forestry 545 titles, authors and abstracts february 4, 2014 dr sue watts faculty of forestry...
TRANSCRIPT
Forestry 545Titles, Authors and Abstracts
http://suewatts.forestry.ubc.ca/frst-545/
February 4, 2014
Dr Sue WattsFaculty of Forestry
University of British ColumbiaVancouver, BC CANADA
General manuscript format Title Author(s) affiliations Abstract Introduction Materials & methods Results Discussion References
2
Title
Remember the working title?
This was step #5 of laying your ground plan
You may come up with several working titles before you are ready to publish
After drafting the main section of your paper “refine” your title
3
What is in a title?
Title needs to be:1. Interesting2. Concise3. Informative4. Accurate for electronic indexing
4
What is in a title?
The title is the ultimate précis of your paper
May be used alone for indexing Many readers judge by title alone Title plus abstract form small
scientific report
5
What is in a title?
A strong title identifies your field of study and separates your paper from all others in the field
6
Title “rules”
1. Title’s words must characterize your paper
2. Title must provide clear and useful information
3. Be in past tense4. Be a maximum of 2 lines
7
Title “rules”
1. Title words must characterize your paper
Words must indicate the most distinctive part of your work (max 3-4 details) Secondary details go to introduction
Have immediate comprehension to reader of a TOC
Include keywords picked up by indexing
8
Title “rules”
2. Title must provide clear and useful information Avoid abbreviations (consider how you
would look for this type of information in an index)
Do not pose title as a mystery Choose words carefully
9
Abbreviations
Should the title use HCl or hydrochloric acid?In an index most people would look under hy not hc
Now most large indexing services bring together DNA and deoxyribonucleic acid
10
Abbreviations
Best rule is to avoid abbreviations in titles or use full name as well
Diameter at breast height (DBH) measurements of ..
11
Avoid mystery titles
Does classical music increase Douglas-fir height growth?
What can whole-log export restrictions add to rural communities?
12
Avoid empty titles
A new way to survey mountain pine beetle damage
13
14
thingsbiological.wordpress.com
Word choice
Use no more than 3 modifiers for 1 noun
Large red 7-striped Guatemalan tarantulas ….
BetterLarge red Guatemalan tarantulas with 7 stripes
15
Word choice
Watch out for dangling participles (dangling modifier of a noun)
Participle denotes the quantity, quality, extent of the thing being named – most end in ing, en or edMost often dangled is “using”
16
Word choice
Dangling participle example
Using a hypodermic needle, dogs were immunized with sheep red blood cells
17
Word choice
Dangling participle example
No ticks were found using the standard bait traps
No ticks were caught with the standard bait traps
18
Word choice
Poor syntax
Preliminary canine and clinical evaluation of a new anti-tumour agent , Streptovitacin
Dog was evaluating new drug?
19
Title “rules”
3.Titles should be past tense
When describing your own work you should use past tense
20
Past tense titles
Example (wrong)Heavy rain decreases pollen production in Lonicera
Heavy rain decreased pollen production in Lonicera
21
AST example
Avoid ASTs (assertive sentence titles)
Bacillus thuringiensis is an effective control agent for mountain pine beetle in northern BC
Bacillus thuringiensis controlled mountain pine beetle in northern BC
22
Title “rules”
4. Max of 2 lines
Most journals prefer short titles Often 100 characters (10-12 words) Shorten by removing excess words
23
Excess words
A title is not a sentence and does not need SVO
Cut “waste” words such as: Studies on Investigations of An opening A, An or The
24
Excess words
Titles need to be short but not too short
Studies on mountain pine beetle
Not helpful
25
Excess words
Titles need to be short but not too short
Most titles that are too short are so because they are too “general”
Need to be much more specificNeed to use genus, species and strains!
26
Declarative titles
Declarative titles tell what the paper says
Not all journals allow them!
