gcse exam technique

Upload: will-teece

Post on 14-Apr-2018

228 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    1/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    GCSE History

    The Exam Top Tips

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    2/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    What to do before getting to the exam

    REVISE:Sorry, but its true if you fail torevise, you will fail

    Get a revision timetable sorted Read Make notes

    Look, cover, write, check Draw spidergrams and Mind Maps Practice past papers and get some marked! Practice makes perfect! Talk to yourself you dont have to sit in silence to revise Give yourself treats and regular breaks. 20-40 minutes is enough for one

    session, then you should have a drink or an apple or a cake or some lard whatever Record yourself and listen back Test each other, get your parents, friends to test you, test yourself Use the internet simply type in GCSE Medicine revision into google

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    3/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    What should I do in the exam hall?

    Stay calm take deep breaths DONT TALK! Make sure you have all your equipment For goodness sake dont take your mobile in!!!!!!! Read the questions and the sources and read all the information

    that comes with it. Think about how it can help you with yoursources answers PLAN! Failing to plan = planning to fail! How long can you afford to

    spend on each question? Can you do a little plan to your answer? If you are running out of time try to note down everything else you

    were going to say it can get you marks

    USE THE SOURCES!!!!!!!!!! Proof read your answer if you have time. You can add stuff by using

    a little star, but make sure its perfectly clear to the examinerwhere you have added anything extra

    Make notes on the paper if you want to!

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    4/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    What will the papers be like?Paper 1:

    Paper 1 (DEVELOPMENT STUDY WITH THE AMERICAN WEST,1840-95)

    It will look like this: Go to: subject resources/history/DAC Year 11History/Revision/Paper 1

    This Paper is two hours long It will ask you questions on both the American West AND Medicine through

    time You MUST then answer one compulsory question first on the Medicine

    Through Time section, then you have a choice of others, of which you only

    need to answer one. You MUST answer one compulsory question first on the American West,then you have a choice of others, of which you only need to answer one.

    You WILL have some sources to look at to help you with the compulsoryquestions. USE THEM!

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    5/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    What will the papers be like?

    Paper 1:Examples of questions:

    Top Tips for Paper 1: Use the marks available [4] to guide you on how long to

    spend on a question Use the SOURCE and YOUR OWN KNOWLEDGE for thecompulsory questions!!!!

    Be specific use examples to back up your argument. Describe events if you need to, but EXPLAINING your

    answer is more important. ALWAYS answer the actual question! Try to develop, explain and link any points you make

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    6/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    Paper 2: Medicine Through Time sources paper

    This is worth the most marks! You MUST,MUST, MUST use the

    SOURCES wherever possible ANDyour own knowledge when asked to

    Paper 2 looks like this:Go to: Subject resources/history/DAC

    Year 11 History/Revision/Paper 2

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    7/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    Top Tips for Paper 2: Use the Sources! Cross reference sources (especially on the bigger questions) if

    possible to show how they support/oppose each other Use your own knowledge as well especially when you are asked to! Quote from the sources and say which source it is (e.g. it says in

    source F Florence was a) Think about reliability of the sources BUTdont confuse that with

    usefulness JUST BECAUSE A SOURCE ISNT RELIABLE, ITDOESNT MEAN ITS NOT USEFUL!

    Show what you can Infer from the sources This means what youcan work out from the source or what the source is suggesting Examine areas or agreement/disagreement BEFORE writing your

    answer

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    8/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    OK

    Lets get practicing.

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    9/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    Questions that ask you to DESCRIBE(These are Paper 1 style questions)

    Tip - These are easy questions if you have revised thoroughly.

    They simply ask you to recall information you have learned.

    Tip Look for key words in the question to clarify what the examinerwants. Underline them to remind you to stick to the point.

    Tip Take a minute to recall the information needed.

    Tip These questions are only worth 4-6 marks so give theinformation clearly without using too much time

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    10/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    For example:

    Describe the problems facing surgeons in the early 19th century. (6

    marks)

    Read this answer. What would you give it out of 6?

    Remember ALWAYS think about what the examiner is actually asking

    the question for. What do they want to know?

    Surgeons carried out operations using dirty

    instruments or wearing dirty clothes. The rooms

    were not cleaned and germs were everywhere.Operations were done fast as patients were in pain

    and were losing blood.

