for investment professionals and institutional investors 1

27
FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

Upload: meredith-craig

Post on 29-Jan-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS1

Page 2: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS2

Plan sponsors using an advisor today

Totals may not add up to 100% due to multiple answer options.

Across all plan sizes.

TOP REASONS WHY:

58%

53%

48%

31%

Need help with plan investments

Want a better understanding of how well the plan is working for employees

Concerned about their fiduciary responsibilities

Have less time to devote to the plan

RESULTS AND TRENDS

UP

9 POINTS FROM 2012

84%of all

respondents

Page 3: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS3

Satisfaction increasingRESULTS AND TRENDS

55%57%

60%62%

50

60

70

2008

2010

2012

2013

Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.

While satisfaction has increased since

2008, 38% say they are less than satisfied/not satisfied with their current advisor.

Satisfaction with advisor (very satisfied/satisfied):

Page 4: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS4

Opportunities remain

Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.

10%

RESULTS AND TRENDS

4

ACTIVELY LOOKING TO SWITCH:

17% 16%14%

10%

0

10

20

20082010

2012

2013

38% of plan sponsors are less than satisfied/not satisfied with their advisor

of plan sponsors are actively looking to switch advisors

Page 5: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS5

Confidence about fiduciary responsibilities is still a concern

Plan sponsors’ overall understanding of their fiduciary responsibilities:

Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.

RESULTS AND TRENDS

58% are certain/very certain 42% still need help

THEY UNDERSTAND:

58% Investment

options

59% Service provider selection

62% Plan

documents

61% Plan

expenses

62% Participant

communications and education

53% Testing and

reporting

Page 6: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS6

1 2 3Suggested ways to

lower costs

Suggested ways to

improve plan performance

Offered help with

administrative tasks

What caught plan sponsors’ attention

ON AVERAGE,

plan sponsors are personally solicited by an advisor FOR THEIR BUSINESS

Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.

SELLING

4X PER YEAR

Page 7: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS7

Why plan sponsors look to switch

Need a more knowledgeable

advisor

2010: 25%2012: 30%

Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.

TOP REASONS FOR CHANGING ADVISORS:10% of plansponsors are actively looking to change advisors

41% of

sponsors who

switch advisors also change recordkeepers

SELLING

Servicing issues with a plan provider

2010: 19%2012: 15%

Not enough advisor support

for plan servicing

2010: 5%2012: 8%

31% 28% 12%

Page 8: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS8

Sponsors define “more knowledgeable advisor”SELLING

56% Keeps us informed on regulatory changes

56% Consults with us on how to manage fiduciary responsibilities and risk

50% Consults with us on plan design

FOLLOWED BY:

44% Offers proactive suggestions for improving plan performance

44% Helps us

minimize costs

33% Offers fresh insight

on participant trends and behavior

33% Helps us select

and monitor investment options

for our plans*

Totals may not add up to 100% due to multiple answer options.* Investment professionals should consult with their firm’s legal and/or compliance professionals before selecting and monitoring plan investment options, as certain restrictions may apply.

Plan sponsors want an advisor who:

Page 9: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS10

Services plan sponsors look for

Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.* Investment professionals should consult with their firm's legal and/or compliance professionals before recommending investment option changes to a plan or plan participant, as certain restrictions may apply.

Top 3-ranked advisor services:

RETENTION

75% Providing performance

information on investment options and guidance on potential changes*

49% Providing employee

education on investment selection*

32% Analyzing participation rates,

deferral rates, investment allocations, and strategies for improving plan performance

Page 10: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS11

Totals may not add up to 100% due to multiple answer options.Across all plan sizes.

Evaluating advisors

58% Investment performance

57% Costs and fees

57% Value delivered

Plan sponsors look at key areas

RETENTION

HOW FREQUENTLY

44% Plan

compliance

At least annually

Longer than a year

No fixed schedule

57%

21%

22%

36% Improvingparticipantoutcomes

37% Improving

plan measures

42% Experience

35% Fiduciary

responsibilities

31% Reputation

SIX OTHER HIGH SCORERS

Page 11: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS12

60% don’t

Demonstrate your value

Report how much time is spent working on the plan

Demonstrate how plan performance improved

Report on types of activities for the plan 69% don’t

78% don’t

What plan sponsors say advisors don’t do:

Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.

