h2o: the fundamental link between stormwater management ... · negative outcomes resulting from...

8 March/April 2014 | StormH2O.com

While a necessity of life, water is associ-ated with a variety of very important public health and environmental con-cerns. In particular, stormwater and dry-weather urban runoff (now collectively

referred to as “stormwater”) have been directly and indi-rectly connected to numerous human diseases and mala-dies as well as to environmental damage and pollution. To mitigate these undesirable consequences, government agencies were created or expanded to address specific areas of concern, eventually growing to become the flood and stormwater management and mosquito control agen-cies we work in today. The common ancestry of these agencies has been largely forgotten, but the shared DNA can still be found within the missions of these two seem-ingly disparate groups as they strive to protect public and environmental health. In urbanized areas of the United States, stormwater management and mosquito control agencies share many of the same goals, work with the same structures, and face many of the same day-to-day and long-term challenges. To illustrate this point, five top-ics important to both groups are discussed.

Stormwater InfrastructureThe principal function of all modern fl ood and storm-water management agencies is to protect the health and safety of our communities through fl ood protection and water-quality improvements. To achieve this, stormwater infrastructure must be regularly maintained, repaired, improved, and expanded. Many mosquito control agen-cies also work with stormwater infrastructure to protect public health, particularly in urban and suburban areas. Stormwater infrastructure has been identifi ed as a major source of mosquitoes in many metropolitan areas and in some cases is considered the single largest source. For example, storm drains and catch basins are the primary source of potentially disease-carrying mosquitoes in the greater Chicago metropolitan area, covering over 1,000 square miles. Within the Chicago city limits, the city’s vec-tor control program focuses almost exclusively on catch basins, of which there are upward of 200,000. Likewise, in the suburbs north of Chicago, the North Shore Mosquito

Abatement District (NSMAD) devotes approximately 75% of its control operations to treating more than 60,000 catch basins once or twice a season with mosquito larvi-cides (Figure 1). Much of the remaining control operations for NSMAD are focused on mile after mile of stormwater drainage ditches.

H2O: The Fundamental Link Between Stormwater Management and Mosquito Control AgenciesBY JUSTIN E. HARBISON AND MARCO E. METZGER

Figure 1. Stormwater catch basins are often located close to sub-urban residences and in many areas represent the most common source of mosquitoes treated by local mosquito control agencies.

GUEST EDITORIAL

8-15SW1403_GUEST.indd 88-15SW1403_GUEST.indd 8 2/19/14 8:32 AM2/19/14 8:32 AM

StormH2O.com | March/April 2014 9

Water ManagementSince ancient times, conveyance infrastructure has served to pro-tect people and property against fl ooding by routing runoff water downstream and out of harm’s way as quickly and effi ciently as possible. Pioneers in mosquito control also managed water, but focused on the removal of standing water sources in and around populated areas to protect people from swarms of blood-sucking mosquitoes and mosquito-borne diseases such as malaria and yellow fever. Water management engineers, including those that worked on creating the Panama Canal, played an integral role during the fi rst organized mosquito control efforts in the early 1900s (Figure 2). In fact, for decades the most common hand tool used by mosquito control technicians was a shovel to dig channels and drain areas of standing water. Today, public health and safety is still a priority, but certain approaches to water management have changed

to benefi t the environment and preserve resources. Wetlands are now recognized as benefi cial and are rarely drained for mos-quito control or urban develop-ment, but rather are carefully managed to coexist with an ever-increasing human popula-tion. Also in sharp contrast to the past, we now consider the benefi ts of holding some runoff

on site to replenish belowground aquifers, reduce the use of piped water, and decrease downstream erosion and pollution. The retention of stormwater runoff in engineered water-quality structures, water harvesting containers, and

Figure 2. A historical example of collaborative efforts to reduce standing water and mosquitoes in 1928. The Sanitary District of Chicago used dynamite to create ditches and drain large areas of water-logged land for the North Shore Mosquito Abatement District in Northfield, IL. Not surprisingly, there were more complaints of damage to homes than about mosquitoes.

No

rth

Sho

re M

osq

uito

Ab

atem

ent

Dis

tric

t

ONE COMPANY + ONE TREATMENT TRAIN = 6 TMDL SOLUTIONS!

