getting the iot into tesco: internet of things ux for the mass market - iot 14

26
Getting the IoT into Tesco or: IoT user experience for the mass market Tesco Toton by Roger Claire Rowland/@clurr BLN Internet of Things 2014 Wednesday, 16 April 14

Upload: claire-rowland

Post on 17-Aug-2014

2.614 views

Category:

Design


1 download

DESCRIPTION

My slides from the BLN IoT14 conference. (I'm not affiliated with Tesco btw... it's just a title the conference suggested).

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Getting the IoT into Tescoor: IoT user experience for the mass market

Tesco Toton by Roger

Claire Rowland/@clurrBLN Internet of Things 2014

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 2: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Hello :)

- Independent UX and product consultant

- O’Reilly author: “UX design for the consumer internet of things” (due end 2014)

Previously :- Service design manager for AlertMe- Head of research at Fjord- Smarcos: EU consortium researching

interusability of interconnected embedded devices

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 3: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

photo by steven de polophoto by lyzadanger

photo by nickpophoto by david ward

Consumers are a very challenging audience for IoT

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Before I worked in IoT, a lot of my design and research experience was with consumers, and I got interested in how new technology becomes mass market. In my IoT work, I deliberately focused on research and testing with people who were not early adopters, and this talk is informed by what I learned from them.

One thing I definitely learned was that the kind of mundane day to day activities to which many consumer products relate are some of the most socially complex and interesting things to design for, therefore it’s really easy to get things wrong.

In many respects, consumers are the most difficult audience for a complex new technology. Upshot: The IoT is still tech led and still not quite ready for consumer primetime. There are still many technical challenges but there is also a lot we don’t know about design.

Page 4: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Mass market products should- Solve a real problem

people have (value)- Offer a good solution

(desirable, usable)- Come at a cost

(financial, effort) that feels in proportion to the value

Wednesday, 16 April 14

What makes compelling mass market product?

Many examples in home automation going back up to 40 years of systems that never managed to convince people en masse that what they did was worth the money and effort to install.

This is x10 powerhouse for the commodore 64 from 1986, allowed you to control appliances, lights, heating from any phone. this system is nearly 30 years old and we’re not all using it, but those are exactly the same kind of things about which people are still getting excited on Kickstarter :)

Page 5: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

UX for IoT is not just UI and industrial design

UI/visual designscreen layout, look and feel

Platform designdiscovery, control and coordination for interconnected devices and services

Service designcustomer lifecycle, customer services, integration with non digital touchpoints

Productisationaudience, proposition, objectives, functionality of a specific service

Industrial designphysical hardware: capabilities

and form factor

Interaction designarchitecture and behaviours per

service, per device

Interusabilityinteractions spanning multiple

devices with different capabilities

Conceptual modelHow should users think about the

system?

Many different layers of design shape the end user experience

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Platform design is concerned with discovery, control and coordination experiences for interconnected devices and services. A complicated one that’s a whole talk in itself... think of it as the UX angle on interoperability.

Page 6: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

UX for IoT is different...We don’t (yet) expect Things to behave like the Internet

The average consumer is going to find it very strange when objects take time to respond, or lose instructions.

Wednesday, 16 April 14

In addition to the complexity of the design thinking required, also some inherent challenges putting the internet into things.

We accept latency on the internet. It’s out of our control. We also accept a little bit of unreliability. We know that web pages may be slow to respond, and that Skype calls fail. We don’t like it, but we accept it.

It’s not normal for this to happen in the physical world. We expect physical things to respond immediately and reliably.

But when you put internet latency/reliability into physical objects, that might not happen. Over the internet, your lights might take 2 minutes to come on. We’re going to have to be careful how we design this and what promises we make, or it will just feel broken.

Page 7: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

3 key guidelines for successful consumer IoT products:-Solve a tangible problem-Keep the conceptual model simple-Make distributed interactions feel coherent

Wednesday, 16 April 14

There are lots of things we could talk about, like setup experiences, service experience, industrial design, interface design for embedded devices, platforms.

For the sake of time I’ve picked 3 fundamental guidelines that provide a framework for much of the UX:

Page 8: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Solve a tangible problemWhat does it do? Why would I want it?

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 9: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

In areas where they don’t have expert knowledge or are short on time

consumers need products, not tools

Product Tool

Wednesday, 16 April 14

The majority market is used to buying products that make a promise to solve a specific problem and come reasonably well configured to solve it.

Page 10: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Nest do productisation really wellWednesday, 16 April 14

Leaving aside recent problems with user interaction, the Nest protect advertising is very interesting: it doesn’t talk about connectivity at all, it’s all about how it is a better smoke/CO alarm.

