home - stfc computational mathematics group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦i ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ®...

39

Upload: others

Post on 29-Sep-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

����� ������� �������������������� � �!�"�����#�$� �%�&�$����"' () &�*����� +,�-�"� �*� (����/.�� ���10�243 5 �����6����'&� 7 � �8��9�� ��� : �;9�<>=@?A� ���B���!� ����51�

CED8(&� ?���>5F� �������8��G

HJILKNM$OQPSR$TVUXWZY\[^]O`_XWba-[1cdWeILaJfBT-Uhg$ikj

lSO`KNM$a$ImKnWbPpoqOnrtsbuwvxlqoXy{zB|}y{~b�;yZ�\��^� ox�\| � f

����|x�/O���T � sbu�I�s/P�Im��-�Q�/� ��l%sbg-P�s/g-��O � OQ[$O��

�$uNWeaVK�O

�����p���1�!�����O��VOQP�ILOn�/OJvwM-Wev�v�M$O�WZ�{WeILPmWe�$ILP�I�vdY�sb��rVs/u�vNWe�$PLO�WeaV[�O� !K�ILOna�vF�wOnu�ImWePhWba-[�r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnPa�g-¡�OQuwImKnWbPkP�IL�$uNWeu�I�O`�¢v�M-W{vhKQWea��tO}g-�wOQ[FWb�^�$g$ILPL[$I�a$£��-P�s\KN¤\�^IL�@On��v�uwOQ¡¥OnPLY�I�¡¥rtsbuwv�Wea�v�¦sbuS�tsev�M���IL¡¥r$PLI§�¦Y;ILa$£XWbr$r$PLILKQW{vwILsba��wse�¨vd©@Weu�Oª[\On�/OnPLsbr$¡¥OQa/v«Wea-[}IL¡¥r$uws{�;ILa$£qu�OnPLILWb�$I�PLI�vdYbTl@M$IL�¬Im�­ILP�PLg-��vwuNW{v�OQ[��;Y�K�s/a-��Im[\OQuwILa$£�v�M$O®�wsbPLg\v�I�s/a�se�p�¦g$PLPBWea-[���r-Wbu��wOxPLI�a-OQWeu^��Y\��vwOQ¡¥�QT��O�[$OQ��K�u�I��tO¯��gVKnK�O`�w�wIL�bO°PLWZY/OnuN�Fse��K�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-WeP�¤bOnu�a$OQPL�J�wg-KNM�Wb�±v�M$O¯²@³S|®fk´vwM$O±��rVWeuN��O�²@³%|Xfk´«�$PLs;KN¤/OQ[¯WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡����¦s/u��µWbK�vws/uwIL¶nILa$£ �¦g-P�Pq�wY;��vwOQ¡��n´¢[\ILu�OQK·v¥Wea-[I§v�OnuNW{vwIL�bO}¡¥O�v�M$s\[$�^�¦sbux�wr-Wbu��wO}P�ILa$OQWbux��Y\��vwOQ¡¥�QT��O±WePm��s���M$s{©�M-s{©¸vwM$O±WeuNKNM$I�vwOQK�vwg$u�O!sb�xvwM$O1vws\[$WZYk¹ ��rts{©¬OQu��¦g-P^oqc�f � r$u�s;KnOQ����s/u��¡¥WZY�I�a\ºVg$Ona-KnO�O� !K�ILOna�vxK�s\[\O�[$OQ�wI�£/apT»8¼b½-¾h¿;ÀnÁkÂ`Ã@Ä-ÅNÆZÅNÇtÈ�ÉÊÄtË^Ì$Í;Î�Ï�ÐÒÑdÓÕÔbÖµÎ�Ï�ÐÒÑdÓ×Ô8ØZÅ�ÑdÙ/ÅNÇ×ÚNÍ\Û­ÜÒÌ�Ý*Þ/Ñdß{à�ÅNÚÒÚÒßQÑdÚNÍ-á�Ç×ß{à�ØZÅ·â�ãpÚÒØZß·äªÖÌeàwå/Ù;Ïná\ÅNǨÍ\Þ;Ï�Ñ�ÏQÇ×Ç×ÅNÇBÉÊÄVË@Ì$Í�ÚÒÞ;Ï�ÑdÚÒÅ®âbÓ×ÑdÅ�à�Ð@Î�Å�Ðdå/ßeâ/ÚNÍ�ÚÒß`Ç×æ/ÐdÓ×ß`Ù!Ç×Ó×Ù�Å·Ï�Ñ@ÚèçbÚèÐdÅNÎ�ÚNÍ�ÅNÇ×ÅNÎ�ÅNÙ{ÐÒÖµáeçeÖÅ�ǧÅ�Î�ÅNÙ{ТÞ/ÑdÅNàNßQÙ;âbÓ×ÐdÓ×ßQÙ�Ó×Ù�ébÍ�ÚÒÞ�ÏnÑdÚÒÅhÉÊÄtË^Ì$êë�ìîí%ïðìîñ�íkò ·ótôVõ�¼bö`÷�öZø�ù;··ú�ûpöQù�÷·úL¿;ükÂ`ìýZþQÿ��`þeÍ$ý`þQÿpþ��bê

��� Ï�ÑÒÐ!ß��XÐdå�Ó×Ú�ÚèÐdæ;âeç°äªÏnÚ��mæ�Ù�â/Å·â¯á{ç�Ý«ß`Ù/ÚÒÅNÓ×ÇXÛÅNé`Ó×ßQÙ;ÏQÇ���Ó§â/ÓÕÖ � çeÑ ÅNÙ�ÅNÅNÚ�æ/Ù;â/ÅwÑ¥Þ/Ñdß��èÅ�à�Ð�¬Ë^ã�����Û^ã%Ý������`È����������eê��Êå�Ó×ÚªÞ�ÏQÞ\Å�ÑÊäÊÏQÚ¢Þ/ÑdÅ�ÚÒÅNÙ{ÐdÅ·â�á{ç}Ðdå/Å@Ïnæ/Ðdå�ßnÑdÚÊÓ×Ù8Ð äÊßhÓ§ÙeÆeÓÕÐdÅ·â�Ð�ÏQÇ×ØeÚÏ�ТÐdå�Å@Î�ÅNÅwÐdÓ§Ù/é��^ã«Ý � ˬÛ�� �`ý®Ó×Ù � ßnÑÒÐdß��LÑdßQÎ��`þ�Ðdå8Ðdß ��!·Ðdå!ÌbÅNÞbÐdÅNήá\ÅwÑ·Í"�#���QýbêË­Ç×ÚÒß�ÏQÞ/Þ\Å·ÏnÑdÅ·â�ÏQÚ­ã%$@Ì/ãSãSÜ&�'�«ÖµÜðÛ­Ü(�°Û­ÅNÞ\ßnÑÒТÛ)�*�nË �)+ ���Qý,��-bê. ãpÎ�ÏQÓ×Ç0/�â/ÏNç�âbÅ�1^ÅNÙ/ÚÒÅNÅNÓ×å{зê ��Ñ·ê ã2$qÌ/ãSãpÜ3�'�«ÖµÜ Û¬Ü3�^Í4�6Ñdæ�Å�ÝÊÏnÎ�Ó§à�å�Å�ǦͥÈ5�6�,! �7�tßQæ�Ç×ß`æ/ÚÒÅÝÊã2�qã28XÍ�ÿ/Ñ�ÏQÙ/àNÅ`ê9 ãpÎ�ÏQÓ×Ç0/Sâ/æ5:;1^àNÅ�Ñ<�mÏQàNÚNê �LÑ·ê«Ë¬Ç×ÚÒß�Ï�Ь˪ÐdǧÏnÚ^Ý«Å�ÙeÐÒÑdÅQÍ�Û¬Ë^ÄpÍ + ÔbßQÙ + 8=������>?8XÍ/ãpÙ�é`ǧÏnÙ;â-ê

Page 2: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

@BADCDEGFHC�E�I

JLK�MON�PRQ2S�T)U5N�V&Q;M J

WXK�Y[ZG\]U N^Q;_`N�a�bdc`beYfQ;P�gihjV&bkP,\]P,U,aOglQ;_ � K �«� m PRQ2U5ben�n�Q;PRn^Q;Mm bkPR_3Q;PRYf\]M�U5b W

o � a)b �p¬�F��� Q;YfZ�T)N�\"N�VqQrM)\tsvujbkPRM)besqn o� T � UhO`��IL£baFse�ªW¥�-W/�dv � � H�H��¦s/uxoqc�f � z¢u�s\K�OQ���wsbuN�=wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw �� TÕ�yxh�wO}se� � � H H I�aJUXOQ�wI�£/a$ILa$£�vwM$O z}OQuwa$OQP fk{®o=z|w4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw ~� T � zªWeuNWePLP�OQP;}ªOQu��wILsba-�@sb�SvwM-O�²^³%|Xf~w4w4wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw �Q�

� � QrsqT)N�V&Q;M7Q;_=�%T�sqs p VqM�be\"P � g2n�N�beYfn Je��-T � cÒa�vwu�s;[$g-K·v�I�s/a�wHw4w�w4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw � ��-TÕ�yxh�wO}se�ªzªWeuNWePLP�OQPt²@³S|®f�wHw4wHw4wHw4w4wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw � ��-T � ²^P�s\KN¤bO`[ � ��¤/s{©'�Òf\KNM-a-We�tOnPBH±s\[\I��-OQ[ � M$s/P�O`��¤;Y��VWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a�w�w4wHw � �

�-T � T � l@M$O � �w¤bs{©'�df\KNM$aVWe�tOnPBH±s\[\I��VOQ[ � M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y��-W/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsbaST w � ��-T � TÕ� �xg$¡¥OQuwImKnWbP � �\rVOQuwIL¡¥Ona�v��QT wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw � �

�X��n�b�Qr_ p bk�;bes o ��p­�±� VqM`N�a�b���V�PRbeU N � Q;s&T%N�VqQrM`Qr_ � Z�\"PRn�b p VqM�be\"P� g2n�N�beYfn J"�

� � QrsqT)N�V&Q;M[Qr_ m \"P,N�V&\]sqsqg � bkZG\"PR\"��s&b p VqM�be\"P � g2n�N�beYfn ��n�V&M)����s&bkY�bkMON����gO����sqbeYfbeMON m PRbeU5QrM)S�V�N�VqQrM)bkPRn W;��$T � cÒa�vwu�s;[$g-K·v�I�s/a�wHw4w�w4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw � ��$TÕ� � PLOn¡¥Ona�v��ð�;Yk� � P�OQ¡¥Ona�v^z­uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$OnuN��w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw � ��$T � z¢u�Onr$u�s\K�O`�w�wI�a-£�se�Gxxa-W/�w�wOn¡8�$PLOQ[F³pILa$OQWbuhf;Y\�dv�On¡���wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw �b�

�$T � T � |x¡�WePL£/Wb¡�W{vwILsba±|xPL£bs/uwI�vwM-¡FT�w4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw � ��$T � �xg$¡¥OQuwImKnWbP � �\rVOQuwIL¡¥Ona�v���wHw4wHw4w4wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw � �

�$T �-T � xh�wO�se�ªf;r-WeuN�wO�f;vwsbuNWe£/ObT�w4w4wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw � �  � a)b � ZG\"PRn�b �p¬�F� W  �;T � UhO��-a$I�vwILsba±se�ªf;r-Wbu��wO�²^³%|Xf¡w4wHw4w4wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw �/��;TÕ�yxh�wO}I�a±cèvwOQu�WevwIL�bO�H±OnvwM$s\[$�HwHw4wHw4w4wHw4w�w4wHw4w4wHw4wHw4wHw4w4w�w4wHw �$�

¢ � QrM�U5sqT�n�VqQrM o%J

I

Page 3: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

£ ¤ CDEG¥¦A�§�¨�©?E�ª�ADC

« a$Oqse�tvwM$OxKnsb¡¥¡¥sba¥r$u�sb�$PLOn¡��«�¦s/u­Wer$r-P�ImKnWevwILsba¥�wKnI�OQa/v�IL��v��¢IL�Êv�s�O��\r$PLsbI�v­Wb�ÊOn �KnI�OQa�vwPLYWb��rts/����IL�$PLO"vwM$O�M-Wbu�[$©^WbuwO)se�°M$IL£bM"�èrVOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O�K�s/¡¥r$g\vwOQu��­¬µOnI�vwM$OQu>�wOnu�ILWbPJsbur-WeuNWePLP�OQP¯®ª©qI§v�M$sbg\v­vwsevNWePLP�Y�u�On©qu�I§v�I�a$£�sbu¢u�OQ[\O`��IL£ba-I�a$£�On�\IL��vwILa$£�Kns;[$OQ�­Wba-[!WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡��nT��O*�tOnPLI�OQ�bO�vwMVW{v±vwM$O¯WZ�{WbI�PmWe�$ILPLI§vdY�sb�8rtsbuwv�We�-P�O°Wea-[�O� !KnI�OQa/v��wOnu�ImWeP�Wea-[�r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnPa�g-¡�OQuwImKnWbPSPLI��-u�WbuwILOQ�@v�M-W{v}KnWbaJ�VO8g-��O`[ Wb�x�$g$ILPL[\ILa$£1�$P�s\KN¤\�xIm�XO��;vwu�On¡¥OnPLYFI�¡¥rtsbuwv�Wea�v�¦sbu¢�tsev�M¥�wIL¡�r-P�I��¦Y;I�a$£�Wbr$r$PLILKQW{v�I�s/a¥�wse�¨vd©@Weu�O@[\On�/OnPLsbr$¡¥Ona�v¢WeaV[8IL¡¥r$u�s{��ILa$£}u�OnPLILWb�$I�PLI�vdYbTl@M$O�WZ�{WeILPLWb�$ILP�I�vdY>sb�¥rts{©^Onuw�¦g$P8oqc�f � r-uws\K�O`�w�wsbuN�±Im� se��¡�WR°ds/u IL¡�rtsbuwv�Wba-K�O�I�a

vws\[$WZYk¹ �¬¡�Weu�¤bOnv¬��ILa-KnOhv�M$OnY�Weu�OhgV��O`[��VsbvwM1I�a1©¬s/uw¤\��v�W{v�I�s/a-�­Wba-[�ILa!v�M$OX¡¥s��dv^uwO`K�Ona�vr-WeuNWePLP�OQP�K�s/¡�r-g\vwOQu��QT l@M$OQY�Weu�O°g-�wg-WePLP�Y�¡¥sbu�O�On !K�ILOna�v vwMVWea"�bO`K·vws/uJr$u�s;KnOQ����s/u��sba���KnWbPLWbu�Wer$r-P�ImKnWevwILsba-�QT�l@M$O1¡¥WbI�a�uwO`Wb�wsba��¦sbu�vwM$OQI�u¥��gVKnK�O`�w��I�a�vwM$O1¡�Weu�¤bO�v�r$PmWbK�OIL�¯vwM$OQI�u��bOnu�Y £bs;s\[ Kns/��v¯vws&rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�O�uNW{vwILs-T l@M$OQY�Weu�O�g-��O`[�Wb��W � zvx�VsbvwMîILa�©¬s/uw¤\��v�WevwILsba-��Wba-[�I�a�¡¥s��dv�sb�}vwM$O�K�g$u�uwOQa�v1HJz­z¬��¬µU �^� |xPLr$M-W�I�a�v�M$O� ox|�{ l � U8´Xf\zB|Xo � ILa)vwM$O � H � Wba-["z � c � f$�\´ ±Xz zB| I�a)v�M$O ��« ��} �*²�*²X� HJz­³%|ho�´BWba-[�z « � � o�r$u�s\K�OQ���wsbuN�hILa�v�M$O¥cd²qH f\z � Wba-[�f$z¬�5®�T���O¥uwOQrVs/u�vI�a>l«We�-P�O � T � vwM$O�g$a$ILr$u�s;KnOQ����s/u!rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�O�se���wsb¡¥O�Kng$uwu�Ona�v1oxc�f � r$u�s;KnOQ����s/u��sba¯v�M$OJ[\sbg-�$P�OFr$u�OQKnIL�wI�s/a �`�b� �è�;Yk� �`�b� Wea-[ �Q�/�b� �è�;Yk� �`�b�b� ³Sc³�hzB| � z,�tOna-KNM$¡�Wbuw¤\�¬µUXsba$£�Weu�u�W-´ � ~b~��5®·T«��O�WePm��s�uwO`K�s/u�[�vwM$OQI�uqrtOQWb¤!rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�O/T

� sb¡¥r$g$vwOnu ³Sc³�hzB| � z ³Sc³�hzB| � z zÊOQWb¤�`�b�k´\�Q�/� �Q�/�b�e´;�Q�/�b� rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO

U �^�~µ � �/��� y �/�b� � � � � �/� � �/�cd²qH z « � � oh�R�è~/~ � � � � � � � � µ �±hz�~ �b�/� yb� �b� � � �Q� � � �/�f$�®c@z « � � o � M-WePLPLOna$£/O �Q� � �e� � �b�/�

l%Wb�$P�O � T �5¶ zÊOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO�I�a�HJ�«P�s/r-�hsb�­oqc�f � r$u�s\K�O`�w�wsbuN�qsba vwM$O�[\sbg$�-P�O8r$uwO`K�Im��ILsba³pc³�hzB| � z&�VOQa-KNM$¡�Weu�¤\���OX�$uwILO�ºVY�Knsba-�wIL[$Onu¢v�M$OhIL¡¥r-WbK�v^sb�kvwM$O®¡¥On¡¥sbu�Y8M-I�OQu�Wbu�KNM;Y�s/a¥vwM$OXrVOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O

se�hoqc�f � Wbu�KNM-I§v�OQK·v�g$u�OQ��ILa�f;O`K·v�I�s/a��\T�cÒa�f;OQK�vwILsba � ´Ê©¬OF��M$s{©¸M$s{©¸rtsbuwv�Wb�$P�OFWea-[O� !K�ILOna�v��wOnu�ImWeP¬Wba-[*r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnP­�bOnuN�wI�s/a-��sb�^v�M$O±³pOn�/OnP � ²@³S|Xf�KnWba*�VOF[\OQ�wI�£/a$OQ[*�¦sbuoqc�f � �è�-Wb�wOQ[!Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OnuN�^g-��ILa$£¥K�s\[\OXvwg$a-I�a$£8vwO`KNM$a$I¯·�g$OQ�@�wg-KNM�Wb�^�$PLs\KN¤;I�a$£V´�Knsbr;Y;I�a-£-´Wea-[1P�s;s/rFg-a$uws/P�PLILa$£-TÊcÒaJf;OQK�vwILsba±�-´\©^O}£bIL�bO�WeaFO��$We¡¥r$PLO}se�ªW��$P�s\KN¤/OQ[��µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/aWePL£bsbu�I�vwM$¡ sb�¢��rtOQKnILWbPpI�a�v�Onu�OQ��vq�¦sbuxs/r\vwIL¡¥I�¶`W{vwILsbaJWbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡��nT­l@M-IL�h�$P�s\KN¤1�bOnuN�wI�s/a�se�vwM$OX¡�s\[\I��-O`[ � M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y��µW/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsba�sb� � �w¤bs{©�Wea-[�f$KNM$a-We�tOnPtIm�­[\O`��IL£ba$O`[¥vws�¡¥Wb¤bOI�a�vwOQa-�wI��/O�g-�wO8sb�¢vwM-O�³SOn�bOQP � ²@³S|Xf I�a�vwM$O¥��We¡¥O8©@WZY±Wb�XsevwM-Onu®�$P�s\KN¤ WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡��nTcÒa f;OQK�vwILsba � ´�©^O�ILa-[\ImKnWevwO�M-s{©4²^³%|Xf)�¦s/u �¦g$PLP¥¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ��KnWba �VO6g-�wOQ[�©qI�vwM-I�aK�s\[\OQ�X�¦s/uhv�M$O�[\I�u�OQK�v}�wsbPLg\v�I�s/a�se�^��r-Wbu��wO�PLI�a-OQWeu}O�·/gVW{vwILsbaV�nT}cÒa*f;OQK�vwILsba��-´k©¬O¥��M-s{©M$s{© WeaîOn �KnI�OQa�v1r$u�OQKnsba-[\I�vwILsba-OQ[îKnsbaR°dg$£�W{v�O £buNWb[\ILOna�v1WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡ �¦sbu±��Y;¡¥¡¥O�vwu�ImKe´r-WeuwvwImWePLP�Y!�wOnrVWeuNWe�$PLOb´�g$a-W/�w�wOn¡8�$P�O`[!PLI�a-OQWeuq�wY\�dv�On¡��@KnWea1�VO�[\O`��IL£ba-OQ[�v�s8¡�Wb¤bO®g-��O®se�vwM$OFr$u�On�;I�s/g-�wP�Y°[\OQ��K�u�IL�VO`[¯K�s/¡�r-g\v�WevwILsba-WbP¬¤/Onu�a$OnPm�nT���O1g-�wO � P�OQ¡¥Ona�v��è�;Y¸� � PLOn¡¥OQa/v

Page 4: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

r$uwO`K�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu��@v�s!O��\r$PLsbI�vqvwM-O8��vwu�g-K·v�g$uwO�sb�ÊvwM$O8r$uws/�$PLOn¡��nT^��O8[\OQ¡�s/a-��vwuNW{vwO�M-s{©W�a;g$¡¥Onu�ImKnWeP@r$u�Onr-uws\K�O`�w�wILa$£���vwOnr�KnWba�[\uNWe¡�WevwImKnWePLPLY�IL¡¥r$u�s{�bO��tsev�M�v�M$O±a;g$¡¥Onu�ILKQWeP�VOQM-WZ�;I�s/g$upWea-[®v�M$O¢rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO«sb�/v�M$O¢r$u�OQKnsba-[$I§v�I�s/a$OnuN�nTS��O¢[\O`�wKnuwIL�tOb´`I�a�f;O`K·v�I�s/a8�;´Wea°O��;vwOQa-�wI�s/a�sb�¬v�M$O!²@³S|Xf��¦s/u�M-Wea-[$P�ILa$£ �wr-WeuN��O�¡�W{v�uwI���sbrtOnuNW{v�I�s/a-��WeaV[�ILa-[\ImKnWevwOI§vN�ªg-�wOqI�a�vwM-OqI§v�OnuNW{vwIL�bOq�wsbPLg\vwILsba¥sb�k�wr-WeuN�wO¬O�·/gVW{vwILsbaV�nT«��Oqr-uwO`��OQa/v­�wsb¡¥OqK�s/a-K�PLg-[\ILa$£uwOQ¡¥Wbuw¤\�^ILaJf\OQK·v�I�s/a µ T

¹ ¤)ºl»�¼ ©?ELA�½¾E*¿jF À F º A�¥vÁ Âê�F�¥ ¼ ¥?©v¿�Á A�½ÅÄ ¤*Æ @Ç ¥vAÈ©�F�IGIGA�¥vI^ADC Ç F�¥v½¸A�¥ ºl¼ C�©�F

l@M$O�We�-I�PLI§vdY1se�ÊvwM-O�¡¥On¡¥sbu�Y!v�s!��g-r$r$PLYF[$Wev�W¥v�s¥vwM$O8r$u�s;KnOQ����s/u��@WevXW���g$ �KnI�OQa�vhu�WevwOIL�1K�u�g-K�ImWePqs/a�¡�s��dv!¡¥s\[\OQuwa�K�s/¡¥r$g\vwOQu��QT"l@M$IL�!a$OQKnOQ����I�v�WevwOQ��W*K�sb¡¥r$PLO��6¡¥On¡¥sbu�Ysbu�£/Wea-I�¶`W{vwILsbaS´V©qM$OQuwO8vwM-O�¡¥OQ¡�s/uwYJIm�}g-�wg-WePLPLY Weu�u�Wba$£bO`[±I�a°W�M-I�OQu�Wbu�KNM$ImKnWbP%¡�Wba$a$Onu`Tl@M$O}¡�ILa$IL¡¥I�¶`W{vwILsba1se�Ê[$W{vNW�v�u�Wba-�d�¦OQu��¬�tO�vd©^OnOna1vwM-O®PLOn�/OnPm�­sb�Sv�M$O}¡�OQ¡¥sbu�Y�M-I�OQu�Wbu�KNM;YIL�¢W}¤/OnY8IL����g-O@�¦sbu¢rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnOH¬ð�}WePLP�IL�{Weap´;RbWbP��;Y�Wea-[�H±OQI�OQuQ´ � ~ µ �;´b�}WbP�PLI��{Wbap´�R/WePL�;Yb´H±OnILOnuxWba-[Jf\We¡¥OnMS´ � ~ µ¸µ ®�TH±s/��v«sb�-v�M$Oqoqc�f � �è�-Wb�wOQ[8WeuNKNM$I§v�OQK�vwg$u�OQ�«g-�wO^W®¡¥sbu�O@K�sb¡¥r$PLO���¡¥OQ¡�s/uwY�M-I�OQu�Wbu�KNM;Y

vwM-Wba1Im�@g-�wg-WePLP�Y!vwM$O�KnW/��OX�¦sbu@�/OQK·v�sbu@r$u�s\K�OQ���wI�a$£�g$a$I�v��QT¢l@M$Im�@a$sbu�¡�WePLP�Y�ILa;�bs/P��/OQ�¬sba$Osbu8�wOn�/OnuNWeP¢PLOn�/OnPm��sb�hKnW/KNM$ObT � WbPLKng$PmW{vwILsbaV��Weu�O!r$ILrtOnPLI�a$O`[¯s{�/Onu�ILa-[\OQrVOQa-[\Ona�v��wKQWePmWeusbrtOnuNW{vwILsbaV�8ILa-��vwO`Wb[¯sb�X�/OQK·v�sbu¥sbrtOnuNW{v�I�s/a-�QT�l@M$Im�¥IL�¥©qM;Y°vwM-O±[$OQ�wI�£/a�sb�XK�s\[\O`���¦sbuoqc�f � r$u�s\K�O`�w�wsbuN�p¡�WZY��wg$�-��v�Wea�v�ILWbP�PLY�[\I§ikOnu«�¦u�sb¡"v�M-W{vÊse�VKns\[\O­�¦s/uÊ�bOQK�vws/u%r$u�s\K�O`�w�wsbuN�nT|�M$IL£bMJu�Ong-�wO�se�«vwM$O�[$W{vNW¥P�s\KQW{vwO`[±W{vxv�M$O�M$IL£bM$O`�dvXP�OQ�bOnPm�qsb�%v�M$O�¡¥On¡¥s/uwY!M-I�OQu�Wbu�KNM;YIL��u�O�·�g$ILu�OQ[��¦sbu�On �KnI�OQa�v8K�s\[\O`�®�¦sbu�oqc�f � �ð�-W/��O`[°WeuNKNM$I§v�OQK�vwg$u�OQ�QT!l@M$O�g-�wO!se�^vwg-a$OQ[K�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-WeP¬¤bOQuwa$OQPL��vwM-Wev8KnWba*�VO1g-��O`[*Wb���$g$ILPL[\ILa$£ �-P�s\KN¤\��Im��Knuwg-KnILWbPª�¦sbu8�VsbvwM��IL¡¥r$P�I��¦Y;I�a-£!Wer$r$PLImKnW{v�I�s/aF�wse�¨vd©@Weu�O}[\On�/OnPLsbr$¡¥Ona�vxWeaV[1W/KNM$I�OQ�;I�a$£�M$IL£bM±rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�O/Tl@M$OXKQWbKNM$Ox¡¥OQ¡�s/uwY¥Im�­gV��O`[¥vws�¡�Wb�w¤�v�M$OX¡¥OQ¡�s/uwY¥PmW{v�Ona-KnYȬ¦vdY;r$ILKQWePLP�Y�v�M$OXKQWbKNM$O

PLWevwOnaVK�Y±IL�XWeu�sbg$aV[ � �d��K�PLs\KN¤;�h©qM$ILP�O8I§v®IL�Xse�¨v�Ona �`� vwIL¡¥OQ�XM$I�£/M$Onuh�¦sbuXvwM$O8¡¥On¡¥sbu�Y]®·Tl@M$O¬Kns;[$O­rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�OªIm�%M$I�£/M��wsxP�s/a$£hW/�BvwM-O^KQWbKNM$O¢M-I§v«u�WevwILsxIL�«K�PLs/�wOªv�s �Q�/�kÉ TSl@M$Im�©qI�PLPkM-Wer$rtOna1I§�%vwM$O}[$Wev�W8I�a;�bs/P��/OQ[¥ILa�v�M$O}KnWePmK�g-PLWevwILsba-�^KnWbaD�$vqI�a�vwM$O}KnW/KNM$Ohs/u@I§�pv�M$OKnWePmK�g-PLWevwILsba-�xKQWeaJ�tO�s/uw£�Wea$IL¶nO`[F�ws�v�M-W{v}[$W{vNW!KnWbaJ�VO�¤/Onr\v®I�a�KnWbKNM-O�Wea-[±On �KnI�OQa�vwPLYuwOQg-��O`[BT « a$O�se�¬vwM$O�¡¥s/��v}Knsb¡¥¡¥sba$PLYJg-�wOQ[Jv�OQKNM$a-IÊ·�g$O`�h�¦s/u®vwM-Wev}r-g$uwrts/�wO�IL�}KnWbP�PLOQ[�$P�s\KN¤;ILa$£1Wba-[ Wea�O��$We¡¥r$PLO�sb�¢vwM-IL�®Im�hu�OnrtsbuwvwO`[JI�a�vwM$O8�¦sbPLPLs{©qI�a$£F��O`K·v�I�s/apT�²¬PLs\KN¤;I�a$£Ona$M-Wba-K�O`�p�wr-W{v�ILWbPbWea-[Xv�On¡¥rVs/u�WbPbPLs\KnWePLI�vdYxI�a�Knsb¡¥r$g\vNW{v�I�s/a-�nT�xxa\�¦s/u�v�g$a-WevwOnPLYb´`�$PLs\KN¤�ILa$£IL�^a$sbvqWbP�©@WZY\�­�wg\ !K�ILOna�vq��ILa-K�OXvwM-O}KQWbKNM$O®¡¥IL���^u�WevwILs8KQWea��tO�[\uNWe¡�W{v�ILKQWePLP�Y¥ILa-K�u�OQW/��O`[I�aj·�g$I�vwO�Wba1g$a-r$uwO`[\ImK·v�Wb�$PLO�©^WZY!I��ÊvwM$O�¡¥OQ¡�s/uwY1WbKnKnOQ����O`�@g-�wO�W���vwu�Im[\O�£bu�OQWevwOnu^v�M-Wea� ¬ ��OQO�²^s;[$I�a±Wea-[Jf;OQ¶na$O`Ke´ � ~b~e�e®·Tf;sb¡¥Oq�dv�uwIm[\O`�«WbuwO^se�¨v�Ona�KnWbP�PLOQ[ÈË�Ì#Í0Î&ÍqË6ÏRÐZ�tOQKQWeg-�wO^vwM$OQY�£bOQa$OnuNW{v�O^W®�bOQuwY�M-I�£/M�KQWbKNM$O