RETENTION

Page 12: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS13

Plan sponsors define value

SEES VALUE FOR MONEY SPENT:

“Their fee … is less than the hourly rate we pay to many outside consultants and professionals … accountants, lawyers, etc.”

RETENTION

APPRECIATE TOTAL COMMITMENT:

“They have reduced our overall costs by more than $150,000 over the past two years. They are spot on … with investment options … meet with our committee quarterly … provide fiduciary training … respond quickly … keep our recordkeeper on their toes.”

Clients’ experience is no guarantee of future success and may not be representative of the experience of other clients.

– Heads of human resources: for companies with 501–1,000 plan participants

Page 13: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS14

Expand your reach

* Investment professionals should consult with their firm's legal and/or compliance professionals before proceeding, as certain restrictions may apply.

81% of plan sponsors are very willing to allow the

financial advisor to solicit company employees about financial planning needs other than 401(k)s*

However,70% note that

advisors are not doing this

RETENTION

Page 14: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS15

Why have a 401(k) plan?

TOP 3 REASONS

76% Attract and retain employees

59% Ensure employees can accumulate enough for retirement

44% Provide tax benefits to employees

Across all plan sizes.

Best practices

• Highlight the plan as part of the overall pay and benefits package

• Generate an overall benefits statement at least annually to keep “retirement readiness” top of mind

• Educate all employees about the key benefits of the plan

RETIREMENT READINESS

Page 15: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS19

Improving plan options

57% Improve plan coverage

48% Increase employee savings rates

36% Provide improved investment options

25% Reduce expenses

RETIREMENT READINESS

Why plan sponsors make design changes:

Plans that offer auto-enrollment:

88% of employees participate*

Totals may not add up to 100% due to multiple answer options.Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.* Building Futures, 03/31/2013 (see final slide for additional details).

Plans that offer auto-increase:

Only 13% of enrolled employees

participate*

Page 16: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS20

Totals may not add up to 100% due to multiple answer options.Plans with 25 to 2,500 participants.

Trends in plan changes

33% Auto-enrollment

29% Roth 401(k) contributions

24% Lifecycle or target-date default option

19% Auto-increase program

20% Auto-enrollment

18% Auto-increase program

15% Roth 401(k) contributions

13% Lifecycle or target-date default option

RETIREMENT READINESS

In the future: Changes in the past two years: 72%

of plans have made a plan

design change

UP 13 points

FROM 2012

55% are looking to make a plan

design change

UP 17 points

FROM 2012

Page 17: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS21

Top investment menu changes

70% Replaced underperforming fund

43% Increased # of plan options

28% Added a target-date default option

Across all plan sizes.

RETIREMENT READINESS

PAST 2 YEARS

Totals may not add up to 100% due to multiple answer options.

31%Annually

28%Semiannual

32%Quarterly

9% Other

91% of plan sponsors review investmentperformance annually or more frequently

Page 18: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS22

Objectives

A fiduciary must act solely in the interest of the plan participants, their beneficiaries and alternate payees to ensure that only fair and reasonable expenses are being paid

The process should be comprehensive, measurable and documented and done so with the care, skill, prudence and diligence that a prudent person familiar with such matters would exercise

Page 19: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS23

Changes to Consider/ Plan Design:

Auto Enrollment @ 6%

Auto Increase @ 1% annually to a maximum of 10%

Align match to deferral rate - Consider match change to help deferral target (12% match to 10%)

Reboot all employees into age appropriate TDF’s

Analysis of Target Date Funds

Reduce the number of funds in the fund lineup

Plan design options - New Comparability Profit Sharing Plan Design; Cash Balance; Safe Harbor; Non – Qualified Plan

Review Fiduciary File - IPS

Page 20: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS24

Outcomes of Different match Formulas

The Formula Likely Employee Combined Employer CostDeferal Employee/Employer (%of payroll)

DeferalStatus Quo

.50 up to 6% 6.00% 9.00% 2.10%

Option 1.25 up to 6% 6.00% 7.50% 1.35%

Option 2.25 up to 10% 10% 12.50% 2.25%

Option 3.20 up to 10% 10% 12% 1.80%

assumes a 90% participation rateassumes employees save to cap.example -opt.2; 25%x10%x90% = 2.25

