gf,;f sjlzq9 gfulzsm df8[ sfg}gl ;[jfvmf imhgf4 z€¦ · l;wwf\tmgm :jlsfz szjfdf\ vfjimp tfp !,l...
TRANSCRIPT
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 1
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!&
!P!P!P!P 5}J"E}lDSF5}J"E}lDSF5}J"E}lDSF5}J"E}lDSF ovovovov
!P! JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGM V[S V,FINM ;D}C K[P! T[DGL 5F;[ 7FG VG[
VG]EJGM E\0FZ K[4 KTF\ 36F lS:;FVMDF\ T[DG[ CF\l;IFDF
WS[,L N[JFDF\ VFJ[ K[ VG[ VFHGL I]JF 5[-L JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[
;DFH p5Z AMHM U6L T[DGL VJU6GF SZ[ K[P JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGM
;D}C V[S ;DFG GYL CMTMP T[DGFDF\ 36F\ AWF TOFJT HMJF
D/[ K[P H[JF S[4 JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF ;D}CDF\H p\DZGM TOFJT4
XFZLlZS VG[ DFGl;S ;T"STFG]\ :TZ VG[ SFD SZJFGL 1FDTF
JU[Z[P
!PZ K[<,F 36F JQFM"DF\ lJ7FGGL 5|UlTGF SFZ6[ ;Z[ZFX
VFI]QIDF\ GM\W5F+ JWFZM YIM K[P JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[GL
ZFQ8=LI GLlT4 Z_!! DF\ H6FjIF D]HA ccJ:TL lJQFIS
~5Z[BF NXF"J[ K[ S[4 JQF" Z___ YL Z_5_ NZdIFG EFZTGL S],
J:TLDF\ 55@ GM JWFZM YX[P HIFZ[ &_ JQF" S[ T[YL JW] p\DZGF
JIH}YDF\ #Z&@ GM JWFZM YX[ VG[ (_ JQF"YL JW]GF
JIH}YDF\ ;F{YL JWFZ[ v V[8,[ S[ *__@ GM JWFZM YX[Pcc lJ`JGL
!q( J'wW J:TL EFZTDF\ J;[ K[P CSLSTDF\ J'wW jIlSTVMGL
J:TLDF\4 JQF" !)5! DF\ ,UEU Z SZM0YL JQF" Z__! DF\ *PZ
SZM0GM JWFZM GM\WFIM CTM VG[ T[ J:TL JQF" Z_!! DF\ !_P#(
SZM0 CTLP VFD4 (@ J:TLGL p\DZ &_ JQF"YL JW] K[P &_ JQF"YL
!PGM\W o VF IMHGFDF\ &_ JQF" S[ T[YL JW] p\DZGL jIlSTVMG[ cJlZQ9 GFUlZSc U6JFDF\ VFJ[, K[
VG[ XaNM H[JF S[ c J'wW GFUlZSc 4 ccDM8L p\DZGL jIlSTVMcc ;DFG VYL" TZLS[ JF5Z[, K[P
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 2
JWFZ[ p\DZGF jIlSTVMGL ;F{YL JW] 8SFJFZL S[ZF,F ZFHIDF\ K[P
ZFHIGL S], J:TLDF\ J'wW GFUlZSGL ;\bIF !ZP55@ K[P &_
JQF" S[ T[YL JW]GF JIH}YDF\ :+LVMGL ;\bIF JW] K[P H[DF\
Z_!!GL J:TL U6+L D]HA :+LVMGL ;\bIF 54Z*4**4!&( GL
;ZBFD6LV[ 5]~QFMGL ;\bIF 54!_4*!4(*Z CTLP
!P# JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ ;\bIFA\W VG[ VGMBL ;FDFlHS4 XFZLlZS4 DFGl;S
VG[ VFlY"S ;D:IFVMGM ;FDGM SZJM 50[ K[P VFlY"S ;D:IFG\]
SFZ6 GMSZL U]DFJJFG]\ CM. XS[4 H[DGF ,LW[ VFJSGM VEFJ
VG[ VFlY"S V;]Z1FF 5[NF YFI K[P XFZLlZS ;D:IFVMDF\
VFZMuI VG[ TALAL ;D:IFGM ;DFJ[X YFI K[P SF{8]\lAS
VFWFZGM VEFJ VG[ ;FDFlHS lJ;\JFlNTF H[JL ;FDFlHS
;D:IF CM. XS[P ;]Z1FF 56 J'wW jIlSTVM DF8[ V[S DCtJGM
D]–M K[P ;\I]ST S]8]\AGF lJEFHGGF ,LW[ VF ;D:IFVMDF\
JWFZM YIM K[ VG[ JW]G[ JW] J'wW jIlSTVMG[ TZKM0L N[JFDF\ VFJL
ZCIF K[P S]8]\AGF SDFTF ;eIM UFD0FDF\YL XC[ZM TZO :Y/F\TZ
SZL ZCIF K[P T[YL U|FdI lJ:TFZGL :+LVM VG[ J'wW jIlSTVMG[
JW] D]xS[,LVMGM ;FDGM SZJM 50[ K[P
!P$ J'wWM 5Z jIJl:YT VG[ ;TT N]jI"JCFZGF 5]ZFJF 56 K[P H[JF
S[4 XFZLlZS 4 EFJGFtDS VG[ DFGl;S jIYF 5CM\RF0JLP V0WFYL
p5ZF\T J'wWM V5DFG VG[ p5[1FF p5ZF\T VFJF N]jI"JCFZMGM EMU
AG[ K[P G[XG, S|F.D Z[S0" aI]ZM sV[GP;LPVFZPALPf GF
VC[JF, VG];FZ HFgI]VFZL Z_!$ YL VMS8MAZ Z_!$ ;]WLDF\
JlZQ9 GFUlZSM lJ~wWGF U]GFGF S], ()*# S[;M GM\WFIF
CTFP NZ[S ;DFH VG[ ZFHI JlZQ9 GFUlZSGF VD]S CSSMGM
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 3
:JLSFZ SZ[ K[P H[ ;DFHGF VgI ;eIMGF CSSM SZTF V,U K[P
!P5P JQF" !)$( YL J'WtJGM D]–M ;DI[ ;DI[ ;\I]ST ZFQ8=DF\
p9FJJFDF\ VFjIM K[P JQF" !)(Z DF\ J'WtJ p5Z lJ`J
;\D[,G lJI[GFDF\ IMHJFDF\ VFjI]\ CT]\P H[DF\ J'wWtJ
V\U[GF VF\TZZFQ8=LI 5U,FGL IMHGF :JLSFZJFDF\ VFJL CTLP
T[GM D]bI p–[X J'wWMGL BF; H~ZLIFT VG[ lCTG[ wIFGDF\ ZFBL
N[XGL J:TLGL p\DZDF\ YTF JWFZFG[ 5CM\RL J/JF DF8[ NZ[S
N[XGL 1FDTFGM lJSF; SZJFGM K[P JQF" !))! DF\ JlZQ9
GFUlZSMGL :JT\+TF4 EFULNFZL4 SF/HL4 DMEM VG[ 5|lTQ9FG[
wIFGDF\ ZFBL ;\I]ST ZFQ8=GL ;FDFgI ;EF £FZF VD]S
l;wWF\TMGM :JLSFZ SZJFDF\ VFjIMP TFP !,L VMS8MAZ G[ J'wWM
DF8[ VF\TZZFQ8=LI J'wWtJ lNJ; TZLS[ HFC[Z SZJFDF\ VFjIM K[
VG[ CJ[ T[G[ J'wW jIlSTVM DF8[GM VF\TZZFQ8=LI J'wWtJ lNJ;
TZLS[ VM/BJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
ZP ZP ZP ZP AAAA\\\\WFZ6LI AFWFZ6LI AFWFZ6LI AFWFZ6LI AF\\\\C[WZLC[WZLC[WZLC[WZL ovovovov
ZP! EFZTGF A\WFZ6GM VG]rK[N Z! HLJG HLJJFGM VG[ jIlST
:JT\+TFGF VlWSFZGL AF\IWZL VF5[ K[P T[GF VY"DF\ UF{ZJ
;FY[ HLJG HLJJFGF VlWSFZGM ;FDFJ[X YFI K[ VG[ T[ JlZQ9
GFUlZSGF UF{ZJ ;FY[ HLJG HLJJFGF VlWSFZG[ VFJZL ,[ K[P
A\WFZ6G]\ VG]rK[N $! V[J]\ 5|:YFl5T SZ[ K[ S[ VFlY"S ;wWZTF
VG[ lJSF;G[ GHZ ;D1F ZFBL A[ZMHUFZL4 J'wWtJ4 lADFZL VG[
V5\UTF TYF VgI DHA}ZLGF lS:;FDF\ SFD SZJFGF4