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    11/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    How many marks did you award? It is onlyworth 2/6 marks. Why?

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

    Surgeons carried out operations using dirty instruments or wearing dirty

    clothes. The rooms were not cleaned and germs were everywhere.

    Operations were done fast as patients were in pain and were losing blood.

    This is only worth 2/6 marks because:

    -There is no priority (the candidate hasnt said what the most important

    problems were)

    -They have not identified the three main problems ofPain, Infection andBleeding

    -The question is not really answeredthis doesnt really describe the

    problems, it merely mentions them.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    12/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    Compare the last answer to this one:

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

    The main problem surgeons faced was their patients

    died and they did not understand why. There were

    no anaesthetics, so patients suffered great pain.

    Surgeons tried to reduce this by working very fastamputations were done in less than 3 minutes. They

    wore dirty coats, did not wash hands and used dirty

    instruments because they did not know that germs

    were responsible for infection. Finally they could notstop patients dying from blood loss but they worked

    fast to tie up the ends of blood vessels.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    13/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    Why is it better?

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

    The main problem surgeons faced was their patients died and they

    did not understand why. There were no anaesthetics, so patients

    suffered great pain. Surgeons tried to reduce this by working very

    fast amputations were done in less than 3 minutes. They wore

    dirty coats, did not wash hands and used dirty instruments because

    they did not know that germs were responsible for infection. Finallythey could not stop patients dying from blood loss but they worked

    fast to tie up the ends of blood vessels.

    It shows prioritisation

    It mentions the problems of pain, infection and bleeding It clearly describes problems rather than listing them

    This is still not the perfect answer, but it is much, much better!

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    14/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    Your turnHave a go at any of these and then ask a friend tomark you

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

    Describe the ways in which Egyptian and Greek medicine were similar. (6 marks)

    Describe an example of war helping a development in medicine. (4 marks)

    Describe briefly the work of Florence Nightingale. (5 marks)

    What provisions for public health were made by civilisations before the time of

    the Roman Empire. (5 marks)

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    15/80

    Hardenhuish School History Department

    Questions that ask you toANALYSE PROGRESS

    For example:Why did William Harveys discovery of the circulation of the blood do so

    little to improve medical treatment in the 17th century. (6 marks)

    Remember, as before, think about why the examiner asked the question. What

    do they want you to show? Now think for 30 seconds what is this answer going to have to include?

    GCSE HistoryThe ExamTop Tips

    Did you get something like this?

    -Show knowledge of Harveys discovery

    - Know why his discovery was not that useful at the time ie: no knowledge

    of blood groups or germ theory etc

    -Example of an advance in one area which didnt lead to immediately in an

    advance in other areas

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    16/80

    Questions that ask you to

    ANALYSE PROGRESS

    William Harvey discovered that blood circulates around the

    body. He found this out by doing experiments and calculations.

    He found that there are valves in the veins to ensure that blood

    can only go in one direction. Before this discovery they thoughtthat blood was made in the liver and burnt up by the body.

    Harvey calculated how much blood passed through the heart

    every hour and realised it must be circulating.

    Level 1 (1-2 marks)

    Why did William Harveys discovery of the circulation of the blood do so little to improvemedical treatment in the 17th century. (6 marks)

    Look at these three answers which follow. Can you work out how and why

    they got their marks?

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    17/80

    Questions that ask you to

    ANALYSE PROGRESS

    William Harvey discovered that blood circulates round the

    body. He also discovered the secondary circulation through

    the lungs. Before this, they believed that blood was made

    and burned up all the time or that there was a way through the

    septum. The discovery had very little effect because they

    believed in the 4 humours and his ideas would not fit into

    their understanding.

    Level 2 (3-4 marks)

    Why did William Harveys discovery of the circulation of the

    blood do so little to improve medical treatment in the 17th

    century. (6 marks)

    William Harvey discovered that blood circulates round the

    body. He also discovered the secondary circulation through

    the lungs. Before this, they believed that blood was made

    and burned up all the time or that there was a way through the

    septum. The discovery had very little effect because they

    believed in the 4 humours and his ideas would not fit into

    their understanding.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    18/80

    Questions that ask you to

    ANALYSE PROGRESS

    William Harveys discovery made a huge difference to

    understanding of anatomy. Many treatments today rely on an

    understanding of the circulation of the blood. However 17th

    century people could not make use of his discoveries. They did

    not know about blood groups so transfusions were not possible.They did not know about germs so could not know that disease

    was circulated in the blood they continued with treatment

    based on the 4 humours. His discovery is an example of an

    advance in one area of medicineanatomythat did not lead to

    an advance in other areas.

