halifax, 31 oct – 3 nov 2011global standards collaboration smart grid standardization activities...

Halifax, 31 Oct – 3 Nov 2011

Global Standards Collaboration

Smart Grid Standardization Activities

David Su, TIA, NIST

Document No:

GSC16-PLEN-35

Source: TIA

Contact: David Su ([email protected])Jane Brownley ([email protected])Mike Lynch ([email protected])

GSC Session:

PLENARY

Agenda Item:

6.10

mailto:[email protected]



GSC16-PLEN-35

Halifax, 31 Oct – 3 Nov 2011 ICT Accessibility For All

Priority Areas for Standards• Demand Response and Consumer Energy Efficiency: Mechanisms and

incentives for business and residential customers to cut energy use during times of peak demand.

• Wide Area Situational Awareness: Monitoring and display of power-system components and performance across interconnections and wide geographic areas in near real-time

• Electric Storage: Means of storing electric power, directly or indirectly • Electric Transportation: Enabling large-scale of plug-in electric vehicles

(PEVs)• Advanced Metering Infrastructure: Means for utilities to interact with

meters at customer sites• Distribution Grid Management: Maximizing performance of feeders,

transformers, and other components of networked distribution systems and integrating with transmission systems and customer operations.

• Cyber Security: Cyber security for smart grid systems and networks• Network Communications: Networking infrastructure for above functions

2

GSC16-PLEN-35


Smart Grid Interoperability Panel

Governing Board

SGIP Officers

Priority Action Plan Teams

PAP 2

Domain Expert Working Groups

H2G

TnD

B2G

I2G PEV2G

BnP

SGIP Administrator

PAP 1 PAP 3

PAP …PAP 4 PAP 17

NIST

Standing Committees &Working Groups

Test & Certification Committee (SGTCC)

ArchitectureCommittee

(SGAC)

Cyber Security Working Group

(CSWG)

Coordination Functions

Program Mgmt Office(PMO)

Comm. Marketing Education

(CME)

Bylaws & Operating

Procedures (BOP)

SGIP Membership

Electromagnetic Interoperability Issues

3

GSC16-PLEN-35


Standards Come from Many Developers

International

Regional andNational

GlobalConsortia

4

http://www.jisc.go.jp/eng/index.html

GSC16-PLEN-35


• PAPs supporting smart grid communications, and networking:– Guidelines for the Use of IP Protocol Suite in the Smart Grid (PAP 01); – Guidelines for the Use of Wireless Communications (PAP 02);– Harmonize Power Line Carrier Standards for Appliance Communications in the

Home (PAP 15)• PAPs supporting metering:

– Meter Upgradeability Standard (PAP 00); – Standard Meter Data Profiles (PAP 05)

• PAPs supporting enhanced customer interactions with the smart grid:– Standards for Energy Usage Information (PAP 10,PAP17); – Standard Demand Response Signals (PAP 09); – Develop Common Specification for Price and Product Definition (PAP 03);– Develop Common Scheduling Communication for Energy Transactions (PAP 04)

Filling Gaps in the StandardsPriority Action Plans (1)

Main Focus: Communications for smart grid applications – networking, data models, representations, and semantics.

5

GSC16-PLEN-35


• PAPs supporting distribution and transmission:– Develop Common Information Model (CIM) for Distribution Grid Management

(PAP 08); – Transmission and Distribution Power Systems Model Mapping (PAP 14);– IEC 61850 Objects/DNP3 Mapping (PAP 12); – Harmonization of IEEE C37.118 with IEC 61850 and Precision Time

Synchronization (PAP13)

• PAPs supporting new smart grid technologies: – Energy Storage Interconnection Guidelines (PAP 07); – Interoperability Standards to Support Plug-in Electric Vehicles (PAP 11)– Wind Power Communications (PAP16)

• PAPs for smart grid application profiles.– Migration path for Zigbee Alliance Smart Energy Profile 1.x to 2.0 (PAP18)

Filling Gaps in the StandardsPriority Action Plans (2)

6

GSC16-PLEN-35


Networking & Communications Standards (PAP 1, 2, 15)

• Reached a consensus on the use of IP-based network for Smart Grid networks (PAP01, RFC 6272, Internet Protocols for the Smart Grid)

• Produced a Guideline for Assessing Wireless Standards for Grid Applications (PAP02 NISTIR 7761)

• For a revision of NISTIR 7761, PAP02 continues to evaluate the performance of wireless protocols using the parameters specific to smart grid applications and their environments

• Harmonized power line communications protocols (PLC) and their coexistence mechanisms (PAP15).