¡�Im���qu�WevwILs�¬¦�¦sbuxOn�$We¡¥r$PLOb´\©qM$OQaFu�O��¦OQuwOQa-K�ILa$£�KnW/KNM$O}P�ILa$O`�@vwM-WevhWeu�OX¡�Wbr$rVO`[FI�a�vws¥v�M$O�wWb¡�Ohr$M;Y;�wImKnWePVP�s\KQW{vwILsba�sb�BvwM$O®KnW/KNM$O�®�TÊl@M-OQ�wOhK�u�I§v�ILKQWePt�dv�uwIm[\OQ�¬sb�;�;ILsbg-�wP�Y�[\OnrtOnaV[!sbavwM$O¥KnW/KNM$O�¡�Wea-Wb£bOQ¡�OQa�v®��vwuNW{vwOQ£bY/Th�$s/uXOn�\Wb¡¥r$P�O/´kI§�¢v�M$O8KQWbKNM$O8P�ILa$O8P�OQa$£ev�M�Im�hO�·/gVWePvws¥�¦sbg-uq©¬s/u�[$�@Wba-[!v�M$O�KnW/KNM$O}IL�xI�a$I�vwImWePLPLY!On¡¥r\vdY/´\vwM$O�On�\OQK�g$vwILsbaFse�«vwM$O�PLs;sbr

Ñ"Ò`Ó,Ô�Õ�ֳצֳØ

Page 5: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

Ù]Ú,Û]Ü Ô Ù]Ú,ÛtÜ~ÝßÞGà ÓeáÚ ×]ÑeÑ"Ò

©qI�PLPSKnWbg-�wO}W¥KQWbKNM$O}¡¥IL���@sbaFOQW/KNM1u�OQW/[�sb�«W;¬¦I0®·´-W/�w�wg$¡¥I�a-£8v�M-W{vhW;¬¦I0®^IL�@s/a$O}©¬s/u�[pT� sbr;Y;I�a$£J�-P�s\KN¤\��sb�q[-W{v�W�¬¨�¦sbu8O��$We¡¥r$PLO��wg$�$¡�W{v�uwImK�O`��®}vwM-Wev�Weu�O�M$O`WZ��ILPLY�u�Ong-�wOQ[

¡¥WZY�M$OQP�r°v�s�IL¡�r-uws{�/O�¡�OQ¡¥sbu�Y�WeaV[¯KnW/KNM$O!WbKQK�OQ���wOQ��¬µ��Y°WZ�bs/IL[$I�a$£ KnuwI�vwImKnWbP¬��vwu�IL[$OQ��¦sbu�O��$Wb¡�r-P�O,®·TD±xs{©^On�/Onu`´p��ILa-K�O��wg-KNM°K�sbr;Y;ILa$£1¡�WZY ILa-[\gVK�O�WFPLWbuw£/O8s{�/Onu�M$OQW/[B´BI§v�Im�a$sev}WePL©^WZY\�xW���ImWe�-P�O�vwOQKNM-a$IÊ·�g$O/Th��O�ILP�PLg-��vwuNW{v�O�vwM-O8g-�wO�sb�­K�s/r�Y;ILa$£!ILa sbg-uh�$PLs\KN¤bOQ[I�¡¥r$PLOn¡¥Ona�vNW{vwILsbaJsb�ªvwM$O8²^³%|Xf±ILa�f;O`K·vwILsba � Tq��O�a$sev�O�vwMVW{vh�$PLs\KN¤;I�a$£!Wba-[ Knsbr;Y;I�a$£Weu�O}WbPL�ws��bOnu�Y!g-�wO��¦g-PpI�aFPLI�¡¥I�vwILa$£¥vwM$O�Kns/��vxse�«¡�OQ¡¥sbu�Y!r-We£/I�a-£-T

â ã ¿jFåäçæ7è Æ @éA ºl» ¨�E ¼ E*ª�A�C ¼êìë F�¥?CjF ê I

|h�x©^O�M-WZ�/O�r$u�On�;I�s/g-�wP�YF[\IL��K�gV�w�wOQ[B´VI§vXIL�h�bOnu�Y�IL¡¥rVs/u�vNWea�vxv�s!g-�wO��dvNWea-[-WeuN[1�-g$I�Pm[\ILa$£�$P�s\KN¤\�«I�a�Wer$r-P�ImKnWevwILsba8Kns\[\OQ�QT%l@M$OQY�Weu�O¬On�;vwu�On¡¥OnPLY}g-��On�¦g$P;�¦sbuª�wI�¡¥r$PLI��¦Y�ILa$£XvwM$Oq[\O`��IL£base�¬Kns;[$OQ�X©qM$I�PLO�£/g-WeuNWea�v�OnOnILa$£!rtsbuwv�Wb�$ILP�I�vdYJWea-[JOn !K�ILOna-KnYbT�l@M$O��-g$I�Pm[\ILa$£F�$P�s\KN¤\�h�¦sbu¡�g-KNMFse�Êsbg$uq©^sbu�¤k´;�VsbvwM±I�aFv�M$O���s/P�g$vwILsbaFse�ª��r-Wbu��wO}Wb�@©^OnPLPpWb�^�¦g$PLPS�wY;��vwOQ¡��n´-Wba-[1I�a¡�s/uwO}K�s/¡¥r$P�ImKnWevwO`[1WbuwO`Wb�¬se�«��K�ILOna�v�I��VK}Knsb¡¥r$g\vNW{vwILsbaS´$Weu�OXv�M$O�²@Wb�wILK®³pILa$OQWbuq|xPL£bOn�-u�Wf;g$�$r$u�sb£/u�Wb¡��ª¤;a$s{©qa�Wb�ªv�M$OX²@³%|XfkT;�$s/u¢uwO`Wb�wsba-�¢se�BO� !K�ILOnaVK�Yb´;©^OhWeu�OqILa/v�Onu�OQ��vwO`[¥I�avwM$O^M$IL£bM$OQu%PLOn�/OnP;²^³%|Xfk´ZILa�r-Wbu�v�ILKng$PLWbuSv�M$O@³pOn�/OnP � ²@³S|®fD¬µUXsba-£/Weu�uNW$´ZUhg � uws/¶b´{Uhg$iWea-[ì±hWb¡¥¡¥WbuwPLILa$£-´ � ~b~ � ®�vwM-Wev!I�aVK�PLg-[\OJ¤bOQuwa-OnPm�8PLIL¤bO±vwM-OJ¡¥Wevwu�I§�e�è¡�W{vwu�I��¯¡�g$P�vwILr$PLYuws/g\vwILa$O � � H H°TÊcÒa-[$OnOQ[p´¢I�a�U®WZY;[^]Ob´¢UXg\i>WeaV[�zÊO�v�I§v�O�vj¬ � ~b~e�OÏ�®�Wea-[¡zjíWe£/��vwu,îsb¡±´³pILa$£6Wba-[>³Ss/Wba�¬ � ~b~ � ®·´hI§vJIm�F�wM$s{©qa�M$s{©�WePLP®vwM$O*³pOQ�bOQP � ²@³S|®f�u�sbg\v�I�a$O`�±KnWea�VO�[$OQ�wI�£/a$OQ[��¦sbu�M$I�£/M°rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�O�g-�wI�a-£±vwM$O � � H H ¤bOQuwa$OQP T1��O1K�sbaV��Im[\Onu}v�M$OrVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�OXWba-[¥v�M$OXIL¡¥r$PLOn¡¥Ona�v�WevwILsba1se� � � H�H M$OQuwO®Wea-[!�wM$s{©�´;ILaFf;O`K·vwILsba � TÕ�\´M$s{©�I§v}KnWba �VO�g-�wOQ[±v�s1[\O`��IL£ba±v�M$O�sevwM-Onu}³pOn�/OnP � ²@³S|®f±¤bOQuwa$OQPL�hsba s/a$O�On�$We¡¥r$PLO ¶vwM$O��wY�¡¥¡¥O�v�uwImKXu�Wba$¤k�ð¤¥g$rk[$W{v�O fk{®o�z¥T\l@M$O}OnitO`K·v@se�%gV��ILa$£¥²^³%|Xf!I�a1vwM$O��wsbPLg\vwILsbase�-PLI�a-OQWeu«O�·�g-WevwILsba-�Q´��-uN�dvÊ©qM$Ona�vwM$O@K�s;On �KnI�OQa�v«¡�W{v�uwI���IL�%�¦g$PLPð´{vwM$OQa8©qM-Ona�I�vÊIL�Ê�wr-WeuN��O©qI�PLPp�tO�[\IL��K�gV�w�wOQ[1uwO`��rtOQK�vwIL�bOQP�Y!ILa f;OQK�vwILsba-�@��Wba-[ � T|¸vwg$a-OQ[°¡�Wea;g\�µW/K·vwg-uwOQu��Ò��g-r$r$PLI�O`[��/OnuN��ILsba�se�@v�M$O�²@³S|®f�IL��vws\[$WZY�WZ�{WbI�PmWe�$PLO�sba

¡�s��dvJM$IL£bM]�ðrtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO�Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OnuN�JWea-[B´�ILa"KnWb�wOQ�±©qM-Ona"I§vJIm�Ja$sbv±r-uws{�;Im[\OQ[B´�W�dvNWea-[$Wbu�[��$s/u�v�u�Wba�IL¡�r-P�OQ¡�OQa�v�W{v�I�s/a�Im��WZ�{WeILPLWb�$PLO1s/a�v�M$O M)bkN�sqV�� OQP�O`K·vwu�sba-ILKF��OQuw�/Onu¬µUXsba$£�Weu�u�W�Wea-[±�®u�s/����O/´ � ~ µ � ®·T

ï'ð�ñ òôó%õeö³÷vøçù*ú�û�ü�û�õ¸ý þôÿ���� ú6ù��������� ��]ù��Oó%õeõkù��tõ��O8M-WZ�bO�[$On�bOQP�s/rVO`[JW��wO�v®se�­³pOQ�bOQP � ²@³S|®fJK�s/¡¥r$g\v�WevwILsba-WbPS¤/Onu�a$OnPm�xILa��wI�a$£/P�O�Wea-[[\sbg$�-P�O1r$uwO`K�Im��ILsba��¦s/u8On �KnI�OQa�v�I�¡¥r$PLOn¡¥OQa/vNW{v�I�s/a¯sba�oxc�f � r$u�s;KnOQ����s/u��D¬ UXWZY\[^]O�Wea-[Uhg\iÊ´ � ~/~b�k®·T l@M$Im�±�bOQu��wILsba>sb��vwM-O¯³pOn�/OnP � ²@³S|Xf>Im�JWea>OQ�bs/P�g\v�I�s/a>sb��vwM-O*sba$O[\OQ��K�u�I��tOQ[î��YîU®WZY\[^]O OnvFWbP T4¬ � ~b~b�rÏ�®¥�¦sbuJH±c�HJU �bO`K·v�sbu�¡8g$P�vwILr$uws\KnOQ����s/u��QT&l@M$OQYuwOQrVs/u�v�sba¯On�;rtOnu�IL¡�OQa�v��8sba�W�u�Wba$£bO!sb�XK�s/¡¥r$g\vwOQu���¬µ|X³S³Scd|=�hl}´ ��« �=} �*² ´%cd²qHWea-[ � oh|�{H®¬Wea-[1[\On¡¥sbaV�dv�u�WevwOqv�M$OXOn !K�ILOna-KnY�sb�BvwM$OQI�u@Wer-r$uws�WbKNM�©qM$OQa$On�/Onu^W�vwg-a$OQ[�bOnuN�wI�s/a�se�«vwM-O�¡¥Wevwu�I§�e�è¡�W{vwu�I��!¡�g$P�vwILr$PLILKQW{vwILsbaFu�sbg\v�I�a$O � � H H IL�xWZ�{WbI�PmWe�$PLObT

Page 6: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

« g$u¢�-W/��ImKqIm[\OQW}�¦s/u­On �KnI�OQa�v¬IL¡�r-P�OQ¡�OQa�v�W{v�I�s/a!se�kv�M$OX²@³S|®f¥sba!oxc�f � r$u�s;KnOQ����s/u��IL�¢vws�On�;r-uwO`�w�¢WbP�P$vwM$O®³pOn�/OnP � ²^³%|Xf�¤/Onu�a$OnPm�ªILa¥vwOnu�¡��¢sb�B�wg$�$¤/Onu�a$OnPm�Êsba!�wg$�$¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ�vwM-Wev�ILa��/sbPL�bO"OnI�vwM-Onu � � H H sbrtOnuNW{v�I�s/a-��s/uîsbrtOnuNW{v�I�s/a-��ILa��/sbPL�;I�a$£¸v�uwImWea-£bg$PmWeu��g$�-¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�QTJ|h[$[\I�vwILsbaVWePLP�Y/´ÊWbP�P­vwM$OFKnWbPLKng$PLWevwILsba-��sba*�$PLs\KN¤;�8Weu�O�rVOQu��¦s/uw¡¥O`[°g-��ILa$£vwg$a$O`[>�-sbuwvwuNWeaîK�s\[\O`��©qI�vwM�P�s;s/r"�ðg-a$uws/P�PLILa$£-T � s/r;Y�ILa$£¯Im�1s;KQKnW/��ILsba-WbP�PLY6g-��O`[BT « �K�sbg-u��wOb´VvwM$O�u�OnPmW{vwIL�bO8O� !K�ILOnaVK�Y±se�¢v�M$Im�®Wbr$r$u�s/W/KNM±[$OnrtOna-[$�®s/a vwM-O�WZ�{WeILPmWe�$ILP�I�vdYFse�¬WM$I�£/M$PLY�vwg$a-OQ[ � � H�H�¤/Onu�a$OnPðTl@M$IL�¬Wer$r-uws�WbKNM�IL�­uwOQPLWevwIL�bOnPLY�ILa-[\OQrVOQa-[\OQa/v^se�kvwM-OhK�s/¡�r-g\vwOQu ¶ sba$PLY8vwM$Ox�-P�s\KN¤¥��IL¶nO

r-WeuNWe¡¥O�v�Onu`´ZM$Onu�O¬KQWePLP�O`[ �h²®´{WeaV[�ILa8�wsb¡¥O^KQWb�wOQ�SvwM$O^PLs�s/r"�èg$a$u�sbPLP�ILa$£X[$Onr\v�M8�wM$sbg$Pm[��tOvwg$a$O`[1W/KnKnsbuN[\I�a-£�vws8vwM-O}KNMVWeuNWbK·v�Onu�IL��vwImKn�¬se�SvwM$O®v�Wbuw£/O�v@¡�WbKNM$ILa$ObT��X²�IL�@[\OnvwOQuw¡¥ILa$OQ[��Y�v�M$O®�wIL¶nOhsb�pvwM-O®KQWbKNM$OhWba-[�v�M$OhPLs;sbr"�èg$a$u�sbPLPLI�a$£8[\Onr\v�M!�¦u�sb¡¸v�M$Oha;g$¡8�VOQu^sb�S�wKQWePmWeuuwOQ£bIm�dv�OnuN�nT��O®[\OQ��K�u�I��tOhs/a$PLY8v�M$Oh�-P�s\KN¤bO`[�IL¡�r-P�OQ¡�OQa�v�W{v�I�s/a!se� � � H H,ILa�vwM-IL�@�wg$�-�wOQK·v�I�s/apT

l@M$Oqsev�M$Onu¢¤/Onu�a$OnPm�ªWeu�Oq[\OQ�wIL£ba$O`[8ILa�vwM$OX�wWb¡�O@©@WZY�WeaV[8©^OxK�s/a-�wIL[\OQuQ´/Wb�¢Wba�On�$We¡¥r$PLOb´fk{®o�z ILaJf\OQK·v�I�s/a � T �$Tª�$g$uwvwM$OQuh[\Onv�WeILPm�qKnWeaF�tO}�¦sbg$a-[FILaJUXWZY\[^]O}WeaV[FUXg\i¡¬ � ~/~b�¸®�T� � H H rVOQu��¦s/uw¡��@s/a$O}se�«vwM$O�¡�W{v�uwI��e�ð¡�Wevwu�I§�!s/rVOQu�WevwILsba-�

����� s/r%¬ � ®^sbr%¬ � ®���� � ´©qM$Onu�O � Wba-[��"Weu�O1��KnWbPLWbu��Q´ � Wba-[ � WbuwO1uwO`K·v�Wba$£bg-PLWbu�¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�8sb�X[\IL¡¥Ona-�wI�s/a-�¡��ª¤1Wea-[F¤��ªap´\u�OQ�wrVO`K·vwIL�bOQP�Y/´ � Im�xW�¡���a±¡�W{v�uwI��B´$Wea-[Fs/r%¬ � ®^IL� � s/u � � T��O�K�sbaV��Im[\OnuhvwM$O¥KnW/��O8K�sbu�u�OQ�wrVs/a-[\ILa$£�vws1sbr O�·�g-WePSvws"!��xs�vwuNWea-�wrVs���O$#¥I�a��VsbvwM

KnWb�wOQ�qWba-[1�$P�s\KN¤�v�M$O�K�s/¡¥r$g\v�WevwILsba±Wb� ¶

%'&)(+* (,&�(-* _& _ * _ & _ * _�. �/� %10�(+* (20�(+* _0 _ * (20 _ * _3. %145(-* (245(-* _4 _ * (24 _ * _3. ��� %1&�(+* (,&)(+* _& _ * (,& _ * _�.� � H H KQWea¥vwM-Ona!s/���;ILsbg-�wPLY��tOhsbu�£/Wba$IL¶nOQ[�ILa�vwOQuw¡��­se�pW��wg-KnKnOQ����ILsba�sb�k¡�Wevwu�I§�e�

¡¥Wevwu�I§�1¡�g$P�vwILr$PLILKQW{vwILsbaV�qsba±��g-�$¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�qW/�^�¦sbPLP�s{©x� ¶� T & (+* (�6 � & (-* ( � � 0 (+* ( 4 (+* ( ¬ � � H H�®�\T & (+* (�6 & (-* ( � � 0 (+* _ 4 _ * ( ¬ � � H H�®� T &�(+* _ 6 � &�(-* _ � � 0�(+* (745(+* _ ¬ � � H H�®�-T &�(+* _ 6 &�(-* _ � � 0�(+* _ 4 _ * _ ¬ � � H H�®� T & _ * ( 6 � & _ * ( � � 0 _ * (745(+* ( ¬ � � H H�®�$T & _ * (�6 & _ * ( � � 0 _ * _ 4 _ * ( ¬ � � H H�®�;T & _ * _ 6 � & _ * _ � � 0 _ * ( 4 (+* _ ¬ � � H H�®µ T & _ * _ 6 & _ * _ � � 0 _ * _ 4 _ * _ ¬ � � H H�®

Page 7: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

l@M$O sbuN[\Onu�ILa$£ se� vwM$O`��O OQI�£/M/v Knsb¡¥r$g\vNW{v�I�s/a-WeP&��vwOQr-� Im��[\OnvwOnu�¡¥I�a-OQ[�;YK�sbaV��Im[\OnuNW{v�I�s/a�sb�¬v�M$O�O� !K�ILOna�v�u�Ong-�wO¥se�q[$W{vNW1M-OnPm[�ILa°KnWbKNM-ObT¥��O�MVWZ�bO�[\OQKnIL[$OQ[�vwsuwOQg-��O�vwM$O���g$�-¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�hse� � W/�x¡8g-KNM�Wb�hrVs��w�wIL�$P�O�Wea-[±©^O�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡,WePLP%s/rVOQu�WevwILsba-�I�a;�bs/P��;ILa$£¥W���g$�-¡¥Wevwu�I§�1se� � �VOn�¦sbu�O�¡�s{�;ILa$£�vws�Wea-sevwM-Onuqsba-O�¬µ�wOnO��«I�£/g$u�O � T � ®·T¢�-sbusbg$uÊ��IL¡¥r$PLO­O��$Wb¡�r-P�O/´`I�vÊ¡�O`Wea-�SvwMVW{v%©^O­rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡)vwM$O@KnWbPLKng$PmW{vwILsbaV�pILa�vwM$O^sbuN[\OQu ¶ f�v�Onr� ´«f;vwOnr � ´«f�v�Onr � ´Êf�vwOQr��;´Êf�vwOQr*�$´«f�v�Onr*�V´«f�v�Onr*�$´«Wea-[*f�v�Onr µ T!l@M-IL��Wbr$r$u�s/W/KNMIL����IL¡¥I�PmWeu�vws�vwM-Wev8g-�wOQ[*�;Y°Uhs/a$£/WbuwuNW$´ªHJWZY/OQ��Wba-[¯oxW/[\ILKQW{v�I¬[\Iq²^uws/¶ns/P�s[¬ � ~b~ �98 ®·TcÒa�r-u�W/K·vwImK�O/´%�h²&IL�}gV��g-WbP�PLY�KNM-s/�wOna��wsFvwM-Wev�WePLPªvwM-O!��g$�-¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�}sb� � ´ � ´SWba-[ �uwO�·/g-I�u�OQ[��¦sbu8OQW/KNM°�wg$�$¡8g$P�vwILr$P�ImKnWevwILsba[�-v�I�a¯vwM$O!PmWeu�£bO`�dv�s/a"�ÒKNM$I�r*KQWbKNM$O/T « a¯�wsb¡¥O¡¥W/KNM$ILa$OQ�Q´hWbKQK�O`�w�!vws�sbi;�ÒKNM$ILrîKnW/KNM$OQ��M-Wb�F��s�P�s{©,PmW{v�Ona-KnY�v�M-W{vF©¬O�KnWbaîI�¡¥r$u�s{�bOrVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�O®��Y�g-��ILa$£�W�PLWbuw£/Onu@�$PLs\KN¤!��IL¶nO/T¢l@M$IL�@Im�^vwu�g$O/´\�¦sbu@O��$Wb¡�r-P�O/´\sba1vwM$O�f$�®czÊs{©¬OQu � M-WbP�PLOna-£bObT!f;ILa-KnO¥WbP�P¢vwM$O!Knsb¡¥r$g\vNW{vwILsbaVWePʤbOQuwa$OQPL��KQWePLP � � H H*´kvwM$O��$PLs\KN¤��IL¶nO��h²�Im��WePL©@WZY;�®[\OnvwOnu�¡¥I�a-OQ[�W/�XvwM$O¥¡¥s/��v�Wer$r$u�sbr-uwImW{v�O��$PLs\KN¤ ��IL¶nO8�¦sbu � � H�H°´vwM-WevxIL�Q´]�h²>IL�@v�M$O�PmWeu�£bOQ��v@On�bOQa1ILa�vwOQ£bOnux�wg-KNM1vwM-Wev

� ¬;: 4 ® _=<?>A@CBED'&5F)G©qM$Onu�O <H>C@CB Im�­vwM$O®a;g$¡��tOnu^se�p�;Y�vwO`�¬Knsbu�uwO`��rtsba-[$I�a$£}v�M$O®r$uwO`K�Im��ILsba�gV��O`[�¬¦�8��Y�v�OQ�­�¦sbu��ILa$£bPLOxr$u�OQKnIL�wILsba!WeaV[ µ �;Y�vwO`�ª�¦sbu^[\sbg-�$P�OXr$u�OQK�Im�wI�s/a�I�a!c �¬�­� �¦s/uw¡�Wev6®¢Wba-[ &5F Im�¢v�M$OKnWbKNM-O���IL¶nO�ILa �;Y�vwOQ�QT^��O�KNM-s�s���O�Wba±On�bOQaJI�a�v�On£bOQu@vws��µW/K�ILP�I�v�WevwO�PLs;sbr"�èg$a$u�sbPLPLI�a$£VT¬�-sbuO��$We¡¥r$PLO}©qI§v�M±W¥�b�¸z}�;Y�vwOQ�@KQWbKNM$O/´]�h²îIm�q�wO�vqvws � ��gV��ILa$£��e�5�ð�$I�vxWeu�I§v�M$¡¥O�v�ILKbTzªWeuwvhse�ªv�M$O�[$sbg$�$PLO�r$uwO`K�Im��ILsba��$P�s\KN¤/OQ[ Kns;[$O�Im�®�wM$s{©qaJILa��«IL£bg$u�O � T � T®cèvN�h¡�WbI�a

�¦OQW{v�g$u�OQ�qWeu�O®vwM$O}�¦s/P�PLs{©qILa$£ ¶I l@M$O}¡8g$P§v�I�r-P�ImKnWevwILsba±se� � �;Y �°IL�xrVOQu��¦s/uw¡¥OQ[1�tO��¦sbu�O�WePLPpsev�M$OnuxKQWePmK�g$PmW{v�I�s/a-�QTI l@M$O���g-�$¡�W{vwu�I��Fsb� � Im�h¡8g$P§v�I�r-P�ILOQ[���Y � Wea-[JvwuNWea-�wrVs���O`[±I�a�v�s�Weu�u�WZY 0�0 vwsWZ�/sbIm[8a-sba"�èg$a$I�v@��vwu�Im[\OQ�¬�VO`KnWbg-��Ohse�%W/KnK�O`�w�­�;Y�u�s{©x�¢ILa�v�M$OXILa$a$OQuw¡¥s��dv^P�s;sbrV�¢se�v�M$O!KnWbPLKng$PLWevwILsba-�QT�l@M$O`��O!WbuwO¥s/uw£�Wea$IL¶nO`[�ILa*��g-KNM*W±©@WZYJvwMVW{v 0�0 IL��¤bOnr$v�I�aKQWbKNM$O}Wb�@PLsba$£�W/�@uwO�·/g-I�u�OQ[BT

��O�g-��O vd©¬s*v�g$a$O`[>�$s/u�v�u�WbaîK�s\[\O`��vws�rVOQu��¦s/uw¡ KnWbPLKng$PmW{vwILsbaV�!sbaî�wg$�$¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ�¬µ�wOnO8�«IL£bg$u�O � T �¸® ¶ U}� � H H ³%� ² ��Im�}W�vwg-a$OQ[�K�s\[\O��¦s/uXrtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥I�a-£�¡�W{v�uwI��e�ð¡�W{v�uwI��¡�g$P�vwILr$PLILKQW{vwILsba�sba���·�g-Weu�Oq¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�­se�pOQ�bOna�s/u�[$Onu$J�Wba-[!U}� � H HJ³�IL�^W}v�g$a$OQ[1K�s\[\OvwM-WevhI�aVK�PLg-[\OQ�XWb[$[$I§v�I�s/a-WePBv�OQ��v��hs{�bOnuxU}� � H�HJ³%� ² ��v�s�M-Wea-[$P�O�¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ�q©qI�vwMJs\[$[sbuN[\Onu`TÊcèvxIL�@s\KnKQWb�wI�s/a-WePLPLY!��PLI�£/M�vwPLY!P�O`�w�@On !K�ILOna�vqvwM-WbaFU}� � H�HJ³%� ² �\T

��O1M-WZ�bO!gV��O`[°vd©¬s��bOQu��wI�s/a-�}�¦s/u�WbP�P¬vwM$O1vwg-a$OQ[¯Kns\[\OQ� ¶ vwM$O±lqoqcd|XUhc � s/r\vwILsba�¦sbu�K�s/¡�r-g\vwOQu���©qM$OQuwO1vwu�ILW/[\ImK�s/rVOQu�WevwILsba-��Weu�O�OQI§v�M$Onu!�wg$r$rtsbuwvwO`[¯ILa�v�M$O1MVWeuN[\©^WbuwO¬¨�¦sbu°On�\Wb¡¥r$P�O�vwM-O�ºVs/W{v�I�a-£ �èrVs/I�a�v°¡�g$P�vwILr$PLY¸�ÒWeaV[e�èW/[$[ s/a&cd²qH oXf-y{� �b�b� ®Js/u�WbuwOO� !K�ILOna�vwPLY�Knsb¡¥r$ILP�O`[B´@Wea-[�vwM$O�� « lqoqcd|hUXc � sbr\v�I�s/a��¦s/u�sevwM-Onu!K�s/¡¥r$g\vwOQu��QT�l@M$Og-��O®se�Svwu�ILW/[\ILKXsbrtOnuNW{v�I�s/a-�^��M$s/g$Pm[!a$sbv@a-sbu�¡¥WbP�PLY�[\On£/u�W/[\Oxv�M$O}rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O®��OQ�bOnu�OnPLYsba�r$u�s\K�OQ���wsbuN�-v�M-W{vÊ[\sqa$sbv%��g-r$rVs/u�vSvwM$O`��O¢s/rVOQu�WevwILsba-�S��ILa-K�O­O� !K�ILOna�v%Kns;[$O¢£bOQa$OnuNW{v�I�s/aKnWea"v�u�Wba-���¦sbu�¡ v�M$On¡ILa/v�s>[\Y�Wb[\ImK*sbrtOnuNW{v�I�s/a-�QTd±xs{©^On�bOQuQ´�ILa O`Weu�P�Y)�bOQu��wI�s/a-�±se�f\zB|ho � K�sb¡¥r$ILPLOnuN�n´\©^O��wWZ©>vwM-WevqvwM$OQuwO�©@Wb�q�wsb¡¥O�v�I�¡¥O`�q��g-KNM±W�[\OQ£buNWb[$WevwILsbapTªl@M;g-�

Page 8: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

KK LAMON7PRQTSVU�WYX$ZA[AKOQK \ L^]E_C`Aa$bdc;`fegcVhO`CifjRk+a$l$`Cmn jpoOqsr�U�tvuwmn j"t+q \ U�tvuwxQg] \ u rykzU3hO`Cifjt+q QCj{mAa \ mO|A`o$q QAj{mCa \ m$|A``$}f~{` n j��AqsrzURtvuEmn j��Cq \ URtvu�xQg] \ u r�k�U�_C`Aa$bfKOQg] \ u�ryk�Cq QAj{mAa \ m$|A`�Aq QAj7mAa \ m$|C``$m n \ LKK LAMON7P�Q1S�Uy[C�{�$�f[AK{bfK+_"��WYX$ZA[AKOQ^cK n j��Cq�}pURtvu��duEmC_}C_�Uzx \ md]E���z}��"tvuEmC_�kn j��Cq \ U"tvuExduEm$_\ _pU3x \ m^]Ex�� \ �Rtvu�mC_�kn j \C\ U \ u \ � \ _"�"tn j�}C}yU�}duE}p�3}C_y��tbCbg]V}C}f�{}A��tvu \C\ � \ ��t$k+U$b$}C�ClCbfK{b^] \$\ u�}C}9k`Cm nCn j`Cm nCn jn j3�$qsr�U�tvuEm^uwmC_r7_�Uzx \ md]�my�pr3�"tvuEmC_�kKK��YX$NC�AMON7PpPf�Y�OZf�7�f�C�C�$[OZf�OM{��M7�"�7�CW7P9[OZCNf�$�OXY�K \ LT]C];xfj n ] \ _du�ofk?c�`fegc�q�kcVb$m n cO]Vxfj n ]�r7_�u�ofk?c�`�egc�q�kAkyaOlC`CmQ$bO}C} nY� `$xCxC}foO�Ao ] \ _du�r7_duV}C_^u�bCb^uVm$_duV_d]V}^u=rYkuV} n _^u¡Qg] \ u¢rAk?uV} n Q�k`C}f~{` Q$bO}C} nY� `$xCxC}d] \ _du¢r7_du;}C_du�bCbguVmC_duV_^]V}du¢rYkvu�} n _du�Qg] \ u¢rfkuV} n Q�k`Cm n \ L�$q QAj7mAa \ m$|C`�Cq QAj{mAa \ m$|A`�Cq QCj{mAa \ mO|A`�«IL£bg$u�O � T �¸¶ zªWeuwv^sb�Sv�M$O��$PLs;KN¤/OQ[FK�s\[\O®�¦sbuXU®� � H H

Page 9: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

KK Q1S�Uy[C�{�$�f[AK{bfK+_"��Q^cK n j��Cqsr�U�tvuEm^u£on j��Cq \ URt9uwxdu�oa9t$t�U�Qg] \ u¢rYkaYoft�U�Qg] \ ��tvu¢rAka9t+o�U�Qg] \ u¢rO��tOkaYo$o�U�Qg] \ ��tvu¢r{��t$kn j��$q�}pU�tvuE�_vt�U3_^]V}du¢rYk_fo3U3_^]V}du¢rO��t$kb9t�U�bg]V}du \ kbYo3U�bg]V}du \ ��t$ka9tCt�U�a9tCt��z_vt{K{b9taYo�t�U�aYo�t��z_vt{K{bYoa9t7o�U�a9t7o��z_foAK{b9taYoCo�U�aYoCo��z_foAK{bYo�$q QAj7mAa \ m$|C`Qg] \ u¢rYk�U�a9tCtQg] \ ��tvu¢rAk�U3aYo�tQg] \ u¢rO��tOk�U3a9t7oQg] \ ��tvu¢r{��t$k�U�aYo$o�Cq QAj{mAa \ m$|A`�Cq QAj7mAa \ m$|C`�«IL£bg$u�O � TÕ� ¶ zªWeuwv^sb�Sv�M$O}vwg$a-OQ[JK�s\[\O®�¦s/uxU®� � H HJ³%� ² ��¬µlqoxcd|hUXc � s/r\vwILsbar®

Page 10: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

DGEMM std

DGEMM tuned

DGEMM lib.