1384 Pompton Ave. #2, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009

MANAGED DISCHARGE SYSTEMS

TMDL Solutions, Service and SustainabilityThe SiteSaver® “Treatment Train” concept combines a complete system: Netting TrashTrap® & Floatables capture, Oil/grease removal, Inclined Cell Sedimentation; Filtration for TSS, Nutrients and heavy metal reduction plus pathogenic disinfection. And, the TelNet® Alert System telemetry keeps you in touch. Fresh N Up™ O&M Services are also available for all customers.

Copyright: 2014, Fresh Creek Technologies, Inc.

See the complete system on our website at: www.freshcreek.com

Phone: 973.273.9099 FAX: 973.237.0744 Toll Free: 1.800.741.9486



downstream pollution, and preserve the function of engineered water-quality structures. Maintenance of stormwater infrastructure is equally important to reducing mosquito habitat. Cracked and sunken conveyances, debris buildups, unchecked plant growth, and other blockages all contribute to forming pools of standing water where mosquitoes can breed. These sources, even those deep underground, provide larval habitat for some of the most important disease-car-rying species. Stormwater management agencies ensure the proper function of these systems through routine or “as needed” maintenance. However, mosquito control technicians often carry hand tools such as shovels to remove small blockages and restore water fl ow because mosquitoes are frequently associated with stagnant pools not large enough to trigger maintenance activities by stormwater management agencies. Both groups rely on proper maintenance of stormwater infrastructure to help achieve their goals.

Figure 3. A mosquito control technician monitoring a catch basin for mosquitoes and applying a bacterial-based insecticide as treatment

other structures, however, has created new sources for mosquito production that will require continuing collaboration to reach the best possible compromise for simultaneously protecting public health and water quality. In the mean-time, both groups have been working toward a common goal of reducing the amount of dry-weather runoff in our cities (which contributes to downstream pollution and mosquito habitat) by pro-moting more judicious water use.

MaintenanceStormwater infrastructure requires constant maintenance to ensure that it functions as intended. In older cities especially, aging infrastructure requires periodic repair from damage and sometimes-full replacement with larger-capacity pipes and channels to accommodate greater water volumes resulting from upstream popula-tion growth. Maintenance is critical to ensure fl ood protection, reduce



Water QualityAs it fl ows over surfaces, stormwater runoff picks up and carries a variety of suspended, dissolved, and fl oating pollutants, which are then captured and concentrated by stormwater infrastructure. An overabundance of these pollutants reaching downstream destinations can cre-ate anything from an aesthetic eyesore to more severe consequences such as algal blooms that cause hypoxic conditions lethal to many aquatic organ-isms and concentrations of coliform bacteria that pose a health risk to those partaking in recre-ational water activities. Stormwater management agencies have the diffi cult task of developing strategies to mitigate this nonpoint-source pollu-tion through regulations, recommendations, and public education campaigns. Certain stormwa-ter quality regulations that aim to reduce the volume of and improve the quality of runoff are also benefi cial to the work conducted by mosquito control agencies. In particular, mosquito con-trol agencies support and sometimes assist the efforts of stormwater management agencies to eliminate urban dry-weather fl ows to reduce nonpoint-source pollution. This “urban drool” is responsible for creating and maintaining many of the mosquito breeding habitats in and around our communities. Organically rich (polluted) stormwater runoff is highly conducive to some urban mosquito species,

especially those that can transmit West Nile virus. Many natural predators such as fi sh, dragonfl ies, and predatory beetles cannot survive in such harsh conditions, allowing larval mosquitoes to develop unchallenged and in greater numbers. The elimination of such habitats can greatly minimize risk of mosquito-borne disease, biting nuisance, operational costs, and pesticide use.

Environmental StewardshipThe Clean Water Act sets protecting public health and wel-fare as a cornerstone of modern stormwater management agencies. Similarly, this describes the fundamental mission of mosquito control agencies, which endeavor to reduce negative outcomes resulting from mosquitoes on human health, public welfare, and property values. And while it may not be as immediately evident for mosquito control

When we start thinking of mosquito control agencies as valuable stormwater teammates, we all score points for public health and the environment.

