gr no 184172 garchitorena.doc

8/12/2019 Gr No 184172 Garchitorena.doc

1/3

Page 1of 3

Parricide

SECOND DIVISION

THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, G.R. No. 184172Appellee

- versus - Present:CARPIO MORALES,J., Acting Chairperson,

LUIS ANTONIO GARCHITORENA, TINGA, VELASCO, JR., LEONARO E CASTRO,

!!

"n# $RION,Appell"nt. Pr%&ul'"te#:M"( ), *++

----------------------------------------------------------------------------R E S O L U T I O N

TINGA,J.:

On "ppe"l s t/e *0 J"nu"r( *++) e1s%n203%4 t/e C%urt %4 Appe"ls n CA-G.R. CR-HC N%. ++*+ "5r&n' t1%nv1t%n %4 "ppell"nt Lus Ant%n% G"r1/t%ren" %4 t/e 1r&e %4 p"rr1#e 6( t/e Re'%n"l Tr"l C%urt 7RTC8 %4 9ueCt(.

T/e "11us"t%r( p%rt%n %4 t/e n4%r&"t%n re"#s:

Cr&n"l C"se N%. 9-;A TA$LA GARCHITORENA, ?t/ ntent t% @ll,## t/en "n# t/ere, 2?ll4ull(3, unl"?4ull( "n# 4el%n%usl( "tt"1@, "ss"ult "n# e&pl%( pers%n"l v%len1eup%n t/e pers%n %4 s"# FLORELI>A TA$L2A3 GARCHITORENA, /s ?4e, 6( t/en "n# t/ere s/%%tn'/er ?t/ " 'un, /ttn' /er %n t/e /e"#, t/ere6( n1tn' up%n /er ser%us "n# &%rt"l ?%un#, ?/1/?"s t/e #re1t "n# &&e#"te 1"use %4 /er unt&el( #e"t/, t% t/e #"&"'e "n# preBu#1e %4 t/e /ers%4 s"# FLORELI>A TA$LA GARCHITORENA.

C%ntr"r( t% l"?.2*3

Appell"nt entere# " n%t 'ult( ple". Tr"l ensue#.

T/e pr%se1ut%n ?tnesses 1%nssts %4 PO Fl%ren1% Es1%6#%, t/e p%l1e nvest'"t%r ?/% resp%n#e# t% t/1r&e s1eneD PSr. Inspe1t%r M1/"el M"un"/"n, &e#1%-le'"l %51er %4 t/e Centr"l P%l1e str1t Cr&e L"6%r"t%r(PSr. Inspe1t%r Gr"1e Eust"u%, 4%rens1 1/e&stD M"rv1 $"rt%l%&e, 1%usn %4 t/e v1t&D R%s"r% T"6l", &%t/er %t/e v1t& "n# r. E#'"r S"vell", &e#1%-le'"l %51er %4 t/e N$I.

PO Es1%6#% ?ent t% t/e /%use %4 "ppell"nt "n# t/e v1t& t% nvest'"te. He ?ent ns#e t/e 6e#r%%& "4%un# 6l%%# %n t/e 1"rpete# %%r, " &&. 1"l6er pst%l "n# t?% 7*8 lve 6ullets. Appell"nt #s1l%se# t% POEs1%6#% t/"t t/e sp%uses /"# "n "lter1"t%n "n# "ppell"nt suspe1te# t/"t /s ?4e /"# "n etr"&"rt"l""r. Appell"nt t/en 1%1@e# /s pst%l t?1e, '"ve t t% /s ?4e, "n# t%l# /er kung guilty ka, ituloy mo. T/e v1"lle'e#l( t%%@ t/e 'un, p%nte# t t% /er /e"# "n# sueee# t/e tr''er. PO Es1%6#% reueste# " 6"llst1e"&n"t%n %4 t/e re"r&.23

C"pt. M"un"/"n 1%n#u1te# "n "ut%ps( %n t/e v1t&. In t/e Me#1%-Le'"l Rep%rt N%. M-+


2/3

Page 2of 3

Parricide

r. S"vell" "ls% 1%n#u1te# "n "ut%ps( %n t/e 6%#( %4 t/e v1t& "n# %pne# t/"t s unn"tur"l "n# unl@el( tt/e v1t&s nBur( ?"s sel4-n1te#.2


3/3

Page 3of 3

Parricide

WHEREFORE, t/e e1s%n #"te# *0 J"nu"r( *++) %4 t/e C%urt %4 Appe"ls 1%nv1tn' "ppell"nt LusAnt%n% G"r1/t%ren" %4 t/e 1r&e %4 p"rr1#e s AFFIRMED.

SO ORDERED.

gr no 184172 garchitorena.doc

Documents