    Why did William Harveys discovery of the circulation of the

    blood do so little to improve medical treatment in the 17th

    century. (6 marks)

    William Harveys discovery made a huge difference to

    understanding of anatomy. Many treatments today rely on an

    understanding of the circulation of the blood. However 17th

    century people could not make use of his discoveries. They did

    not know about blood groups so transfusions were not possible.They did not know about germs so could not know that disease

    was circulated in the blood they continued with treatment

    based on the 4 humours. His discovery is an example of an

    advance in one area of medicineanatomythat did not lead to

    an advance in other areas.

    William Harveys discovery made a huge difference to

    understanding of anatomy. Many treatments today rely on an

    understanding of the circulation of the blood. However 17th

    century people could not make use of his discoveries. They did

    not know about blood groups so transfusions were not possible.They did not know about germs so could not know that disease

    was circulated in the blood they continued with treatment

    based on the 4 humours. His discovery is an example of an

    advance in one area of medicineanatomythat did not lead to

    an advance in other areas.

    William Harveys discovery made a huge difference to

    understanding of anatomy. Many treatments today rely on an

    understanding of the circulation of the blood. However 17th

    century people could not make use of his discoveries. They did

    not know about blood groups so transfusions were not possible.They did not know about germs so could not know that disease

    was circulated in the blood they continued with treatment

    based on the 4 humours. His discovery is an example of an

    advance in one area of medicineanatomythat did not lead to

    an advance in other areas. Level 3 (5-6 marks)

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    19/80

    Questions that ask you to

    ANALYSE PROGRESS

    Hippocrates suggested bleeding as a treatment and this wasstill being used in the 18th century. Does this mean that therehad been no progress in understanding the causes and cures of

    disease during this time? Explain your answer. (6 marks)

    Both the Great Plague of 1665 and the cholera of 1831 killed

    large numbers of people in England. Why was there so little

    progress in public health between 1665 and 1831?

    Have a go at these similar questions.

    Remember to think about what the

    examiner wants to see!

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    20/80

    Questions that ask you toANALYSE TURNING POINTS

    Tip - These questions ask you to assess theimportance of a particular event. So you needto know what happened before and whatchanges were possible afterwards.

    Tip These events were important but they wereoften not the only events of significance. Ask

    yourself if there were other important that weremore/equally/ almost as important.

    Tip These questions are often worth a lot of marks

    so make a plan before you start to write.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    21/80

    Questions that ask you toANALYSE TURNING POINTS

    For example: Was the development of anaesthetics a

    turning point in the history of surgery? (12 marks)

    As you read the question, think about what surgery was like

    before and after this event. What other events could claim to

    be important in the development of surgery?

    What information do you need?

    19th century surgery especially anaesthetics

    Important events in the history of surgery from other

    periods.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    22/80

    Questions that ask you toANALYSE TURNING POINTS

    What is the examiner looking for?

    Level 1: Describes discovery of anaesthetics. (1-3 marks)

    Level 2: Agrees with the statement describing surgery before

    anaesthetics. (4-6 marks)

    Level 3: Agrees with the statement but also includes somedescription of what was possible after anaesthetics. (7-9

    marks)

    Level 4: Balanced judgement taking other events (antiseptics

    etc) into account also. (10-12 marks)

    Was the development of anaesthetics a turning point in

    the history of surgery? (12 marks)

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    23/80

    Questions that ask you toANALYSE TURNING POINTS

    Do you agree that the most important turning point intreating illness between 1000BC and the end of theMiddle Ages took place in the time of the Ancient

    Greeks? Explain your answer.. (12 marks)Did the improvements to public health in the second half of the

    nineteenth century mean that there was little more to be done to

    improve public health in the twentieth century? (12 marks)

    This time its your turn.

    Choose one of the questions below and answer it.

    You have about ten minutes!