E6JFGF TYF HFC[Z ;CFI D[/JJFGF VlWSFZMGF Z1F6 DF8[
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 4
ZFHI IMuI 5U,F ,[X[P VG]rK[N $& ZFHI p5Z CSFZFtDS
HJFANFZL D}S[[ K[ S[ T[ GA/F JU"GF VFlY"S lJSF;GL lJX[QF
;\EF/ ,[X[ VG[ T[DG[ ;FDFlHS VgIFI VG[ VgI TDFD
5|SFZGF XMQF6 ;FD[ Z1F6 5]Z\] 5F0X[P VG]rK[N $! VG[ $& GM
;DFJ[X ZFHI GLlTGF DFU"NX"S l;\wWF\TMDF\ YFI K[4 H[G]\
SFINFGL SM8" £FZF 5F,G SZFJL XSFT] GYL KTF\ T[ ZFHI p5Z
CSFZFtDS HJFANFZL D}S[[ K[ VG[ T[ N[XGF JlCJ8DF\ VlT
DCtJGF K[P
ZPZP A\WFZ6GL ;FTDL VG];}lRGL ZFHI IFNLGL GM\W ) VG[ ;DJTL"
;}lRGL GM\W Z_4 Z# VG[ Z$ J'wWFJ:YF 5[gXG4 ;FDFHLS ;]Z1FF
VG[ ;FDFlHS JLDM TYF VFlY"S VG[ ;FDFlHS VFIMHG lJX[ K[P
;DJTL" ;}lRGL GM\W Z$ BF; SZLG[ cc DH}Z S<IF64 SFI" :Y/GL
5lZl:YlT 4 ElJQIlGlW s5|MlJ0g8 O\0f4 SFDNFZ J/TZGL
HJFANFZL4 VXSTTF4 J'wWFJ:YF 5[gXG TYF 5|;}lT ,FEcc lJX[
K[P VFD4 J'wWFJ:YF DF8[ 36L AWL A\WFZ6LI GM\WM K[P
#P #P #P #P SFINFSLI DF/B]SFINFSLI DF/B]SFINFSLI DF/B]SFINFSLI DF/B]\\\\ ovovovov
#P! CF, 5|JT"DFG DM8F EFUGF SFINFVM DFvAF5GF HLJG
lGJF"CGL HMUJF. SZJF lJX[ K[ VG[ T[DF\ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGM
RMSS; p<,[B SZJFDF\ VFjIM GYLP lCgN] SFINF D]HA 5F{ZF6LS
;DIYL 5]+ p5Z HJFANFZL D}SJFDF\ VFJL K[ S[ T[ 5MTFGF
DFvAF54 H[VM 5MTFG]\ HLJG lGJF"C G R,FJL XS[4 T[DGL
;FZ;\EF/ ZFB[P lCgN] NœS VG[ EZ65MQF6 WFZM4 !)5& D]HA
J'wW VG[ lADFZ DFvAF5G[ 5MTFGF 5]+ VG[ 5]+L TZOYL
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 5
BFWFBMZFSL D[/JJFGM VlWSFZ K[P V[ XZT[ S[ DFvAF5 5MTFGL
VFJS TYF lD<STDF\YL 5MTFGM HLJG lGJF"C G R,FJL XSTF CMIP
D]:,LD 5;"G, ,M AF/SM p5Z HJFANFZL D}S[[ K[ S[4 DFvAF5
5MTFGL ZLT[ SDF6L SZJF ;1FD CMJFKTF\ ;FDFgI
;HMUMDF\ ;\TFGM T[VMGF DFTF l5TFG]\ EZ65MQF6 SZ[ TYF
H[ T[ jIlSTGL HJFANFZL K[ S[4 H[D T[ 5MTFGF UZLA l5TFG]\
EZ65MQF6 SZ[ K[4 T[JL H ZLT[ HM T[GF NFNF NFNL S[ GFGF GFGL
UZLA CMI TM H4 T[DG]\ EZ65MQF6 SZ[[P
#PZ OMHNFZL SFI"ZLlT ;\lCTF4 !)*# GL S,D !Z5 YL !Z( DFTF
S[ l5TFG[ VlWSFZ VF5[ K[ S[4 HM T[VM 5MTFGM HLJG lGJF"C G R,FJL
XSTF CMI TM T[VM 5MTFGF 5]bT 5]+ q 5]+L H[VM DFvAF5GL
p5[1FF SZ[ K[ VYJF T[DG]\ EZ65MQF6 SZJFGM .gSFZ SZ[ K[
T[DGL 5F;[YL EZ65MQF6 DF\UL XSX[P VF V[S WD"lGZ5[1F SFINM
K[ VG[ T[ AWFH WDM"G[ ,FU] 50[ K[P HM SM. jIlST H[GL lJ~wW VFN[X
VF5JFDF\ VFjIM K[ T[ IMuI SFZ6 l;JFI EZ65MQF6GL
ZSD R}SJJFDF\ lGQO/ HFI TM4 SFI"5F,G VZHL NFB, SZL
XSFI K[ VG[ VFN[XGM VGFNZ SZJF DF8[ SM8" N\0 56 SZL XS[ K[
VG[ H[ T[ jIlSTG[ H[,GL ;HF 56 SZL XSFI K[P T[JL H ZLT[ HM
DFTF 3Z[,] lC\;FGM EMU AG[ TM T[ 3Z[,] lC\;F ;FD[ :+LVMG[
Z1F6 WFZM4 Z__5 D]HA 5MTFGF 5]+ ;FD[ VZHL NFB, SZL XS[
VG[ VF SFINFDF\ VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, V,U V,U NFN D[/JL
XS[P
#P#P JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF CSSMGF Z1F6GL H~ZLIFTG[ wIFG[ ZFBL TYF
A\WFZ6LI C[T]VMG[ VFU/ JWFZJF DF8[ DFTF l5TF VG[ JlZQ9
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 6
GFUlZSGF EZ65MQF6 VG[ S<IF6 DF8[GM SFINM4 Z__*
30JFDF\ VFjIM K[P VF SFINF D]HAPPP
sVf cDFvAF5c V[8,[ S[ DFTF VYJF l5TF H[DF\ S]NZTL4 NœS
,[GFZ S[ ;FJSL DFTF TYF ;FJSF l5TFGM ;DFJ[X YFI K[P
VG[ PPP
sAf cJlZQ9 GFUlZSc V[8,[ S[ &_ JQF" S[ T[YL JW] p\DZGL jIlST4
EZ65MQF6GL VZHL NFB, SZL XS[ K[P VFJL EZ65MQF6GL
VZHLPPPPP
sVf DFTFl5TF S[ NFNF NFNL 5MTFGF V[S S[ V[SYL JWFZ[
;\TFGM V[8,[ S[ 5]+4 5]+L4 5F{+ VG[ 5F{+L H[VM ;ULZ G
CMI4 T[DGL lJ~wW NFB, SZL XSX[P
VG[PP
sAf lGo;\TFG JlZQ9 GFUlZS 5MTFGF ;UF V[8,[ S[ SFG}GL
JFZ; H[ ;ULZ GYL VG[ H[ CF,DF\ T[DGL lD<STGM
SAHM WZFJ[ K[ VYJF T[DGF D'tI] 5KL H[ T[DGL
lD<STGM JFZ;NFZ AGX[4 T[GL lJ~wW VFJL VZHL
NFB, SZL XSX[P
VF SFINF V\TU"T EZ65MQF6GF S[;M ;F\E/JF VG[ T[GM
lGSF, SZJF DF8[ NZ[S TF,]SF :TZ[ V[S VYJF V[SYL JWFZ[
8=LaI]G,GL :YF5GF SZJFGL TYF 8=LaI]G,GF VFN[X lJ~wW
NFB, SZJFDF\ VFJTL V5L,GL ;]GFJ6L DF8[ NZ[S lH<,F :TZ[
V[S V[5[,[8 8=LaI]G,GL :YF5GF SZJFGL HMUJF. SZJFDF\ VFJL
K[P DCtJG]\ K[ S[ VF SFINF D]HA EZ65MQF6 D[/JJFGM
VlWSFZ H[ jIlSTGL TZO[6DF\ DFvAF5 q JlZQ9 GFUlZSGL lD<ST
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 7
TANL, SZJFDF\ VFJL K[ VG[ H[GL TZO[6DF\ lD<ST TANL,
Y. K[ T[G[ VF VlWSFZGL HF6 CMI TM H T[GL lJ~wWDF\
VD, SZL XSFI VYJF HM VFJL TANL,L J6DF\UL CMI TM
VFJM VlWSFZ4 TANL,L H[GL TZO[6DF\ SZJFDF\ VFJL K[ T[G[ HM
VFJF VlWSFZGL HF6 G CMI TM4 T[GL lJ~wWDF\ VD, G SZL
XSFIP HIFZ[ JlZQ9 GFUlZS[ lD<ST A1FL; S[ VgI SM. ZLT[ V[
XZT[ TANL, SZL CMI S[ TANL, ,[GFZ TANL, VF5GFZG[
D}/E}T ;]lJWFVM VG[ XFZLlZS H~ZLIFTM 5}ZL 5F0X[ VG[ HM
