george orwell - politics vs. litterature an examination of gullivers travels[1]

8/8/2019 George Orwell - Politics vs. Litterature an Examination of Gullivers Travels[1]

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/george-orwell-politics-vs-litterature-an-examination-of-gullivers-travels1 1/23

#""##!#$!'#$%!)"!%"

(FK9@@9CF;9

$" #!"" 'CB=7H=CB$! <HHD;IH9B69F;B9H5I



$#!&F=7 FH<IF @5=F #IB9 Q #5BI5FM 69HH9F ?BCKB 6M H<9

D9B B5A9 9CF;9 (FK9@@ K5G 5B B;@=G< 5IH<CF 5B8 >CIFB5@=GH 'CH98 5G5 BCJ9@=GH 7F=H=7 DC@=H=75@ 5B8 7I@HIF5@ 7CAA9BH5HCF (FK9@@ =G 5ACB; H<9ACGH K=89@M 58A=F98 B;@=G<@5B;I5;9 9GG5M=GHG C: H<9 H< 79BHIFM !9

=G 69GH ?BCKB :CF HKC BCJ9@G 7F=H=75@ C: HCH5@=H5F=5B=GA =B ;9B9F5@ 5B8,H5@=B=GA =B D5FH=7I@5F B=A5@ 5FA 5B8 '=B9H99B =;<HMCIF CH<K9F9KF=HH9B5B8DI6@=G<98HCK5F8H<99B8C:<=G@=:9,CIF790=?=D98=5

(!# -<=GKCF?=G5J5=@56@9:CF7CIBHF=9GK<9F97CDMF=;<H=G%=:9

# -<=G6CC?=G6FCI;<HHCMCI6M9986CC?G<HHDKKK:9986CC?G7CA,HF=7H@M:CFD9FGCB5@IG98CBCHIG9H<=G:=@9:CF7CAA9F7=5@DIFDCG9G



"B .%%"/+, -+/%, <IA5B=HM =G 5HH57?98 CF 7F=H=7=N98 :FCA 5H@95GH H<F99 8=::9F9BH 5B;@9G 5B8 H<9 =AD@=98 7<5F57H9F C: I@@=J9F <=AG9@: B979GG5F=@M 7<5B;9G GCA9K<5H =B H<9 DFC79GG "B )5FH " <9 =G H<9 HMD=75@9=;<H99BH<79BHIFM JCM5;9F 6C@8 DF57H=75@ 5B8 IBFCA5BH=7 <=G <CA9@MCIH@CC? G?=@:I@@M =ADF9GG98 CB H<9 F9589F 6M H<9 6=C;F5D<=75@ 89H5=@G 5H

H<9 69;=BB=B; 6M <=G 5;9 <9 =G 5 A5B C: :CFHM K=H< HKC 7<=@8F9B K<9B<=G 58J9BHIF9G GH5FH 5B8 6M H<9 =BJ9BHCFM C: H<9 H<=B;G =B <=G DC7?9HG9GD97=5@@M <=G GD97H57@9G K<=7< A5?9 G9J9F5@ 5DD95F5B79G "B )5FH "" <9<5G =B ;9B9F5@ H<9 G5A9 7<5F57H9F 6IH 5H ACA9BHG K<9B H<9 GHCFM 89A5B8G =H <9 <5G 5 H9B89B7M HC 89J9@CD =BHC 5B =A697=@9 K<C =G 75D56@9 C:

6C5GH=B; C: PCIF BC6@9 CIBHFM H<9 &=GHF9GG C: FHG 5B8 FAG H<9,7CIF;9 C: F5B79R 9H7 9H7 5B8 5H H<9 G5A9 H=A9 C: 69HF5M=B; 9J9FM5J5=@56@9 G75B85@CIG :57H 56CIH H<9 7CIBHFM K<=7< <9 DFC:9GG9G HC @CJ9"B )5FH """ <9 =G AI7< 5G <9 K5G =B )5FH " H<CI;< 5G <9 =G 7CBGCFH=B;7<=9:@M K=H< 7CIFH=9FG 5B8 A9B C: @95FB=B; CB9 <5G H<9 =ADF9GG=CB H<5H<9 <5G F=G9B =B H<9 GC7=5@ G75@9 "B )5FH "/ <9 7CB79=J9G 5 <CFFCF C: H<9 <IA5B F579 K<=7< =G BCH 5DD5F9BH CF CB@M =BH9FA=HH9BH@M 5DD5F9BH =B H<995F@=9F 6CC?G 5B8 7<5B;9G =BHC 5 GCFH C: IBF9@=;=CIG 5B7<CF=H9 K<CG9 CB989G=F9 =G HC @=J9 =B GCA9 89GC@5H9 GDCH K<9F9 <9 75B 89JCH9 <=AG9@: HCA98=H5H=B; CB H<9 ;CC8B9GG C: H<9 !CIM<B<BAG !CK9J9F H<9G9 =B7CBG=GH9B7=9G 5F9 :CF798 IDCB ,K=:H 6M H<9 :57H H<5H I@@=J9F =G H<9F9 7<=9:@MHC DFCJ=89 5 7CBHF5GH "H =G B979GG5FM :CF =BGH5B79 H<5H <9 G<CI@8 5DD95FG9BG=6@9 =B )5FH " 5B8 5H @95GH =BH9FA=HH9BH@M G=@@M =B )5FH "" 6975IG9 =B 6CH<

6CC?G H<9 9GG9BH=5@ A5BC9IJF9 =G H<9 G5A9 =9 HC A5?9 H<9 <IA5B 69=B;

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

69 J9BH=B; <=G DF=J5H9 ;F=9J5B79 5;5=BGH 7CBH9ADCF5FM ,C7=9HM "H K=@@ 69

F9A9A69F98 H<5H K<9B H<9 AD9FCF C: %=@@=DIHG D5@579 75H7<9G :=F9 I@@=J9F DIHG =H CIH 6M IF=B5H=B; CB =H "BGH958 C: 69=B; 7CB;F5HI@5H98 CB <=GDF9G9B79 C: A=B8 <9 :=B8G H<5H <9 <5G 7CAA=HH98 5 75D=H5@ C::9B79 6MA5?=B;K5H9F=BH<9DF97=B7HGC:H<9D5@5795B8

" K5G DF=J5H9@M 5GGIF98 H<5H H<9 ADF9GG 7CB79=J=B; H<9 ;F95H9GH 6<CFF9B79 C: K<5H " <58 8CB9 F9ACJ98 HC H<9 ACGH 8=GH5BH ,=89 C: H<9



CIFH :=FA@M F9GC@J98 H<5H H<CG9 6I=@8=B;G G<CI@8 B9J9F 69 F9D5=F98 :CF<9F .G9 5B8 =B H<9 )F9G9B79 C: <9F 7<=9: CB:=89BHG 7CI@8 BCH :CF695FJCK=B;+9J9B;9

77CF8=B; HC )FC:9GGCF & -F9J9@M5B '%' .'+ *.''' D5FH C: H<9 F95GCB :CF ,K=:HG :5=@IF9 HC ;9H DF9:9FA9BH K5G H<5H

H<9 *I99B K5G G75B85@=N98 6M -% ( -.T5 D5AD<@9H =B K<=7<,K=:H DFC656@M :9@H H<5H <9 <58 8CB9 5 ;F95H G9FJ=79 HC H<9 B;@=G<FCKB G=B79 =H G75F=:=9G H<9 =GG9BH9FG 5B8 GH=@@ ACF9 H<9 5H<C@=7G K<=@9@95J=B; H<9 GH56@=G<98 <IF7< 5@CB9 "B 5BM 75G9 BC CB9 KCI@8 89BMH<5H .%%"/+, -+/%, =G 5 F5B7CFCIG 5G K9@@ 5G 5 D9GG=A=GH=7 6CC?5B8 H<5H 9GD97=5@@M =B )5FHG " 5B8 """ =H C:H9B 89G79B8G =BHC DC@=H=75@ D5FH=G5BG<=D C: 5 B5FFCK ?=B8 )9HH=B9GG 5B8 A5;B5B=A=HM F9DI6@=75B=GA 5B85IH<CF=H5F=5B=GA @CJ9 C: F95GCB 5B8 @57? C: 7IF=CG=HM 5F9 5@@ A=L98 ID=B =H -<9 <5HF98 C: H<9 <IA5B 6C8M K=H< K<=7< ,K=:H =G 9GD97=5@@M 5GGC7=5H98 =G CB@M 8CA=B5BH =B )5FH "/ 6IH GCA9<CK H<=G B9K DF9C77ID5H=CB8C9G BCH 7CA9 5G 5 GIFDF=G9 (B9 :99@G H<5H 5@@ H<9G9 58J9BHIF9G 5B8 5@@H<9G9 7<5B;9G C: ACC8 7CI@8 <5J9 <5DD9B98 HC H<9 G5A9 D9FGCB 5B8H<9 =BH9F7CBB9L=CB 69HK99B ,K=:HG DC@=H=75@ @CM5@H=9G 5B8 <=G I@H=A5H989GD5=F=GCB9C:H<9ACGH=BH9F9GH=B;:95HIF9GC:H<96CC?

)C@=H=75@@M ,K=:H K5G CB9 C: H<CG9 D9CD@9 K<C 5F9 8F=J9B =BHC 5 GCFH C: D9FJ9FG9 -CFM=GA 6M H<9 :C@@=9G C: H<9 DFC;F9GG=J9 D5FHM C: H<9 ACA9BH)5FH " C: .%%"/+, -+/%, CGH9BG=6@M 5 G5H=F9 CB <IA5B ;F95HB9GG75B 69 G99B =: CB9 @CC?G 5 @=HH@9 899D9F HC 69 G=AD@M 5B 5HH57? CB B;@5B8 CB H<9 8CA=B5BH 0<=; )5FHM 5B8 CB H<9 K5F K=H< F5B79

K<=7<T<CK9J9F 658 H<9 ACH=J9G C: H<9 @@=9G A5M <5J9 699BT8=8 G5J9IFCD9 :FCA 69=B; HMF5BB=N98 CJ9F 6M 5 G=B;@9 F957H=CB5FM DCK9F ,K=:HK5G BCH 5 #57C6=H9 BCF GHF=7H@M GD95?=B; 5 -CFM 5B8 <=G 897@5F98 5=A =BH<9 K5F K5G A9F9@M 5 AC89F5H9 D9579 HF95HM 5B8 BCH H<9 CIHF=;<H 89:95HC: B;@5B8 '9J9FH<9@9GG H<9F9 =G 5 H=B;9 C: EI=G@=B;=GA =B <=G 5HH=HI89K<=7< 7CA9G CIH =B H<9 9B8=B; C: )5FH " 5B8 G@=;<H@M =BH9F:9F9G K=H< H<95@@9;CFM 0<9B I@@=J9F :@99G :FCA %=@@=DIH B;@5B8 HC @9:IG7IF5B79 H<9 5GGIADH=CB H<5H 5 <IA5B 69=B; G=L =B7<9G <=;< =G =B<9F9BH@M7CBH9ADH=6@9 G99AG HC 69 8FCDD98 0<9F95G H<9 D9CD@9 C: %=@@=DIH <5J9

69<5J98 HCK5F8G I@@=J9F K=H< H<9 IHACGH HF957<9FM 5B8 A95BB9GG

H<CG9 C: @9:IG7I 69<5J9 ;9B9FCIG@M 5B8 GHF5=;<H:CFK5F8@M 5B8 =B8998H<=G G97H=CB C: H<9 6CC? 9B8G CB 5 8=::9F9BH BCH9 :FCA H<9 5@@FCIB8 8=G=@@IG=CBA9BH C: H<9 95F@=9F 7<5DH9FG J=89BH@M ,K=:HG 5B=AIG =G =B H<9:=FGH D@579 5;5=BGH '%' "H =G PMCIF '5H=J9GR =9 I@@=J9FG:9@@CK7CIBHFMA9B K<CA H<9 $=B; C: FC68=B;B5; 7CBG=89FG HC 69PH<9 ACGH D9FB=7=CIG +579 C: @=HH@9 C8=CIG J9FA=B H<5H '5HIF9 9J9F



