hidden morbidity following colorectal resection: postoperative evaluation · 2016. 9. 24. ·...

1
Hidden morbidity following colorectal resection: postoperative evaluation G C Thorpe 1 & J M Hernon 2 1 School of Health Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich 2 Norfolk & Norwich University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust Introduction Methods Results Conclusion References 1 Grocott MPW et al (2007) The Postoperative Morbidity Survey was validated and used to describe morbidity after pelvic surgery. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 60: 919-928 2 Dindo, D. et al (2004) Classification of Surgical Complications: a new proposal with evaluation in a cohort of 6336 patients and results of a survey. Annals of Surgery 240(2):205-213 3 Spanjersberg, W.R. et al (2011) Fast track surgery versus conventional recovery strategies for colorectal surgery. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews CD007635 Table 2: Patient questions to ascertain post- discharge SSI Since leaving hospital, has (have) your wound(s): Been red/inflamed/hot/more painful? Opened? If so how much and how deep? Produced any discharge? If so how much, what was its appearance and did it smell? Been assessed by a healthcare professional who said it was infected? Required dressing (and packing)? Been swabbed? Have you taken any antibiotics for your wound? The implementation and evaluation of Enhanced Recovery after Surgery programmes over the past 15 years has ensured the accurate reporting of inpatient morbidity post colorectal resection. However, there is a paucity of audit or research examining post- operative morbidity (POM) in the early discharge period. A clinical survey was conducted May-August 2014, funded by Research Capability Funding, to ascertain the incidence of post-discharge morbidity following colorectal resection. The sample comprised 142 consecutive patients undergoing colorectal resection (see table 1 for sample characteristics). Audit data were collected on 138 patients in a nurse-led outpatient clinic at 30 days following discharge. Data collection templates were developed using the Postoperative Morbidity Survey 1 , Clavien-Dindo classification criteria 2 and additional colorectal-specific evidence of post-operative morbidity 3 . Templates were piloted and modified to include additional data, such as information from the entire discharge period that could indicate surgical site infection (SSI) (table 2). Results were recorded and analysed using SPSS. Findings suggest that individuals undergoing colorectal resection experience significant levels of post- discharge morbidity, extending the burden on them and the services required to support them for longer than may have been previously anticipated. Nurse-led follow-up using an auditable documentation template can identify the incidence of complications following discharge, providing both data to inform service improvement and valuable support for patients. Figure 1: Post-operative morbidity post colorectal resection at 30 days following discharge from hospital Findings revealed unexpectedly high levels of post-discharge morbidity in the following areas (figure 1): 35% (n=32) of infection-free inpatients developed SSI following discharge (n=29 elective surgery). 34% (n=47) of all patients had one or more significant urinary problem (UTI, incontinence, sensory change, hesitancy, frequency, urgency, self- retaining catheter). Questions regarding dietary intake revealed an appetite of half, or less than half, usual intake in 27% of patients (n=37), with moderate to major changes in dietary intake in 17% (n=17) of people without an ileostomy compared to their pre- operative diet. Of those without an ileostomy, 20% (n=20) had four or more daily bowel movements, with 22% (n=23) describing their stool consistency as watery, loose or unsettled. 50% (n=39) of those without a stoma reported one or more problematic new bowel symptom related to their surgical experience at 30 days post- discharge (urgency, incomplete emptying, constipation, diarrhoea, tenesmus, excessive wind, incontinence, pain). Table 1: Description of Sample Age Gender Male Female Presentation Elective Urgent/Emergency Stoma Ileostomy Colostomy Diagnosis Malignant Benign Operation Site Left-sided Right-sided Mean 67.39y (SD 13.692) n=73 (51.4%) n=69 (48.6%) n=98 (69%) n=44 (31%) n=38 (26.8%) n=22 (15.5%) n=87 (61.3%) n=55 (38.7%) n=91 (64%) n=51 (36%)

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jan-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • Hidden morbidity following colorectal resection:

    postoperative evaluationG C Thorpe1 & J M Hernon2

    1 School of Health Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich 2Norfolk & Norwich University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

