmi

.anoiisluqoq owl oull noowlod ubum -toflib Ion ob anolabob oaoth 233lv10E bits aboo9lo

IU noowiod aoanoioThb 9nibnoqa boIs9olg9saib 9ni1sns olni 'sio1 airl 13dlo9oI noLsT

inuo33s ow oonO .n011332 auoivolq orlilo ailuaoi oth aoisiodoiio aiodio bits ablorloauorl inoiqi3ol

noiriaoqmoa bits osia lims1 lo 133113 oth iol bits a3iiahoIatnsth 3idqsl9Omob ioth iii aonoio11ib iol

H .boioqxo vsrI td9irn ono nsth aaol daum isrlIo rbso moIl ioThb aquoi owl oth 9niod-Ilow no

odi isulw is anioiisq 9nibnoqa 'arrloiqiaol nislnism 01 noiaiflua al atilonod IU lo lovol oth (oano-tolni

81

Page 34: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

drwi.cLyjo wqnqcq iu pc LCC!OU2 MGLG iuqicoL AuspJG IPL poriapojq 2C L9CG 2CX Ac' uq

14=

18840 JO0

(o) (3138)

JGcibic1u 4O8RX

(?8?) (1013)

xbCuq1U1LG ?iO3O

(1) (3)

VJPJG jopI 4WJJG2 oLIwblc4 °LflI ffGCG!bZ Oil DflLJPIG bIILCPG nJq eI

Page 35: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

b33n3nsqx3 Ion b&1 'dtIi nd svsd bluow di a3ibni ab1odauod 1iin3bi 3alwl3dio'IO ioivr13d

in3mo1qm3nu

niviJ lo bubiud 9th bns ffi,iiefl ITJ .IV

afn3tqia31non 10 aor1t ol 9v11s131 atflslqf3$1 lo abvI 8113113w 3r11 b3rlirnsx3 3v1311 3w 1131 audi'

3(11 8niniElnism ni lEIu3itI13q ni aInuom ffi3n3d ITJ lo 31o1 8th b8ibula 11i3i1qx3 ion 3vsrI w lud

iol aiiIn3d in3moJqm3nu bfloq81 3s18vA .2in3iqi33i1o noiishiqoq 8th nirf 11w niviI1o blBbn13ia

1n3i3q 0.8 a3IuiiarIo3 113111w VE I lio1 3Iqmaa iuo ni ar1sup r1i ivo ablod,wod 1n31qi331

nwornl (111w 1(1312121103 sliup ame no11313ut aidT .abIod3euod 323111 lo 3(1103(11 1sunnii 113101 311110

slutiianoD anirr1s IaoI (m sb iltluol-8110) a1w 1 ai nolisiub b3isarI3qmo3 81313vs1I :213á1

3vl3ado bluow w 1n3i3q 0 ai 1n3rn3sIq3l aeoi bris mooriibo wofI a'bforl3auod 311110 1113313q 0

.311103111 Isunns a'bIorl3auod 1n31q13381 s 01 i113313q .V bbs aifl3rl3d IU Isril

aiolq 01 itirI .3m11 13V0 21fI3n3d lUbo 8onsrloqrrn 3111 111 2noii13ui31Jft Isilnsiadua 3113 31311T

310111 £ 3113 alfIsn3d IIJ .1QQ1 duoir1t :08Q1 moII 3(1103(11 Isiol fix 2ffi3(13d10 110i1313ft 3E18VS 8th

bo noii3s 8th 11311w al3tIsup 320111 ni ablorf3auod 11131q1331 iob moanr bo 331U02 Insnoqrni

IU :18QI rfauoldl 8Q1 boh3q 1138-0w1 8th 13v0 .t28dif1 ai 2ffi3115d flivi3331 ebfod3auorl

8th 1:Q81 r1uoirf1 1:V8Q1 moiI .arnoni 'ablod3auoH lfI3iqi38lbO 1n8313q Q b3s13vs affI3n3d

bo msflsq 1s3iI3313tffuo3 811110 Ifua3l sdI ei eid Iduob oM .1n9318q EÔ esw 8s13vs nibnoqa311o3