    Use paper if you like, or open a word file

    Then ask somebody to mark it or mark it yourself now that you know what

    the examiner is after

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    24/80

    Questions that ask you toEXPLAIN

    Tip - The best answers give more than one

    reason.

    TipDont just give a list. Try to link the reasons

    together.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    25/80

    Questions that ask you toEXPLAIN

    Explain why medieval monasteries were able to remainhealthy places while large towns and cities like Londonwere unhealthy? (10 marks)

    Make a list of reasons why monasteries remained healthy

    places in the Middle Ages.

    Now make a list of reasons why towns and cities remained

    unhealthy.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    26/80

    Questions that ask you toEXPLAIN

    Explain why medieval monasteries were able to remainhealthy places while large towns and cities like Londonwere unhealthy? (10 marks)

    List of reasons why monasteries remained healthy places in

    the Middle Ages.

    They held collections of books written by ancient Greeks

    and Romans.

    They believed it was important to remain clean for

    religious reasons.

    They lived in large buildings away from everyone else.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    27/80

    Questions that ask you toEXPLAIN

    Explain why medieval monasteries were able to remainhealthy places while large towns and cities like Londonwere unhealthy? (10 marks)

    List of reasons why towns and cities remained unhealthy.

    They knew nothing about the ideas of Greeks or Romans.

    Some of the things they did were bound to cause disease.

    They did not have a religious reason to encourage them to

    live clean lives.

    They lived in crowded conditions so infections spread

    rapidly.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    28/80

    Questions that ask you toEXPLAIN

    Explain why medieval monasteries were able to remainhealthy places while large towns and cities like Londonwere unhealthy? (10 marks)

    How can we plan an answer around these two lists?

    Plan 1take each of these 3 points and contrast the way

    of life inside and outside the monastery.

    Plan 2 write one large paragraph about the monastery

    life and another about town life.

    Choose one of the 2 plans. Research the detail to go with your

    plan. Then write up the answer.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    29/80

    Questions that ask you toEXPLAIN

    Did religion help or hinder medicine in the Middle

    Ages? (10 marks)

    War has sometimes led to advances in surgery. Choose oneadvance in surgery and show how war helped to bring it about.

    (10 marks)

    Why was there conflict between the Plains Indians and thewhites? (10 marks)

    Have a go at one of the following:

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    30/80

    Questions that ask you to

    UNDERSTAND SOURCES

    Tip - Look for the number of marks on offer. If there

    are only a couple of marks, make a couple of

    quick points and move on.

    Tip If there are several marks, the examiner is

    expecting you to go beyond what you can see or

    read. You are expected to infer information from

    the sources.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    31/80

    Questions that ask you to

    UNDERSTAND SOURCES

    In what ways do sources A and B show agreement in

    their ideas about the causes of illness? (2 marks)

    Source B: The treatment of King

    Charles II in 1685.

    Two of the Kings doctors opened a vein in

    his right arm and drew off about 16 ounces of

    blood. The next day, the doctors considered itnecessary to open both jugular veins and drew

    off about 10 ounces of blood.

    Source A:

    Medieval doctorbleeding a patient.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    32/80

    Questions that ask you to

    UNDERSTAND SOURCESIn what ways do sources A and B show agreement in

    their ideas about the causes of illness? (2 marks)

    How many marks?

    2 so make a couple of quick points and move on.

    Doctors in both periods treated patients by bleeding.

    This was because they both believed in Hippocrates

    Theory of the Four Humours.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    33/80

    Questions that ask you to

    UNDERSTAND SOURCES

    What can you learn from this source

    about Stone Age medicine? (5 marks)

    How many marks?

    5 so what can you infer from the source

    about Stone Age medicine?

    Evidence of surgery?

    Reasonrelease of evil spirits?

    Importance of the brain?

    A prehistoric skull.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    34/80

    Questions that ask you to

    UNDERSTAND SOURCES

    What can you learn about the life and

    work of cowboys from this source? (5

    marks)How many marks?

    5 so what can you infer from the source

    about the life and work of cowboys?

    Some were black. Why?

    Hard-wearing clothes. Why?

    Armed. Why?

    Nat Love, a black

    American cowboy

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    35/80

    Questions that ask you to

    UNDERSTAND SOURCES

    In what ways do these sources contain different ideas

    about the causes of the Black Death? (5 marks)

    Source B: Flagellants whipping

    each other.