    Introduction

    Methods

    Results

    Conclusion

    References1Grocott MPW et al (2007) The Postoperative Morbidity Survey was validated and used to describe morbidity after pelvic surgery. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 60: 919-9282Dindo, D. et al (2004) Classification of Surgical Complications: a new proposal with evaluation in a cohort of 6336 patients and results of a survey. Annals of Surgery 240(2):205-2133Spanjersberg, W.R. et al (2011) Fast track surgery versus conventional recovery strategies for colorectal surgery. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews CD007635

    Table 2: Patient questions to ascertain post-discharge SSISince leaving hospital, has (have) your wound(s):

    • Been red/inflamed/hot/more painful?

    • Opened? If so how much and how deep?

    • Produced any discharge? If so how much, what was its appearance and did it smell?

    • Been assessed by a healthcare professional who said it was infected?

    • Required dressing (and packing)?

    • Been swabbed?

    Have you taken any antibiotics for your wound?

    The implementation and evaluation ofEnhanced Recovery after Surgeryprogrammes over the past 15 yearshas ensured the accurate reporting ofinpatient morbidity post colorectalresection. However, there is a paucityof audit or research examining post-operative morbidity (POM) in theearly discharge period. A clinicalsurvey was conducted May-August2014, funded by Research CapabilityFunding, to ascertain the incidence ofpost-discharge morbidity followingcolorectal resection.

    The sample comprised 142consecutive patients undergoingcolorectal resection (see table 1 forsample characteristics). Audit datawere collected on 138 patients in anurse-led outpatient clinic at 30 daysfollowing discharge. Data collectiontemplates were developed using thePostoperative Morbidity Survey1,Clavien-Dindo classification criteria2

    and additional colorectal-specificevidence of post-operativemorbidity3. Templates were pilotedand modified to include additionaldata, such as information from theentire discharge period that couldindicate surgical site infection (SSI)(table 2). Results were recorded andanalysed using SPSS.

    Findings suggest that individualsundergoing colorectal resectionexperience significant levels of post-discharge morbidity, extending theburden on them and the services requiredto support them for longer than may havebeen previously anticipated. Nurse-ledfollow-up using an auditabledocumentation template can identify theincidence of complications followingdischarge, providing both data to informservice improvement and valuablesupport for patients.

    Figure 1: Post-operative morbidity post colorectal resection at 30 days following discharge from hospital

    Findings revealed unexpectedly highlevels of post-discharge morbidity in thefollowing areas (figure 1): 35% (n=32) of infection-free

    inpatients developed SSI followingdischarge (n=29 elective surgery).

    34% (n=47) of all patients had one ormore significant urinary problem(UTI, incontinence, sensory change,hesitancy, frequency, urgency, self-retaining catheter).

    Questions regarding dietary intakerevealed an appetite of half, or lessthan half, usual intake in 27% ofpatients (n=37), with moderate tomajor changes in dietary intake in17% (n=17) of people without anileostomy compared to their pre-operative diet.

    Of those without an ileostomy, 20%(n=20) had four or more daily bowelmovements, with 22% (n=23)describing their stool consistency aswatery, loose or unsettled. 50%(n=39) of those without a stomareported one or more problematicnew bowel symptom related to theirsurgical experience at 30 days post-discharge (urgency, incompleteemptying, constipation, diarrhoea,tenesmus, excessive wind,incontinence, pain).

    Table 1: Description of SampleAgeGender

    MaleFemale

    PresentationElectiveUrgent/Emergency

    StomaIleostomyColostomy

    DiagnosisMalignantBenign

    Operation SiteLeft-sidedRight-sided

    Mean 67.39y (SD 13.692)

    n=73 (51.4%)n=69 (48.6%)

    n=98 (69%)n=44 (31%)

    n=38 (26.8%)n=22 (15.5%)

    n=87 (61.3%)n=55 (38.7%)

    n=91 (64%)n=51 (36%)