.8V13331 213)110w b3otqm3nu 113111 a1n3rn13q ffi3rI8d bo noiinub 113u1313 8th

33n3uflrn 113111 2232213 leum 3W 3113113w '21n31q1331 no athen3d JU bo 138qm1 8111 ornrrnoi3b oT

11311110 9n3ieieno3 8111 no \J1a1n3msbnLft abrl3q3b rnu1 flu ir1T .213v31 noilqmuanoa '21n3iqi331 no

113111w 01 11131x3 3(11 81U253 01 iqm3fls nsdi 13(111351 ai23f1ioq'r1 3m031u-ifl3nsfffl3q 3(111111W loivEd3d

Page 36: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

3MOOI1I GJOH28UOH Tt,121q132F1 RO k1OITFIOOR A 2A 2T1R3V38 IU -Or BRUOIR

I I I I I I BRAH2 2T1R3M28

rr

or

e

w 0 w

8

a

I e beer seer oeer acer er 8er oer

RA3Y

I I I I I I I 88er

Page 37: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

dt t3)13Id ni w i9vo noiiqmu2noo dioom2 or bn31 bnE woiiod or 3kJB 13mueno3

:no!iqmu22B 3msltx3 owr nbLsm d aiftn3d ITflo r3fts 9rIr1o sbuiinm

5iuribn3qx9 W1inirnism iii iofl3 31dioq t23-11 9th 3vsrf bliiow if13n9d ItJ

tn3Tw3 ni rwd3 irfi oa iibiupiI d bni ano 13r9Iqmoo 319W in9iqi35l

d3u2 nomA .3luiibn3qx3 Isror ni gnsd3 !wp3 ns ni b 31131 IIüI d b!uow OfTIO3III

Isroilo 13v31 bndo 3rIr Iqmi i 2ifI3n3d eth iuocliiw ani3d-!19w ibdr alsubivibni

93nq tfIBv3I8I 9th 'd b3rsfl3b b3vi9331 ri13n3d rn8mo1qm3nu 9th f 3luribn3qx3

.81S3 33n015vwp3 bns x9bni

£ 919w in31q1331 '03v&Ii t33fl3 sldiaeoq r311sm 9th 8v511 bluow ffi3n3d IU

33ub31 bluow aifl9n8d 8nuisnimil3 r&li nI ".l3muano3 9fno3ni-ifI3nm13q"

eidi b 9u1sv b3siiiunns f d noirqmuno3 5Io1319rf bits difs9w 3miiohf 'ern3fqi33l

.9s9133b

b!or!3auod isrir noirqmus 3rn311x9 3r!t l3bnu ii19n3d liflo a133fi9 3fh 3fllffISX3 'IIsilini 3W

b3rsuisv3 315113W bIorI3wol1 lo 91U253 owl 9th ii1 ô 9IdsT .b9nisflno3-iibiupiI 'bi31qrno3 515

31JII3WlO 01151 11513V0 3f11 el3tIstJp 8th wvo 3lqmsa Hi siiin3 3r11 ioT .2ffi8n3d iuorliiw bits fiiw

tn3mO1qm3(1U ri1V13331 mofi oiom nis thIorI3auorl 13nuoY . 1.1 i 2ffbonsd luortliw bns thiw

.2bIod3wouI b8b8311-eIstn&I bits stirlwnon ob as 13V9W0f! 2tI5q13iflU03 13b10 iir1i 01 OVIlSISI aiFbnsd

bits t2E311tIOM 3111 (Ii 3a0111 bits ablod3auorl b31s3ub3-ae3I flOffIS 19f11r1 SIB lUlo ai33fI3 3VflSI31 silT

rio b3asd anothsqrnoa moi1 lidaifa frio 13fiib anOaIlSqmO3 91s115v1d 3Iqmra 929f1T .la3WbiM 8th

.33f10 is ainsflirnl3i3b 353r1r I1 3bu13111 isill an0iaa3131 3tqiflurn

stli 13V0 11siinsiedija b3ansd3 atn3iqi3sl bo 315113w 3(11 nO aiilensd IU 1o t3sqmi 3(11 asH

rliiw arn3iqr33llo 315113w 3111 ni 33n313Thb lsnoil-ioqoiq 3S1OVS 8111 wor1a If oiui1 Vbohsq 3IqrnSa

Page 38: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

140 G9UJC2 J•4401pC12 J.J JLX

113 1132bonac JJ JJOJJGL2 J JO 1 JOHq 2bon2G opcLa J .Ox I ax

J•IJ 111H'q 112 11?