27
Declarative titles
The effects of nitrogen on leaf length of Lonicera
As declarativeNitrogen increased the leaf length of Lonicera
28
Declarative titles
WarningSome journals ban titles that make claims about the results
29
Thesis titles
Thesis titles are a bit different to journal titles as they cover a much broader scope
Thesis titles often have a main heading with a more specific sub-heading (something not many journals allow)
30
Paper series
If you are writing a series of papers on the same subject, title each one separately (do not number)Why
• Publishing can get out of sync easily• Journals do not like to feel “obliged”
31
Hanging titles
Same as series titles but with colon rather than Roman numeralvery common in journals (Science)
results presented independently in each paper
32
Hanging titles
DrawbackMay place emphasis on general term rather than significant one
ExampleMountain pine beetle outbreaks in BC: Impacts on the local communities
33
General manuscript format Title Author(s) affiliations Abstract Introduction Materials & methods Results Discussion References
34
Authors & addresses
Official criteria for authorship of medical journals set in Vancouver, 2002
1. Conceived & planned work or interpreted evidence
2. Written paper or taken part in revisions3. Approved the final version
All 3 must be met
35
Authors
In the real world of research, much work is done by teams – each contributing different skills (intellectual and practical)
Medical criteria too restrictive? What about lab technician?
36
Authors & collaboration
How many of you have committee members from another discipline?
With joint authorship, need to discuss the writing EARLY on so that it can be divided accordingly
37
Authors & collaboration
Does not usually work to give each author a separate section as this weakens logical flow
Better to assign best writer as the group coordinator
38
Author order
Usually most prominent author is first or last position with co-authors listed between in descending order reflecting level of contribution
Team leader usually decides on this ranking
Ideally, every contributor receives credit
39
Author credits
Check with journal Adding a “credits line” with who did
what may be appropriate This could also be done in the
covering letter to the journal
40
Author credits
Agreement on author order can lead to disputes
In one example, asking each author what share they believed that they had in writing the paper revealed some interesting stats
41
Author credits
Ethically, any author listed on a paper should agree to take public responsibility for paper’s content
To agree to this really requires taking part in research and writing
42
Author credits
Some authors listed should NOT be
Collected data only Grant proposal writing only General lab supervisor only
43
Author credits
First author is usually referred to as senior authorHead of lab may “automatically” come first or second
Visibility is important – beyond 1st, 2nd or 3rd author you are invisibleinvisible
44
Author credits
If all authors agree to be equal, then can list alphabetically (not common in N America)
Record for most number of co-authors is 488 from 30 different institutions (Physical Particle Physics)
45
Author credits
Tendency to list multiple co-authors is sometimes linked to “publish or perish” syndrome
Many established scientists do not want dilution of their work by adding multiple co-authors
46
Form of names as authors
Vinicius A LubeCindy E Prescott
NotVA LubeCE Prescott
why?
47
Form of names
Consider Robert A Day
Search for RA Day brings up Rachel Day, Ralph Day…notRobert A Day
48
Form of names
John D SmithNot John David Smith
Why?
49
Form of names
Take the former dean as an example
John N Saddler JN Saddler John (Jack) Saddler John (Jack) N Saddler Jack Saddler John Saddler Jack N Saddler
50
Author addresses
Addresses very useful identifying author (John Smith, Yale..)
