fourth internacional - june 1940 - socialist workers party

8/18/2019 Fourth Internacional - June 1940 - Socialist Workers Party

1/32

M L U

A N S i t W

d i

L T R

BalanceSheetof theFinnishEvents

F a t U

P aR

P r

L a L u

“ S

u

o @

F D

J P C

e b

G N

e a

W H

S

e

J G

T


2/32

M a o

I

O up p et h assue

F o u rf o e

h iuo b

o r ds e ce c

l aa i li g h a e

l hr a n cie n t h

s tr ih ao uu

n uf f i

F ro ac o ao m r

ar i tt e l la b o

h el aa n s hh a

e nt he s e r ht o

h en t e r n a tf o

mt r ee e t io u

o ua m p a ino c i

a m p aou b s c

i ob e io n d u cd d

e w s s tre io

o r dw i d hi

t ha g a z

M at hr a n cro

c f ou

t ha e s p e c

i e l

C o m p li se x p iu

a e ea l

g e ng o r

t hu b s c r i

h ia os i n u

r i aa u n ceb t a

b f o l l ot h ei s

D u r ihi r we e

hr it o t1 8u

e e nh e

e s p oe m o n s t

w o r k ea n g uh u

h i

n u ms u c

b r a n co l l

N eo is i t he

is u br to o h

ei t e r ag e ah o

h eo i ae a

nhh e r i

on c r e ah

t ha g a z

l hi t e r ag e

aw unc ti e

n t h u s

s e ci u

o oJ o h

. hi t e r ag ec e

l a co st h

on o

b ul o hS

A

i t h iis u

l me ne

io s t ai o r g a

n hr i o ha rr e

C h i c a

F I

P N C S W P

v I

J une1940

No.23 WholeNo.2

P ubiishedmonth~ yy the SoemMTWomma

PARTY,16Uni-

vers i tyP lace,New York,N. Y. Telephone:ALgormuin-8547.

S ubs cript iona tes :$2.00per

ear ; bundles,14cfor 5 oopiesan d

u p. C a n a d aa n d F or eig n: 50 per y ea r ; t m nd lee16. f .r 6

copiesa ndu 2 c lrightsappliedor.

Ed 4tor4aloard :

J AM E SP . C ANNON

ALB E RTG OLD MAN

J OSE P HHANSEN

G E ORG ENOVACK

FELIXMORROW

Genera lManager :

MI CH AELCO RT

T AC O N

E D ITORIALC OMME NT . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35

FB I ANDTHE UNI ONSbg Fa rrell

Dobbs 39

B ALANC ESH EE TOF THE F I V

Trotaky 4

T R E S IA Meorge

N

45

ONC EAGAIN—LE NI NANDLU XEM B U RG

W H

47

THE P ATHOL OG YFRE NE G ACY J C 52

“SC IE NCE ”-B U

R NH AM’SS TYL E J a r oieG er Za md . 56

TH E S OU THAFRI C ANNATIVEAND TH E WAR

58

F RO MTH E ARS E NALOF

MARXISMTh G ro@nga ~ nthe

Communist Oppoeitima

60

ORGANSOF TH EF OU RTHNTER NATOIN AL

I B C

M A N AO L

I F C

c ais u

hf as p

s c r it yh i tr om t

C s e5 s u b s c r en ui fw

f i o

n e v eg o t a

~ i % w an ob f s eu

t P aa n a ra r‘ i1 i~ i

J o h eu b s c~ ~ ~ ;a t

W if ie cM i

a p ot p ao t

b r a ne x pe o

p e t it n ee p

d uf i

w ea t ol h2

s u b s c rao b a

“ s t av i g

c a m p

s u b s c r ir o

M “ Hs em o

s o o

S r a nes u b

t i ol i t eg e

i C lA s p e a

t o m rht h

p a yt b ai

F r a nm a kd e

m if fc li a

c o ue x at o t

b r a n

s e5 s u b s c

T ha f ih o i

c o m rhl a r

e m p lw o rh

p n v ec o n s

f e cp lh u t -

P ho I lu t

f o len$

m ord n k i

m s u b sr o

H o wa e nf

a r eh a l

t o p pd a

t o m a gm m i

a d irs m o

i s sr em

a n s

A f S a

n er ef o

i r e at a p

o I “

f o rt ‘ t

w n e ns uu

B i c e rb e

t b et u

w o tc o

a hha t

d w N I

t t c o

h w r to o p

t t hd e m

k d i

g r a ~e n

St Louis comesin for specia l - -

c o mu b

m e n to is u boa t S

t i o

A ms m ar au re

t s d t m S

h a t

t f s i s

s u b

d o f 2 t 4 a m

A r l

P a i

i b o

A w e n

f p o b

o b a p

f i mt r

c t f i i

c nl

a a s m i

s o r

d t s t t p

a s i w t l d

l I v o t e

i f r t s d

w a n g t l a o

t b a i t

d eB w o

f n m

A s i t p

m o b b o

S b e a

e t b t a

t h r a d

i t B w e e

e si i c w

p p o t c

b o t b b

a c b l

b rw t p

l s c t

m p f l

i t d

*

O f m a b

c i n

C ew l

g p e b

o t m l o o m

a m t p o g

t I i

t f

d ia a y f

h E m w m s

o I h

d o b w r

a m 2 a b f

m w r e

c o t s

p w b u t g

I t o o c

r a s t

b e i

p og o m

z t i o P

h i ms

a m q p

*

A k t d s

u f s u


3/32

F I

T M M

of t he soci al i st w ork ers Pa

V O L U

TU

1

N

E d i

T S o M S l

AP ITALIS MN ITS DE ATHAG ONY n V i S P

s o c i nt hoe r ra i s c o

m al a u g hhi l lt o iw e

h e r dn he rm p e rr a eu

a g a i ho r t i f i cB e lH o l

m i l lt o i l hee rnA lm p

i sr m ia eh ret m eo f f e

M u s s oa i u hi gp l uI t ao

e rn hl oa t nt a c iJ a p

A m e r im p e r i al ae at vr

c o l o no os t a

T he co r ahp eir e l a

m i ni l i tc t iau p e rb s e

t ho u r gr e nl s e wc o n ch h

w ao m p l ei f l err e va h v

w ef a r — w hh r oe ss t u p i

c o n f ot a ln v aF i n le x a i

t ha jt r u gh e htt o f f

t ht i l ihs t r a n gt F i nv

w ha g r e u ng aS o n

t ho h ha r ra o ut hi

t i ov eh e m sah h hi

d i f f e rr ha nni i n c ri o l

s w i fe m n tor o fn v o lt

m a s s

O t he c h ni dm p e rr mi e v

r e s pr mir e ae s t ra p ht

l a aa r t i c ut hit l at d e v

m et h io re c ei rm p

t h a ae ct hi m e n sa f o

c o n j u n cia n nr m ag ia

s w i f t nne s t r u c ti t hn k r

s w a rp l ar ovo p ul o

b o mh r ro l lm e c hr

d e s ta i l wu i i do mi tt he s

e x e r c id o m i n ao s i tt c o n s e

t hi ro ra ol la p i tt c l

t ho n f lt r i he ri l ia c h

c o m p e lhe ra p i t ai m p ln o n

c o m p l eo de v ee s pe n ot r

a b i ll r ee m o n st P o lvi

S c a n d i n ao uc o u n tr i tr

t i o na vo ws p e chf lu sc o

j u n c ti ao r ch iG e m

i a l ii m m ed v a nhi tu t i

t ht m o

C o

E vs uo w a r

b ea t M ar t

o t s eW H t u s

o h e ap s a p

S tb c rt t h n

e f li ncA a

m t G et b aN o

s ud i sh i

i t B row l t t d

t C h a ab f t t

o f t t h m f t t W F

H ioh m ii S

l a ua thL C

N m im a i t l W W

m at c ot i mi

w i to e o a t w

n a vh b c

a rt h t o m t c

w ob i t f t d

o t m ii cb b t t o

d ee

T l w w e b t m t

n w h a sa a t a

n b el t t h w l

t heb ei r a t t

m b om g a t i r

t hou t p i a s w

f i eC h

I o rc o t i c

p ec u s f od t i t m

e t h oh t t i t e n l

t e ns u nt t r u

d ev c as t i m

v i oe xt s g o

m et c et s

w e t s eW

B i t F E

T N e tc

w i n ed et s d t H

a d vt L C om o

D uat L a s t

c o m mF oV K

t C o iJ M W N o t D

g o vp og ot A

w t s r ed e f

o t G eis B a f


4/32

O UN T E R

une 194-0

m m e d ii l i tb j e c tr u st N e t

a nl a cs t a om u oe sT

t ho r p oo l dR o t tt

u p e r - e x p lna b u liu an d

‘ T h e s e - i s ly ie t wu s tt o s i

n hh i l i p pnr en d o ~t o t

p e r ct ho r le pp e rt

u b bp e r ct o ro p3 p e

et ho r l iar o d ut s t r a

ho s sa l ue p ot a o i h

n d ho m i nt un a

r e t tt aa c r e da tt

a

L oe f oi ta u nf f ec

u to r d hu e st ab eo

m o hm p e r ia n d1 9N e t h e

p e1 1 , 8 0 0t hn it aw p l ab

t han d n1 91 0 , 6

ul a e ho m m at F r eo

h aa eS i n g ac o n f eig e

rt a ft hr i to l oo m it

ho n f e ri s c ud e fe a

J a p a nd e s i

T h wm p e r io woi tn t et h

o o r hn it a na pn a i

ha p a no v e r n aod v op r o

o w ho u t hi r et P h i

r e nn d o - Cr i tu rbt

u tan d i oh es l ae et w e

st hu r o po wo s s eo l oi a

i s t ah i ha p arai

ac o n qC h in ao

nn do vs e ca ra e n

m or o ge x p a nl eo t r e

o o ht t es t a b ir ea p e

rC h i aa s c rt hm b ie

n his l ao uJ a p

W ha pao th i rn t et F

i t l en v aS c a n d i na

r o m pe p lhw oa c r

o to s s e s she rd i p l

h ia nt hp hhi p lo

h el uhp r ot a he c r

um m e d i as ss t a t ee tt c l

t hn i tt at h aa Tn it

o m pp a r t iao lh e

T h ee c l a r aeo l la h i gi g n

R ed m iK T a ut e s t

o he n ao m m in af fA p

“ c a n ne oc al t i mr ee r

n aa c c ot ha si t u

o uw a r r au s ic o nf i n ae

nn e c e so rp r e sn t eC h i

T ht a t ec o m p lt o l lo a

r ie s t ie f hao m m iT r

g r e a to n ct hn it at p r e i

t h aa s. .

