gemeinsames unternehmen für biobasierte industriezweige ... · - 2015 bbi calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20...

35
Bio-Based Industries Joint Undertaking (BBI JU) Programme, achievements & Call 2016 Agata PIENIADZ Project Manager BBI JU German Info Day Life Sciences Köln, 1 June 2016 Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Bio-Based Industries

Joint Undertaking (BBI JU)

Programme, achievements & Call 2016

Agata PIENIADZ

Project Manager BBI JU

German Info Day – Life Sciences

Köln, 1 June 2016

Gemeinsames Unternehmen

für biobasierte Industriezweige

Page 2: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

• About BBI JU mission, objectives, exected impact

• Achievements projects, participation statistics

German participation

• Call 2016 budget, topics, timing

Content

Page 3: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

About BBI JU

• Public Private Partnership (PPP) between

European Commission (EC) & Bio-based Industries

Consortium (BIC) supporting R&I for Bio-based

industries

• Budget € 3.7 billion

(27% EU - 73% industry)

• Independent legal entity

since 26 October 2015

• Horizon 2020

rules for participation

• Principles of openness,

transparency & excellence

3 www.bbi-europe.eu

Page 4: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Implement, under Horizon 2020 rules, the Strategic Innovation and Research Agenda (SIRA) developed by the industry

BBI JU programme office team is in charge of:

• Call management

• Proposals evaluation (by independent expert panel)

• Grant Agreement preparation process

• Whole project management life cycle

• Communication, dissemination & stakeholder management

• Support to policies

• Contribution to Annual Work Plan building & SIRA review

BBI JU Mission

Page 5: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BBI JU - Governance

Private partner Represented by BIC

73% of contribution

in BBI JU

Public partner Represented by

EC 27%

contribution in

BBI JU

Advisory bodies

Programme office team : 23

Governing Board (10 seats)

Executive Director

BBI JU

Page 6: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BBI’s overall objectives

Developing sustainable and competitive bio-based

industries in Europe, based on advanced biorefineries

that source their biomass sustainably by:

• Demonstrating new technologies to fill the gap in

value chains;

• Developing business models integrating all economic

actors along the value chain

• Set-up flagship biorefinery plants deploying business

models & technologies to keep investment in EU

COUNCIL REGULATION (EU) No 560/2014

of 6 May 2014 establishing the BBI JU

Page 7: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

• Replace 30% of oil-based chemicals & materials

• Diversify & grow farmers’ revenues

• Create 700,000 jobs – 80% in rural areas

• Reduce EU dependency on import of fossil raw

materials, protein and P - K

• Develop potential of agriculture waste & forestry

residues

• Shift to bio-based products average 50% GHG

emission reduction

Expected impact for Europe by 2030

Page 8: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BBI JU & examples

of complementary programmes

SC 2 Food

Security

SC 5

Climate

Horizon 2020 Industry

KET

Biotech

EIPs (EIP-Agri,…) Other PPP

(SPIRE…)

BBI

JU

Chemistry

Pulp & paper

Agro-food

Other SCs

Other

KETs

JPI (FACCE,…)

KICs / EIT

JRC

Other

industries &

feedstock

suppliers

BBI JU programme: is complementary to other

public and (EU, national), private (industrial) and

private –public programes (JUs, PPPs)

Page 9: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

• About BBI JU mission, objectives, exected impact

• Achievements projects, participation statistics

German participation

• Call 2016 budget, topics, timing

Content

Page 10: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BBI JU Calls Evolution

Our achievements

Call 2014: 10 running projects: 1 Flagship, 2 Demo, 7 RIAs

Call 2015.1: 3 flagship projects (just signed)

Call 2015.2: 23 proposals selected (RIA, DEMO, CSA)

out of 73 submitted. GA Preparation ongoing

Call 2016: publised. Deadline for proposals submission 8-Sept ‘16

1 2 3 7 6 5 4

Call

2014

Call

2015

Call

2016

Call

2020 ……. Call

2017

Page 11: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BBI on-going projects

Calls 2014 + 2015.1

VC RIA

( TRL = 4-5 )

