hlhs current consideration & expectation sha...
TRANSCRIPT
HLHS Current Consideration &
Expectation SHA 2017
Ahmed Abdullah Jamjoom
A spectrum of cardiac malformations characterized by
underdevelopment of the left heart with significant hypoplasia
of the left ventricle including atresia, stenosis or hypoplasia of
the aortic or mitral valve, or both , and hypoplasia of the ascending
aorta and aortic arch
Society of Thoracic Surgeons Congenital Heart Surgery Nomenclature and Database defines
HLHS
Incidence • 0.2 per 1000 live births • HLHS accounts for 2.5% of congenital heart defects
but is responsible if left untreated for up to 25-40% of all deaths within the first week of life
• Without surgical palliation, 95% of children die within the first month of life
• A male predominance ( male to female ratio 1.5:1 )
• Prevalence of CHD 2.1 and 10.7 per 1,000 persons
• The incidence of severe CHD 5.4 per 1,000 live births per year
• HLHS 9.1% of total severe CHD
• 0.5 per 1000 live births VS 0.2 per 1000 live births
Congenital Heart Dis. 2012 May-Jun;7(3):277-82. Incidence of severe congenital heart disease at the province of Al-Qassim, Saudi Arabia. Al-Mesned A1, Al Akhfash AA, Sayed M.
Pathogenesis • Intrauterine infarction, infection, and
LV cardiomyopathy have been suggested
• Anatomical abnormality of the atrial septum or foramen oval
• Abnormal development of the left ventricle itself (Endocardial fibroelastosis)
• Abnormality of the mitral (parachute, arcade) and/or the aortic valve (bicuspid or unicuspid)
• Fetal demise is reported, most pregnancies reach term gestation
Genetics • Commonly occurs sporadically in otherwise
clinically normal neonates
• Recurrence risk of left heart disease in first degree relatives of infants with HLHS is 2-4%
• HLHS has been associated with Turner syndrome (XO), Jacobsen syndrome (deletion of distal 11q), trisomy 13, and trisomy 18
Impact of Patient Characteristics on Results of Norwood Operation for Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome Bahaaldin Alsoufi, Makoto Mori, Scott Gillespie, Brian Schlosser, Timothy Slesnick, Brian Kogon, Dennis Kim, Ritu Sachdeva, Kirk Kanter Annals of Thoracic Surgery 2015, 100 (2): 591-8
Diagnosis • Echocardiographic imaging,
pre - or postnatal
• Mortality is not reduced if a prenatal diagnosis is made
• Morbidity reduction when HLHS is diagnosed before birth
Prenatal diagnosis, birth location, surgical center, and neonatal mortality in infants with hypoplastic left heart syndrome Shaine A Morris, Mary K Ethen, Daniel J Penny, Mark A Canfield, Charles G Minard, David E Fixler, Wendy N Nembhard Circulation 2014 January 21, 129 (3): 285-92
• Infants with HLHS born far from a CSC have increased neonatal mortality, and most of this mortality is pre surgical
• Efforts to improve prenatal
diagnosis and delivery near a large volume CSC may significantly improve neonatal HLHS survival
Pre-natal Diagnosis
• Potential fetal intervention
• Fetal listing for heart transplantation
• Genetic testing and evaluation for extra
cardiac anomalies
• Counseling to discuss the option of pregnancy termination or comfort care after birth
Fetal Intervention In HLHS • Only applicable to small
number of cases
• Long-term outcome still in question
(Circulation. 2010;121:1256-1263.)