GI::9F98 HC 7F5K@ IDCB H<9 GIF:579 C: H<9 5FH<R 5B8 H<9 @CB; D5GG5;9 5HH<9 9B8 89BCIB7=B; 7C@CB=N5H=CB 5B8 :CF9=;B 7CBEI9GH =G D@5=B@M 5=A985H B;@5B8 5@H<CI;< H<9 7CBHF5FM =G 9@56CF5H9@M GH5H98 -<9 IH7< B;@5B8G 5@@=9G 5B8 H5F;9H C: CB9 C: ,K=:HG ACGH :5ACIG D5AD<@9HG 5F9 5@GCACF9 CF @9GG K5BHCB@M 5HH57?98 =B )5FH """ -<9F9 =G 9J9B K<5H GCIB8G

@=?9 5 D9FGCB5@ BCH9 =B H<9 D5GG5;9 =B K<=7< I@@=J9F F97CF8G <=G G5H=G:57H=CB H<5H H<9 J5F=CIG 7CIBHF=9G <9 <5G 8=G7CJ9F98 75BBCH 69 A589 7C@CB=9GC:H<9F=H=G<FCKB

-<9 !(.2!'!'&, =B8998 5DD95F BCH HC 69 GC K9@@ DF9D5F98 :CF05F 5 ,7=9B79 HC K<=7< H<9M 5F9 D9F:97H ,HF5B;9FG 5B8 9GD97=5@@M 5;5=BGHA=GG=J9 095DCBG !CK9J9F GIDDCG=B; AMG9@: HC 69 5 &=B=GH9F C: ,H5H9 "7CI@8 B9J9F ;=J9 AM 58J=79 :CF =BJ58=B; H<9AS "A5;=B9 HK9BHM H<CIG5B8 C: H<9A 6F95?=B; =BHC H<9 A=8GH C: 5B .+()' 5FAM 7CB:CIB8=B; H<9 +5B?G CJ9FHIFB=B; H<9 5FF=5;9G 65HH9F=B; H<9 05FF=CFG 579G=BHC&IAAM6MH9FF=6@929F?G:FCAH<9=F<=B89F<CC:GS

CBG=89F=B; H<5H ,K=:H 8C9G BCH K5GH9 KCF8G H<5H D<F5G9 P65HH9F=B;H<9 K5FF=CFG :579G =BHC AIAAMR DFC656@M =B8=75H9G 5 G97F9H K=G< HC G99H<9 =BJ=B7=6@9 5FA=9G C: H<9 I?9 C: &5F@6CFCI;< HF95H98 =B 5 @=?9 A5BB9F -<9F9 5F9 G=A=@5F HCI7<9G 9@G9K<9F9 J9B H<9 7CIBHFM A9BH=CB98 =B)5FH """ K<9F9 PH<9 I@? C: H<9 )9CD@9 7CBG=GH =B 5 &5BB9F K<C@@M C: =G7CJ9F9FG 0=HB9GG9G "B:CFA9FG 77IG9FG )FCG97IHCFG J=89B79G,K95F9FG HC;9H<9F K=H< H<9=F G9J9F5@ GI6G9FJ=9BH 5B8 GI65@H9FB "BGHFIA9BHG 5@@ IB89F H<9 C@CIFG H<9 CB8I7H 5B8 )5M C: &=B=GH9FG C: ,H5H9R =G 75@@98 %5B;8CB K<=7< =G K=H<=B CB9 @9HH9F C: 69=B; 5B 5B5;F5A

C: B;@5B8 G H<9 95F@M 98=H=CBG C: H<9 6CC? 7CBH5=B A=GDF=BHG =H A5MD9F<5DG <5J9 699B =BH9B898 5G 5 7CAD@9H9 5B5;F5A ,K=:HG )!2,"%F9DI@G=CB :FCA <IA5B=HM =G 79FH5=B@M F95@ 9BCI;< 6IH CB9 <5G H<9 :99@=B;H<5H <=G 896IB?=B; C: <IA5B ;F5B89IF <=G 8=5HF=69G 5;5=BGH @CF8G DC@=H=7=5BG 7CIFH :5JCIF=H9G 9H7 <5G A5=B@M 5 @C75@ 5DD@=75H=CB 5B8 GDF=B;G:FCA H<9 :57H H<5H <9 69@CB;98 HC H<9 IBGI779GG:I@ D5FHM !9 89BCIB79G=B>IGH=79 5B8 CDDF9GG=CB 6IH <9 ;=J9G BC 9J=89B79 C: @=?=B; 89AC7F57M"B GD=H9 C: <=G 9BCFACIG@M ;F95H9F DCK9FG <=G =AD@=98 DCG=H=CB =G J9FMG=A=@5F HC H<5H C: H<9 =BBIA9F56@9 G=@@M7@9J9F CBG9FJ5H=J9G C: CIF CKB85MTD9CD@9 @=?9 ,=F @5B !9F69FH )FC:9GGCF & 2CIB; %CF8 =HCB

H<9 -CFM +9:CFA CAA=HH99 CF H<9 @CB; @=B9 C: 5H<C@=7 5DC@C;=GHG :FCA0 ! &5@@C7? CBK5F8G D9CD@9 K<C GD97=5@=N9 =B 7F57?=B; B95H >C?9G 5HH<9 9LD9BG9 C: K<5H9J9F =G PAC89FBR 5B8 PDFC;F9GG=J9R 5B8 K<CG9CD=B=CBG 5F9 C:H9B 5@@ H<9 ACF9 9LHF9A9 6975IG9 H<9M ?BCK H<5H H<9M 75BBCH =B:@I9B79 H<9 57HI5@ 8F=:H C: 9J9BHG :H9F 5@@ GI7< 5 D5AD<@9H 5G '+.&'- -( )+(/ -!- -! (%",!"' (



!+",-"'"-2 9H7 =G J9FM @=?9 P-=ACH<M ,<MR <5J=B; 5 6=H C: 7@95B:IB K=H< H<9 F5=BG -FIGH CF 5H<9F +CB5@8 $BCL 9LDCG=B; H<9 9FFCFG C: 9FHF5B8 +IGG9@@ B8 H<9 95G9 K=H< K<=7< ,K=:H <5G 699B :CF;=J9BT5B8:CF;=J9B GCA9H=A9G 6M 89JCIH 69@=9J9FGT:CF H<9 6@5GD<9A=9G C: -% ( -. 89ACBGHF5H9G 7@95F@M 9BCI;< H<9 :996@9B9GG C: F9@=;=CIG

G9BH=A9BHG5G7CAD5F98K=H<DC@=H=75@CB9G!CK9J9F H<9 F957H=CB5FM 75GH C: ,K=:HG A=B8 8C9G BCH G<CK =HG9@:

7<=9:@M =B <=G DC@=H=75@ 5::=@=5H=CBG -<9 =ADCFH5BH H<=B; =G <=G 5HH=HI89 HCK5F8G ,7=9B79 5B8 ACF9 6FC58@M HCK5F8G =BH9@@97HI5@ 7IF=CG=HM -<9:5ACIG 7589AM C: %5;58C 89G7F=698 =B )5FH """ C: .%%"/+,-+/%, =G BC 8CI6H 5 >IGH=:=98 G5H=F9 CB ACGH C: H<9 GC75@@98 G7=9BH=GHGC: ,K=:HG CKB 85M ,=;B=:=75BH@M H<9 D9CD@9 5H KCF? =B =H 5F9 89G7F=6985G P)FC>97HCFGR H<5H =G D9CD@9 BCH 9B;5;98 =B 8=G=BH9F9GH98 F9G95F7< 6IHA9F9@M CB H<9 @CC?CIH :CF ;58;9HG K<=7< K=@@ G5J9 @56CIF 5B8 6F=B; =BACB9M IH H<9F9 =G BC G=;BT=B8998 5@@ H<FCI;< H<9 6CC? H<9F9 5F9A5BM G=;BG HC H<9 7CBHF5FMTH<5H PDIF9R G7=9B79 KCI@8 <5J9 GHFI7? ,K=:H5G 5 KCFH<K<=@9 57H=J=HM -<9 ACF9 G9F=CIG ?=B8 C: G7=9BH=GH <5G 5@F958M<58 5 ?=7? =B H<9 D5BHG =B )5FH "" K<9B H<9 P,7<C@5FGR D5HFCB=N98 6M H<9$=B;C:FC68=B;B5;HFMHC577CIBH:CFI@@=J9FGGA5@@GH5HIF9

:H9F AI7< 965H9 H<9M 7CB7@I898 IB5B=ACIG@M H<5H " K5G CB@M+%)%.& ,%-! K<=7< =G =BH9FDF9H98 @=H9F5@@M %.,.,'-.+ 5 9H9FA=B5H=CB 9L57H@M 5;F9956@9 HC H<9 AC89FB D<=@CGCD<MC: .+() K<CG9 )FC:9GGCFG 8=G85=B=B; H<9 C@8 J5G=CB C: (.%-.,, K<9F96M H<9 :C@@CK9FG C: +",-(-% 9B895JCIF98 =B J5=B HC

8=G;I=G9 H<9=F ";BCF5B79 <5J9 =BJ9BH98 H<=G KCB89F:I@ GC@IH=CB C: @@=::=7I@H=9GHCH<9IBGD95?56@98J5B79A9BHC:<IA5B$BCK@98;9": H<=G GHCC8 6M =HG9@: CB9 A=;<H 5GGIA9 H<5H ,K=:H =G A9F9@M H<9 9B9AM

C: ,!& G7=9B79 "B 5 BIA69F C: D@579G <CK9J9F <9 ;C9G CIH C: <=G K5MHC DFC7@5=A H<9 IG9@9GGB9GG C: 5@@ @95FB=B; CF GD97I@5H=CB BCH 8=F97H98 HCK5F8GGCA9DF57H=75@9B8

-<9 @95FB=B; C: H<9 FC68=B;B5;@5BG =G J9FM 89:97H=J9 7CBG=GH=B;CB@M =B &CF5@=HM !=GHCFM )C9HFM 5B8 &5H<9A5H=7G K<9F9=B H<9M AIGH

69 5@@CK98 HC 9L79@ IH H<9 @5GH C: H<9G9 =G K<C@@M 5DD@=98 HC K<5H A5M 69 IG9:I@ =B %=:9 HC H<9 =ADFCJ9A9BH C: ;F=7I@HIF9 5B8 5@@ A97<5B=75@

FHG GC H<5H 5ACB; IG =H KCI@8 69 @=HH@9 9GH99A98 B8 5G HC "895G BH=H=9G 6GHF57H=CBG 5B8 -F5BG79B89BH5@G " 7CI@8 B9J9F 8F=J9 H<9 @95GHCB79DH=CB=BHCH<9=F!958G

-<9 !CIM<B<BAG ,K=:HG =895@ 69=B;G 5F9 657?K5F8 9J9B =B 5 A97<5B=75@ G9BG9 -<9M 5F9 IB57EI5=BH98 K=H< A9H5@G <5J9 B9J9F <95F8 C:

6C5HG 8C BCH DFCD9F@M GD95?=B; DF57H=G9 5;F=7I@HIF9 K9 5F9 HC@8 H<5H



H<9 C5HG K<=7< H<9M @=J9 IDCB P;FCK B5HIF5@@MR 5B8 5DD95F BCH HC <5J9=BJ9BH98 K<99@G -<9M <5J9 BC 5@D<569H 5B8 9J=89BH@M <5J9 BCH AI7<7IF=CG=HM 56CIH H<9 D<MG=75@ KCF@8 -<9M 8C BCH 69@=9J9 H<5H 5BM =B<56=H98 7CIBHFM 9L=GHG 69G=89 H<9=F CKB 5B8 H<CI;< H<9M IB89FGH5B8 H<9ACH=CBG C: H<9 GIB 5B8 ACCB 5B8 H<9 B5HIF9 C: 97@=DG9G PH<=G =G H<9 IH