7

GSC16-PLEN-35


Energy Usage Information Standards (PAP10)

class EnergyUsageInformation

Reading

+ cost: float [0..1]+ ID: string [0..1]+ timeStamp: dateTime [0..1]+ value: float [0..1]

Interv alReading

+ cost: float [0..1]+ endTimeStamp: dateTime [0..1]+ ID: string [0..1]+ timeStamp: dateTime [0..1]+ value: float [0..1]

ReadingQuality

+ quality: string [0..1]

0..*

0..*

• Standardizes data elements available to consumers or authorized 3rd party application providers

• Energy usage information -Standard developed and published by NAESB - December 2010

8

GSC16-PLEN-35


Electric Vehicle Charging Standards (PAP11)

2020 SUMMER LOAD IMPACT – NO UTILITY INVOLVEMENT*

10,000

12,000

14,000

16,000

18,000

20,000

22,000

24,000

26,000

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24Hours

MW

I nitial Load Forecast Ports Rail Trucks Forklifts PEVs

Worst Case

2020 SUMMER LOAD IMPACT – WITH UTILITY INVOLVEMENT*

10,000

12,000

14,000

16,000

18,000

20,000

22,000

24,000

26,000

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24Hours

MW

Initial Load Forecast Ports Rail Trucks Forklifts PEVs

• Data model & Information exchange protocols - “SAE J2836/1 Enables Electric Vehicle, Power Grid Communication.”

• Fast charging connector standard - “SAE J1772 Electric Vehicle and Plug in Hybrid Electric Vehicle Conductive Charge Coupler.”

9

GSC16-PLEN-35


• Building cyber security in from the start has been a paramount concern

• Permanent Working Group– Over 650 public and private sector

participants

• August 2010 NIST publishes: Guidelines for Smart Grid Cyber Security

• Guideline includes: – Risk assessment guidance for implementers– Recommended security requirements– Privacy recommendations

Guidelines for Smart Grid Cyber Security(Cyber Security Working Group)

10

GSC16-PLEN-35


Testing and Certification Framework

• Defined in SGIP Interoperability Process Reference Manual (IPRM)

SGIP Testing and Certification Committee

Interoperability Testing and Certification Authorities

Certification Bodies

Test Labs

SGIP IPRM documents requirements and best practices for ITCAs, CBs and TLs

ITCAs establish T&C schemes for specific domains/use cases and accredit CBs and TLsInitially-identified ITCAs: NEMA, UCAIug 61850, OpenADR, and Multispeak

Certify test results

Perform conformance and/or interoperability testing to specified test cases

11

GSC16-PLEN-35


NIST Smart Grid Framework and Roadmap 2.0

http://www.nist.gov/smartgrid/

• Release 2 draft has gone through reviews by SGIP Working Groups and PAPs– Final draft to be published on

Federal Register Notice for public review soon

• Contains updates to: – list of standards and their status– output of Priority Action Plan

Projects and Working Groups– cyber security strategy, privacy,

and reliability issues

2.0

12

GSC16-PLEN-35


TIA TR45.5 Smart Grid Activities• Together with other wireless technology standards development

organizations (SDOs) and the utilities industry, TR45.5 has been participating in the Smart Grid Interoperability Panel’s Priority Action 2 (Wireless Technologies for Smart Grid) since early 2010

• SGIP PAP2 approved its first document NIST Interagency Report 1776 “Guidelines for Assessing Wireless Standards for Smart Grid Applications” in January 2011– This was published by NIST as an Interagency Report

• PAP2 has been working on the second version of 1776 since early 2011 to further enhance the evaluation of wireless technologies

13

http://collaborate.nist.gov/twiki-sggrid/pub/SmartGrid/PAP02Wireless/NISTIR7761.pdf

http://collaborate.nist.gov/twiki-sggrid/pub/SmartGrid/PAP02Wireless/NISTIR7761.pdf

GSC16-PLEN-35


• TR-50 (Smart Device Communications) and TR-41 (User Premises Telecommunications Requirement) are engaged in standards development related to smart grid devices and communications, more specifically M2M communications.

• TR-51 is developing access standards for Smart Utility Networks – Addresses OSI Layers 1 – 4– Facilitate a set of wireless solutions allowing:

• Use of IEEE 802.15.4g PHY information as appropriate (subcommittee TR-51.1)

• Participation by compatible industries - e.g. electric and other utility providers

TIA TR50 &TR51 Smart Grid Activities

14

GSC16-PLEN-35


Proposed Resolution on Smart Grid

• Propose that GSC-16 reaffirms Resolution GSC-15/29 on Smart Grid.

15

GSC16-PLEN-35


Supplementary Slides

16

GSC16-PLEN-35


• NIST’s role is to coordinate development of standards, NIST will not itself develop the standards or conduct testing/certification – SDOs, test labs and certification bodies will do this and their deliverables will be referenced by NIST.

• NIST publishes a smart Grid framework and roadmap document to guide the process. a will periodically revise the framework until work is complete. The Release 1 framework was developed through a phase 1 process involving public workshops and public review and comment of documents.