Current Status of Fetal Cardiac Intervention Doff B. McElhinney, MD; Wayne Tworetzky, MD; James E. Lock, MD
Presentation
• Honeymoon period immediately after birth because of adequate systemic perfusion through the PDA and relatively high PVR
• PDA begins to close and PVR decreases, infants become symptomatic with a decrease in systemic perfusion
• Infants with a restrictive or no ASD at birth present with severe cyanosis and respiratory distress
Choice of management
• Staged palliative surgery is the management choice for HLHS over cardiac transplantation and compassionate care
• Debate to whether compassionate care should be offered • Most parents choose staged surgical palliation, and compassionate
care is rarely selected
Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome: Exploring a Paradigm Shift in Favor of Surgery Erin A Paul, Kristina Orfali, Thomas J Starc Pediatric Cardiology 2016, 37 (8): 1446-145
Attitudes and practices of cardiologists and surgeons who manage HLHS Milan Prsa, Crystal D Holly, Franco A Carnevale, Henri Justino, Charles V Rohlicek Pediatrics 2010, 125 (3): e625-30
Transplantation • Highest waitlist mortality of all solid organ recipients 17%
• Primary heart transplant for HLHS is rarely offered in this era and is
not recommended
• 8% of the Patients who had undergone Norwood procedure were listed for heart transplantation
• 74% received heart transplantation 23% died before transplantation 3% were delisted • 38% between the Glenn and Fontan 35 % between the Norwood and Glenn 27 % post Fontan • Overall survival at 1, 5, and 10 years following transplantation was
82%, 68%, and 59%, respectively
Ethics of Cardiac Transplantation in Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome
Alexander A. Kon Pediatr Cardiol (2009) 30:725–728, DOI 10.1007/s00246-009-9428-z
Stage I
• Include the Norwood procedure, the Sano
procedure, and the hybrid approach • Objectives of initial surgery Unobstructed blood flow from the RV to the body Controlled source of pulmonary blood flow Unobstructed way between the PV and the RV
Stage II Cavopulmonary shunt
• The original shunt is removed and the superior vena cava is anastomosed end-to-side to the pulmonary artery
• Patients whose stage I was performed in a hybrid
fashion require a more extensive stage II operation
Stage III Fontan procedure
• Creates a venous pathway that directs the IVC flow
into the PA • Although this is the final stage of palliation for HLHS,
proportion of patients may require additional intervention
• Failure of the Fontan may require takedown of the Fontan or heart transplant
HLHS Stage I palliative surgery Early Mortality Series
23%
Variation in Outcomes for Benchmark Operations: An analysis of the STS Congenital Heart Surgery Database Jeffrey Phillip Jacobs, MD,1 Sean M. O’Brien, PhD,2 Sara K. Pasquai, MD,2 Marshall Lewis Jacobs, MD,3 Francois G. Lacour–Gayet, MD,4 Christo I. Tchervenkov, MD,5 Erle H. Austin, III, MD,6 Christian Pizarro, MD,7 Kamal K. Pourmoghadam, MD,8 Frank G. Scholl, MD,9 Karl F. Welke, MD,10 and Constantine Mavroudis, MD3
Ann Thorac Surg. 10.1016/j.athoracsur.2011.06.008
• RV-PA group was superior to the BT shunt for the
primary endpoint of death or transplant at 12 m, at 32 m this was no longer significant
• The need for ECMO during the Norwood hospitalization was greater in the BT shunt group
• Unintended cardiovascular interventions on the shunt or neoaorta were more common in the RV-PA group
• Echo measures of RV end-DV, EF were superior for the RV-PA group up to Stage II, but had equalized by 14 m
• PA size was larger in the BT shunt group
SVR (Single Ventricle Reconstruction) Trial A Pediatric Heart Network, 15-center, National Institutes of Health–sponsored, randomized trial compared the BT shunt and RV-PA
Mortality Outcome • 5 year survival 70% for infants who undergo stage I repair
• For children who survive to the age of 12 months, long-term survival is
approximately 90%
• Mortality rates associated with stages II and III are low
• 1, 5, and 10 year survival rates of 75, 70, and 65 %, respectively
• HLHS with genetic disorders, prematurity, low birth weight, living in poor neighborhood, ECMO , unplanned reoperation Mortality increases
Improved Survival of Patients Undergoing Palliation of Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome: Lessons Learned From 115 Consecutive Patients
James S. Tweddell, MD; George M. Hoffman, MD; Kathleen A. Mussatto, RN; Raymond T. Fedderly, MD; Stuart Berger, MD; Robert D.B. Jaquiss, MD; Nancy Nancy S. Ghanayem, MD; Stephanie J. Frisbee, MSc; S. Bert Litwin, MD Circulation is available at http://www.circulationaha.org DOI: 10.1161/01.cir.0000032878.55215.bd
• Exercise intolerance