IA-DEMO

( TRL = 6-7 )

IA-Flagship

( TRL = 8 )

VC1

( lignocellulose ) US2GREENCHEM ValChem

BIOSKOH

LIGNOFLAG

VC2

( forest-based )

SmartLi

Greenlight

PROVIDES

- EXILVA

VC3

( agro-based )

Carbosurf

PROMINENT Pulp2Value FIRST2RUN

VC4

( organic waste ) NewFert - -

11

More information on the projects:

BBI JU website, Flyer, your folder, Corda

● ● ●

across

VCs

+ call 2015.2 (●)

● ● ● ● ● ● ●

● ● ● ● ● ●

● ● ● ● 3 CSA ● ● ●

GA not signed yet

Page 12: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BBI on-going projects

Calls 2014 + 2015.1

VC RIA

( TRL = 4-5 )

IA-DEMO

( TRL = 6-7 )

IA-Flagship

( TRL = 8 )

VC1

( lignocellulose ) US2GREENCHEM ValChem

BIOSKOH

LIGNOFLAG

VC2

( forest-based )

SmartLi

Greenlight

PROVIDES

- EXILVA

VC3

( agro-based )

Carbosurf

PROMINENT Pulp2Value FIRST2RUN

VC4

( organic waste ) NewFert - -

12

In blue: project (10) & proposals (17)

with German participants

● ● ●

across

VCs

+ call 2015.2 (● ●)

● ● ● ● ● ● ●

● ● ● ● ● ●

● ● ● ● 3 CSA ● ● ●

GA not signed yet

Page 13: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BBI on-going projects

Calls 2014 + 2015.1 VC Project DE Partners

VC1

(lignocell

ulose )

US2GREENCHEM TTZ/Hochschule Bremerhaven, Weber Ultrasonics GmbH,

Environmental Systems GmbH, Jowat AG

ValChem Technische Universität Darmstadt (Coo)

LIGNOFLAG

Clariant Produkte (DE) GmbH, (Coo), Fliegl Agrartechnik GmbH,

Bayerische Forschungsallianz GmbH, Industrielle Biotechnologie

Bayern Netzwerk GmbH

VC2

( forest-

based )

SmartLi

Tecnaro Gesellschaft Zur Industriellen Anwendung

Nachwachsender Rohstoffe Mbh: Fraunhofer Gesellschaft zur

Forderung Der Angewandten Forschung EV

Greenlight Faserinstitut Bremen EV; Sächsisches Textilforschungsinstitut EV.,

Fourne Machinenbau Gmbh

PROVIDES Voith Paper Gmbh & Co. Kg

VC3

( agro-

based )

Carbosurf Fraunhofer Gesellschaft zur Forderung Der Angewandten

Forschung EV; Imd Natural Solutions Gmbh; Evonik Industries Ag

PROMINENT Südzucker Ag, AB Enzymes GmbH

Pulp2Value Nova-institut

VC4

(waste ) NewFert Kwb Kompententzzentrum Wasser Berlin Gemeinnutzige Gmbh 13

with German part.

Page 14: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Distribution of participants per country

- 2015 BBI calls -

14

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS FO IL TR CH RS

EU-15

AC

EU-13

TC

305 participants in both 2015 calls (Call 2015.1 & Call 2015.2)

• Germany: the highest number of participants (40)

• In 2015 higher geograpfical diversity than in Call 2014

• Increasing participation of EU 13 (‚NMS‘) & Associated Countr.

Page 15: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK NO AT IE CH EL HU PT HR SK IS PL RO RS SI TR EE FO IL LV BG

SELECTEDNumber of beneficiaries in selected proposals

SUBMITTEDNumber of applicants in submitted proposals

Success rate by country

15

Countries with success rate > 50 %

Norway (>70%), Slovakia, Hungary, Sweden, Switzerland, Island

Countries with success rate 40% - 50%: NL, BE, DE, FR

Page 16: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

• About BBI JU mission, objectives, exected impact

• Achievements projects, participation statistics

German participation

• Call 2016 budget, topics, timing

Content

Page 17: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

1 2 3 7 6 5 4

Call

2014

Call

2015

Call

2016

Call

2020 …….