Page 11: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Belkin’s mobile app is good, buta connected socket is a tool that requires users to solve their own problems

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Belkin WeMo has a pretty good UX, but is essentially an example of a tool: something that requires end users to define and solve own problems.

It requires an imaginative leap even to think about what you might do with it. Tools can be powerful things, and empowering more people to use them is a great aim. But they require a lot of attention invested and I’d argue most majority consumers won’t have space for more than a couple of these things in their lives.

Page 12: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

This, though, is a great idea

Wednesday, 16 April 14

WeMo Crockpot slow cooker, out this spring

Phone app allows you to adjust temperature, change timings, turn it on and off remotely.

There’s a clear benefit, and the remote control aspect fits perfectly with context of use of a slow cooker: left running in house whilst you’re out.

Page 13: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Simple conceptual modelThe user’s understanding of how it works, and what it can do

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 14: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Conceptual models should be simple

Wednesday, 16 April 14

A conceptual model is the user’s understanding of how something works and what it can do.

Page 15: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Connectedness requires users to think about system models

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Connectedness adds in additional complexity. There are extra bits. Some of the infrastructure devices are not very transparent in function: what do they DO? A hub is a mysterious box to many people.

There are more things that can lose power or connectivity and more places where code can run. All of those have implications as to how the system works.

In the case of a lighting system with automated rules that turn lights on and off at different times, in order to predict whether it will still run if your internet connection goes down, you essentially have to know where the code governing those rules runs. If it’s on your phone or in the cloud, then it won’t; if it’s in a hub it will.

Page 16: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Beware the surprise packageTaking a successful mass market product and making it back into an early adopter productScott Jenson, ‘The Simplicity Shift’

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 17: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

You can try to explain the system model...

BERG Cloud bridge: transparent network comms

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 18: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

...but users shouldn’t have to understand exactly how a complex system works in order to be able to use it successfully

Wednesday, 16 April 14

You have to explicitly design conceptual models, it’s not just about getting people to understand the way that you have built the system

Learn what they need and design to fit the way people currently think: existing knowledge, behaviours and beliefs

Page 19: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Coherence across distributed interactionsInterusability: distributed UX

Cross-Platform Service User Experience: A Field Study and an Initial Framework. Minna Wäljas, Katarina Segerståhl, Kaisa Väänänen-Vainio-Mattila, Harri Oinas-Kukkonen MobileHCI'10

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 20: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

vs

CompositionDistribute functionality to suit the context of use

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Tado thermostat has no UI, it’s all on the phone. Keeps bill of materials down as UI components are expensive. Making a good phone UI is relatively cheap. It’s an elegant choice but has limitations: if you don’t have your phone to hand, or it’s not working, or you’re a guest in the house without access to the phone UI, you can’t adjust the heating.

This is the old AlertMe I worked on: a standard thermostat with phone and web apps, which are easier to use (the one you see here looks rather plain as it’s an unbranded version). This means that you, and your guests or other residents without smartphones, can still use it as a conventional thermostat. Both approaches have value in different contexts.

Page 21: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

ConsistencyCreate device-appropriate interfaces that feel like a family

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Nest example: rotating bezel on wall thermostat makes clicking noise as you turn it. The touchscreen interface uses up and down arrows to control temperature (rotational controls are inefficient and inaccurate on touchscreens), but still makes the same click.

Page 22: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Continuity

Create fluent cross platform interactions... BERG Cloudwash prototype

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 23: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

19

2 min delay21

...ensure data is up to date on all platforms if possible

Constrained devices often suffer discontinuities

iphone by daniel, cloud by edward boatman, router by joe harrison, thermometer by ashley reinke, radiator and boiler by axeny virtinsky

Wednesday, 16 April 14

A lot of the knottiest design problems I’ve run into in my work are continuity challenges. It sounds obvious: If i interact with the service on one device, I would expect all other devices reflect that change in state. e.g. if I turn the target heating temperature up on my wall thermostat, you’d expect the new temperature to be immediately reflected on the smartphone too.

But sometimes this isn’t technically possible.

Many heating controllers in the UK are battery powered, and sending data to the network uses a lot of power, so they only connect intermittently. It’s possible to have a delay of up to two minutes before which a command sent from a smartphone is registered by a heating controller, during which time the two devices appear to be giving different information about the status of the system.

This breaks fundamental usability principles.

Page 24: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Good consumer UX for IoT is deceptively hard

A final thought

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 25: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Tesler’s law of the conservation of complexity:

As you make the user interaction simpler you make things more complicated for the designer or engineerLarry Tesler, former VP of Apple

Wednesday, 16 April 14

Page 26: Getting the IoT into Tesco: Internet of things UX for the mass market -  IoT 14

Thank you@[email protected]

Wednesday, 16 April 14