Putting nature on its side. Turning an industry on its head.

www.ModularWetlands.com

HORIZONTAL FLOW.ONE SYSTEM. MULTIPLE TREATMENT STAGES.



agencies as for stormwater management agencies, both are also stewards of environmental health. For example, control of mosquitoes that can transmit West Nile virus protects humans as well as domestic and wild animals including local and migratory birds that might otherwise be infected and succumb to this avian disease. Restoring tidal fl ows in salt marshes, unclogging streams impacted with sediment and trash, and managing invasive vegetation are other examples used for reducing mosquito populations that also benefi t water quality and the environment. When pesticides must be used, most mosquito control agen-cies preferentially utilize biologically based and mosquito-specifi c control products such as Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis (Bti) rather than the broad-spectrum chemical formulations of the past (Figure 3). Being conscientious stewards of the environment and public health are roles heartily embraced by stormwater management and mos-quito control agencies alike.

Moving ForwardIf a “stormwater management agency” can be defi ned as an agency that 1) works with stormwater conveyance and water-quality infrastructure on a regular basis, 2) is depen-dent on the proper function and maintenance of this infrastructure, 3) benefi ts from increased surface water quality, and 4) has been created to protect public health, environmental health, and property values by addressing a surface water-based concern, then mosquito control agen-cies have a decent shot at such a title. Even the National Association of Flood and Stormwater Management

Figure 4. Even in times of drought, irrigation and other sources of dry-weather runoff continually replenish standing water in stormwater catch basins and other structures, allowing mosquitoes to breed.

Be Mobile. | Be Smart. | Be In-Situ.

Innovations inWater Monitoring

Your Smartphone Just Got SmarterYour job takes you everywhere. Your team wants information instantly.

New SMARTROLL™ Handhelds with revolutionary iSitu® App transform the way you monitor water quality.

• Instantly email results or log data to a smartphone.

• Tag sites with GPS coordinates and photo.

• Choose from multiparameter and dissolved oxygen probes.

Order a SMARTROLL™ from the In-Situ e-store:

store.in-situ.com

Enter code Shipsmart to receive free shipping

www.in-situ.com

Retention, Detention, Water Quality, Conveyance & Reuse

Phone: 877.426.9128www.StormChambers.com

Exceeds H-20 Load Rating By 4 Times Obtain Up To 18 Leed Points Eliminates Pre-Treatment Devices!

The Most Cost Effective The Cadillac of Chambers Double or Triple Stacke Stack

50% Recycled Materials

MADE IN THE USA

Orange Green~~

(Don’t let the big boys fool you)



Agencies describes its members as “public agencies whose function is the protection of lives, property, and economic activity from the adverse impacts of storm and fl ood waters”—a description that is also largely applicable to mosquito control agen-cies. But why might this matter? At a time when public agencies are asked to do more with fewer resources, increased interagency collaboration and communication could be the key to improving effi ciency and meeting program objectives. Perhaps if we begin to think of our local mosquito control agencies as partners helping to fulfi ll the mission to protect health and environment, strong partnerships could more easily be established. Simply think of them as local “storm-water mosquito agencies.”

Interagency partnerships between stormwater management and mosquito control promise to deliver mutually benefi cial results, and as water-quality regulations and policies become more stringent, interagency communication and cooperation will become increasingly important. Stormwater infrastructure, particularly in larger metropolitan areas, has to be routinely monitored and maintained to ensure it functions properly when needed. The size and complexity of some of these systems almost guar-antees that stormwater management agencies would benefi t from addi-tional help. Since mosquito control agencies often have staff routinely working with stormwater structures, they represent an untapped resource for stormwater management agen-cies that function as additional “eyes and ears” in the fi eld. For the most part, mosquito control technicians can identify malfunctioning structures and blockages that could be reported before they create potentially larger and more expensive problems and liabilities. Swift action by stormwater management agencies to mitigate reported problems would have the mutual benefi t of reducing mosquito larval habitat after repairs or mainte-nance was performed.

