global christianity
DESCRIPTION
Paper that I wrote for my Global Christianity class.TRANSCRIPT
1
Tanya Marchun Global Christianity
Final Paper While the sixteenth century was most important in the changes between the Catholic and
Protestant churches there were many factors that lead to the changes that took place. Many of those
changes came from previous centuries, most notably the eleventh through thirteenth centuries. During
these centuries the transformation of the church subtly began. During the eleventh century the split of
the Eastern and Western churches laid the foundation for the rise of the nation state, the Protestant
Reformation, the Catholic Reformation as well as the development of the Gutenberg Printing Press and
Renaissance thinking. Thomas Aquinas pursued interpreting Aristotelian theology into Christianity and
wrote his most important work the Summa Theologica.
The rise of scholasticism allowed people to become more knowledgeable, it trained the Western
mind, and the printing press helped motivate individuals to communicate. One major writer that had an
impact on society was Thomas Moore who famous book, Utopia, had a large impact upon the political
and social movements taking place within Europe at the time of its release. The centralized monarchy
had many tensions between where authority should lie, with the King or with the Church. A separation
of church and state caused new developments and new belief systems.
During the Renaissance, Humanism developed which lead to a completely different way of
thinking, that a man can choose his own destiny. Previously, Christian thinking was theocentric which
was God centered while, the Renaissance lead to an anthropocentric way of thinking, based on self
centeredness. Many centrifugal forces lead to the breakup of Christendom. Over one third of Europe
converted to Protestantism, tensions between authorities arose, there were political as well as
theological changes taking place, and much of the papacy was corrupt. Martin Luther ignited the wick
which detonated the reformation bomb, so to speak.
2
Martin Luther had many doubts and questions about the Catholic faith, which grew as he
studied the Bible. Luther entered a monastery and became part of the order of the Observant
Augustinians. What is ironic about Luther is that he was not a person that was against the Catholic faith
at all, he just questioned some of the beliefs such as salvation. He seemed to have a hard time believing
that humans could not achieve salvation on their own. As he studied the Bible more, he was able to
come up with a phrase, justification by grace through faith, which allowed him to realize where he
places his authority, in himself or in Jesus Christ.
Mostly Luther is known for his attack on the sale of indulgences.
“Indulgences released people from the penalties or works of satisfaction they still owed by
drawing on the surplus good works of the saints and of Christ….Thus, for example, a sinner
might receive an indulgence to offer prayers and alms instead of a pilgrimage as her work for
satisfaction, and the merits of Christ and the saints would make up the deficiency (Cory &
Hollerich, 319).”
Luther’s Ninety-‐Five Theses expressed many of the questions and reservations people had about
indulgences. However, this lead to greater questioning of not only the church, but also the authority of
the pope, which ultimately lead to Luther’s excommunication from the Catholic Church. Luther also had
many important writings in the year 1520: Address to the Christian Nobility of the German Nation, On
the Babylonian Captivity of the Church, and Christian Liberty. The Address called for German princes
and rulers to complete the reforms that the church officials would not do. Luther defended the position
that he took saying that Christians have the right because of their baptism. The Captivity of the Church
was writings about the sacraments of the church. Luther refused transubstantiation, thought it was too
much of a philosophical approach to the body and blood of Jesus. In the broader picture, Luther was
criticizing the way the Catholic Church practiced and believed the sacraments. Oddly enough, Luther
still believed in two of the sacraments, Eucharist and Baptism. He also believed that the practice of
3
private confession was good for Christians to do. In his third writing, Christian Liberty, he describes his
theology of justification by grace through faith. He defines Christian freedom and describes the
relationship between faith and other works in a Christian’s life.
Luther got protection from his own ruler, who took him into hiding for 10 months. After his
hiding Luther was preaching again and called for reform, which caused another uprise a few years later
called the Peasants’ Revolt. However, he was also successful in helping conclude the revolt by asking for
a resolution between the peasants and the German princes.
An important foundation within the reformation was the First Diet of Speyer. This allowed for
each German prince to act however he wanted, some supported Luther while some stayed loyal to the
Catholic Church. The Second Diet of Speyer declared that Lutheranism would only be allowed in areas
where it could thrive without violence. Germany was divided into Catholic and Protestant. The
Augsburg Confession is an important document that was used to attempt to show the similarities
between Protestants and Catholics. After the spread of Lutheranism, Luther spent many years
afterwards organizing the church. Luther translated the entire Bible, wrote two catechisms to help
instruct believers, reorganized and reworded the Liturgy of the Mass, and created a hymn book.