    Avoid baths which open the pores of

    the skin because pores are doorways

    through which poisonous air canenter the body. If the plague occurs

    in hot weather, you must eat cold

    things.

    Source A: Book written at the timeof the Black Death, explaining how

    to avoid catching it.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    36/80

    Questions that ask you to

    UNDERSTAND SOURCESIn what ways do these sources contain different ideas

    about the causes of the Black Death? (5 marks)

    How many marks?

    5 so what can you infer from the sources about ideas on the

    cause of the Black Death?

    Source A: avoid hot baths. Why? Eat cold foods in hotweather. Why?

    Source B: whip each other. Why?

    Difference in approach?

    Source A: avoid hot baths. Why? Eat cold foods in hotweather. Why?

    Source B: whip each other. Why?

    Difference in approach?

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    37/80

    Questions that ask you to

    UNDERSTAND SOURCES

    In what ways do these sources contain different ideas

    about the causes of the Black Death? (5 marks)

    What is the examiner looking for?

    Level 1: Describes what the sources say or show. (1

    mark)

    Level 2: Compares the 2 sources but only on the basisof what they show. (2-3 marks)

    Level 3: Compares the 2 sources in terms of what

    they reveal about ideas of the causes of the Black

    Death. (4-5 marks)

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    38/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Tip - Always start with what you can see in the source.

    Tip Then think about the context. What can you

    remember about the topic.

    Tip A good answer combines the information from thesource and the context drawn from your

    knowledge.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    39/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Use this source and your own knowledge to describe how people

    reacted to Jenners discovery of a vaccine for smallpox. (8

    marks)

    The CowpockorThe

    Wonderful Effects of the New

    Inoculation.

    ( a cartoon published by The

    Anti-Vac cine Society in

    1802)

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    40/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Firstwhat does the source tell us?

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    41/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Secondwhat is the context (your own knowledge of the event)?

    Smallpox was a killer disease.

    Jenner discovered a new method of preventing smallpox.

    People did not trust the new method. Why?

    Eventually the government made vaccination compulsory.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    42/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Use this source and your own knowledge to explain how medicalscience and governments worked together to overcomediphtheria.

    (8 marks)

    A graph showing deaths from

    diphtheria, a highly

    infectious disease usually

    attacking children.

    Causal Organism Identified

    Anti-toxin First Used in Treatment

    National Immunisation Campaign Begun

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    43/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Firstwhat does the source

    tell us?

    Causal Organism Identified

    Anti-toxin First Used in Treatment

    National Immunisation

    Campaign Begun

    It is a declining graph BUT

    It rises at the start.

    It falls steeply from c1890. It levels off 19141918.

    It falls again but rises c1940.

    It falls steeply again.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    44/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Secondwhat is the context (your own knowledge of the event)?

    Diphtheria was one of many killer diseases.

    1860 - 1890 Pasteur and Koch showed how germs and disease

    were connected. Disease-causing germs identified.

    1890s Koch discovered many vaccines. Deaths dropped.

    1900s Government played greater part in public health. Death rate

    fell but vaccinations neglected during war.

    1947 National Health Service created and National immunisation

    programmes started. Deaths fell sharply again.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    45/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Level 1: Describes information in the graph (1-2 marks)

    Level 2: Uses source only or knowledge only to explain

    graph. (3-4 marks)

    Level 3: Uses source and knowledge to give simpleexplanation. (5-6 marks)

    Level 4: Uses source and knowledge in full explanation.

    (7-8 marks)

    Use this source and your own knowledge to explain how medicalscience and governments worked together to overcome diphtheria.

    (8 marks)

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    46/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE RELIABILITY OF SOURCES

    Tip - Always start with the NATURE of the source.Some types of source (eg diaries) are often morereliable than others (eg an advertisement). Thenlook at the ORIGIN of the source. Who wrote itand when? Finally decide the PURPOSE of thesource. Why was it produced? Who was theintended audience?