On the fl ip side, as stormwater infrastructure continues to grow to meet new water-quality requirements,

FFaircloth Skimmer® Surface Drains for Sediment Basins

PVC skimmer floats on the surface, releasing the cleanest water Drains from the basin’s SURFACE instead

of the bottom Improves basin performance Simple, automatic, gravity operation Works in basins with risers or

sediment traps with spillway

Patent #5,820,751

Replaces perforated risers and stone outlets as the basin’s drain Convenient for using a detention basin as a temporary sediment

basin during construction 8 sizes available Inlet orifice easily adjusted for drawdown requirements

Sizes, flow rates, prices, illustrations, instructions and SIZING CALCULATOR online at www.FairclothSkimmer.com

J W Faircloth & Son Inc. Hillsborough, NC 27278(919) 732-1244 (919) 732-1266 Fax



mosquito control agencies could ben-efi t from assistance in locating and safely accessing potential mosquito breeding sources within the system. This is very important for mosquito control and disease prevention. The below-average rainfall observed in many areas of the country in 2012 led some to speculate that mosquito populations would be negatively affected. This may have been true for some species, but others fl ourished in urban stormwater infrastructure where dry-weather fl ows maintained stand-ing water habitats (Figure 4). By the end of 2012, the number of human West Nile virus cases had reached the second highest on record in the United States. Closer interagency collaboration may help to reduce the risk of this and other mosquito-borne diseases in the future.

In closing, we encourage you to invite a mosquito control repre-sentative to give a talk at your next conference or write an article for your newsletter. Alternately, register as a participant and speaker at the next state or national conference on mosquito research and control. Ask mosquito control professionals for input in your next stormwater management manual and work with them to evaluate new stormwater products or design concepts. Most likely they will be happy to oblige, and the collaboration might lead to better designs, strategies, and protocols. When we start thinking of mosquito control agencies as valuable stormwa-ter teammates, we all score points for public health and the environment.

Selected ReferencesAnderson, J. F., F. J. Ferrandino, D.

W. Dingman, A. J. Main, T. G. Andreadis, and J. Becnel. 2011. “Control of Mosquitoes in Catch Basins in Connecticut with Bacil-lus thuringiensis israelensis, Bacil-lus sphaericus, and Spinosad.” Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association 27:45–55.

Calhoun, L. M., M. Avery, L. Jones, K. Gunarto, R. King, J. Roberts, and T. R. Burkot. 2005. “Combined Sewage Overfl ows (CSO) Are Major Urban Breeding Sites for

Culex quinquefasciatus in Atlanta, Georgia.” American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 77: 478–84.

Harbison, J. E., and M. E. Metzger. 2010. “We Want You to Fight Stormwater Mosquitoes: A Call for Interagency and Interdisciplinary Collaboration.” Stormwater 11(2): 22–31.

Harbison, J. E., M. E. Metzger, W. E. Walton, and R. Hu. 2009. “Evaluation of Factors for Rapid Development of Culex quinquefas-ciatus in Belowground Stormwa-ter Treatment Devices.” Journal of Vector Ecology 34:182–90.

Metzger M. E., J. E. Harbison, and R. Hu. 2011. “Discovery of Vector Mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae) in Newly Installed Above- and Belowground Storm-water Treatment Systems in San Diego County, California.” Journal of Medical Entomology 48: 1136–44.

Metzger, M. E., C. M. Myers, S. Kluh, J. W. Wekesa, R. Hu, and V. L. Kramer. 2008. “An Assessment of Mosquito Production and Nonchemical Control Measures in Structural Stormwater Best Man-agement Practices in Southern California.” Journal of the Ameri-can Mosquito Control Association 24: 70–81.

Su, T., J. P. Webb, R. P. Meyer, and M. S. Mulla. 2003. “Spatial and Temporal Distribution of Mosquitoes in Underground Storm Drains Systems in Orange County, California.” Journal of Vector Ecology 28: 79-89.

Justin E. Harbison, Ph.D., is an assistant professor of Public Health Sciences at Loyola University of Chicago. Marco E. Metzger, Ph.D., is a senior public health biologist with the Vector-Borne Disease Section, California Department of Public Health.

For related articles: www.stormh2o.com/program-management

ww

w.c

ulte

c.co

m

1(80

0) 4

-CU

LTEC

Co

mm

erc

ial

Dra

inag

e

WE

HA

VE

SOLU

TIO

NS

Rec

har

ger

® &

Con

tact

or®

Stor

mw

ater

Ch

amb

ers

®FR

EE

CUL

Storm

Gen

ie®Sinc

e 19

86

Resi

den

tial

Dra

inag

e


h2o: the fundamental link between stormwater management ... · negative outcomes resulting from...

Documents