Another important person within Protestant reformation was John Calvin. Calvin had much of
the same thought as Luther did regarding faith. “Calvin, then, is very much of the same mind as Luther
in his emphasis on the inability of human beings to save themselves by fulfilling the Law. They must rely
on their faith alone, for only God can bring about their redemption (Cory & Hollerich, 337).” Calvin also
believed in election, which was the idea that God chooses certain people to entire into a special
relationship with. Calvin’s two defenses for this idea of election were that one, God could choose
emphasizing God’s dominion and two, it is part of God’s plan to make one holy and set the person apart
for a special task.
4
Calvin also expounded on this idea with double predestination, in which God has already chosen
some for salvation and some for damnation. “Calvin believed that double predestination was a freeing
doctrine: It meant that people did not need to be anxious about the destiny of their souls, since that had
already been determined (Cory & Hollerich).” Much of what Calvin believed was similar to Luther;
however, one thing set him apart. Calvin did not completely agree with transubstantiation but he did
ask an important question of how the body of Christ becomes present in us and how Christians become
more united to Christ. He had three answers: first, Jesus’ sacrifice for us, second, thanksgiving of
acceptance for what Christ did, and finally, a communion where all Christians take part in one body.
Calvin was very important in attempting to give an understanding of authority for the reformed
Protestant church. He established a consistory, which was a group of twelve members: four church
members, four from the government, and four from the church leadership. However, this did not last
long and Cardinal Sadoleto drafted an appeal to the Genevan people to return to the Catholic Church.
This did not work either, but the Genevan people wanted to reply to Sadoleto and turned to Calvin to
write it. Calvin returned to Geneva and remained there until his death in 1564. He was also an
important figure in the foundation of the Presbyterian Church and his idea of consistory is still useful
today for other denominations.
During this time of Protestant Reformation there was also a reformation taking place within the
Catholic Church. Just like previous reformations and changes within the church, this reformation was
the renewal and clarification of doctrines; it was a spiritual renewal as well as a renewal for religious
orders and missionization. The Protestant Reformation actually opened up a space that allowed for the
changes in the Catholic Church to take place. There was the external change, to confront the movement
of the Protestant reformers, as well as the internal change, to meet concerns of those who believed the
fundamental changes within the Catholic Church.
5
Some of the new religious orders that were created before the Council of Trent included:
oratories, which were groups of clergy who banded together to pray, meditate and support each other
in discussion about the reforming church. The most famous is the Oratory of Divine Love which trained
reform-‐minded clergy to enter into the church. There was also the Congregation of the Mission, which
held retreats and prepared men for priesthood, founded by St. Vincent de Paul. There was also the
Ursulines, which was the first order of women that dedicated themselves to teaching. One of the most
influential even to this day was the Society of Jesus also known as the Jesuits, which was founded by
Ignatius of Loyola. The Jesuits were highly skilled in education, especially higher education and even
today there are universities founded by Jesuits as well as classes still taught by Jesuit priests or brothers.
One of the most important parts of the Catholic Reformation was the Council of Trent. Pope
Paul III called this council together, which wanted to come to grips with the basic teachings within the
church and then have internal reform. The council gathered in 1545, but it spanned over a matter of
nearly 20 years. It consisted of three different sessions, the first from 1545-‐1547, dealt with doctrinal
definitions. The second from 1551-‐1552, dealt with doctrinal and practical matters. The third from
1562-‐1563, dealt with disciplinary correction and regulations of church activities for the future. The
Council was able to make clarifications about many of the issues that the Protestant’s regarded, such as
justification by faith.
The council responded to this by clarifying the difference between justification and salvation.
Faith, hope and charity are needed for salvation. Another issue was the Bible as authority for the
Protestants, in which the council declared, “Unwritten tradition of the church must also be received
with reverence, since it too contains the word of God, having its origins in the teaching of the apostles.
The sacraments were reasserted as essential to the Christian life (Cory & Hollerich, 356).” Luther and
other reformers attack of the traditional Mass of Christ’s sacrifice was met with a strong redefinition of
the Liturgy, which incorporated the Vulgate and was named the only authoritative translation of the
6
Bible. The Council of Trent was also important in the fact that it ended the selling of indulgences, gave
Bishops supervision of their dioceses, and seminaries to educated Bishops were created, among others
things.