TANL, ,[GFZ VFJL ;]lJWFVM S[ XFZLlZS H~ZLIFTM 5}ZL 5F0JFGM
.gSFZ SZ[ S[ lGQO/ HFI tIFZ[ 8=LaI]G, JlZQ9 GFUlZS £FZF
SZJFDF\ VFJ[,L VFJL TAlN,L4 TANL, SZGFZGL DZHL YL
ZNAFT, SZL XS[P
#P$ VF SFINFGL DCtJGL lJX[QFTF V[ K[ S[ HM SM. jIlST 5MTFGL
;\EF/ VG[ Z1F6DF\ ZC[,F JlZQ9 GFUlZSG[ TZKM0[ TM T[ U]GM
AG[ K[ VG[ VFJF U]GF DF8[ DCœD +6 DlCGFGL H[, VYJF
~FP54___qv ;]WLGM N\0 VYJF A\G[GL ;HFGL HMUJF. K[P JlZQ9
GFUlZSGL lH\NUL VG[ lD<STGF Z1F6 DF8[ TYF T[DG[ D/L GF
XS[ T[JL HuIFV[ TZKM0L N[TF V8SFJJF DF8[ VF V[S DCtJGL
HMUJF. K[P VF SFINF V\TU"T4
v UZLA JlZQ9 GFUlZSM H[VMGL 5F;[ 5}ZTF 5{;F G CMI
T[DGF DF8[ J'wWFzD :YF5JFGL HMUJF. K[P
v V[JL 56 HMUJF. SZJFDF\ VFJL K[ S[4 ZFHI ;ZSFZ
;]lGl`RT SZX[ S[ ;ZSFZL CMl:58, TYF ;ZSFZ TZOYL
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 8
5}Z[5}Z]\ VYJF VF\lXS E\0M/ D[/JTL CMl:58, £FZF
JlZQ9 GFUlZS DF8[ 5YFZL 5]ZL 5F0JFDF\ VFJ[ VG[ JlZQ9
GFUlZSM DF8[ pEF ZC[JF V,U ,F.GGL jIJ:YF
SZJFDF\ VFJ[ VG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ C9L,F4 HLJ,[6 TYF
D8L G XS[ T[JL lADFZLDF\ IMuI ;FZJFZ D/L ZC[P
$P $P $P $P JlZQJlZQJlZQJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[GL ;ZSFZL IMHGFVM ov9 GFUlZSM DF8[GL ;ZSFZL IMHGFVM ov9 GFUlZSM DF8[GL ;ZSFZL IMHGFVM ov9 GFUlZSM DF8[GL ;ZSFZL IMHGFVM ov
$P! S[gN= ;ZSFZGF V,U V,U D\+F,I £FZF JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[
H]NL H]NL IMHGFVM ACFZ 5F0JFDF\ VFJ[, K[P JlZQ9 GFUlZSM
DF8[GL ZFQ8=LI GLlTGM D]bI C[T] JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ D]bI
WFZFDF\ ,FJJFGM4 5MTFGF 3ZDF\H S[ 5MTFGL HuIFV[ H
J'wWtJDF\ 5|J[X SZJFGL lJRFZWFZFG[ 5|Mt;FCG VF5JFGM4
ZC[6F\SGL jIJ:YF4 VFJS ;]Z1FF TYF ;FZ;\EF/GL ;[JF 5}ZL
5F0JFGM4 J'wWFJ:YF 5[gXG VG[ VFZMuI JLDF IMHGF H[JL
;[JF VF5JFGM TYF J'wWFJ:YFG]\ UF{ZJ H/JFI T[ DF8[
VgI SFI"S|D VG[ ;[JFVM 5}ZL 5F0JFGM K[P JlZQ9 GFUlZSM
DF8[GL IMHGFVM GLR[ D]HA K[P
!P J'wWM DF8[GF ;\Sl,T SFI"S|D V\TU"T J'wWFzD4 0[ S[Z ;[g8Z
VG[ DMAF., NJFBFGFGL :YF5GF TYF HF/J6L DF8[
TYF J'wWMG[ lAG ;\:YFSLI ;[JFVM 5}ZL 5F0JF DF8[ lAG
;ZSFZL ;\:YFG[ 5lZIMHGFGF BR"GL )_@ ;]WLGL VFlY"S
;CFI VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
ZP VFJSJ[ZFDF\ J/TZ4 VFJSJ[ZF WFZM4 !)&! GL S,D
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 9
(_ v0L V\TU"T VFZMuI JLDF l5|lDID ~FP
#_4___qv ;]WLGL S5FT4JlZQ9 GFUlZS DF8[ lGlN"Q8 SZFI[,
lADFZLVMGL ;FZJFZ DF8[ ~FP &_4___qv GL S5FT4
VFJSJ[ZF ZL8G" EZTL JBT[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ V,U
,F.G VG[ :Y/ p5Z H RSF;6LGL ;[JFVMP
#P cJlZQ9 GFUlZS ART IMHGFc V\TU"T &_ JQF" S[ T[YL JW]
p\DZGF GFUlZSM ART A[\SG]\ SFI" SZTL 5M:8 VMlO;DF\
~FP !4___qv S[ T[GF U]6F\SDF\ 5{;F HDF SZFJL XS[ K[P
H[GL p5Z JFlQF"S ) @ jIFH D/[ K[ VG[ VF YF56GL 5FSJFGL
D]–œ 5F\R JQF"GL K[ H[G[ ALHF +6 JQF" ;]WL ,\AFJL XSFI
K[P &5 JQF" S[ T[YL JW] p\DZGF JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ ART
IMHGF 5Z JWFZ[ jIFH NZ D/L XS[ K[P
$P .lgNZF UF\WL ZFQ8=LI J'wWFJ:YF 5[gXG IMHGF V\TU"T
UZLAL Z[BF GL[R[ VFJTF &_ JQF" YL JW] p\DZGF JlZQ9
GFUlZSG[ ~FP Z__qv VG[ (_ JQF"YL JW] p\DZGF JlZQ9
GFUlZSG[ ~FP 5__qv G]\ DFl;S 5[gXG VF5JF DF8[ S[gN=
;ZSFZ TZOYL ;CFI VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[ VG[ VF
;CFIDF\ ZFHI ;ZSFZ £FZF 56 T[8,L H ZSDGM OF/M
VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ T[JL V5[1FF ZFBJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
5P .SMGMDL JU"GL VF\TlZS CJF. D];FOZL DF8[ 5|FZ\lES
EF0FDF\ K]8KF8 VG[ lJDFGDF\ A[;JF DF8[ VlU|DTFP
&P JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ Z[<J[GF NZ[S JU"DF\ ZFCT4 GLR[GF
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 10
AY"DF\ VlU|DTF4 l8lS8 BZLNJF q lZhJ["XG VYJF ZN
SZFJJF DF8[ V,U SFpg8ZGL jIJ:YF4 TYF NZ[S H\SXG4
lH<,F D]bI DYSM TYF VgI DCtJGF :8[XGM p5Z
JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF p5IMU DF8[ jCL,R[ZGL jIJ:YFP
*P ZFHI JFCG jIJCFZ lGUD £FZF R,FJJFDF\ VFJTL
A;MDF\ VFU/GL CZM/DF\ A[ A[9S JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[
VGFDT ZFBJL VG[ EF0FDF\ 56 ZFCTP
(P JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ CMl:58,DF\ S[; S-FJJF DF8[ TYF
TALAL RSF;6L DF8[ V,U ,F.G TYF SL0GL4 ÕNI4
0FIFlA8L; TYF VF\BGL ALDFZLGL ;FZJFZDF\ ZFCTP
)P V\tIMNI IMHGF V\TU"T H[ UZLAL Z[BF GLR[GF
sALP5LPV[,Pf S]8]\ADF\ JlZQ9 GFUlZS CMI T[DG[ ZFCT NZ[
S]8]\A NL9 NZ DlCG[ #5 lS,M VGFH VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