Peak perf.

DEC3000 DEC8400 HP 715 IBM 750 SGI POW SUN2050 CS2−HA 0

100

200

300

400

500

600

Computers

MF

lops

�%IL£bg-uwO � T �]¶ |h�bOQu�Wb£bO rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO se�)U®� � H H �¦u�sb¡ oqc�f � ²@³S|Xf ¬7!��xsvwuNWea-�wrVs���O$#$´�!��hs�vwuNWea-�wrVs���O$#¸®�T

SGEMM std

SGEMM tuned

SGEMM lib.

Peak perf.

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 80

100

200

300

400

500

600

Computers

MF

lops

�%IL£bg-uwO � T � ¶ |x�bOQu�Wb£bOÊrtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�OÊsb�$f-� � H H �¦u�sb¡)oqc�f � ²@³S|Xf�¬{!��hs@vwuNWea-�wrVs���O$#$´!��xs�v�u�Wba-��rts/�wOO#k®·Tµ

Page 11: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

©¬Oxr-uwOn�¦Onu¬vws�sbitOQu­�tsevwM1sbr\v�I�s/a-�QT«zªWbu�v¢sb�BvwM$Ohvwg$a$O`[�Kns;[$Oq�¦sbu^U®� � H HJ³%� ² ��g-��ILa$£vwM$O�lqoqcd|XUhc � sbr$vwILsba-�@Im�x�wM$s{©qa1ILaJ�«I�£/g$uwO � T �$TcÒa �%IL£bg-uwO`� � T � WeaV[ � T �-´�©^O¯ILP�PLg-��vwuNW{vwO�uwO`��rtOQK�vwIL�bOnPLYîv�M$O�[$sbg$�$PLO�Wba-[���ILa$£/P�O

r$uwO`K�Im��ILsba WZ�/OnuNWe£/O�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO¯se��v�M$O��dvNWea-[$Wbu�[�Wba-["v�M$O��$PLs\KN¤bO`["�bOnuN�wI�s/a-�Jse�� � H H ¬µWZ�bOQu�Wb£bO`[}s{�bOnu«��·�g-WbuwO¬¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�%se�VsbuN[\Onu � �$´Z�b�-´e~/�$´{Wea-[ � � µ ©qM$OQa � Wea-[� Weu�O}a$sevxv�u�Wba-�wrVs���O`[t®·Tª��O�WePm�ws�ILa-KnP�g-[$O�vwM$O�rtOQWb¤�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO®sb�%v�M$O�Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OnuWea-[�v�M$OxrtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�Oqsb�kvwM$Ox¡�Wba�g$�µWbK·v�g$u�Onu��è�wg$r$r$PLILOQ[��bOQu��wI�s/a8©qM-Ona!WZ�{WeILPLWb�$PLO@vws�g-�QTl@M$IL�ªvwg$a$O`[���g-�-��Onvªse�tvwM$Oh²@³%|Xf�¤�KnWePLPLOQ[8vwM$Oxoxc�f � ²@³%|Xf�¤�IL�¢r$g$�$PLILKQWePLP�Y�WZ�{WeILPLWb�$P�O��ImW¥Wea$s/a;Y�¡¥s/g-�¬�¨vwr W{v@�¨v�rpT OQa-�wOnOnILM�vQT �¦uxILaFr-g$�tyZa;g$¡¥OQuwI¯·�g$OZye²^³%|Xf-yeoqc�f � Tl@M$IL�F�$PLs\KN¤bO`[îIL¡�r-P�OQ¡�OQa�v�W{v�I�s/a�sb� � � H�H £/I��/OQ�FW�£�WeILa>ILa�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO�se�

£bu�OQW{v�OnuÊv�M-Wea!W}�µW/K·v�sbu¢sb�tvd©^s�K�s/¡¥r-Weu�OQ[�©qI�vwM�v�M$Oh��v�WeaV[$WeuN[¥�$sbuwvwuNWea�Kns;[$OQ[¥�bOQu��wILsbapT�$g$uwvwM$OQuw¡¥s/uwO/´�©¬O�M-WZ�bO*s/�-�wOnu��bOQ[)v�M-W{v�vwM$O�rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O¯Im��On�bOQa��VOnv�v�Onu°I§��v�M$O¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�¯WbuwOîWbP�u�OQW/[\Y&M-OnPm[¸I�a�v�M$O>KQWbKNM$O`¬µ©qM$ILKNM�©@Wb�¯a$sev¯v�M$O�KQWb�wO�I�a¸v�M$OQ�wOO��\rVOQuwIL¡¥Ona�v��6®·T

ï'ðV¥ ¦ õkóßùvú þôÿ���� ö�ø^òôó%õeö³÷vø�ö�ø=÷`ý§�ó'¨~ó��tø�ó�© «ª¬��¨��O8a$s{©�K�sbaV��Im[\OnuhvwM$O8g-�wO�se� � � H H ILa�[\O`��IL£ba$ILa$£!sbvwM$OQuh¤/Onu�a$OnPm�hW/�xILa�UXWZY\[^]O�O�vWePðT2¬ � ~/~e�OÏ�®·TÊ��O�g-�wO}vwM$O�¤/Onu�a$OnP fk{}o�z v�s�I�PLPLg-�dv�u�WevwO®vwM-IL�QT

fe{®o�z rVOQu��¦s/uw¡��@s/a$O}se�«vwM$O��wY;¡�¡¥Onvwu�ILK®uNWea$¤k�è¤�sbrtOnuNW{vwILsbaV� ¶

�£­®�«��� Nv¯ � � ´-sbu �£­®�%� N � ¯ � �©qM$Onu�O � Wea-[®�*Weu�O®��KnWbPLWbu��Q´ � IL�qWba1aR��aJ�wY;¡�¡¥Onvwu�ILK®¡�W{v�uwI���¬¦s/a$P�Y!vwM$O�g$r-rVOQuqsbuP�s{©^Onuhvwu�ILWba$£bg$PmWeuXr-Weuwv��XWeu�O�g$rk[$WevwOQ[;®·´pWeaV[ � Im�®W!a/��¤J¡�Wevwu�I§�±I�a�vwM$O�-uN�dv}KnW/��OWea-[FW¥¤���a±¡�W{v�uwI���ILaFvwM$O��wOQKnsba-[FKnW/��O/T��OJK�s/a-�wIL[\OQu�v�M$O KnW/��OFK�s/uwu�OQ�wrVs/a-[\ILa$£ v�s ��­®�«��� N9¯ � � ©qM-Onu�O1s/a$P�Y*g-r$rVOQu

vwu�ILWba$£bg$PmWeu­r-Weuwv¢se� � IL�­g$rk[$W{v�OQ[�¬¦vwM-Wev­IL�Q´°!�xxr-rVOQu�#-´/WeaV[y!��hs}vwuNWea-�wrVs���O$#¸®�´/WeaV[¥©¬O�$P�s\KN¤�v�M$O�K�s/¡¥r$g\v�WevwILsba±Wb�

%±& (-* ( & (+* _� & _ * _ . ��� %/0 (+* ( 0 (-* _0 _ * ( 0 _ * _ . % 0 � (-* ( 0 � _ * (0 � (-* _ 0 � _ * _ . ��� %±& (+* ( & (-* _� & _ * _ . w� T &�(+* ( 6 � &�(-* ( � � 0�(+* (70 � (-* ( ¬ fk{}o�z ®�\T & (+* (�6 & (-* ( � � 0 (+* _ 0 � (-* _ ¬ fk{}o�z ®� T & (+* _ 6 � & (-* _ � � 0 (+* ( 0 � _ * ( ¬ � � H H�®�-T & (+* _ 6 & (-* _ � � 0 (+* _ 0 � _ * _ ¬ � � H H�®� T & _ * _ 6 � & _ * _ � � 0 _ * (70 � _ * ( ¬ fk{}o�z ®�$T & _ * _ 6 & _ * _ � � 0 _ * _ 0 � _ * _ ¬ fk{}o�z ®

~

Page 12: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

l@M$O*��Y;¡¥¡¥O�vwu�ImK°u�Wba$¤k�ð¤�g$rk[$WevwO*Im�JO��\r$u�OQ����O`[>W/�JW6�wO�·�g$OQa-K�O*sb� fk{}o�zA�¦sbug$rt[-W{vwILa$£�vwM$O¥��g-�$¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ� &«²�* ² WeaV[ � � H H �¦sbuXvwM$O8sevwM-Onu®�$P�s\KN¤\�QTXl@M$O8g$rt[-W{vwO`�se�kvwM$O®��g-�$¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�­se� � KnWea��tOhrtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥OQ[¥ILa-[\OQrVOQa-[\Ona�v�P�Y/T¢l@M$O � � H�H g$rt[-W{vwO`�se�Xsbi;�Ò[\ImWe£/sba-WbP¬�$PLs\KN¤\��KQWea��VOJK�s/¡��$ILa$O`[BT���O±a$sev�O1v�M-W{v`´¬Wev�v�M$O±r$u�ILKnOFsb�hO��;v�u�WsbrtOnuNW{vwILsbaV�n´q©^O�Knsbg$Pm[�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡ v�M$O�g-rt[$WevwO�se��v�M$O�[$ILWb£bsbaVWePh�-P�s\KN¤\�!sb� � g-��ILa$£� � H H I�aV�dv�OQWb[Fsb� fk{}o�z¥TzªWeuwvÊsb�Vv�M$OhKnsbu�uwO`��rtsba-[$I�a$£®�$PLs\KN¤bOQ[¥Kns;[$OqIL�¬��M$s{©qa¥ILa��%IL£bg-uwO � T � T%��Oxa$sbvwO@vwMVW{v

I§v^IL�­¡�s/uwOhO� !K�ILOna�v¢v�s�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡&v�M$Ox¡�g-P§v�I�r$PLImKnW{v�I�s/a!se�B¡�W{v�uwI�� & ��Y�� �tO��¦s/uwOhKQWePLP�ILa$£� � H H u�WevwM$OQu^vwM-Wba1rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥I�a$£8vwM-IL�q¡8g$P�vwILr$P�ImKnWevwILsbaF©qI§v�M$ILa � � H H°T$l@M$O�Kns;[$OQ��¦sbuqU®fe{®o�z�³«� ² �8WeaV[1U}fk{®o=z�³�WbuwO®[\OQ�wIL£ba$O`[!g-�wI�a-£8PLs;sbr�g-a$uws/P�PLILa$£�Wba-[�Knsbr;Y;I�a-£-TcÒa �%IL£bg-uwO`� � T �îWeaV[ � T×�;´�©^O¯ILP�PLg-��vwuNW{vwO�uwO`��rtOQK�vwIL�bOnPLYîv�M$O�[$sbg$�$PLO�Wba-[���ILa$£/P�O

r$uwO`K�Im��ILsba WZ�/OnuNWe£/O�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO¯se��v�M$O��dvNWea-[$Wbu�[�Wba-["v�M$O��$PLs\KN¤bO`["�bOnuN�wI�s/a-�Jse�fk{®o�zå¬ WZ�bOnuNWe£/OQ[�s{�bOQu���·�g-WbuwOJ¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ��sb�}s/u�[$Onu � �\´x�e�V´q~b�$´qWba-[ � � µ �¦sbu!v�M$OKnWb�wO�!�xxr-rVOQu�#±WeaV[/!��xs1vwuNWea-�wrVs���O$#¸®�T8��O�WePm��sFI�aVK�PLg-[\O¥vwM-O�rtOQWb¤ rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�O�se�vwM$O¥K�s/¡�r-g\vwOQuXWeaV[±vwM$O�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�O�se�ªvwM-O8¡�Wea;g\�µW/K·v�g$uwOQu��Ò�wg$r$r$PLI�O`[±�bOQu��wI�s/a±©qM$OnaWZ�ZWbI�PmWe�-P�OXvws�g-�QT�$sbu^v�M$IL�x¤bOnu�a$OQP ´\s/g$uq£/WbI�a-�^s{�/Onu@g-�wI�a$£���v�Wba-[$WeuN[F²^³%|Xf1Weu�O���IL£ba$I��VKQWea�vQ´\g-�wg-WbP�PLY

��Y1W��µW/K·vws/u@se�«KnP�s���OXvws�vd©^s-TÊ��O}Knsba-�wIm�dv�Ona�vwPLY�sbg\v�rVOQu��¦s/uw¡ vwM$O}�bOQa-[\s/u@Kns\[\OXs/a�v�M$Of$�®ck��Y}Wq�wI�£/a$I��tKnWea�vSWb¡�s/g$a�vpI�a��wILa$£bPLOªr$u�OQK�Im�wI�s/apT « g$up�-P�s\KN¤bO`[}K�s\[\O¢Im�p�wg$�-��v�Wea�v�ILWbP�PLY�VOnv�vwOQuqvwMVWeaFvwM$O}�/Ona-[\s/uq¤bOQuwa$OQPksbaFvwM$O�U �^�~µ � �b� Wea-[1©¬s/g$Pm[��tO�On�/Ona1�µWb��vwOnuqI��Ê©¬Og-��O`[1vwM$O��/Ona-[\s/u��Ò�wg$r$r$PLI�O`[ � � H H°T

ï'ð&ï �û��]û³©´©³ó�©�µ�ód�tõeö³ù¦ø=õ[ù*ú ý§�ó'¶y·w¸±l@M$O�I�a-KnuwO`Wb�wOQ[&£buNWea;g$PmWeu�I§vdY)se�FM$I�£/M$Onu*³SOn�bOQP�²^³%|Xf WePm��s"WePLPLs{©x��¡¥sbu�O6O� !K�ILOna�vr-WeuNWePLP�OQP�IL¶QWevwILsbaF�VO`KnWbg-��O}sb�ªW�u�OQ[\gVK·vwILsba±ILa±vwM$O��wY;a-KNM$u�sba$IL¶QWevwILsbaFs{�bOQuwM$O`Wb[$�H¬ UXWZY\[^]OO�v®WbP TL´ � ~/~e�rÏ�Wea-[ |h¡¥OQ��vws{Yb´kU®WZY;[^]Ob´kUhg$i*Wba-[�H±s/uO¹Onu�Ob´ � ~b~ � ®·Th| r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnP%�bOnuN�wI�s/ase�BvwM-O®³SOn�bOQP � ²@³S|Xf�IL�^OQW/��ILPLY8s/�\v�WbI�a$O`[�g-�wI�a-£�v�M$OhPLs;sbr"�èP�OQ�bOQP-r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnPLIL�w¡�WZ�{WeILPLWb�$P�OsbaF¡�s��dvxsb�Sv�M$O���MVWeu�OQ[FWea-[1�;I�uwvwg-WbPp��MVWeu�OQ[1¡�OQ¡¥sbu�Y!¡�g$P�vwILr$u�s\K�OQ���wsbuN�nT��O±M-WZ�/OF[\OQ�bOQP�s/rVO`[¯r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnP@�bOQu��wILsba-�8se�XvwM$OJ³pOQ�bOQP � ²@³S|®f*�¦s/u¥vd©¬s��;I�uwvwgVWeP

��M-WbuwO`[ ¡¥On¡¥s/uwY�Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OnuN� ¶ vwM-O!²^²'�¸l � � �/�b� Wea-[�vwM-O�z�f\o � T « a�¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�®se�sbuN[\Onu �`�e� �$´Vsbg$u�f$� � H�H K�s\[\O8O��\OQKng\vwO`�XWev �Z�e� HFº-s/r-�®sba��e�!r$u�s\K�OQ���wsbuN�qsbaJv�M$O²^²'��l � � �b�b� ´SWeaV[�I�v�Im��rVs��w�wIL�$P�O¥v�sJsb�\vNWeILa �`� � � H±º-sbr-�}©qI�vwM��b�1r$uws\KnOQ����s/u��®sbavwM$O�z�f\o � �¦s/u�¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�}sb�¬sbuN[\OQu��e� µ ¬µ|h¡�O`�dv�s{Y O�v�WbP TL´ � ~b~ � ®·T�l@M$O!oqc�f � ²^³%|XfWeu�O®gV��O`[1W/�^vwM$O}v�g$a$OQ[±�wOnu�ILWbPpK�s\[\O`�nTl@©¬s6Wb[$[\I�vwILsbaVWeP®P�IL�$uNWeu�I�O`��M-WZ�/O��tOnOQa�[\O`��IL£ba$O`[îILa>s/u�[\OQu�v�s�¡�Wb¤bO�W�r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnP

²^³%|Xf¥WZ�{WeILPmWe�$PLO@sba¥¡¥OQ���wWb£bO��èr-W/�w�wI�a-£®�wY\�dv�On¡�� ¶ vwM$OX²^³%| � fȬµ²@Wb�wImKq³pILa$OQWbu¢|xPL£bOn�-u�W� sb¡¥¡�g$a-ILKQW{vwILsba¥f;g$�$r-uws/£buNWe¡��n´{�wOnO@Uhs/a$£/WbuwuNWhWba-[���MVWePLOnYb´ � ~b~ � ®BvwM-WevªWbuwO¬g-�wOQ[�Wb�W�K�sb¡¥¡8g$a$ImKnW{v�I�s/a±PLWZY/Onu ¬¦s/a±vws/rJse�Ê¡�O`�w��We£/O�r-Wb���wI�a$£¥PLI��-u�WbuwILOQ�x�wg-KNMJWb�hz*}®H*´;� ² ´HJz¢c·´ � H HJU8´LT�T ®·´-Wba-[�v�M$O�z­²@³S|®f�¬ zªWeuNWePLP�OQPV²@Wb�wILK®³pILa$O`Weu@|xPL£bOn�-u�W�f;g$�$r$u�sb£/u�Wb¡��n´��OQO � M-sbIð´-Uhs/a$£/WbuwuNW$´ « ��vwu�sbg-KNM$s{�k´;zÊO�v�I§v�O�vQ´-��WbP�¤/OnuqWea-[F��M-WbP�OQYb´ � ~b~ � 8 ®�T��O1I�a-[$ILKQW{vwO/´¢ILa��«I�£/g$uwO � T µ ´«vwM-O1rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO!se�qv�M$O1rVWeuNWePLP�OQP­¡�W{v�uwI��e�ð¡�W{v�uwI��

r$uws\[\gVK·v¢�¦u�sb¡ z­²@³S|®f�¬µ©¬OXK�sbaV��Im[\Onuª�tsev�M�vwM-Oh��ILa$£/P�OxWba-[¥[\sbg$�-P�Oxr-uwO`K�Im��ILsba�¤bOQuwa$OQPL�Q´vwM-Wev%Im�%z^f$� � H H¸Wba-[�z­U}� � H�H¸uwO`��rtOQK�vwIL�bOQP�Y]®ks/a�vwM$O@H � c³z «6� f$�,�<±h|*ILa-��v�WbP�PLOQ[

�Q�

Page 13: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

n j�t+�Cqgu \ U�tvuwmduVmC_mC_fº{} \ � º$QCU{x \ md]Vm$_duVmf� \ ��t$kKK xC�f�OZf�+�f�A�C�$[{Zf�$M{�RMO�p»Y�$[O¼YM{�Y[C�3Wf�CMA�-½�MO�yQK \ LT];_C`AaCbdc�`fegc�hO`$ifjfk3a$lC`Cmn jyr�URt9uwmC_fº7} \ � º$Qn j \C\ URtvu£rQg] \C\ � \ �ftvu¢rO� \ ��t$k3UphO`CiYj`Cm nCn j`$m nCn j`C}f~7`n jyr�URt9uwmC_fº7} \ � º$Qn j \C\ URtvu£rQg] \C\ � \ �ftvu¢rO� \ ��t$k3U3_C`Aa$bfKOQg] \$\ � \ ��t9u¢rO� \ �ft$k`Cm nCn j`$m nCn j`Cm n \ Ln j�¾$qguE}YU�t9uV�duVmC_mC_fºOQAj{}fºObCUOx \ md];mC_duV�f�7}Y��t$k\ LT]C]VxYj n ]VmC_Yº{} \ � ºOQgu�ofk?c�`fegc�q�kcVb$m n cO]Vx�j n ]Vm$_�º$QAj{}�ºObgu�ofkHc;`fe c¡q�kCk+aClC`$mQ$bO}C} n ~{¿$iC�C}foO�Ao ]VmC_fº7} \ � º$Q uVmC_fº$QCj{}fºObdu�bO}C�ClYb^uÀ bg] \ uV}9kvuV} n b^u¡j{mC`du¡Q ] \ u \ kvuV} n Q�k`C}f~7` Q$bO}C} n ~{¿$iC�C}d]Vm$_fº{} \ � º$QguVmC_Yº$QAj{}fº{b^u�b$}A�ClCb^uÀ bg] \ uV}9kvuV} n b^u¡j{mC`du¡Q ] \ u \ kvuV} n Q�k`Cm n \ L¾$q QAj{mCa \ m$|A`mC_fºOQAj{}fº$Q$UOmf�{mC_Yº{} \ � ºOQA� \ ��tmC_fºOQAj{}fºObCUO�Q$b$}$} nY� `Cx$xd]CÁVmdÂ$uCÁ�a^ÂCu;mC_fº{} \ � º$QguVm$_fº$QAj{}YºCQguVmC_�º$QCj{}fº$b^uÀ b$}C�$lAb^u�b^] \ u�t$ku;} n b^u�bg] \ �OmC_Yº{} \ � º$Q u�t$k?uV} n bduÀ _C`Aa$b^u�Qg] \ u \ �OmC_fº7} \ � º$QfkuV} n Qfkt-�Cq QAj{mCa \ m$|A`�«I�£/g$u�O � T �]¶ zªWeuwv@sb�Sv�M$O��$PLs;KN¤/OQ[FK�s\[\O®�¦sbuxU}fk{}o�z

�b�

Page 14: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

DSYRK std

DSYRK tuned

DSYRK lib.

Peak perf.

DEC3000 DEC8400 HP 715 IBM 750 SGI POW SUN2050 CS2−HA 0

100

200

300

400

500

600

Computers

MF

lops

�%IL£bg-uwO � T � ¶ |x�/OnuNWe£/O®rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO�se�¢U}fk{®o�z �¦u�sb¡,oqc�f � ²@³S|®f ¬7!�xhr$rtOnu-#$´Ã!��xsvwuNWea-�wrVs���O$#¸®�T

SSYRK std

SSYRK tuned

SSYRK lib.

Peak perf.