EWCL C0Wb00U

1•10Of11JJ 113

q/21 1 134OI4IJG2 114

Brou o ciqcucc

QLqric CJJOOI I 0ô I 0ôC011CG Lqnc 111 11020WGC0IIG 111 1•JJH!P cp0o1 &qrnt1c U 13 1.13-JJLqc 114 JJ3J-g&qc JJ4 JJ4J40 CJJOO1 112 114

EqC!0Uopcq

EGW1G 114 113113 1.11

QGUJCL oj, pcq

J40UMJJ!C J .

JAJJG 1.11Jçcc opcq

22-Q4 113 J•JJ42-24 111 J•1032-44 113 11332-34 113 113

J•14 I•14OpG1q

OAG11 1J3 115

11!0) ()

110J•J5113113

J . JQ

J•J5

1P1G Q I{8I!0 °L ii°"'p°iq /1GILuL H!iP \ /1!4P0flJ ifi B'UM11 [11 IC!b!GU( ØUj)

Page 39: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

9th molt anit1u31 31sII3w Iii eini 318VB 8rlT N shn 328th nhub fi3n3d iuodiiw bn

viisfi 3di oi b3fl131 13viti2oq iv3wod ni 3dT iff3313q V.l I i 21113n3d JUlo tqi1

8ñi 23ñiñ aaw 2n3iq!331 'to noilloqoiq 8th 11311w ,:8Q1 briE :8Q1 ft88wt3H .msioiq 8th 'to

s1no n3dw Q8I bns :V8Q1 nwisa .inen8q 1.81 sw etiI3n3d molt ni 311113w 9Z18VS

.in3ol3q 0.1 aw atfl3iqi33l anom f!iE 311113w 3E19vfi 8th th3n3d b3vio1 31qrn 3di'to t1133-13q

81fi 2blod3auod 1n31q1331-IU tsth 363 lELoq 21a 8th 110 b3sd 81E 2110 nsqmo 328th to I LA

Isnoitioqoiq sth no bnuod qqu n in3a3lq anoiIBIu3Ia3 3fIi fI3u2 aA .iibiupiI d b3nifiltano3 Its

331192dB 9th ni n33d 3vsri bluow ii rsdw O 3Vi15131 €n3iqi381 'to 911118W 9th ff0 2i119ff8(1 IU 'to i33TI9

8th isth nimus 'd 3253 isloq bnoa3e erli ru b3tsIuoIs3 3d 1153 bnuod l8woI A .fflB1O1 9(11 'to

-lodsi 8%618V5 8th (1&1I 1S3' lsIu3itlBq \flE Iii 2ffi8n3d II.J 8vi3381 01 18)hI 310ffl 01121 1n81q1301 1soiqr

3253 2i111 nI .(331o'I iodsl oth eois 'Imobrtsi boiuJdili2ib ei 3fi8iqi331 IU isrIi .si) insqi3rrlsq 831o't

inuoms 8th ol IBup8 fIoiiqmLJ2fIo3 Isrifuuis 'to wofi £ bbi' brus 311103111 in3nsrrn3q 32i51 i2Uj2ift3118d JU

gnullzioi 23i13n3d thiW .3mi18'tiI gninism3i'to 21B3' biqx3 b1orbwor1 r!i 'd bobivib 2ffl3n8d dYto

bs311 blod32uod wvs 8th rttiw bns ;abIod32uod 1n81q1331 ff1 3fflO3fli 9513vS 'to 1n3319q 0.8 '1no

8th flOfflU2flO3 9mooni-in3frnml3q 25 3vErI3d 2bIorl32uorI'ti i13rIi 15813 21 ii bIo 21B3 Qt Ino rnod