ACGH DFC;F9GG C: H<9=F ,-+('(&2R M 7CBHF5GH H<9 D<=@CGCD<9FG C: H<9 :@M=B; =G@5B8 C: %5DIH5 5F9 GC 7CBH=BICIG@M 56GCF698 =B A5H<9A5H=75@GD97I@5H=CBG H<5H 69:CF9 GD95?=B; HC H<9A CB9 <5G HC 5HHF57H H<9=F 5HH9BH=CB 6M B5DD=B; H<9A CB H<9 95F K=H< 5 6@5889F -<9M <5J9 75H5@C;I98H9B H<CIG5B8 :=L98 GH5FG <5J9 G9HH@98 H<9 D9F=C8G C: B=B9HMH<F99 7CA9HG5B8 <5J9 8=G7CJ9F98 =B 58J5B79 C: H<9 5GHFCBCA9FG C: IFCD9 H<5H &5FG<5G HKC ACCBGT5@@ C: K<=7< =B:CFA5H=CB ,K=:H 9J=89BH@M F9;5F8G 5G F=8=7I@CIG IG9@9GG 5B8 IB=BH9F9GH=B; G CB9 A=;<H 9LD97H <9 69@=9J9GH<5H H<9 G7=9BH=GHG D@579 =: <9 <5G 5 D@579 =G =B H<9 @56CF5HCFM 5B8 H<5HG7=9BH=:=7?BCK@98;9<5GBC695F=B;CBDC@=H=75@A5HH9FG

0<5H " S H<CI;<H 5@HC;9H<9F IB577CIBH56@9 K5G H<9 GHFCB; =GDCG=H=CB " C6G9FJ98 =B H<9A HCK5F8G '9KG 5B8 )C@=H=7G D9FD9HI5@@M 9BEI=F=B; =BHC )I6@=7 ::5=FG ;=J=B; H<9=F >I8;9A9BHG =B &5HH9FG C: ,H5H9 5B8D5GG=CB5H9@M 8=GDIH=B; 9J9FM =B7< C: 5 )5FHM (D=B=CB " <5J9 =B8998 C6G9FJ98 H<9 G5A9 =GDCG=H=CB 5ACB; ACGH C: H<9 &5H<9A5H=7=5BG " <5J9?BCKB =B .+() H<CI;< " 7CI@8 B9J9F 8=G7CJ9F H<9 @95GH B5@C;M

69HK99B H<9 HKC ,7=9B79G IB@9GG H<CG9 D9CD@9 GIDDCG9 H<5H 6975IG9 H<9GA5@@9GH =F7@9 <5H< 5G A5BM 9;F99G 5G H<9 @5F;9GH H<9F9:CF9 H<9 +9;I@5H=CB 5B8 &5B5;9A9BH C: H<9 0CF@8 F9EI=F9 BC ACF9 6=@=H=9G H<5B H<9

!5B8@=B;5B8-IFB=B;C:5@C69"G H<9F9 BCH GCA9H<=B; :5A=@=5F =B H<5H D<F5G9 P" 7CI@8 B9J9F 8=G7CJ9FH<9 @95GH 5B5@C;M 69HK99B H<9 HKC G7=9B79GR "H <5G DF97=G9@M H<9 BCH9 C: H<9 DCDI@5F 5H<C@=7 5DC@C;=GHG K<C DFC:9GG HC 69 5GHCB=G<98 K<9B 5 G7=9BH=GH IHH9FG 5B CD=B=CB CB GI7< EI9GH=CBG 5G H<9 9L=GH9B79 C: C8 CF H<9=AACFH5@=HM C: H<9 GCI@ -<9 G7=9BH=GH K9 5F9 HC@8 =G 5B 9LD9FH CB@M =BCB9 F9GHF=7H98 :=9@8 K<M G<CI@8 <=G CD=B=CBG 69 C: J5@I9 =B 5BM CH<9F-<9 =AD@=75H=CB =G H<5H H<9C@C;M =G >IGH 5G AI7< 5B 9L57H G7=9B79 5G :CF=BGH5B79 7<9A=GHFM 5B8 H<5H H<9 DF=9GH =G 5@GC 5B 9LD9FH K<CG9 7CB7@IG=CBG CB 79FH5=B GI6>97HG AIGH 69 5779DH98 ,K=:H =B 9::97H A5?9G H<9 G5A9

7@5=A :CF H<9 DC@=H=7=5B 6IH <9 ;C9G CB9 69HH9F =B H<5H <9 K=@@ BCH 5@@CKH<9 G7=9BH=GHT9=H<9F H<9 PDIF9R G7=9BH=GH CF H<9 58 <C7 =BJ9GH=;5HCFTHC 695 IG9:I@ D9FGCB =B <=G CKB @=B9 J9B =: <9 <58 BCH KF=HH9B )5FH """ C:

!CIM<B<BAGHCCC@8HCK5@?5F989G7F=6985G69=B;75FF=98CBPG@98;9GRCF=BP5?=B8C:J9<=7@98F5KB@=?95G@98;9R)F9GIA56@MH<9G9<58BCK<99@GIH<CFGBCH9



.%%"/+, -+/%, CB9 7CI@8 =B:9F :FCA H<9 F9GH C: H<9 6CC? H<5H@=?9 -C@GHCM 5B8 @=?9 @5?9 <9 <5H9G H<9 J9FM =895 C: GHI8M=B; H<9 DFC79GG9G C: '5HIF9 -<9 P+95GCBR K<=7< <9 GC 58A=F9G =B H<9 !CIM<B<BAG8C9G BCH DF=A5F=@M A95B H<9 DCK9F C: 8F5K=B; @C;=75@ =B:9F9B79G :FCAC6G9FJ98 :57HG @H<CI;< <9 B9J9F 89:=B9G =H =H 5DD95FG =B ACGH 7CBH9LHG

HC A95B 9=H<9F 7CAACB G9BG9T=9 5779DH5B79 C: H<9 C6J=CIG 5B8 7CBH9ADH :CF EI=66@9G 5B8 56GHF57H=CBGTCF 56G9B79 C: D5GG=CB 5B8 GID9FGH=H=CB "B ;9B9F5@ <9 5GGIA9G H<5H K9 ?BCK 5@@ H<5H K9 B998 HC ?BCK5@F958M 5B8 A9F9@M IG9 CIF ?BCK@98;9 =B7CFF97H@M &98=7=B9 :CF =BGH5B79 =G 5 IG9@9GG G7=9B79 6975IG9 =: K9 @=J98 =B 5 ACF9 B5HIF5@ K5MH<9F9 KCI@8 69 BC 8=G95G9G ,K=:H <CK9J9F =G BCH 5 G=AD@9@=:9F CF 5B 58A=F9F C: H<9 'C6@9 ,5J5;9 !9 =G =B :5JCIF C: 7=J=@=N5H=CB 5B8 H<9 5FHG C: 7=J=@=N5H=CB 'CH CB@M 8C9G <9 G99 H<9 J5@I9 C: ;CC8 A5BB9FG ;CC8 7CBJ9FG5H=CB 5B8 9J9B @95FB=B; C: 5 @=H9F5FM 5B8 <=GHCF=75@ ?=B8 <9 5@GC G99GH<5H 5;F=7I@HIF9 B5J=;5H=CB 5B8 5F7<=H97HIF9 B998 HC 69 GHI8=98 5B87CI@8 K=H< 58J5BH5;9G 69 =ADFCJ98 IH <=G =AD@=98 5=A =G 5 GH5H=7 =B7IF=CIG 7=J=@=N5H=CBTH<9 KCF@8 C: <=G CKB 85M 5 @=HH@9 7@95B9F 5 @=HH@9G5B9F K=H< BC F58=75@ 7<5B;9 5B8 BC DC?=B; =BHC H<9 IB?BCK56@9 &CF9H<5B CB9 KCI@8 9LD97H =B 5BMCB9 GC :F99 :FCA 5779DH98 :5@@57=9G <9F9J9F9G H<9 D5GH 9GD97=5@@M 7@5GG=75@ 5BH=EI=HM 5B8 69@=9J9G H<5H AC89FBA5B <5G 89;9B9F5H98 G<5FD@M 8IF=B; H<9 D5GH <IB8F98 M95FG "B H<9 =G@5B8C:GCF79F9FGK<9F9H<9GD=F=HGC:H<9895875B6975@@98ID5HK=@@

" 89G=F98 H<5H H<9 ,9B5H9 C: +(& A=;<H 5DD95F 69:CF9 A9 =B CB9 @5F;97<5A69F 5B8 5 AC89FB +9DF9G9BH5H=J9 =B CIBH9FJ=9K =B 5BCH<9F -<9

:=FGH G99A98 HC 69 5B GG9A6@M C: !9FC9G 5B8 9AMC8G H<9 CH<9F 5$BCHC:)98@5FG)=7?DC7?9HG!=;<K5MA9B5B8I@@=9G@H<CI;< ,K=:H IG9G H<=G G97H=CB C: )5FH """ HC 5HH57? H<9 HFIH<:I@B9GG C:

F97CF898 <=GHCFM <=G 7F=H=75@ GD=F=H 89G9FHG <=A 5G GCCB 5G <9 =G 895@=B;K=H< F99?G 5B8 +CA5BG !9 F9A5F?G C: 7CIFG9 IDCB H<9 7CFFIDH=CB C: =AD9F=5@ +CA9 6IH <9 <5G 5B 5@ACGH IBF95GCB=B; 58A=F5H=CB :CF GCA9 C: H<9@958=B;:=;IF9GC:H<95B7=9BHKCF@8

" K5G GHFI7? K=H< DFC:CIB8 /9B9F5H=CB 5H H<9 G=;<H C: +.-., 5B87CI@8 95G=@M 8=G7CJ9F H<9 ACGH 7CBGIAA5H9 /=FHI9 H<9 ;F95H9GH "BHF9D=8=HM 5B8 =FAB9GG C: &=B8 H<9 HFI9GH %CJ9 C: <=G CIBHFM 5B8 ;9B9F5@

9B9JC@9B79 :CF &5B?=B8 =B 9J9FM %=B95A9BH C: <=G CIBH9B5B79S "

-<9D<MG=75@897589B79K<=7<,K=:H7@5=AGHC<5J9C6G9FJ98A5M<5J9699B5F95@=HM5HH<5H85H9!95HHF=6IH9G=HHCGMD<=@=GK<=7<K5G5B9K8=G95G9=BIFCD95B8A5M<5J9699BACF9J=FI@9BHH<5B=H=GBCK=GH=@@98@=EICFG5@GCK9F95BCJ9@HM=BH<9G9J9BH99BH<79BHIFM5B8AIGH<5J9@985H:=FGHHC5;F95H=B7F95G9=B8FIB?9BB9GGIH<CFG:CCHBCH9



<58 H<9 <CBCIF HC <5J9 AI7< CBJ9FG5H=CB K=H< +.-., 5B8 K5G HC@8H<5H <=G B79GHCFG #.'"., ,(+-, )&"'(', -( H<9MCIB;9F ,"+ -!(&, &(+ 5B8 <=AG9@: K9F9 D9FD9HI5@@M HC;9H<9F5 ,1-.&/"+- HC K<=7< 5@@ H<9 ;9G C: H<9 0CF@8 75BBCH 588 5G9J9BH<

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

-C 69;=B K=H< <9 <5G ACA9BHG K<9B <9 =G P7CBGHFI7H=J9R 5B8 9J9BP58J5B798R -C 69 C775G=CB5@@M =B7CBG=GH9BH =G 5@ACGH 5 A5F? C: J=H5@=HM=B .HCD=5 6CC?G 5B8 ,K=:H GCA9H=A9G =BG9FHG 5 KCF8 C: DF5=G9 =BHC 5 D5GG5;9 H<5H CI;<H HC 69 DIF9@M G5H=F=75@ -<IG <=G =895G 56CIH H<9 98I75H=CBC: H<9 MCIB; 5F9 :5H<9F98 CB HC H<9 %=@@=DIH=5BG K<C <5J9 AI7< H<9G5A9 J=9KG CB H<=G GI6>97H 5G H<9 !CIM<B<BAG -<9 %=@@=DIH=5BG 5@GC