DEC3000 DEC8400 HP 715 IBM 750 SGI POW SUN2050 CS2−HA 0

100

200

300

400

500

600

Computers

MF

lops

�%IL£bg-uwO � T×� ¶ |x�/OnuNWe£/O�rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�O�sb�¬f$fk{}o�z¸�¦u�sb¡ oqc�f � ²@³%|Xf[¬{!�xxr-rVOQu�#-´«!��xsvwuNWea-�wrVs���O$#¸®�T

� �

Page 15: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

Double prec., N=500

Double prec., N=1000

Single prec., N=500

Single prec., N=1000

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 200

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

Number of processors

MF

lops

Perf. of P_GEMM from PBLAS on MEIKO CS2−HA, NX version of BLACS using RISC BLAS (nb=64)

�%IL£bg-uwO � T µ ¶ zÊOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnOJse��r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnPX¡¥Wevwu�I§�e�è¡�W{vwu�I��6r$u�s\[\g-K�v��¦u�sb¡ z­²@³S|®f�sbaH � c³z « � f$�R�(±X|

�Q�

Page 16: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

W{v �^� oh�\| � fk´\g-�wI�a$£���·�g-Weu�O}¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�@sb�%sbuN[\OQu �e�b� WeaV[ �`�b�/� TÊl@M$O�r$u�s;KnOQ����s/u¬Im�xW�Q�b� HJM$¶ ±xY;rtOnu·f\zB|ho � se�ªrtOQWb¤1rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO�O�·�g-WePpvws �`�b� HJ�«PLsbr-�QT@��O�gV��O�v�M$O�bOnuN�wI�s/aFsb�¢²^³%| � f±sba±v�sbrJsb�ªvwM$O�� ² ¡¥O`�w��We£/O�r-Wb����ILa$£�PLI��-u�WbuwY/Txl@M$O�vwg-a$OQ[ �wOnu�ImWeP²^³%|Xf1g-�wOQ[1IL�qvwM$O�oqc�f � ²@³S|®fkT

Ä Æ A ê ¨ÈE�ª�ADC A�½±Å�¨ ê�ê æìª�CjF ¼ ¥ Æ ÁÈI)EGF º IÆ�ð�ñ �¸ø¦ýv�]ù�Ç�È��rý]ö�ùvøl@M$O!²@³S|Xf�KQWea��VO!gV��O`[��wg-KnKnOQ���d�¦g-P�PLY�ILa*[\OQ�wI�£/a$ILa$£JK�s\[\OQ�®�¦s/u�vwM-O!��s/P�g\v�I�s/a�sb�¬v�M$OP�ILa$OQWbux��Y\��vwOQ¡

� É�� � w ¬µ�-T � ®©qM$Ona � Im�^�¦g$P�PðTl@M$Oq³S|hzB| � z>P�IL�$uNWeu�Y�¬µ|ha-[\OnuN�wsbap´b²@WbI ´b²^Im�wKNM-se�d´bUXOn¡¥¡¥OnPð´�UXsba-£/Weu�uNW$´{Uhg � uws/¶b´

�®uwOQOna;�-Weg-¡F´H±hWb¡¥¡¥WbuwPLILa$£-´�HJK�z}OQa$a$OQYb´ « �dv�uws/g-KNM$s{��Wea-["f;s/uwOQa-��OQap´ � ~b~��5®�g-�wOQ��$P�s\KN¤�WePL£bsbu�I�vwM$¡���Wb��¡�g-KNM*Wb��rVs��w�wI��-P�O¥v�s±v�We¤/O!Wb[\�{Wba/vNWe£/O�sb�¬v�M$O!M$IL£bM-Onu�PLOn�bOQP¢se�²^³%|XfkT`³S|XzB| � z�Knsba�v�WbI�a-�S��g$�-uws/g\vwILa$OQ�Bvwsx�wsbPL�bO¢�wY;��vwOQ¡��Bse�\PLI�a$O`WeuBO�·/gVW{vwILsbaV�n´`P�ILa$O`WeuP�O`Wb��v��Ò��·�g-WbuwO`�­r$u�sb�-P�OQ¡¥�Q´\OnIL£bOQa;�ZWbP�g-OXr$u�sb�-P�OQ¡¥�Q´$WeaV[1�wI�a-£bg$PmWeu@�{WePLg$O}r$u�sb�$PLOn¡��QT«cèvqIm�[\OQ�wI�£/a$OQ[*vws�£bIL�bO�M-I�£/M�O� !KnI�OQa-K�Y°sba��bO`K·vws/u�r$u�s\K�O`�w�wsbuN�n´ªoqc�f � �ð�-W/��O`[¯K�s/¡¥r$g\vwOQu��Q´Wea-[F��MVWeu�OQ[1¡�OQ¡¥sbu�Y!¡�g$P�vwILr$u�s\K�OQ���wsbuN�nT

Æ�ðV¥ ¦ õkóßùvúÊ Èû��]û³©=©³óË©w¶y·w¸±��OxMVWZ�bOqg-�wOQ[�r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnP$�/OnuN��ILsbaV�Êse�kvwM$OX²^³%|Xf�¡¥Ona�v�I�s/a$OQ[�ILa�f;OQK�vwILsba � T � vws�On�\r$P�s/I§v`´I�a6W±vwuNWea-�wr-WbuwOQa/v8¡¥Wba$a$OQuQ´ªr-Wbu�WbP�PLOnPLIm��¡ I�a�K�s\[\OQ���¦u�sb¡ vwM$OF³S|XzB| � z ³pIL�$u�WbuwY�sba��M-WbuwO`[�Wba-[��;I�uwvwg-WbP­�wM-Weu�OQ[�¡¥On¡¥sbu�Y�K�s/¡¥r$g\vwOQu��D¬ ��OQO!UXWZY\[^]O¥Wba-[°Uhg$i«´ � ~/~ � Wea-[|x¡¥OQ��vws{Y!OnvhWePðT�´ � ~b~ � ®·Tl@M$O1f\KQWb³S|XzB| � z PLI��-u�WbuwY7¬ � M$s/I ´ÊUhOQ¡¥¡�OQP ´¢UXM$ILP�PLsbaS´ÊUXsba-£/Weu�uNW$´ « ��vwu�sbg-KNM-s{�t´

zÊO�vwI�vwOnvQ´­f�vNWea$PLOnY/´Ê��WbP�¤/Onu8Wba-[*��M-WbP�OQYb´ � ~/~ � Ï�®}Im��Wba¯O��;vwOQa-�wI�s/a*se�h³S|XzB| � z �¦sbu[\IL��vwu�IL�$g\vwO`[�¡¥OQ¡�s/uwY�Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OnuN�nTÊcèvqI�PLPLg-�dv�u�WevwO`�­v�M$O®I�¡¥rtsbuwv�WeaVK�O®se�%�-g$I�Pm[\ILa$£��$P�s\KN¤\��¦sbu­u�OngV��ILa$£�O��\Im�dv�I�a-£���sb�¨vd©^WbuwOxW/�¢¡8g-KNM!Wb�ªrts/���wI��$PLOxILa�vwM-OX[\OQ�bOnPLsbr-¡�OQa�v­se�Brtsbuwv�We�-P�OWea-[6O� !KnI�OQa/v�Kns\[\OQ�QTîf\KnW/³S|hzB| � z IL�!�-Wb�wOQ[�sba�vwM$O�²^³%|Xfk´¬³S|hzB| � z¥´¢z¬²@³S|XfWea-[�²@³S| � f6PLIL�$u�WbuwILOQ�QT)��O��wM$s{©�´@ILa>�«I�£/g$uwOJ�VT � ´^vwM$O�rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�OJse�}v�M$O�³%x�´� M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y�Wea-[�Ì®o��µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a-�%�¦uws/¡ f\KQWb³S|XzB| � z��bOQu��wILsba � T � g-�wILa$£}�VsbvwM���ILa$£/P�OWea-[±[\s/g$�$PLO�r$uwO`K�Im��ILsba±s/aFu�OnPmW{v�I��/OnPLY!��¡�WbP�Pp¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ�qsb�«s/u�[\OQu �`�b�b� sbaFvwM$O�H � c³z «� f$�,�<±h|�Wev �^� ox�\| � fkT

Æ�ð&ï ¶y©³ù��Í*óËÇ ÿjõ�Í*ùËÎyÏf��?§�ø�û�Ð4ó�© �¾ù�Ç�ö�Ñ�óËÇ ��§�ùé�ó%õ�Í«Òü�û³�rýeùÃ�tö¢Ó�û�ý]ö³ùvø

l@M$O¥¡�s\[\I��-O`[ � M$s/P�O`��¤;YF�µWbK�vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba�¡¥s\[\I��-OQ�}Wba�ILa-[\O��-a$I�vwO¥¡�W{vwu�I��JvwsFsb�\vNWeILa�W� M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y��µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsbaJsb�­W!a$O`Weu���Y1rVs���I�vwIL�bO�[\O��Va$I§v�O8¡�Wevwu�I§�BThcèv®IL�®Wea�I�¡¥rtsbuwv�Wea�v

� �

Page 17: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

LU Double

LU Single

LLT Double

LLT Single

QR Double

QR Single

4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20100

200

300

400

500

600

700

Number of processors

MF

lops

SCALAPACK on MEIKO CS2−HA, NX version of BLACS using RISC BLAS,N=1500

�%IL£bg-uwO°�-T �5¶ zÊOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO�sb���¦g$PLP�¡�W{v�uwI����µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a-�1�¦uws/¡ f\KQWb³S|XzB| � z sbaH � c³z « � f$�R�(±X|

�`�

Page 18: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

K�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-WeP¬¤bOQuwa$OQP¢ILa¯sbr\v�I�¡¥IL¶QWevwILsbapT cèv�©^W/��ILa/v�uws\[\gVK�OQ[°�;Y¯�®ILP�P@Wea-[¯HJg$uwuNWZY¬ � ~;�Z�e®¬Wba-[±IL¡�r-uws{�/OQ[F�;YF�®ILP�Pð´kHJg$uwuNWZY�Wba-[F��u�I�£/M�v¬ � ~ µ � ®^Wea-[±¡¥sbu�O�u�OQK�OQa�vwPLY��;Y� �w¤bs{©¸Wea-[�f$KNM$a-We�tOnPH¬ � ~b~ �98 ´ � ~b~ � Ï�®�T cèv8Im�8r-WeuwvwImK�g$PmWeu�PLY�g-�wO��¦g-P¬ILa�s/r\vwIL¡¥I�¶`W{vwILsbaWePL£bsbu�I�vwM$¡��w¤��tsev�M6ILa�g$a-Knsba-��vwuNWeILa$OQ[6WeaV[6Knsba-��vwuNWeILa$O`[�s/r\vwIL¡¥I�¶`W{vwILsba ¬ �®ILPLPhO�v�WbP TL´� ~ µ � ®¡¤@v�sh£/Ona$OQu�WevwO¢Wx[\O`�wKnOna�v%[\ILu�OQK·v�I�s/a�©qM$Ona�vwM$O?±xOQ���wILWba�¡¥Wevwu�I§�}Im�pa$sbv%��g$ �KnI�OQa�vwPLYrVs���I�vwIL�bO��è[\O��-a$I�vwO/T«cèv¬IL�¬WePm��s�g-�wOQ[¥ILa!�wsb¡¥Oqvwu�g-��v­u�On£bILsba8vwO`KNM$a$I¯·�g$OQ��¬µ�wOnOhUXOna$a-IL�^Wea-[f\KNM$a-Wb�VOQP ´ � ~ µ � ´`f\KNM$aVWe�tOnPð´,z}s;s/a/v�¶­WeaV[}��OQIL���n´ � ~ µ � ®·´`I�a}v�M$O¬³%|=� �^� ³ « l�r-W/KN¤{We£bO¬ � sba-ap´/�®sbg-PL[8Wea-[�l%sbILa�vQ´ � ~b~��5®·´ZWeaV[�ILa��wr-WeuN�wO¢r$u�OQK�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu��?¬ f$KNM$P�ImKN¤k´ � ~/~ � ®�TpcèvM-Wb�qWbPL�ws8�tOnOQa±g-��O`[1vws¥�$g$ILPL[ � P�OQ¡�OQa�v��è��Yk� � PLOn¡¥Ona�v@r$u�OQK�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu��¬�¦s/uqPLWbuw£/O®��KnWbP�Osbr\v�I�¡¥IL¶QW{v�I�s/aFWbr$r$PLILKQW{v�I�s/a-�4¬µU®WZY\[¬]Ob´$³­¹ � �$K�OnPLPLOna�v@Wba-[J�®sbg$Pm[B´ � ~b~b� 8 ´ � ~b~ � ®·T��O�u�O��¦OQuxM$OQuwO}v�s�vwM$O � �w¤bs{©'�df\KNM$a-Wb�VOQPBHJs;[$I��-O`[ � M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y1�VWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/apT¬³SO�v

� �tO�W¯�wY�¡¥¡¥O�v�uwImK�ÔO�è�;Y¸�¡Ôª´@a$sevFa$OQKnOQ���wWbuwILPLY¯rVs���I�vwIL�bO��è[$O��-a$I�vwO�¡¥Wevwu�I§�B´@v�M$Ona�v�M$O� �w¤bs{©'�df\KNM$a-Wb�VOQP-�µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsbaFK�sb¡¥r$g$vwOQ� ¶

m5Õ ¬ � � � ® m'�~pvpÖÕ©qM$Onu�O m IL�±W�rVOQuw¡8g\v�WevwILsba�¡¥Wevwu�I§�>Wba-[ � Im�FvwM$OpÔO�è�;Y¸�¡Ô�¶nOQuws�¡�W{vwu�I��îI§� � Im���g\ !KnI�OQa/v�P�Y�rVs���I�vwIL�bO [$O��-a$I�vwO/T « vwM-Onu�©qIL�wO � IL��W°a$sba"�èa$OQ£/W{v�I��/OF[$ILWb£bsbaVWePq¡�W{v�uwI��KNM$s/�wOnaF��s�vwMVW{v � � � Im�x�wg\ !K�ILOna�vwPLY!rts/�wI§v�I��/O��Ò[\O��Va$I§v�ObTªl@M$OQuwO}Im�qa$s¥a$OnO`[!v�s¥¤�a-s{©Ï�×;Ì#Í;Ø Ì#ÍqI§� � Im��rts/�wI§v�I��/O��Ò[\O��-a-I§v�O Wea-[�vwM-OJ¡¥Wevwu�I§� � Im�![\O�v�Onu�¡¥I�a$O`[�[\g$u�I�a$£°v�M$O�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a�r$uws\KnOQ���nT¸l@M$O � ��¤/s{©'�Òf$KNM$a-We�tOnP®H±s\[\I��VOQ[ � M-sbPLOQ�w¤�Y��VWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/aO��\M$IL�$I§vN�ª�tO�v�v�Onu¬r$uws/rVOQu�v�I�O`�ÊI�a¥v�Onu�¡��Êse�BK�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-WePVK�s/��v��ªWba-[¥Wea�ÏÙ×;Ì#Í;ØRÌ#Í\g-r$rVOQu�Vs/g$a-[!s/a�Ú � Ú7Û&v�M-Wea�vwM$s���O®[\OQ��K�u�I��tOQ[!��Y!�®ILP�PkWeaV[1H±g$u�uNWZY�¬ � ~��{�k®ªWba-[��®ILP�PkO�vqWePðT¬ � ~ µ � ®·T��ܯodÜ&J � a�b���n{ÝrQ9Þ� � U,a�M)\]�vbes?c Q2S)V;ß�beS � a)QrsqbenOÝ�g��%\]U5N�Q;PRV;à5\]N�VqQrMÖÜl@M$O � ��¤/s{©'�Òf\KNM-a-We�tOnP-H±s\[\I��-O`[ � M$s/P�O`��¤;Y8�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a�Im�¬�-Wb�wOQ[¥s/a�W��wI�¡¥r$PLOhIm[\O`W$´a-We¡¥OnPLY¯v�M-W{v!s/a-K�OJWba�Wbr$r$u�sZ�\I�¡�W{v�I�s/a¯se�®vwM-OJ¡�s��dv!a-On£/WevwIL�bO±OnIL£bOQa;�ZWbP�g-OFsb� � Im�[\O�v�Onu�¡�ILa$O`[�¬µg-��ILa$£XvwM$Ox�®OQu���KNM$£bs/uwILa�K�ILuNK�PLO­v�M$Ons/uwOQ¡��Vs/g$a-[$�6®·´eI�vªIL�«O`Wb�wY}vws}K�sb¡¥r$g$vwO� Wb�JW�[\ImWe£bs/a-WeP}¡�W{v�uwI��îv�M-W{v��wM$I��¨v��±v�M$O*¡¥s/��v±a-On£/WevwIL�bO°OnIL£bOQa;�ZWbP�g-O�v�s{©^Wbu�[$�±W��g\ !KnI�OQa/v�P�Y6rts/�wI§v�I��/OJ�ZWbP�g-ObT « ��K�sbg-u��wOb´^I§v1IL�1[\OQ�wI�uNWe�-P�O±v�M-W{v!v�M$O OQI�£/Ona;�{WePLg$OQ���tO��M$I��¨vwO`[�v�s{©^Wbu�[$�pvwM$O^rts/�wI§v�I��/O­�{WePLg$OQ�%�;Y�W�·�g-Wba/v�I§vdY®v�M-W{v«IL�«a$sbv«�wg$�-��v�Wea�v�ILWbP�PLY}£bu�OQW{v�OnuvwM-Wba1v�M$O�¡¥s/��vqa$On£�W{vwIL�bO}OQI�£/Ona;�{WePLg$OXsb� � Tl@M$O8WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡ �¦sbuXvwM$O�H±s\[\I��-OQ[ � M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y±�VWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a Im�hs/uw£�Wea$IL¶nO`[±I�a�vd©¬s

r$M-Wb�wOQ�QTAl@M$Of�-u���v�r-M-Wb�wO�K�s/uwu�OQ�wrtsba-[$�Jvws�W>�dvNWea-[$Wbu�[ � M-sbPLOQ�w¤�Y��µWbK�vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsbapTl@M$O�WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡��w©qI§vNKNM$OQ�hvwsJWF��O`K�sbaV[Jr$M-W/��O8vwsFrVOQu��¦s/uw¡�W1¡¥s\[\I��VOQ[��µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a©qM$Ona,v�M$O ¡�W{v�uwI�� Im�î[\OnvwOQK�vwO`[ vws �tO a$sbv>��g\ !KnI�OQa/v�P�Y rts/�wI§v�I��/O��Ò[\O��-a-I§v�ObT cèvN�¡¥WbI�a�KNM-Wbu�W/K·vwOQuwIm��vwImK!Im��vwM-Wev�[\ILWb£bs/a-WeP@r$IL�bsbvwILa$£�Im�¥g-�wOQ[��-Wb�wOQ[�sba�vwM-OJ¡¥We�\I�¡8g$¡[\ILWb£bs/a-WeP«OnPLOn¡¥Ona�v`T���M$Ona�vwM$O¥¡�W{v�uwI��JIL�X�¦sbg-a-[ v�s��tO¥a$sev}rVs���I�vwIL�bO��è[$O��-a$I�vwOȬµ�wsb¡¥O[\ILWb£bs/a-WeP\OQP�OQ¡�OQa�v¢�VO`K�sb¡¥O`�ªa$sba]�ðrts/�wI§v�I��/O�®�´bWea�Wer-r$uwsZ�\IL¡�W{vwILsba�se�tvwM-Oq¡�s��dv¢a-On£/WevwIL�bOOnIL£bOna;�{WePLg$O8se� � IL�}Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OQ[ gV��ILa$£1vwM$O��®OnuN�wKNM-£bsbu�ILa � I�uNK�PLO�l@M-Onsbu�On¡,�tsbg$aV[$�®I�asbuN[\Onu®vws±[\OnvwOnu�¡¥I�a-O8v�M$O�We¡¥sbg-a/v}v�sFW/[$[ v�sFvwM$O�[\ImWe£/sba-WbP%sb� � T�cèv�IL�}On�$WbK·v�P�Y±v�M$O� M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y¥�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a�I�� � Im�q��g$ �KnI�OQa�vwPLY!rVs���I�vwIL�bO��è[$O��-a$I�vwO/´$Wea-[1ILa1v�M-W{vhKQWb�wOhv�M$Oa�g-¡��tOnuxsb�%º-s/r-�@se�«vwM-O�¡�s\[\I��-O`[��µW/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsbaFIm�@vwM$O���We¡¥O�Wb�q��v�Wba-[$Wbu�[ � M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y

� �

Page 19: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

¬{áYâj º-sbr-�Q´tr$P�gV�xsbuN[\OQuxse��Ô°sbrtOnuNW{v�I�s/a-�@v�s!r$u�OQKnWbPLKng$PmW{vwO�vwM$O�a-On© [\ImWe£/sba-WbPpOna�vwu�ILOQ�6®·T��M$Ona � Im�Xa$sev���g$ �KnI�OQa�vwPLYJrVs���I�vwIL�bO��è[\O��-a$I�vwO/´kvwM$O¥K�s��dv®se�¢v�M$IL�X�µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba Im�}W{v¡�s��dvX�YÔp_}Wb[$[\I�vwILsbaV�xWea-[�áYã_ ¡8g$P�vwILr$P�ImKnWevwILsba-�x£bu�OQW{v�Onu^vwMVWeaFvwM$O���v�Wba-[$Wbu�[ � M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/apTl@M$Ox�$PLs\KN¤bOQ[��/OnuN��ILsba�se�kvwM-Oh¡¥s\[\I��VOQ[ � M$s/P�O`��¤;Y��µW/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsba¥rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡��ªO��$WbK�vwPLY

vwM$O±�wWb¡¥O��µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba¯W/��v�M$OFsbu�I�£/I�a-WbP¬a-sba"�è�$PLs;KN¤/OQ[°s/a$ObT*cèv¥IL�¥[\O`��IL£ba-OQ[¯ILa¯v�M$O�wWb¡�O�©^WZY�Wb��sbvwM$OQu��$PLs\KN¤�WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡��D¬µ|xaV[\OnuN��s/a*O�v¥WePðT�´ � ~/~/�\´«UXWZY\[^]O!Wea-[*UXg\iÊ´� ~ µ ~$´-U®WZY\[^]O�WeaV[JUhg\iÊ´ � ~b~ � ´-Wba-[JUXsba$£�Weu�u�W-´$Uhg\iÊ´Bf;sbu�Ona-�wOnaJWba-[±�{Wea [\OQu=}ªsbuN��vQ´� ~b~ � Ï�®·T!cèv�Im��s/uw£�Wea$IL¶nO`[ g-�wI�a-£J�$P�s\KN¤�K�sbPLg$¡¥a-��sb�@vwM$O�¡�W{v�uwI��BT1|^v�v�M$O®ä�vwM¯��vwOQrp´vwM$O°�$PLs\KN¤îK�sbPLg$¡¥aTäîIm�1�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶QOQ[>g-��ILa$£�³pOQ�bOnP � WeaV[>³pOQ�bOQP��6²@³S|®f�©qI�vwM�Weag$a;�$P�s\KN¤/OQ[�WePL£bsbu�I�vwM$¡�[\OQuwIL�bO`[J�¦u�sb¡ vwM$O���v�WeaV[$WeuN[ � ��¤/s{©'�Òf$KNM$a-We�tOnP%�µWbK�vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsbapTl@M$O^�wg$�-�wO�·�g$OQa�v«g$rk[$WevwOQ�ÊWbuwO¬O�ikOQK·v�OQ[8g-�wI�a$£}³pOQ�bOQP � ²@³S|XfBT « �tK�sbg-u��wO¢v�M$Oq[\ILWb£bs/a-WePr$I��/sev�I�a$£8Wea-[�g-rt[$WevwOXse�%�®OnuN��KNM$£bs/uwILa¥�Vs/g$a-[$�^K�s/¡�r-P�ImKnWevwOqv�M$I�a-£/�^��ILa-K�OhvwM$Im�¬I�¡¥r$PLI�O`�vwM-WevXv�M$O�[$ILWb£bsbaVWePS�{WbP�g$O`�}Wea-[±v�M$O��Vs/g$a-[ O`�dv�I�¡�WevwOQ�®¡8g-�dv®�VO¥g$rk[$WevwOQ[�W{�¨v�Onu®OQWbKNMK�sbPLg$¡¥a6�µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/apT�|xPm��sV´­v�M$O �w©qI§vNKNM��¦u�sb¡ z¢M-W/��O � vws¯z­M-Wb�wO ��¡�WZY¯IL¡¥r$PLY�dv�sbr$r$ILa$£Jv�M$O��µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba°se�xWJ�-P�s\KN¤�KnsbPLg$¡¥a°vws rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡ WePLP­g$rk[$W{v�OQ��uwO`��g$P�vwILa$£�¦uws/¡ v�M$O�PLW/�dv��dv�Onr-�XILa�z¢MVWb�wO � �tO��¦s/uwO8¡¥s{��ILa$£�vws1z­M-Wb�wO��$T�H±sbu�O�[\Onv�WeILPm�®KQWea �tO�¦sbg$a-[FILaJUXWZY\[^]O�¬ � ~b~/�¸®·T��ܯodÜ0W åjT�YfbkP,V&U5\]s¦� É Z¦b¸PRV&YfbeMON�n�Ü��O¥u�OnrtsbuwvXsba�O��\rtOnu�I�¡¥Ona�vN�Xs/a � vdY;rVO`�Xsb�¢�¦g$PLPª¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�X�$g$ILP�v}gV��ILa$£1vwM$O �rbkM�Yf\"Nr$uws\KnOQ[\g$u�OhWZ�{WeILPmWe�$PLOhILa�vwM-O®�wse�¨vd©@Weu�Oq�¦u�sb¡ � �w¤bs{©�Wea-[1f\KNM$a-Wb�VOQP T¢l@M$Im�¬£bOna-OnuNW{vwO`�­Wu�Wba-[\sb¡ ¡�W{v�uwI��1v�M-W{v®M-Wb�XOnIL£bOQa;�ZWbP�g-OQ�qILa�W!uNWea-£bO�se�¢r-uwO`�wKnuwIL�VO`[±�{WePLg$OQ� ¶ ¡¥Wevwu�I§�±se�vdY�rtO � MVWb�@OnIL£bOQa;�ZWbP�g-OQ�¬I�a1vwM$O}uNWea$£/O=� � T«v�s �`�b� ´;¡�W{v�uwI��!se�%vdY;rVO���M-Wb�@OQI�£/Ona;�{WePLg$OQ�I�a1vwM$O�uNWea-£bO�� �Q�/�b�/� Tpv�s�� � ´$Wea-[1¡�W{vwu�I��!se�SvdY;rtO � MVWb�^OnIL£bOQa��{WbP�g$O`�^I�aFvwM-O®uNWea-£bO � Tvws �Q� T��O"��M-s{©�´JI�a,l%Wb�$PLO��VT � ´1v�M$O"rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O)se� v�M$O�³pOQ�bOnP � Wea-[ ³pOQ�bOnP �

²^³%|Xf��bOQu��wI�s/a!se�SvwM$O�H±s\[\I��-OQ[ � M$s/P�O`��¤;Y��µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a�¬µKQWePLP�O`[ S�n�g2Y�SGW ®­Wba-[�v�M$OrVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�O�se�­v�M$O¥�$PLs;KN¤J�/OnuN��ILsba¡¬µKnWbP�PLOQ[ S�n�g2YfS�_ ®xs/a vd©^sFoxc�f � ©^sbu�¤\�dvNW{vwILsbaV� ¶vwM$O�±hz"� �`� y{�b�¥Wba-[±v�M$O8cd²qH oXf-y{� �b�b� �d� �e� Tq��O8£bIL�bO�v�M$O�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO8W/KNM$I�OQ�bO`[g-��ILa$£}[\I�itOQuwOQa/vª�$PLs\KN¤���IL¶nO`�'¬ � �-´ � �$´eWea-[8�e�k®%WeaV[��¦s/u«¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ�%se�Vs/u�[$Onu �Q�b� Wea-[ �e�/� T��O}WePm��s8£bIL�bOhvwM$O®rVO`We¤�rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnOhILaFHJ�«PLsbr-�^se�%OQWbKNM1K�sb¡¥r$g$vwOnu^ILa1r-WbuwOQa�vwM$O`��O`�nT��O}g-�wO®vwM$O�¡�Wea;g\�µW/K·v�g$uwOQu��Ò�wg$r$r$PLI�O`[!²@³S|®f�s/a!v�M$OQ�wO�K�sb¡¥r$g$vwOnuN�QT«��O�sb�V��OQuw�/OxvwMVW{vvwM$O¬�$P�s\KN¤/OQ[®�µWbK�vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba�Im�%Wev%PLOQWb��vpvd©qImK�O^Wb�B�µW/�dvÊWb�pvwM$O^g$a;�$PLs;KN¤/OQ[}s/a$ObT«l@M$O¬Kns;[$OQ�[\OQ��K�u�I��tOQ[FM$OQuwO�WbuwO�WZ�{WeILPmWe�$PLO}g-��ILa$£¥�¨v�r Wea$s/a�Y;¡¥sbgV�­v�s¥�¨vwrpT OnaV��OQOnILM/v`T �¦uXI�a [$I�u�OQK�vwsbu�Yr$g$�ty{a�g-¡�OQuwI¯·�g$OZybH « U � ± « ³¢T

� �

Page 20: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

� s/¡¥r$g\vwOQu « uN[\Onu l¬Y;rVO S)n�g2YfS�W S�n�g2Y�S)_� � � � �e�

±Xzî� �`� y{�b� �`�b� � µ T � � �$T×� � �-TÕ� �/� T �� µ T � �/� T � � �-TÕ� �/� T �

¬ � � µ HJ�«PLsbr-�6® � µ T � � �$T×� � �-TÕ� � �$T×��b�b� � �-TÕ� � �;T×� � µ T � � �-T ~

� �-TÕ� � �;T � � µ T � � �-T µ� �-TÕ� � �;T µ � µ T � � �-T ~

cd²qH ohf-ye� �b�/� ��� �b� �`�b� � � �$T×� �/� T � � �-TÕ� �/� T �� � �$T×� �/� T � �b� T � �/� T �

¬ � � � HJ�«PLsbr-�6® � � �$T×� �/� T � �b� T � � �$T×��b�b� � � ~$T � ���$T µ � � T ~ ���$T µ

� � � T � �/�-T µ � � T µ � � T �� � ~$TÕ� �\�;T � � µ T � � � T µ

l%Wb�$P�O��VT �¸¶ zÊOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO8ILa�HJ�«PLsbr-��sb�@vwM$O�[$sbg$�$PLO�r$u�OQKnIL�wI�s/a¯H±s\[\I��VOQ[ � M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y�-WbK�vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsbapT

� µ

Page 21: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

æ ç IGF A�½`æ7F�è�F ê­â äçæ7è Æ ª�CXE*¿jFêédª�¥¦F�©?E Æ A ê ¨�E*ª�ADCA�½ Æ »�¼ ¥vIGFåæìª�CjF ¼ ¥ Æ ÁÈI)EGF º I