    Tip - Remember that there is no such thing as acompletely reliable source or a completelyunreliable source. The examiner is asking you toshow that you can be aware of the pitfalls of usingsource material.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    47/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE RELIABILITY OF SOURCES

    SOURCE A

    You gentlemen of England can have little idea from reading the

    newspapers of the horror and misery in a military hospital of

    operating on those exhausted, dying men. A London hospital isa garden of flowers compared to it. Let no lady come here who

    is not used to exhaustion and shortages. Even the nuns working

    here complain about the conditions. The poor fellows who are

    brought here have not had a clean shirt or been washed for

    months but we have not a basin, nor a towel, nor a bit of soap

    nor a broom.

    From a letter written by Nightingale to a London surgeon in

    1854, describing conditions at the hospital in Scutari.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    48/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE RELIABILITY OF SOURCES

    Do these two sources provide reliable evidence of how FlorenceNightingale improved conditions at the hospital at Scutari?

    Explain your answer. (8 marks)

    SOURCE B

    A late 19th century

    painting of the wardat the hospital at

    Scutari showing the

    improvements made

    by Nightingale andher nurses.

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    49/80

    Questions that ask you toUNDERSTAND SOURCES IN CONTEXT

    Level 1: Comments on sources, taking them at face value

    OR says they are reliable because they are from

    the time. (1-3 marks)

    Level 2: Uses own knowledge to evaluate the source. (4-6marks)

    Level 3: Evaluates sources using nature, origin, purpose

    and own knowledge. (7-8 marks)

    Do these two sources provide reliable evidence of how FlorenceNightingale improved conditions at the hospital at Scutari? Explainyour answer. (8 marks)

    Q

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    50/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE RELIABILITY OF SOURCES

    Is this source reliable evidence of why homesteaders were able

    to make a success of their farms despite all the problems?. (8

    marks)

    A drawing made in

    the 1860s showinghomesteaders

    gathering pumpkins

    and maize.

    Q i h k

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    51/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Tip - All sources are useful but exam questions askyou whether a source is useful for a particular

    purpose. So your first task is to ask yourself whatit tells you about that purpose.

    Tip - Secondly ask yourself how reliable the source is.Do a NOP test on the source.

    Tip - You need to look at reliability in the context of thepurpose. Just because a source is unreliable,dont dismiss it. A speech by Hitler may be verybiased but if you are asked if it tells you aboutHitlers views, it might be very useful.

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    52/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Now read the 2 sources. For each, jot down notes about:

    What does it tell you about advances in surgery in wartime?

    Is it reliable?

    Remember you are not being asked about usefulness ingeneral. You are asked about usefulness for a particular

    purpose. What purpose?

    Question:

    Which of sources A and B is more useful for finding out

    about advances in surgery in wartime? Explain your choice.

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    53/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    SOURCE A

    Edmonds was placed in the bed next to mine. He had been

    trapped in the aircraft when it turned over and burst into flames.

    He fried for several minutes before they dragged him out.When he was first brought to Archie McIndoe he was

    unrecognisable. Never once did Edwards complain although it

    would take years to build him a new face. Three days after the

    operation to replace his eyelids, I noticed a dribble from under

    the dressings of this eyes. It was the blood-poisoning

    streptococcus germ at work again.

    The Last Enemy by Richard Hilary, a 2nd World War fighter

    pilot who was also treated by McIndoe. Published 1950.

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    54/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    SOURCE B

    The new weapons of the 1st World War caused horrific facial

    injuries. To deal with these, Harold Delf Gillies set up a jaw

    and plastic surgery unit in Aldershot. Shortly after the 2nd

    WorldWar began, Archie McIndoe, consultant in plastic surgery in the

    RAF, founded a unit at the hospital in East Grinstead. The

    Battle of Britain in 1940 brought McIndoe some 4,000 young

    men with new injuries terrible burns to the face and hands

    from the high octane fuel that had caught fire. It often took

    several operations to rebuild a face.

    A History of Medicine by Nancy Dunn, a historian, and Jenny

    Dunn, a doctor. Published 1992.

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    55/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Level 1: Describes what is in the sources. No comparisons.

    (1-3 marks)

    Level 2: Comments on reliability of sources. Bottom of level

    if source rejected. (4-6 marks)Level 3: Uses comments on reliability of the sources to make

    comparisons of usefulness. (7-9 marks)

    Which of sources A and B is more useful for finding outabout advances in surgery in wartime? Explain your choice.

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    56/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Now mark these 3 answers.