• NIST established a permanent organization – the SGIP – which provides an institutionalized process to evolve and maintain the SG framework, as well as developing process for testing/certification.

• Our vision is that the SGIP will evolve from a US-initiated organization to a fully international organization in much same was as IAB and ICANN evolved. We envision that SGIP’s role continues to be coordination and high-level architecture, and does not get into standards development.

NIST Standardization Process Design

cypher

Something not correctPossiblychange "process. a will" to "process, which will be"orchange "process. a will" to "process. It will be"

GSC16-PLEN-35


Smart Grid Stakeholders

18

1 Appliance and consumer electronics providers

2 Commercial and industrial equipment manufacturers and automation vendors

3 Consumers – Residential, commercial, and industrial

4 Electric transportation industry Stakeholders

5 Electric utility companies – Investor Owned Utilities (IOU)

6 Electric utility companies - Municipal (MUNI)

7 Electric utility companies - Rural Electric Association (REA)

8 Electricity and financial market traders (includes aggregators)

9 Independent power producers

10Information and communication technologies (ICT) Infrastructure and Service Providers

11 Information technology (IT) application developers and integrators

12 Power equipment manufacturers and vendors

13 Professional societies, users groups, and industry consortia

14 R&D organizations and academia

15 Relevant Federal Government Agencies

16 Renewable Power Producers

17 Retail Service Providers

18 Standard and specification development organizations (SDOs)

19 State and local regulators

20 Testing and Certification Vendors

21 Transmission Operators and Independent System Operators

22 Venture Capital

GSC16-PLEN-35


• Total # of Member Organizations: 680• # of Participating Member Organizations: 372• # of Observing Member Organizations: 308• # of Organizations who joined in May & June: 9

• Total # of Individual Members*: 1,794

SGIP Membership

# of Organizations by Country• USA: 604• Europe: 22• Asia: 18• Oceania: 5

# of Participating Member Organizations by Declared Stakeholder Category

Stakeholder Categories

* Omits non-active Signatory Authorities.

• North America (non-US): 29

• South America: 1• Africa: 1

As of July 2011

19

GSC16-PLEN-35


Catalog of Standards• SGIP produces and maintains the Catalog of Standards (CoS) relevant for the

development and deployment of a robust and interoperable Smart Grid– The wireless portion of the CoS

• The standards in CoS has to have:– Standards Information Form– Development Process Statement: what SSO does relative to:

• Openness.• Balance of interest• Due process• An appeals process• Consensus

– Criteria and Analysis Report: recommendation to add to CoS standards that are not emerging from Priority Action Plans (PAPs)

• Produced by individual DEWG or Standing Committee assigned by SGIP Plenary Leadership• Relevancy• Community Acceptance• Deployment Suitability• Interface Characterization• Document Maintenance• CSWG Analysis• SGAC Analysis• SGTCC Analysis

• The objective is to have TIA standards as part of the Catalog of Standards

20

GSC16-PLEN-35


The CoS Process

21

GSC16-PLEN-35


TIA TR45.5 Evaluation of Protocols• An SDO subcommittee was formed in PAP2 to produce more evaluation details• Using Version 5 of the SG Net group in OpenSG document describing

messages, transmission characteristics (e.g., frequency of transmission) and messaging requirements (e.g., latency requirements) in a smart grid network, the group is furthering its evaluation on:– Path loss models, link budgets, and system throughputs– Proposed text changes and additions to the NISTIR 7761 document – A link budget tool for various wireless technologies based on S/(N+I)

necessary for various data and code rates and other operating conditions.• The objective is to have a successful evaluation that includes TIA inputs

22

GSC16-PLEN-35


TR-51

• TIA created a new committee - TR-51– Exclusively for Smart Utility Networks (SUN) and

similar applications– Addresses OSI Layers 1 – 4– Facilitate a set of wireless solutions allowing:

• Use of IEEE 802.15.4g PHY information as appropriate (subcommittee TR-51.1)

• Participation by compatible industries - e.g. electric and other utility providers

– Complement architecture work being done in TR-50

23

GSC16-PLEN-35


TR-51 Focus• OSI L1 – L4 and interoperability• Protocols optimized for Smart Utility Networks

applications• Unique customer requirements

• Overlay networks for fault reporting, control and metering• High reliability

• Low duty cycle

24

GSC16-PLEN-35


TR-51 Timeline Summary

• 2 year timeframe (2011 – 2013)– 4 Face-to-Face meetings per year– Bi-weekly conference calls or as needed

• Documentation– PHY Layer document – MAC Layer document – Network Layer document – Transport Layer document – Test and/or conformance documents

25

halifax, 31 oct – 3 nov 2011global standards collaboration smart grid standardization activities...

Documents