311113W 8th 'to 3ismui28 bnuod-13wo1 3rIT IIsrrI2 v ei 2ffi8n3d IU d b9bivolq noiiqmu2no3 01 quilt

.018S 'dls8n 21 2th3fl8d JU 'to 2133118

noiwbnoD .111

21fl8113d ITJ'to '3SuR3bS 8f11'tO 281U253ffl 3113103fLt-31E't18W IaiII 8111 b81n3281q asrl 'buiE 2111T

bisq 315 3th 21113r18d 'to irwoms 9th (18v1i) 1S813 (18V 21 111J281 I613(13 31IT .28isi b8lirlU 8th ni

2.6 311113W 31(11011033 'to 13V81 311152 3111 1158u1 8V811135 21fl3113d 3Vi3331 lEth 2bIOfI3eUOff

IU flOfl3iflO 31111011033 21th '1 .2i113113d 3V13331 ion ob isrli ablod3euorI 16311n3b1 IIa3irtqs1om3b

Page 40: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

2RARJ3W em3IqIo3R MO 2TIR3k128 RO T3AIMI 2DATM23R2 MUMIXAM - F F BflUOIR

I I I I I I I

o

8t

-I w ar o w -a

I I I I I I

eer seer oeer acer 08er RA2Y

201'I3RBRRIG BRARJBW

88SF

Page 41: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

t3v3I 8th LA .2tn31q1331 IU ns3n8mA lo noiiqmuno3 8th nisinism or eisup3bs iasL is 51S il13n3cJ

3111 b3v311135 ams1o1q b3bn3ix3 1513 b31 bits alft3n3d IIJ 's1s1 2OQ I 'hss bris O8Q 1 &lr ni b3bivolq

".1n3cnolqm3nu lo bisssd 3111 nu1siv3lls"1o Iso 1itiho 'raA

'ns no 31dioq ion i 113111w) i1sns Isnoiribbs sd b&Iibom 3d bIuo3 no!euIono3 irIT

nivo1qmi-81s113w 8th b8rsfl3vo 3vsd 'sm w abnuoi wonsn nO .(sisb lo r 8IdsIisvs 1in5nu3

'ablorl9wod in3iqioel b noiis3oIIs 3111 fl 3nsr13 ml inuos or 'ii1idsni wo 'd 2i113n3d Eflo 2133113

101 1i '.rn3rrro1qrn3nu 118th d b33ubni ai rsth noirouboiq bIorI32uod bits i3Ilsm n33w13d iodsl

isth 22o1 811113w eth rs*isrn 3111 181n8 or isrlro 8th 23oubni in3rn'o1qm8nu 2'o2uoq2 3fl0 81qmsx8

3111 $21UO3 10) .b3rs2n3qrnoa '1ki1 ion losI ni i 2ffion3d lo 1qi8331 8111 d mooivo 3d 01 2ffl332

w o1A (.noii33iib sii2oqqo 8th iii nonsqmo sisllow 3111 2orIsr13 iuei81 tthow b3o1qmonu

3ns1 rii1 LA .2131110 bits 2in3iqi33i no xsi IIJ odilo n3blud 311110 2133119 8111 iol b9inuo33s ion 3v5f1

33ni2) noi2uI3no3 iuo n3din3ii2 bluow xsi 311110 n8biIJd ecu iol fIiifIuO33S isdi r3eqXe bluow 3110

lo 138113 len 8111 tud ;(213*iow be'oIqmo-'Iku1 fs3tinobi 321w13111o nsrli 2231 ff158 21n31q1351 01311 o2gi

.3151U3163 01 iILJ3IThb '13m31ix3 3d bluow sbsrn 3vSd 3W isdi afio2xisqmo3 315113W 3111 110 n13nsr1fl

tn3fflo1qm9f1ulo 2113q2 l3di3rlw 3111m1313b 01 2U wolls Ion ob sisb iuo 2bnuo1 iebsoid nO