<5J9 J5F=CIG GC7=5@ 5B8 @9;5@ =BGH=HIH=CBG :CF =BGH5B79 H<9F9 5F9 C@8 5;9D9BG=CBG 5B8 D9CD@9 5F9 F9K5F898 :CF ?99D=B; H<9 @5K 5G K9@@ 5G DIB=G<98 :CF 6F95?=B; =H K<=7< ,K=:H KCI@8 <5J9 @=?98 HC G99 DF9J5=@=B; =B<=G CKB 7CIBHFM "B H<9 A=88@9 C: H<=G D5GG5;9 ,K=:H F9A9A69FG <=G G5H=F=75@ =BH9BH=CB 5B8 588G P"B F9@5H=B; H<9G9 5B8 H<9 :C@@CK=B; %5KG "KCI@8 CB@M 69 IB89FGHCC8 HC A95B H<9 CF=;=B5@ "BGH=HIH=CBG 5B8 BCH H<9ACGH G75B85@CIG CFFIDH=CBG =BHC K<=7< H<9G9 D9CD@9 5F9 :5@@9B 6M H<989;9B9F5H9 '5HIF9 C: &5BR 6IH 5G %=@@=DIH =G GIDDCG98 HC F9DF9G9BH B;@5B8 5B8 H<9 @5KG <9 =G GD95?=B; C: <5J9 B9J9F <58 H<9=F D5F5@@9@ =B B;@5B8 =H =G 7@95F H<5H H<9 =ADI@G9 HC A5?9 7CBGHFI7H=J9 GI;;9GH=CBG <5G

699B HCC AI7< :CF <=A IH ,K=:HG ;F95H9GH 7CBHF=6IH=CB HC DC@=H=75@H<CI;<H =B H<9 B5FFCK9F G9BG9 C: H<9 KCF8G =G <=G 5HH57? 9GD97=5@@M =B)5FH """ CB K<5H KCI@8 BCK 69 75@@98 HCH5@=H5F=5B=GA !9 <5G 5B 9LHF5CF8=B5F=@M 7@95F DF9J=G=CB C: H<9 GDM<5IBH98 PDC@=79 ,H5H9R K=H< =HG9B8@9GG <9F9GM<IBHG 5B8 HF95GCB HF=5@G 5@@ F95@@M 89G=;B98 HC B9IHF5@=N9DCDI@5F 8=G7CBH9BH 6M 7<5B;=B; =H =BHC K5F <MGH9F=5 B8 CB9 AIGH



F9A9A69F H<5H ,K=:H =G <9F9 =B:9FF=B; H<9 K<C@9 :FCA 5 EI=H9 GA5@@ D5FH:CF H<9 :996@9 ;CJ9FBA9BHG C: <=G CKB 85M 8=8 BCH ;=J9 <=A =@@IGHF5H=CBGF958MA589 CF 9L5AD@9 H<9F9 =G H<9 DFC:9GGCF 5H H<9 ,7<CC@ C: )C@=H=75@)FC>97HCFG K<C PG<9K98 A9 5 @5F;9 )5D9F C: "BGHFI7H=CBG :CF 8=G7CJ9F=B;)@CHG 5B8 CBGD=F57=9GR 5B8 K<C 7@5=A98 H<5H CB9 75B :=B8 D9CD@9G

G97F9HH<CI;<HG6M9L5A=B=B;H<9=F9L7F9A9BH975IG9 &9B 5F9 B9J9F GC G9F=CIG H<CI;<H:I@ 5B8 =BH9BH 5G K<9B

H<9M 5F9 5H ,HCC@ K<=7< <9 :CIB8 6M :F9EI9BH LD9F=A9BH :CF =B GI7<CB>IB7HIF9G K<9B <9 IG98 A99F@M 5G 5 HF=5@ HC 7CBG=89F K<5H K5G H<9

69GH 05M C: AIF89F=B; H<9 $=B; <=G (F8IF9 KCI@8 <5J9 5 H=B7HIF9 C: F99B 6IH EI=H9 8=::9F9BH K<9B <9 H<CI;<H CB@M C: F5=G=B; 5B "BGIFF97H=CBCF6IFB=B;H<9&9HFCDC@=G

-<9 DFC:9GGCF 5B8 <=G H<9CFM 5F9 G5=8 HC <5J9 699B GI;;9GH98 HC ,K=:H 6M H<9T:FCA CIF DC=BH C: J=9KTBCH D5FH=7I@5F@M 5GHCB=G<=B; CF 8=G;IGH=B; :57H H<5H =B 5 F979BH ,H5H9 HF=5@ GCA9 @9HH9FG :CIB8 =B GCA96C8MG DF=JM<58 699B DIH =B 9J=89B79 %5H9F =B H<9 G5A9 7<5DH9F K9 G99A HC 69 DCG=H=J9@M=BH<9A=88@9C:H<9+IGG=5BDIF;9G

"B H<9 $=B;8CA C: -F=6B=5 6M H<9 '5H=J9G 75@@98 %5B;8CBS H<9 I@?C: H<9 )9CD@9 7CBG=GH =B 5 &5BB9F K<C@@M C: =G7CJ9F9FG 0=HB9GG9G "B:CFA9FG 77IG9FG )FCG97IHCFG J=89B79G ,K95F9FGS "H =G :=FGH 5;F9985B8 G9HH@98 5ACB; H<9A K<5H GIGD97H98 )9FGCBG G<5@@ 69 577IG98 C: 5)@CH -<9B 9::97HI5@ 5F9 =G H5?9B HC G97IF9 5@@ H<9=F %9HH9FG 5B8 )5D9FG5B8 DIH H<9 (KB9FG =B <5=BG -<9G9 D5D9FG 5F9 89@=J9F98 HC 5 ,9HH C: FH=GHG J9FM 89LH9FCIG =B :=B8=B; CIH H<9 AMGH9F=CIG &95B=B;G C:

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

69 5B5@MG98 =B H<9 :C@@CK=B; 0CF8G +,",-T )%(- ", +(.!-

!(&T-! -(.+ 'CH9 HCK9F B8 H<=G =G H<9 5B5;F5AA5H=7A9H<C8

(H<9F DFC:9GGCFG 5H H<9 G5A9 G7<CC@ =BJ9BH G=AD@=:=98 @5B;I5;9G KF=H9 6CC?G 6M A57<=B9FM 98I75H9 H<9=F DID=@G 6M =BG7F=6=B; H<9 @9GGCB CB 5K5:9F 5B8 75IG=B; H<9A HC GK5@@CK =H CF DFCDCG9 HC 56C@=G< =B8=J=8I5@=HM 5@HC;9H<9F 6M 7IHH=B; C:: D5FH C: H<9 6F5=B C: CB9 A5B 5B8 ;F5:H=B; =H



CB HC H<9 <958 C: 5BCH<9F -<9F9 =G GCA9H<=B; EI99F@M :5A=@=5F =B H<9 5HACGD<9F9 C: H<9G9 7<5DH9FG 6975IG9 A=L98 ID K=H< AI7< :CC@=B; H<9F9=G 5 D9F79DH=CB H<5H CB9 C: H<9 5=AG C: HCH5@=H5F=5B=GA =G BCH A9F9@M HCA5?9 GIF9 H<5H D9CD@9 K=@@ H<=B? H<9 F=;<H H<CI;<HG 6IH 57HI5@@M HC A5?9H<9A %,, (',"(., -<9B 5;5=B ,K=:HG 577CIBH C: H<9 %9589F K<C

=G IGI5@@M HC 69 :CIB8 FI@=B; CJ9F 5 HF=69 C: 25<CCG 5B8 C: H<9P:5JCIF=H9R K<C 57HG :=FGH 5G 5 8=FHMKCF?9F 5B8 @5H9F 5G 5 G75D9;C5H :=HGF9A5F?56@M K9@@ =BHC H<9 D5HH9FB C: CIF CKB H=A9G IH 5F9 K9 HC =B:9F:FCA 5@@ H<=G H<5H ,K=:H K5G :=FGH 5B8 :CF9ACGH 5B 9B9AM C: HMF5BBM 5B8 57<5AD=CB C: H<9 :F99 =BH9@@=;9B79 'C <=G CKB J=9KG GC :5F 5G CB9 75B8=G79FB H<9A 5F9 BCH A5F?98@M @=69F5@ 'C 8CI6H <9 <5H9G @CF8G ?=B;G

6=G<CDG ;9B9F5@G @58=9G C: :5G<=CB CF89FG H=H@9G 5B8 :@IAA9FM ;9B9F5@@M 6IH <9 8C9G BCH G99A HC H<=B? 69HH9F C: H<9 7CAACB D9CD@9 H<5B C: H<9=F FI@9FG CF HC 69 =B :5JCIF C: =B7F95G98 GC7=5@ 9EI5@=HM CF HC 69 9BH<IG=5GH=7 56CIH F9DF9G9BH5H=J9 =BGH=HIH=CBG -<9 !CIM<B<BAG 5F9 CF;5B=N98IDCB 5 GCFH C: 75GH9 GMGH9A K<=7< =G F57=5@ =B 7<5F57H9F H<9 <CFG9G K<=7<8C H<9 A9B=5@ KCF? 69=B; C: 8=::9F9BH 7C@CIFG :FCA H<9=F A5GH9FG 5B8 BCH=BH9F6F998=B; K=H< H<9A -<9 98I75H=CB5@ GMGH9A K<=7< ,K=:H 58A=F9G =BH<9 %=@@=DIH=5BG H5?9G <9F98=H5FM 7@5GG 8=GH=B7H=CBG :CF ;F5BH98 5B8 H<97<=@8F9B C: H<9 DCCF9GH 7@5GG9G 8C BCH ;C HC G7<CC@ 6975IG9 PH<9=F IG=B9GG 69=B; CB@M HC H=@@ 5B8 7I@H=J5H9 H<9 5FH<S H<9F9:CF9 H<9=F 8I75H=CB=G C: @=HH@9 CBG9EI9B79 HC H<9 )I6@=7R 'CF 8C9G <9 G99A HC <5J9 699BGHFCB;@M =B :5JCIF C: :F998CA C: GD997< 5B8 H<9 )F9GG =B GD=H9 C: H<9 HC@9F5H=CB K<=7< <=G CKB KF=H=B;G 9B>CM98 -<9 $=B; C: FC68=B;B5; =G 5G

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

P+95GCBR K<=7< 5F7 JC@IBH5F=@M 5779DH98 6M 9J9FMCB9 -<9 9B9F5@GG9A6@M C: H<9 !CIM<B<BAG P9L<CFHGR I@@=J9FG A5GH9F HC ;9H F=8 C: <=A 5B8 <=G B9=;<6CIFG DIH DF9GGIF9 CB <=A HC A5?9 <=A 7CAD@M -KCF95GCBG 5F9 ;=J9B (B9 =G H<5H H<9 DF9G9B79 C: H<=G IBIGI5@ 25<CC A5MIBG9HH@9 H<9 F9GH C: H<9 HF=69 5B8 H<9 CH<9F =G H<5H 5 :F=9B8@M F9@5H=CBG<=D

69HK99B 5 !CIM<B<BA 5B8 5 25<CC =G PBCH 5;F9956@9 HC +95GCB CF



'5HIF9 CF 5 -<=B; 9J9F <95F8 C: 69:CF9 5ACB; H<9AR I@@=J9FG A5GH9F=G GCA9K<5H IBK=@@=B; HC C69M 6IH H<9 P9L<CFH5H=CBR 5 !CIM<B<BAK9 5F9 HC@8 =G B9J9F (&)%% HC 8C 5BMH<=B; <9 =G A9F9@MP9L<CFH98R CF P58J=G98R 75BBCH 69 8=GF9;5F898 -<=G =@@IGHF5H9G J9FMK9@@ H<9 HCH5@=H5F=5B H9B89B7M K<=7< =G 9LD@=7=H =B H<9 5B5F7<=GH CF D57=:=GH

