global forest and community tenure challenges by jenny springer
DESCRIPTION
Presented as part of the Seminar on Securing Forest and Community Land Rights - Challenges, Trends and Ways Forward. The seminar focused on forests and other off-farm areas that constitute vital resources for the food security and livelihoods of the rural poor in many developing countries. These lands are often used in integrated ways by local communities under communal customary arrangements while often formally owned by the state. Unclear land rights make these resources and associated livelihoods particularly vulnerable in the current context of increased demand for land; this needs to be better recognized and articulated in discussions on land rights and responsible land investments.TRANSCRIPT
Global forest and
communitytenure trends
Progress, slowdown, and climate outcomesJenny SpringerUniversity of Gothenburg seminarSeptember 10, 2014
2Introduction
Findings from 2 recent publications - focused on centrality of community forest rights as to the future of forests What Future for Reform? (RRI 2014) – tracking forest
“tenure transition” • Human Rights basis – recognition of customary rights to
forests• Growing recognition of effectiveness of community
management Securing Rights, Combating Climate Change (WRI-RRI
2014) – importance of community forest rights as a climate change solution
3What Future for Reform? – 2002-2013Global forest tenure transition has continued
Administered by Government
Designated for IPs & Communities
Owned by IPs & Communities
Owned by Firms & Individuals
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
77.9%
1.5%
9.8% 10.9%
73.0%
2.9%
12.6% 11.5%
20022013
Lands allocated to IP/LC on a
conditional ba-sis, without the full legal means to secure their
rights
Communities have the legal
right to exclude outsiders, hold
rights in perpetu-ity, and have the
right to due process and just compensation
4Forest tenure transition in LMICs2002-2013
Significant increase: from 21% of forested lands to
more than 30%
5Uneven progress across regions (2013)
6Uneven progress within Asia (2013)
¾ of forests owned by communities in Asia are in China’s rural collectives
High proportion of customary lands and very limited recognition in Indonesia, peninsular SE Asia.
7And recognition has slowed since 2008…
26.8
19.3
66.8
50.3
19.716.7
11.2 9.3
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
LMIC REDD+ LMIC REDD+
Designated for IPs and local communties Owned by IPs and local communities
2002-2008 2008-2013
Increase in area recognized by time period and tenure category, in Mha
No legal frameworks created since 2008 confer ownership
8Securing Rights, Combating Climate Change: A WRI & RRI REPORT
9Community forests sequester massive amounts of carbon
15.5 percent of the world’s forest (513 mil ha)
WRI-RRI 2014
10Deforestation rates inside indigenous & community forests with legal recognition and strong government protection are significantly lower than in forests outside these areas
WRI-RRI 2014
12What’s needed?legal recognition & government support
WRI-RRI 2014
13Concluding Recommendations
1. Recognize & support community forest rights and management – call to national governments
• Continuing in - and moving beyond - Latin America
2. Provide more concrete support from climate initiatives – valuing CF rights as a climate solution
3. Engage private sector corporations and investors in respecting community forest rights
• Slowdown coinciding with industrial concession expansion
4. Catalyze broad-based change by including community land rights in the post-2015 development agenda
14
Thank you!
For more information, visit www.rightsandresources.org