2bIod32uod 3O2 23btJ13f1i abIoIl8euofI rneiqiaeinonlo quoi 3111 isrIl o lls is bsls&t3qrnoo nied 315

anulnuoa3s dIrIom-evl3wl 3111 8nrrub iu13m(oIqm3fru lo 115q2 s 233n3f13qX3 l3drnem eiw daidw iil

sill 331115 815 'I1s31 'ei1r nsili 8isLJp3bs elom mo 2iiton3d IU a1sm sisb erli iii 3iuIiáI 2ifIT .boil3q

rtolls3filaesb 2ith d bsisr2i3bnu 21 213*10w b3olqm3 lo (noiiqrnu2noo 1dsmu231q bits) 311103111

-owl 11ü1 isth (1QI bisD 1)ris )IffBIH nwo11o1) 3muaas 9w11 2sid 2111121 rnshoqmi woH .rneldoiq

9th isth nouqmue2s 3m811x3 3111 3)lsm bits eb3ls2nsqrnoo Ion 315 2113q2 inerrroIqrnenu lo 2bliIli

11112 21 i3Bqffli 8th (13th ein3iq1a3i IU 'd i2oI isili es 311152 3111 213W 21bq2 320111 111 22o1 3ffl03111 3S13V5

Page 42: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

qrruLJ OJJCI. IIWCa !U WG prtpc CACJG

COU€UI PMIJJ OJ O 1GAILJ [II LGCib!GU2 LGIspACJA 9 MJ O qnuu LGCG2210132 g

JCLJUAG pqc OACL pGC bio&w acw o jrnic ciiccq u oricowc i LOflJJJA

poncpojq Ow LI!LJ qf1Lu LCCG!OU JJC C4A J Ø2 uq o j o-oi jpc couu

onjjcicu wuiUIqG o bcicu pc /AGflJG jO2 !U cc!bcI4 poncpojq IGJtAC 10 UOIJL6C!b!CIU

cx.cuqcq pcuc qciuu IIWC2 o pip nucmbjoAwcu pop cwboLI.A uqiucLq XCu2iOu lii.c

nucwbjoAwcu CUCLIIA jpc LCJ2 j2o w9jG ! pnuqujA CICL bLoLw2 ojcLcq

CRLLGUj fClt62 OL iJJO2G MpO LCCCIAG pGw ji Ae uop,u porn poi i1c cowbcu2Gq thcjja o

jp ccuuj uqJu iwbpc2 pcuc gwonu ug bocwisj gnLiou Lc qcdnG pcJL

Lonb

fl2 pi.qjA p cpucqqiic conqcxcriqc nucwbjohcq uou1.Gc!b!cu ponpoq .owpc cowbuaou

cbtis wGnLc) ps ic uocq !U cciou IA O uo WOLC pu g. bcLcGuf1 OflL coucr1ou MorlJq

€xbcucuccq uo nucwbjo?uiu qnuu ip Ai. u2 ijow pc bcLccu qru.cLcIJcc (nu bci.-

iuA jpc ACLC g1ncg qijcLcucc iu MCJpLC pcwccu flj Lcc!b,cIU uq poncpoqa jrni

Page 43: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

(jôgj):1Gi.iA HflWI' r1LbIn 9uq cqMcIju r'o VIJJGL!CU ECOUOW!C

(ios): jo-jDU!CJ HUJG1.UJCP ,OCJJ JU2flLIJCC q C0Uaflmb!0U v" Ewb!L!cI Judn!i.X J€UCUEC0U0W!C

bL M° X2O JO1J flLGII OECOUOIJJ1CJçcGLcpoirnpu GLnPGL JjJc ou2nwbpou uioopiu8 pcuj oLfluGwbIo?uu6u ftOLjciu

AOIflWC j. JpiuOu: J.4CflC jooC0UJ113!!0U OIJ flucwbIoAuJcLJl Combcu!ou fluGuJbIoAwcI4 CowbGu!ou: ngic ugj-jcui.A jcjqci uq uc-Th p ,qcdncA o yu cauiciu iu

ECOUOW!C2 jo (jg): jj-gAfl.fC DAUfl uq CAGU jJCJjJIJ .COUf1JJJbfJO1J iiq ucwbjoAwcu, Or1LictjA iorn.uj o

flUIhCL2UA hLG2 JgØVIJ112 DCOU uq Ojiu JflGJJSflCL ECOUOWIC ug COLJ2fIW GJJA!OU WpIJqG: wpuqc