J=G=CB C: ,C7=9HM "B 5 ,C7=9HM =B K<=7< H<9F9 =G BC @5K 5B8 =B H<9CFM BC7CADI@G=CB H<9 CB@M 5F6=H9F C: 69<5J=CIF =G DI6@=7 CD=B=CB IH DI6@=7CD=B=CB 6975IG9 C: H<9 HF9A9B8CIG IF;9 HC 7CB:CFA=HM =B ;F9;5F=CIG 5B=A5@G =G @9GG HC@9F5BH H<5B 5BM GMGH9A C: @5K 0<9B <IA5B 69=B;G 5F9;CJ9FB98 6M PH<CI G<5@H BCHR H<9 =B8=J=8I5@ 75B DF57H=G9 5 79FH5=B5ACIBH C: 9779BHF=7=HM K<9B H<9M 5F9 GIDDCG98@M ;CJ9FB98 6M P@CJ9R CFPF95GCBR <9 =G IB89F 7CBH=BICIG DF9GGIF9 HC A5?9 <=A 69<5J9 5B8 H<=B?=B 9L57H@M H<9 G5A9 K5M 5G 9J9FMCB9 9@G9 -<9 !CIM<B<BAG K9 5F9 HC@8K9F9 IB5B=ACIG CB 5@ACGH 5@@ GI6>97HG -<9 CB@M EI9GH=CB H<9M 9J9F",.,, K5G <CK HC 895@ K=H< H<9 25<CCG (H<9FK=G9 H<9F9 K5G BCFCCA :CF 8=G5;F99A9BH 5ACB; H<9A 6975IG9 H<9 HFIH< =G 5@K5MG 9=H<9FG9@:9J=89BH CF 9@G9 =H =G IB8=G7CJ9F56@9 5B8 IB=ADCFH5BH -<9M <58 5DD5F9BH@M BC KCF8 :CF PCD=B=CBR =B H<9=F @5B;I5;9 5B8 =B H<9=F 7CBJ9FG5H=CBG H<9F9 K5G BC P8=::9F9B79 C: G9BH=A9BHGR -<9M <58 F957<98 =B :57HH<9 <=;<9GH GH5;9 C: HCH5@=H5F=5B CF;5B=N5H=CB H<9 GH5;9 K<9B 7CB:CFA=HM<5G 697CA9 GC ;9B9F5@ H<5H H<9F9 =G BC B998 :CF 5 DC@=79 :CF79 ,K=:H 5DDFCJ9G C: H<=G ?=B8 C: H<=B; 6975IG9 5ACB; <=G A5BM ;=:HG B9=H<9F 7IF=CG=HM BCF ;CC8B5HIF9 K5G =B7@I898 =G5;F99A9BH KCI@8 5@K5MG G99A HC<=A G<99F D9FJ9FG=HM P+95GCBR 5ACB; H<9 !CIM<B<BAG <9 G5MG P=G

BCH 5 )C=BH )FC6@9A5H=75@ 5G K=H< IG K<9F9 A9B 75B 5F;I9 K=H< )@5IG=6=@=HM CB 6CH< ,=89G C: 5 *I9GH=CB 6IH GHF=?9G MCI K=H< =AA98=5H9 CBJ=7H=CB 5G =H AIGH B998G 8C K<9F9 =H =G BCH A=B;@98 C6G7IF98 CF 8=G7C@CIF98 6M )5GG=CB 5B8 "BH9F9GHR "B CH<9F KCF8G K9 ?BCK 9J9FMH<=B;5@F958M GC K<M G<CI@8 8=GG=89BH CD=B=CBG 69 HC@9F5H98 -<9 HCH5@=H5F=5B,C7=9HM C: H<9 !CIM<B<BAG K<9F9 H<9F9 75B 69 BC :F998CA 5B8 BC 89J9@CDA9BH:C@@CKGB5HIF5@@M:FCAH<=G

09 5F9 F=;<H HC H<=B? C: ,K=:H 5G 5 F969@ 5B8 =7CBC7@5GH 6IH 9L79DH =B79FH5=B G97CB85FM A5HH9FG GI7< 5G <=G =BG=GH9B79 H<5H KCA9B G<CI@8 F979=J9 H<9 G5A9 98I75H=CB 5G A9B <9 75BBCH 69 @569@@98 P%9:HR !9 =G 5

-CFM 5B5F7<=GH 89GD=G=B; 5IH<CF=HM K<=@9 8=G69@=9J=B; =B @=69FHM 5B8DF9G9FJ=B; H<9 5F=GHC7F5H=7 CIH@CC? K<=@9 G99=B; 7@95F@M H<5H H<9 9L=GH=B;5F=GHC7F57M =G 89;9B9F5H9 5B8 7CBH9ADH=6@9 0<9B ,K=:H IHH9FG CB9 C: <=G7<5F57H9F=GH=7 8=5HF=69G 5;5=BGH H<9 F=7< 5B8 DCK9F:I@ CB9 AIGH DFC656@M5G " G5=8 95F@=9F KF=H9 C:: GCA9H<=B; :CF H<9 :57H H<5H <9 <=AG9@: 69@CB;98HC H<9 @9GG GI779GG:I@ D5FHM 5B8 K5G D9FGCB5@@M 8=G5DDC=BH98 -<9



PCIHGR :CF C6J=CIG F95GCBG 5F9 5@K5MG ACF9 F58=75@ H<5B H<9 P=BGR IHH<9 ACGH 9GG9BH=5@ H<=B; =B ,K=:H =G <=G =B56=@=HM HC 69@=9J9 H<5H@=:9TCF8=B5FM @=:9 CB H<9 GC@=8 95FH< 5B8 BCH GCA9 F5H=CB5@=N98 89C8CF=N98 J9FG=CB C: =HT7CI@8 69 A589 KCFH< @=J=B; (: 7CIFG9 BC <CB9GH D9FGCB 7@5=AG H<5H <5DD=B9GG =G '(0 5 BCFA5@ 7CB8=H=CB 5ACB; 58I@H <I

A5B 69=B;G 6IH D9F<5DG =H (.% 69 A589 BCFA5@ 5B8 =H =G IDCB H<=GEI9GH=CB H<5H 5@@ G9F=CIG DC@=H=75@ 7CBHFCJ9FGM F95@@M HIFBG ,K=:H <5GAI7< =B 7CAACBTACF9 " 69@=9J9 H<5B <5G 699B BCH=798TK=H< -C@GHCM5BCH<9F 8=G69@=9J9F =B H<9 DCGG=6=@=HM C: <5DD=B9GG "B 6CH< A9B MCI <5J9H<9 G5A9 5B5F7<=GH=7 CIH@CC? 7CJ9F=B; 5B 5IH<CF=H5F=5B 75GH C: A=B8 =B

6CH< 5 G=A=@5F <CGH=@=HM HC ,7=9B79 H<9 G5A9 =AD5H=9B79 K=H< CDDCB9BHGH<9 G5A9 =B56=@=HM HC G99 H<9 =ADCFH5B79 C: 5BM EI9GH=CB BCH =BH9F9GH=B;HC H<9AG9@J9G 5B8 =B 6CH< 75G9G 5 GCFH C: <CFFCF C: H<9 57HI5@ DFC79GG C: @=:9 H<CI;< =B -C@GHCMG 75G9 =H K5G 5FF=J98 5H @5H9F 5B8 =B 5 8=::9F9BHK5M -<9 G9LI5@ IB<5DD=B9GG C: H<9 HKC A9B K5G BCH C: H<9 G5A9 ?=B8

6IH H<9F9 K5G H<=G =B 7CAACB H<5H =B 6CH< C: H<9A 5 G=B79F9 @C5H<=B;K5G A=L98 ID K=H< 5 ACF6=8 :5G7=B5H=CB -C@GHCM K5G 5 F9:CFA98 F5?9K<C 9B898 6M DF957<=B; 7CAD@9H9 79@=657M K<=@9 7CBH=BI=B; HC DF57H=G9H<9 CDDCG=H9 =BHC 9LHF9A9 C@8 5;9 ,K=:H K5G DF9GIA56@M =ADCH9BH 5B8<58 5B 9L5;;9F5H98 <CFFCF C: <IA5B 8IB; <9 5@GC H<CI;<H 56CIH =H =B79GG5BH@M 5G =G 9J=89BH H<FCI;<CIH <=G KCF?G ,I7< D9CD@9 5F9 BCH @=?9@MHC 9B>CM 9J9B H<9 GA5@@ 5ACIBH C: <5DD=B9GG H<5H :5@@G HC ACGH <IA5B 69=B;G 5B8 :FCA C6J=CIG ACH=J9G 5F9 BCH @=?9@M HC 58A=H H<5H 95FH<@M @=:9=G 75D56@9 C: AI7< =ADFCJ9A9BH -<9=F =B7IF=CG=HM 5B8 <9B79 H<9=F =BHC@

9F5B79GDF=B;:FCAH<9G5A9FCCH,K=:HG 8=G;IGH F5B7CIF 5B8 D9GG=A=GA KCI@8 A5?9 G9BG9 5;5=BGH H<9 657?;FCIB8 C: 5 PB9LH KCF@8R HC K<=7< H<=G CB9 =G H<9 DF9@I89 G <98C9G BCH 5DD95F HC 69@=9J9 G9F=CIG@M =B 5BM GI7< H<=B; =H 697CA9G B979GG5FM HC 7CBGHFI7H 5 D5F58=G9 GIDDCG98@M 9L=GH=B; CB H<9 GIF:579 C: H<995FH< 6IH GCA9H<=B; EI=H9 8=::9F9BH :FCA 5BMH<=B; K9 ?BCK K=H< 5@@H<5H <9 8=G5DDFCJ9G C:T@=9G :C@@M 7<5B;9 9BH<IG=5GA D@95GIF9 @CJ9

HH<99B8C:H<96CC?5GHMD=75@GD97=A9BGC:<IA5B:C@@M5B8J=7=CIGB9GG,K=:HB5A9GP5%5KM9F5)=7?DC7?9H5C@CB9@5CC@5%CF855A9GH9F5)C@=H=7=5B5

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



5B8 8=FH T9@=A=B5H98 :FCA =H G <=G =895@ 69=B; <9 7<CCG9G H<9 <CFG9 5B5B=A5@ K<CG9 9L7F9A9BH =G BCH C::9BG=J9 -<9 !CIM<B<BAG 5F9 8F95FM

695GHGTH<=G =G GC ;9B9F5@@M 58A=HH98 H<5H H<9 DC=BH =G BCH KCFH< @56CIF=B; ,K=:HG ;9B=IG 75B A5?9 H<9A 7F98=6@9 6IH H<9F9 75B <5J9 699B J9FM:9K F9589FG =B K<CA H<9M <5J9 9L7=H98 5BM :99@=B; 69MCB8 8=G@=?9 B8

H<=G =G BCH :FCA KCIB898 J5B=HM 5H G99=B; 5B=A5@G DF9:9FF98 HC A9B :CFC: H<9 HKC H<9 !CIM<B<BAG 5F9 AI7< @=?9F HC <IA5B 69=B;G H<5B 5F9H<9 25<CCG 5B8 I@@=J9FG <CFFCF C: H<9 25<CCG HC;9H<9F K=H< <=G F97C;B=H=CB H<5H H<9M 5F9 H<9 G5A9 ?=B8 C: 7F95HIF9 5G <=AG9@: 7CBH5=BG 5 @C;=75@ 56GIF8=HM -<=G <CFFCF 7CA9G IDCB <=A 5H <=G J9FM :=FGH G=;<H C: H<9AP" B9J9F 69<9@8R <9 G5MG P=B 5@@ AM -F5J9@G GC 8=G5;F9956@9 5B B=A5@BCF CB9 5;5=BGH K<=7< " B5HIF5@@M 7CB79=J98 GC GHFCB; 5B BH=D5H<MR IH=B 7CAD5F=GCB K=H< K<5H 5F9 H<9 25<CCG 8=G;IGH=B; 'CH K=H< H<9!CIM<B<BAG 6975IG9 5H H<=G H=A9 I@@=J9F <5G BCH G99B 5 !CIM<B<BA"H 75B CB@M 69 =B 7CAD5F=GCB K=H< <=AG9@: =9 K=H< 5 <IA5B 69=B; %5H9F<CK9J9F K9 5F9 HC 69 HC@8 H<5H H<9 25<CCG + <IA5B 69=B;G 5B8 <IA5B GC7=9HM 697CA9G =BGIDDCFH56@9 HC I@@=J9F 6975IG9 5@@ A9B 5F9 25<CCG "B H<5H 75G9 K<M 8=8 <9 BCH 7CB79=J9 <=G 8=G;IGH C: <IA5B=HM 95F@=9F "B 9::97H K9 5F9 HC@8 H<5H H<9 25<CCG 5F9 :5BH5GH=75@@M 8=::9F9BH :FCAA9B 5B8 M9H 5F9 H<9 G5A9 ,K=:H <5G CJ9FF957<98 <=AG9@: =B <=G :IFM5B8 =G G<CIH=B; 5H <=G :9@@CK7F95HIF9G P2CI 5F9 :=@H<=9F H<5B MCI 5F9R!CK9J9F =H =G =ADCGG=6@9 HC :99@ AI7< GMAD5H<M K=H< H<9 25<CCG 5B8 =H=G BCH 6975IG9 H<9M CDDF9GG H<9 25<CCG H<5H H<9 !CIM<B<BAG 5F9 IB5HHF57H=J9 -<9M 5F9 IB5HHF57H=J9 6975IG9 H<9 P+95GCBR 6M K<=7< H<9M 5F9