W n eu nd e l ut

hi no l i cJ a p. . I c o n ft

h o ua p ao nE an

ho u s o l he ho e

T hn i tt al ec o n c e no m e e

o H aa b A nj n

o t J a su n

s iJ a or t t w

l ot R or d

o h c ot F E a h d e

“ m as t

t i f o t o i

p e rag t b

W oA mi t d t

t o op lc t s

W ob a c oJ o t c i

t F E amm pm p a

a r ra t b at w m w b

n o p pi d d oe e T

c uw r i t v n f i t F

E t U nt b w

J at D o

W t c o ew e

i m p ew at c t t

o t w oh b d rt a w

f e lF nt b

‘ rG e eah s

p o lp pa s u n

m t rf rt u o

F r uI r ur a t

r u tra e d g a

D et m ao c ai d

a gd a c luc r

b c a po e a a b c

o rf ie m pt

i t f rt o pw f

d i sd a

D i t V

T e x orU S d

i w oh b g t

s u cet A lb t t o t

J a pm pt o t D E I

R o o seo mt A a

f iam ia ri t F E

p a r tt W eb l t s

i f w m at e

u s A li gp o

w hn t b t m I t A

s hia d eW S w b c

p es o i e x pa i d i t

l vet A h h t d

t A m eob s o v

T i n ouU S d

i v oib g

t l ed et p m w

h o c cA mam w c

b c o u ne mb i nt w

o a f g ru t n L S t

b u s nt w u f t d o t 1

d e pre sF i

a grst w d S

1 hb o o i nt b i

h ae ss a s t

T ni 1 j p t t S

i C o nA mi a a m

h i tt v ilo b i


5/32

J u 9 O UN T E

t e r p r ea i n d i ct e ce c oa

w h o le i t

o v e r sn v e n

“ c u

d oe x p o

tx p l a no b t

b o u r gr e oo p uo n s ua c c

t he p r e s sx p a nn v e na n o s

o e x p a nn d u sc t is p e ca w s i

t i hn d u s tn c rhn v e ne x p

t ih ur o f ne c as h i pa zf

e x p or ahi n w io m m e ni m p

a n i ho m ea ra f a cf f er o

t i o hi ma hx pM a rha

f u r te c li n d u sr o d ua w h

m a r ka m o

e x pa M a “

1 9 3h ohm e rc os u f f r

m oe r r in t ei c k nx pM ac c

t t ho v e r ni g ux c em pa a m

g r e ah ha na i 9

T hi a b s o l ul ehp e ee c

m o r rm e rn d u sr o d uof a

w i hh a r pnoi s a se ca i h

t o rd e c lh io uf d e eh h

p e r i e n1 9 2 9 - 1i t hr o sh i a

s m ua s he pt ac alt

N e u t r ac nho n s tn oa a

W at r e ea r t i c it e coo a

t r e m e nc an e v i t

I a n t i c i pU n it an thb e

m a r kn c r es t er dt p ae h

m oi kr e c oiu p st b u s

d e x — w h eh io ne m pi i m p o

s a hn dn oi ni r eid e v e

o w a r —l u c t u ae ad e gA m e

i n v o l v et ho n fl o sf ui l

p a r t i c i p a

C o nM a

i C a n

A i w en o ha p i tn g o o t

b a t t l e fh e m s ehrf om a n

f i g h toh ehr ea t u rhm a

f i go l u n t ae nh eb a rp r

g a no ot ho u r gr“ n a tn i

t h sa r r yuo c iit i m p e

g o v e r n m

I G r er i tr a nn it h a

p a i ae a cur o p o ri i m p op

u a s i ne w s pw he d i to l

t hee p oh e m sn h a mt “ n

f on a t in i t

a ba sg ia i h a

w oa i o ha“ n a tn ii c a

l i m i trp ea es t a bF r

E n g l ac e n s ol a moa p u b l i

T he ae n ai n v os e dc t i h

i sp p o s it haai e f fa

c h a i nh an nr i v i lat b o

o r d et d i o in t e ra t uc a p i

c o n t it ah er o fw ie n o r

c e l e r aa t uhp r e cp u r“ n a

u n i t

tt i ho r kl as a f ep r

s y s t

I F r“ d n

b eu a i nw A t

w hb s a c “ h

i ms ei t a k e i

t i nd i oF

G e rieb o

t n o tf i mt U

S td w i d et P b

r ew h al i F u

t i np rot A

t rnt a

A s a t w s tF e a

m i t c o ea o 1 a 4

c at a r mL 1 w

r e tj t w l g

m o f fo ft r a

t s m f t a b i a f

v et w w e b

a o i n fs um j

t t b a a t

A o s tp ra h l w

l ag ah w

o a w or 6 a w I “

f a ch w m p i o

t i a l6 h h b w

o o a o v4 p d i

a a s pT a “ s T d

w on e 1 f m o 1 f

m a c h c

T hn o s a

O F ea d a s

a f o aw p t

d i fe lt s d a d

m o bw w w c

r e gc o mf

w hg od e

O t o t ob l e

m o iu m o t p w i n

i n iw oE a m

d ai i n p li r c

I a dt t w G B a

j a “ fp a p e b J

K eB ro cs

r et i nt w g o a

p u l

T hi cw p i “

F rE nn s t U

S tK ei a s f

b p rJ F c o t

c uE x o p h

l i m

f a r m r rc a

p r oe b p d t t

e r np ab c

“ l aa d

W “ ni t c u

t n o t M P t A w

f t w a m iim

a cA tt e

s a f l os a i


6/32

..

P a g e

O UN T E R

1

l a a u la b oi go r g at s t

h i g ha gm eh eo iw ia i

F r a nnr er i t

“ N a t i on ie ao ts u f ft

m a s sh eo n v e rna no dt c a

t a l in a t in i

e an l ip p o r

p r o f i t

T D i aM

T h e r we n t ihl mvo

f e et ho u nh a tw aa h a

H i t loh ee n t ir o g r eha

o H i t le f l ei t lr u st l ao v

i G e r m an ir uu p p ra t n a t

m i n o r ii t hh ie il mvo

l o nr d e no hm a sH i tha

w ae f l ehe a l i zt o rhm p e

w aw a gnh io nt p rt

c a p i t au l e

I t hn it a ha sx pha

w aa d e s os o l at a w r

E u r o po n f l oe e pw a hx p

t h ea t roi th r oc q u i eW a s

t o ne m aoa d e qe fe a s u

C l e ve m a g ox p lot hr o g

s e n t i m ehs o l a t ie n ts e ipt

S t a l i ni m p l e hr eo rot

K r e m lt hn it at a lp p o

t h ap ue m a gc c a s iha

s h or t it t a ci to rg is e m b

r e s p e c t a bt h ei nf a t r e

o s i tw ac o n c ehn b e th

.

s o l a t i ohi k e“againstwar ”

h sg a iu n ths i z eo l l h

h aev e rt ha t t l eu n f u

s t a nt r it hr oo mS t a lo

f o l lo sr dc l o h hu n

t t r huo l l oha c t up p

a ht a l i na ex pm ai h

a rc o m p l ea n k rhi c o mn o w

h an t i -io nt e m pa n h

w ih a ng ao m oh ot aha

l e g i ari tt hl l

T hn t i -e n t iv ei d e sh r o

t ho u n thoe ca loip e r

t ho t en onp p oo p pu r

h eE n g l nr a n“ ht A l h

o w ad i s r e g ae n t ia l mn a n

o p p o s iw a up o w ee n ta l e

t aa f f ehr e s i d el e cv it p o

s i b i lA l le f eb oe p u bD e

c r a ta n d i dv o hs ss t rw i

a m b i g uh r a sI n d e p ea a i

m i l i tn t i -r o gor o f of

c o u rt r a d i to l it n it am a

W at r e eip l u no u nw

i m m e a s u roi f f i

H t D e i

T h oe m a g oe vt r i p ee m o

l a ba k eo u r go l i t ia d vu p

i t A lm pa m . c H

a n ot a W S T u

t s a r gt l w i o t g t

m as u pA a t K T

“ e w ra w o

f m v id eT f t “

t w of d e b t

F aN d i cn m d

s hF r rt U S

T hr olt b

a bd ee “ i “

s it w “ pnc g

r u a em l T e

o t l W w h t i ms

i t hf rw s u s

p oA l at w o d s a

H ia s irc ai d

a gw s u no b s

t e na pt w b f

r o t hom t p i o w

a fn

T m at u nt d t

c a p yi n ea a a t o

t c a po o c of s a

w S tf s o ei

t w ob f o ma s

r e vG ew u l

o a s ul si mh a

k H iw h t t t t w

o t o tauo c

m a i lgG t e

t f on o t f s i

c o n st w a t O

c o n st l w H w b c i t

j a h f et d

c o u

M U S

“ U n tM at p i i t

b t w a s to M r t

s t yt f p w t 6 c

o o E ud w t c b c n f

a r e st s g

l D L ei t c o e a b

c at hm it s

i t t hli ltt O R

l us y mM a e t

t l id w t U S T d

o vd n e o a i

m o vt p r oa t s t o

g e at t A w i a f

j u aw E o uP

t e ca p r os p t

O w i t s pd ob t

M aa pA mM w b

t m et a d m

— ro K M

o K M


7/32

J u 9

O UN T E

F A T U

F D

.—.-

.

‘ h-

T

HETR~DE”UN”&

N 6 t z E ~ lit

m oh o r o u g ho v e r nt tt f f i

d at ha la ihs sa r

p l a n no n d ua m oe l i ba na

b e c or o as c oe tt ie

m or a z tu r pt p r eA m e o

e r oo cu b m ir e g i m ei n d

s e r vt hi l ia c hho o sc

W at r el u n hn it anoI

T hr o o ha m pp r eC o

g r e s sa ri nC o m mU n - A

c ac t i v i ti n or e pg b a v

s ar o unll i te ep r em a

a i n v e s t i gf a s cr o ia n n o h

t hh at hoh o m mb ea t

t o r il e a p ee on at a c h

s t a t e mf aa l hrt h im a

f eo t it hi r e cr e ct hi

n or e p ag eos e ru st a

t a ct ho r kr g a n i zc c oh o

a n n o u n c eh e rn t e nt n et

t ha m p a

T hat hio m mt s tp u u

p i c io wn ie a di l iaf i

t h r om u d - t h ra m pr ei t b

d oR o o s e vo l i to lF e du

I n v e s t i g ah it hp e at e n n

u n ir ih u rr n oet a n t i

v i s it hn it ae p a rJ u s

R o o s e v eu m na t c h et c o u r

i t h em b i tm a ur e p aM -

w h it h ae p a r tat d o w h

t hm e r io ric o m pg t w a

P r e s e n tp p r o p r iF e du

I n v e s t i gro u gi fil at h

w e1 9 1 heU n it an no

W aT h Bp e ra i ei nr o

w h a t el e nr e te du r i sl a

c a s eh hn oo s sF g i ut

t ho co l no u r

J E d go o vet Be s te

H o up p r o p r io m m iN o v e9 h

t h B ar g a n“ g e nn t e li v

w h i ao m p ix t e ne ci n d i vr

a nr g a n i z an g aw hc as u b

a c t i v ilt h e ra r ma r rm a

w ho o s el u no u n ai

m e d ib j e ct ho v e rt c uo t

t r an io v ea d vt w a m a

t hi l i tl e mp o s s it hc tht

t e r r o rho r k ns p e cw o rl

l e a d et hh eia m i nr e s i

t h al a he cg o v e rc tg a

u n i oh oho o s e v e l t - A ro n

“ s u b v e rc t i v i nut hnt e

r o r i

T s ouJ E H i q a

c h a rh s t m o t I

t is s oP i J 1

<

w ht es ff w

a a d vt p s T f f

h e rht N L

l a oN o1 c

B o ixs pf o a p

a i m p ec i q w

i w hF h n j u H i i

e sk el l j n m h t

a p t h

T F h o s eco p r

t b g oa w m p

a d e m ot t m h s

p r ea lc f e

M i ns tt s a

t w a s nh r t

i a do a “ s

T t ht s o t t m s

p io t w o

I n diw ha t

l o

m mn F i n “

t aa o s c at H R

H o hw t w o e o t U

g o vd r et s s

I i o a s f t t t b o s

a “ i nat p rs l

e a “ af o o

T h re s o h “

t ra ma l t I

L a nt A s a l o w

c an q uit S A

L hd i t e t a d

d oc ct w a e m

a p r af d t t

t t r a d eej h r

w i dn d gu a t u

o f fc h“ c oc

t r

“ i n ti n a

o thF c d u w w g

A ro p pw t a u t t

i m o hc

T S hnw e b C

i 1 a a r et p rt w

f ad et h t a m

b c ut g o vw f u n a

t t ra gA U

1 8h ec i i a

u n c rt e T

w o r k egp s s

t 1 C oC A s

e x et “ c w

c oj u st b o t S L


8/32

...