ALP5LPV[,P JU"GF &_ JQF"YL JW] p\DZGF jIlSTVMG[
VM/BDF\ VlU|DTF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
!_P ZFHIM VG[ ;\3 5|N[XM £FZF VD,L cVgG5}6F" IMHGFc
V\TU"T H[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ J'wWFJ:YF 5[gXGGM ,FE GYL
D?IM T[DG[ jIlST NL9 NZ DlCG[ !_ lS,M VGFH lJGF D}<I[
VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
!! P jIFHAL EFJGL N]SFGDF\ &_ JQF"YL DM8L pDZGF Z[XG SF0"
WFZSMG[ Z[XG VF5JFDF\ VlU|DTFP
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 11
!ZP N}Z;\RFZ D\+F,I £FZF 8[l,OMG HM0F6 VF5JFDF\
VlU|DTF VG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZS £FZF SZJFDF\ VFJ[,L BFDL
V\U[GL q VgI OlZIFNG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZS JU"DF\
JLPVF.P5LP O,[U VF5L NFB, SZL VlU|DTF VF5JLP
$PZ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF S[;MGF h05L lGSF, DF8[ SM8M"DF\ 56
VlU|DTF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[P DFlCTL VlWSFZ VlWlGID4 Z__5
V\TU"T JlZQ9 GFUlZS £FZF NFB, SZFI[, ALHL V5L,G[ prR
VU|TF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[P
$P# 36F AWF ZFHIMV[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF lCT DF8[ BF; SZLG[ T[VMG[
Z1F6 5}~ 5F0JF DF8[ 5MTFGL IMHGFVM VG[ SFI"S|DM 30IF K[P
$P$ JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ 36L AWL SFG}GL HMUJF.VM VG[ IMHGFVM
CMJF KTF\ T[GM ,FE AC] VMKF JlZQ9 GFUlZSM ;]WL 5CM\rIM
K[P 36L JBT JlZQ9 GFUlZSM 5MTFGF CSSMYL VHF6 CMI K[
VG[ q VYJF T[VM V[8,F AWF lGZFWFZ CMI K[ S[ T[VM VF
,FE ,. XSTF GYLP T[DGL OST lD<ST H 50FJL ,[JFDF\ GYL
VFJTL 5Z\T] T[DG[ AWFH 5|SFZGL C[ZFGUlT SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[4 H[
T[DG[ UF{ZJCLG AGFJ[ K[P lJWJF JlZQ9 GFUlZSM VYJF ;[JF
lGJ'T JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ 5MTFGF 5[gXG VG[ VgI ,FEM
D[/JJF N]QSZ AGL HFI K[P SFINFVM VG[ IMHGFVM JlZQ9
GFUlZSMG[ CSSM VF5[ K[ VG[ HM JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ VF SFINF VG[
IMHGFVM V\TU"T T[DGF CSSM D[/JJFDF\ D]xS[,L 50[ TM
cGF,;FcG]\ V[J]\ DFGJ]\ K[ S[ VF 5lZl:YlTDF\ SFG}GL ;[JF
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 12
;\:YFVMV[ VUtIGM EFU EHJJM HM.V[ VG[ VF ;\:YFVM
JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ IMHGFVM VG[ SFG}GL HMUJF.VMGM ,FE D/[ T[
DF8[ 5FIFGL E}lDSF EHJL XS[P
$P5 SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/ VlWlGID4 !)(* G]\ VFD]B V[ JFT
p5Z EFZ D}S[ K[ S[4 SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/M ;DFHGF GA/F
JUM" ;FY[ ;\A\lWT K[ VG[ SM. GFUlZS SM. SFZ6 VYJF VFlY"S S[
VgI V1FDTFG[ SFZ6[ gIFI D[/JJFGL TSMYL J\lRT G ZCL
HFI T[ HMJFGL T[DGL OZH K[P SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/
VlWlGID4 !)(* GL S,D $sBf VgJI[ SFG}GL ;[JFVM p5,aW
SZFJJF DF8[4 S[gN=LI ;œF D\0/ V[8,[ S[ ZFQ8=LI SFG}GL ;[JF
;œF D\0/G[ ;F{YL JW] V;ZSFZS VG[ VFlY"S IMHGFVM 30JF DF8[
HJFANFZL ;M\5JFDF\ VFJ[, K[P p5ZF\T4 S,D $s-f S[gN=LI
;œFD\0/G[ ,MSMDF\ SFG}GL ;F1FZTF VG[ SFG}GL HFU'lT O[,FJJF
DF8[ IMuI 5U,F\ ,[JF DF8[ OZH 5F0[ K[ VG[ BF; SZLG[
;DFHGF GA/F JU"GF ,MSMG[ ;DFH S<IF6 SFINFVM VG[
VgI SFINFVM TYF JCLJ8L SFI"S|DM TYF IMHGFVM äFZF
VF5JFDF\ VFJTF CSSM4 ,FEM VG[ lJX[QFFlWSFZMGL DFlCTL
VF5JLP T[JL H ZLT[ S,D *sUf C[9/4 ZFHI ;œF D\0/ V[8,[
S[ ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/GL SFI" lGJFZS VG[ jI}CFtDS
SFG}GL ;CFI SFI"S|DM CFY WZJFGL OZH K[P VF ZLT[4
SFINM 5MT[ SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/G[ SFINFVM VG[ lJlJW JCLJ8L
5U,FVM VG[ SFI"S|DM lJX[ SFINFSLI HFU'lT O[,FJJF VG[
lGJFZS VG[ jI}CFtDS SFI"S|DM CFY WZJFGL OZH 5F0[ K[P
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 13
5P 5P 5P 5P IMHGFG]IMHGFG]IMHGFG]IMHGFG]\\\\ GFDGFDGFDGFD ovovovov
5P! VF IMHGF GF,;F s JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4
Z_!& SC[JFX[P
5PZ VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JS4 SFG}GL ;[JFVM4 lS,lGS VG[ 5[G, V[0JMS[8
H[JF XaNMGF VY" ZFQ8=LI SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/ slGoX]<S VG[
;1FD SFG}GL ;[JFVMf lGIDM4 Z_!_ VG[ ZFQ8=LI SFG}GL ;[JF
;œF D\0/ sSFG}GL ;[JF lS,lGSf lGIDM4 Z_!! VG[ VW" SFG}GL
:JI\;[JSM DF8[GL GF,;F IMHGF s;]WFZ[,f DF\ H6FJ[,
jIFbIFVM D]HA ZC[X[P
&P &P &P &P IMHGFGF p–[XMIMHGFGF p–[XMIMHGFGF p–[XMIMHGFGF p–[XM ovovovov
VF IMHGFGF D]bI p–[XM GLR[ D]HA K[P
! P JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ D/JF5F+ D}/E}T VlWSFZM TYF ;CFIGL
~5Z[BF T{IFZ SZJLP