;CJ9FB98 =G F95@@M 5 89G=F9 :CF 895H< -<9M 5F9 9L9ADH :FCA @CJ9 :F=9B8G<=D 7IF=CG=HM :95F GCFFCK 5B8T9L79DH =B H<9=F :99@=B;G HCK5F8G H<9 25<CCG K<C C77IDM F5H<9F H<9 G5A9 D@579 =B H<9=F 7CAAIB=HM 5G H<9 #9KG=B '5N= 9FA5BMT 5B;9F 5B8 <5HF98 P-<9M <5J9 BC CB8B9GG :CF H<9=FC@HG CF C@9G 6IH H<9 5F9 H<9M H5?9 =B 98I75H=B; H<9A DFC7998G 9BH=F9@M :FCA H<9 =7H5H9G C: +,('R -<9M @5M GHCF9 6M PF=9B8G<=DR 5B8P9B9JC@9B79R 6IH PH<9G9 5F9 BCH 7CB:=B98 HC D5FH=7I@5F (6>97HG 6IH IB=J9FG5@ HC H<9 K<C@9 +579R -<9M 5@GC J5@I9 7CBJ9FG5H=CB 6IH =B H<9=F 7CBJ9FG5H=CBG H<9F9 5F9 BC 8=::9F9B79G C: CD=B=CB 5B8 PBCH<=B; D5GG98 6IHK<5H K5G IG9:I@ 9LDF9GG98 =B H<9 :9K9GH 5B8 ACGH G=;B=:=75BH 0CF8GR

-<9M DF57H=G9 GHF=7H 6=FH< 7CBHFC@ 957< 7CID@9 DFC8I7=B; HKC C::GDF=B;5B8 H<9F95:H9F 56GH5=B=B; :FCA G9LI5@ =BH9F7CIFG9 -<9=F A5FF=5;9G 5F95FF5B;98 :CF H<9A 6M H<9=F 9@89FG CB 9I;9B=7 DF=B7=D@9G 5B8 H<9=F @5B;I5;9 7CBH5=BG BC KCF8 :CF P@CJ9R =B H<9 G9LI5@ G9BG9 0<9B GCA96C8M8=9G H<9M 75FFM CB 9L57H@M 5G 69:CF9 K=H<CIH :99@=B; 5BM ;F=9: "H K=@@ 69G99B H<5H H<9=F 5=A =G HC 69 5G @=?9 5 7CFDG9 5G =G DCGG=6@9 K<=@9 F9H5=B=B;



D<MG=75@ @=:9 (B9 CF HKC C: H<9=F 7<5F57H9F=GH=7G =H =G HFI9 8C BCH G99A HC 69 GHF=7H@M PF95GCB56@9R =B H<9=F CKB IG5;9 C: H<9 KCF8 -<IG H<9M D@5795 ;F95H J5@I9 BCH CB@M CB D<MG=75@ <5F8=<CC8 6IH CB 5H<@9H=7=GA 5B8H<9M 5F9 89JCH98 HC DC9HFM IH H<9G9 9L79DH=CBG A5M 69 @9GG 5F6=HF5FMH<5B H<9M G99A ,K=:H DFC656@M 9AD<5G=N9G H<9 D<MG=75@ GHF9B;H< C: H<9

!CIM<B<BAG =B CF89F HC A5?9 7@95F H<5H H<9M 7CI@8 B9J9F 69 7CBEI9F98 6M H<9 <5H98 <IA5B F579 K<=@9 5 H5GH9 :CF DC9HFM A5M :=;IF9 5ACB;H<9=F EI5@=H=9G 6975IG9 DC9HFM 5DD95F98 HC ,K=:H 5G H<9 5BH=H<9G=G C: ,7=9B79 :FCA <=G DC=BH C: J=9K H<9 ACGH IG9@9GG C: 5@@ DIFGI=HG "B )5FH """<9 B5A9G P"A5;=B5H=CB 5B7M 5B8 "BJ9BH=CBR 5G 89G=F56@9 :57I@H=9G =BK<=7< H<9 %5DIH5B A5H<9A5H=7=5BG =B GD=H9 C: H<9=F @CJ9 C: AIG=7 K9F9K<C@@M @57?=B; (B9 AIGH F9A9A69F H<5H 5@H<CI;< ,K=:H K5G 5B 58A=F56@9 KF=H9F C: 7CA=7 J9FG9 H<9 ?=B8 C: DC9HFM <9 H<CI;<H J5@I56@9 KCI@8DFC656@M698=857H=7DC9HFM-<9DC9HFMC:H<9!CIM<B<BAG<9G5MG

AIGH 69 5@@CK98 HC 9L79@ H<5H C: 5@@ CH<9F &CFH5@G K<9F9=B H<9 #IGHB9GG C: H<9=F ,=A=@9G 5B8 H<9 &=BIH9B9GG 5G K9@@ 5G 9L57HB9GG C: H<9=F9G7F=DH=CBG 5F9 =B8998 =B=A=H56@9 -<9=F /9FG9G 56CIB8 J9FM AI7< =B

6CH< C: H<9G9 5B8 IGI5@@M 7CBH5=B 9=H<9F GCA9 9L5@H98 'CH=CBG C: F=9B8G<=D 5B8 9B9JC@9B79 CF H<9 )F5=G9G C: H<CG9 K<C K9F9 /=7HCFG =B +579G5B8CH<9F6C8=@ML9F7=G9G

@5G BCH 9J9B H<9 ;9B=IG C: ,K=:H K5G 9EI5@ HC DFC8I7=B; 5 GD97=A9B 6M K<=7< K9 7CI@8 >I8;9 H<9 DC9HFM C: H<9 !CIM<B<BAG IH =H GCIB8G5G H<CI;< =H K9F9 7<=@@M GHI:: =B <9FC=7 7CID@9HG DF9GIA56@M 5B8 BCHG9F=CIG@M=B7CB:@=7HK=H<H<9DF=B7=D@9GC:P+95GCBR

!5DD=B9GG =G BCHCF=CIG@M 8=::=7I@H HC 89G7F=69 5B8 D=7HIF9G C: 5 >IGH5B8 K9@@CF89F98 ,C7=9HM 5F9 G9@8CA 9=H<9F 5HHF57H=J9 CF 7CBJ=B7=B;&CGH 7F95HCFG C: P:5JCIF56@9R .HCD=5G <CK9J9F 5F9 7CB79FB98 HC G<CKK<5H @=:9 7CI@8 69 @=?9 =: =H K9F9 @=J98 ACF9 :I@@M ,K=:H 58JC75H9G 5G=AD@9 F9:IG5@ C: @=:9 >IGH=:M=B; H<=G 6M H<9 7@5=A H<5H P+95GCBR 7CBG=GHG=B H<K5FH=B; MCIF =BGH=B7HG -<9 !CIM<B<BAG 7F95HIF9G K=H<CIH 5 <=GHCFM 7CBH=BI9 :CF ;9B9F5H=CB 5:H9F ;9B9F5H=CB HC @=J9 DFI89BH@M A5=BH5=B=B; H<9=F DCDI@5H=CB 5H 9L57H@M H<9 G5A9 @9J9@ 5JC=8=B; 5@@ D5GG=CBGI::9F=B; :FCA BC 8=G95G9G A99H=B; 895H< =B8=::9F9BH@M HF5=B=B; ID H<9=FMCIB; =B H<9 G5A9 DF=B7=D@9GT5B8 5@@ :CF K<5H "B CF89F H<5H H<9 G5A9

DFC79GG A5M 7CBH=BI9 =B89:=B=H9@M -<9 BCH=CBG H<5H @=:9 <9F9 5B8 BCK =GKCFH< @=J=B; CF H<5H =H 7CI@8 69 A589 KCFH< @=J=B; CF H<5H =H AIGH 69 G57F=:=798 :CF GCA9 :IHIF9 ;CC8 5F9 5@@ 56G9BH -<9 8F95FM KCF@8 C: H<9!CIM<B<BAG K5G 56CIH 5G ;CC8 5 .HCD=5 5G ,K=:H 7CI@8 7CBGHFI7H;F5BH=B; H<5H <9 B9=H<9F 69@=9J98 =B 5 PB9LH KCF@8R BCF 7CI@8 ;9H 5BMD@95GIF9 CIH C: 79FH5=B BCFA5@ 57H=J=H=9G IH =H =G BCH F95@@M G9H ID 5G



GCA9H<=B; 89G=F56@9 =B =HG9@: 6IH 5G H<9 >IGH=:=75H=CB :CF 5BCH<9F 5HH57? CB<IA5B=HM -<9 5=A 5G IGI5@ =G HC <IA=@=5H9 &5B 6M F9A=B8=B; <=A H<5H<9 =G K95? 5B8 F=8=7I@CIG 5B8 56CJ9 5@@ H<5H <9 GH=B?G 5B8 H<9 I@H=A5H9ACH=J9 DFC656@M =G 5 ?=B8 C: 9BJM H<9 9BJM C: H<9 ;<CGH :CF H<9 @=J=B;C: H<9 A5B K<C ?BCKG <9 75BBCH 69 <5DDM :CF H<9 CH<9FG K<CT GC <9

:95FGTA5M 69 5 @=HH@9 <5DD=9F H<5B <=AG9@: -<9 DC@=H=75@ 9LDF9GG=CB C: GI7< 5B CIH@CC? AIGH 69 9=H<9F F957H=CB5FM CF B=<=@=GH=7 6975IG9 H<9 D9FGCB K<C <C@8G =H K=@@ K5BH HC DF9J9BH ,C7=9HM :FCA 89J9@CD=B; =B GCA98=F97H=CB =B K<=7< <=G D9GG=A=GA A5M 69 7<95H98 (B9 75B 8C H<=G 9=H<9F

6M 6@CK=B; 9J9FMH<=B; HC D=979G CF 6M 5J9FH=B; GC7=5@ 7<5B;9 ,K=:H I@H=A5H9@M 6@9K 9J9FMH<=B; HC D=979G =B H<9 CB@M K5M H<5H K5G :95G=6@9 69:CF9H<9 5HCA=7 6CA6TH<5H =G <9 K9BH A58T6IH 5G " <5J9 HF=98 HC G<CK <=GDC@=H=75@5=AGK9F9CBH<9K<C@9F957H=CB5FMCB9G

FCA K<5H " <5J9 KF=HH9B =H A5M <5J9 G99A98 H<5H " 5A "',-,K=:H 5B8 H<5H AM C6>97H =G HC F9:IH9 <=A 5B8 9J9B HC 69@=HH@9 <=A "B 5DC@=H=75@ 5B8 ACF5@ G9BG9 " 5A 5;5=BGH <=A GC :5F 5G " IB89FGH5B8 <=A29H 7IF=CIG@M 9BCI;< <9 =G CB9 C: H<9 KF=H9FG " 58A=F9 K=H< @95GH F9G9FJ95B8 .%%"/+, -+/%, =B D5FH=7I@5F =G 5 6CC? K<=7< =H G99AG =ADCGG=6@9 :CF A9 HC ;FCK H=F98 C: " F958 =H :=FGH K<9B " K5G 9=;<HT CB985M G<CFH C: 9=;<H HC 69 9L57H :CF " GHC@9 5B8 :IFH=J9@M F958 H<9 7CDMK<=7< K5G HC 69 ;=J9B A9 B9LH 85M CB AM 9=;<H< 6=FH<85MT5B8 " <5J979FH5=B@M BCH F958 =H @9GG H<5B <5@: 5 8CN9B H=A9G G=B79 "HG :5G7=B5H=CBG99AG =B9L<5IGH=6@9 ": " <58 HC A5?9 5 @=GH C: G=L 6CC?G K<=7< K9F9 HC 69DF9G9FJ98 K<9B 5@@ CH<9FG K9F9 89GHFCM98 " KCI@8 79FH5=B@M DIH

.%%"/+, -+/%, 5ACB; H<9A -<=G F5=G9G H<9 EI9GH=CB K<5H =GH<9 F9@5H=CBG<=D 69HK99B 5;F99A9BH K=H< 5 KF=H9FG CD=B=CBG 5B8 9B>CMA9BHC:<=GKCF?