    Which of sources A and B is more useful for finding outabout advances in surgery in wartime? Explain your choice.

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    57/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Source A tells us how people were treated for burns by McIndoe. He carried out operations

    to rebuild peoples faces after their planes caught fire after crashing. We learn that not all his

    operations were successful. Source B tells us who did plastic surgery in both wars. We learn

    that there were 4,000 pilots who suffered burns in the Battle of Britain and it took severaloperations to rebuild a damaged face.

    Level 1: Describes what is in the sources. No comparisons. (1-3 marks)

    Level 2: Comments on reliability of sources. Bottom of level if source rejected. (4-6

    marks)

    Level 3: Uses comments on reliability of the sources to make comparisons of usefulness.

    (7-9 marks)

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    58/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Both sources have their uses but both present problems. Source A is not very useful because

    it only describes one patient. Hilary was one ofMcIndoes patients so may be biased in his

    favour. Source B is a secondary source but the authors will have researched the topic. One is

    a historian and one a doctor so between them they are likely to get things right. Source Btells us that plastic surgery began in the 1st World War and gives reasons and figures for the

    2nd World War. It is therefore more useful than source A for finding out about advances in

    surgery in wartime.

    Level 1: Describes what is in the sources. No comparisons. (1-3 marks)

    Level 2: Comments on reliability of sources. Bottom of level if source rejected. (4-6

    marks)

    Level 3: Uses comments on reliability of the sources to make comparisons of usefulness.

    (7-9 marks)

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    59/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Neither of these sources is really much use in telling us about advances in surgery in wartime.

    Source A was written 10 years after the events and the author could have remembered them

    wrongly. It only tells us about one operation. He was bound to feel grateful to a man who

    treated him. Source B was written 50 years later by people who were not there at the time.In finding out about surgery in wartime, they could have made all sorts of mistakes.

    Level 1: Describes what is in the sources. No comparisons. (1-3 marks)

    Level 2: Comments on reliability of sources. Bottom of level if source rejected. (4-6

    marks)

    Level 3: Uses comments on reliability of the sources to make comparisons of usefulness.

    (7-9 marks)

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    60/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Question:

    How useful is this source to an historian studying 19th

    century attitudes to anaesthetics? Explain your answer.

    Now read the source and think about:

    What does it tell you about attitudes to anaesthetics?

    Is it reliable?

    Are you clear about the purpose?

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    61/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    SOURCE A

    In years to come, those who follow us will look back with

    sadness on those doctors today who believe in the need for pain

    in surgical operations. They will marvel at the idea of kind menbelieving that the terrible agonies they inflict should be endured

    and not avoided. It will seem impossible that they would prefer

    to operate on patients while still awake instead of under

    anaesthetic. All pain is destructive and even fatal.

    Extract from a report by Dr James Simpson, December 1847.

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    62/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Have a go at writing an answer. 10 minutes allowed.

    How useful is this source to an historian studying 19th

    century attitudes to anaesthetics? Explain your answer.

    (7 marks).

    Exchange papers and use the mark scheme to mark your

    partners answer.

    Q estions that ask o to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    63/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST THE USEFULNESS OF SOURCES

    Level 1: Takes source at face value for its content. (1-2

    marks)

    Level 2: Comments on reliability, bias etc. (3-4 marks)

    Level 3: Uses comments on reliability to make statements

    about usefulness. (5-7 marks)

    How useful is this source to an historian studying 19th

    century attitudes to anaesthetics? Explain your answer.

    Q ti th t k t

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    64/80

    Questions that ask you toTEST AN INTERPRETATION OF HISTORY

    Tip - You will usually be given a statement about someaspect of the history you have studied. This will

    be in the form of an interpretation of history. It isusually only partly correct so dont be tempted toagree or disagree. Give a balanced view.

    Tip - Write your answer as 2 large paragraphs oneshowing how you agree with the statement andone showing how you would disagree.

    Tip - The examiner will sometimes ask you to drawupon the source(s) and/or your own knowledge toback up your opinion. Make sure you follow the

    instructions..

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    65/80

    Questions that ask you to

    TEST AN INTERPRETATION OF HISTORY

    Question:

    Anaesthetics made complex operations safe and successful.

    Use your knowledge to comment on the accuracy of thisstatement.

    Make a list of points you would make to disagree with thisinterpretation.