• Changes in the operational environment of BBI

(politics, markets, technology, new stakeholders …)

• Need to accelerate the developments towards

meeting the BBI 2020 objectives and impacts

• Input from stakeholders‘ consultations and lessons

learned from previous Calls

Main drivers for Call 2016 design ?

BBI JU Calls Evolution

Page 18: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Strategic orientation

SIRA

• A guiding document for BBI call(s) design

• Main focus: 4 value chains:

lingocellulosic feedstock to advanced BB prod.

forest-based & agro-based VCs

new VCs based on organic waste

Novelties in Call 2016

• new areas covered (aquatic biomass, BB products with

new functionalities for diverse market applications)

• Topics: no restriction to a specific VCs mentioned

in the SIRA (topic numbering)

Page 19: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Sufficient and sustainable biomass feedstock supply at affordable price, incorporating the feedstock suppliers as partners in the value chains

Development of biorefinery technologies and processes to increase the competitive position of the bio-based industries in Europe

Higher market demand and customer awareness through the development of innovative products and applications in partnership with actors in the end consumer markets…

Cro

ss

-secto

rial

inte

gra

tio

n

alo

ng

an

d a

cro

ss v

alu

e c

hain

s

Strategic orientation – Call 2016

Page 20: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Implementation

- Type of Actions -

Coordination and Support Actions (CSA)

cross-sectorial challenges, supporting VCs, integration, networking…

• Research and Innovation Actions (RIA)

• Innovation Actions (IA)

Demonstration actions

Flagship actions

Source: Types of Actions are described the 2016 BBI JU Guide for Applicants.

Page 21: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

0

Technology Readiness Levels (TRL)

TRL 1 – basic principles observed

TRL 2 – technology concept formulated

TRL 3 – experimental proof of concept

TRL 4 – technology validated in lab

TRL 5 – technology validated in relevant environment

TRL 6 – technology demonstrated in relevant environment

TRL 7 – system prototype demonstration in operational

environment

TRL 8 – system complete and qualified

TRL 9 – actual system proven in operational environment

FLAGSHIP

DEMO

RIA

Source: TRLs are described in Part G of the General Annexes to the EC Work Programme.

Page 22: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Budget distribution Call 2016

- Type of Actions -

RIA € 50 m

DEMO € 70.2 m

Flagship 1 € 40 m

Flagship 2 € 25 m

CSA € 3.5 m

In addition substantial resources from industry

expected: Estimated value of the in kind contributions:

Minimum € 110 Million

Indicative total BBI JU

budget € 188.65 Million

Page 23: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BBI JU Calls Evolution

- Submission Statistics -

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

2014 2015 2016

Topics

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

2014 2015 2016

Proposals

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

2014 2015 2016

Prop. / Topic

• Call 2014 to call 2015 increase in overall mobilisation

• Call 2016: more than 90 (100?) proposals expected and

more than 4 (5?) proposals per topic

Page 24: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

RIAs in Call 2016

Objective: Filling specific gaps in the value chain

by developing (TRL 3) or validating a technology, process

or materials/chemicals at lab (TRL 4) or at pilot scale (TRL 5)

12 RIA topics with different focus /priorities;

Feedstock: wastewater (R1), MSW (R8), aquatic biomass (R9)

Process: fermentation (R2), control of contamination (R3),

separation & purification (R12), …

Products & Markets: biomaterials for food packaging (R5),

biopolymers with advanced functionalities (R7)…

BBI JU Budget: € 50 million

Considered total eligible budget: € 2-5 million per proposal

Page 25: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

DEMOs in Call 2016

Objective: demonstration of the technical and economic

viability of a new or improved technology, process, product

or service or value chain in relevant (TRL 6) or operational

(TRL 7) environment

9 DEMO topics: industrial crop & novel sources of biomass (D2);

biorefinery concepts for underexploited areas (D4),

BB polymers/plastic materials with new functionalities (D5)…

Shall address the whole value chain, from feedstock sourcing to

market applications

BBI JU Budget € 70.2 million

Considered total eligible budget: up to € 15 million / proposal

Page 26: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Flagships in Call 2016