": CB9 =G 75D56@9 C: =BH9@@97HI5@ 89H57<A9BH CB9 75B )+"/ A9F=H=B 5 KF=H9F K<CA CB9 899D@M 8=G5;F99G K=H< 6IH '#(2&'- =G 5 8=::9F9BH A5HH9F ,IDDCG=B; H<5H H<9F9 =G GI7< 5 H<=B; 5G ;CC8 CF 658 5FHH<9B H<9 ;CC8B9GG CF 658B9GG AIGH F9G=89 =B H<9 KCF? C: 5FH =HG9@:TBCH=B89D9B89BH@M C: H<9 C6G9FJ9F =B8998 6IH =B89D9B89BH@M C: H<9 ACC8 C: H<9 C6G9FJ9F "B CB9 G9BG9 H<9F9:CF9 =H 75BBCH 69 HFI9 H<5H 5 DC9A =G;CC8 CB &CB85M 5B8 658 CB -I9G85M IH =: CB9 >I8;9G H<9 DC9A 6M H<9

5DDF97=5H=CB =H 5FCIG9G H<9B =H 75B 79FH5=B@M 69 HFI9 6975IG9 5DDF97=5H=CB CF 9B>CMA9BH =G 5 GI6>97H=J9 7CB8=H=CB K<=7< 75BBCH 69 7CAA5B898 CF 5 ;F95H 895@ C: <=G K5?=B; @=:9 9J9B H<9 ACGH 7I@H=J5H98 D9FGCB <5G BC 59GH<9H=7 :99@=B;G K<5H9J9F 5B8 H<9 DCK9F HC <5J9 59GH<9H=7:99@=B;G =G J9FM 95G=@M 89GHFCM98 0<9B MCI 5F9 :F=;<H9B98 CF <IB;FM CF5F9 GI::9F=B; :FCA HCCH<57<9 CF G95G=7?B9GG $"' %+ =G BC 69HH9F



:FCA MCIF DC=BH C: J=9K H<5B )-+ )' 2CI A5M ?BCK =B 5B =BH9@@97HI5@ G9BG9 H<5H =H =G 69HH9F 6IH H<5H =G G=AD@M 5 :57H K<=7< MCI F9A9A69FMCI K=@@ BCH % H<9 A9F=H C: $"' %+ IBH=@ MCI 5F9 BCFA5@ 5;5=BB8 59GH<9H=7 >I8;9A9BH 75B 69 IDG9H >IGH 5G 8=G5GHFCIG@MTACF9 8=G5GHFCIG@M 6975IG9 H<9 75IG9 =G @9GG F958=@M F97C;B=N98T6M DC@=H=75@ CF

ACF5@ 8=G5;F99A9BH ": 5 6CC? 5B;9FG KCIB8G CF 5@5FAG MCI H<9B MCIK=@@ BCH 9B>CM =H K<5H9J9F =HG A9F=HG A5M 69 ": =H G99AG HC MCI 5 F95@@MD9FB=7=CIG 6CC? @=?9@M HC =B:@I9B79 CH<9F D9CD@9 =B GCA9 IB89G=F56@9K5M H<9B MCI K=@@ DFC656@M 7CBGHFI7H 5B 59GH<9H=7 H<9CFM HC G<CK H<5H =H!, BC A9F=HG IFF9BH @=H9F5FM 7F=H=7=GA 7CBG=GHG EI=H9 @5F;9@M C: H<=G?=B8 C: 8C8;=B; HC 5B8 :FC 69HK99B HKC G9HG C: GH5B85F8G B8 M9H H<9CDDCG=H9 DFC79GG 75B 5@GC <5DD9B 9B>CMA9BH 75B CJ9FK<9@A 8=G5DDFCJ5@ 9J9B H<CI;< CB9 7@95F@M F97C;B=N9G H<5H CB9 =G 9B>CM=B; GCA9H<=B; =B=A=75@ ,K=:H K<CG9 KCF@8J=9K =G GC D97I@=5F@M IB5779DH56@9 6IH K<C=G B9J9FH<9@9GG 5B 9LHF9A9@M DCDI@5F KF=H9F =G 5 ;CC8 =BGH5B79 C: H<=G0<M =G =H H<5H K9 8CBH A=B8 69=B; 75@@98 25<CCG 5@H<CI;< :=FA@M 7CBJ=B798H<5HK95F9'(-25<CCG

"H =G BCH 9BCI;< HC A5?9 H<9 IGI5@ 5BGK9F H<5H C: 7CIFG9 ,K=:H K5GKFCB; =B :57H <9 K5G =BG5B9 6IH <9 K5G P5 ;CC8 KF=H9FR "H =G HFI9 H<5HH<9 @=H9F5FM EI5@=HM C: 5 6CC? =G HC GCA9 GA5@@ 9LH9BH G9D5F56@9 :FCA =HGGI6>97HA5HH9F ,CA9 D9CD@9 <5J9 5 B5H=J9 ;=:H :CF IG=B; KCF8G 5G GCA9D9CD@9 <5J9 5 B5HIF5@@M P;CC8 9M9R 5H ;5A9G "H =G @5F;9@M 5 EI9GH=CB C: H=A=B; 5B8 C: =BGH=B7H=J9@M ?BCK=B; <CK AI7< 9AD<5G=G HC IG9 G 5B9L5AD@9 B95F 5H <5B8 @CC? 657? 5H H<9 D5GG5;9 " EICH98 95F@=9F GH5FH=B;

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

G<C7?=B; &=@@=CBG C: D9CD@9 =B A5BM 7CIBHF=9G AIGH <5J9 9B>CM98.%%"/+, -+/%, K<=@9 ACF9 CF @9GG G99=B; =HG 5BH=<IA5B =AD@=75H=CBG 5B8 9J9B H<9 7<=@8 K<C 5779DHG )5FHG = 5B8 == 5G 5 G=AD@9 GHCFM;9HG 5 G9BG9 C: 56GIF8=HM :FCA H<=B?=B; C: <IA5B 69=B;G G=L =B7<9G <=;<-<9 9LD@5B5H=CB AIGH 69 H<5H ,K=:HG KCF@8J=9K =G :9@H HC 69 '(- 5@HC;9H<9F :5@G9TCF =H KCI@8 DFC656@M 69 ACF9 577IF5H9 HC G5M BCH :5@G9 5@@



H<9 H=A9 ,K=:H =G 5 8=G95G98 KF=H9F !9 F9A5=BG D9FA5B9BH@M =B 5 89DF9GG98 ACC8 K<=7< =B ACGH D9CD@9 =G CB@M =BH9FA=HH9BH F5H<9F 5GH<CI;< GCA9CB9 GI::9F=B; :FCA >5IB8=79 CF H<9 5:H9F9::97HG C: =B:@I9BN5G<CI@8 <5J9 H<9 9B9F;M HC KF=H9 6CC?G IH K9 5@@ ?BCK H<5H ACC8 5B8GCA9H<=B; =B IG F9GDCB8G HC H<9 9LDF9GG=CB C: =H -5?9 :CF =BGH5B79 CB9

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

G99 6CH< <CFFCF 5B8 D5=B 5F9 B979GG5FM HC H<9 7CBH=BI5B79 C: @=:9 CB H<=GD@5B9H 5B8 =H =G H<9F9:CF9 CD9B HC D9GG=A=GHG @=?9 ,K=:H HC G5M P": <CFFCF5B8 D5=B AIGH 5@K5MG 69 K=H< IG <CK 75B @=:9 69 G=;B=:=75BH@M =ADFCJ98R !=G 5HH=HI89 =G =B 9::97H H<9 <F=GH=5B 5HH=HI89 A=BIG H<9 6F=69C: 5 PB9LH KCF@8RTK<=7< <CK9J9F DFC656@M <5G @9GG <C@8 IDCB H<9A=B8G C: 69@=9J9FG H<5B H<9 7CBJ=7H=CB H<5H H<=G KCF@8 =G 5 J5@9 C: H95FG



5B8 H<9 ;F5J9 =G 5 D@579 C: F9GH "H =G " 5A 79FH5=B 5 KFCB; 5HH=HI89 5B8CB9 K<=7< 7CI@8 <5J9 <5FA:I@ 9::97HG IDCB 69<5J=CIF 6IH GCA9H<=B; =BIG F9GDCB8G HC =H 5G =H F9GDCB8G HC H<9 ;@CCAM KCF8G C: H<9 6IF=5@ G9FJ=795B8H<9GK99H=G<GA9@@C:7CFDG9G=B57CIBHFM7<IF7<

"H =G C:H9B 5F;I98 5H @95GH 6M D9CD@9 K<C 58A=H H<9 =ADCFH5B79 C:

GI6>97HA5HH9F H<5H 5 6CC? 75BBCH 69 P;CC8R =: =H 9LDF9GG9G 5 D5@D56@M:5@G9 J=9K C: @=:9 09 5F9 HC@8 H<5H =B CIF CKB 5;9 :CF =BGH5B79 5BM 6CC?H<5H <5G ;9BI=B9 @=H9F5FM A9F=H K=@@ 5@GC 69 ACF9 CF @9GG PDFC;F9GG=J9R =BH9B89B7M -<=G =;BCF9G H<9 :57H H<5H H<FCI;<CIH <=GHCFM 5 G=A=@5F GHFI;;@9

69HK99B DFC;F9GG 5B8 F957H=CB <5G 699B F5;=B; 5B8 H<5H H<9 69GH 6CC?GC: 5BM CB9 5;9 <5J9 5@K5MG 699B KF=HH9B :FCA G9J9F5@ 8=::9F9BH J=9KDC=BHG GCA9 C: H<9A D5@D56@M ACF9 :5@G9 H<5B CH<9FG "B GC :5F 5G 5KF=H9F =G 5 DFCD5;5B8=GH H<9 ACGH CB9 75B 5G? C: <=A =G H<5H <9 G<5@@;9BI=B9@M 69@=9J9 =B K<5H <9 =G G5M=B; 5B8 H<5H =H G<5@@ BCH 69 GCA9H<=B;

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

-<9 8IF56=@=HM C: .%%"/+, -+/%, ;C9G HC G<CK H<5H =: H<9 :CF79C: 69@=9: =G 69<=B8 =H 5 KCF@8J=9K K<=7< CB@M >IGH D5GG9G H<9 H9GH C: G5B=HM=GGI::=7=9BHHCDFC8I795;F95HKCF?C:5FH



"%"