. . ..... .. .. . ......... . .. ..

a

F O UN T E R

1

T o d an d hg ri b eo o si t

e et hB he p a rJ u si

i v i s h lr a ca ge v

rl r et he dr ia r e

hr i vt h rn de oe np

h i go u rtt hn c t r

rn dow a ir ic o n s i du

n dr o b a t ie d ef f ij ae n ta

% vh ee a

T hi rn ii c tt ig a“ a

a m p aae c oM 6 w hF e d

o ur d ev e ra c q ua c a

ha s h i nC l o nt A

c c o rt ha te po o s e v

eu n d e ch e ta p po

a ka h i go ua f u rt tj ah

r an i o n i

T ho r kai tet c ioa

t ho co lg eg ah cv i o

h a ad e fh e m ss t r b l

h ai tn c o n f it c a b ea

ah er i ei d i f f eiF Bhm u

t hi nt o rt ho o

en d e r s th nt a kud v at

a c

A f e e la wo w ae du t hd r i

n hi nt ho r ku rhc ha

ha r e fu r tc l er o p ah r o

h ed ui fht hr id v at F

a i n s t r u o ha m pg au n i

h e aec a r ep eu ia u g

t h Bt hyt w o r kh i

a m p ag a ii l l ia

t cr o v iht a ou i ls e rm o

l al o r i fhG - Me i nd r

ee et hG - Mt r a ic c o m

hn e v i ta dp eJ E do o a e

p o w e ru p p l e hac o n t rs h

hG au s t

e rt h ru m

t he v i ch ea c ta eb h eR o

eh in t i - ur i

T he t hm p lt a r r eo r

nr i n ght r ie l i b ea l c

he n eu bm p r eh hd a n

hoo p uot a r rt r

t h Bb e t wA .5 A .t

ha ir eo fi pi a d v

hr r et h h ab ti c tt “ G -

ho r k fj aa n d cf a s

a c h a uj at as l

ri v h lo u g h - c o pc

i rG - M ha lt h c ea r d -

a tn o tG - Mow p r eb

na n“ h eo rh d o e

“ c o n f e st he lo ra i r -t o

b oha p pt h or r et F w d

ot el lc o m p ac tt hht

t hr e qe a r cw o r ko i

uvm ut ho r m aa w a r

B a o oo r kr r et F h b e

u n ia n s at t F h

m an tt e t u t

c oo p rb i s t

s u p e rca t eb f

j ua cb i r e

p r at F i t p % f

e t i aoa l t l m b

f i a rh et h h l t

t c oh c op d

A g e xF m t c o t

r ec o ns o l u o t

A T e aF ea S C I

t t F m m ea s

o h it b o I

i o re s ut F C

H w s f t a a a m

o i n t ep i t w o t e t o

t b b oly a a h h e s

t t o t a l nD t p t

F h t o t t i c o

p rc s t u r

t rip pp O

d e fl t 4 h f t t h w f

a s a l ah w b t T m

w s et y i a F p

a a n u p a t t h

c o

A p o t w i f t F b b e

a b d io ls u s a b

l oop r otc o i

r e c gw t s i m

b t f ea t l c O a s

p l eo tt yt i t c

R e pr e sE D

t es B u

t i nt A t G S c

T B u e on n t h o

c o p s -t a d u

i o nt s h h f

i n t ehw i o n D t s

d o t p r ot u c h

A t le ei a s

p lo ft u u t c

a d i sm eb t i w n

a d jW L M co t f w

l als u cp t u

N Y c o o M 8 w t h

l i

S oD H S U

s wF a gnt c

q u aa vc o s

m a lot d e

T hb a v es o

b or et u b t F a l

p op r ota p o t c

b oef ec g j h b

e a on i t r o

u nh b b rt g j r

T e m pr as w R

v en tt o i b t

o m es n ot w h

t g t t F a t l c D s


9/32

. .. . . . . ... .. . . . . ... .. ..

J u 9 O UN T E

a rn s t i tg a i hrn ie vp p o r

F i n rl a nt hn ii n s tua

c o u n tnh hne cd r a

c o u nr ina t t oa c c o ui

a na ot hm p l os s o c

T ho l d nt hrg al e af f

t r an ie m o n s to o s er geg

t h oo ni a ln m i s tv ih c

t e m oh oee a dit hn c

t i o nu p p ohe tt R o o s e v e

H o o vg eia s w e eo l la m

r e c tg a im ur ot rt t r n

m o v e m

S or an i o nee ac o no o

i n n o ca no m p lt ha m p ho

o uhd i op p oh ur nt p o

a t t o r n e y - ghr au re l et

U n i tt au p ro uhr eo o s h

t he p a r tJ u s toa l wt f

a p p r o p r ih ir e q ut ho ne c

t h e m s ent h ehi tn c in a f

t he n ei nam i sbR o o st

h e at hn t i -r i

T h Fa p r e se am art

a t t a uh o oe hC c a f

r e m ai lh oe s c

B a l

T C o o

i is e n t a

a li ml t C F W

e U ni o a b es t

g e et C t i i s t s a

p eA t s u a b i c a

a ta to bf

c o n set s t

u noa p w i t e b g

c o n st C m oi t A

t hd dc oi

l o f a s t p o

u ni ni w m m

l ew p h et o p

T t oc oa v t

t i v e x iop s

u nm w t h h

f at m od i c o i

t a tr et u b h

f b t g o vt w b u t

f t haui n

o t w o

T c a lno t g

m m b m h ed o t u

b j a c at ho a t

t a ab r es o t m

m i a fi nt l m

i a s tp o d m

l at f p aa t u

S ht F

L T

??