ZP SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/ VlWlGID4 !)(* Z GL S,Dv!Z D]HA4
JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;CFI VG[ 5|lTlGlWtJG[ ZFQ8=LI4
ZFHI4 lH<,F VG[ TF,]SF S1FFV[ DHA}T AGFJJL S[ H[YL 5|JT"DFG
lJlJW SFG}GL HMUJF.VMGM ,FE ,. XSFIP ZP GMZP GMZP GMZP GM\\ \\W oW oW oW o SFG}GL ;CFI D[/JJF DF8[ IMuITF V\U[GF DF5N\0 SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/ VlWlGID4
!)(* GL S,Dv !Z DF\ VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, K[P VF SFINFGL S,Dv!Z D]HA AWLH :+LVM4 H[DF\ JlZQ9 GFUlZS :+LVMGM ;DFJ[X Y. HFI K[4 SFG}GL ;CFI D[/JJF CSSNFZ K[ VG[ S,Dv!Z DF\ H6FJ[, SM.56 JU"DF\ ;DFlJQ9 jIlSTVM4 H[DF\ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGM ;DFJ[X YFI K[4 T[VM SFG}GL ;CFI D[/JJF CSSNFZ K[P VFD KTF\4 JlZQ9 GFUlZSMDF\ VgI ;[JFVM H[JL S[4 ;ZSFZL IMHGFVMGM ,FE D[/JJFDF\ DNNSTF" YFI T[ DF8[ SFG}GL HFU'TTF O[,FJL XSFX[P
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 14
#P JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ H]NL H]NL ;ZSFZL IMHGFVM VG[ SFI"S|DMGM ,FE
D/[ T[ ;]lGl`lRT SZJ]\P
$P ;œF D\0/M TYF DFTF l5TF VG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF
EZ65MQF6 VG[ S<IF6 DF8[GM SFINM4 Z__* V\TU"T 8=LaI]G,
VG[ V[5[,[8 8=LaI]G, ;\:YFVMV[ s.g:8L8I]Xg;[f JlZQ9 GFUlZSM
DF8[ J'wWFzDGL :YF5GF YFI T[ ;]lGl`RT SZJ]\P
5P JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ H]NFH]NF SFINFVM TYF ;ZSFZL IMHGFVM VG[
SFI"S|DM V\TU"T D/JF5F+ CSSM TYF VlWSFZM lJX[ lH<,F SFG}GL
;[JF ;œFD\0/M4 TF,]SF SFG}GL ;[JF ;lDlTVM4 5[G, JSL,M4
VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSM4 lJnFYL"VM VG[ SFG}GL ;CFITF lS,lGSM
£FZF HFU'lT O[,FJJLP
&P TF,LD4 VlEUD,1FL VG[ ;\J[NGFtDS SFI"S|DM IMHLG[ 5[G, JSL,M4
VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSM4 SFG}GL ;CFITF lS,lGSMGF :JI\;[JSM4
lJlJW IMHGFVMGF VD, ;FY[ ;\S/FI[,F ;ZSFZL VlWSFZLVM4
;[JF VF5GFZFVM4 5M,L; VG[ lAG ;ZSFZL ;\:YFVMGL SFI"1FDTF
JWFZJLP
*P V,U V,U IMHGFVM VG[ SFINFVMGF VeIF; DF8[ ;\XMWG
VG[ N:TFJ[HLSZ6 SZJ]\P H[YL +}8LVM VG[ p5IMlUTF XMWL
XSFI TYF IMuI ;œFD\0/G[ ;]WFZF ;}RJL XSFIP
VF IMHGFGM V\lTD p–[X V[ ;]lGl`RT SZJFGM K[ S[4 JlZQ9
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 15
GFUlZSM ;gDFG5}J"S HLJG HLJL XS[ VG[ T[VMG[ D/JF5F+ ,FEM VG[
;]lJWFVM D[/JL XS[P
*P*P*P*P SFI" IMHGFSFI" IMHGFSFI" IMHGFSFI" IMHGF ovovovov
*P*P*P*P!!!! 8=LaI8=LaI8=LaI8=LaI]]]]G,4 V5L, 8=G,4 V5L, 8=G,4 V5L, 8=G,4 V5L, 8=LLLLaI]G,GL :YF5GF ovaI]G,GL :YF5GF ovaI]G,GL :YF5GF ovaI]G,GL :YF5GF ov
JlZQ9 GFUlZSM 5MTFGF CSS DF\UL XS[ T[ DF8[ V[ H~ZL K[ S[
VF SFINF VgJI[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL ;CFI DF8[ GSSL SZJFDF\
VFJ[,L ;\:YFVMGL :YF5GF YFIP
sSf DFTF l5TF VG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ EZ65MQF6 VG[
S<IF6 VlWlGID4 Z__* GL S,Dv* DF\ EZ65MQF6GF
S[;M ;F\E/JF VG[ T[GM lGSF, SZJF DF8[ NZ[S TF,]SF :TZ[
V[S S[ V[SYL JWFZ[ 8=LaI]G,GL :YF5GF SZJFGL HMUJF. K[P
VF SFINFGL S,Dv!5 DF\ 8=LaI]G,GF VFN[X lJ~wW
V5L, 8=LaI]G, :YF5JFGL HMUJF. K[P ZFHI SFG}GL
;[JF ;tTF D\0/ VG[ lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ VF
SFINFGF VFN[X D]HA ZFHI ;ZSFZG[ 8=LaI]G, VG[
V5L, 8=LaI]G, :YF5JFGF D]–[ TFSLNGF WMZ6[ ZH}VFT
SZX[P
sBf DFTF l5TF VG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ EZ65MQF6 VG[
S<IF6 VlWlGID4 Z__* GL S,Dv!) DF\ VlS\RG
JlZQ9 GFUlZS V[8,[ S[ V[JF JlZQ9 GFUlZSM S[ H[VM ZFHI
;ZSFZ £FZF ;DI[ ;DI[ GSSL SIF" D]HA 5MTFG]\
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 16
EZ65MQF6 SZL G XS[ T[8,L V5}ZTL VFJS WZFJTF CMI
T[DG[ DF8[ 5]ZTL ;\bIFDF\ J'wWFzD :YF5JFGF D]–[
ZH}VFT SZX[P ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ VG[ lH<,F
SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ v ;LPV[;PVFZP V\TU"T VlS\RG
JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ J'wWFzDGL :YF5GF SZJFGL
XSITFVMGL RSF;6L SZX[P
sUf JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ 5}ZTL ;]lJWF D/L ZCL K[ TYF T[DGL ;FY[
;gDFGGLI jIJCFZ SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[ T[ ;]lGl`RT SZJF
ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ £FZF J'wWFzDGL lGIlDT
D],FSFT ,[JFGL ZC[X[P
*PZ*PZ*PZ*PZ SFG}SFG}SFG}SFG}GL ;CFITF GL ;CFITF GL ;CFITF GL ;CFITF lS,lGSMlS,lGSMlS,lGSMlS,lGSM ovovovov
sSf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ DFTF l5TF VG[ JlZQ9
GFUlZSMGF EZ65MQF6 VG[ S<IF6GM SFINM v Z__* C[9/
:YFl5T YI[, NZ[S 5\R VG[ V5L, 5\RM BFT[ TYF