• Neurodevelopmental delay
• Growth
• Thrombotic complications
• Fontan Failure • Quality of life
Morbidity Outcome
Neurodevelopment in children with hypoplastic left heart syndrome Anne Sarajuuri, Eero Jokinen, Riina Puosi, Leena Mildh, Ilkka Mattila, Aulikki Lano, Tuula Lönnqvist Journal of Pediatrics 2010, 157 (3): 414-20, 420.e1-4
Electronic Referral Report To KFSH-J Pediatric Cardiology January 2013- January 2017 TOF Single ventricle Heart VSD HLHS AVSD TGA Aortic arch Hypoplasia, Coarctation ASD-secundum Partial AVSD SAM, LVOTO
Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome: Experience With Palliative Surgery
WILLIAM 1. NORWOOD, MD, FACC’ JAMES K. KIRKLIN, MD* STEPHEN P. SANDERS, MD+ Boston, Massachusetts
Persistent effort to improve the long-term outlook of neonates with hypoplastic left heart syndrome is to be encouraged for the following reasons: (1) It is the fourth most common congenital cardiac anomaly entering the
New England Regional Infant Cardiac Program (after ventricular septal defect, tetralogy of Fallot and transposition of the great arteries)
(2) Unlike many forms of congenital cardiac disease, the syndrome has a very low incidence rate of associated extracardiac anomalies
Prevalence Report of Congenital Cardiac surgery Operations KFSH-J January 2013- January 2017 Tetralogy repair 104 9.52 % Cavopulmonary anastomosis 101 9.25 % VSD-perimembranous repair 82 7.51 % Fontan operation 81 7.42 % Stage I – Norwood 71 6.50 % AVSD-complete repair 58 5.31 % TGA repair-arterial switch 49 4.49 % Aortic arch repair 31 2.84 % ASD-secundum repair 30 2.75 % Partial AVSD 26 2.38 %
Norwood Procedure 135
BT Shunt
(n=76)
56.3%
RV-PA shunt
(n-=52)
38.5%
Stage II (Glenn) (n=29) 51.3%
Stage II (Glenn) (n=22)
42.3%
Norwood Cavopulmonary
Anastomosis (n=7) 5.2%
EC Fontan (n=2) 3.8%
EC Fontan (n=12) 15.8%
Lost Follow
up (n=12) 15.8%
Early Mortality
(n=17) 22.4%
Lost Follow
up (n=8) 15.4%
Early Mortality
(n=13) 25%
I. S. Mortality
(n=4) 5.3%
I. S. Mortality
(n=3) 5.8%
Annual cases
BT shunt Vs RV-PA Shunt
Diagnosis BT shunt (n=76) RV to PA conduit (n=52) P-value
HLHS 53 46 0.028
AA,MA 15(19.8%) 27(51.9%) 0.001
AS,MA 27(35.5%) 11(21.2%) 0.02
AA,MS 11(14.5%) 8(15.4%) 0.757
Others 23(30.3%) 6(11.5%) 0.02
Diagnosis
BT shunt (n=76) RV to PA conduit (n=52) P-value
Gender (male) 43(56.6%) 30(57.7%) 1.0
Age(days) 47.71±35.28 37.02±32.8 0.163
Weight (Kg) 3.3±0.73 3.03±0.67 0.029
Height (cm) 50.9±7.9 50.03±4.5 0.47
Pre Operative Data
BT shunt (n=76) RV to PA conduit (n=52) P-value
Aortic cross clamp 84.39±30.46 69.12±30.78 0.01
Total bypass time 163.97±54.34 134±76.58 0.02
LOS 56.6±37.18 48.46±37.71 0.659
ICU stay 45.55±33.26 38.46±33.39 0.688
ECMO 14(18.4%) 10(19.2%) 1.0
Early Mortality 17(22.4%) 13(25%) 0.832
Intra – Post Operative Data
BT shunt (n=76) RV to PA conduit (n=52) P-value
Time for Stage II 274.79±107.92 200.24±76.8 0.007
Stage II 29(38.2%) 22(42.3) 0.714
Stage III (EC Fontan) 12(15.8%) 2(3.4%) 0.043
Inter Stage Data
Postoperative
intervention
BT shunt (n=76) RV to PA conduit
(n=52)
P-Value
Aortic arch
intervention
10 (13.2%) 5(9.6%) 0.15
PA stent 2(2.6%)
3(5.8%) 0.12
Shunt stent 5(6.6%) 3(5.8%) 0.78
Atrial septostomy 2(2.6%) 0 0.134
Collateral coiling 2(2.6%) 1(1.9%) 0.421
Aortic arch repair 4(4.2%) 1(1.9%)
0.357
Surgery to the Shunt
2(2.6%) 2(3.8%) 0.561
Recoarctation After Norwood I Procedure for Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome: Impact of Patch Material Keti Vitanova, Julie Cleuziou, Jelena Pabst von Ohain, Melchior Burri, Andreas Eicken, Rüdiger Lange Annals of Thoracic Surgery 2017, 103 (2): 617-621
P-Value RV to PA conduit
(n=52)
BT shunt (n=76) variable
0.832 13(25%) 17(22.4%) Early Mortality
0.677 3(5.8%) 𝟒(𝟒. 𝟐%) Interstage Mortality
0.697
16(30.8%)
21(27.6%) Overall mortality
Mortality Data
Predictors of early mortality - Low body weight - Prolonged bypass time and - ECMO
HLHS Evolution 1982 1985 1990 1995 2000 2017
Stage I Norwood
Fontan Modification
Improvements in Intraoperative Support
Improvements in Postoperative Support
Pre natal Diagnosis
PGE Echo ICU
Evolving Strategies Fetal Intervention
Stem Cell Home Monitoring
Conclusion • Norwood operation can be successful with good results that warrant offering
treatment to most newborns with HLHS in KSA
• Survival beyond the neonatal period and into adulthood is possible
• Lack of heart transplantation should not be considered sufficient reasons to deny surgical care to HLHS patients
• The last four decades, from comfort care to long-term survival, should make patients with HLHS, their families, and the physicians who care for them hopeful that outcomes will continue to improve
With all the challenges and obstacles this is the care we should pursue !
THANK YOU
Thank You