��Oxu�O��¦OQuªvws�vwM$Oh��vwgV[\I�O`�ªse�p|h¡�O`�dv�s{Y8Wba-[¥Uhg\i[¬µ|h¡¥OQ��vws{Y¥Wea-[¥UXg\i«´ � ~ µ ~-´ |h¡¥OQ��vws{Yb´� ~b~ � ´ |x¡¥OQ��vws{Y Wea-[AUhg\iÊ´ � ~b~ � ´ |x¡¥OQ��vws{Y O�v¸WePðT�´ � ~b~ � ®)s/a vwM$O,�wr-WeuN��O ³%x�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a se�@��·�g-WbuwO8¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�®sba���MVWeu�OQ[ ¡¥OQ¡�s/uwY±¡8g$P§v�I�r-uws\K�O`�w�wsbuN�QT�l@M$OnY gV��OWî¡�g-P§v�I§�¦u�sba�v�WbP�Wbr$r$u�s/W/KNM��¦s/u�v�M$O��µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/apT �-g$u�v�M$Onu��-W/KN¤�£/uws/g$a-[)sba vwM$Im�Wer$r$u�s/W/KNM�KnWba��tOJsb�$v�WeILa$O`[¯�¦u�sb¡ v�M$OJsbu�IL£bILa-WeP^r-WertOnuN�¥�;Y�UXg\i�WeaV[�oqOQIL[ ¬ � ~ µ � ´� ~ µ �k®�TcÒa¯W±¡�g$P�vwI��¦uws/a�v�WeP¬¡¥O�vwM-s;[p´%v�M$O1�wr-Wbu��wO¥�µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a�r-uws\K�OQOQ[$����Y°W �wO�·�g$OQa-K�O

se�@�µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a-��s/a¯��¡�WePLP¢�¦g-P�P^¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�Q´ÊKnWePLPLOQ[��¦u�sba�v�WbP­¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�nTJl@M$O!s/u�[$Onu�I�a$£�¦sbu�v�M$O��wO�·�g$OQa-K�O!sb�xK�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-��Wba-[�vwM-O!�¦u�sba�v�WbP¢¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�8Weu�O![\O�v�Onu�¡¥I�a$O`[*�;YW K�s/¡�r-g\v�WevwILsba-WbPªvwu�OnO/´ÊKQWePLP�O`[*Wb����OQ¡��$PLY v�uwOQOb´«©qM$Onu�O!O`WbKNM°a$s\[\O!u�Onr$u�OQ�wOna�vN��W±�¦g$PLP¡¥Wevwu�I§�*�µW/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsba�Wea-[�OQW/KNM�OQ[$£bO1vwM$OFvwuNWeaV�d�¦OQu�sb�X[$Wev�W��¦uws/¡4KNM$ILPL[�vws�r-Weu�Ona�va$s\[\ObTªl@M$Im�@Wb����OQ¡��$PLY�vwu�OnO®IL�@[\OnvwOnu�¡¥I�a-OQ[��¦u�sb¡¸v�M$O}��r-Wbu��wI�vdY�rVW{v�v�Onu�a�sb�pvwM$O®¡�W{v�uwI��Wea-[��¦u�sb¡¸W�u�OnsbuN[\OQuwILa$£®vwM-Wev­u�OQ[\g-KnOQ�¢vwM$O=�-P�P��èI�a![\g-uwILa$£�v�M$Oxa;g$¡¥Onu�ILKQWeP-�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a¬µ�wg-KNM�Wb�­vwM-OX¡¥ILa$I�¡8g$¡ [\OQ£bu�OnOxs/u�[\OQuwILa$£�v�M-W{v@©^Ohg-�wOhM$OQuwO,®·TªUXg$uwILa$£�vwM$O®a;g$¡¥Onu�ILKQWeP�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/ap´@OnPLI�¡¥ILa-W{v�I�s/a-��WevFWea;Y�a$s\[\O�KQWea�r$u�s\K�OnO`[�Wb���ws;sbaîW/��vwM-s/�wO�W{v!v�M$OKNM$I�Pm[°a$s\[\O`��M-WZ�/O¥Knsb¡¥r$PLO�v�OQ[*WeaV[�vwM$O!u�OQ�wg$P�vwILa$£ K�s/a�vwu�I��$g$vwILsba-�}�¦u�sb¡ vwM-O�KNM$ILPL[\u�OnaM-WZ�bO}�tOnOnaJ�wg$¡¥¡¥OQ[[¬µW/�w�wOn¡8�$PLOQ[t®¬©qI�vwM [$Wev�W�W{v@v�M$O�r-WbuwOQa/vqa$s\[\O/T­l@M$Im�qIm�@vwM$O�sba$PLY��Y;a-KNM$u�sba-I�¶`W{vwILsba®v�M-W{v«IL�%uwO�·�g$I�u�OQ[�Wba-[}¡¥OQWba-�pv�M-W{v«sbrtOnuNW{v�I�s/a-�pW{v«a$s\[\OQ�pvwM-WevÊWbuwOªa-sevWea-KnOQ��vwsbuN�^sbuq[\OQrVOQa-[$Wea�vN�xWeu�O®Knsb¡¥r$PLO�v�OnPLY�ILa-[\OnrtOnaV[\Ona�vQT¢l@M-O�r-WeuNWePLP�OQP�Im�w¡�uwO`��g$P�vwILa$£�¦uws/¡�vwM$Im�qs/�-��OQuw�{WevwILsba�©qILPLPp�VO�u�O��¦OQuwu�OQ[�vws�W/�^vwu�OnO}r-WeuNWePLPLOnPLIL�w¡±T��O®a$sev�Ohv�M-W{v^vwM-OX�µW/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsba!Wev^O`WbKNM1a$s\[\OXIm�@[\sba-Ohg-�wI�a-£��¦g$PLPBPLI�a$O`Weu@WePL£bOQ�$u�W

Wea-[1[\I�u�OQK�v@W/[$[\u�OQ����ILa$£��ws8vwM-Wev¬�µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba�Knsb¡¥r$g\vNW{v�I�s/a-�­©qI�vwM-I�a±W�a-s;[$O®KQWea�gV��OvwM$O�²@³S|®fkT-|hP�PBv�M$O�ILa-[\ILuwO`K·vhWb[-[\uwO`�w�wILa$£8Im�qK�s/a"�-a$O`[1vws�vwM$O�W/�w�wOn¡8�$PLY�r$uws\KnOQ���nT|x¡¥OQ��vws{Y®Wea-[}UXg\i�MVWZ�bOª[\On�/OnPLsbrtOQ[}W@r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnP{¡8g$P§v�I§�¦u�sba�vNWeP/Kns\[\OÊ�¦sbuBv�M$O­�wsbPLg\vwILsba

se�x��Y;¡¥¡¥O�v�uwImKnWbP�PLY���vwu�g-K·v�g$u�OQ[°g$a-�wY;¡¥¡�Onvwu�ILK!O�·�g-W{v�I�s/a-��¬ |x¡¥OQ��vws{Y�Wea-[*UXg\i � ~ µ ~$´|x¡¥OQ��vws{Y � ~/~ � ´Q|x¡¥OQ��vws{Y}Wea-[�UXg\i � ~/~ � ´n|x¡¥OQ��vws{Y®O�v«WePðT � ~b~ � ®·TpoqO`K�OQa/v�P�Y/´eWqPLI��$uNWeu�Y�bOnuN�wI�s/a!se�%vwM$O}O��\rtOnu�I�¡¥OQa/vNWePBK�s\[\O�KQWePLP�O`[�ë®ìÃí^îk´\M-Wb�^�tOnOQa1ILa-K�PLg-[\O`[�ILa±oqOnPLOQW/��O � �se�«vwM$O ±XWeu�©¬OQP�P«f;g$�$u�sbg\v�I�a-O�³pIL�$u�WbuwY ¬q±Xf$³¢´ � ~b~/�¸®·T¬l@M$IL�=±Xf\³¯Kns\[\O�IL�XKnWbP�PLOQ[ðï9ñ Ø�Õ ´Wea-[�vwM$O�u�OQ�wg$P�v��qILa1vwM$Im�x�wOQK·v�I�s/aFWbuwO®�¦u�sb¡ u�g$a-�x©qI§v�M1v�M$Im�xK�s\[\O/TUhg$u�ILa$£�v�M$OJ³%x �µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/ap´¢I��Xs/a$P�Y°v�M$OFvwu�OnOFr-WeuNWePLPLOnPLIL�w¡ IL��O��\r$PLsbI�vwO`[B´¢v�M$O

��rtOnO`[e�ðg-r�Im���bOQuwY [$IL��Wer$rtsbILa�vwILa$£-T�l@M$O�W/K·vwgVWeP¢�wrVOQOQ[e�èg$r°[\OnrtOna-[-��sba�vwM$O�r-uws/�$P�OQ¡�$g\vhIm�@vdY;r$ImKnWePLPLY!sba$PLYF��v�s � I�u�uwO`��rtOQK�vwIL�bO}se�«vwM-O�a�g-¡��tOnuxsb�«r$u�s\K�O`�w�wsbuN�nTªl@M$Im�qrts;sburVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�O±IL��KnWegV��O`[��;Y�vwM$O±�µW/K·v!v�M-W{v�v�M$OJvwu�OnOJrVWeuNWePLP�OQP�Im��¡ [\OQKnuwO`Wb�wOQ�¥Wb�¥v�M$OK�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a�r$u�s\K�OQOQ[$�8vws{©@WeuN[$��vwM$O±u�s�sbv�sb�xvwM-O1v�uwOQObT�HJsbu�Ons{�bOQuQ´ª|h¡�O`�dv�s{Y¯Wea-[Uhg\i߬ � ~/~ � ®qM-WZ�/O8s/�-��OQuw�/OQ[±v�M-W{v}vdY;r$ImKnWbP�PLY�� �kÉ se�¢v�M$O�©^sbu�¤FIm�}rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�O`[ ILa�v�M$Ovwsbr6v�M$uwOQOJP�OQ�bOQPL��sb�Xv�M$O�W/�w�wOn¡8�$P�Y¯vwu�OnObT>cèv�IL��vwM;g-��a$O`K�O`�w��Weu�Y°vws¯s/�\v�WbI�a��¦g$uwvwM$OQur-WeuNWePLP�OQP�Im�w¡ ©qI�vwM$ILa¯v�M$O�PmWeu�£bO�a$s\[\OQ��a$OQWbu�vwM-O1u�s;sev�sb�qvwM$O�vwu�OnO��;Y°g-�wI�a-£�r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnP�bOnuN�wI�s/a-�¢sb�pvwM$O}²@³S|®f�ILa!vwM-Oh�µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba-�¬©qI�vwM$ILa!v�M$OXa-s;[$OQ�QTÊ|h¡¥OQ��vws{Y!WeaV[!Uhg$iKnWePLPpv�M$Im�ha$s\[\O8r-WeuNWePLPLOnPLIL�w¡±Tq��M$Ona��VsbvwMJv�uwOQO�Wea-[ a$s\[\O�r-Wbu�WbP�PLOnPLIL�w¡,Weu�O�K�s/¡��$ILa$OQ[vwM$O��wI§v�g-W{v�I�s/a1�tOQKnsb¡¥OQ�x¡�g-KNMF¡¥sbu�O®OQa-K�s/g$uNWe£bILa$£VT

� ~

Page 22: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

cÒa�l«We�$PLO � T � ´e©^Oq��M-s{©*vdY;r$ILKQWeP\rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnO^sb�Hï9ñ Ø2Õ �¦sbu¢W®u�Wba$£bO^se�koqc�f � �è�-Wb�wOQ[K�sb¡¥r$g$vwOnuN�QT�l@M-O oqc�f � ²^³%|Xf�Im�¥g-��O`[6sba�vwM$O U �^� Wea-[�vwM-O�H � c³z « Wba-[¯v�M$O¡¥Wba;g\�µWbK�vwg$u�Onu��è�wg$r$r-P�ILOQ[°s/a$O�ILa¯v�M$O�sbvwM$OQu�KQWb�wOQ�QT�| ¡�O`[\ILg$¡4��IL¶nOF��rVWeuN��O!¡�Wevwu�I§�B´ò�ó5ô�ô õ5ö�÷fø��¦u�sb¡ vwM$O�±hWbuw©^OnPLP��Ò²^s;OnILa$£ ��Onv�¬ Uhg\iÊ´¬�®u�I�¡¥O`��WeaV[¯³pOQ©qIL�Q´ � ~b~��5®�´%Im�g-��O`[�I�a�vwM-IL�}vNWe�$PLObT!l@M-IL��Im��WF¡�W{vwu�I���se�^sbuN[\Onu � ~e� µ ©qI�vwM �b� � µ � �!a-sba$¶QOnu�s/�X�¦uws/¡W���vwu�g-K·v�g$u�WbP«Wba-WePLY\��Im�®Wer$r$PLImKnW{v�I�s/apT}|&¡¥ILa$I�¡8g$¡ [\OQ£bu�OnO�s/u�[$Onu�I�a$£�IL�®g-�wOQ[ Wba-[Jv�M$Oa�g-¡��tOnu¥se�Xº-s/WevwILa$£ �èrVs/I�a�v�sbrtOnuNW{vwILsbaV���¦s/u8v�M$OF�µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a¯Im�¥�b� � ¡¥I�PLP�ILsbaST�l@M$OrVOQu��¦s/uw¡�WeaVK�O�WbKNM$ILOn�/OQ[���YÊï�ñ Ø2Õ Im�qg-�wg-WePLP�Y�¡�s/uwO®v�M-Wea±� �eÉ se�«vwM-Wevxse�ÊU®� � H H°T

zÊO`We¤�rtOnuw�dT U}� � H H ï�ñ Ø2Õ� sb¡¥r$g$vwOnu HFº-s/r-� HFº-s/r-� HFº-s/r-�

U �^� �b�/�b� y{� �/� �Ò| ² z �Q�/� ��~ � �±Xzî� �`� y{�b� � � µ �/� �/�cd²qH ohf\� �b�b� yb� �e� � � � �Q�$� �b�cd²qH f\z¬��¬¦vwM$ILaJa$s\[\O�® �e�/� � �Q� � �b�H � c³z « � f$�,�<±h| �Q�/� � � �-�

l%Wb�$P�O � T �5¶ zÊOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O}��g-¡�¡�WbuwY1se�ÊvwM$O8¡�g$P�vwI��¦u�sba�v�WbPS³%x �µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a®ï9ñ Ø2Õ sba¡¥Wevwu�I§�!² � f$f\l�z �Z� sba1W�uNWea$£/Oxse�Soxc�f � r$u�s\K�OQ���wsbuN�nT«l@M$OXWZ�/OnuNWe£bOqrtOnuw�¦sbu�¡�Wea-KnOxse�U®� � H H IL�xWbPL�ws���M-s{©qa ¬ WZ�bOnuNWe£/OQ[�s{�/Onuq��·/gVWeu�OX¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�@se�ÊsbuN[\Onu � �\´$�b�-´$~b�-´$Wea-[� � µ ®·T|xP�vwM$s/g$£bM6©¬OJMVWZ�bO±K�sbaVK�Ona�v�u�WevwOQ[�I�a6v�M$IL����O`K·vwILsba�s/a�v�M$OJg-�wOFsb�®M-I�£/M$Onu�PLOn�/OnP

²^³%|Xf°ILa�W�¡�g$P�vwI��¦uws/a�v�WeP¬¡¥O�vwM-s;[�[\OQ�wI�£/a$OQ[*�¦sbu8�wY;¡¥¡�Onvwu�ILKQWePLP�Y°��vwu�g-K·v�g$uwO`[¯�wr-WeuN��O¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�Q´Sv�M$O!g-�wO!sb�q�wg-KNM¯Knsb¡¥r$g\vNW{vwILsbaVWeP¢¤/Onu�a$OnPm��ILa¯��r-Wbu��wO![\ILuwO`K·v8Kns\[\OQ��Im��a-s{©�bOnu�Y®©qIL[\O`��r-uwO`Wb[}Wea-[�IL�%Weu�£bg-Wb�$P�YhvwM$O^¡�WeILa�K�s/a/v�uwIL�$g\v�sbuSvwsqv�M$O­On �KnI�OQa-K�Y}sb�$¡�s\[\OQuwaK�s\[\OQ���¦s/u¥vwM$O�[\I�u�OQK�v!��s/P�g\v�I�s/a�sb�}�wr-Wbu��wO1O�·�g-W{v�I�s/a-�nTîl@M-OnY¯M-WZ�/OJWePm��s��VOQOna�g-�wOQ[I�ap´t�¦s/uXOn�\Wb¡¥r$P�O/´tvwM$O�¡�g$P�vwI��¦u�sba�v�WbPS�µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsbaJsb�¢g$a-�wY�¡¥¡¥O�v�uwImK�¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ��¬µU®WZ��Im�Wea-[�Uhg$i � ~/~ � ®hWba-[�I�a*�wg$rVOQuwa-s;[-WeP¢K�s\[\O`�®�¦sbu�g$aV��Y;¡¥¡¥O�vwu�ImK8r-uws/�$P�OQ¡��D¬µUXOn¡¥¡¥OnPð´� Im��OQa-�dvNW{v`´��®ILP��tOnuwvQ´\³pIkWeaV[�³pILg � ~/~ � ®�T%|î�¦g$P�PLOnu@[\Im�wKng-����ILsba¥sba!vwM$OXg-��Ohse�BM$IL£bM!PLOn�/OnPK�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-WePB¤/Onu�a$OnPm�^I�aJ�wr-WeuN�wO®[\ILu�OQK·vx¡¥OnvwM$s\[$�xKQWeaF�VO}�¦s/g$a-[FILa±UXg\i¡¬ � ~/~b�¸®�T

ù Æ A ê ¨ÈE�ª�ADCA�½ Ç ¼ ¥*E�ª ¼ê�ê Á Æ F »�¼ ¥ ¼Eú�ê Fåæìª�C�F ¼ ¥ Æ ÁÈI)EGF º I ç I�ª�Czûü ê F º FHC�EËý ú ÁÊý ü ê F º FHC�E Ç ¥¦F�©�ADC�§�ª#E*ª�ADCjF�¥vIþ'ð�ñ �¸ø¦ýv�]ù�Ç�È��rý]ö�ùvø

��O���vwgV[\Y>v�M$O��wsbPLg\vwILsba"sb��PmWeu�£bO°g$a-W/�w�wOn¡8�$PLOQ[)r-WeuwvwImWePLPLY��wOnr-Wbu�Wb�$P�O*�wY\�dv�On¡��J�;Y¡�OnvwM$s\[$�­vwMVW{v^WbI�¡ v�s�O��\r$PLsbI�v­v�M$OnILu¬ILa$M$OQuwOQa�v¬�dv�uwgVK·vwg-uwO/T«cÒa�r-WeuwvwImK�g$PmWeu`´b©^OhKnsba-�wIL[$Onu

� �

Page 23: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

vwM$O�PLI�a-OQWeu��wY\�dv�On¡��®vwMVW{v�Weu�Im��O��¦u�sb¡ v�M$O�¡¥I�a$IL¡¥I�¶`W{v�I�s/a�sb�¬v�M$O�r-Wbu�v�ILWbP�PLY��wOnr-Wbu�Wb�$P�O¬ �®u�I�OQ©^Wba$¤�WeaV[1l%sbILa�vQ´ � ~ µ �¸®¢s/�"°dOQK�vwIL�bOX�¦g$a-K�vwILsba

ÿ ¬ É ® � �� ²��Ë( ÿ ² ¬ É ² ® G ¬ �$T � ®

©qM$Onu�O¥OQWbKNM°�wO�v�se�HÐ Ø�Ë6ÏRÐB�{Weu�ILWb�$PLOQ�Q´ É ²���� á� ´%IL��WF�wg$�-�wO�v�sb�¬v�M$O�5Ð Ø 8 ÏRÐS�ZWbuwImWe�-P�O`�n´É ��� á ´-Wba-[ÊÔ ²� ÔªTcÒaJg$a-K�s/a-��vwuNWeILa$OQ[Fsbr$vwIL¡�IL¶QWevwILsbap´V©¬O�se�¨vwOQaJuwO�·�g$I�u�O�Weaf¬ Wer$r-uwsZ�\IL¡¥WevwO,®@��s/P�g\v�I�s/ap´

S ´\v�s�vwM$O �hOn©@vws/a±O�·�g-W{v�I�s/a-� ����� ÿ ¬ É ® S ��� ��� ÿ ¬ É ® ¬ �$TÕ�5®��M$Ona ÿ MVWb�^vwM-O}�¦sbu�¡ ¬µ�-T � ®·´\O�·/gVW{vwILsba ¬µ�-T �¸®^KnWea±�tO�O��\r$u�OQ����O`[�W/�� �� ²��°( ����� ÿ ² ¬ É ² ®�� S ��� �� ²��°( ��� ÿ ² ¬ É ² ®�w ¬ �$T � ®

l@M$O�±hOQ����ImWea¥¡�W{v�uwI���sb�pOQW/KNM ÿ ² Im�¬W�PLs{©'�èu�Wba$¤k´b��rVWeuN��Oq¡�W{v�uwI��BT«l@M-Ohs{�bOQu�WbP�P]±hOQ����ImWeaIL�pvwM;g-�B�¦u�O�·�g$OQa�vwPLYXWePm�wsx��r-Wbu��wObTpz­g\v�v�I�a-£qvwM$Im�pILa�W@¡¥sbu�Oª£bOQa$OnuNWePbKnsba�vwOn�;vQ´`©¬O¢Knsba-�wIL[$OnuvwM$O��wsbPLg\vwILsbaFse�ª��vwu�g-K·v�g$uwO`[1�wY\�dv�On¡��@se�ÊPLI�a$O`Weu@O�·�g-WevwILsba-�@sb�%v�M$O}�¦sbu�¡

� É�� � G ¬ �$T �k®©qM$Onu�O

� � �� ²��°( � ² w ¬ �$T � ®Wea-[ � Im�FPLWbuw£/O�Wba-[>a-sbu�¡¥WbP�PLY�rVs���I�vwIL�bO°[\O��-a$I�vwObT,f;IL¡�ILPmWeu±P�ILa$O`WeuJ��Y\��vwOQ¡¥�±WbuwIm��O©qM$Ona*�wsbPL��ILa$£JK�s/a-��vwuNWeILa$OQ[�sbr\v�I�¡¥IL¶QWevwILsba°r$u�sb�$PLOn¡��}g-�wI�a-£ Weg$£/¡�OQa�vwOQ[�³SWb£buNWea$£/ILWba¡�OnvwM$s\[$�Q´qWea-[p´^sb�}Knsbg$uN�wOb´­©qM-Ona�g-�wI�a-£ �Va$I§v�O��èOnPLOn¡¥Ona�v�¡¥OnvwM$s\[$�¥v�s¯��s/P��/O±OnPLP�ILr\vwImKr-WeuwvwImWePp[\I�ikOnu�Ona�vwImWePBO�·/gVW{vwILsbaV�nT|xP�vwM$s/g$£bM [\ILu�OQK·vX¡�OnvwM$s\[$�h¡�WZY1�tO�Wer-r$uws/r$u�ILWevwO}�¦sbuX��s/P��;ILa$£�¬µ�-T �e®·´t©¬O�Knsba-�wIL[$Onu

M$Onu�O°vwM$O*gV��O*sb�8v�M$O¯K�s/aR°dg$£/WevwO*£/u�W/[\I�OQa�v±¡¥OnvwM$s\["K�s/¡��$ILa$OQ[)©qI�vwM � P�OQ¡�OQa�v��è��Yk�� PLOn¡¥Ona�v8r-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$OnuN�QT |h[$[\I�vwILsbaVWePLP�Y/´ª©¬OF��M$s{© v�M-W{v¥We¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwILa$£ OQP�OQ¡�OQa�v���VOn�¦sbu�O¥Knsba-��vwu�g-K�vwILa$£F�wg-KNM�W1r-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$Onu}KnWba�[$u�Wb¡¥WevwImKnWbP�PLY±I�¡¥r$u�s{�bO8vwM$O��wrVOQOQ[Wea-[1a;g$¡¥Onu�ILKQWePB�tOnM-WZ�;ILsbg$uqsb�SvwM-O�¡�OnvwM$s\[BT

þ'ðV¥ ÿ�©�ó�� ó%ø¦ý�Ï$ЫҫÏ�ÿ�©³ó�� ó%ø¦ýy ��tó��Oùvø�Ç�ö<ý]ö³ù¦ø�ód�tõ� PLOn¡¥Ona�v��Ò²^Yk� � P�OQ¡�OQa�v4¬ � ² � ®^r-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$OnuN�q©^Onu�O}I�a�vwu�s\[\g-KnOQ[±�;Y�±hg$£bM$O`�n´t³pOQ��I�vWea-[ ��I�a-£bO�v`¬ � ~ µ � ®�Wea-[ « uwvwIL¶b´ z¢ILa-�w¤;Y Wea-[ l%WZY;PLsbu­¬ � ~ µ � ®¯Wba-[ M-WZ�bO)�VOQOna��g-KQK�O`�w���¦g$PLP�Y¥Wer$r-P�ILOQ[�ILa�W}a;g$¡��tOnu¬se�pWer$r-P�ImKnWevwILsba-�ªILa�Ona-£bILa$OnOQuwILa$£�Wea-[¥r-M�Y\�wILKQ��¬µ�wOnO/´�¦sbu�On�\Wb¡¥r$P�O/´�±xg$£/M$OQ�Q´«�-Onu�Ona-Kn¶!Wea-[[±XWePLPÊ·�g$I�v���¬ � ~ µ �5®·´«Wea-[ � uwM$OQP ´Êl%u�WZY;a-Wbu�[�Wea-[}hIm[\u�W/�wKng­¬ � ~/~ � ®�®·T�|�[$O�v�WbI�PLOQ[�Wba-WePLY\��Im��sb�®v�M$Im�!v�OQKNM$a$I¯·�g$O Im�!£/I��/Ona��;Y��°W{v�M$Ona

� �

Page 24: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

¬ � ~ µ ~k®·Tªl@M$OQ�wO�r$u�OQKnsba-[\I�vwILsba-OnuN�¬MVWZ�bO}��s/¡�O}a$ImK�O}�¦O`W{v�g$uwO`�nT¢l@M-OnY1KQWeaF�VO�Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OQ[OnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��è©qIm��OJWeaV[�¡¥s��dv�se�®vwM-On¡ [$s�a-sev!u�O�·�g$ILuwO±Wb����OQ¡��$PLYbT��-g$u�v�M$Onu�¡¥sbu�Ob´­vwM$OQYrVOQuw¡¥I�vxO� !K�ILOna�vxr-Wbu�WbP�PLOnPLI�¶`W{v�I�s/apT��O}[\OQ��K�u�IL�VO®M$Onu�O®sba$PLY¥vwM$O � ² � r$u�OQK�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu^�wILa-K�O/´\I�a1sbg$u@O��\rtOnu�I�OQa-K�O/´�vwM$Im�

IL��s/a$OJse�®vwM-O ¡¥s/��v!r$uws/¡¥IL�wI�a-£-T>�-g$u�v�M$Onu1[\O�vNWeILPL�!KQWea��tO±�¦sbg$a-[�ILa�UXWZY\[^]OFOnv1WePðT¬ � ~/~e� 8 ®�T|h����g$¡¥ILa$£�vwM-Wev � IL�@rts/�wI�vwIL�bO�[\O��Va$I§v�Ob´V©¬O}¡�WZY!u�On©qu�I§v�O � W/� ¶

� � �� ²��°( c ² ���� ²��Ë( ¬ � ² � c ² ® � c ���� ²��°( ¬ � ² � c ² ® G ¬ �$T �¸®

©qM$Onu�O c ² ������ "! ¬ � ² ®�WeaV[ c �$# � ²��Ë( c ² T`�hs{©�´qP�Onv c �¾p&%Èp Õ % �tO v�M$O� M$sbPLOQ�w¤;Y��µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a�sb� c ¬ p % Im�q��IL¡¥r$P�YFW¥[\ILWb£bs/a-WePk¡�W{v�uwI��t®·T¢l@M$OQap´� �ôp % �

K �'�� ²��Ë( p)( (% ¬ � ² � c ² ® p*( Õ% � p Õ % � p % �K ���� ²��Ë( � ² � p Õ % G ¬ �$T×� ®

©qM$Onu�O � ² ��p)( (% ¬ � ² � c ² ® p)( Õ% T^xX��ILa$£6vwM-O°Wbr$r$u�sZ�\I�¡�W{v�I�s/a K � # � ²��Ë( � ²,+- � ²��Ë( ¬ K � � ² ®·´-©^O}sb�\vNWeILa ¶� + p % �.²��Ë( ¬ K � � ² ® p Õ % w ¬ �$T µ ®

|)�¦g$u�v�M$OnuxWbr$r$u�sZ�\I�¡�W{v�I�s/a�£/I��/OQ�^vwM-O � ² � r-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$Onu

/101210 �~p % � �.²��Ë( p ² � � �.²��Ë( � ² �435 (.²�� � p Õ²�67 p Õ % G ¬ �$T ~¸®

©qM$Onu�OqvwM-O p ² WeaV[ � ² �µWbK�vws/u��¬K�sb¡¥Oq�¦u�sb¡ vwM-O p � p Õ �µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba¥se�Bv�M$Oh¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ�K � � ² ¬µWbPL�ws¥¤�a-s{©qa1Wb�^v�M$O���ILa$£bOnvh[\OQKnsb¡¥rVs���I�vwILsbar®·T� P�O`Weu�P�Y/´±vwM$O�On �KnI�OQa-K�Y se��v�M$O � ² � r$u�OQK�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu�[\OnrtOna-[-��sba vwM$O"v�M$O

r-WeuwvwI�vwILsba$ILa$£�se��vwM-O¯I�a-I§v�ILWbP�¡�W{vwu�I��)WeaV[�s/a>v�M$O¯¡�We£/a$I�vwg-[\O*sb�8v�M$O*seir�Ò[\ILWb£bs/a-WePOnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��xse�«vwM$O�OQP�OQ¡�OQa�v�Weu�Y!¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�nT¢|X�@vwM-O�[\OQKnsb¡¥rts/�wI§v�I�s/a1sb� � Im�n´-I�aJ£/Ona$OQu�WbP ´a$sev­g-a$IÊ·�g$O/´/[\I�ikOnu�Ona�v¬[\O`K�sb¡¥rts/�wI§v�I�s/a-�ª¡�WZY8�wIL£ba$I��VKnWba�vwPLY8W{ikOQK�v¢vwM-OxrVOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O@se�vwM$O�r$u�OQKnsba-[$I§v�I�s/a$Onu`Tþ'ð&ï ��]ó98��]ù��Oó%õeõeö�ø�÷ ù*úð¦ ø�û�õeõkó��TÐ�©�ó�Ç · ö�ø�ó2û��/ÖÒ�õ¸ý"ó��Bõl@M$O@O�ikOQK·v�I��/Ona$O`�w�«sb�-vwM-O^r-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$Onuª[\OQrVOQa-[$�ªKnuwg-KnILWbP�PLY�sba�vwM$Oqs{�/Onu�PLWbr��VOnvd©¬OQOnaOnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��QT U®WZY;[^]O�O�v�WePðT�¬ � ~b~b� 8 ®*��M-s{©Av�M-W{v�We¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwILa$£"OnPLOn¡¥Ona�vN���tO��¦s/uwOK�sbaV�dv�uwg-K�vwILa$£���g-KNM)W�r-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$OnuJKQWea�[$u�Wb¡¥WevwImKnWbP�PLY�I�¡¥r$u�s{�bO�vwM$O*�wrVOQOQ[)Wea-[a�g-¡�OQuwImKnWbP!�tOnM-WZ�;ILsbg$u¯sb�±vwM$O�¡�OnvwM$s\[BT l@M-O>We¡�WePL£/Wb¡�W{vwILsba r$u�s\K�OQ���°vdY;r$ImKnWbP�PLYuwO`[\g-K�O`�ªv�M$OXs{�/Onu�PLWbr¥�VOnvd©¬OQOna!OQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��Q´;Wba-[�I�v¬Im�¢v�M$Im�­v�M-W{v^P�O`Wb[$�­vws8I�¡¥r$u�s{�bOQ¡¥Ona�v��I�a±rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥Wba-K�O/T

�b�

Page 25: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

« g$u�r$u�Onr$u�s\K�OQ���wI�a$£ ��vwOQr Knsba-�wIm�dvN��se�"£bu�sbg$r-I�a$£ v�M$O�OnPLOn¡¥OQa/vN��ILa/v�sA�wO�v��Q´Wb����OQ¡��$PLI�a-£hv�M$O@OnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��Ê©qI�vwM-I�a¥OQW/KNM��wO�vªILa�vws�W;:=<C×?>�Ì=@A>�Ð�>CBD>CEtÎð´bWba-[�v�M$Ona�Wbr$r$PLY�ILa$£Wea � PLOn¡¥Ona�v��ð�;Yk� � P�OQ¡¥Ona�v¬v�OQKNM$a-IÊ·�g$O}v�s¥vwM$O��wg$rtOnu��ðOQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��@ILa-�dv�OQW/[1sb�%v�M$O�sbu�IL£bILa-WeP� ² T |hP§v�M$sbg$£/Mp´�W/�J©¬O*MVWZ�bO¯WePLu�OQWb[$Y>�wWbIL[p´�©¬O°�¦s\Kng-� s/a�v�M$O¯g-�wO¯sb�8v�M$O � ² �r$uwO`K�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQuQ´;¡¥s/��vxse�%vwM$O�Knsba-KnP�g-�wILsba-�qWbuwOXvwu�g$O}�¦sbu@v�M$O�sev�M$Onuqs/a$OQ�QT�dܯodÜ&J � Y�\]sq�r\]Yf\"N�VqQrM � sq�rQtPRV�N�a)Y¬Ü| �{Weu�I�OnvdY±se�­We¡�WbP�£�We¡�W{v�I�s/a1v�OQKNM$a-IÊ·�g$O`�hWeu�O8Knsba-�wIm[\Onu�OQ[±ILa�[\Onv�WeILP«��YJU®WZY\[¬]O�O�v�WePðT¬ � ~/~e� 8 ®�TG±hOnu�Ob´\©^O}sba$PLY1Knsba-�wIL[$Onu^vwM$O�¡¥s��dvx�wg-KnKnOQ���d�¦g$PSse�Sv�M$OQ�wObT³pO�vGF ² [$Ona$sbvwO¥Wea OQP�OQ¡�OQa�vQ´9H ² [\Ona-sevwO8vwM-O��wO�v}se�¢ILa-[\ImK�O`�Xsb�­�{Weu�ILWb�$PLOQ�xgV��O`[ �;Y

vwM$O�OQP�OQ¡¥Ona�vIF ² ´tWea-[KJ H ² J$[\Ona$sbvwO}v�M$O�KnWbu�[$I�a-WbPBse�LH ² T¬³pOnv)M �ON ¬ � ®^u�O��¦OQuqvws¥v�M$O�v�I�¡¥O��rtOna�v ¶I ILa W ¡¥Wevwu�I§�e�è�bO`K·vws/u,r$uws\[\gVK·v�se�¸sbuN[\OQu � �¦sbu�vwM$O4[\ImWe£/sba-WbP ¬µUXcd|x�4®

r$u�OQKnsba-[$I§v�I�s/a$Onu4¬µ��vwuNW{v�On£/Y \]Yf\]s&�%J ILaFl«We�-P�O��-T �¸®+J\sbuI ILaJW¥¡¥Wevwu�I§�e�è�bO`K·vws/u@r$uws\[\gVK·vXWba-[FI�a±vd©^s�vwu�ILWba$£bg$PmWeux�wsbPL�bO`�@se�ÊsbuN[\Onu � �¦sbuqv�M$O� ² � r$u�OQKnsba-[\I�vwILsba-Onu4¬µ��vwuNW{v�On£bY \]Yf\]s&�OW ILa±l«We�-P�O��$TÕ�5®�Tl@M$O�We¡�WePL£/Wb¡�W{vwILsba�r$uws\KnOQ���@©¬O}M-WZ�/OXg-�wOQ[±Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OQ�^vwM-O 8 >CEP>RQ*ÎS ¬RF ²´G F?T�® � M �UN ¬VJ H ² J ®��WM �ON ¬XJ HYTZJ ® � M �ON ¬XJ H ²?[ HYTZJ ® G ¬µ�-T �`� ®�¦sbu�WePLPªr-WbI�uN�®se�¬OQP�OQ¡¥Ona�v���Wba-[�We¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwO`�xv�M$O�r-WeILu}©qI§v�M�vwM$O�PmWeu�£bO`�dv}�VOQa$O��-v���sP�s/a$£�Wb�@I�vxIL�@PmWeu�£bOQu¬v�M-WeaJW�ÎR\¸ÌV>]:^\9ØRÐ�_}�{WePLg$ObT��O�a$sev�O�v�M-W{v�M �ON ¬ � ®qsba-P�Y [\OQrVOQa-[$�®sba � Wea-[�KnWea��VO�K�s/¡¥r$g\vwO`[ s/a-K�O�Wea-[ �¦sbu

WePLP T�l@M-OQ�wO�¡�W/KNM$I�a-O��Ò[\OnrtOna-[$Ona�v�K�s��dvN��Weu�O¥��vws/uwO`[�ILa �-PLOQ��Wba-[°[\O�v�Onu�¡�ILa$O`[�[$g$uwILa$£vwM$O�I�aV�dvNWePLPLWevwILsba sb�¢vwM$O¥�wse�¨vd©@Weu�ObThcè�¬©¬O¥Weu�O�sba-P�YJILa�vwOnu�OQ��vwO`[JILa�u�OQ[\g-KnI�a-£!vwM-O�v�I�¡¥OrVOQuªI§v�OnuNW{vwILsbaS´{vwM$Oq�tOQ��v¢�{WePLg$O^�¦sbuÊv�M$O@vwM$u�OQ�wM$s/PL[8©¬s/g$Pm[��tOq¶nOQuwsV´{�$g\v¢a$OQ£/W{v�I��/O@�ZWbP�g-OQ�©qI�PLP\uwO`��g-P§vÊI�a��¦g$uwvwM$OQuÊWb¡�WePL£/We¡�WevwILsba-�%Wea-[B´bM$Ona-KnOb´{rts/����IL�$PLY��VOnv�v�Onuªr$u�OQKnsba-[\I�vwILsba-OnuN�nT

þ'ð�Æ `±ÈI��ó��tö=�Oû³© ÿba*84ód�töV� ó%ø¦ý"õ��O�[$OQ��K�u�I��tOb´�ILa l«We�$PLO¯�$T � ´�Wî�wO�v sb�¥vwOQ��v�¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�±vwMVW{v�©qILP�P8�VO�g-��O`["I�a�s/g$uO��\rVOQuwIL¡¥Ona�v��QTRÔ>Im��vwM$OJs/u�[\OQu8sb�hv�M$OJ¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�Q´ < v�M$O±a�g-¡��tOnu�se�®OnPLOn¡¥Ona�vN�n´@Wea-[c v�M$O±K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a�a;g$¡8�VOQuQT¯l@M$OF¡�W{v�uwImK�O`��Knsb¡¥O�OQI§v�M$Onu��¦u�sb¡ v�M$O�±XWeu�©¬OQP�P��Ò²¬s;OQI�a$£K�sbPLPLOQK·v�I�s/ap´{��OQO^UXg\i�O�vªWePðTL´ � ~b~��H¬ �^� �}²@� µ � �5®·´`sbuÊWeu�O¢r$u�sb�-P�OQ¡¥�%ILa�f;cd�F�¦s/uw¡�W{v%�¦uws/¡vwM$O � xhl � K�sbPLPLOQK·v�I�s/ap´e�wOnO¬²^s/a$£/Wbu�v�¶b´ � sba$ap´b�®s/g$Pm[�WeaV[�lSs/I�a�v`´ � ~b~ � ¬ � ²@ox|ªl�x � U8´� « ²'�hU®l « o�´-Wba-[�� � l � ®·Tl@M$O�r-Wev�v�Onu�a�se� �^� �}²q� µ � �°WbuwIm�wOQ���¦u�sb¡ W���vwu�g-K�vwg$uNWePXOna$£/I�a$OQOnu�I�a-£¯r$u�sb�$PLOn¡±´

� « ²'�hU®l « o Im�¥W ·�g-W/[\uNW{vwImK1OnPmWb��vwImK!v�sbuN��ILsba¯r-uws/�$P�OQ¡AWeu�Im��ILa$£ �¦u�sb¡4Wba�s/�-�dvNWbKnP�Or$uws/�$PLOn¡ sba�W ��·�g-WbuwO/´ � � l � Im�)W��bOQuwY I�PLP��èKnsba-[\I�vwILsba-OQ[ On�\Wb¡¥r$P�O �¦uws/¡Ev�M$Osbr\v�I�¡¥IL¶QW{v�I�s/a°se�xW±M$IL£bM"�èr$u�OQ����g$u�O¥£/W/�}a$O�vd©^sbu�¤k´%WeaV[ � ²@ox|ªl�x � U IL��s/�\v�WbI�a-OQ[°�;Y[\IL��K�u�O�v�I�¶QI�a-£¥W¥Knsb¡¥r$PLO�� � U z­U � r$uws/�$PLOn¡ ILaJW�Kng$�$ImK}uwOQ£bILsbapT

� �

Page 26: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

H±ILa HJWe� HJOQWea UhOQ£bu�OnOz¢u�sb�$PLOn¡ Ô < OQP§v OnP�v OQP§v se� ca-We¡¥O ��IL¶nO �wI�¶QO �wIL¶nO s{�/Onu�PLWbr

� ²^oh|ªl�x � U � � ~e� � � ~e� � µ �;T � �;T � � w ��� �Q� (�^� �}²q� µ � � �e�/~e� �Q� µ �;� � � � µ T×� �\T � � w×�E� �Q�d� � l � �\� � �e�-� � � �\T � �\T×� �"w ��� �Q��e� « ²'�hU®l « o � µ � � ��� � � �-TÕ� �-T ~ � w µ � �Q� _

l«We�$PLO��$T �5¶ f;g$¡¥¡�Weu�Y!sb�SvwM-O�KNM-WeuNWbK�vwOnu�Im�dv�ILKQ�¬sb�%O`WbKNM1vwOQ��vxr$u�sb�$PLOn¡

« a$O�I�¡¥rtsbuwv�Wba/v�KNMVWeuNWbK·v�Onu�IL��vwImK�IL��vwM$O�[$On£bu�OnO�sb�qs{�bOnu�PmWerpT�cèv�Im��[$O��-a$O`[*Wb�}v�M$OWZ�bOnuNWe£/Oqa;g$¡��tOnu@se�%OnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��@�wM-Weu�ILa$£�O`WbKNM!�{Weu�ImWe�$PLOXWba-[!Im�@Wea�ILa-[\ImKnWevws/u@W/�¢v�s8M-s{©©¬OQP�P � P�OQ¡�OQa�v��è��Yk� � PLOn¡¥Ona�v@r$u�OQK�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu��^©qILP�PS�VOQM-WZ�bO/TcÒa&r$uNWbK�vwImK�Ob´¥©^O�gV��O�W)HJs;[$I��-O`[ � M-sbPLOQ�w¤�Y"�µW/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsba K�PLs/�wO�v�s>v�M$O�sba$O

[\OQ��K�u�I��tOQ["ILa f;O`K·v�I�s/a �-T � vws>£bg-Wbu�Wba/v�OnO°v�M-W{v�vwM$O�r$uwO`K�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu�� WbuwO�rVs���I�vwIL�bO[\O��-a-I§v�ObTUhOnv�WeILPLOQ[�uwO`��g-P§vN�}se�qWe¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwILsbaJ�¦s/u��{Weu�I�s/g-�®r$u�OQK�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu��}KQWea°�VO¥�¦s/g$a-[

I�a U®WZY;[^]O"O�v>WePðT ¬ � ~b~b� 8 ´ � ~/~ � ´�Wea-[ � ~b~b�k®·T l@M$O`��O"u�OQ�wg$P�v���ILa-[\ImKnWevwO"vwMVW{v� PLOn¡¥Ona�v��è�;Yk� � P�OQ¡�OQa�v�r$u�OQKnsba-[$I§v�I�s/a$OnuN�8WbuwO±OnitO`K·vwIL�bO±ILa6vwOnu�¡��¥se�XvwM$OJa;g$¡8�VOQu���se�I§v�OnuNW{vwILsbaV�*uwO�·�g$I�u�OQ[ WeaV[ vwM$O>KnP�gV�dv�Onu�I�a$£�sb�FOQI�£/Ona;�{WePLg$OQ�¯se�FvwM$Oîr-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$OQ[±xOQ���wILWbap´­r-Wbu�v�ILKng$PmWeu�P�Y°I��Xv�M$O±s{�bOnu�PmWer¯�tO�vd©^OnOQa��$PLs\KN¤\�¥IL�¥�w¡¥WbP�PðT�²¬g$vQ´^O��$K�OQr\v¥�¦sbuI�PLP��ÒK�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$O`[ r$u�sb�-P�OQ¡¥�Q´ � ² � IL�}a$sbv}�wIL£ba$I��VKnWba�vwPLYJ¡�s/uwO�O� !KnI�OQa/v®vwMVWea°[\ILWb£bs/a-WePr$uwO`K�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$ILa$£-T « a$O�u�OQWb�wsba Im�*�VO`KnWbg-��O�sb�1v�M$O>��vwu�g-K·v�g$u�O�se�±vwM$O�OQP�OQ¡¥Ona�v��QT��M$Ona�v�M$Onu�O Im��P�s{© s{�bOQuwPmWerS´ � ² � Wbr$rVO`WeuN�¥¡�g-KNM�¡¥s/uwO±O� !KnI�OQa/v�vwM-Wbaî[\ILWb£bs/a-WePr$uwO`K�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$ILa$£-Tq|h¡¥WbP�£�We¡�W{v�I�a-£�OnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��h¡�WZY1u�OQ[\gVK�O}vwM-O�a;g$¡��tOnuXse�ªI�vwOnuNW{v�I�s/a-���Y1[\OQKnuwO`Wb�wI�a$£8vwM-O�[\On£/uwOQO®sb�%s{�/Onu�PLWbr�ILa1v�M$O�a$OQ©>r-Wbu�v�I§v�I�s/apT��Oh�wM$s{©�´/I�a!l«We�$PLOh�-T �$´{vwM$OXO�ikOQK�v­se�pWe¡�WbP�£�We¡�W{v�I�a$£}OQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��ª�¦s/u­[\ImWe£/sba-WbP-Wea-[

� ² � r$u�OQKnsba-[$I§v�I�s/a$I�a-£X©qI�vwM¥Wxv�M$u�OQ�wM$sbPm[�O�·/gVWeP�vws � �¦sbuÊuwg-a-�«sba¥Wea±Xz°� �`� y{�e�VTpl@M$O��s/P�g\v�I�s/aFvwIL¡�O/´fMAgihAjd´VI�a-KnP�gV[\OQ�@v�M$O�v�I�¡¥O��¦s/uhK�s/¡�r-g\vwILa$£�v�M$O�r$u�OQK�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQuhWeaV[�v�M$OvwIL¡�O��¦sbuXI§v�OnuNW{vwILa$£�v�s�K�s/a;�bOnu�£bOQa-K�O/Tql@M$O�vwIL¡¥O��¦s/uXK�s/¡¥r$g\vwILa$£�vwM$O8r$uwO`K�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu��¬¦�tsevwM [\ILWb£bs/a-WeP�Wba-[ � ² � ®±IL��a$On£/P�IL£bIL�$PLO¯sba WbP�P�vwM$O�r$u�sb�$PLOn¡���¬µP�O`�w� vwM-Wba � T �b���O`K�sbaV[$��®XOn�\KnOnr\v�©qM-Ona°g-�wI�a$£ � ² � s/a � ²@ox|ªl�x � U Wba-[ � � � ²q� �/� �!©qM$Onu�O¥I§v�Im�Weu�sbg$a-[ � T � Wea-[ � T×�8��O`K�s/a-[$�^uwO`��rtOQK�vwIL�bOQP�Y/T³SWeu�£bO¥£�WeILa-��ILa¯O��\O`K�g\v�I�s/a°vwIL¡�OFWeu�O�sb�\vNWeILa$OQ[¯g-��ILa$£�Wb¡�WePL£/We¡�WevwILsba�©qM$Ona*v�M$O

OnPLOn¡¥Ona�v���Weu�O¯ILa$I�vwImWePLP�Y �w¡�WePLP8WeaV[�s{�bOQuwPmWer��wI�£/a$I��tKnWea�v�P�Y/TA��I�vwM Wb¡�WePL£/We¡�WevwILsbap´� ² � IL��¡¥s/uwO±O� !KnI�OQa/v�vwM-Wba�[$ILWb£bsbaVWePqr$u�OQKnsba-[\I�vwILsba-I�a$£*W/����s;sba�W/��vwM$O r-uws/�$P�OQ¡IL����g$ �KnI�OQa�vwPLY)MVWeuN["vws)��s/P��/ObTA�-sbu°[\ILWb£bs/a-WeP�r-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$ILa$£-´�vwM$O6£/WbI�a-� �¦uws/¡We¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwILsba�Weu�O@[$g$Oqvws}v�M$Oq�tO�v�v�Onu¬O��\OQKng\vwILsba¥uNW{vwO`�Ê©qM$Onu�OQW/�n´e�¦sbu � ² � ´ZvwM$Oq£�WeILa-�Weu�O}[$g$O}�VsbvwMFvws!W��tO�v�v�OnuxOn�\OQK�g$vwILsbaFu�WevwO�Wea-[±W¥�w¡¥WbP�PLOnuqa;g$¡8�VOQuqse�«I§v�OnuNW{vwILsbaV�nTl@M$O®Wb¡�WePL£/We¡�WevwILsba�r$u�s\K�OQ[$g$uwOXIL�@Kng$uwu�Ona�v�P�Y¥uNW{vwM-Onu@K�s/��vwPLYb´;�$g$v^I�vqIL�^M$s/rVO`[�vwMVW{v

£bs;s\[XM-Ong$u�IL��vwImKn�p©qI�PLP/[\O`K�u�OQW/��O«vwM-IL�Sr$uwOQr$u�s;KnOQ����ILa$£@K�s��dvS©qI�vwM�u�sbg-£bM$PLYqvwM-O­�wWb¡¥OªO�ikOQK·v`T

�{�

Page 27: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

k1lnm o�prq^m=s=tuq^v wYxYwy{z s=|}v�~i� k1�)q^v�m}� k1�)q^v�m}� � �Up��i~� p��*~ ~iv � �&����� ���U�A� ��� �&����� ���R�V� ���� x��9k{���1�=o �Z�"�Z� �]�=�^� �n� � �=� ��� � ��� � �=  ����¡ �}� ¢£�¤¥£�¦r§?¨ �}� � �^�] =  ����¡ �=� ��� � ¡A �� � �=� ��� ¢ ��� ¢£�¤¥£�¦r§Z© ª �   ¡A�=�=  ¡i�}�   �=� ��� ª ¡A���   �^� ��� ª �n� ¢� wY«¬x�� ª  =� �Z�"�Z� ¡A  ª � ª � � ¢=¢�¡ ��¡=� � ¡A¢�� � ¡A�=  ¡A��� ¢ ¡A��� �£�¤¥£�¦r§?¨  �� � ¡A  ª � ª � � ¢=¢�¡ ��¡=� � ¡A¢�� ¢ ¡A�=  ¡A¢��   ¡A����¡£�¤¥£�¦r§Z©  �� � ¡A =¢ �=��� � ¢=¢=  ��¡=� � ¡A¢�� � ¡=¡=¡ ¡i�}� ¢ ¡A��� �­ wP��� �Z�"�Z� �=� ª ��� ¢ ¡A�=�=� ��� � �}� � �^�=� ª � � ¡=� �£�¤¥£�¦r§?¨  ���¡ ¡i�]� ��� ¢ ¡A� ª   ��� � ª � ª �=¢ ª ¡=� � �}� �£�¤¥£�¦r§Z©  �� � �]� ¡=¡=��¡ ¡A¢=¢ ª ��� � ¡A��� � ��¡A¢ ¡=�   ª � �­�® x ­ o�� ® � �Z�"�Z� �=¢=� �}� � ¢ ª  �� � �n� � �=   �� � ���  £�¤¥£�¦r§?¨  �� � ¡A ]� ¡=¡=� � ¢ ª  �� � ¡A��� � �=¢  �� � ª � �£�¤¥£�¦r§Z©  �� � �]� ¡V�n� � ¢ ª  �� � ¡A��� � �=�  �� � ��� ªl%Wb�$P�O �-T � ¶ � sb¡¥r-WbuwIm�wsba sb� UXcd|x� WeaV[ � ² � r$u�OQKnsba-[\I�vwILsba-OnuN�A©qI�vwM$s/g\vWe¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwILsbaJWeaV[ ©qI�vwM�Wb¡¥WbP�£�We¡�W{v�I�s/a �dv�u�WevwOQ£bILOQ� \tYf\]sq�)J Wba-[ \]Y�\]sq��W sba ±hz� �`� y{�b�-TJ|x¡�WePL£-T vwIL¡�OFIm��v�M$O!v�I�¡¥O!�¦s/u8rtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥I�a-£JvwM$OF��Y;¡8�Vs/P�ImK!We¡�WbP�£�We¡�W{v�I�s/ar$P�gV�­v�M$Oha;g$¡¥OQuwImKnWbPtW/�w�wOn¡8�$P�Y�se�SvwM$O®��g$rtOnu��èOnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��QT < Im�¢v�M$O®a�g-¡��tOnu^se�SOQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��Wea-[±HJ�¯Im�@v�M$O�rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O®O��\r$u�OQ����O`[�ILa HFº-s/r-�nT

|h�®©¬O�¡�WZY±M-WZ�bO�v�sF�wsbPL�bO8¡�Wea;YJ��Y\��vwOn¡��®©qI�vwM v�M$O¥�wWb¡�O¥��vwu�g-K·v�g$uwO8I�a�vwM$O�Knsbg$uN��Ose�8W�a$sba$PLILa$OQWbu1s/r\vwIL¡¥I�¶`W{vwILsba)KnWbPLKng$PLWevwILsbap´XW�£/s�s\[�r-uwOQr$uws\KnOQ����ILa$£���vwOQr>¡�WZY�r-WZYM-Wea-[-��s/¡�O�[\IL�;IL[$Ona-[$�xI�aFvwM-O�P�s/a$£8u�g$apT�dÜÊ��Ü&J ��n�bjQr_ � Z�\"PRn�b � N�Q;P,\t�;b Ü��M$Ona°g-�wI�a-£±�wg-KNM°Wea°WePL£bs/uwI�vwM$¡±´kv�M$O!��g-rVOQu��èOnPLOn¡¥Ona�vN��Weu�O���vws/uwO`[�W/�h�¦g-P�P¢¡�Wevwu�ILKnOQ�Wea-[�vwM;g-�ª�wsb¡¥O@¶nOQuws��%¡�WZY��tOqO��\r$PLILKnI§v�P�Y8�dv�sbu�OQ[BT«l@M$Oq[\Ona-�wI�vdY�se�tvwM$Oq�wg$rtOnu��ðOQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��[\OnrtOna-[-�­s/a�vwM$O®�dv�uwgVK·vwg-uwOxsb�kvwM$OXI�a$I�vwImWePtOnPLOn¡¥OQa/vN�¬Wba-[B´��VO`KnWbg-��Ohse�BvwM-OX[\OQrVOQa-[\OnaVK�Ose�-v�M$OqWe¡�WePL£/Wb¡�W{vwILsba�sba¯M �ON ¬³w ®·´�WePm��sXsba8vwM$O^v�Wbuw£/O�vªK�s/¡�r-g\vwOQuQT«�$sbuªOn�$We¡¥r$PLOb´{sba¥Wea|h³S³Scd|=�Xl�� ² y µ � �bOQK�vws/u­K�s/¡�r-g\vwOQu­g-�wI�a-£�W}vwM-uwO`��M$s/PL[¥O�·�g-WeP-vws�¶QOnu�s-´b©^OqvdY;r$ImKnWbP�PLYsb�\vNWeILa!OnPLOn¡¥Ona�vN�­©qI�vwM�W8[\OnaV��I�vdY�Weu�sbg$a-[ � T � ´/©qM-ILKNM!Im�?·/g-I§v�OhPmWeu�£bOq�¦s/u¢vwM-OXOQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��vws��VOFvwu�OQWevwO`[¯Wb�¥�wr-WeuN��O/T « a�oqc�f � WeuNKNM$I§v�OQK�vwg$u�OQ�Q´ÊvwM$OJ[\OQa-�wI§vdY*sb�xvwM$O±OQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��sb�\vNWeILa$OQ[1KnWeaF�tO®PmWeu�£bOQuQ´;�wI�a-KnOhv�M$O�We¡�WePL£/Wb¡�W{vwILsba�r$uws\KnOQ���­Im�q�dv�sbr$rtOQ[1OQWbuwPLILOnuH¬¦PLsba$£�bOQK�vws/u��}Weu�O�a$sev�u�O�·�g$ILuwO`[ �¦s/u}O� !K�ILOna-KnY�W/�}sba°W1�/OQK�vwsbu}r$u�s\K�O`�w�wsbu#®·T�±xs{©^On�/Onu`´B©¬OM-WZ�bO¥��g-£b£bO`�dv�OQ[ vwM-Wev�Knsba�vwILa;g$OQ[�We¡�WbP�£�We¡�W{v�I�s/a IL�}sb�¨vwOQa��tOna$O��VK�ImWeP¢vws1vwM$O�·�g-WbP�I�vdYse�tvwM$Oxr-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$Onu`´/Wba-[8vwM$Im�¢u�OQ�wg$P�v��ªILa�W}uwO`[\g-K�vwILsba�ILa8v�M$Oh[\OQa-�wI§vdY�se�tvwM$OX��g$rtOnu��OnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��QT�l@M;g-�®I�v}¡�WZY±©^OnPLP«�tO�Wb[\�{Wba/vNWe£/OnsbgV�qvwsFg-�wO�WF�wr-WeuN��O8uwOQr$u�OQ�wOna�v�WevwILsbaJse�vwM$O��wg$rtOnu��ðOQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��QT«��O�[\O��-a$O}vwM-O�WZ�bOnuNWe£/OX[\OQa-�wI§vdY�v�s��VO}v�M$O�uNW{vwILs

��� # � ²��°( Ô9° ²# � ²��°(�± _² G ¬µ�-T �/� ®

� �

Page 28: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

©qM$Onu�O < Im�¥vwM$O�a�g-¡��tOnu�sb�®OQP�OQ¡¥Ona�v��Q´�Ô9° ² IL�!vwM$O a;g$¡8�VOQu!se��a$s/a$¶nOQuws°OQa/v�uwILOQ�!I�aOnPLOn¡¥Ona�v � ´$Wea-[ ± ² Im�^vwM$O�a;g$¡8�VOQuxse�«�ZWbuwImWe�-P�O`�¬ILaFvwM$O�OQP�OQ¡¥Ona�v � TcÒa�l«We�$PLO*�$T � ´h©^O*��M-s{© vwM$O*Knsba-��vwu�g-K·v�I�s/aîv�I�¡¥O*Wea-[>vwM-O�v�I�¡¥O*�wrVOQa/vJILa>v�M$O