Objective: deployment of a demonstrated technology leading

to a system, which is complete and qualified (TRL8) for

successful commercial operation (large scale production

facility in Europe)

2 Flagship topics focusing on high added-value products:

- F1: by-products or waste-streams from the food industry

BBI JU Budget € 40 million (2 projects possible)

Considered total eligible budget: up to € 30 million/ proposal

- F2: bio-based feedstock

BBI JU Budget € 25 million

Considered total eligible budget: up to € 35 million/ proposal

Page 27: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

CSAs in Call 2016

Objective: supporting value chains development

S1 A roadmap for the chemical industry to a bioeconomy

S2 Bioeconomy related open access research infrastructure

and assessing its capabilities for industry driven

development projects

S3 Open-innovation Platform strengthening cooperation

and joint development of bio-based industries and

downstream sectors

S4 Clustering and networking for new value chains

BBI JU Budget € 3.5 million

Page 28: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Call 2016

Indicative Timetable Call launch:

→ Open for proposals: from 19 April 2016

Submission of proposals:

→ Deadline: 8 September 2016

Information on the outcome of the evaluation process:

max 5 months after the proposal submission deadline

→ By: 8 Feb 2017

Signature of grant agreements:

max 8 months after the proposal submission deadline

→ By: 8 May 2017 For more information (topics, timing ) see BBI JU Annual Work Plan 2016 (BBI JU AWP).

The Call 2016 FAQ are published on the BBI JU website.

Page 29: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

More Info on Call 2016?

29

BBI Info Day 2016:

Presentations (here) and a video stream of the event is available. Watch

the 2016 BBI Info Day.

Page 30: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Q&A

Page 31: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Annexes

31

Page 32: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

Budget

Number

EU13 AC EU15

6% 8%

12% 18%

86%

70%

Participation structure

- Goups of countries -

32

Among projects (3) & proposals (23) resulting from 2015 Calls

• 6% beneficiaries from EU13 (19 out of 305 beneficiaries)

• 12% of the total BBI funding is going to EU 13 (€ 20.5 million)

• 8% beneficiaries from AC (23 beneficiaries incl. 10 from NO)

• 18% of the total BBI funding is going to AC (€ 31.5 million,

with the majority going to NO ~ € 30 million)

Page 33: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

Private-for-profit organisations

(PRO) 63%

Research Organisations

19%

Higher Education

Establishments 12%

Others 4%

Public Organisations

2%

Participation structure

- Type of organisations -

33

Among projects (3) & proposals (23) resulting from 2015 Calls

• 63% are PROs (192 out of 305 beneficiaries)

• 72% of the total BBI funding is going to PROs (€ 130 million)

• Similar in Call 2014: 65% PROs receiving 74% of funding

Page 34: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

SME Participation

34

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

Number

Budget

SMEs Non SMEs

25%

37%

Among projects (3) & proposals (23) resulting from 2015 Calls

• 37% are SMEs (113 out of 305 beneficiaries)

• 25% of the total BBI funding is going to SMEs (€ 45,5 million)

• Better than the H2020 targets (20% budget target for SME)

• Better than in Call 2014 (24% SME receiving 21% of funding)

Page 35: Gemeinsames Unternehmen für biobasierte Industriezweige ... · - 2015 BBI calls - 14 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 DE NL SE IT ES BE UK FR FI DK AT IE EL PT HU HR SK PL RO EE SI NO IS

BIC participation

35

21%

79%

BIC (Full and Associate)

Non-BIC

30%

70%

BIC (Full and Associate)

Non-BIC

Submitted proposals

35

Among projects (3) & proposals (23) resulting from 2015 Calls

• 21% of the participants: BIC members in submitted proposals

• 30% of participants: BIC members in selected proposals

Selected proposals

• Higehr success rate if BIC members in the consortium

• Similar conclusions for call 2014