,CBG5B8%CJ9FG%!!#&!-<9 H<=F8 DI6@=G<98 BCJ9@ C: ! %5KF9B79 H5?9B 6M A5BM HC 69 <=G

95F@=9GH A5GH9FD=979 H9@@G H<9 GHCFM C: )5I@ &CF9@ 5 MCIB; A5B 5B8 6I8

8=B; 5FH=GH +=7<5F8 @8=B;HCB 9LD@5=BG H<9 G9A=5IHC6=C;F5D<=75@ B5HIF9C:<=GA5GH9FD=9790<9B MCI <5J9 9LD9F=9B798 ,CBG 5B8 %CJ9FG MCI <5J9 @=J98 H<FCI;<H<9 5;CB=9G C: H<9 MCIB; %5KF9B79 GHF=J=B; HC K=B :F99 :FCA <=G C@8 @=:9O9B9F5@@M =H =G BCH CB@M 7CBG=89F98 5G 5B 9JC75H=J9 DCFHF5M5@ C: KCF?=B;7@5GG @=:9 =B 5 A=B=B; 7CAAIB=HM 6IH 5@GC 5B =BH9BG9 GHI8M C: :5A=@M7@5GG5B895F@MG9LI5@F9@5H=CBG<=DG

-<9CIBHC:&CBH9F=GHC'!$"-<9 CIBH C: &CBH9 F=GHC F9B7< %9 CAH9 89 &CBH9F=GHC =G 5B

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

79FB98 K=H< H<9A9G C: <CD9 >IGH=79 J9B;95B79 A9F7M :CF;=J9B9GG 5B8895H<5B8=GHC@8=BH<9GHM@9C:5B58J9BHIF9GHCFM

-<9FH=7@9GC:CB:989F5H=CB!-<9 FH=7@9G C: CB:989F5H=CB 5B8 )9FD9HI5@ .B=CB 7CAACB@M F9

:9FF98 HC 5G H<9 FH=7@9G C: CB:989F5H=CB K5G H<9 :=FGH 7CBGH=HIH=CB C: H<9H<=FH99B .B=H98 ,H5H9G C: A9F=75 -<9 ,97CB8 CBH=B9BH5@ CB;F9GG 5DDC=BH98 5 7CAA=HH99 HC 8F5:H H<9 OFH=7@9GO =B #IB9 5B8 DFCDCG98 H<98F5:H HC H<9 ,H5H9G :CF F5H=:=75H=CB =B 'CJ9A69F -<9 F5H=:=75H=CB DFC79GG K5G 7CAD@9H98 =B &5F7< @9;5@@M :989F5H=B; H<9 GCJ9F9=;B 5B8

=B89D9B89BH GH5H9G 5@@=98 IB89F H<9 FH=7@9G C: GGC7=5H=CB =BHC 5 B9K:989F5H=CB GHM@98 H<9 .B=H98 ,H5H9G C: A9F=75 .B89F H<9 FH=7@9G H<9GH5H9G F9H5=B98 GCJ9F9=;BHM CJ9F 5@@ ;CJ9FBA9BH5@ :IB7H=CBG BCH GD97=:=75@@MF9@=BEI=G<98HCH<979BHF5@;CJ9FBA9BH

&5FG=F@ !!#(



&5FG =F@ =G F9A=B=G79BH C: $IFH /CBB9;IHOG 95F@M G5H=F9 3"HOG4 5 6=N5FF9 G5H=F=75@ FCAD H<5H C::9FG 5 ;@=ADG9 =BHC H<9 A98=5 5B8 DC@=H=7G C: 5 :IHIF9 H<5H =G DFC656@M B95F9F H<5B ACGH KCI@8 @=?9 HC 58A=H =HM)I@G9%5BG=B;&=7<=;5B

F95H=J9CAACBG%=79BG9

-<=G KCF? =G @=79BG98 IB89F 5 F95H=J9 CAACBG HHF=6IH=CB'[email protected]%=79BG92CI 5F9 :F99 HC 8CKB@C58 5B8 8=GHF=6IH9 &5FG =F@ K=H< 5HHF=6IH=CB :CFBCB7CAA9F7=5@DIFDCG9G

KKKA5FG;=F@IG

566=HH !&""B H<=G G5F8CB=7 DCFHF5=H C: H<9 ID5B87CA=B; A=88@9 7@5GG 8IF=B; H<9

DFCGD9FCIG G ,=B7@5=F %9K=G D9F:97H@M 75DHIF9G H<9GCIB8 H<9 :99@ 5B8 H<9 5HH=HI89G C: H<9 ;9B9F5H=CB H<5H 7F95H98 H<9 7I@H C: 7CBGIA9F=GA 0=H< 5 G<5FD 9M9 :CF 89H5=@ 5B8 ?99B DCK9FG C: C6G9FJ5H=CB %9K=G HF57?G GI779GG:I@ F95@HCF 9CF;9 566=HHOG 85=@M GHFI;;@9G HCF=G9 HC H<9 HCD C: <=G DFC:9GG=CB K<=@9 A5=BH5=B=B; <=G F9DIH5H=CB 5G 5BIDGH5B8=B;:5A=@MA5B(B H<9 GIF:579 566=HH 5DD95FG HC 69 H<9 EI=BH9GG9BH=5@ A=88@97@5GG 9A

6C8=A9BH C: 7CBG9FJ5H=J9 J5@I9G 5B8 9BH<IG=5GA :CF H<9 K9@@HC8C @=:9GHM@9 C: H<9 GA5@@ 9BHF9DF9B9IF IH 69B95H< H<9 7CAD@579BH :57589 <95@GC 9LD9F=9B79G 5 F=G=B; B5A9@9GG 8=G7CBH9BH -<9G9 :99@=B;G 9J9BHI5@@M@958 566=HH =BHC F=G?M 9G75D589G H<5H H<F95H9B <=G :5A=@M 5B8 <=G GH5B8

=B;=BH<97CAAIB=HM

)9H9F)5B)9H9F5B809B8M !!)9H9F )5B CF -<9 CM 0<C 0CI@8BOH FCK .D 5B8 )9H9F 5B8 09B8M

5F9 H<9 GH5;9 D@5M 5B8 BCJ9@ F9GD97H=J9@M K<=7< H9@@ H<9 GHCFM C: )9H9F)5B 5 A=G7<=9JCIG @=HH@9 6CM K<C 75B :@M 5B8 <=G 58J9BHIF9G CB H<9 =G@5B8 C: '9J9F@5B8 K=H< 09B8M 5F@=B; 5B8 <9F 6FCH<9FG H<9 :5=FM-=B?9F 9@@ H<9 %CGH CMG H<9 "B8=5B DF=B79GG -=;9F %=@M 5B8 H<9 D=F5H95DH5=B !CC? -<9 GHCFM K5G KF=HH9B 6M ,7CHH=G< D@5MKF=;<H 5B8 BCJ9@=GH

#&5FF=9=BGD=F986M<=G:F=9B8G<=DK=H<H<9%@9K9@MB5J=9G:5A=@M

-<9K5?9B=B;(H<9F,<CFH,HCF=9G#-<9 K5?9B=B; G<C7?98 HIFBC:H<979BHIFM F9589FG K=H< =HG :CFH<

F=;<H HF95HA9BH C: G9L 5B8 GI=7=89 9D5FH=B; :FCA @=H9F5FM 7CBJ9BH=CB$5H9 <CD=B :5=@98 HC 7CB89AB <9F <9FC=B9OG 89G=F9 :CF 5B 5::5=F K=H< H<9GCB C: 5 %CI=G=5B5 F9GCFH CKB9F K<CA G<9 A99HG CB J575H=CB -<9



DCK9F C: G9BGI5@=HM H<9 89@IG=CB C: 97GH5H=7 @CJ9 5B8 H<9 GC@=HI89 H<5H577CAD5B=9G H<9 HF5DD=B;G C: A=88@9 5B8 IDD9F7@5GG @=:9 5F9 H<9 H<9A9GC: H<=G BCK7@5GG=7 BCJ9@ G $5M9 =66CBG DC=BHG CIH =B <9F "BHFC8I7H=CB <CD=B K5G KF=H=B; A9F=75B F95@=GA 69:CF9 ACGH A9F=75BG7CI@8695FHC<95FH<5HH<9MK9F9@=J=B;=H

-<9/=75FC:05?9:=9@8%!"#F )F=AFCG9 <=G K=:9 96CF5< 5B8 H<9=F G=L 7<=@8F9B @=J9 5B =8M@@=7 @=:9

=B 5 7CIBHFM D5F=G< -<9 J=75F =G K9@@C:: 8I9 HC =BJ9GH=B; 5B =B<9F=H5B79<9 F979=J98 :FCA 5 89795G98 F9@5H=J9 5B8 H<9 J=75F 8CB5H9G H<9 DCIB8G H<5H <=G >C6 D5MG 5BBI5@@M HC @C75@ CFD<5BG 5B8 K5F J9H9F5BG (BH<9 9J9B=B; C: <=G GCB 9CF;9OG K988=B; HC K95@H<M F569@@5 0=@ACHH<9 J=75F @CG9G 5@@ <=G ACB9M H<FCI;< H<9 65B?FIDH7M C: <=G A9F7<5BH =BJ9GHCFK<C@9:HHCKBK=H<<=GACB9M

0IH<9F=B;!9=;<HG (!#) 0IH<9F=B; !9=;<HG =G A=@M FCBHUOG CB@M BCJ9@ "H K5G :=FGH DI6@=G<98

=B IB89F H<9 DG9I8CBMA @@=G 9@@ 5B8 5 DCGH<IACIG G97CB8 98=H=CB K5G 98=H98 6M <9F G=GH9F <5F@CHH9 -<9 B5A9 C: H<9 BCJ9@ 7CA9G:FCA H<9 2CF?G<=F9 A5BCF CB H<9 ACCFG CB K<=7< H<9 GHCFM 79BHF9G 5G 5B58>97H=J9 KIH<9F=B; =G 5 2CF?G<=F9 KCF8 F9:9FF=B; HC HIF6I@9BH K95H<9F-<9 B5FF5H=J9 H9@@G H<9 H5@9 C: H<9 5@@9B7CAD5GG=B; 5B8 D5GG=CB5H9 M9HH<K5FH98 @CJ9 69HK99B !95H<7@=:: 5B8 5H<9F=B9 5FBG<5K 5B8 <CKH<=G IBF9GC@J98 D5GG=CB 9J9BHI5@@M 89GHFCMG H<9A 5B8 A5BM 5FCIB8

H<9A

,H5F&5?9F#0=89@M F9;5F898 5G CB9 C: H<9 HFI9 7@5GG=7G C: G7=9B79 :=7H=CB ,H5F

&5?9F =G 5 DC9H=7 5B8 899D@M D<=@CGCD<=75@ KCF? -<9 GHCFM 89H5=@G H<9A9BH5@ >CIFB9M C: 5B IBB5A98 B5FF5HCF K<C =G HF5BGDCFH98 BCH CB@M HCCH<9F KCF@8G 6IH 5@GC CH<9F ;5@5L=9G 5B8 D5F5@@9@ IB=J9FG9G IBH=@ <99J9BHI5@@M 697CA9G D5FH C: H<9 7CGA=7 A=B8 =FGH DI6@=G<98 =B (@5: ,H5D@98CBOG 89G7F=DH=CBG C: 5@=9B @=:9 5F9 5 DC@=H=75@ 7CAA9BH5FM CB<IA5B @=:9 =B H<9 HIF6I@9BH =BH9FK5F M95FG -<9 6CC? 7<5@@9B;9G DF97CB

79=J98 BCH=CBG C: =BH9@@=;9B79 5B8 5K5F9B9GG 5B8 I@H=A5H9@M 5F;I9G :CF 5 6FC589B98 D9FGD97H=J9 H<5H KCI@8 :F99 IG :FCA 7I@HIF5@@M =B;F5=B98H<CI;<H 5B8 CIF =B9J=H56@9 5BH<FCDCACFD<=GA -<=G =G H<9 :=FGH G7<C@5F@M98=H=CB C: 5 6CC? H<5H =B:@I9B798 GI7< KF=H9FG 5G , %9K=G 5B8 FH<IF@5F?95B8K<=7<#CF;9%I=GCF;9G75@@985DFC8=;=CIGBCJ9@



&&&"CC8:CFH<9A=B8

george orwell - politics vs. litterature an examination of gullivers travels[1]

Documents