J'wWFzD BFT[ SFG}GL ;CFITF lS,lGSMGL :YF5GF SZX[P
sBf CF,DF\ HIFZ[ p5ZMST 5\RM ;D1F JSL,MG[ CFHZ YJF
;FD[ DGF. K[4 tIFZ[ 5|lXl1FT VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSM SFG}GL
;CFITF lS,lGSM BFT[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ VZHLVM SZJFDF\
VG[ VgI 5|lS|IFUT H~lZIFTMG[ 5CM\RL J/JFDF\ DNN SZ[
T[ ;]lGl`RT SZJFDF\ VFJX[P
sUf SFG}GL ;CFITF lS,lGSMGL :YF5GF lJX[ 5M,L; VG[ lAG
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 17
;ZSFZL ;\:YFVM ;lCT AWL H ;ZSFZL ;\:YFVM VG[
lJEFUMG[ HF6 SZJFGL ZC[X[P
s3f VF ZLT[ :Y5FI[, SFG}GL ;CFITF lS,lGSMGL SFDULZL4
DF/BFSLI ;]lJWFVM4 Z[S0" VG[ ZHL:8ZGL HF/J6L4 VW"
SFG}GL :JI\;[JSMGL lGI]lST VG[ lS,lGSM p5Z lGI\+6 H[JL
AFATMG]\ lGIDG ZFQ8=LI SFG}GL ;[JF ;œFD\0/ sSFG}GL
;[JF lS,lGSMf lGIDM4 Z_!! D]HA YX[P
sRf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ TYF lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF
;tTF D\0/ SM,[HM TYF lJ`J lJnF,IMDF\ :Y5FI[,
SFG}GL ;[JF lS,lGSMGF lJnFYL"VMG[ J'wWFzDGL D],FSFT
,[JF DF8[4 TYF ;DFHGF JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ SFG}GL ;CFI
5}ZL 5F0JF DF8[ 5|Mt;FlCT SZX[P
sKf SFG}GL ;CFITF lS,lGSM4 lJWJFVM TYF JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[
lGJ'lT J[TGG[ ,UTF ,FEM TYF VgI CSSM D[/JJF DF8[
DNN SZX[P
*P#*P#*P#*P# SFG}GL 5|lTlGlWtJ ovSFG}GL 5|lTlGlWtJ ovSFG}GL 5|lTlGlWtJ ovSFG}GL 5|lTlGlWtJ ov
sSf AWFH JlZQ9 GFUlZSM S[ H[VM SFG}GL ;[JF ;œFD\0/ SFINM4
!)(* GL S,D !Z C[9/ SFG}GL ;CFI D[/JJF DF8[
CSSNFZ CMI4 T[VMG[ VU|TFGF WMZ6[ SFG}GL ;CFI
VF5JFDF\ VFJX[P
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 18
sBf V[ H~ZL K[ S[4 SFG}GL ;[JF ;\:YFVMG]\ EF{lTS DF/B]\
sDSFGf JlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ ;],E CMI4 VgIYF T[VM
;Z/TFYL gIFI GlC D[/JL XS[P T[YL4 SFG}GL ;[JF ;\:YFVM
£FZF ;],ETF ;]lGl`RT SZJF DF8[ IMuI 5U,F ,[JF
HM.V[4 H[JF S[4 EM\ITl/I[ VMlO; CMJL HM.V[P
sUf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ £FZF V[ ;]lGl`RT
SZJFG]\ K[ S[4 JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ SFI"JFCL lJQFIS
VF\8L3}8LDF\ SM. 56 5|SFZGL V;]lJWFGM ;FDGM SZJM G
50[P
s3f NZ[S lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/ VG[ TF,]SF SFG}GL
;[JF ;lDlT VMKFDF\ VMKF +6 5[G, JSL,MG[ SFG}GL
;[JF VlWSFZLVM TZLS[ VF IMHGFGF C[T]G[ 5FZ 5F0JF DF8[
lGI]ST SZX[P
sRf lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;œF D\0/ VF IMHGFGF VD, DF8[
5]ZTL ;\bIFDF\ VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSM 56 lGI]ST SZX[ VG[
VF C[T] DF8[ T[VM V[JF VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSMG[ 5;\N SZX[ S[
H[VM JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ 50TL TS,LOMGM ;FDGM SZJF DF8[
TF,LD 5FD[, CMIP JlZQ9 GFUlZSMDF\YL s5]~QF VG[ :+L
A\G[DF\YLf VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSMG[ VM/BJF VG[ TF,LD
VF5JF DF8[ 5|ItGM SZJF HM.V[P
sKf VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSMV[ ;DFHDF\GF V[JF JlZQ9 GFUlZSM S[
H[VM SFG}GL ;[JF ;\:YFVMGM ;\5S" GYL SZL XSTF VG[
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 19
SFG}GL ;[JF ;\:YFVM JrR[ HM0TL S0L TZLS[ SFI" SZX[P HIFZ[
JlZQ9 GFUlZSM T[DGL 5lZl:YlTG[ ,LW[ SFG}GL ;[JF
;\:YFVMGM ;\5S" SZL XS[ T[D G CMI tIFZ[ SFG}GL ;[JF
;\:YFVM 5MTFGF 5[G, JSL,M VG[ VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSM
£FZF T[DGF ;]WL 5CM\RX[P
sHf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ £FZF 5[G, JSL,MG[ JlZQ9
GFUlZSMGF S[;MG[ ;\J[NGFtDS ZLT[ CFY 5Z ,[JF DF8[
TF,LD VF5JFDF\ VFJX[P ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF
D\0/ V[ ;]lGl`RT SZX[ S[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ VF5JFDF\
VFJTL SFG}GL ;[JFVM prR S1FFGL CMI4 H[YL T[VMG[ VY"5}6"
VG[ V;ZSFZS SFG}GL ;[JFVM VF5L XSFIP
*P$*P$*P$*P$ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ V;ZSTF" D]–FVMGL VM/BJlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ V;ZSTF" D]–FVMGL VM/BJlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ V;ZSTF" D]–FVMGL VM/BJlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ V;ZSTF" D]–FVMGL VM/B ovovovov
sSf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ VG[ lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF
;tTF D\0/ £FZF JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ RMSS; AFATDF\
V;ZSTF" D]bI D]–FVMGL VM/B SZJFGM 5|ItG SZJFDF\
VFJX[ VG[ T[ D]HA T[GM C, SZJFDF\ VFJX[P HIFZ[
S[8,F\S D]–FVM ;DU| EF{UMl,S ;\HMUMGL N'lQ8V[ ;ZBF CM.