Not only were doctrines and people changed during the time of the Reformations, art and
architecture was also changing. Many of the new churches that were built by the Protestant Reformers
were simple. Many of the churches that were taken over by the Protestants were repainted and
stripped of their ornamental statues, etc for a more simplistic style. The art of the Renaissance had a
great impact upon the art that was created during the time of the Reformations. Realism is an aspect
that the artists strived for. Many of the artists depicted scenes from the Bible, while others also
depicted everyday life situations. Some strived to illustrate the beauty of creation, a sense of power,
the need for salvation as well as the good and bad sides of human nature.
Germany was most influential in its production of music that was created with larger masses of
people in mind. “The hymns were sung in the vernacular. Some of our most well-‐known Christian
hymns, including several new arrangements by Johann Sebastian Bach, date back to the time of the
Reformation (Cory & Hollerich, 359).” New art was also commissioned to show the important aspects of
Catholic orthodoxy. Baroque was the term given to this art and architecture during this time. “While it
had been influenced by the realism of the Renaissance, Baroque art and architecture added the
dimension of light and darkness, suggesting that the division between this world and the heavenly realm
is penetrable, at least through the mediation of the Virgin Mary and the saints (Cory & Hollerich, 359).”
Much of the art changed in the sense that it tried to involve the observer. Many churches were
also filled with depictions from the Bible which were meant to be awe inspiring and dramatic. “As an art
form, it was the intention of the Baroque to bring immediacy of experience, to appeal to the feelings
and the emotional side of faith, to illustrate doctrine in a way that made pastoral sense and yet was
7
compelling religiously and artistically (Cory & Hollerich, 360).” The art and architecture was specifically
made to be inviting and interesting to attract people to the church.
While these changes took place in certain areas, there was a need to expand the word and
works throughout the world. This lead to the global expansion and missionizing outward proclamation
of the faith. Jesuits were large leaders in the missions in Peru and the Franciscans and Dominicans were
leaders in the East such as Japan and China as well as in the West. Francis Xavier was influential in India
and the Far East; he brought Christianity to Japan for the first time. What made Xavier so successful in
Japan was that he made himself become part of the culture of Japan. He did not try to just go in and
convert people, he took his time, becoming a friend to people and learning their ways of life. As the
exploration of the new world expanded, Christianity also corresponded with missionary work.
Portugal and Spain were important in the exploration of the new world. The church protected
the natives that were in the new world, and gave them rights which are equivalent to Human Rights
today. One of the greatest boosts in Catholicism in the Spanish new world came from an apparition of
the Virgin Mary to Juan Diego in Mexico City. Our Lady of Guadalupe is influential still today and is very
important to the devotion of Spanish-‐American Catholicism. This era of time was very important to the
expansion of Christianity throughout the world and just like with other expansions of Christianity, there
were challenges to it.
The deepest disagreements within Christianity really seemed to be disagreements about where
to strike the balance between seeing modernity as revolt versus seeing it as the adulthood of the human
race. The modern period beginning around 1600, had a large demand for autonomy or “one’s self as
law.” This time period developed more importance about personal rights versus being under rights of
the church or another authority. The ultimate authority was “self.”
Science was very influential in the changes during this time for Christianity. People were now
capable of understanding through science, Christianity could not be explained with science; therefore,
8
many people began to question its very structure and foundation. Scientific exploration and change
began with Nicholas Copernicus who proposed that the earth and other planets revolved around the
sun. This idea contradicted previous scientific statements about the Earth being the center of the
universe and the planets and sun orbiting around it. Galileo Galilei was influential because he supported
Copernicus’ theory. This new idea was a threat to Christianity because it contradicted what was in the
Bible, or so it seemed that it was taught that the sun revolved around the Earth. Galileo was able to
teach the Copernican theory as a theory; however, he could not teach it as fact. And when he began to
teach it as fact, the Catholic Church condemned him from teaching it at all. Now the church is looked
down upon by scientists because they believe that the church opposes science, when in reality that is
not true.
The New Science replaced the older scientific views such as Aristotelian physics with a new
physics that was based on tiny particles – atoms that followed mathematical and mechanical laws.
Everything was based upon these atoms and nature was seen as more of a machine. Many scientists
such as Galileo Galilei, Francis Bacon, Rene Descartes, Isaac Newton, and others were influential in the
beginning of the new science. Isaac Newton developed inertia and gravity. This new understanding of
the world and how it worked as a machine was easily developed and the need for God within it was
unnecessary. Rene Descartes developed a system of doubting everything that was traditionally taught
to arrive at what was absolutely certain.