For more than one author, addresses are listed in order of authors
Use a and b superscripts when more than one at same address
51
Author addresses
Author addresses also useful for readers to obtain reprints
Journal usually asks for 1 author to be marked as “person to whom enquiries can be made”
52
Copyright
You own the copyright to anything you write and publish (in N America for life + 50 years)
When you publish in a journal you transfer the copyright to them
Copyright laws still apply to copyright materials available through the internet
53
Copyright
Copyright does not cover the ideas or the data itself (just the way in which they have been presented)
If you hold the copyright you can control the way that the work is reproduced and disseminated
54
Copyright
“Fair Use” is allowed under copyright laws by teachers for the purposes of criticism, comment or news reporting
You must source any such use of copyrighted material
55
General manuscript format Title Author(s) affiliations Abstract Introduction Materials & methods Results Discussion References
56
Abstract v summary
Two are differentAbstract is written as an abbreviated version of the paper for someone who may never read the paperSummary restates the main findings and conclusions of a paper and is written for someone who has read the paper
57
Abstract purpose
Help readers decide if they want to read full article
Make the title clear Help reader assess the level of difficulty of
the article Help reader rapidly gather competitive
intelligence Index articles for quick recovery and cross-
referencing
58
Abstracts ISO requires abstract with every journal
article Length specified by journal or indexing
service (usually 200-250 words) Because abstracts appear in online
databases & abstract journals separated from the articles they describe, they should be complete and understandable on their own
59
Abstract defined
By definition, an abstract provides an abbreviated but accurate presentation of the contents of a document without added interpretation or criticism and without distinction as to who wrote it
60
Abstracts and titles
Title and abstract are always read together
Do not waste words by repeating title in abstract
Be as brief as possible but write in complete sentences that flow together logically
61
Abstracts and keywords Most journals ask for 3-10 keywords Keywords are used for cross-indexing your
article under standard headings in large data bases
Choose keywords specific to your paper and some terms that categorize your paper more generally if work has an interdisciplinary content
Do not use words from title
62
63thingsbiological.wordpress.com
Abstracts and keywords
Consider my paper on the number of dorsal stripes on Guatemalan tarantulasPossible keywords
Central American spidersTarantulasGuatemalan arthropodsColouration of spidersDorsal stripes
64
Abstracts and indexing
For an abstract to be useful in an online retrieval system it must incorporate the key terms that a potential researcher would use to search – this way extraneous items retrieved by a “full-text” search can be avoided
65
Abstract types
Informative abstracts One paragraph containing purpose,
methodology, results & conclusion Used with reports of research
Indicative abstracts Sketch of topics without summarizing
evidence and conclusions Used with review articles
66
Structured abstracts Sometimes used in medical journals
as miniatures of the actual paper This type uses sub-headings parallel
to the research article Usually longer, up to 400 words
BackgroundMethodsResults Conclusions
67
Informative abstracts Address the same questions as the paper,
but without supporting tables or graphs Use complete sentences in same level of
technical language as article Choose active verbs instead of passive (the
study tested rather than it was tested by the study)
Must be complete enough to stand on its own
68
Informative abstracts Do not use references Do not use abbreviations (some exceptions,
DNA, pH, USA) Do not use definitions Do not use phrasing such as “this report
presents conclusions and recommendations from a survey on carrot growth”
Avoid using I or we Do not refer to information that is not in the
article
69
Informative abstracts
As an aid to database searches, abstracts may be used to provide synonyms for terms provided in the title
For example, if title uses “entomology”, abstract might use “insects”
70
Informative abstracts
Informative abstracts must include Purpose – we did Methodology – we saw Results & conclusions – we concluded
All in 1 paragraph
71
Abstract contents
PurposeState the background or reasons for your study placing the work in context (1-2 sentences)
72
Abstract contents
MethodologyState the methods and describe at length only if unusual (1-2 sentences)
73
Abstract contents
Results and conclusionsIndicate the main findings – this is essential (1-2 sentences)Include 1 sentence giving the most important consequence of the work (telling what the results mean)
74
How to write an abstract
Read the article with the goal of abstracting in mind
Highlight the objectives and conclusion(s) in the article (introduction and discussion usually cover this)
Write a rough draft without looking back at the paper
75
How to write an abstract
Do not rely on the way material was phrased in the article – summarize information in a new way
Rephrase sentences until they are direct and concise
Eliminate wordiness Revise your abstract, checking for
how well your ideas flow
76
Checklist for a good abstract Should be readable, well organized, brief
and self contained Should not repeat the title Should not refer to “this paper..”, but
should be about the research Should not refer to information not in the
paper The abstract should be about the
research, not about the act of writing
77
Checklist for a good abstract
It is generally true that a good abstract is followed by a good paper
A poor abstract is a harbinger of woes to come
A brief and clear abstract using significant words will impress the editor, reviewers and readers
78
Assignment #2 worth 20%
Write an informative abstract, provide a title and include 3-6 keywords for one of the 2 “almost” published journal articles handed out in class
Use between 200 and 250 words for your abstract
Follow the rules provided in this class
Due date March 4, [email protected]
79