frbs and serendipity matthew bailes swinburne university ......matthew bailes swinburne university...

41
FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski

Upload: others

Post on 07-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes

Swinburne University of Technology

ARC Laureate Fellow

Photo: Fabian Jankowski

Page 2: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

FRB Discovery n  1967: Early Days (Hewish et al. 1968)

¨ Chart recorders and repeated single pulses

n  1974: Filterbanks + Computers (Hulse & Taylor 1975) ¨ FFT allowed large integration times, bandwidths

n  1982: MSPs (Backer et al. 1982) ¨ Finer filters and more computers

n  2006: RRATs (McLaughlin et al. 2006) ¨ Single pulsed “pulsars”

Page 3: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Grote Reber’s Radio Data

Page 4: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Classic Dutch BP diagram B-P Diagram

Millisecond Pulsars

Slow, boring Pulsars

Magnetars

Young Pulsars

Page 5: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Single Pulse Hunting ‒ Nice (1999)

Page 6: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Pulsar Dispersion Measures

Lyne’s rule of thumb DM sin b < ~ 45 pc/cc

Computationally

Limited

Magellanic Clouds

Page 7: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

The RRATs ‒ Mc Laughlin et al. 2006

Fluence – 1-15 Jy-ms Luminosity ~ 10-100 Jy kpc2

Page 8: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Lorimer Burst Discovery (2007)

Motivated by RRATs Manchester et al. (2001) pulsar survey

Page 9: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

2007 Science paper

Page 10: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

The LORIMER BURST (2001 data, published in Lorimer et al. 2007)

Page 11: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Old 1-bit Hardware RFI algorithm Zapped the Lorimer Burst!

Page 12: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Pulsar Dispersion Measures

DM sin b < 45 pc/cc

Page 13: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Doubts:

n Distance of ~300 Mpc? n Brightness ridiculously large (1010 x brighter than RRATs) n  It didn’t repeat (!!!) n No-one else could find one.

¨ ATA Fly’s eye survey, Westerbork, old and new Parkes surveys – all nothing

n Where were all the fainter ones???

Page 14: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Quoting Lorimer et al. (2007)

“Perhaps the most intriguing feature of this burst is its 30-Jy strength. While this has allowed us to make a convincing

case for its extraterrestrial nature, the fact that it is over 100 times our detection threshold makes its uniqueness puzzling.

Often, astronomical sources have a flux distribution that

would naturally lead to many burst detections of lower significance; such events are not observed in our data.”

Page 15: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

And 10 orders of magnitude brighter??

Page 16: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

The “Perytons”: FRB-like events, DM~375?? Burke-Spolaor et al. (2011)

Page 17: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

The “Keane” Burst (2012) n An FRB “in the plane” DM=746 pc/cc.

¨ Possibly galactic event? ¨ Bannister & Madsen(2014) argued against an

extra-galactic event. ¨ Not much scattering?

Page 18: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

HTRU Surveys

n HITRUN Surveys (Keith et al. 2010) n Employed iBOB boards with FPGAs n  1024 x 0.4 MHz channels (340 MHz usable) n  8x frequency resolution, 2-4x time resolution, 2-bit data n Aim was to slice through dispersion

¨ Find MSPs ¨ Higher DM pulsars ¨ Relativistic binaries ¨ Lorimer bursts

Page 19: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Local Interference is ridiculously correlated between beams Beam 1

Beam 2 Beam 3

Kocz developed eigenvector common RFI removal algorithms

Page 20: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Use common RFI to remove it

Raw

Clean

Page 21: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Pulsar Dispersion Measures

DM sin b < 45 pc/cc

Page 22: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Dispersion Smearing with the Andrew Lyne 3 MHz Filterbanks

n For DM = 375, smear was 3.7 milliseconds n For DM = 1000, smear was 10 milliseconds n For DM = 2500, smear was 25 milliseconds

t = 8.3us BMHz

DMpc / cc

nuGHz!

"#

$

%&−3

Page 23: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

HITRUN Regions

Page 24: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Success! Thornton et al. (2013) bursts

Page 25: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

FRB 110220 – the first HTRU FRB n DM = 944 cm-3 pc; W = 5.6 ms n Evidence of scatter broadening n But 49 sigma!!! •  Bright enough to fit the pulse shape as

a fn. of frequency to find dispersion & scattering indices

EMBARGOED – Thornton et al 2013 (in prep)

Page 26: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Thornton FRBs n Required hires

filterbanks n Most would have

been smeared out in old filterbanks

n A new phase space was being explored

n  ”Four-minute mile”

Page 27: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Pulsar Dispersion Measures vs FRB DMs

DM sin b < 40 pc/cc

Page 28: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

The Arecibo Burst! (Spitler et al. 2014) n FRB 121102

¨ DM=557 pc/cc ¨ (BTW 557 ~ 1.5 * 375), b~0.0, l~180

n FRB 110523 DM=623 (Masui et al. 2015) ¨ 42 sigma! Large Rotation Measure? GBT! “local”?

Page 29: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

A GBT Burst! n FRB 110523 DM=623 (Masui et al. 2015)

¨ 42 sigma! Large Rotation Measure? Scattering, RM “perfect”

n FRBs exist at 800 MHz! But are FRBs “relatively local”?

Page 30: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Kulkarni et al. (2014)’s abstract

First, the detection of a single FRB by an interferometer with a kilometer (or longer) baseline will prove that

FRBs are of extraterrestrial origin.

Second, we urge astronomers to pursue observations and understanding of Perytons since they form (at

least) a formidable foreground for the FRBs.

Page 31: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

The Repeating Fast Radio Burst aka “The repeater” (Spitler et al. 2016)

n The Arecibo FRB repeats!

Page 32: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

The repeating Fast Radio Burst (Spitler et al. 2016)

n The Arecibo FRB repeats!!! n Almost certainly a neutron

star – magnetar? ¨ Distance? ¨ Energy? ¨ Scintillation?

n Two classes?

Page 33: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

DM search space n  Lorimer et al. DM = 375 n Burke-Spolaor & Bailes searched Edwards et al. and

Jacoby et al. surveys ¨ Max DM was 600! (missed DM > 600 FRB)

n Real-time FRB Heimdall pipeline (Jameson/Barsdell) ¨ Uses GPUs ¨ DM searched up to 1500 pc/cc ¨ Moved to 2000 pc/cc – soon found DM=1912 pc/cc! ¨ Moved to 3000 pc/cc – soon found DM=2600 pc/cc!

Page 34: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

SUPERB Latest Developments (1) n FRB 151206

¨ DM = 1912 pc/cc!

Page 35: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Latest Developments (3)

n FRB 160102 n DM = 1912 pc/cc!

Page 36: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Manisha Caleb On behalf of UTMOST collaboration

Page 37: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

The “MOTER” Transient Monitor

Page 38: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Pulsar detections

Page 39: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

Molonglo FRBs!!!

Page 40: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early
Page 41: FRBs and Serendipity Matthew Bailes Swinburne University ......Matthew Bailes Swinburne University of Technology ARC Laureate Fellow Photo: Fabian Jankowski FRB Discovery n 1967: Early

FRB Discovery n Required pulsars to be discovered first

¨ Without PSRs, instrumentation incapable of detection

n Data volume so large requires “clever algorithms” to handle it ¨ RFI rejection deleted Lorimer burst, PSR J0437-4715 ¨ DM sin b < 45 ¨ Often blinds us to new discovery space

n PKS MB receiver pivotal in FRB discovery n A proposal to search for FRBs would be rejected by any

sane time assignment committee ¨ “Theoretically impossible”