This new mechanical philosophy was called Deism. “Deists believed in a God who designed the
world-‐machine and started it going – as a clockmaker might make a watch and wind it up. But
thereafter God did not intervene in the workings of the universe, which ran on its own like a watch (Cory
& Hollerich, 382).” Deism also led to the Enlightenment, which was also called the Age of Reason.
Rationalism came from this time because of the reduction of reality to simply science. Rationalism sees
that there is no need for a supernatural being to understand the world and everything within it. Many
9
of the Enlightenment believers would antagonize priests and clergy, they would also be skeptical of
anything supernatural, which lead to question Jesus’ divinity. If they did not believe in miracles and
supernatural things, then they easily disputed Jesus’ divinity because these are many of the “proofs”
that show Jesus’ divinity in Christianity.
Enlightenment thinkers also denied original sin and said that humanity was more directed
towards the good, and it is society and other things that cause people to do bad things. Enlightenment
thinkers were also large believers in liberty and freedom from political and religious authority. Religious
freedom was achieved in America when the Bill of Rights was created.
After the Enlightenment, many of the Enlightenment ideas still exist. Religious toleration is one
of those examples, as well as the fact that humans have certain inalienable rights. Atheism also became
acceptable and still is today. The Enlightenment era was the end of the time period where the Christian
Church and state would have authority. After the Enlightenment, the religious atmosphere was much
more different, it was seen more secular and more skeptical.
The impact of the Enlightenment in the 19th century led to the rise of liberalism from political
and economic problems. The 18th and 19th centuries also had a large development in geology which led
to the Theory of Evolution by Charles Darwin. This had a major change within the churches. Many
people and churches were split between whether to believe that humanity evolved from animals and
about the natural selection and survival of the fittest. Pope Pius XII acknowledged the fact that maybe
the human body had actually evolved; however, it was God who created and gave humans their souls.
But the changes in science led to a better clarification that science cannot explain everything within
religion. It is not that religion and churches do not believe or support science, it is just that when
science tries to reduce religion and God down to what can be measured, there is a problem. The
Enlightenment thinkers were trying to update Christianity and make it more modern. While doing so,
being able to reduce everything within Christianity to measurable instances and materials created a
10
different outcome. The Church responded by realizing that it was becoming a Christ of Culture and that
this reduction was limiting instead of broadening horizons.
Christianity’s intellectual response to this situation was to ask how Christianity fit into the
changes taking place. The scientific changes were causing Christianity to become a Christ of Culture but
both science and religion have autonomy. There was a change of looking at the historical Jesus versus
the supernatural Jesus. The churches are also loosing people because of the rising idea of individualism.
But both Protestant and Catholic Churches held a traditional vantage point. They were over and against
the Christ of Culture idea. Both hold fast to the traditional Christian fundamentals of the Bible, the
creeds, Christ’s resurrection, etc. There were also more Catholic missions and Evangelical revivals,
which also brought upon more devotional practices that were expressed in response to secularization.
Protestants intensified their Biblical reading and prayers and Catholics put more emphasis upon the
rosary, charity works and forgiveness. The Sacred Heart of Jesus, which emphasized love, charity and
devotion, was a major part of Catholicism.
Post modernism is a radical individualism where reality is a social construction and ultimate
authority rests in the individual. Nihilism is the belief that there is no objective basis for truth and
human values are worthless. This was developed by Friedrich Nietzsche. Post modernism also believes
that nothing is given by God. Post modernism calls people back to the religion; however, instead of just
one religion it is pieces of many with no coherent order. While in past eras scripture and tradition were
fundamental building blocks for theology, the post modern theologians put more attention on human
experiences as the beginning for theology. Post modernism also challenges the way that historical
methods of interpreting the bible and if the information still has the same relevance it did when it was
written.
Post modernism is hostile against Christianity because of all of these previous things. It really
goes against all the things that are most fundamental to Christianity. Christianity has to stand against
11
post modernism because it could break apart the foundation of Christianity. There needs to be an
authority figure within the church, a person cannot be the sole authority. Everything is given to
humanity by God, humans did not evolve, and the world was not the result of colliding energies in
space. Post modernism is much like the Renaissance period, placing more emphasis upon human
experiences and success. The emphasis of Christianity is the one true authority figure, Jesus Christ.
“While he was still speaking, suddenly a bright cloud overshadowed them, and from the cloud a
voice said, “This is my Son, the Beloved; with him I am well pleased; listen to him!” When the
disciples heard this, they feel to the ground and were overcome by fear. But Jesus came and
touched them saying, “Get up and do not be afraid. And when they looked up, they saw no one
except Jesus himself alone.” (Matthew 17:5-‐8)