    Make a list of points you would make to agree with thisinterpretation.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    66/80

    Questions that ask you to

    TEST AN INTERPRETATION OF HISTORY

    Question:

    Hippocrates made the greatest advances in medicinein the ancient world. Do you agree with thisinterpretation? Explain your answer using the sourcesand your own knowledge.

    Make a list of points you would make to disagree with thisinterpretation.

    Make a list of points you would make to agree with thisinterpretation.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    67/80

    Questions that ask you to

    TEST AN INTERPRETATION OF HISTORY

    Question:

    Religion has done more to help the development ofmedicine than hinderit. Do you agree or disagree withthis statement? Support your answer with reasons andexamples.

    Make a list of points you would make to disagree with thisinterpretation.

    Make a list of points you would make to agree with thisinterpretation.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    68/80

    Questions that ask you to

    TEST AN INTERPRETATION OF HISTORY

    Question:

    War has always resulted in progress being made inmedicine. Do you agree or disagree with thisstatement? Support your answer with reasons andexamples.

    Make a list of points you would make to disagree with thisinterpretation.

    Make a list of points you would make to agree with thisinterpretation.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    69/80

    Questions that ask you to

    TEST AN INTERPRETATION OF HISTORY

    Question:

    Throughout history, medical care has alwaysprogressed. Do you agree or disagree with thisstatement? Support your answer with reasons andexamples.

    Make a list of points you would make to disagree with thisinterpretation.

    Make a list of points you would make to agree with thisinterpretation.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    70/80

    Questions that ask you to

    TEST AN INTERPRETATION OF HISTORY

    Question:

    Railroads were more important than the actions ofgovernments in making it possible for people to move to

    and live on the plains. Do you agree. Use yourknowledge of the period to help you explain youranswer.

    Make a list of points you would make to disagree with thisinterpretation.

    Make a list of points you would make to agree with thisinterpretation.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    71/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 1: Describe:

    Describe [.].

    How did [..].

    .

    Answer:

    Tell the story clearly and simply but check frequently that

    you are answering the question.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    72/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 2: Analysis of progress:

    Why did [] do little to improve the treatment ofillness?

    Why was there so little progress [..]?

    [Two events described]. Does this mean there was littleprogress between the two?

    .Answer:Several paragraphs each giving a reason for the progress orlack of it.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    73/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 3: Analysis of turning points:

    Why was [.] an important turning point in the history ofmedicine?

    Why was [] such an important event in the history ofmedicine?

    .Answer:

    Three paragraphs

    What was the situation before the event?

    What were the changes?

    What was different afterwards?

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    74/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 4: Explain:

    Explain why [.].

    Answer:

    One paragraph for each reason (find several). Plan theanswer so reasons are grouped together in a logical order.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    75/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 5 Comprehension of sources:

    What do the sources tell us about [.].

    Answer:

    One paragraph:

    Say what the source tells you about the given topic.

    Make sure you try to infer things from the source.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    76/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 6 Comprehension of sources in context:

    Use [name of source] and your own knowledge toexplain [..].

    Answer:

    Three large paragraphs:

    Extract information from the source.

    Add your own knowledge.

    Put the 2 together to show how they explain whatever youwere asked to explain.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    77/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 7 Reliability of sources:

    How reliable is [name of source} for [purpose].

    Answer:

    Four large paragraphs:

    Nature of the source.(advantages/drawbacks of diary,book etc.

    Origin of the source (author, date etc). Primary orsecondary material.

    Purpose of the source (intended audience, intentions ofauthor)

    Conclusion.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    78/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 8 Usefulness of sources:

    How useful is [name of source} for [purpose].

    Answer:

    Three large paragraphs:

    What does it tell us about the purpose.Is it reliable?

    Conclusion.

    Questions that ask you to

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    79/80

    Questions that ask you to

    SUMMARY OF QUESTION PATTERNS

    Question type 9 Interpretations:

    [Statement]. Do you agree. Use your knowledge of the

    period to help you explain your answer.

    Answer:

    Three large paragraphs:

    Agreement with the statement.Disagreement with the statement.

    Conclusion.

    GCSE History The Exam Top Tips

  • 7/30/2019 GCSE Exam Technique

    80/80

    GCSE History The Exam Top Tips