w

“

FORESAW l l iiiw r

S h a c h nu rb t s e i

E a s to l an v aF i nn

“ wo u l do r ehv e uo m p

p r o b ant t en e x pv ee c e s h

s i sc o m p lp h eo o l iho l i

l a b on d hm p r ep p a rht e

a a l l i aii to rr oa g

h i hf o r el l iw hh e

c o u l do r ehw w h

T he c o g hi gt o r ktm a

v ee t w hm p e r iat c o ng

m e ni ng a in o thg r eh o

o b v i o uat h eoe ft w o r

s t a thc q u i se c o nt r a to t

v a n t anc i r c u m se re x t et

b at ho r kt ae g e no r t

a t t e mg ah en io b u r e ae

o dh ie v et o no n fii n t

o t ho rr o l e t ax a hs u n e x

a nu n p r e d ib or e mt tg a

m ui c o ur tl l iii t

I o ul l - s to l i t ia if o rti

o ne c ah at hs i nu ee r

t h r ot hnu rr o t re g o t

t hn g l o - Fe l e gt s u m1 9

K r e mp ee m ai l io n vB a

s t e nF r t g

t c o to n e a

l i n da a gH w s

S tl ot B s P

t p ew o a pm

p r es t at hh

S tc ct W h r t m

f os o T c e d h

a g rm o H o S G s

i c o vp rt m

r et e vt a c

n os s

B et d e gt w s

S o ua t t t s

p e rt b f w t i n h

S t gH h a i o t

c ut U f a G a a g

s eU f b d i a m

W he ot p h o

E atc oH

v E a oo t a h o

s u p pu o t W

b ot U A a r o t e

e vU a cc f w G

a b v it v f t d f a v

G e em d w S

p eH ig n

T e pt p aP h i d


10/32

a

F O UN T E R

une 1940

ne qt hc a n d ir ei o

oaa ig i on t i mh “ f r

hp l a ns e ic a n d io u n

o u oaa ib r nc ow

f tl hi g n io m pe ro m it

eF i n l ane no n s td i rh

L e n i n gng at as eu p p l

g a i il lh iF i n lo w

m eie r ie s i sh e“ m i lx

i or a g ne a n wc a n dh r eb

o hr em a ja r fi th c o

ir e p a r a o hlg ae n

e m a nht ao n ce ae

ac u il ah oe n oo v i

h e r ha l ie a tt c o

t hu r o po r t h

mat I m

U n d ho n d i tW o aa p p

t has m at ars t a n

n d e p e n dn e u t r att r e

hp h ei m p e r iy t h os t rn v

o ro m i n a thu e st e x i st

S is o lp a s shr oh o

t ha c k g ria c e ro mo

t ho r e f rf at hms e cat

ro n c e rh rl r eo at h a

hr eo w e hor e ehte t

h na l i m ix t et r ec h o

w ea s t e

T wo v e r n mt r uw hN o r

t ho r w ea zo vt G e

ar o ot ho u no c i a l - do

ih eit o rh oN o

o r kau p p od e m o a

ha s c io l l on a ip

i gf i rl ap pi t hu e sh

t hf f i r m ar e a hot

ib l u nS p ha i s o

i va hn t e r v ef o rm p e ro w

m p o ri t s ee v e r te ms e

h a r a chi n v oN o rt d i

nm m e dl ae t wm p e ra

h oa n ha r ro r w eo v e ro n

o ot ho rrs u pe i

at hl l o haG e r mo n s e

h a o hl i g he aj u s t i fs u p

ni t hnt h ee m p ooi to

T he ap p rua p pF i n

r ht a n d po ht r at w or o l

ai n ne s i s tam oa o i n d e p

e f eht he s i sN o r h

ee m o n s tt hi n no v e rt h

c e a le s i sa th ai n

r a n s fnm i l iaE n g

n hn it a te c oa c i

n d e p e nF i n lN o rd e f

d e m o c rt co w em p ot h e m s

on t e r t wt ht r ui n f i noo w

o ro r cn ro m p lu b o rt h

m i ed o

p oa c ct b f

T p r o gt F I n

t w g a e xt t q s

y eT t h

i o n d

e s pi c ot i o t d o

d e mm r eu d t w

o s mn eo S p

B e lS c ao. . A f

o “ Oe t tlR G

f g o dv s

t W oi w h w b d i a m

f d e fi n dS w

p e t t yq mw w i

a m ed e ii i p t d

t er ott b o a t e

s a t i nF t R A

G a F

J d ut ic

w o fap ar

b o uo ni a m ii

p e ri s e i ui

p e rw o t oa

r e v o l ui ov t i

d e pt o t s s T o t r

l e st c te t d o t

i n t ep rs b d

P h in b p r e

T S oe1 f o

G e ho no g i

a st C at s tt p

p n ae l f -g d m h

b

i o bs s o vt s

p oe x ta o t s

i tn t ea p em t a

d uF t s tt s et

w o r tu re ns

t j u ss a ft s r

l u oe oe

W om pa l t u q o

v i oG et r ai m

p up gS oS I

a t l i t c aE a a t

p r e pa p om in

t S o v

I e xs w a i t c o G t

w oo u ti nF i m

b i lup gU T s

d e mt c t c o a t v o

d e mm pu c o t

s t ae t tt r

A lt s t it t

i n sm in ti h a p

f oi f f ri f f b t

S oe1 T 1 t o t F

I n t eW d e

m

m S ou rt w c

d it t oe xt a

p ot U f t w w c T

S o v i er erc


11/32

J u 9

O UN T E

w i t hu n sL e n i nr at O c t

r e v o l u thr e se gt U Si n c a

e x e r c ia t t r ao rd of o r

t h h hS us u r r et i m p e r

b un h hS ut oo t h a

t hu r e a u c

“ Wt C W

“ Bh et hi vF i nhp r

i sd e m he a dt o rp p o

h a oe c he a dt t hap r

i so t h io nn a lt p o sa r

t hu r te v e l ot o v i e to n

T he i zi s o la sF i na p r o

t ho m p lc c u pF i n ls e ib a

p r e s u p pa i n t ao u re gh r o

t het ho u nc c u pr e s us o

o v e r th io ui m p o si tn v o

w o r k no oa r mc i ai n ii

m a te g o t i ae t wo sH e ln d

a a t t es o l hu e st w i w s o

w i ht ha lt a ti n le s io m

t hr e ms e tnh ri le a

S t a lo uu s t he fb r oa

o ns o v i e ti n lp p o it K u

i no v e r nn d i ch aw ai n

w a oht ha lt at hP o lh

S t a l i na thm ao l ut

“ t h ia mc r i b b l ei mo m pp r

v oi v a no v e r tr o pe l a

I s p e c ie v ei mht w i F i n

n ou b m ea g e n eaS t an c o

p e l lr e t re ft h rro u t h

w o uf o rc a rh rs o v i eF i n

T h ai t s au oi f fhs o v

i z iE a s to l aoi f frm i l

s t a n d p ooi n la p pb b er e

M oi f f ir

nuthd

s t a n dF i n o

s e s sl or a d is t r un a tn d e p

f ru s sh e r hk r a it W h u

s i aei g hg a io l oi f fr

s o c it a n d p o hi no u r gi i o

w ao l vhr e - c a p ig r ar oh r

c r e a ta a g r i c u le t t y - b o ue v e r

t hi l i ti c tS t avi no

q u e s t i oa auo s so v e rp r

p e re l a ti ol es s i srF i

n io r k nm aa r m

W hhi dt aat hle c

c o l o so b i l i zb o u ru bp ie

a g a i hS Se c an gF r ae r

p o s hu e sm i l in t e r vi n a l

b u oe ai m p o r t a n c ei to a

l o n g hp p e a rE n gF r er

F i n lo uae ad i rh rH i t c

d i n a vl ah ieac o n ss u

p r i sa ut hia t w oa n gs i

f r hl l nrt hi t

t

n o u no v i e ti n li m ii mt s e i

o i s o l at r a t eo s i t

T ha r t it ht ha t at

s t ae t tp t t f

i c o n src w i F

f c at U i a n

w o c cs iU i n a w

s tr ew n n ef l

a d ep ow i F f

s o c iet U s

b nt e xE P T o

t p r ew a

c ob a cb t s t i f

t O ce vo f u

K r l hs s

t npow n t s

g rd ou a

w oi tor t v s o

t F iw a I p o B c

c h uc t s l r

l u eW t c

m i lp et p o t R A n

t h on t o t u c w

F i n

E vi sra c

m c op rm c i

p r on a p rw c b c

g i ar ut d t

t d e va w t t a d

o rf ot e a a c

m op r et w s e

p r ec oc t a

g iaro i o m

r e s eea t t c oo

p r oo o s e oc n

a t r o s at t r h

t f o F it e

p aL i tE t

p aE ao o t s s

t r et “ c

T D o t S U

S t sF n o c s

a i d et U T p t S

i i g ut B o ub

r f f o oi p

p r er ed m b t

d eU d a t e o

U a t e xt w p

w r et c lhe d

o pt S o v oc t

e iii nu o e

s hr e st i F w

r e pa s ii t c o t p

t B o nu r

I i o t s oS d h

i se si d t t

f ao ma t e t

w oon m w c S

b g uw c ai c

t S o ne ac

l t O cea c T e

t i ub f o d o

U S


12/32

a

F O UN T E R

1

T ht t et ho n j u ne f e a.a

d e f e a te x t rh e m rh

p r o m iht vA l ln t e

h ih ah ee f e ao la d f e ni a

v a si i g e ne ad e t e

n eo l i cc c o ra s ta ts p en

o n d i tt hr i tat S o v i

i ah a oe cn o wl le n

e a c ho n c lhe rq ut

o uo nh r oe s t rM u r

b o m bf r i rp ov i

s t r a th au io r rq u ei n

n o n - i n t e rt l lf o u

a h a ir ha ap p a rp r i n

t h

t ha mla n gf r

ee g i nc o n s ihw n e c ed

n eo s ia c c o rib a l

a mt ha hm u oe l i

S ut E

P o l

T ho ld e f e an u n i sa g i

oht hrh c o m ma

r hl ae l a t i oM a r i

w an oa sa b s tos e

o n s i d e r ut o cp p ra r

ii te c i p re l a tite gs u

b y s s oe c aep o l i

u p e rM u s s oe cd e f

b a c k wo u ng a io l op p re

li m p e r i ah it ant w o

l ad e fSn d e p et

t ho se gu n d ae a

he ft hSou pm p e

i eo l o se s o uor om a

e a he ag oc a p i to c ie c o

o u n d at hSl e at p a r

ra p aa s s un b oc o

nu l t ur o g rh ia p i to u n di

l op o s s i b i lx cu re c

w hn m a ho ir i oa i t h h

o n t i nc o n s hSw o r kta t i

w ht a ae s t ro l sa h

w at r a n ghr o l e te v o lS p h

h w ae t r a ho re v o lt n a“ P

p l er o n nc o l l ee c u rnt h

c o n d i the c o ge c ed e f e

U Sa w o r kt as o ot h a

S t a ln vd e m o c ri n ls o ob o

g e ou bp i nt hm p e re m o c r a

c o v ea np p rt a lr ig a

c o m m u n iho r ke a s a nh o

t hk i eh un n o vm m e de c lY

t hi n t o l eA no l l oo o s he c

a m o rm b ag a io vn i

E d u c ai t c h - du r ne a st

t h ehd e f e nSt h ee

H i t la n ei tp e cp e t t y - ba t

e d n eh ie ef o ro n t r ae a n

f r aa t w o yd

t S oet B r d t

w o uo ho n T p

m aht F nw w d

i d et q u s

a g r es a t o t i

i s tn p r et r

p at s ti nt w r

s t bi s i o

j u sl ab i a o i B d

t U w s tm s eS

w H id B uC

I i t rBS hn s a

L on oo F c

a ant f t t “

d eU Ss b i n h

B o a t oU i t s a o a

t oC ( Go L

w d ea gb ot f t t

C o n fh es cL J

w d eb ew e s T

R ue nih F

I n t ei a B A b t F

I n t eor eU a

w o rte hm

t S en ti l b s e

t r at t yoH a

L lb ee x r

l u tiJ 1 a t m p

t p rT M e p

t S en tp b r

r e cS oa a w o

g ra i h s b u T

f a lb rc M

t t r a s a n b a

w ot B lo

T d i fei o t t S a

C e xc rv e

s o ce vt B c t t t

o u ooc a

T w ob t a i h e f

t m e ra bh n a i i i

b a “ s or e n

w f ii t d o r e d

e vot w oe t i m

d i st p rh T w c

n d ep on c n o

A p1

N ‘ I

“ Sb n t o a i nb

d e vt m at w t p o t

m o vo E b S

i d en m h h n c

a ‘ tdm oa s t b -

a n tn b a n a

o geb e oa w

m s t i

o g

e“ t B D


13/32

J u 9

O UN T E

T P r e sa

l G N

R

EACTIONAT HOME an d w a b r o ai n

p r e s eo m iu rr e s i a

p a it hn it a ho r g a

t e r l io r m wia s i ni s tr o

D o m e se a c aet w om p e

c r i soi p enro m ho ni

t ug g r a vt ho n sn t e rR o o s

g o v e r nw o rf i al i io i m p e

p o l i

L iv eo u r g e o i se gt hpc a

t a l ie c he m o cd m i n i so n ti

i i t s er he g i noi ce a c

t e n d e n ch ee s tnb e n e it

N ee a oni b eo u re f o rp a

b o s sia gN ee rS o uo u

l i oo b i nna ro g ei ui

r e p r e s e n tB ia n kB u s iG i a

t haA m e r io fi c e - PR o c

l e rt a n dir uN e rB e r

B a r uh en d i s ge a c t ieh a n

o n uo n f i dt r e sd i r eh

a d m i n i s t r

D u r iii ree vo n s et

c r i so u pi hr e st m ao m

a nn a bo o s eh ohe a c tl e

c h e co r eo lW a s h il i ku

d i n aR o o s e vr o gi n t ee f

T o d lh ah a ne a ci iW a

i n g th i he l a ta s sa c il i m

l o m ao lt h eeh b ei s c

f a va f a r - ff f eb e hA m e

m o n ia s t e

T dR e

I t ha raR o o s eur e a c

f o r ci t ni t hd m i n i eb l

t l aow a io p p o rk nN D e

a ns p e c ito n c e st l or d h

t a s ti r s t -t hu poe c iu t

t h R nt h een a c trh

l e gn t r e n c hha lof i nj o

T ha p i t as s ag ar e f oe n d

a nh r ohg a io ra sr e

w an tc o m p lo n qo o si m

R o o s e v ee s e rt ea g ro l

t r i u oo n s e r va p i tt hl o

n oa t ic r i s i s -u ll ai m p e

b o u r g e oe m ao s ic trhx e

i t hh io uot o m et i n t

t i o nr o n hu c c er o s et W D

r e q u i on ho o s rN D e

a lt r u gg a i hc o no y at ht

c h a rt hr ig a io rp r e p

e n t r an ho n f lho o s en t i

t i ooi n t eah r em p eo l

T he a c t idt D eb e e

a s pA mb m k b t

e a u n eo “

a l“ fg h i h

a a n tant l w

r is ta rg

b d eeJ i t

m o v pa p eu

u n eea nd t

u c a po nb i t s

b u ro u pf u

p l ed ig t m m

J os oj t a A t

a s mo t w s

T W D efs h

e n c oe f o r t

t T s tt r ei C

d it o v eb t H

o R e p rA 1 t t W

w hur u1 F b

a gc em b

B e to rw a

t p s u bt i w i d

e m al l et W a H

a t N aR eA m t e

t hf t p ut B w d

7 t 2 v

O p pa s b t g c r

t w ot k i nc a f

a m ec oI d e

s tt o fu o

c a pt s a pb t s

t P r ep t c a n i

r ed it o b

T S W t D P

T s h ac or t

r e it r e eT

c o n sh V i

e li gm p

a s i t m oei c t r

c o ot p a t c

l e r oh o

n oc at D e

T l w o t D ei l b J

L ert U M W a t

S ed it w m L

s e et N D f t f

p rl at hb f t D

c ro rt p i c t D

c rn a p c i f

c oo nat C H

o uw t r t w

d i s i lR ot d t

l ot p o ot c p

T a tt o t

c ix pL i“ G


14/32

. .

O UI N T E R

1

e t o ki m p e npt D e m o

o o

t he m o c ra ro o sc c ui n

o s i te t w wx ta c tr i

ip e ne p r e s e iu s it l e i

e p r e s e huo r g aa bo

e au n c t is u p rr bt c o n f

w eh en t a g o na c th p ab e t

h en t a g o no co ri tn a tp r

i no l i to w aee r rs u c

e r f o rhu n c t

o s ia nio mo a

s s aer e s u lt p r e sx e

p it h ep p oai a m e a

h ee l a tt r e no da p i te a co t

ho r k rt e f e nt t r

mt ho n s e r vit o n v ed r

ho r kw

ok eh e

ha nh i

R e

f r he m o co o sa n

f o rn ivd eu p

p o l i tr g a n i

t R e

f t he m o ci ct p a

l e c t iw rt S A p

9 3“ T hr ed ed i

t hr a lab u rl i

N nt he p u ba tu p p

o re r ct hl e c t. . i h a g e no l

ox i s t ei b t r a dc a p

oi r ene p e no l ie p r e st

l ao uo c iis e a sc tu

io r mn d e r s hr aab w a i

t hi n go ph he an i t s p

i gir e iet hc r e pa o

o rn er iig ae p u ba p o

im ar e i oo w

S i h aob eh at b a n kt

ee a he p u b la ro u1 9b e

s t r e n g tt he a chc a n dw

hr e s i d ew ir o bn oec o

ro n g r hoi ke p u ba n d

D e wm e g a pc o n s ep i

nc o n s c i e na r e et te vt m c

e hie v e r t hi a s t ro n t

o hr e s i dnt ae x c eh ae l

i os p e c iii s r ut e m oa

T f R o

T hi t tt r u gi te m o cat

a R e p u b li c tr oa g i t

h ie oo o s ed e f iA m eo l

c c o rh ia l ao o sl

oo g e thi v el e mi tD e m o

nn si c te m o cvh

D e w ht r o nt R e p ua

h er g u ma ro n v it p o l

t hr i n ct an t e rbi

hr o fo f f im ou p p ot t h i r

m o vf s c ohB H o

N J eK eC h

F p oo ni c R

a le x pd et l t n

t t p r r

T m s os tt t t h

e v ot w a rt p

f ea na t w w t g t w q

t h o rw irT c i

d e ct A mc d

a m ei e i t w i e t

s t rg b e“ I “

t e r v ee nq c t

p a ii l ea n r ef

D eh

pre convention

ps s

p t f rod h

t s e

T c h aR o oc

t a lt p eJ C ro D

D uo e eb “ w r

g i fa rt rD

o C a ph ot d

l t 1 D e aC w

a p pR oA mC

U rb e ld

c ls yt U S w t A

P oi i ns t t l

C r ob c hh j b a b

B ar f S eN J H r

n f G oH w

b C h det N i R

c a bi a p e it f i t D

c ra roC

P r es t s uh o t

n a

F i np eb i R

w oa nt r er

a t d et N D H w t p

t W D t i e V v ieh

f a im o d t b t s o

A m ea pi h o n L W

W id rs ef o h b

A m e id ip s

h h oi nn o h ii i

i t l eer eh w t

c hs uk a h u t c o

e v

F a I nP

W hn R of a t t w

t D e m us o r i

w ha p ot n f y a

p o lu es e ma m

t p r ioi no t r

c lg r aP rp g

t m ae vd a d n o

n a to lAF c

b t hc ep

p a r tl t i n

w i o ra sd ot w


15/32

J u

9

O UN T E

W io o s ew i t hiD e ie v

t ha m a t n t o e

t i tn e v i tn

a n in t u f a L P i t

T h no wa p ac h e cm r u

T i m mo t m it m m

A m e r im p e r io w

s

t m it o

g a n io r kl at hi t up o l ie

s i ot h Ie a dtt h et m o

d y n ae c tt hl as so r l d - h i

n i f i c ae wh rb r iD e m o

l a u nt h ia ra nt as e r iv i

h iae cc o m p rt hs ss o c i a

o t no n s e r vo l i tu t lp r o xt

w a hr e s st ho v e rt t e c h

f i c u l tn v o l

i t g a c lo r

i n ce n

T e x pt A mP i N

Y t F a ri M

a l ai n s t p o

A m od v q i

c h at p rl es o

p att f oa g a i

n a ti o c t c

c a mhi m b

A t ha i hod v ao rt i

g rs f ot p rt U

d u s t rn i rx e ro u n t e r -pe

S tw t o r gt C O i t

l e h ao wn d e p eo l ic t

c t A m op o o

A m e r io r khe ef i g ho l ia

r e sl e

O ng

eL u

1

W H

W t B i

f

P

AU L FR OELI C H, ”

