Some idea of the Herculean task of constructing the Lido course is gained from this photograph which shows in the foreground thecommencement of the filling process by pumping sand and the water of the lagoons which is now all hard ground

THE LIDO GOLF COURSEBy C. B. MACDONALD

AST year the site of the new Lido Golf Linksnear Long Beach was a flat sea meadow partlyunder water. This unpromising territory was

chosen for the making of an ideal golf course partlybecause of its climate and proximity to New Yorkbut partly also because it left the hand of the golfarchitect perfectly free to build his course from thebottom up. It was Mr. C. B. Macdonald who con-ceived the simple though expensive plan of pouringout a golf course just as Mr. Edison pours out con-crete houses. The sea meadow was first filled inwhere the water covered it, and then all the hills andundulations of an ideal course were constructed bypumping sand out of the lagoon on to the level sur-

face of the meadow. This part of the work is practicallyfinished and by the fall the course will be ready forseeding. Play of some sort will be possible over thecourse next June if weather conditions are normal,though it will be fall next year before good golf canbe expected. Every hole on the course has beenmolded so as to make it as perfect as nature hasmade some of the holes on the classic courses abroad,and every hole will have a distinct character of itsown. Mr. C. B. Macdonald the architect of thiscolossal enterprise has kindly written out a shortdescription of the course for readers of GOLF IL-

LUSTRATED.

"To write a description of any golf course neces-

This photograph was taken from the 5th green looking back toward the tee and shows the nature of the rough, sandy hillocks coveredwith beach grass

31

L

G O L F I L L U S T R A T E D

A PLASTI

GOLF COUR

DESIGNED BY

sitates stating the premises upon which is based the descrip-tion—for instance, the undulations and hillocks, thecharacter and placing of the bunkers, the variety of puttinggreens, each to suit the particular character of hole, thequality of turf, the width of the fair green, and the descrip-tion of the teeing grounds with their proximity to puttinggreens—in fact there is so much ground to cover that I cangive you only a very brief description. To start with, theundulations will vary on the different holes. Some will belongitudinal, some will be lateral, and others will be atvarious angles, so that the player will be obliged to playhis ball in every conceivable position in relation to hisstance. The reader may recall Vardon's article in which,while it was full of most inaccurate statements—such asthere being one hundred bunkers in the best holes in GreatBritain—he made one good criticism of a very large majorityof American golf courses, and that is that there were no

No.123456789

undulations and oneusually played the ball

on a level fair green. Thatwill never be a criticism of the

Long Beach course."As to putting greens, there will

be every variety, most of them copiesof greens with which all experienced

golfers are more or less familiar in thegreat courses."The majority of the bunkers will be built

and placed so that one can nearly always see them.They will be real bunkers—that is, sand excavations."The side hazards will be sand, with bent grass.

The length of the course speaks for itself:Yds.375405160510320466440220340

3236

Par443545534

37

No.101112131415161718

Yds.400390420300130400190540400

3170

Par444434354

35

"The width of the fair green will vary from 45 to 60yards, according to the character of the hole.

"The teeing grounds will be 40 to 50 yards in length

32

G O L F I L L U S T R A T E D

CINE MODEL OF THE LIDO

SE, LONG BEACH, LONG ISLAND,

THE ARCHITECT OF THE COURSE,

MR. C. B. MACDONALD

and quite in close proximity to the putting greens."The lengths are from the middle of the tee to the

middle of the green, which means every hole can be short-ened or lengthened 30 to 40 yards.

"The first hole is more or less like the fifteenth orNarrows at the National, which is a good drive and a fulliron shot. A player may find a lie of varying stance, asthe undulations run diagonally across the green. Thesecond shot must be very accurate. The hole can be mademore or less difficult by the placing of the cup on thegreen.

"The second hole resembles in some measure theeleventh at the National. The shot from the tee is a blindone, but on the fall there is considerable slope which gives,particularly to the long driver who carries the bunkers tothe right, a run which leaves him a driving iron or cleek tothe green. The green is a double plateau and is built afterone of the prize greens selected by a committee consistingof Mr. Hutchinson, Mr. Darwin and Mr. Fowler out ofeighty designs submitted to them in Great Britain for thebest two-shot hole.

"The third hole is a copy of the Eden, or eleventh, atSt. Andrew in Scotland. The only point here is that thebank protecting the green has been made much steeper thanthat at St. Andrews or the other holes built in this countrymodelled after the eleventh at St. Andrews.

"The fourth hole is a long hole of the elbow type, whichto the usual scratch player will be a three-shot hole, 510yards in length. Both the first and second shots will beover water. The green is built high on the plateau with a

deep bunker protecting it some 60 yards from the middleof the green. However, unusually long drivers, who areaccurate, may play in a pocket among sand dunes by carry-ing .180 yards off the tee direct on the flag into a valley offair green some 100 yards in length by 30 yards in width.Having accomplished that, they have a brassie shot for thegreen, making a par-four-hole of it by playing it thatway. It is a hole the idea of which I got from one of thelast holes on the links at Littlestone, England. I think thishole will be considered the finest 510-yard hole in theworld.

"The fifth hole resembles the Cape hole at the National,but the bunkering and undulations probably make it alittle more scientific than our Cape hole off the tee. Onewill always see however that it is the creation of man andnot the creation of Nature, for it has, as most holes on thiscourse have, the technical design of an architect rather thanthe inimitable design of nature.

"The sixth hole has many of the features of the seven-teenth at St. Andrews in Scotland. The green is a replicaof that green reversed, approaching from the left insteadof from the right. This hole also is of the elbow type.The undulations and bunkering are so arranged as to givethe long player a great advantage. On the second shotthere is a large and important bunker to carry.