XS[4 S[8,F\S D]–FVM S[8,F\S lJ:TFZM DF8[ lJlXQ8 CM. XS[P
H[D S[4 S[8,F\S lJ:TFZMDF\4 JlZQ9 GFUlZSM 5MT[ V[S,F
ZC[TF CMI K[ T[ V[S DM8L ;D:IF CM. XS[P SFZ6 S[4
T[DGF S]8]\ALHGM ALHF XC[ZDF\ S[ ALHF N[XDF\
:Y/F\TZ SZL R}SIF CMI K[P VD]S RMSS; lJ:TFZDF\
S[8,FS VFZMuI lJQFIS ;D:IFVM U\ELZ CM. XS[ K[P
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 20
sBf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ VG[ lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF
;tTF D\0/ 5|FN[lXS 1F[+[ p–EJ[, D]–FVMGM pS[, D[/JX[
VG[ T[GF :+MTM £FZF H[ T[ ;\A\lWT ;ZSFZL V[Hg;LVMGF
;\S,GYL VD, DF8[ 5|IF; SZX[P
sUf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ VG[ lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF
;tTF D\0/[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF :JI\ ;CFITF H}YMGL
:YF5GF SZJF DF8[GL ;]lJWF SZL VF5JL4 H[YL T[G[
;DFHG]\ ;DY"G D/L ZC[ VG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMDF\YL
5ZFWLGTFGL EFJGF 38F0L XSFIP
*P5*P5*P5*P5 0[8F A[h0[8F A[h0[8F A[h0[8F A[h ovovovov
sSf AWFH ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ 5F;[ S[gN= VYJF
ZFHI ;ZSFZGL JlZQ9 GFUlZSM ;\A\lWT 5|J"TDFG IMHGFVM4
GLlTVM4 GLlT lGN["XMGM 0[8F A[h CX[ VG[ T[ RM5FGLIF
VG[ 5]l:TSFGF :J~5DF\ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF CSSM ;\A\lWT
DFlCTLGM O[,FJM VG[ HFU'lT ,FJJF DF8[ 5|SFlXT SZJFDF\
VFJX[P
sBf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ VG[ lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF
;tTF D\0/ DFlCTL 5]l:TSFGF :J~5DF\ 5|FN[lXS
EFQFFDF\ ;Z/ ;DH}TL ;FY[ GLR[ D]HAGL DFlCTL
5|SFlXT SZX[P
s!f U]HZFG4 Jl;IT4 ;FDFlHS S<IF6 IMHGFVM DF8[
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 21
SFINFGL HMUJF.VMP
sZf p5FIM 5|F%T SZJFGL lJUTMP
s#f ;DU| ZFHIDF\ C[<5 ,F.G G\AZGL 5|F%I ;\5S"
lJUTMP
p5ZMST DFlCTL 5]l:TSFVMG]\ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMDF\
lJTZ6 SZJ]\ VG[ HFU'TTF SFI"S|DMDF\ p5IMU SZJMP
sUf lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ V[ NJFBFGFVM4 TALAL S[gN=M
VG[ VgI ;]lJWFVMGM 0[8FA[h HF/JX[P H[ JlZQ9
GFUlZSMG[ T[DGF lJ:TFZDF\ p5,aW ZC[X[P
s3f lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ £FZF HF/J[,L DFlCTL
TF,]SF SFG}GL ;[JF ;lDlT4 U|FD 5\RFITM4 SFG}GL
;CFITF lS,lGSM VG[ VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSMG[ 5}ZL
5F0JFDF\ VFJX[P
sRf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ q lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF
;tTF D\0/ ;\U|lCT SZ[,L DFlCTLG[ T[DGL J[A;F.8 p5Z
D]SX[P
sKf lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ T[DGF lJ:TFZGF JlZQ9
GFUlZSMGM 0[8F A[h T{IFZ SZX[P H[YL H~Z 50I[ VW" SFG}GL
:JI\;[JSMG[ T[DGL ;CFI DF8[ lGI]ST SZL XSFIP VF
0[8FA[h SFINF VD,LSZ6 V[Hg;L ;FY[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL
;]Z1FF ;\NE[" T[GL VF5v,[ SZL XSFI K[P VF AFAT
lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ VG[ ;\A\lWT BFTFVM H[JF
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 22
S[4 VFZMuI VYJF 5M,L; BFTF ;FY[ ;\S,G ;FWL
TS,LODF\ ZC[, JlZQ9 GFUlZSG[ tJlZT DNN 5CM\RF0JF
;1FD SZX[P
*P& *P& *P& *P& lJlJW IMHGFVMGM VD, ovlJlJW IMHGFVMGM VD, ovlJlJW IMHGFVMGM VD, ovlJlJW IMHGFVMGM VD, ov
sSf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/4 JlZQ9 GFUlZSM VG[
;ZSFZL SD"RFZLVM DF8[ GLlTVM4 IMHGFVM4 SFI"S|DM lJX[GL
DFlCTLGM 5|RFZ SZJF DF8[ H~ZL V[JF AWFH 5U,F\ ,[X[P
sBf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/ ;]lGl`RT SZX[ S[4 VF
DFlCTLG[ J'wWFzDM4 NJFBFGFVM VG[ VgI HuIFVMV[ TZT
GHZ[ 50[ T[ ZLT[ 5|NlX"T SZJFDF\ VFJ[ S[ HIF\ JlZQ9
GFUlZSMGL JW] VJZ HJZ CMIP
sUf lJlJW ZFHIMDF\ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL ;]Z1FF DF8[ BF;
IMHGFVM CMI K[P H[JL S[4 JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL ;\A\lWT 5M,L;
:8[XGDF\ GM\W6L lJU[Z[P ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/4
SFINF VD,LSZ6 V[Hg;L ;FY[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL ;]Z1FF
;\A\W[ S0L~5 AGX[ VG[ T[ 5M,L; VG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSM
JrR[GF ;\5S"G[ ;TT RMSL 5C[ZM VG[ NZ V9JFl0IFDF\q
5BJF0LIFDF\ V[S JBT JlZQ9 GFUlZSM ;FY[ lGIlDT ;\5S"
£FZF VFU/ W5FJX[P ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/4
lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/4 VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSMG[
lGI]ST SZX[ S[ H[VM JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL 5M,L; :8[XGDF\
GM\W6L4 DFl,S VG[ EF0}VFTGL BZF. VG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 23
;]Z1FF ;FY[ ;\S/FI[,L VgI AFATMDF\ ;CFI SZX[P
s3f ,FEFYL"VMG[ lJlJW ;ZSFZL IMHGFVM VG[ T[GF ,FEM S[
H[GF DF8[ T[VM CSSNFZ CMI T[GF lJX[ H6FJJ]\4 IMHGFVM
C[9/GF ,FEM D[/JJF H~ZL N:TFJ[HM D[/JJFDF\
