High angular resolution withHigh angular resolution withnear-infrared Adaptive Opticsnear-infrared Adaptive Optics

in the era of the Virtual Observatoryin the era of the Virtual ObservatoryUsing VObs techniques to search for AO-suitable targetsUsing VObs techniques to search for AO-suitable targets

Jens Zuther

Wolfgang Voges (MPE, MPDL), Gerard Lemson (ARI, MPE), Jaiwon Kim (MPE), and Andreas Eckart (Univ. of Cologne)

M13

ALTAIR AO @ Gemini

HST

ALTAIR AO @ Gemini

1st AIDA community workshop : Multi-wavelength Astronomy and the Virtual ObservatoryESAC, 1-3 Dec. 2008

seeing limited

Overview

1. Astrophysical motivation & Instrumental solution:

Adaptive Optics

2. Find suitable targets:Virtual Observatory

3. Summary & Outlook

Folie: 2

1. Astrophysical motivation & Instrumental solution

Folie: 3

Folie: 4

• Every galaxy harbors a supermassive central black hole

• M●/ relation

• Coeval growth of massive black holes and galaxy bulges

• Starburst/AGN connection• But only 10% of the local

galaxies are Seyfert-like

(Tremaine et al. 2002)

The hosts of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN)

(Marconi & Hunt 2003)

Size, luminosity, and structure of the host galaxy can provide Size, luminosity, and structure of the host galaxy can provide valuable information on the origin and fuelling of AGN.valuable information on the origin and fuelling of AGN. Need high angular resolution in order to reach small Need high angular resolution in order to reach small linear scales, linear scales, BUTBUT limitations by atmospheric turbulence. limitations by atmospheric turbulence.

Solution: Adaptive Optics (AO)

Folie: 5

(Courtesy Gemini Observatory)

Folie: 6

Why conduct AO-assisted near-infrared (NIR) studies?

• NIR is less influenced by dust extinction by a factor of about 30, compared to visible wavelengths.

• Dominance of the red stellar host against blue AGN.

• Adaptive Optics feasible in the NIR, allowing for high angular resolution and separation of nucleus and host; even at higher redshifts.

• Several diagnostic lines to probe star formation and nuclear activity are available.

Current results from AO studies: Fuelling

• VLT NACO observation of NGC 1097(Almudena Prieto et al. 2005, AJ, 130, 1472)

• Gemini NIFS observation of NGC 4051(Riffel et al. 2008, MNRAS, 385, 1129)

Folie: 7

Mrk 609 – SINFONI

Folie: 8

(Zuther+ 2007, A&A, 466, 451)

Folie: 8

SDSS r-band

• H+K, R~1500

• z~0.034

• FWHM~270pc

• Broad Pa + [SiVI]

• LINER nucleus?

-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5

-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

starbursts Seyfert 1 Seyfert 2 LINER super nova

log

( [F

eII]

/ P

a )

log ( H2 / Br )

LINER

AGN

SB

5

total

photoionization

shock

3

2

4

1

IRAS00317

2.Find suitable targets

Folie: 9

AO conditions

• isoplanatic patch0~

• nearby star can serve as a pointsource reference(natural guide star)

• Here:– target / NGS ang. separation θθ ≤ 40´´ ≤ 40´´

– NGS visual brightness VV < 14< 14magmag

Folie: 10

Selecting AGN• Soft X-ray background has

been almost completely resolved into discrete sources, dominated by type-1 AGN ( efficient selection criterion;e.g. Brandt & Hasinger 2005).

• Furthermore, the impact of the strong AGN (phase) on its host galaxy is still far from being understood satisfactory (cf. Begelman 2004; Wang 2008; Schawinski et al 2006).

crossmatch SDSS and X-ray data sets (like ROSAT or XMM)

Folie: 11

The matching problem …

Folie: 12

guide star

AGN

… combining catalogs with different resolutions!(i) Pure positional matching (OpenSkyQuery, GAVO matcher,AstroGrid [Topcat, Stilts]).(ii) add further knowledge like spectroscopy, X/radio correlation(SDSS AGN [Anderson et al 2003], CLASS-X [McGlynn et al 2004])

The AO X-ray AGN sample: VObs in a broader sense

Folie: 13

localDB

localDB

FIRSTRASSSDSS …

OpenSkyQuerycone search,ADQL,VOTable

SDSS CasJobsVOTable

AstroGrid UKcone search,SIA, SSA,VOSpace,VOTable,Registry

NEDweb service,cone search

TopcatTopcat DS9overlaysDS9overlays

IDL + Java + Python + dpuser, spectral anaylsis,image processing

IDL + Java + Python + dpuser, spectral anaylsis,image processing

(Zuther et al. in prep.)