s t au b l ila

d i s c iR ou x eo o h c o

r a d e s - i n oi fet os t

t hr oh i hi r e c. . H k nw on

o ne lo eh en o e tu a lw r

b i o g r a p

T hd i s c ino m r a d e s -R ou

b u r gr eu s so n t e mc o - f ie

p r o v hh e o nt oa m eh a

i t hi s tm a n ku e sa t ur i

c a he r dm ui f ft e p it

g r eo ln t e r n a t ie vl it

G e r ma bo v e m

W d n oe fe rur s to m r a d e

o R o s at hi e n3 b e rht s e

v it hi n ir e mi s a nlr oh

n e x p r e st ha n gm a nc a p

a d e q u ah a r a c t eae r lp p

s uo r mo m r a d e s -R o st d at

S p a r t a k uh eq u a li o g rar o

a nt h eh in t e l luJ aa l

H e i n rr a n du gh a l ht

“ H a nhK ai e b a e

a b u sa b a nn dht r a no n t r

w r eF r o e l io o

P r e c i sh a oh ai at r

r e v o l u t i o nd v ah i nh i sc o

t r a bih io sp i gt h et

G e r m. AS o c iaa raa l

a nar o e la ear e d ua f f o

l ah i co r e oa m o uhm u gc t i

o nt hoe ce r ic c es u p

o t hr i m it a l ie o pro ld e f

o t he go v e rn d e rt a

1

R L G T

ByPaulFroelch.EditionsNou-

vellesInternationeles.a r i&1989.

a gS pE a r

a c r if is o i s

p a t rf a v B

p e rG em c b n d

a t t v eL uw h

n ot “ q i a c

r a d eh c o

I T a D C B f

L a L

F r oro

s ii n sf h w

s ee v u oR L

b uei t a a i r t t

q u ei mt s i a h

e x aR L u

R t G eW l b h f t b

p a qt o t R p

w h ol t G r v

P F ri n w c i

q u eo o o bc oo

p ut o c oi i s w

F r ot l d m t t d a

v it R ut d o t G (

t i n t ee t d

b eL ut r a t b

i o t r e vw h s t s

a e c iv O w

p i cai L h a r

a “ e x av o t q a h d

o h w rD a “ S F

w aS a

F r oi nL “ u

t ro n c

o t “ s o

L e nr g aot e u w

t f o lth o

“ o L eob 1 d


16/32

a

F C ?N T E Rune 1940

B l a n qa n g oa m ua

o l u n th in a t uu ii s c

nc o n f r oo n ci t u a t

W hu n m i s t aa lht p i n ch r

h i he n s hh i l iie ne n i

oa p r a c to l i ta nd e nvt

m p i r i c

i n o s sb lt

n s u r r er hn nh i s t o

h ie n s hr e j uo mt o u

hc t on s u r r ei tn t i c ih e o ro

hp p a ro n t r a d ie s oh i a t y

lh i l i sa s he ni c t ob e c

ih e o r e to n c e p ue sh h o

t ht ha ne s p eb v io ro n c

g r ae f ev e r ys ti h e

L e n a aro n s i dh e o ri

o u t le x a g g e rt c o n t

h ia m p hL eio m m uI n f a i

— w hp p eh re fO c te

ar e c it ht h e ov e

nt hh ia ut v i ct

I t he c oh a pt ha m pex p l

Tx p e r it hi c t oi c t a tt p r

R u s al e aht ha u

bt h iw ha oc c ap o nv

hu e s thb s oe n t r a lt s t r i

t hr o l e tt b ao n d

oi c tv ho u r g eho f e i

u arn oh ob eit

t w hm e an ho n di

. . O n hi s tB o l s hu

h oe r ii tx i s ta t i s f ax p

w abb u ia na i nn oi f f

hri s c ie c et v i c

hr o l e t a r

H t h ng ao r m up lu n m i s

e r he l a t i oe t we a d ep a

ha s sTo l i tt r aa ca r

t ho l i te a d e rt ar e ah r

hc t i vt ha ra w h uc o r ra

h sa sM a r xh e o

B u hc t i vt ha ro oc o u a

l aa v a c uTr o aa suc o

2Theconten t ionha tLen inrev isedhis ow nview sis usu a llyba sedon

prefa cew hichhew rot eor a collectionf hisessa ys,Tw elveYear s,”

1907.Thisprefa cesta tes:1“Theasicmista kef a llt hosew hotoday

emicizega instWha tto Do?’consistsn this,th a ttheytearit com-

telyout of a contextwhichbelongsto a distinctsocialmilieu,a

ifica nd long sinceoutst rippederiodin th e developmentf our. . Whoeverspeaksodayof thefact tha t Iskra (in 1901and

02)exagger a tedheidea of th eorga niza tionf professionalevolu-

nis ts ,an jus t as eas i lyblametheJ apaneseow,a f ter the Russo-

pa nesea r,for exa ggera tin ghest reng thof Rus sia nmilit a rypower ,

ma kingexagg era tedffortsin th est ruggle ga instth ispow er.The

nesewere na tura llyduty-boundo mobilizeaga insta possible

ximumf Russia npower,n orderto a chievevictory.U nfortuna tely,

nyjud e fromtheoutside,wit houteeingha ttheideaof theorgan-

ftiono professiona levolutionistsa s a chieveda completevictory

t

H owever ,bis victoryw ouldha vebeenimpossiblef a t

t t imethisideahadnot beenpushedntotheforeground,f it ha d

beenpreachedo Deoplew host oodlikeobsta clesn its w a Y,P re-

v it he xt p

a t at p c o

S c o nt b s f r f t

L u x et t c ot

p ae at f ot p o a

s u b oi h n c

w l av o le t p

t iot B o O

b 1 9

“ o lv ia

t p a r lr eoa

t M e nc ac t v

n o fw i E A p

t ii w b n m a s m T B

s hn c f t o vt g

a t b e gt p ne t

i w i m po vu t c

t m o t S ob c d n

p r ob ot b o t

C o n ssd e fa b

g eea C o b t

o w iC o nst a W

a P e aeS eb t a

b o u r g e o i s - ds

c a rh olp r

c oh o b iN n

h a iv i

L eip at f p t t

m o vG ec o o

“ c a ot B ot n

p ot S p at y C

p an f o ef u a s T

“ Lr ii t l et C

( Z i aut G p i

t a d vt “ t G

l e a d e‘ eP L a C

Z e t np i t b p

i p u td

T t h eu st g

q u“ v o

u n

o tt s M aF rb w o

c o m pe as

I t p u oe n t h o

t he lt ht o f

e r - Ft m i mi t u

L em e

L uo S

P ro c r i d

e x ia L us

s ew ha t a h b

t

t

t

e p iL ed n c u t a

c o lc a pd n i a w d t

r c o n sh in f t p

A t i n c oc b p b s o

q u oh w rw a b h w l

w hd et e dt p

t d e vi r e vB s d

c ot o t p t a gp

T r s l t t m aa t L

f o r mt t a sr e


17/32

J u 9

O UN T E

--

P

s t a nul ot ho s it M e n sl

( tl o gt he v o l u te n s h1 9

t ht ho v e r ne n s h1 9 1 7 ) —

r e v o l u t

L e ne hat hc r e ap a h

s u b o r d it st hi s tr o coi

h i s t or o ct sc r e ar g a ne v

i ta c t ir o ee m it he f s

j eb o hu x e mdp r or eo

g a n i z a tung ar rw op p

o L e n ii d H ad i s ci m h

g a n i z ao rt h er a n s f os u b o

t t hr o cd e v e l ot o v ea w h o

A i i w ee n hi sc r ep aa

v a c uA i i w ee e nr e c i

i n f l u ee t w ha rh i sr oA

h d i ap o he l a t ia w d i a m e

o p p o st hR ou x e mo r g a n

t ha c tr ~ c r eot r ob t he

w hc h iu n d e r s tt p r om e

M a r xh e n hu b o rh e mt

p r o ch r o hl a b o ra p la ph

u n d e r s t a ne rt i l l u shh o i

a e x a mra t uc i e

T ho wa ta w a t eb t r a n sn

e l e c t r i u ov ee ri t oi c a p

o a c c o m p l ihe ac i e nd u ct r a

a rn d i s p e nt ht as c i e n

t r a in g i n ra t u ro n s td r h

p l ac c o rt hi va to n d ih

b s a io w e va m a he ct h e

e n g i n e ec i e nr an s“ e l e

f o rw a th ir o dl e c t rs h

e n t i ru s t il a u go c o ui i

o t h e r wi ho cr o cw f t hn

o t he ahe nsj ebc o n c

“ o r g a n i zp r o c

hc o u n t eh

c o n c e p t

T S p p

S i nr o e le v a l up o l iia

w h ot h wr eo r ke ab e9

t e nc h ae nir ra thu

b u rw ao m eu r it h e v a lR o

p o l i t ii s tJ a n u’ 9c a t a st

G e r mo v e m

H ix p l a nb ot a rf a n t T

t r u sh e aS p a r tp r i s

w h hf oe f ei n st

L e d e br id o puv i e wp l

j u r i d ie s p o n s ia n 9v

B e r lt hn eha t uuu s t

e vb j e c to r r

o w ea h i s t

p o l i t i cha nl eo m e rv e u

a a n s wc o m p ln a d e

I i o c o urt ha nt r u e r

p a rt he a d e rt o u n t e r - i

c u m s p e cne t e r m ier ot h

w ir eu n n i

us d o ic o u n t e

t i ane r f o ru n cw hb s u

i c b b la j n b a h w

r ur o a p i

T q uW w S pc

i b t p r o

F t i p ra o

w oS p pi t p

e rd t I a b h v e

t oS pc a a i d T

w r i F r o

“ Ruw h t l

C o m an a t t d m

R ah ec u t f t

t rd i ss tc n a

t m s s C oi J 1

w n n ef n i c s c w

t ht B ow t l i a s

s i tJ 1 s ug a d

r ea f a oG C

p a oa sl ee f

f ef r e

A m ah it C

n y a C o hc n a l

C o mA y a o H r

i m pb eob s

O b a ct b o i u n

o i t e mu tt p e

d i si o r a e vr

a u t ht m at m t f

t s u pt B oe

F r oil h l h t c

w hn t s um p p

b t e ne o1 w

“ u n mlv o

T B o lw s uF

a O cp r ot g w

t r e v omt i t a

o a s md et m M

s i tJ ai B t s

t g er c

A po 1 i S P et t

J aw d t B ow i t m

d e m o oe o A i c

t M i rs r o “

t P r ooa w i g

u l to lp rp

t hr o e ht o

t hg o vB oC

s u bt S oo t d ea

c la r e st s “ w t

v i so vw i n“

s o tc oo ro

p et s o t r e

s le ie p o l t a o

a d v eh a

B a vp ip rb h

c hr e v mt m

k ew io hB

e i a c hc o c

l ee nm ot w t

s h et e o t e m o t r

3LeonTrotskY:

H R R

Vol.I, p. 3F


18/32

. . ... . .. .

a

F O UN T E R

1

e bd e l il i vh n ho p

t ht ha na c c o ric o n c

hac o n t r ol e am a

ei ct he v o l ui l e t

heS . Pe a dt e d ey n o

e l i vn ho rt e o t

o nt he v o l una b o r

F r o e ln ir a t ea t u ah al

bx p l a n a o lo ra b o rd e f

T h hi re rt e v o ln e v e r

ih e a nt od e ce f

d u om ut hai s to m mt

r ot t a hhi s

ru n p r e c e di f fi t u a

O c o u rc o u rb or g a nt

rr e at hr o chi o n u

aa t t r i l hi s tt i t ua h

t hu mi nh io n chi e n a

p r a tn d l ei t hve en ea c t

t h a he s se v ee fs cx a m i

ho u o aa o b s t e thfw

e ap r a c ti lio ta b o re c

t h h he s urn p r e c

r o c eb i rhr o c it

ac o n t ihod e s t ri tm u

a a t t ep e r f in o wo b s t e

o if a chp r e c ii s tu np o

F r o e l ill ot r e v oi

he v e r y ti thm p ic l e cl

l oh ei tr ahx pd eM a r

no b j e c t i

C o n d i ta he a cus t hc

aie r t ao d ho me v o i a

l an di r c u m sh i ao b j e

a lr e ve v o l up pc o m p

ih i ll aha ka om p e

t g r o uu r s et hc ir e v ot

h eu ara r rt he r n

T r o u u hi c tm u le n h

a r h nh ior o ea ih o m i

ho l l o wo ua sh fa d e c i

e t we n nu x e mf i h

o l i tt ha n ua ef r r

n no n t r a d i c np o hu e ss

a he c e sh y st r et e x e c

ha sx h a us hh r o lm p r

eO “ d hr ee aha t h e o r

t hl at r uo i un s w

n ni r m nar e ahl t ie r ft

a a r hi s r e gs h io

n ou od e ce a l i shc r i

r e a c n op uh r ud e c

t he r f e ct he at e v o l ur

h ie c al e nl ot e rL e

a ns o l v. .

hea np o su e se v n

g a hoa P h i l i sfh d i s

hd e o l o gp p o s ie t wg re v o

sm e ar a t i o n a l ir oe a p

ig at lap e r s o n at hh a r

i sl ew “ s a o w

e e vo l ui

e nac lp r ep

b ro i t or u n

L uo t

cC

A fac oF

p r e se na p o a h

b i oa gL uw c

n d o up ld m

t h e oa gs u n t

m w “ kw a n o e d

I c o nh r

L u x eha c cm t

f o ls t

i s ie mt a d h 1

a e s

“ A o u uc o h

t ha c c uh a m h

a c tu cu nw i

L u x er gv s o h

b p f oo bc

t a c c uc at h m

t t i w t c ac I

r ef om oo a i

m e et p ra c e

p he vea cr w t

i n vc ap ri t f o

n m ep r oo w f t i

l ao ei t e i h t

h u n dR ah t o

e s ti n to m i t r

o s uf u rr a i

t d ixa c b t

p r om p rm o c

t

I i h t u nF n b a

q u aR oa w i o d

R a gd e ih a

m e nB uf v t t p

h p ar t

N oR p of m

c at u lo p ri i

p r e ot p ra c i o

r e p ra p r o n N

d o ch t s a s ot s o t

m oa t m t p o e

b ep rt p ri

a t p r ot c o i T

b s ua cM s i o t o t

s u as i n a t o t

p xb c o a b s i

p r oas uF t

$ od i fp o t d im o

“ dx cep rt p

g ont p rt c

i n ds put i v o h r

e rt v s p t t “ R

m O B i h d o F

“ i i m po m s w a


19/32

. . . . ... . . ....

u 9

O UN T E R

c a r lu n s a la n dt e s t am a c

f a c tiw a r e huu n m a ra l o

H o w e veh e h ou x ee r

t s ao r ds hw f ro n

hc c u m u lc a p iih o am o

a p io e vo n t ehtw hc a p

i s ro n c eb o uuc o n ts t

e x p r e s

“ Tr a n s f o rs u ra nm o

f ot hs s e nc o nr e r e qc a p i

u m u l a teh oi n e s s el e

a c t ue p r o d u ce t wr o d ur e p r o

t we t a m o r ph e r eet s u r r

d u c hh e d dt hot a s s u

t hu t uoo r r e s pt p u ra c c

l a t i o

mm p h a s i s

F are s i g n hu rm o n e y -t

u l t i moc a p i tc t i op e c iu

t hiM a h uo a rm o n e y

o ni m pc c u m u lw e ahn a e l e

o a c t ue p r o d u c nt or e c T

c u m u l aw e an r o d ua a t h

f o ovi n c r ep r o d ub ei

A g a ioo r m ur of o l F

p u r p oa c c u m u lat s u ran

c o n s ut ha p i t at r a n sna p

f o hu r pp r o g r e sx p ar o d

T hu e s thr i sh eob ut h

s u r pr o dh i ha p i th e mn c o

s u nh i ho r kv e bc o n

s i nh e wo n s u mc o vo m pa

g i va r i aa p ih ed e ma c c

l a tu r pa l rM a uW h o

m o no rp aa c c u mu r

v a l “

B un s ts e e ko l uhb i o g

( f o l l ou k h a aen a mt s u

p l e m e nr e am o ne ga a

o p o s ihu e so b lc o n tl

f o l l o wr et h o u

“ Ie l a tm o na m e dc i r c

m ue ro b s e rr or e p r oa

w h o ls sha p i to cl wa i d i

p o s hm om o ne q ui p r oc i

c u l a te la bc r eu b s ti W h

m ue x p l a io w eg ro c

e x c h aa lo rr ec o ne eha p

i su r pa le fc a c c u m u a

t h r o ho noa nl eo c o n s

t i ooM ai m saa n oc c a o

e o t h nii vip r o g r ex p

r e p r o d u ct ht hio s s ix t

m o n ei no ni t sn a e l ea c

r e p r o d u c t

I B u k h a h aec q u ait h

q u o t a t ic c uR ot r a n s f“ n oa

t a l inm e d io n e y -u s u n

P u s h k ig r en i g

t b ea“ m

c a p i t a lh h oa f ol t oo

4RosaLuxemburg: A K P. 115.

5Op.

Cit.

. 127.

a R L u r r

f a id e i

R d n a a d t c

“ f at f e x

m ew i i t e c r

t ha nh a a o R L

c r iu nt a d

i t c o nt M o p

l e x pe pt e o t s v

o C aa c cc f c a

w hs ow a c i t c

s u mt w ow a t c p

s iii ms o p c

I t m aw h s

d i sB uo t a a

i h y p op oa s

w h hn c r

T oeu h i i p

c a pt g ro s

m at ai m s s

t d yt p rc o

u e rxp

i l i pi o t e t p c

I R T o t B

o H I o t P

I h g i t q ut t o a

t b eD c oi h a

e n tS p oR L t C

s co L et d R L

i n ao nt t o t p f

t ha c cp r o t c

t L u x“

“ m e co c a

A a g ut p o t e i

p rh b s e xh t h w

w a c o ns s it p

s t rgm pj a i h A

d e sa t t o t s c

b ot s o ri a a

f at b nf o

W C o eh c r R

t ha c cq p t

e ft n a b

t c a pa a w o I a a

t i o v e rd a

t p o lc a pa t p

d p r hf a w o I d

n a pe c ol o w t c

a w a t w os u M

c o nt e c es a a

t ui rp ri

a lem m h m r h

a bs u bc oa p o L

w hi c oa b t c

p e r sos “ a f a w o

i o rr ee pa p r

i s cp a b

6N. B u kh a rin“ I t nper ia lism u.snd A K

t

P . 21.

7Bukharin:Op .

C

P . 8 4 .

8 E W 16.

9RosaLuxemburg:G W Vol.VI.,P.479.


20/32

a

F O UN T E R

1

W ho m re ta i n hh ia

e au r n ir oh ia no b sa n

n t h ho l lc a p i tot al

t hc o n oe nhm p o s sr e t

ha p i t ar o cc i r c ut h e ri

r e a l iu r pa lc a na l

i it ho n t ru ri sp r e s

ie x a ma t r e m eo l lt c a p i

c i r c u l ooa ro w o

t ho ut 9 2 9r io r

2 p eei o lt c o n j u

e n a oi nhe c op p r eu

o s s i br e a l iu ra os e

b d o iw ei t hht o aw o

r a1 9m o u6 b i lo l le t 9

n9f e2 b i l lhl mn e -i

f o r ma lc c u m u lr o g r ex p a

e cm p o soa

s e v ee c ag hp r e cw s p

t hs td e c l ne cc a p i tf i

o r a at se x p r et het

r e so r ai k e wx ca f g r ee g

I i p r e c ie c at m p o s sr e a l

l i m ic c u m uu r pat i m p o s

w o ra p i t as o c ia w hp li t p r

c ep r o d u ch ht r umc a p i

t a kt hoa p e r mow h i

r e v o l uo on t e r v eet d e c

o uh oi v i l i zi n c l ua t uo a

t a l iw e l

C o m re to m p lhm a r t T e

m ae i no l s h e v id n od e

c o r ro n c l u s il ute l l st

d i f f e r ee t we nou x er e

b e c af a id e dn a d eo n ct

t a st ha rrh ea c c u m u

h on c o n s e q uhm g l e re

a m pt h e as sE n ec o n n

w i hi x t ii r tC o mr o n

p u b l i sl e n gi o g r ar td e v u

c o r r e cho iv i hr oh c o n c

o t hu i l dt ha re f9 1 7 —s i

10New I nebr ua r y1939.