K!CI OUIJCOWC ug J2 (JÔQÔ): 3-F''-! CP IJCIJ DI OLCIJOU jpc AG2flLCWCU Ofl2 jçc Cb!! 1ubn

0UPG IUgnL!I 1I!0U2 if C2C1.CJJ v22Oc!ou j (j):bI Uq GLI.A KUiOJ 1BGUY yq6dflCA ° hflUCWb10AWCU EGUqU1LC

flULACL2IA j

flJ JIJCOWC D!2L!Pfll0U uq fLMU suqLq2) flubrlpji2pcq bbcL

(j): j-.9141IJ BLOM1J1IJ ,,p1Jq1.U suq llopojq ECOUOW!C BCJJAJOL 1OflUJj OLECOLIOWIC F!CLWLC

(ioo): j-CACIJ LflflJj) hJJJC flp1I1J1JOU B! °L rbCALC2 bL!CG Juqcx vuJcuCu ECOUOW!C

Exbju!ou Of1146Lj? 0LEC0uOIn!Ca j (jj): jj-gipcc pj"r uq D! cq 1cu jtcuq !u iuLcq uq nuwnLcq ucubjoAuicu: 12 jCLC

}C2GLCJJ flOLJ(iU bbGL ,4O JcfObiw!!ou E/qqI'cc j.OW WC COU2flWCL xbcuqwLG 2flLAGA41 J4WOUJ B11LG(T OLECOUOW!COIO yUirnaO uq GflI!61W0 MGPCL I2 COU21IWb1U!0U QLON4JJ C0U212G1U ''p JucI4cwJboI.!J

BEIEBE14CE2

Page 44: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

ECOuouJic ug (jô):D11!G! JCUJCIC 11y LC C0UflWbf0U uq A!U ! b02M nuiGq I�CMGM Oj

qAiaoLA COflUC!! ou ucwbjoAwcu C0WbCU!0UCpu.lobpcL r'GI.? jpc yqcdricA IunLucc BCUUt flubnpppcq

j-jg Ecouowuc ? (jgg): oo-ojujAu IUCL uq JICp9iq J,ACDO1Jqq 1IfU ujAi2 oj 2flp2fui!OU B2 rn yjcnuu8 juriou

Page 45: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

TOT4

3iLduq 10 ocniaix3 3111 isdr afi 3vitsgn 3Idioq sns ioni li s2usd bituod qqu its i 2iuIT .1 .wlivsa '(Iano!ius33lq '2bIor1euod ni ubni 1dim 2ffion3d IIJ

3mi18'Ii! Io eiuasm 'ion a 111i ai 51oI313d1 bits in3noqmo3 ioli2nsi1 a asri 0215 noilqrnu2noD . iuasm 81s1u33s 310ffl a 'fbcIuobnu i ii ivworI lx 3r11 ni b3dn323b 2no2s31 th io1 .31s13w

.311103111 3fl3TIU3 nath

d bsshsmmu2 316 2no2nSqmo3 315113w idi 1sQa 33fl3!5vWp3 10 u 3r11 t2niss 2in3fflualA .(QQ1) ninwoiH

2in3ftoqmO3 w1 a 1no 3buIani Isril slab no ibui2 niasd wod2 (IQ1) 13d3W baa oiasnsflA aA .I 3191qmo3 'd b3ilqmi 21 larlw 1111w lnslaieno3ni 318 lsrIi loivsrf3d imuanoo no 11usi 2b13i nibn3q2 10

.noiiqmuanoa lo 231U253

21 231quo3 bnsm thiw 2flnu l3mu2no3 ni bar1 r1t aypnua l3ihs3 riliw 'an3tino3 3sn31q oT . bits 'b1odauod" 2rn131 9th au sw noiiiaoqx3 b ease iol o2fA .bnsdaud 3111 3d ol b3mu2as

.s1dsnsd31slni "luau l9mu2no3"

belisbb baa V1U2 48QI 3111 WII2U b316m1123 21 no12231g31 3!nob3fl a I8I bits 081 loI . .83f13b1231 3111'to 23112fl313515113 3111 itO noitsiffloliti