GAVO matcherGAVO

matcher

Sample properties

• Based on SDSS DR6 & RASS• Use Princeton spectroscopic

re-reductions (97149 objects classified as AGN)

• Find targets with nearby guide stars(7123)

• Crossmatch AO-suitable targets with RASS(~6 optical counterparts per X-ray source)

Folie: 14

Pragmatics

• Interested only in spectroscopic sources try to validate association.

• >90% of the X-ray sources have only 1 spectroscopic counterpart.

• Apply the angular separation cut of Parejko et al.

Folie: 15

(Parejko+ 2008)

~550

Catalogs

• visualize relations betweencatalog properties

Folie: 16

Morphological classification

• Large fraction point-likeFolie: 17

petrorad_r > 2‘‘early-type

BUDDA as VObs service: Work in progress

Folie: 18

(cf Gadotti 2008)

Spectra

Folie: 19

use Bruzual & Charlot starburst templates extracted via AstroGrid

H

Baldwin-Phillips-Terlevich diagram

Folie: 20

-1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5-1.0

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

lo

g([

OIII

]/H)

log([NII]/H)

A07 new Kauffmann '03 Kewley '01 mixing curve

Seyfert

LINERstarburst

composites

3.Outlook

Folie: 21

Current sample• High angular resolution is necessary, but• The sample awaits more in-depth classification

(e.g., BUDDA) focus on sizable subsets (e.g. composites)

• Publication of the sample database• Publication of the AO observations

3D standards for integral-field data (EURO-3D; cf. Chilingarian 2008)

Multi-conjugate AO and the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT)

Folie: 23(image credit: Marc-Andre Besel and Wiphu Rujopakarn)

(Bertram 2007)

The end. Thanks!

Folie: 24

Folie: 25

The need for high angular resolution

• The apparent interplay between the AGN and its immediate surroundings call for high angular resolution in order to – to resolve the nuclear gas/stellar dynamics– distinguish between emission from the SMBH

and the circum-nuclear environment

• BUT: atmospheric turbulence limits the resolving power of large telescopes

I. Physikalisches InstitutJens Zuther05.03.2007

Folie: 26

Luminosity-dependent evolution

• Broad-line AGN dominate the number densities at the higher X-ray luminosities, while non broad line AGN dominate at the lower X-ray luminosities.

• The comoving emissivity of AGN occurs at lower and lower redshift for AGN of lower and lower luminosity.

Downsizing

(Hasinger et al. 2005, Barger et al. 2005)

Throwing darts• Extensive simulation and SDSS/ROSAT

cross-matching of spectroscopically identified sources give source-separation distance at fixed truematching fraction

(Parejko et al. 2008)

Folie: 27

What is the VObs?

• The Virtual Observatory is a framework that allows worldwide transparent access to distributed data.

• Allows scientists to discover, access, analyze, and combine data from heterogeneous data collections in a user-friendly and standardized manner

Folie: 28

The AO X-ray AGN sample: Using the VObs

• Cross-matching is classical VObs use case– collect catalog data (SDSS, ROSAT,

FIRST, 2MASS, IRAS, …)– positional matching– collect further information, e.g., via NED

Folie: 29

What are composite galaxies?

• ROSAT/IRAS match (Moran+ 1996)• Visible- spectrum dominated

by starburst features, while• X-ray spectrum typical of those of

Seyfert-1s• no big-blue-bump

Interpretation: AGN & star formation of similar strength

1. reddening towards the nucleus

2. host outshines AGN (e.g., Moran 2002, ApJ, 579)

3. cold accretion (e.g., Koratkar & Blaes, 1999, PASP,111)Folie: 30

(cf. Moran+ 1996, ApJS, 106, 341; Panessa+ 2005, ApJ, 631, 707)

The more information the better (probabilistic matching)• Pure positional matching:

minimization process- OpenSkyQuery- AstroGrid & Topcat & Stilts

• Add astronomical knowledge:– source type (spectroscopy)– know correlations, e.g., X-ray/radio

- SDSS AGN selection (Anderson et al. 2003)

- CLASSX oblique decision trees (McGlynn et al. 2004)

Folie: 31

(see Budavari & Szalay 2008 for a details)