halvor erikstein ewhn 2006 organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · organophosphates in...

45
Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE www.safe.no [email protected] RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European Work Hazards Network

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Organophosphates in turbine oil

Halvor EriksteinSAFE www.safe.no

[email protected]

RIGAEWHN 29. September 2006

European Work Hazards Network

Page 2: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

http://www.balpa.org/intranet/BALPA-Camp/The-Aircra/index.htm

Page 3: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 4: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 5: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Bilde hentet fra AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air – An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003” www.aopis.org

Page 6: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Bilde hentet fra AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air – An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003” www.aopis.org

BLEED AIR

Page 7: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Bilde hentet fra AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air – An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003” www.aopis.org

Page 8: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Bilde hentet fra AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air – An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003” www.aopis.org

No problems here?

Page 9: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

To viktige additiver til bl.a MILSPEC 23699

1%N-phenyl-1-napthylamine3%Tricresylfosfat (TCP) 10 isomerer(TOCP, DOCP, MOCP,

TMCP, TPCP, DMCP, DPCP…….)

Bilde hentet fra AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air – An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003” www.aopis.org

Page 10: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 11: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

• MIL SPEC 23699 Sammenligning av to oljer som møter samme spesifikasjon

Castrol 5000

Exxon 2380

Oppvarming 525 C

C. Van Netten and V. LeungAppl.OccEnv.Hyg Vol 15(3)277-283,2000

Page 12: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Eksempel på omdanning under høy temperatur.Hvor mange andre slike mekanismer finnes?

Page 13: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 14: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 15: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

BP Turbo Oil 25, 2197, 2380, 2389

• 2. COMPOSITION/INFORMATION ON INGREDIENTS• Chemical Composition Synthetic base stock. (90 - 100%)• Tris(methylphenyl) phosphate CAS No. EINECS No. 215-548-8

(<3%) 1330-78-5 • (contains <0.1% ortho isomer)• Mixed aromatic amines (<5%)• Hazardous Components• No component is present at sufficient concentration to require a

hazardous classification.

Page 16: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Standard equipment:3 turbines for power generators

2 turbines for pumps/compressors

Page 17: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Exhaust pipes from turbines

Page 18: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Same engines but different environment

Outside, cold air, high air flow

Indoor, ”high temperature”, limited airflow, running for more than 1000 hours without stopping. Much more tolerant to increased oil consumption and leakages

Illustration Illustration AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air ––An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003”An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003”www.www.aopisaopis.org.org

Page 19: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 20: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Bleed air

Page 21: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Pressure and temperature through a LM2500

Page 22: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Surface temp500 – 700 oC

Page 23: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Turbinoljen skal både smøre og være kjøelmiddel

Page 24: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

• Bearings: The leaking points

• On some offshore installations, the bleed air is used as instrument air and asbreathing air for respiratoryprotection

BLEED AIR

Illustration Illustration AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air AOPIS: ”Contaminated Cabin Air ––An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003”An Ongoing Health and Safety Issue, 2003”www.www.aopisaopis.org.org

Page 25: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

”The Sump Philosophy”

Page 26: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Bearing #1, 2, 3, 4

Page 27: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

The lubrication of bearings

OIL JET

Cavity drain

Air to createoverpressure

Return oil

9000 rpm

Ballbearing

Sump vent

Seals

Page 28: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Sump vent into the exhaust. Earlier routed ”out”

Vent oil tank

Cavity drain; To the floor under the turbine inside the hood!

All seals leaks, but the amount varies

Page 29: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Turbine hood and generator layout

Page 30: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Cavity drain/sump ventAlso used to observethe condition of thesealings

Inside the turbine hood

Page 31: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Many pipes and hoseswhich may leak.This area must be inspected while the engineis running.

Inside the turbine hood

Page 32: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Many pipes and hoses which can leak and rupture.Vapors and aerosols hit hot surfaces

Inside the turbine hood

Page 33: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Always some oil leakage and oil to be removed, sometimes >50 liters

Inside the turbine hood

Page 34: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

The vacuum cleanercreates aerosols

Page 35: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 36: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Outside

Page 37: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Thermal degradation of lube oil

• Some areas may have temperatures exceeding 500 oC

• This temperature will create thermal decomposition of the oil components

• Some of degradation products will be much more volatile and be vented out into the sump vent.

• One must expect that new compounds will be created by different chemical reactions.

Page 38: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Locally, very hot surface

Lube oil

Vent systemVolatile compounds from breakdown of oil components: InhalationSkin uptake

Local thermal degradation of lube oil

Page 39: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

Hot zones

Page 40: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

HightemperatureFrictionpressure,

Page 41: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 42: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

The 24 hours exposureOther sources for organophosphourous

compounds• The flame retardant Pyrovatex is used in

bedlinen and coveralls– Many reports on itchiness from bedlinen

• Other oils and products with flame retardants based on organophosphourous compounds.

Page 43: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 44: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European
Page 45: Halvor Erikstein EWHN 2006 Organophosphates in turbine oils · 2007-05-13 · Organophosphates in turbine oil Halvor Erikstein SAFE Halvor@safe.no RIGA EWHN 29. September 2006 European

The absence of proof is not

proof of absence