fire station site selection - esri · final thoughts •the devil is in ... 2017 esri public sector...

27
FIRE STATION SITE SELECTION David Kulpanowski Lee County, Florida Department of Public Safety [email protected] ESRI Public Sector GIS Conference West Palm Beach, Florida 13 April 2017

Upload: others

Post on 14-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,

FIRE STATION SITE SELECTION

David Kulpanowski

Lee County, Florida

Department of Public Safety

[email protected]

ESRI Public Sector GIS Conference

West Palm Beach, Florida

13 April 2017

Page 2: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 3: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 4: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,

Fire Department Question # 1

•Where should the city add a new fire station to increase the level of coverage?

Page 5: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,

Establish the road network

SELECTRTRIM(CallSign) AS [CallSign]

, Latitude, Longitude, SpeedFROM HISTORY_201501_3WHERE UnitStatus = 'ER'AND Speed > 0AND CallSign NOT LIKE 'M__' AND CallSign NOT LIKE 'MC%' AND Callsign NOT LIKE 'LAR10_' AND CallSign NOT LIKE 'FBA3_'AND CallSign NOT LIKE '%BC%'AND Callsign NOT LIKE '%PG%'

UNION ALLEtc. etc.

SELECTI_EventNumber

, PUN_UnitID, DATEDIFF(SECOND, IIU_tEnroute, IIU_tArrive) AS [ResponseTime], I_MapX, I_MapY, ITI_TypeID, ITI_TypeText, CASEWHEN LEFT(ITI_TypeID, 2) LIKE '[1-9][A-Z]' THEN

LEFT(ITI_TypeID, 1)WHEN LEFT(ITI_TypeID, 2) LIKE '[1-9]' AND LEN(ITI_TypeID) = 1

THEN LEFT(ITI_TypeID, 1)WHEN LEFT(ITI_TypeID, 2) LIKE '[1-9][0-9]' THEN

LEFT(ITI_TypeID, 2)END AS [MPDSCard]

FROM IIncidentUnitSummaryLEFT OUTER JOIN PUnit ON IIU_kUnit = PUN_Unit_PKLEFT OUTER JOIN IIncident ON IIU_kIncident = I_Incident_PKLEFT OUTER JOIN ITypeInfo ON I_kTypeInfo = ITI_TypeInfo_PKWHERE PUN_UnitAGency = 'FM'AND DATEPART(YEAR, IIU_tDispatch) = 2016AND PUN_UnitID NOT LIKE '%PG%'AND PUN_UnitID NOT LIKE '%BC%'

Page 6: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 7: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 8: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 9: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 10: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 11: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 12: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 13: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 14: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 15: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 16: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 17: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 18: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 19: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 20: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 21: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 22: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 23: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,

Fire Department Question # 2

•Split the fire house in the urban corridor into two stations. Where should these two stations be located?

Page 24: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 25: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 26: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,
Page 27: Fire Station Site Selection - Esri · Final Thoughts •The devil is in ... 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference--Presentation Keywords: 2017 Esri Public Sector GIS Conference-Presentation,

Final Thoughts

• The devil is in the details. • Using posted road speeds leads to an over-estimation of speeds

• Analytics can only get you so far.

• Take the Network Analyst results and plug them into a simulation model.

• Ground truth the model. Map out past responses.

• Python is great not just for geo-processing, but for statistical analysis.

• If your municipality is considering building a new fire house it will spend a million dollars. Go ahead and spend $2500 for the Network Analyst extension and test it out. It will be money well spent.