I t t o R L u xt

t ht p e et o h

w hd e gw b

b e vh ew C P s o

p r e sed i L a

T r ef t “ t “ w

s pT rt p

O t c o rs a f M

i p r eh t t i h c

B o ll m m s t i w p

c id i nt e t c p

c a c ch p rt c

c a t aeL

r e fat G s d a

i l loa o t w t

c o nt r eR “ o

l a et “ o pJ t c

i t rw p ro pt q

“ o ret M o r

t id t hc ot u

p o sa c c u m u l

k B ai

t hixt c o o

a r e f

R L a t

F I n

T c o nm o e a t s o

t o p pea L

t ef a c o v t r

e v ec o nh

l a cie “

i “ b u rB “

c e po t o h w m n e

o c r iL ut p w w “

o t c ht b at p w

w d h p r od t w b g

d it t e pL ub t

s ex ch w s a d t

a c a rL uh l a t

h e rF n t

c u s

T P a tR e

J P

R

ECENTLY

h a ee a oo pc c

o t hc i e n tot i oi cu n

I i e x t r en t e r ef o lha t

u n r e l e nu r st hig eh ui s

t hb s ce ro r kt an kt

v i c t ihi n ar a ch ob r o h

t v ir i g ga g l l nm i c r

T h u nf tn o ti c rt u b e r

s y p h ii p h t h nte v a si c k e

i d e n t inh eia bx p onf h

c o u hu rp r e s c r

I m w e e k -e a da l t e rot c h

t

T M i u

I r f p

a i n sa e xs o t l

e f fn u uM w

r i lt l o d B r

h o wrc lt s h

t s th a at h o

t r e v om os o m

b g u gnf i t c

s o co bt n o w i s a d

b i e n se w p t

i f ra t d ei t r

t i op o w t i t c


21/32

J 7 9

O UN T E

d e m o c rm p e r in u“ r e c o n

c i a l na r xuh ht n a

m o r a lnr ue ro cy so ul i

T hp e r a tt h ey p o c ro r a l i t

s es p re s s ie m o r at w o

e ro v e m ri n t eu i t s at h

m a l i g ni s ee ri n t ep e

w as a f e g hu be a

T he ag oc a p i to ne o

l i g h t en d i v it o u rlf o r

i n e v i to w n nd e nh e m sip r

t a r it r u goo c i aa lt ti s i

p e c u lp e cs u p p o rx - s o ce x - r

— d e s e rr ho r ko v e m ea

c oo n v ea f a n a te lt i n d e s t r

o t ha p i t ao rr dd e v e r h

c as h if r he v o l ult p r

t a r ir e ce aa r aif e vd v

c a p i t ae ch en o mo n v ea

c r e a nu l t i pa r t i cmc a

l o w et ho r ko v ev e r wt

v i o lo co n v u lhh a r ae p

n of en t e l l eny m p ai

w o r k eo v e m nv oi f o e

s e n t a t ia ee iia p i ta

i n s ipo m m u n it o t hi s th

v i s c ei s t u r b or o cp r oh o

t h et r a n sh ee r se m o r a

i n‘ ( wl i f o ha s

T h ai s c o vt o t e x p l

b a n k ra p i t aa n o a hr e v o

a rt r u goo c i an oh io o

t i ts s e n t nt r ii y p o cr e t

a no r a l ia p o rht e sa o t h

i n c u dhn c o nen t e lot

1 e g ir e n e g he p ex - c o me n

G i t l

T hi g oo c i aa h ai gt hn

t hi rd e s t ohbe shr a

s e a roo v ed i s cs a n y e

f oh eh e o rh ro t

a

w a r m ea

o t h le v i s i nt a n d ao u rr i t

m i xi ho n c e pt r e - Mt o

w he d uh eo c i a lc h roo n

a t i oi v o rr her oh i s te v

m e nf oh ec t ie o - r eot

f o o t s tt h ea s to c i a l -1 9

T h es y c h o l oo t i vt s ai n e x p

c o n f i dt hu r a bc a p i thi c r

i ne v ee a nd i s bt p ot m a

e w h h ra t h eho rc o lf f

B u hm e ro u la vd e m oa

t a l iri f f ero c i a l - d1 9

t we s p ei r ha te oe c ha

e f o hn tt h eo v e rnw b e

t hu s ht h eu p pr a i1 9d

l i b e r ar e p aa d v as u ms u b

a nr u ex p l oi l lt m ar o de

t hn e m p l ohh a r e c rt N e g

p o uh el ot ha t t l ed e fA m

i ce m o c rht o l ie aa t h

m o r

u lt

l t s oa1 r em o

i z at w ot i p h h

b u hir1 r

n ot h em t s

a t hoi i nt f t

c oc ra s o r c

o t f d et r h

T a a i sne o o t

c o nd i s it p

a i m pua c oa k

o e l ax ph i c t p O

e o t r b ec a w

w hc t l o m t o

l ih ew a t

d i s a pr et t w

m i n ti mt w W

a wt s hf t n o

j u s tp pa u o

s cs t s b s

t hh r e at b t

d e sg e e xt m

b t r o nt t h n c

t s o cuh un s f

s t ra c

I st w oo c

t i oct r m b s

t o nl ot o a s o a

t ar a nl ob

f e o tf o rt h o i

k nt “ L et f

t p r ai o t “

e vo nw t b k a “ J

E o t e p“ r

a r e ac oh d

s is yt v

o t d it a a u t t s z

A fd if r t t i

w o f h ut c aT c

p rws oa

a r ta a

y ip rm b o s d

e m d e vca c

v oo c oa r c

i t ui l r e sh b

t o t at s o ea

a t r am iu d

C a pI d c i n p

s e cd e p m

d e mr e v vc

b u i ep M r

u n a sss e

e x p

C a pl a b a a t

y eT f W g v n o

f t c o m t t m d a t

m i o at w c n

i ti i n ct s p a t

o t G eob i t v

t o c a pi a ue

a f aa a ut t


22/32

O UN T E R

1

a p i t a lhr o l oir t i fn

l i pna s c nhl u ns e

o ra he v i s i oe f o ra s h

e vir e p e ah hoe v o ln v i

e n nr o tf t hm a t e r

nm a gh he fM a rh e

ho n v e n iv e r he r vhr e f o

t he ro c i aao v e

e rG e r ma p i t a nhe hm e

ha hh eo re re m ot

z hoe a c t ii l io rd rd

o r k ee v o l ut lt h o u

teo n

hi ro r a n tf t er o de v

i oR u s snu n ge v o l ui t u

nt a nm i gp st l a

h r o u g hn to rt t d e c

i n he f et he re v o lht

e v o l u t ip h eC h iB r i e

rt r i he v o l uS pg r a

t r ih ii g n ar e v o l ui t u

r a nh e ael ar e v o l ui

i ot haw e n t ye ah eL e

ha ro m i nr ob i n f i noe a l

h ht hk e p te s s ir a ia

e ab e l ia n y tx cot m a

ah ee s tnh ear e s

o rs o c i ai na p i tol oc a p

u r vi t we s o ui ras u p

rr o v it he f o re v i s it l a

hn on d e rha p i th i s

o o mnn oe l it c a pt

a c c o m ph ei s ti s s

h in oa r xe v i sc o

u to rn elu n d a m

a ot hn t e r n aao v et s o c

ht a l ie t rr o v oe

e s ue c aw abe x pt r e m

t hu s se v o lia d v

h ar oio c i a l - di p e

w in a r c h o - S y ne c e p t

am i go we m o r a

ha n g ua bo v et ho

a d e g e n er a i tu r e a

t haa w o r kt hy m b

hu s se v o l ut him i l lm i l

h r o u g ho rn ih i s

l hoe s t r u ce cw n u n

np ae c ad n d et s

l i nt he r va l lo r

p o l i tnh et a l in t r oo t e

i m po v ha g gt e f or

s o c i a l - d e mvm e ti n v

t a lno r r od ai n t e nn

he t ht ho u r goi r e f

sg e nt ht r ug a ir o l ei s r

na l s i f i ch es tt r

hu l il a n tg e ns o co uc l

o u oii t hht an

he w s p ia t is i mo

v h rl y i nd a pt h p u r pr

u a ge v pK h

g aM e ns e vt p

t t hh a rL a T a t

m e rgt K am o r

i t n o s oa S

s ih ad et g b

n etr ioo c a d

o a o d e cip t a u

p r e ce

T s ot r eS f

m e ns a t o s o c

s t hs i i nt i

t et g p s o t

p o lS t al i dt o a

t o te n

t ex o t

s t rd u rw c aa l o

c o nt w eo t f

m o ta b on

d eh e gw p a

t t t b ac ae

i r e v oio c a

I i a i ri rr S

i nb i n sl w s o i

o p pa p oa c p o v

i o t s l t o t S ti S

i ni n ca t a f i t t

p op ha ra p rt p

t a hn b en f u

f o S t aet w

o t w or e c ot e h

i b ea f i cot S U T

p r o fn t iea a

C o mt m aA t n o a

f i ce mc e t a h w

w hc g a j o s a d i

w hc f a r t s f f t

e l e

A o p p or e n ea

i n i o rs o t p o t

p r e sb d b T f t r

A m ea pc t i o t

w oyc ai t i i a

p p o i d e vh a e i

d ed et a l p

t aa w t t r o s r

o rs i t s ib i

t hd oea nd

R e nn a d oa n i i i a d

T r e c or eM c t

t a d vo nd n s t

T n p rs ut s

g M a at m i a p

t o r gm ol a a o c

T hu nnt h o i s t s

s k et r t w a

u n dm o

I o rs t ha h t

c hrt w w t d a o

c a p ia d ok t r t

t s o cut i r er g


23/32

.. . . .. . .. _ . .

J u 9

O UN T E

o t hc i e n to c i aM aE n gt p r

o np as o t p

t a r ia n g ut hn o w lhd o wt

t ad eM a a a

c a p i t ar d n hi c tt p r o l ea loc r em p r

h i s t o r ie c e s nn e v ii t a s s hu ta t a

t hi s t or o co rn c e at s it

T b s l mo r

p r o l e t ae v o l uh iit c o n sor as oa t m a t p

m et ho r ka n go n f im o ria o d i sna

T hi s c iM ais o c ia a

i t s pe mo B t

u t o pc hut he a l ia h i se cl a l apt a f

— it hl oe x p e ra l rh

c i am a h h t d s

n e vo u hu t u heh ep e rot p o r ei t p

i t hat e m p oe t - bd e fM a r

i bat p mj

d o c t rt hr e ar e at p r o l er e

n e cb tt T s

b e c as h o haa rf t w o r

i n fht a t

m o v e mhi l ih eau pq u

p is c ed

a ne a l io n f i dra a rs t rg a

et w t f t T r

M a r x ioo hve rnu n d e

m o vg i h b t s m

“ S c i

u

J

u

P O N R EJ EC TI N G

h

osition

o t F o un t

t i ot hl aa tt S o vt u

h aa s sh e tw i lo n oa g e n

o f f e n sg a i heo u n dM a r u

a o f f e nu f fr gB u rh

a r t iS c i ent yr o p“ m o d

w i h i“ s c i e

I i n oil e ahn d ei s c

t hr t i che p u gh uo v e

o r dr e ts oe p lb o r e d ol

t u d eh evm ai mn i m p i

a g hr t io n to thn b e a

a g a ng aa l he c kM a rr o

s i o n nm a t e hoa c kr g u

m o o uo m p a rh ahs c

t e rh r o u g hm aoe w sv

a s s e m be nr e s et l a to n

s c i ea m im a n c irs u p e ri

t r hh a o eap r ef t a t

a lh ei ls enhr i nar g

s th o nn o er et hi r e s i

v u l g a rno n cm is t roh y p o

B u r ne c l on s th a t g a

T r o t sh a ec r u p uap r e s e

y oe n tr g u m

hs c r ua i rw

s h a er e s e na haat hh p r

c e s s o rt r oe s e mn s c r un f a

O nt hi rr o p o shd o c

t r i b uT r o tt ho l l oFi a l

t e r i a lf o Z Zha ro c ip a r t

t ha r xh et ht at r ue x p r

f o l lh ae m p h aB u ri md o

n oil e a he ao ba f f i r

o r dj u s t ht t r i bs ua s s eh

o p p o n eh ei n dt a rha b

s e n t et a k hi tot hi r a h

A f o hp r on n o ui ur a n d i

G

b B u“ Er

m w e a“ s

p et

p t o

p t

I t ra p rf t t s

t l eM aM d “ f

f l om e tra t h

o t f ihh b h w w n

m t a a b xh d

m a tp r

I t w s w t d

s pt i r et e

p u b lt e i o t a a f

a r uB utT j

g r a ts en f

M a ht s f t R

w o rtt w t w d t L O

s ii t i a ns e

p o lo nt U .1

W h p rs t m a r l n

o d o cb o t s o m

w w um s-

s hb c os o c a

l in et f o a p

B t hm aa r e

l t i n t ei m h t r

i h w iv E a o r

p r ew cl t w

w is l vp h w r

n a a f anM t

E nnB uh d o s

a g r t uuo t e

m t s ea p ra w

t D it p ra p o t m

r ec nl p f

w r it G eri t p

n i s ct b o i s a w a

i s c ra uD

Anti-Duhring,a r t I , b eg in n i n gf C h a p terXII I .