.(QQ1) bins!a a XD 3(11 01 b3ilqqs 26W both3m 21(11 woil no eIisi3b ioI .V

luau 13ffl1J2fl03 iuo1o 2l3dffl8rn ns 10 uo bib adlnom 1 lasq th nhuU" i boq noiiup 3dT .8 mofi b3vi333i 25W ibum wofi O2 II cnoils2n3qrno3 in3mo1qm9nu moul 9fflO3fl! 3V13331

"Vnoiis2n3qmo3 fn9m'o1qm3nu

b9boaqoi rIliw ablod32uor( bits 3mo3nllo nrnoq31 3l3IqmoDni 3bu13x3 srnoortibo 2noiifiIudsi BA .Q

.3mo3ru

.anulood3s on bsrl 8nivsrl b3tloq3l abfofl92uod 1n3iqi33-t-IUU 1nO .01

svilwsr1x its io1 (QQI) 8ffinwolH Ilno331 iom bris (08Q1) l3usdlI3uM bits nols3U .11 .noilarnul23 li3rIt bits 231532 33n315vitJp3 ni bv1ovni 23U221 8f11 b noI22uo2lb

fit 231532 33n915vwp3 31IT .sie bIod92uorf nath 13(110 2noien3mtb 13V0 (1Sv 231532 21J2fl3D 31IT .! 2ô ss l9bnu bs3d 3Ism a rlliw eblodo2uod mislnon iol 318 siuiI

.2ff0i223131 323111 cii bts1oq1o3ni 0215 &is 1dshsv mmub L19r1sup bna IsunnA .

I

-IU n38wi9d 8fl13d-IIOW 31f110f1033 111 so(1913Thb 3(11 uI noilsnsv 1s3i133 'nE lo 331132ds 3dT .M 01 b32u 2ffOi223131 3r11 lo 2r1oi15311133q231 d b9lslodonoo 21 2bIorI3euorl 13(110 bits in3iqiaol

as bits l3tiaup (1363 101 3151 ln3m'o1qm9nu 31sm 35-8fflfl 3(11 anibbA . 91daT bus E iuiI ui I wol3d 113w Iin3l2iano3 is laril 23i12i1sl2-l ab1oi 2u1512 ln3iqi33l-IU (111w ii lo noitasl9lni

.3IJISV 3iuIo2cJs

Page 46: fiOLJUU bL - NBER

h'cfn.G 12 nuqci2cq 2U11 JC22cxbcuqiwLG2 z.c nuqciwcq pA bcLjrnb2 oujA 0? bciccur GIACU ipc 2pbc o cuj!iA4puc1Jou2 fl1CL

nucu.ibjoAcq poncpojq SLG uo pdniqiA-cou2Liucq cou2nwbiou-2uJoopiu WGU2 pS jJCLLnucwbjoAwcu 2bc112 pA oo bcLccLu v22flwiu 1OJJOMW J-JwcuJJc2p (jg) jrn PIL22flUflU 21XA-bCLCCIJ icbjccwcu mc wA pc nuqccq pc iucOwc2 °L poctcpojq mp uoo nucwbjoAwcu HW nu pcuc CCO1UU1U OL g bcLccu o nu cc!b!cIu2, !ucowc uqponcpojq (iii pc bci.ccu oupc eu.ibjc m.c uoui.cc!b!ciu) wi8p jrnic cxbcucuccqj jpza WCU2 j bcLccu (wicc pc bcLccu jrn MGLG i.ccibictu pon2cpojq2) o

ou ccp 2bon2c,2 oujAj Øj'cn.A (J) CWuJ1uC2 pc GTJcc1 ofjj PCUCU2 ou poncpojq McJJ-p6!u WLOP PL !wbC

nuqcLc2r!wc2ponacpojq2 un' (jirn) bbcuiucc !u pc bucj pria pc Of9J2 !U 1J!2 ccotA LG I!ICCIA o pc

IPG CEX iucjfIqca 1UILOUJJ1OU 011 O4JJ C92 uq iu-quq UJ2 2p 1J2 c LCbol4cq oujA UI iJJC