"In the seventh hole will be found a similarity to thehog-back or fifth at the National, though the Lido hole issomewhat shorter, requiring a drive and a brassie shot.The undulations are parallel with the line of play. Thebunkers are much bolder than at the National hole.

33

G O L F I L L U S T R A T E D

This photograph was taken from the fourth tee and shows the lagoon over which the drive is made to an island which is seen incourse of construction

"The eighth hole, 220 yards, is a one-shot brassieor drive and will be known as the Biarritz hole, animprovement on the ninth at Piping Rock.

"The ninth hole resembles the seventeenth at theNational. The hole is some 30 yards longer than theNational hole, but the principles involved are thesame: that is to say, the long driver who can carry190 to 200 yards over deep bunkers has a clean run-upto the hole. Anything under that means a pitch shotto the green, and if one takes the shortest way inhis carry from the tee, he makes for himself a difficultlong carry for his second which will scarcely hold thegreen.

"The tenth is laid out on the principle of theseventeenth at Prestwick, Scotland, resembling thethird at the National and the seventeenth at Piping

Rock. The discussion which raged throughout theUnited Kingdom in 1901 and 1902 as to which wasthe best one-shot, two-shot and three-shot hole,showed that a large majority of the first class playersconsidered this the best two-shot hole in the worldand time has not in any measure altered that opinion.The only point is that the Alps at Prestwick is 375yards, which, with a gutty ball was two good shotswith wood. To-day, with the rubber-cored ball, thehole should be at least 400 yards, and this is thelength of the tenth at Long Beach. I might say herethat it was this "best hole" discussion in 1901 and1902 that gave me the inspiration to build a classicgolf course, the result being the National Golf Linksof America. My experience in that undertaking, mystudy of golf construction, and heed of the criticisms

Looking northwest from the Alps hill (tenth hole), showing the 17th fairgreen, with stakes indicating height of fill still to be made andjust beyond the raised tee to the eighteenth hole

34

G O L F I L L U S T R A T E D

of those entitled to criticize, all are expressed in theconstruction of the Long Beach course.

"The eleventh hole is a composite hole, withlateral undulations, where an over-approach willbring one into the water beyond the green. The plac-ing of the ball from the tee is most important for thesecond shot.

"The twelfth hole is the Punch Bowl, a 420-yardhole, a drive and a brassie. On the first shot, overthe lagoon, the player can 'bite off as much as he canchew.' A 180 or 190-yard carry gives him a runningfall, which will leave him a driving iron shot for thegreen. The green is well protected by a large bunkerrunning entirely across the fair green. A topped sec-ond would either catch this bunker or the water.

"The thirteenth is a drive-and-pitch hole similarto the Knoll or thirteenth at Piping Rock. Theundulations are very pronounced in the fairway, sothat one will have to play the ball from every char-acter of stance.

"The fourteenth is the short hole familiar toeveryone who has played the sixth at the Nationaland the seventeenth at Piping Rock. During thechampionship at Hoylake in 1906, at a meeting of theRules of Golf Committee, Mr. Horace Hutchinson,Mr. John L. Low and myself discussed the best char-acter for a short hole and this particular hole wasdrawn out. The great feature of the hole is the un-dulations on the putting green. When the flag is inthe horse-shoe in the middle of the green one shouldalways play for a two. Another essential feature of ashort hole of this character is that there should be avalley between the player and the hole which deceivesthe player as to its length. It has been said that theshort hole at the National was modelled after the shorthole at Brancaster. It is true I mentioned the shorthole at Brancaster at our meeting, but the criticismof that hole is that the green is higher than the tee,so that one cannot see where the flag goes into thehole. On all short holes the player should be ableto see where the pin enters the hole.

"The fifteenth is a copy of one of the prize holesawarded by the English committee before named.It needs accurate placing of the ball and an ac-curate approach.

"The sixteenth hole is a replica of the Redan atNorth Berwick, familiar in this country to those whohave played the fourth at the National or the third atPiping Rock. Comment upon this hole is unnecessaryas it is so well known, but it may be interesting toknow that in the controversy in 1901 and 1902 as tothe best holes, the majority of players named theeleventh at St. Andrews first, but the Redan at NorthBerwick ran it a very close second. To my mind,although I am a St. Andrews man, the only reason theeleventh at St. Andrews was selected by the majorityis that the St. Andrews hole was better known thanthe Redan. I consider the Redan to be the finest one-shot hole in the world, and on any golf course whereone has freedom in choice there should always be aRedan placed.

"The seventeenth is another composite hole, basedchiefly on the principle of bunkers in echelon. Theplayer who makes a great carry can run down throughthe valley and get a fine second shot, making an easyapproach to the green, while one who takes a shorterway is confronted with undulations which make theshot more or less difficult. There is a carry over adeep cross bunker some 350 yards from the tee thatnecessitates a good drive and a good second.

"The eighteenth hole is a copy of the hole thattook the first prize in the competition abroad, thearchitect being Dr. Mackenzie, who is a noted golfexpert. This hole gives one three different fair greensto play to from the tee, each one to be chosen ac-cording to the player's ability and according to thewind. The fairway is full of bunkers and the secondshot must be as accurate as the first. As a finishinghole I know of none that will give a golfer whoseopponent has him one down a better chance to retrievehimself at the last hole than this one, unless it be theeighteenth at the National."

The tenth or Alps green under construction

35

G O L F I L L U S T R A T E D