24/32

O UN T E R

1

ah a ve dn e c et e

t hx p r o p rrl o g a

t he g a tn gt r or e f

hb s u r ds i mu oa sh a

hr o b

W hou r ne rt hn ca r m

a si b e c aa ni i has ao n

il o g not ha i d e na

ho n c e pM a r xhh o o

ox t ee yv eo rdt d i a l

i t hi a l eh ihn n i hp r e h

il i v ie ih ia ho ut o

o oto t h uc o r

T ho n c el o gc o n s ibo s o

u t sa nrk n o w lrh

o l ln o w lhw hu re

ph eh io c u ms p ebf u n

h ii r e d ua f o rhh o

s c ae p e rro nk n o w

o g alo t h un e g ao oe c

a r r ir i n c ia n d -u re

ho gr a ts e la g ii n s

uo gc o n c e rh io u

D i a l eo gn o hae th l

i vk n o w l ep e n e tn o wta i

e p tc a nix ct hu rd o

ox ix ci ty oo oo t c u r

n e g at s ni t hnf l i m ib s

nt e rr i n c i aro m i nn o w r

hu t s ir e c r et sn c e si “ T o

t h o ue re ie v io ho to

e gne m a r hh i l ife de g

t ho n o tp p l ia t h a

h e sn t i t hy n t ht ha r i h

o t h u ho n c eh hh e m

p a s se y oe gvp

i vs p e c i f ie t e rh a rt c o

nt hy n t hno fy s

o re x p r eep r o fa t e ro n c

hi a l en oe d u ca f i s o a h

b n o nt hei f f i ci s y s

F aro l dt snf om p r

f rx p r ei ms uf o

a tod e v e lo n d ii

ho n c e ps o m eu ta p r

k n o w lp r e c ic h o l a si m os s

u r na nri m r ho n c

nq u et hoe co d ei t t hu

a d iht u rha d v oe p le

R u s s n hi a l es y m bo g

S y m b oo gt he n eaa c o l l

o rh iae v e la rie o t

i rh it ha

e n t

I s h an d i ce ne no n c lt h

i t hn t end e t ae c hn a

h ah ao zpo zq u o t

r he r mn g l o -F r ea t h

i a no g i ce g i nrm i dt l a

f ou r ni md oo td

s c rt ep rv f

b p uu bd

T a rt m of t m p

m a t hs e m ie f

t ut u o s ynt o a

i o rr ec t h

r e l ad e nt s

a c ca f f i o t d

t p o si n o t

l o an op t t e

d e eem at o t

d e da cl o f l a

t c o net n o axioms w

s et p d ei w p

c ac o n oa e xo

i t e na tr a g r i c

f i tnt r t r o l i l

A t g ra t hnw a a

d is yo t p a m

t e ci t o d n b

v e ss yI s h

t h d e fcr o e i t

f is f a

m

i c or

c o nr ei t o s

I w e nf o l s c

p l et r o s yb c

r e t r

A t l ot s f t t “

d a mt hw w c n m

d ew c j o o o s ’ p

c ii d ec o no t e m

d a ds yd n h a d

u hr ie m p t c

O fa i s ic o d

a a l gyt d e i t

s yi o i o t p u t l “

( R uW hp a p h

b or e aa c oi c

p at o a H c b s m

r e Bn r i f i i n h

o fa dp w H a t b

n t s eo h G L (

L oxf r e

l it o nt t o f p

t hm s c in f f

i s mt e t v o P

M a t h

O t t f uo t a a

m ig og n b t d

t e rhpw h a a

f ot n o t -o f

T o b jl o at b d i

e ne ne st a f

w t u nrt S

f itea v f or

a fe xs et s w a t

c o m bep e i n

B i a t p o sn e e f

A.smallunort hodoxurren tdurin g hesela st yea rshas syst em

a llyd evelopedher ejectionof th eprin ciplef t heexclud edmd dle

reserve or lat erexa mina tionhis tend encyw hichBur nha mdoes

mention.


25/32

J u 9

O UN T E R

t f ip i g e o nt hm me xp o s s i b

I n s ot h o uu r n ie a ir o

& r u cu t s nn d e p ei s y m o

p e aa v a ch oc o n s

i n c r et ho wr e aa b a si

h u m i l i au s s ec i ec o m b i np a r t

h av ie n d eu mn t eb s os e

e v e r y to n c e ro ga t h e me u

s en o to g i ct hayt ae v o

s t r u ck ip i aq u iiw e n e

w h il a s s ie l e ne j ev a ro m

t i ot e r ni n an d in o t - c o n

p r o p o s i ti n e c e sa h he o - s c

c ie at hp p oi r e r ht d e

o p m eh u mh o uc i of oa

i ns y sp r e v is t a bo m p a

K f i o w la c t i nt r up a so n t

t i o up a s s i oi s c oe ta n a t

T h uh e ae c lnc o n t ia

a n s wil u r a ni s c o n ths a

p l u r a lr e p lin in o w oa d v

e x c et hn c e ai a l eh o un si i

p e n e t r an v e n tnx t e np ps s e

a c t io v e m ng oe yt si i n

w ie d u ct he g r au t o ma s y

t a b u l aa b ne v e

T hd el o g il g er e q ul ar e v

t i o n ih r ou r ln a tpr i s

l o g iuv eh er o gq ue l ar

t o t lo go n s it hl a s s i fa c e r u

b et ho rt h o ux ah c a t a o

h u n d rb i rc c o re x t eb s e r

f oy m b oo gs t arf p r i nd

d u cr h l ho t - c o n to m b i

B uh o oem uu r thG e

m a t h e m a t ii l be d i s cfr da l

t i o hi f to rt hy l lhr i s

a l r en u m e rh r old ot

t h rr i n c id e p a ry m boe mp a

o f o r mo g hoe v et m oy s t

i i t r u ua t, 3e fr i s

A i l l u s t ri o r dc o n sp r o

t i oA r i s t o to gb r iie gw e

d e f io r hy l l ot i m po s o

s t r u c tih rr i cr iu x ta

t h iy it ot h eve rx a

r e a s o ne x t et e p e tt hl e m

a r r a n g ee x a c haa m ar

w a lr i s t oo ga c a tt v a ro s

w h ip pt hu miy m bo a

u pt s ed i f f ea shd e d ur e a

a l hr r a n g eo s sa g i hb r

t he ng oe yr i s to gi r e t

b r i c k wi th re l a tht t hf u

m e n ta wt h o ui a lb ar i c

a no l l ho v ea l i ve ad o

t ai to id e p a rf om pP r i

m u ou n d a mr o p em a tur

s i s t a nl a s t io h e sp a s ss h h

f o n hi m e nt r ih e mi

t han a l ye t e rt hs s er o p

e xH e mt “ l

f o oec ei t d

t h o

F oa a t l o d c

f i ai m pm d n t b d

p a r tt b es l a v

f t i m mdistinct a m

s c i na d

d e vi o t T H

d i at t u t l e

p r ei w t n o H w b p

i t a ns co m o w

b f o ryi s y

i l oi r bt s b i

m o bt a bi c

m ac o nt r o p w

d i at w i h b t f s

t i vr oi l m s f

H e go t c o i m a

t d eB ep rc t t

i d eec o H l

w a o f ft F e w

l d i an h e

W h e xp rs l a

o ow u a

n o va t o q ul

r eu f

T c r iB uo t d

i nn i i t f e w o m

h a bio t e u t c o

r e nM a t s p

B u td t f ra

t it d et a

r e jt d in i a w a

v a lt r e v eM T

h i ns ut t t f t t S

i aet d i t f

o p h ii t i d S w

B o li n l s ur

t np oS tr

t at d i ei h t m f

o B o li r h s i

m e roo f t j ua t

c rB ua g P o

w o td et s r

t N o hf a t t B

p a ru rg e

p h ra d oi r

p oi s ha s u pf c

i i a a c n a a c w e i c

t a c o

I h f oo r

i n nw h p rs t d

t c rM ag a K

— i t s ai t p he

S t h r er i p

B u rm m t m “

t d i yT c i n a

m article,

“TheAlgebraof Revolution,”n th eM a y i

F I


26/32

O UN T E R

1

c l e ae v ew e l l -ao o

t in i l lt f B

p o wve t t y - b oh ohi

p o ss c iw i a d n f

a en at o un si c o

a

1

S of rat W

S

H E B E G INNINGof t he .seccmd World w a r ra ises a

n u mb er of i mp Or t a n t q u es t icm s f Or r ev ol ut i on is t s in

S ou t h Af ri ca , w h er e t h e ov er w h el mi ng m a jor it y of t h e

r ker s a r e col on ia l s la v es , d ep ri ve d of ci vi c a n d p ol it i ca l

g ht s . Th e r ev ol ut i on a r y t m t ~ s t h a t a r e s ui t a bl e for E u r o-

ea n count ries or for Nort h America ca nnot be a pplied

ch an ica lly t o S out h Afr ica , but m ust be m odified a nd

p tedto th e p r es en t l ev el of p ol it i ca l con s ci ou s n es s o f th e

s a n d th e ci rcu m sta n c es of th e ir da i ly l iv es .

S ou t h Afr ica h a s, in com mon w it h ot h er m em ber s of t h e

t ish C om mon w ea lt h of N a tion s, d ecla r ed w a r on G er -

a ny, but so fa r t he w ar ha s been economic ra ther t ha n

lit a r y. Th e h a r bou rs of t h e D om in ion a r e clos ed t o G e r-

a n sh ippin g a n d a ll t ra de ~ t w een t he t w o coun tr ies h as

een pr oh ibit ed , bu t a s y et n o m ilit a ry d et a ch men ts h a ve

een s en t t o t h e a ct ua l t h ea t er of w a r , Th e m a in r ea s on for

is is t o be fou nd in t he h is tor ic con flict bet w een B r it ish

n a n c eca p it a l a n d th e s em i -f eu da l Du tch a gr i cu ltu r a l com -

n h y, a con fl ict w h ich , i ns t ea d of g r a du a ll y d is a pp ea r i ng

t h t he la pse of t im e, a s B r it ish liber als h oped it w ou ld

n t h ey pa s sed t h e S ou t h Afr ica Act in 1909,

h b e

i ta r e st r oo n t r a

c a p i t a lhu t bw h e ro

h io p u l ai v ina m pf a

t h at hiB r i tt o t

f a v on e u t r ao s to wr ie n e

e r m aw anp r o m hS o

o l d ih os eb rhma b

o b t ap a r l i a ma j of a vw a

S u p e r f ih i ni gt e mc o n h

he v o l u t ia reo nt si h

o m it aw as p e ci a c a

a t i r ol l oj or ha b s

n j u s t i f i coho n c lvt p r e

s t aa f f ao n t i nha ip r o f

f e c tt ha nw it ut r e v o

a r ie x p lhh a p p et hs h h

t hr of r e ei r e a s oe r h

hr e st aa f f aio n t uB r i

i m p e r i aabp e r sd i vof

d e c lai w ia bd e moo n

s i s t ahb e gb h ar e sl rh

e v i d es u p pt hiC a bi n

b e eL o n o hu r at w ( n u

t g i hr i to v e rou pm b

s u r eni l i tr e p a roo ra

s c aha l t o g en w a r rt t h h

S o uf r ii lp u ra so

I t hx p e c tj u s t ii p r o bhe c

i nf f iio p e on r o lC o l

( n o n - E u r om i xe s ci i c e r h

n a t iia c c et rn ln df o

t uw t s s tt t n

t oS t b a t

t eo t o fe t

n at a t t a i

t E u ri n tm et

t op oa . s w

m o ih e b c t a

B aao e a i t t t

a c cA n oi t t

B av m l a c mc

e na ri ns t

a ri set s i m w

f a“ ro c s h

T a lo “ i ns d t t f

t m an ae

e ve t e di p t m

i i i ni q ui q f t l

a be cpn o p t t f

t uE ue t l

n ah ac h d t t a

b a m m c o et s

r i gc t n c a i

c as u bd il b b t

f at g m t T ra s

t w i v i iii i n s

g et c ht u f

m o

T t rt t B a e t a

n b em p s ob t r

c la fm t t w a t

o p pe xn y f l

s u cf ii w t n a o

w pl e ht s t a

i t o E u nh n f

h o o t Z w a B w s

b a n aa m at a m -

h f o ri w i n S R

t M aa dt c

t J ai 1 a s lw m

w h r oo t l T m c

t h et r ei t c o t

p rf on s “ t

c l air s o t r

o rm t s l t k p

w i t B p ri t u o

r iw oaa w a a o s a

w oi t b ew b f

r f l i bn a w f s m

a b sa “ d e

B i t B e xt f f

t n m t h w n b a b t w

t w n b e xc os t t


27/32

J u 9

O UN T E

d e f e“ h io u nt i oa n a

l a ba t t a aeF r ad a t h e

d i ro h ae n ei g“ c i v

d i e rTu s t or e thli s t i a

i st hi eb a tp p lt c at S o

A f r io r cnw h et s ah

w ia p pt hr e saa t

ill be

c a p

t r ih ei vd e f et o sc o n

xploit t hw a r -

well,

B ui n onh oed t r e n a

r a m m u n i nl ea t rw iut h

w al r en u me m p l ae d

w a gt h ea no r kt g r ohw

h ae d uh er o fh hn l o f

t p av h li s e ra gt hr o

g o w in c r e ao m et c ot w

m o ui g ni g hi e v to u

t is

t ho r k hi

fourth internacional - june 1940 - socialist workers party

Documents