Page 21: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS25

Billed FeesBilled FeesInvestment Management Investment Management

FeesFeesAsset Based Fees Asset Based Fees Revenue Sharing Revenue Sharing

DisclosureDisclosure

Billed FeesBilled FeesInvestment Management Investment Management

FeesFeesAsset Based Fees Asset Based Fees Revenue Sharing Revenue Sharing

DisclosureDisclosure

Web-based ToolsWeb-based ToolsAutomated Voice Response SystemAutomated Voice Response System

Loan/Withdrawal ProcessingLoan/Withdrawal ProcessingOnline Enrollment Online Enrollment

Enrollment Materials & MeetingsEnrollment Materials & MeetingsIndividual Advice SolutionsIndividual Advice Solutions

Participant StatementsParticipant StatementsBi-lingual SupportBi-lingual SupportInvestment Philosophy Investment Philosophy

Quantitative AnalysisQuantitative AnalysisQualitative Analysis Qualitative Analysis

ScorecardScorecardSMSM Fund Ranking Fund Ranking

Plan Document, SPDPlan Document, SPDDiscrimination TestingDiscrimination Testing

5500 Filings 5500 Filings ERISA Resources ERISA Resources

Accounting Accounting Employer/Employee Reports Employer/Employee Reports Processing Payroll Deposits Processing Payroll Deposits Quality Assurance StandardsQuality Assurance Standards

RecordkeepingRecordkeeping Technology Technology ServicesServices

Compliance Compliance

Investment Investment ManagementManagement

CommunicationsCommunications

CostCost

ParticipantPlan Sponsor

The Services You Are Procuring

Page 22: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS26

Shareholder Servicing: Revenue shared by the

mutual fund company with the service provider.

Asset / Wrap Fee: Additional fees layered on top of total investment fees.

12b-1: Distribution expenses paid by mutual funds from fund assets. Includes commissions

to brokers, marketing expenses and other administrative services.

Investment Management: Fees for managing investment assets. Charged as a percentage of the assets invested and deducted

from the investment return.

Sub-TA: Brokerage firms and mutual funds often contract recordkeeping

and other services related to participant shares to a third party

called a sub-transfer agent.

Investment Management Fee

12b-1 Fees

Shareholder Servicing Fees

Sub-TA (Agency Transfer Fees)

Revenue Sharing

Page 23: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS27

Complete Total Cost Analysis, Including Revenue Sharing

Integrated Investment Platform Rankings for Clearer Analysis

Sample Vendor Investment Scorecards

Sample Report Excerpts

Vendor Analysis and Research

Page 24: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS28

Administrative FeesAdministrative Fees

Investment FeesInvestment Fees Plan Consulting FeesPlan Consulting Fees

All costs associated

with managing the investments

Services to operate the plan: Recordkeeping, Trustee,

Compliance, Communications

How Services Are Paid For – Model 1

R6 Share Class

Advisory fees paid to a registered

investment advisor or commission paid to a broker

Page 25: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS29

Administrative FeesAdministrative Fees

Investment FeesInvestment Fees Plan Consulting FeesPlan Consulting Fees

All costs associated

with managing the investments

Advisory fees paid to a registered

investment advisor or commission paid to a broker

Services to operate the plan: Recordkeeping, Trustee,

Compliance, Communications

How Services Are Paid For – Model 2

R4 Share Class

Page 26: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS30

Administrative FeesAdministrative Fees

Investment FeesInvestment Fees Plan Consulting FeesPlan Consulting Fees

All costs associated

with managing the investments

Services to operate the plan: Recordkeeping, Trustee,

Compliance, Communications

How Services Are Paid For – Model 3

R3 Share Class

Advisory fees paid to a registered

investment advisor or commission paid to a broker

Page 27: FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS 1

FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS31

Thoughts to Consider:

Continued Provider Consolidation (Hartford)

Fee Disclosures and Regulatory Changes Cost Lots of

Money

Continued Fee Compression - advisors are keeping

track of their time on cases; flat fee

Itemization of services provided

Discussion of all Benefits (cafeteria style) – crucial

financial decision

Advisor Best Practices

Strip Out Revenue Sharing

Flat Fees – not basis point wrap

Outcomes based on quantifiable statistics – Plan Health