,FEFYL"VMG[ DNN SZJL4 lGI]ST SZ[, ;œF D\0/ VYJF
VlWSFZLGF GFD VG[ ;ZGFDF lJX[ ,FEFYL"G[ H6FJJ]\
S[ H[YL T[VM IMHGFVM C[9/GF ,FEM D[/JJF T[VMGM ;\5S"
SZL XS[ TYF lGI]ST SZ[, ;œF D\0/GL SR[ZL VYJF
IMHGF C[9/GF ;\A\lWT VlWSFZL 5F;[ ,FEFYL"VMGL ;FY[
VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSM DMS,JF lJU[Z[ H[JL AFATMGM SFG}GL
;[JFVMDF\ ;DFJ[X YFI K[P
sRf JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF S<IF6 ;\A\lWT H[ lJlJW IMHGFVM
Vl:TtJDF\ K[ T[GF ,FEM JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ 5CM\R[ T[
;}lGl`RT SZJF4 ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/M V[ ;ZSFZL
;\:YFVM S[ VlWSFZLVM4 lAG ;ZSFZL ;\:YFVM VG[ VgI
;\:YFVM ;FY[ V;ZSFZS ;\S,G VG[ ;DgJI ;FWX[P
*P**P**P**P* HFUHFUHFUHFU'lT SFI"S|DM'lT SFI"S|DM'lT SFI"S|DM'lT SFI"S|DM ovovovov
sSf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/MV[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF
VlWSFZM 5ZtJ[ HFU'lT ,FJJF DF8[ JFlQF"S SFI"S|D 30L
SF-X[ VG[ V[JF JFTFJZ6GF lGDF"6 DF8[ 5|IF;M SZJF
HM.V[ S[ H[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL H~lZIFTM VG[ CSSM DF8[
;\J[NGXL, CMIP
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 24
sBf SFG}GL ;[JF ;\:YFVM JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL H~lZIFTM DF8[ ,MSM
JrR[ V[JF ;\J[NGFtDS HFU'lT SFI"S|DMG]\ VFIMHG SZX[ S[
VG[ ,MSMG[ ;\N[XM 5CM\RF0X[ S[ ;\TFGMGL V[ G{lTS OZH K[ S[
JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ T[VMGL J'wWFJ:YF NZlDIFG lGZFWFZ G
KM0JF VG[ T[VMGL SF/HL ,[JLP
sUf SFG}GL ;[JF ;\:YFVM V[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL ;FY[ ;gDFGGLI
JT"G ZFBJF V\U[GL H~lZIFT lJX[ ;DHFJJ]\ HM.V[P
s3f ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/[4 lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF
D\0/M ;FY[ D/LG[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMG[ lJlJW SFINFVM VG[
;ZSFZL IMHGFVM C[9/ D/JF5F+ CSSM lJX[ HFU'lT O[,FJTF
SFI"S|DMG] VFIMHG SZX[P
sRf ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/M4 lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF
;tTF D\0/M VG[ TF,]SF SFG}GL ;[JF ;lDlTVM JlZQ9
GFUlZSMG[ D/TF CSSM DF8[ p5,aW SFG}GL ;[JFVM lJX[ 56
HFU'lT ,FJX[4 H[YL SZLG[ D/JF5F+ CSSM T[VMG[ ;Z/TFYL
5|F%T Y. XS[P
sKf J'wWFzDMDF\ S[ V[JL HuIFVM S[ HIF\ JlZQ9 GFUlZSM
JFZ\JFZ D],FSFT ,[TF CMI tIF\ BF; HFU'lT h]\A[X CFY
WZL XSFI4 VG[ VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSM VG[ lJnFYL"VMG[ VFJF
SFI"S|DMDF\ EFU ,[JF DF8[ 5|Mt;FlCT SZL XSFIP
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 25
sHf HFU'lT SFI"S|DMGF\ VFIMHG NZlDIFG4 lH<,F SFG}GL ;[JF
;tTFD\0/ VG[ TF,]SF SFG}GL ;[JF ;lDlTVM JlZQ9 GFUlZSM
DF8[ BF; VFZMuI RSF;6L S[d5 H[JF S[ ;FDFgI
VFZMuI S[d54 VF\B RSF;6L S[d5 lJU[Z[GF\ VFIMHG DF8[
;\A\lWT VFZMuI lJEFU ;FY[ 56 ;\S,G ;FWL XS[ K[
VYJF TM JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGL BF; GM\W6L h]\A[XGF VFIMHG
DF8[ 5M,L; ;FY[ 56 ;\S,G ;FWL XS[ K[P
shf ,MS HFU'lT O[,FJJFGL XSI CMI T[ AWL H 5wWlTVMGM
p5IMU YJM HM.V[4 H[DS[ N}ZNX"G4 VM, .lg0IF Z[0LIM4
BFGUL 8LPJLP R[G,M4 HFC[ZFTMGF AM0" sCM0L"\u;f4 ;F\:S'lTS
SFI"S|DMG]\ VFIMHG4 WFlD"S D[/F4 TC[JFZM NZlDIFG :8M,
,UF0JF lJU[Z[P
s8f ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/MV[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSM ;FY[
HM0F.G[ ;lS|I ZLT[ lJlJW D]–FVM 5Z HFU'lT O[,FJJFGF
SFI"S|DMGF JCGDF\ T[VMGL ;[JFVM D[/JJL HM.V[P SFZ6
S[4 T[VMGF lJ:TFZDF\ T[VMGL lJ`J;GLITF VG[ 5|EFJ
JW] CMI K[P
*P(*P(*P(*P( TF,LD VG[ VlEUD,1FL SFI"S|D ovTF,LD VG[ VlEUD,1FL SFI"S|D ovTF,LD VG[ VlEUD,1FL SFI"S|D ovTF,LD VG[ VlEUD,1FL SFI"S|D ov
5[G, JSL,M VG[ VW" SFG}GL :JI\;[JSMV[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF
S[;M S[JL ZLT[ CFY WZJF HM.V[ V[GF lJX[ T[VMG[ ;EFG SZJF
VG[ T[VMGL 1FDTF4 7FG VG[ SF{X<IG]\ lGDF"6 SZJF DF8[
ZFHI SFG}GL ;[JF ;tTF D\0/M TF,LD VG[ VlEUD,1FL
SFI"S|DM IMHX[P VgI DFwIDM H[JF S[ ;ZSFZL ;\:YFVM4 5M,L;
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 26
VG[ lAG ;ZSFZL ;\:YFVM DF8[ 56 ;\J[NGFtDS SFI"S|DMG]\
VFIMHG SZJ]\ HM.V[P
*P)*P)*P)*P) J'wWM DF8[GF VFJ'wWM DF8[GF VFJ'wWM DF8[GF VFJ'wWM DF8[GF VF\\\\TZZFQ8=LI lNJ;G]TZZFQ8=LI lNJ;G]TZZFQ8=LI lNJ;G]TZZFQ8=LI lNJ;G]\\\\ 5F,G ov5F,G ov5F,G ov5F,G ov
TDFD SFG}GL ;[JF ;\:YFVM NZ JQF[" ! ,L VMS8MAZGF
lNJ;G[ VF\TZZFQ8=LI J'wWtJ lNJ; TZLS[ 5F,G SZX[ VG[ T[
lNJ;[ JlZQ9 GFUlZSMGF VlWSFZM V\U[ HFU'lT O[,FJTF
SFI"S|DMG]\ VFIMHG SZX[P
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv2vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv
GF,;F sJlZQ9 GFUlZSM DF8[ SFG}GL ;[JFVMf IMHGF4 Z_!& 5FG]\ 27
==================
Translation Department
Gujarat High Court
Doc. Reg. no. 61 of 2017
Translated By...
(Sunil Parmar)
- Translator