��s/P��/OQ�Fse�8vwM$O � ² � r$u�OQKnsba-[\I�vwILsba-OnuFg-��ILa$£��tsevwM)�¦g$PLP�Wba-[��wr-Wbu��wO���vws/u�Wb£bO�se��v�M$O��g$rtOnu��èOnPLOn¡¥Ona�v����¦sbu1vwM-O�v�OQ��vFr-uws/�$P�OQ¡�� � l � T�|h�F¡�W{vwu�I��k�è�bO`K·v�sbu!r$u�s\[\g-K�v��±Wea-[[\sev��ðr$u�s\[\g-K�v���Weu�O±rVOQu��¦s/uw¡¥O`[�ILa6vwM$O ��We¡¥O±©^WZY*ILa��VsbvwM�KnW/��O`�¥²#g-�wI�a$£°v�M$O±�¦g$PLPI�a$I�vwImWeP®OnPLOn¡¥OQa/vN�n´xvwM$O°K�s/a-�dv�uwgVK·vwILsba�v�I�¡¥O�Wea-[�v�M$O v�I�¡¥O°��rtOna�vFI�a�v�M$O°��s/P��/OQ�!WbuwOvwM$O�¡¥sbu�O�¡�O`Wea$ILa$£b�¦g$Pªr-WeuNWe¡¥OnvwOnuN�XvwsJK�s/¡¥r-Weu�ObT8��M$Ona°g-�wI�a-£±�wr-Wbu��wO���vws/u�Wb£bO/´Vv�M$O�µWbK·v�sbu�I�¶`W{v�I�s/a�sb�Xv�M$OJ��I�a-£bO�vF[\OQKnsb¡¥rVs���I�vwILsba6se��O`WbKNM���g$rtOnu��èOnPLOn¡¥Ona�v!Im��sb�\vNWeILa$OQ[g-��ILa$£�vwM$O}��rVWeuN��Ox�wY;¡�¡¥Onvwu�ILKX��s/P��/OnuÃï9ñ?³µ´ ¬ Uhg$iJWba-[!oqOQIL[p´ � ~ µ � ®«�¦u�sb¡ vwM-O�±hWbuw©^OnPLPf;g$�$u�sbg\v�I�a-O8³pIL�$uNWeu�YbT@��O8K�s/¡¥r-Weu�O}vd©¬s1[\I§ikOnu�Ona�v®sbuN[\Onu�I�a-£/�@�¦s/uxvwM-O�OnPLIL¡�ILa-WevwILsbaJse�vwM$O±�{Weu�ILWb�$PLOQ� ¶ vwM-OJ¡�ILa$IL¡�g$¡ [\On£/uwOQO1s/u�[\OQuwILa$£�Wea-[�vwM$O±a-Wevwg$uNWeP@s/u�[\OQuwILa$£�se�hv�M$OOnPLOn¡¥Ona�v��QT � �$K�Onr$v®�¦s/u}�bOnu�Y �w¡¥WbP�PªWba-[ �¦g-P�PªOQP�OQ¡�OQa�v�Weu�YJ¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�n´BI�v�Wer$rtOQWbu��XvwMVW{v¡�ILa$IL¡�g$¡ [\On£/uwOQO}IL�qWbP�©@WZY\�¬�tO�vwvwOQuQT

o�~it}�R~L� � s z q^m=~ ¶n·uq z �U~L� � s z q^m=~� p�tZ�f¸}~im}� ­ q � �fs z ¸"�­ | k�l�m k�l�m � � s=t}�V� �9p��*~ � � s=t}�A� �9p��*~ � s=t}�A� ��p��*~�9¹ z ~i�U¹"� ~iv � �Rp��A~ ¸}~it}�V� p � � � p��*~ �Us=v l]~ p � � � p��*~ �Us=v l]~ � p��*~ �Rs=v l]~ ��  �¡ �]¢=� ��� � ¡=�  =  ¢ ª �  ��  �¡ ��� � ª ¢]�^�  ���¡i� ¢�� �]�  ���¡A� ¢�� �]� ��   ¡A ^� �n�    �� ��¡ �^�]�  ��  =�  �� �^¢ �=��¡  ��  ]� ¡=� �=�  ��  =¢ ¡=� �=�º  ��  = = = ^� �=� ¡=¡=� �  �� �^� ¡ ª �  ��  =�  �� �^� ¡ ª �  ��  ]�  �� ª �  ��  =� ¡=�  =�º  ��  = = �¡A� �=� ¡A����¡  �� �=¢ ¡i�]�  ��  =�  �� ¢=� ¡A� ª  ��  =¢  �� ¢=�  ��  =¢  �� �^�º  ��  = = =� �=� ¡A��� ¢  ���¡A� ¡A�=�  ��  =�  �� ¢=� ¡A�=�  ��  =¢  �� �^�  ��  ]�  �� �^¢º  ��  = �¡ ¡A� � ª � �  ���¡=¡ ª �  ��  ^�  �� �n¡ ª �  ��  =¢  �� �=¢  ��   ª  �� ¢^�º  ��  = ^� ¡A� �] �� �  ��  =¢ �]�  ��  ]�  �� ª � � ª  ��  =¢  �� �=�  ���¡A¢  �� ¢=�º  ��  =� � �]�n� ¢  ��  =� ¡V�  �� �=�  �� ¢=� ¡A¢  ��  =¢  ��   ª  �� �=�  �� �}¡º ¡A = = ��   ª ¢^�}�    ��  �¡ ¡  �� ¢=¢  ���¡i� ¡  ��  ]�  ��  =� ��� �=�  ��  =¢l%Wb�$P�O¯�-T �t¶ oqOQ�wg$P�v��Jsb�¥Wb¡�WePL£/We¡�WevwILsba)sb�\vNWeILa$OQ[>�¦sbuJv�M$O¯r$u�sb�-P�OQ¡ � � l � g-��ILa$£[\I§ikOnu�Ona�v¬vwM$u�OQ�wM$sbPm[$�ªs/a!W8f\zB|Xo � � �`� ©¬s/uw¤\��v�W{v�I�s/a8gV��ILa$£��¦g$PLPkWea-[!�wr-Wbu��wOq¤bOQuwa$OQPL�¢I�avwM$O}v�M$O}�µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a-�@Wea-[�vwu�ImWea$£/g$PLWbuq��s/P��/OQ�QT

l@M$OJ��r-Wbu��wO±�dv�sbuNWe£bO1�VO`K�s/¡�O`�¥¡¥sbu�OFOn !K�ILOna�v¥vwM-Wba��¦g-P�Ph��vws/u�Wb£bO��¦sbu¥vwM-uwO`��M$s/PL[�ZWbP�g-OQ�@��¡�WbP�PLOnu¬vwM-Wba�� � T �b�/�$� �$´b©qM$ImKNM1Knsbu�uwO`��rtsbaV[$�ªv�s�W�[\OnaV��I�vdY!��¡�WbP�PLOnu¬vwM-Wba � T �b�$Tl@M$IL�¢IL�ªO`��rtOQKnILWbP�PLY�v�uwg-O@�¦sbuÊvwM-Oqvwu�ILWba$£bg-PLWbuÊ�wY\�dv�On¡��Ê�¦s/uª©qM$ILKNM�v�M$Onu�OqIL�¢P�O`�w�ªs{�/Onu�M$OQW/[g-��ILa$£��wr-WeuN��O}��vwsbuNWe£/Ohv�M-WeaF�¦s/u@vwM$O}�µW/K·vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsbapTcè�&©¬O K�s/a-�wIL[\OQu W �bO`K·v�sbu,K�sb¡¥r$g$vwOnu`´¸��g-KNM Wb� vwM-O |X³S³pcd|��hl � ² y µ � ´

We¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwILsba6IL��g-�wO��¦g$P®©qI§v�M��¦g$PLP®�wg$rtOnu��ðOQP�OQ¡�OQa�v1�dv�sbuNWe£/ObT�²^g\v±We£�WeILap´^vwM$OQuwOJIm�W��wI�£/a$I��tKnWea�v@s{�bOQuwM$O`Wb[�ILa�g-�wI�a-£��wr-WeuN�wOxOnPLOn¡¥Ona�vN�^�wILa-K�OXvwM$O®a;g$¡��tOnu@sb�SI§v�OnuNW{v�I�s/a-�¢Im�I�a$I�vwImWePLPLY���¡�WbP�P¢Wba-[�a-sev���IL£ba-I��VKQWea�vwPLY u�OQ[\gVK�OQ[��;Y�We¡�WePL£/Wb¡�W{vwILsbaS´pWea-[��VO`KnWbg-��O�se�vwM$O�PmWeu�£bO}We¡¥sbg-a/vqsb�)�-PLP��ðILaJ[\g$u�I�a$£�v�M$O}�µWbK�vwsbu�IL¶QW{v�I�s/a-�QT«l@M$OQuwOn�¦sbu�Ob´;ILa1v�M$Im�xKnW/��O/´\©¬Or$uwOn�¦Onu@v�s�g-��O}PLsba$£¥�/OQK·v�sbuN�^u�WevwM$OQu¬v�M-WeaJ�wr-WeuN�wOXOQP�OQ¡�OQa�v��QT��M$OnaF��s/P��;ILa$£�W8©^OnPLPkKnsba-[$I§v�I�s/a$OQ[�r$uws/�$PLOn¡±´\��r-Wbu��wOhOQP�OQ¡¥Ona�v��@[\s�a$sevqWer-rVO`Weu¬vws

�VO®�bOQuwY¥g-�wO��¦g$PðTª�$s/u@Wba!ILP�P��èKnsba-[$I§v�I�s/a$OQ[�r-uws/�$P�OQ¡±´;Wb¡�WePL£/We¡�WevwILsba�se�¨v�Ona1uwO`[\g-K�O`�¢v�M$O

�e�

Page 29: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

a�g-¡��tOnu�sb�@I�vwOQu�WevwILsba-�QTFf\r-WeuN��O�OQP�OQ¡¥Ona�v��8KnWea�v�M$Ona*�tO!O�ikOQK�vwIL�bO!r-uws{�;Im[\OQ[°W±PLsev�se�We¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwILsba�s\KnKng$uN�nT«��O®�tOnPLI�OQ�bOXvwM-Wev¬v�M$OX¡�WbI�a!gV��O®se�S�wr-WeuN�wOX�wg$rVOQu��èOnPLOn¡¥OQa/vN�¢Im�I�a1vwM$s���O®PmWeu�£bOX��KnWbP�O®ILP�P��èKnsba-[$I§v�I�s/a$OQ[�r$uws/�$PLOn¡��¬�¦sbu@©qM$ImKNMF[\ILu�OQK·v^�µWbK�vws/uwIL¶QWevwILsba�£/I��/OQ�uwIm��O®v�s8v�s;s�¡�g-KNM��-PLP��èI�aST� PLOn¡¥Ona�v��è�;Yk� � P�OQ¡�OQa�v}r-uwO`K�sbaV[\I§v�I�s/a$OnuN�}¡�WZY��tO!O��;v�uwOQ¡�OQP�Y�O�ikOQK�vwIL�bO¥�¦s/u8�wr-WeuN��O

�dv�uwg-K�vwg$u�OQ[¥�wY\�dv�On¡��ªse�kPLI�a$O`Weu¢O�·�g-W{v�I�s/a-�ÊvwMVW{v­Weu�Im��OqILa¥r-WeuwvwImWeP-[$I§ikOnu�Ona�vwImWeP-O�·�g-W{v�I�s/a-�Wea-[1r-WeuwvwImWePLPLY!��OQr-WeuNWe�$PLOha-sba$PLI�a-OQWeuqs/r\vwIL¡¥I�¶`W{v�I�s/a1Wer-r$P�ImKnWevwILsba-�QTª�$g$uwvwM-Onu�¡�s/uwO/´�vwM$OQY��OQOn¡�vwsqseikOnuS£bu�OQW{vprts/���wI��$ILPLI§v�I�O`�Bse�\�bO`K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsbakyZr-Wbu�WbP�PLOnPLI�¶`W{v�I�s/axsba}¡�g-P§v�I�r$u�s\K�O`�w�wsbuWeuNKNM$I§v�OQK�vwg$u�OQ�QT>l@M$OQY6WbPL�ws*WePLP�s{© �¦sbu�v�M$O g-�wO se�}O� !KnI�OQa/vFK�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-WePh¤bOnu�a$OQPL���g-KNM Wb��v�M$O ²@³%|Xf Wba-[ �$PLs\KN¤bOQ[ �µW/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsbaV�nT ��O �tOnPLILOn�bO vwM-Wev>�¦g$uwvwM$OQuO��\rVOQuwIL¡¥Ona�v�WevwILsba°Im��a$OQKnOQ���wWbuwY±v�s Wb����O`�w�®v�M$O¥�¦g$PLP­rtsev�Ona�vwImWeP¢sb�¬v�M$O!¡¥O�v�M$s\[$�QT�l@M$OWe¡�WePL£/Wb¡¥WevwILsba vwO`KNM$a$I¯·/g-O>KnWba¸WbPL�ws��tO>Wer$r-P�ILOQ[ v�s sev�M$Onu � P�OQ¡¥Ona�v��è�;Y¸� � PLOn¡¥OQa/vr$uwO`K�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu��^sbu@v�s¥�$P�s\KN¤!¡¥OnvwM$s\[$�QT

» ã ¿jF Æ »�¼ ¥vIGFåä æìè Æ

Uhs\[$�wsbap´@�®uwIL¡¥OQ��Wba-[�³SOn©qIm�j¬ � ~/~ � ®�r$u�sbrts/�wOQ[�W��wr-WeuN�wO1On��v�Ona-�wILsba�sb�hv�M$OJ²^³%|Xf��s/¡�O�YbOQWbu��8We£/s-´«�$g\v�vwM$Im��s/a$PLY°Knsba-�wIm[\Onu�OQ[�v�M$O1³SOn�bOQP � ²^³%|Xf��¦s/u��/OQK·v�sbu��ð�/OQK�vwsbusbrtOnuNW{vwILsbaV�n´Z��gVKNM�Wb�%Wh�wr-WeuN��O­f$| ² z*{8TZcÒa�¤/OnOnr-I�a$£h©qI§v�M�vwM-O¢vwM-On¡¥O­sb�\vwM$Im�«r-WertOnu`´Z©¬O[\s}a$sev¢[\Im�wKng-���«vwM$O`��O@¤bOQuwa-OnPm�ÊM$Onu�O¬�-g\v­K�s/a-K�OQa/v�u�WevwO^I�aV�dv�OQWb[8sba�r$u�sbrts/��WePm�%�¦sbu¢�wr-WeuN��OO��;vwOQa-��ILsbaV��vws*M$IL£bM$OQu�P�OQ�bOQPx²^³%|Xf¯vwM-Wev!seikOnu�v�M$OJr$u�sb¡¥Im��OFse�}r$u�s{��Im[\ILa$£�O� !K�ILOna�v�$g$ILPL[\ILa$£��$PLs\KN¤\�@I�aJW¥��IL¡¥I�PmWeu@�µW/��M-I�s/a�v�s8v�M$O}�¦g$PLPp¤bOQuwa-OnPm�q[\IL��K�gV�w�wOQ[1OQWbuwPLI�OQuQTcèv�Im��I�¡¥rtsbuwv�Wea�v�vws°�dv�uwO`�w��W{v�vwM-O1s/g\v��wO�v�vwM-Wev!��g-KNM�¤bOQuwa$OQPL��Weu�O�a-sev�[\OQ�wI�£/a$OQ[

�¦sbu®g-��O8©qI§v�M$ILa��wr-WeuN�wO�[\ILuwO`K·v®Kns\[\OQ�QTXcÒaV[\OnO`[ I�v®Im���Vuw¡¥PLYJsbg$u®�VOQP�ILO��­vwM-WevXv�M$O8¡¥s��dvO� !K�ILOna�v�©^WZY±v�sJ[\OQ�wI�£/a��wr-Wbu��wO�[$I�u�OQK�v�Kns\[\OQ�}Im�®vws±u�On¡¥s{�bO¥WePLPªI�aV[\I�u�OQK�v�Wb[$[\u�OQ���wI�a$£�¦uws/¡ vwM$O�ILa$a$OQuw¡¥s/��v°P�s;sbr¸WeaV[�vws"g-�wO6�¦g$PLP!²^³%|Xf �¦sbu°v�M$O�WbK·v�g-WeP¥OQP�IL¡¥I�a-WevwILsbasbrtOnuNW{vwILsbaV�­Wb�­©¬OhI�a-[$ILKQW{vwO`[�ILaFf;O`K·vwILsba � TÊcÒa-�dv�OQW/[B´/©^OhOQa;��Im��We£bO@v�M$Oh¡¥s��dv@K�sb¡¥¡¥sbag-��Ohse�kvwM$OX��r-Wbu��wOx²@³S|®f�¤bOnu�a$OQPL�ªILa¥vwM-OxI§v�OnuNW{v�I��/Oh��s/P�g$vwILsba¥se�p�wr-WeuN��OqO�·�g-W{v�I�s/a-�n´�Wea-[©¬O}ILP�PLg-��vwuNW{vwO��wg-KNM±g-�wO®ILa f;OQK�vwILsba��;TÕ�\T¼ ð�ñ òôó^Ñ�ø�ö<ý]ö³ù¦ø ù*úz½8�û°�;õ¸ó ¶y·E¸±��O Knsba-KnOna�vwuNW{v�OFM-Onu�OJsba6vwM$O ��n�b¸P ³pOQ�bOnPX[\O��-a-I§v�I�s/a6sb�Xv�M$O M$IL£bM-Onu�PLOn�bOQPh�wr-WeuN��O²^³%|Xf�Wb��[$O��-a$O`[¯�;Y*Uhg$i«´@HJWeu�uws/a$Ob´ÊoxW/[\ILKQW{v�I^Wba-[f}XI§vwvwsbPLI4¬ � ~b~ � ®·T�l@M-OFW/K·vwgVWePI�¡¥r$PLOn¡¥Ona�vNW{vwILsba"�¦s/u�W�r-Wbu�v�ILKng$PmWeu�[$Wev�W���vwu�g-K·v�g$u�O¯sba�W�r-Wbu�v�ILKng$PmWeu�Wbu�KNM$I�vwO`K·v�g$uwO©¬s/g$PL[ �VO8rVOQu��¦s/uw¡¥OQ[ g-��ILa$£�v�M$O�P�s{©^OnuxPLOn�/OnP%vws;sbPL¤;I§v}K�s\[\O`�hsb� � Weu�a$OnY/´;±xOQuws/g\� Wea-[³pIv¬ � ~b~ � ®�Tl@M$O¢r$u�sbrts/��WePesb�$Uhg\i�Onv%WePðT¸¬ � ~b~ � ®B[$O��-a$O`�S��v�Wba-[$WeuN[®I�a�v�Onuw�µWbK�O`�B�¦s/upvwM-Oª�¦sbPLP�s{©qILa$£

�¦g$a-K·v�I�s/a-� ¶¬ � ®^W8u�sbg$vwILa$O}�¦sbuqrtOnuw�¦sbu�¡¥I�a$£�v�M$O�r$u�s;[$g-K·vqse�ªW¥��rVWeuN��O}Wea-[FW�[\OQa-��O}¡�W{v�uwI��B´¬ �¸®�WJu�sbg\v�I�a-O��¦sbu¥��s/P��;ILa$£ W �wr-WeuN�wO�g$r$rtOnu�sbu�PLs{©^Onu�v�uwImWea$£/g$PmWeu��wY;��vwOQ¡ se�qP�ILa$O`Weu

O�·/gVW{vwILsbaV�­�¦s/uxW¥¡�W{vwu�I���se�«uwIL£bM�v��èM-Wba-[1�wIm[\OQ�Q´

�/�

Page 30: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

¬ � ®@W�uws/g\vwILa$O}vws!KNM-OQKN¤�v�M$O�ILa$r$g\vh[$Wev�W-´\vws¥v�u�Wba-�d�¦s/uw¡ �¦uws/¡ sba-O}�wr-Wbu��wO®�¦sbu�¡¥WevqvwsWba$sev�M$Onu`´\Wea-[1vws���KnWbP�O�W¥��rVWeuN��O®¡�W{vwu�I��k´VWea-[

¬¦�e®�W*u�sbg\v�I�a-OJvws¯rtOnu�¡�g$vwOJv�M$O�KnsbPLg$¡¥a-�!sb��W���r-Wbu��wOJ¡�W{v�uwI���Wba-[�W*u�sbg\v�I�a-OJvwsrtOnu�¡�g\v�O®vwM$O�u�s{©x�^se�ªW��¦g-P�Pp¡�Wevwu�I§�BT

��O®a$sev�Ohv�M-W{v4¬ � ®­Wba-[�¬ð�5®¬[\O��Va$O®Wba�On��v�Ona-�wILsba!sb�pvwM$O�³SOn�bOQP � ²@³S|XfB´\�$g\v^vwM$OQYI�a-KnP�gV[\O@sbrtOnuNW{vwILsbaV�%s/a��/OQK·v�sbuN�%W/�ÊWhv�uwIL�;ILWbP\��g$�V��OnvQTÊl@M$OQ�wO¬¡�WZY��tOqK�s\[\OQ[��wOnr-Wbu�WevwOnPLYW{vqvwM-O®¡�W/KNM$I�a-O�[\OnrtOna-[$Ona�vxP�OQ�bOQP Tl@M$O¬[$Wev�Wqr-uwOQr$uws\KnOQ����ILa$£qu�sbg\v�I�a$O�¬ � ®BIm�SO`�w�wOna�vwImWePbvwshvwM$Im�«r$uws/rVs��wWbP TScèv%Im�SILa�vwOnaV[\OQ[

vwM-Wev®v�M$Im�Xu�sbg$vwILa$O8�tO�KnWbP�PLOQ[��VOn�¦sbu�O�v�M$O8�ts\[\Y sb�¢vwM$O�Knsb¡¥r$g\vNW{vwILsbaST�l@M$O�I�a�vwOQu��µW/K�OIL�^[\OQ�wIL£ba$O`[�vws�WbKQK�Onr$v¬¡�Wea;Y�[\I�itOQuwOQa/vq[$Wev�W��¦s/uw¡�Wev��­Wba-[!r-uws\[\g-KnOh¡�Wea;Y¥sev�M$OnuN�QT%cÒar-WeuwvwImK�g$PmWeu`´«I§v¥KnWea*ILa�vwOQuwu�sb£�W{vwO�v�M$O�¡�WbKNM-I�a$O�I�v8Im�8uwg$a-a$I�a-£ sba¯Wba-[�vwuNWea-���¦sbu�¡�v�M$O[$W{vNW8ILa�vws�W��¦sbu�¡�W{v@vwMVW{vxIm�@r-WeuwvwImK�g$PmWeu�PLY!��g$I�vwO`[1�¦sbu@vwMVW{vx¡�WbKNM$ILa$O/THJWea;Y�WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡��}uwO�·�g$I�u�O�vwM$O�rVOQuw¡8g\v�WevwILsba*se�@¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�nT±|h[$[$I§v�I�s/a-WePLP�Y/´«�wsb¡¥O

O� !K�ILOna�vhIL¡¥r$P�OQ¡¥Ona�v�WevwILsba-�hse�­�wr-WeuN��O�¡�Wevwu�I§�e�è�bOQK�vws/uqr$uws\[\gVK·v��Q´VWba-[±se�Êv�M$O8�wsbPLg\vwILsbase�p��rVWeuN��O@v�uwImWea$£/g$PmWeu­�wY\�dv�On¡��¢s/a��bOQK�vws/u¢sbu¬r-WeuNWePLP�OQP$r$u�s\K�OQ���wsbuN�n´eu�O�·�g$ILu�O@vwM$OX�bOQK�vws/u��vws±�VO�u�Ons/u�[$Onu�OQ[BT8cè�¬M$IL£bM�O� !K�ILOnaVK�Y Im��u�O�·�g$ILuwO`[B´BI§v�Im�}a$O`K�OQ����Weu�Y1v�sJWZ�bsbIm[ On�\r$P�ImK�I�v�bOQK�vws/uhrtOnu�¡�g\vNW{vwILsbaV�xILa vwM-O�ILa$a$Onu®PLs�s/r-�®Wea-[B´tv�s�OnaVWe�$PLO�vwM-IL�Q´kuws/g\vwILa$OQ�XM-WZ�/O��VOQOnaWb[$[\O`[`¬¦�e®¥v�s�rtOnu�¡�g\v�O��wr-WeuN�wO ¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�1Wea-[��¦g$P�P}¡�W{v�uwImK�O`��Wbr$r$u�sbr$u�ILWevwOQP�Y/T&l@M$OrVOQuw¡8g\v�WevwILsba!u�sbg\v�I�a-OQ�^KnWea1WePm��s��tO}KnWePLPLOQ[�s/g\v��wIL[$OxvwM-Oh�ts;[$Y�se�BvwM-O®Knsb¡¥r$g\vNW{vwILsba�I�asbuN[\Onu}v�sJI�a-KnuwO`Wb�wO¥O� !K�ILOna-KnY��;Y�WZ�/sbIm[\ILa$£±rVOQuw¡8g\v�WevwILsba-��©qI�vwM-I�a°v�M$O�¡�WeILa*P�s;sbr�se�vwM$O�WbP�£/sbu�I§v�M$¡±TÊl@M-IL�^�µW/K�ILP�I�vdY�Im�q[\Im�wKng-�w�wOQ[1¡¥sbu�O}��Y1Uhg\i�O�vhWbP T2¬ � ~b~ � ®�T|xP�vwM$s/g$£bM±v�M$O8u�sbg$vwILa$OQ�hI�a�¬ � ®hWea-[[¬µ�k®xWbuwO8Wea ILa�vwOn£/u�WbPSWeaV[JI�¡¥rtsbuwv�Wba/vXr-Weuwvhse�

vwM$O¬r$uws/rVs��wWbP ´Z©^O¢©qILP�P�M$Onu�O¬Knsba"�Va$O­s/g$u��wOnPL�bO`�kvws®W@�¦g$uwvwM$OQu«[$IL��K�g-���wI�s/a�se�\v�M$O­u�sbg\v�I�a-OQ�I�a[¬ � ®@Wea-[ ¬ �¸®·Tl@M$O�¡�WeILa Wb[$[$I§v�I�s/a-WePpIm����g$O��¦sbuqv�M$O��wr-WeuN��O�KQWb�wO�s{�bOQu@vwM$O�[\Ona-�wO�sba-O�P�ILOQ�hI�a±v�M$O

[$W{vNW��¦sbu�¡¥Wevqg-��O`[1�¦sbuqv�M$O�¡�W{vwu�ImK�OQ�QT¢cÒaFvwM-O���rVWeuN��O}KnW/��O/´\vwM$OQuwO�WbuwO}¡�Wea;Y�[$I§ikOnu�Ona�v�¦sbu�¡¥Wev���©qM-ILKNM¯WbuwO!KNM$s���OQa¯Wb��aVW{vwg-u�WbPª�¦sbu�vwM$O�Wbr$r$PLILKQW{v�I�s/ap´«�¦sbu�Knsb¡¥r-WbK�vwa$O`�w�Q´%�¦sbuK�PmWeu�I§vdY/´/s/u­�¦s/u¬On �KnI�OQa-K�Y/TªcÒa-[\OQOQ[B´�vwM-O®[$Wev�W8�dv�uwg-K�vwg$u�O®g-��O`[�¡�WZY�KNM-Wea$£/OX[\OQrVOQa-[\ILa$£sbaF©qM$ILKNMJKnuwI�vwOQuwILsba1IL�qOQ¡¥r$M-Wb�wIL¶nOQ[pTcÒa!W��$sbuwvwuNWea��/�XOna;�;I�u�sba$¡¥OQa/v`´e©^OhKNM$s;s/�wO^vws�u�Onr$u�OQ�wOna�vªv�M$Oh�wr-WeuN��O@¡�W{v�uwI��¥g-��ILa$£

a$s*P�O`�w�!vwM-Wba���I���WbuwuNWZY\��I�a�s/u�[\OQu¥vws¯W/KnK�s/¡¥¡�s\[$WevwOJ¡¥s/��v�K�s/¡¥¡�s/a$PLY�g-�wOQ[�[$Wev�W�¦sbu�¡¥Wev��QTªl@M$O�r$u�I�a-KnI�rVWePpWeu�uNWZY;�^Weu�O®vwM$O�u�OQWbPkOna�vwu�I�O`�qWea-[1vd©^s¥I�a�vwOQ£bOQu@WbuwuNWZY\�­©qM-ILKNM¡¥WZY/´t�¦sbu®O��$We¡¥r$PLOb´BM$s/PL[JvwM$O¥u�s{©"Wba-[�KnsbPLg$¡¥a�ILa-[\ImK�O`�Xsb�ªvwM$O¥u�OQ�wrVO`K·v�I��/O�Ona�v�uwILOQ�XI§�W�Kns;sbuN[\I�aVW{vwOF�dv�sbuNWe£/O1��KNM$On¡¥O±©¬OQuwOF�tOnILa$£°g-��O`[BT�cÒa6v�M$OF�¦sbPLP�s{©qILa$£-´¢vwM$O`��OJWeu�uNWZY;�Weu�O1[\O`��IL£ba-WevwO`[*�;Y°|�´Êcd| � ´¢Wba-[¯cd|®�\T°| KNMVWeuNWbK·v�Onu���vwu�ILa$£-´¢�«cdUx|�´ªI�a-[$ILKQW{vwO`��v�M$O�dv�sbuNWe£bO^�wKNM-On¡¥O¬�tOnILa$£}g-�wOQ[�¬¨�¦sbuÊOn�\Wb¡¥r$P�O/´b�«cdUx| � ! ��«4« #x�¦sbuªK�s;s/u�[\ILa-WevwO¬�¦sbu�¡¥Wev6®Wea-[°WJKNM-Wbu�W/K·vwOQu�Weu�u�WZY/´pU � f � ox|�´%£bIL�bO`��W{v�v�uwIL�$g\v�OQ��sb�¬v�M$O!¡�W{v�uwI��7¬¦�¦sbu�On�$We¡¥r$PLOb´��Y;¡¥¡¥O�vwu�Yb´`v�uwImWea$£/g$PmWeu�I§vdY]®·Tp�«ILa-WePLPLYb´{W@�¦g$uwvwM$OQu%�wM$sbuwvSILa�vwOn£/OnuSWbuwuNWZYb´Qc³�h� « |�´Q�wg$r$r$PLI�O`��¦g$u�v�M$Onu­I�a\�¦s/uw¡�WevwILsba�K�s/a-K�OQuwa$ILa$£}v�M$Ox¡�W{v�uwI��B´{�¦sbu¢On�$We¡¥r$PLOqvwM$Oqa;g$¡8�VOQu­sb�tOQa/v�uwILOQ�¢I�avwM$O�KQWb�wO®sb�Sv�M$O�K�s;sbuN[\ILa-W{v�O®��KNM$OQ¡�O/TªcÒa�v�M$O��$s/u�v�u�Wba1~ � OQa;��ILu�sba$¡¥Ona�v`´$WePm��s¥[\O��Va$OQ[��Y*UXg\i�O�v¥WePðT?¬ � ~b~ � ®�´ÊWbP�P¬vwM-OQ�wO1Weu�uNWZY;��WbuwO1I�aVK�PLg-[\OQ[¯I�a6W [\Onu�IL�bOQ[�[$W{vNW±vdY;rVO�vws©qM$ILKNM�IL�^WePm��s8Wb[$[\O`[�PLO��¨v^Wba-[�u�I�£/M�v­rVOQuw¡8g\v�WevwILsba�WbuwuNWZY\�n´/z­³�Wba-[�z­o�´/u�OQ�wrVO`K·v�I��/OnPLYbT

� µ

Page 31: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

l@M$IL���-sbuwvwuNWea°~ � [\Onu�IL�bOQ[�[$Wev�W1vdY;rVO¥Im����M-s{©qa�ILa°�«IL£bg$u�O��;T � T¥l@M$O!�wr-WeuN��O�¡�W{v�uwI��M-Wb�@s/u�[\OQuxH �;Y z¥TxYj n |A}C`�aO¿C�C`f~{�a$¿C�C`�~{�CxAbCa\ mCa$` � `Ciyx^uV�QOlCb$iAbAQ$aO`Ci�K$��L \ n bQOlCb$iAbAQ$aO`Ci�Kft n `Y~$QOiAb^]´t+q�k\ mCa$` � `Ci \ mCLYjOb^]�t-q�kn j+|A_C}C`p�$iC`YQ \ ~ \ j{mduV�Yj \ mAa$`$i SCSwb^]AS=k\ mCa$` � `Ci^uV�fj \ mCa$`Ci SCS \ b�tv]AS=ku \ bYo ]AS¢kuV�C}d]CS=kuV�Ci^]AS=k`Cm n aO¿C�C`"~{�$xAbCa`$m n xfj n |A}C`�a$¿C�$`f~{�

�«IL£bg$u�O��;T �5¶ �$s/u�v�u�Wba1~ � [\OQuwIL�bO`[�[$Wev�W�vdY;rtOX�¦s/ux��rVWeuN��O}¡�W{v�uwImK�O`���I§v�M�v�M$IL��[$O��-a$I�vwILsba�se�@W1�wr-WeuN�wO�¡�W{v�uwI��B´kvwM$O�uws/g\vwILa$O`�h�¦s/u®vwM$O¥¡�W{v�uwI��e�ð¡�W{v�uwI��

r$uws\[\gVK·v��@ILa[¬ � ®·´$©qM$ImKNMJWeu�O®[$O��-a$O`[F��YI & 6 � /1¾ 0 /1¿ 4 �y� &I & 6 � /1¾ 0 Õ1/�¿ 4 �"� &Wea-[ �¦sbu���s/P��;ILa$£1vwu�ILWba$£bg$PmWeu}�wY;��vwOQ¡��Xsb�­O�·�g-WevwILsba-�®©qI�vwM�¡�g$P�vwILr$PLO¥uwIL£bM�v��èM-Wba-[��wIL[$OQ�I�a[¬ �¸®·´$©qM-ILKNM±Weu�O�[\O��-a-OQ[F�;YI & 6 ��À /1¾¬Á ( ( /�¿ 4 ��� &I & 6 ��À /1¾¬Á ( Õ9/�¿ 4 ��� &I & 6 � / ¾ Á ( ( / ¿ À 4 ��� &I & 6 � / ¾ Á ( Õ9/ ¿ À 4 ��� &©qM$Onu�OI 0 Im�qW¥��r-Wbu��wO®¡¥Wevwu�I§�I Á�IL�xW8v�uwImWea$£/g$PmWeuq��rVWeuN��O®¡�W{vwu�I��I 4 WeaV[ & Weu�O}[\Ona-�wO�¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�I À IL�hW�[$ILWb£bsbaVWePk¡�W{vwu�I��I / ¾ Wba-[Â/ ¿ Weu�O}rVOQuw¡8g\v�WevwILsbaF¡¥Wevwu�ILKnOQ�I � Wba-[®�°WbuwO���KnWbPLWbu��Q´Weu�O}W/�q��M-s{©qa�ILa±�«IL£bg$u�OQ�h�\T ��Wba-[±�\T � u�OQ�wrVO`K·v�I��/OnPLYbT

�e~

Page 32: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

º$QA~{xCx ]Va$iAb$mf~HuExduEmduw�duEb$}$�ClAb^u��Ci^u�L \ n bgu n `f~$Q{iAb^u£b^u \ b9tvu \ bAo u \ mALAjOb^u��YQgu_duE} n _^uE_C`AaCbgu£QguE} n Qgu¥Ãfj{i$�duE}}Ãfj7iC�du \ `Ci$ifj{i9k�Ê۬˦$@Ì¥ÄÆÅ $=� �Ê۬˦$@Ì¥ÄÇÅ �?�

ÈWÉËÊ�Ì�ÍÏÎÐÌ�Ñ,ÒÔÓÏÕYÈ ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì�Í�ν×ÂÌ�ÑØÒÔÓÙÕYÈ�«I�£/g$uwO��\T � ¶ � f-H H°´-�wr-WeuN�wOX¡�W{v�uwI��!v�I�¡¥OQ�h[\Ona-�wO}¡�W{vwu�I���¤bOQuwa$OQP

ºOQA~C~{xd]Va$iAb$mf~Hu�x^uEmduEbO}C�ClAb^uE|Cm \ a n u n uw�CiduEL \ n a^u n `f~$QOiAagu�a^u \ a�tvu \ aYoHu \ mALYj{a^u�AQguE_du�} n _duE_$`AaCb^u�Qgu�} n Qgu�ÃYj{iC�duE}�Ãfj{iC�du \ `CiCifj{i�k�Ê۬˦$@Ì¥ÄÇÅ $�� �ÊÛ^Ëv$q̯ÄÇÅ �?�

Ú¦$^Ü3�G�ÛÄÇÅ Ú�� ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì�ÍbÜ)Ý � Ì�Ñ�ÒKÓÙÕ�È ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì�ÍbÜ)ÝÞ×ÙÌYÑ,ÒKÓÙÕYÈÚ¦$^Ü3�G�ÛÄÇÅ Ä%� ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì�ÍÏßàÜ Ý � Ì�Ñ�ÒKÓÙÕ�È ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì�ÍÏßáÜ ÝÞ× ÌYÑ,ÒKÓÙÕYÈÚ¦$^Ü3�G�ÛÄÇÅ Û=� ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì Í Ü Ý � ß�Ì Ñ ÒKÓÙÕ�È ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì Í Ü ÝÞ× ßâÌ Ñ ÒKÓÙÕYÈÚ¦$^Ü3�G�ÛÄÇŠɦ� ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì Í ß,ãã Ü Ý � ß,ãã Ì Ñ ÒÔÓÏÕYÈ ÈWÉÖÊ�Ì Í ß,ãã Ü Ýµ× ß,ãã Ì Ñ ÒKÓÏÕYÈ�«I�£/g$u�O��\T �t¶ � f$f$H°´-�wsbPLg\v�I�s/a1sb�Ê�wr-WeuN�wOhv�uwImWea$£/g$PmWeuq��Y\��vwOQ¡¥�@sb�%O�·/gVW{vwILsbaV�

�b�

Page 33: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

¼ ðV¥ ¦ õkó ö�ø � ý"ód�]û�ý]ö�ävó1�¾ó�ý§�ù�Ç�õ|h�}©^O8¡¥Ona�v�I�s/a$OQ[�OQWeu�PLI�OQuQ´tvwM-O�r-uwIL¡�Weu�YFu�OQW/��s/aJ�¦sbu®v�M$O�[\OQ�wI�£/a�sb�­vwM-O��wr-WeuN�wO�M$IL£bMP�OQ�bOnP\²@³S|®f�Im�%�¦sbu«g-��O^ILa�v�M$O¬I�vwOQu�WevwIL�bO^��s/P�g\v�I�s/a�sb�V��rVWeuN��O¬P�ILa$OQWbu%O�·�g-W{v�I�s/a-�nT%��O^a$sbvwOvwM-Wev}s/g$u�r$u�sbrts/��WeP«©qI�PLP��$v�O�·/gVWePLP�Y ©^OnPLPª©qM$OnvwM$OQu}vwM$O¥I�vwOnuNW{v�I��/O���sb�¨vd©^WbuwO8rVOQu��¦s/uw¡��W�KQWePLPBvws�W¥¡�W{v�uwI��e�ð�/OQK�vwsbu^¡�g-P§v�I�r$PLYFuws/g\vwILa$O}sbuq©qM$OnvwM$OQuxu�On�bOQu��wOXKnsb¡¥¡�g-a$ILKQW{v�I�s/a1Im�g-��O`[!�wI�a-KnOhILa!OnI�vwM-Onu@KnWb�wOhW�KQWePLPtKQWea��tOX¡�W/[\Oqvws�W�£/I��/Ona!�wr-WeuN��Oq¡�Wevwu�I§�e�ð�¦g$P�Pt¡�W{v�uwI��¡�g$P�vwILr$PLILKQW{vwILsba�u�sbg\v�I�a$O�JSv�M$O�KnWbP�PªIm�}¡�Wb[\O¥�;YJvwM-O�uws/g\vwILa$O¥I�a�vwM-O¥�¦sbu�¡�OQu�KnWb�wO�Wea-[��Y!vwM$O�g-�wOnuqILaFvwM$O�PmW{vwvwOQuQT��O@�¦OQOnP\v�M-W{vÊvwM-Oq�VO`�dv¢ILa�vwOnuw�µWbKnO^�¦sbu¢I�vwOQu�WevwIL�bO@��s/P��/OnuN�n´{r-Wbu�v�ILKng$PmWeu�P�Y}�¦s/uʺ-O��\IL�$I�PLI�vdY

Wea-[�O� !K�ILOna-KnY°IL�8vws�g-�wO1u�On�/OnuN��O�Knsb¡¥¡�g-a$ILKQW{v�I�s/a���s�vwM-Wev8v�M$O1vdY�r-ILKQWeP^g-��O1se�hs/g$u��r-Wbu��wO!²@³S|®f°©qI§v�M$ILa�Wea*I�vwOQu�WevwIL�bO��wsbPL�bOQu�©¬s/g$PL[°�tO1W/��ILa-[\ImKnWevwOQ[¯I�a°v�M$O1�w¤bOQP�OnvwsbaK�s\[\O}I�aJ�«IL£bg$u�O��;T �-T

å @éA�C�© ê ¨�IGª�ADC

l@M$O���vwgV[\I�O`�J[\OQ��K�u�IL�VO`[îILa>v�M$IL�Fr-WbrVOQuJ[\On¡¥sbaV�dv�u�WevwO�M$s{© rVs/u�vNWe�$PLO°Wea-[>O� !K�ILOna�v¡¥WevwM$OQ¡�W{vwImKnWbP8�wse�¨vd©@Weu�O*KnWea��tO�[$OQ�wI�£/a$OQ["s/a�M$I�£/M�rVOQu��¦s/uw¡�Wba-K�O¯Knsb¡¥r$g\v�OnuN� �;Y¡¥Wb¤;I�a$£±M$O`WZ�;Y g-�wO�se�qK�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-WeP­¤bOnu�a$OQPL�QT!l@M$O�¡�WeILa*K�sb¡¥r$g$v�W{v�I�s/a-WeP­¤bOnu�a$OQPL�vwM-Wev8©^O�K�s/a-��Im[\OQu�Weu�O¥vwM$OF³pOQ�bOnP � ²@³S|XfB´«Wba-[°©¬O1��M$s{© M$s{© vwM-OnY*KnWba*�VO!gV��O`[B´a$sev@sba$PLY¥I�a!vwM$O}��s/P�g$vwILsba!sb�p�¦g$PLPk�wY\�dv�On¡��¬se�SPLI�a-OQWeu^O�·�g-WevwILsba-�­�$g\vqWePm��s8I�a�vwM$O}[\ILuwO`K·v��s/P�g\v�I�s/a se�­�wr-Wbu��wO�O�·�g-WevwILsba-�QTX�-sbuXvwM$O8I§v�OnuNW{vwIL�bO8��s/P�g\v�I�s/a se�­�wr-Wbu��wO�O�·�g-WevwILsba-�Q´t©¬O��M$s{©>M$s{©�W/[\�{Wea�v�Wb£bO}KnWeaF�tO}v�We¤/Ona1se�S�¦g-P�Pp�-P�s\KN¤\�@©qI§v�M$ILa±Wba � P�OQ¡¥Ona�v��è�;Y¸� � PLOn¡¥OQa/vr$uwO`K�s/a-[\I�vwILsba$OQu�Wea-[�M$s{© Wea°O��;vwOQa-�wI�s/a�sb�¬v�M$O!²@³S|®f��¦sbu��wr-WeuN��O¥¡�W{v�uwImK�O`��KnWba��tOg-��O`[FI�a1vwM$O�I�vwOQu�WevwIL�bO��wsbPLg\vwILsba±K�s\[\O/T� U$Ý2M)Q9ÞDs&bkS��rbkY�bkMON�nl@M$OqWeg\v�M$sbuN�%WbuwO^�bOQuwY}£/u�WevwO��¦g-P/v�s�zªW{vwu�ImKN¤}|h¡¥OQ��vws{Y�WeaV[8RÊ]Onu�sb¡¥O¬U ]O`KnWe¡¥r-�S�¦sbu«v�M$OnILu��g$r-rVs/u�vqILaF£/O�vwvwILa$£!��s/¡¥O®sb�Sv�M$O�uwO`��g-P§vN�q[\IL�wr$PmWZYbO`[�ILaFvwM$O�r-WbrVOQuQT

�$�

Page 34: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

Q �YX$NC�AMON7P�[{�"�{ZAX$NY[{Zf�$M{��MO��Z$�YX3_��{QAM{��æ{�C¼Y[OZAX � NY[{»f�OXO�AZ�P�X$Z$�fM{»\ L$}Ab � U�qn j�t+q \ aO`CiYU�tvuwxAbC� \ aQ QA[C�C��ZYMp�$M$�nçAXpNYM{�CZf�7�YXQ$b$}C}"~$j{}}èC`Ci^] \ L$}Ab � u"cCcCcCcCc$cQ2~{���C�{XY�C�{�$�Y��ZAX$N7Pv�+�f[OZf�$M7�\ L'] \ L$}Ab � c�`fegc´t$k�a$l$`Cm� j3aAj�o$q`Cm n \ LQ `ANCNYM{NpNAX$Z$�CN$�\ L'] \ L$}Ab � c�}Aadc�q�k�a$l$`Cm� j3aAj3�Cq`Cm n \ L\ L'] \ L$}Ab � c�`fegc¡ofk�a$l$`CmQ �YX$NC�AMON7P�Z$�AX�P9[OZCNY�CéY�nçAXA�{ZYMONy�ANYM{»$���{ZQ$b$}$} n QA~{x$xd]AcCcCc$cCc� j3aAj"t+q`Cm n \ L\ L'] \ L$}Ab � c�`fegc¡ofk�a$l$`CmQ �YX$NC�AMON7P�Z$�AX3�ANAXY�OM{�A»f�{ZY�$M{���7�C¼�M{�AX$NY[OZf�OM{�Q$b$}$} n QA~C~7xd]AcCcCc$cCc� j3aAj"t+q`Cm n \ Lt+q2QCj{mAa \ mO|A`Q QAMO»AX3ZYMz�f[7�A»Y�$X"�7�f�C�OXY�C�7�$�f��ZAX$N+Pv�7�f[OZY�$M{�o$q c$cCcCcQ QAMO»AX�X�éAXY�7�CZAX$»��{��X$NCNYMONyNCX$Z$�AN$�f��Cq c$cCcCc�«IL£bg$u�O��;T � ¶ xh�wO}se�ʤbOQuwa$OQPL�^ILa±I§v�OnuNW{vwIL�bO��wsbPLg\vwILsbaFse�Ê��rVWeuN��O}O�·�g-WevwILsba-�

� �

Page 35: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

Ä F�½5F�¥vFHC�©�F�I

|x¡¥OQ��vws{Y/´�zÊT�o�T�¬ � ~/~ � ®·´!�-W/K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsba se�±PmWeu�£bO���rVWeuN��O�¡�W{v�uwImK�O`�°�-Wb�wOQ[ sba�W¡�g$P�vwI��¦uws/a�v�WeP;Wer-r$uws�WbKNM�ILa�Wx¡8g$P�vwILr$uws\KnOQ����s/uSOna;�;ILuws/a$¡¥Ona�vQ´Zz¢M-[�vwM$O`��Im�Q´`cÒaV�dv�I§v�g\v�hW{v�I�s/a-WePJzÊs/P�Y�vwO`KNM$a$I¯·�g$O�[\O�l%sbg$PLsbgV��O/T |x�{WeILPmWe�$PLO)W/� �^� ox�\| � f uwOQrVs/u�vl�±®y{zB|}y{~ � ye�$T

|x¡¥OQ��vws{Y/´�zÊT�o�T�Wba-[¸Uhg$i«´1c·T�fkT ¬ � ~ µ ~¸®�´Ùê }ªO`K·v�sbu�I�¶`W{vwILsba se�JW"¡�g-P§v�I�r$u�s\K�O`�w�wsbu¡�g$P�vwI��¦uws/a�v�WePpKns\[\Ob¹L´{ë=E;ÎOì1í?ì³ØiîGï{<C×?>�Ì�Ë-ØB�×P<"ÎO>�Ìñð«×f×rÐ ÍqË]:]ì o�ò?ófô ¤Þõ�ö?÷ø)ùDúnûAüVýuþ ò ÿ ÷��G÷��������� ò�� ÷��Y÷�� ô ö�ö���� ò ê�� únùDý��Xþ ����� ý�� � ü ��ý � ��ûXû � únû!� � û " � �^ûAúù �#� ü ��"#�Xý$�CúnûXûAý%� ù ��� ü&�(')�Xý � ü ��� ùDúCü *?ý � û,+ ò ë=E�-�ì�í?ì�ØAîÏï{<C×?>/. 0-ØuB�×{<�-�>1.Âð)×f×32(450=:Cì6 ò�7�ó ¤�8%9Þ÷ø)ùDúnûAüVýuþ òZÿ ÷��G÷ ò :� þ �<;ú ò �Ô÷�=?÷ ò ��� ò$� ÷$�Y÷$���3�>� ý�� ¹ú/�Xú ò"ÿ ÷3� ô ö�öZõ�� ò ê ? � � ú � � ����@ ú,A#� �� ��� � ����� ü ��ý � û¯ý �B�DC ���Vü ����� û * � �Xú � ùDúnù�ý%�VþE�]ý"ùF" � üVú,�,+ ò ë=E3-IíØ<�.=EHGI2�ØiîFJK4 \ïf×?>X>^_ML³ØB�×P<�-N4 EµO6 ò 9 ô ¤ ó �f÷ø ��� ú,�XûVý � ò:P ÷ òKQ � � òKR ÷ òKQ ��û&�S*?ý�' òKT ÷ ò únù�ùDú � ò =f÷ ò ý �#@�� �&� � ò =f÷ ò �� T �Vý%U ò =?÷ òV �Vúnú � A ��� ù ò ø ÷ òXW � ùDù � � � � �#@ ò �Y÷ ò � �/Y�ú ��� úCþ ò ø ÷ ò[Z ûAü �Xý � �S*fý C ò �Y÷\������ ý��Xú � ûVú � ò ¯÷]� ô ö"ö%9�� ò�^ ð�_�ðOLa`cb�:C>/.^:#dfe½<�4�_">nì ò � � ø �K÷

Q ý � � � ò�g ÷������h� ú,U � úi� ò ø ÷�� ô ö�ö ó � ò�T � �S*?ú ý%� @���� ��U � ü ��ý � � ��j�� ú � �Cú)ý �\� ýµý%"\A � ý��Sk$� ��@ òl úi�S* � �m� ���a� ú/"Pý��Vü 8�n�� ò$� � � � ø ò � ú �#� únû ò�g � ��� �Cú ÷

Q ý �#@%� �Aü&U ò<� ÷ ò�T ý ��� ò ø ÷o�G÷ ò V ý �#�m� ò�p ÷ � ÷q�Ô÷o�����rl ý%� � ü ò ÿ ÷o? ÷�� ô ö�ö���� ò�sutwv�xfyT ý � ûAü � � � � ú �r�����rz�� �Cý � ûAü � � � � ú �{l únûAü � �#@ P ��C ���Vý � ùDú � ü ò l ú,�S* � �m� ����� ú,"{ý%�Aül���| ÿ ø |uö��$| ô n ò#T}P � g ø T � ò l ý ��� ý � ûAú ò#g � ��� �Cú ÷

T � � � úCþ ò ��÷ ò~W ú/�Xý ��� ò �Ô÷ ø ÷�������? � ò V ÷q� ô ö�ö%�%� ò ø�"#�Vý%"{ýZû ��� '�ý�� � û " � �^ûVú Q ? ø �üVýµý � k$� ü ò l ú,�S* � ��� ����� ú/"Pý��Vü l���| ÿ ø |uö%9�|uö%n!�N� ú C ��ûAú ��� ò]T}P � g ø T � ò l ý �#� ý � ûVú òg � ��� �Cú ÷

T *?ý�� ò =f÷ ò úCùDùDú � ò =?÷ ò *#� ��� ý � òq� ÷ ò ý �#@%� � � � ò =?÷ ò�Z ûiü&�Vý � �S*?ý C ò �Y÷ ò½ÿ úCü ��üVúCü ò ø ÷ ò� ü ���#� únþ ò Y ÷ òO� ��� k�ú,� ò ¯÷K���3� � * ��� únþ ò �G÷ T ÷F� ô ö"ö"õ�G,� ò � � �%? ø ÿ ø T Y y ø"{ý%�Aü � A � ú � � � ú � � ����@ ú/A#� �\� ��A#� � �Xþ>'�ý�� � ��ûAü �&��A � üVú � ùDúCùDý��XþX�Cý�ùF" � üXú/�^ûq� � ú�û�� @����ûXû � únû ����� "{ú,��'�ý%�Vù ��� �]ú ò l ú,�S* � �m� ���3� ú,"{ý%�Aü ? ø ÿ ø T Y � ý��&k�� �#@ p ýüVú ö"õ ò�T � �ö"õ � 9�8%� ò z�� � C ú,�Xû ��üiþ ý�' l ú �#� únûXûVúCú ÷

T *?ý�� ò =f÷ ò ý ��@%� �&� � ò =f÷ ò�Z ûAü �Xý � �S*fý C ò �Y÷ òuÿ úCü ��üVú]ü ò ø ÷ òi� ��� k�ú,� ò ¯÷����3� � * ��� úCþ ò �G÷ T ÷� ô ö"ö"õH��� ò ø�"#�Xý�"Pý"û ��� '�ý%� � ûVú]üñý�'�" � � ����� ú � A � û ��� � � � ú � � ����@ ú,A#� � û � A#"��Vý @ � � ù û òl úi�S* � �m� ���q� ú,"{ý%�Aü ? ø ÿ ø T Y � ý��&k$� ��@ p ý�üVú ô n�n òoT � � öZõ � 9�8%� ò z�� � C ú,�Xû � üiþ ý�'l ú �#� únûXûVúCú ÷

T ý �#� ò ø ÷a�G÷ ò V ý ����� ò�p ÷ � ÷a�Ô÷]�����Dl ý�� � ü ò�ÿ ÷a? ÷u� ô ö"ö%9%� òu�I���~s~xf�%��v�� G����I.�-�. GuE� G%0���G/�Z>�î1��.�2�G�.N�Z>]@O:/0SGI2�>ÛEH�uE32�4 EP>SG�.r� � -�4 BO4��iGI-�45�uE������12��&GI /�Wð}¡ ò ��� ù¢APú/� ô�£4�¤�¥�� "#�&� ��@ ú/� � ú/�&��únû¦� � T ý"ùF" � ü � ü ��ý �����§�¨� ü *?únù � ü �m�Cû,+ ò � "#�&� �#@ ú/�©Lú/� ����@ òW ú/� � ú � APú/� @ ò�Q ú,� � � � ò#p ú/ª« ý��&k ÷

���

Page 36: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

���C ��û ò l�÷ ø ÷����3�¬��� òh� ÷��Y÷h� ô ö�ö%�%� ò ø �¬�#� ûVþµùDù�úCü �&���1��" � üAüXú/� � ù �#� ü&�(')�Xý � ü ���ù�úCü *?ý � '�ý%�âû�" � �^ûAú ?]z ' � �=üXý��&��U � ü ��ý � ò l ú,�S* � �m� ���B� ú,"{ý%�Aü � ø ? ö�� � n%� 7?ò��� ü *fú/� '�ý�� � ø�"#" � ú]üXý �¨?]� A{ý%� � üVý��Xþ ÷

�� þ �};ú ò �K÷­=f÷u� ô ö�ö 7 � ò ø®A � ý��Sk C ú,�Xû ��ý � ý�' ü *?ú�únû k�ýIªq��û �S* ��� APú � ùDý � ��¯fú � �S*?ý � ú�û�kµþ' � �=üXý��&��U � ü&��ý � ò l úi�S* � �m� ���a� ú/"Pý��Vü �wl�| ø ÿqZ |uö"õ�|I8 ò%Pop � PoPo�°W l � � � � l�÷

�� þ �};ú ò �Ô÷}=f÷<�����±��# ò�� ÷q�Y÷�� ô ö%8�ö%� ò ¥ ? ú C ú ��� Q ? ø � � �?]z ' � �=üVý%� ��U � ü ��ý � ý �ü *?ú T � øw«�� 9 òaP l ø�� ô n ÿ ����� �°Q �²�%n�ö%n � 9�n�n$| © g + ò ë�¤3-Oì í?ìo�Aî¯ïH³ � �/. 0S�I´ � ³�-µ�/.ð ��� 2�4501 ]ì­¶ òÞó nI· £ n?÷�� þ �};ú ò �Ô÷]=?÷­�����D��� òa� ÷]�Y÷u� ô ö�ö ô � ò ¥�z ûVú�ý�' � ú C ú �u� Q ? ø � � �¸?�z ' � �=üXý��&��U � ü&��ý �

� �®� ù �#� ü&��"��Vý��]ú�ûVû � �#@ ú ��C ���Vý � ùDú � üØý � ü *��Vúnú C ú,�=üXý��Øù �#� ü ��"#�Xý$�CúnûXûAý%�Xû ò ü&*?úø ?]? � ø p l gw¹ |I8�n ò ü&*?ú T � øw«�� 9 ò ���3� ü&*?ú �°Q � ��n"ö�n�| © g + ò ë1¤�-�ì�í?ì§�iîï3³ � �1. 0S��´ � ³�-º�/.ñð ��� 2�4501 ]ìa» ò ö%9�· ô"ô n?÷�� þ �};ú ò �Ô÷]=?÷a�����§��� òa� ÷]�Y÷~� ô ö"ö 7 � ò ø®A � ý��Sk¨��ùF" � únùDú � ü � ü ��ý � ý�' � ú C ú �u� Q ? ø �

'�ý�� � � � T "#�Xý��]únûXûVý��^û ò l úi�S* � �m� ���a� ú/"Pý��Vü ��l�| ø ÿqZ |uö 7 | ô"ò%P<p � P<P~�°W l � � � � l�÷�� þ �};ú ò �Ô÷{=?÷ ò ��� ò�� ÷��Y÷������ ÿ úCü ��üVúCü ò ø ÷¦� ô ö�ö ó G,� ò ¥ ø¼" � � ����� ú � A � ý��Sk

��ùF" � úCùDú � ü � ü ��ý � ý�' ? ú C ú �K� Q ? ø � k�ú,� � ú � û>'�ý%� � � �¨½C úi�=üVý%�["#�Vý��CúnûXûAý%�Xû,+ òðOL�¾À¿#. GI¤� /G�0/-N45��¤# O�I¤D¾DGI-NÁ$�/´FG�-N450SGI2�ïf�AîS-NÂoG�. ��Ã3Ä ò�ôI£ 8I· ô ö%�?÷�� þ �};ú ò �Ô÷�=f÷ ò ? + P � �]ú ��� ú � ü ò =f÷ « ÷>����� V ý �#�m� òDp ÷ � ÷��Ô÷M� ô ö�ö ó ��� ò¸Z � ü&*?ú

� ûAú ý�'Dú � úCùDú � ü��ºAµþ��Uú � únù�ú � ü["��Vúi�]ý �3� � ü&��ý � ú/�^ûbüVý ûAý ��C ú �m� � @ úKû&� ��� úE" � �Aü&� ����� þûAú," � � � A � úâý%"Þü ��ùF��U � ü&��ý � "#�Xý�A � úCù û ò l úi�S* � �m� ��� �Xú/"Pý��Vü ò�Pop � PoPo�°W l � � � � l òl ý �#� ý � ûVú ò%g � ��� �]ú ÷3��l�| ø ÿ}Z |ö ó | ófò üVý � "#"Pú � �u� ��� � ø �Å= ý � � ����� ý �h� �1��ú � ü ��¯3�T ý�ùF" � ü&� �#@{÷

�� þ �};ú ò �Ô÷[=?÷ ò ? + P � �Cú ��� ú � ü ò =f÷ « ÷X���3� V ý �#�m� ò§p ÷ � ÷!�K÷D� ô ö�ö"õ%� ò � ý ��� ü ��ý �ý�' ûAü � � �=ü � �Xú � ûVþÞûiüXúCù ûËý�' � � � ú � � ú,Æ ��� ü ��ý � û � û � �#@ ú � únù�ú � ü��ºAZþ��Oú � úCùDú � ü"#�Vúi�]ý ��� ��ü ��ý � ú,�Xû ò 4�¤¨¥ ÿ �Xý$�CúCú � � ��@ û 9I��� � � ø T � � � üXú/� ��� ü&��ý �����]� þµùF"Pý"û � � ù ý �� üVú/� � ü&� C ú � ú]ü&*?ý � û�� �!? � � ú � �)ø ��@ ú/A#� � + ò "#" ÷ ô 8 ô · ô ö%n?÷]��� ûVý Pop � PoP~�°W l � � � � ll úi�S* � �m� ���a� ú/"Pý��Vü ò ��l�| ø ÿ}Z |ö"õ%| ô ÷

�� þ �};ú ò �K÷­=f÷ ò ? + P � �]ú ��� ú � ü ò =f÷ « ÷­����� V ý �#�m� ò­p ÷ � ÷a�Ô÷u� ô ö�ö 7 � òPÿ �Vú,"#�Vý��CúnûXû�� �#@ ý�'û�" � �XûVú ����� ûXûAúnù¢A � ú �D� � � ú � ��ûAþÞûAüVúCù û�'�ý���ú/Çh�/��ú � ü�ûVý ��� ü ��ý �¸� û � �#@ ú � úCùDú � ü ��Aµþ��ú � úCùDú � üu"#�Xú,�]ý ��� ��ü ��ý � ú,�Xû ò 4�¤\¥ ÿ �Vý��CúCú � � �#@ û�ý�' P � �Xý�� ÿ � � ö 7?ò ? þ�ý � + ÷#l ý � "#"Pú � � ÷ únù�ùDú � ò =f÷ � ÷ ò~P ��ûAú � ûAü � ü ò ��÷ T ÷ ò V � � A{ú,�Aü ò =?÷w�G÷ ò ? � òw¹ ÷���÷����3��? � � ò =?÷ � ÷ W ÷

� ô ö"ö"õ%� ò ø û � "{ú,� � ý �#����� "#"#�Xý � �S*�üVýGû " � �^ûAú<" � �Vü � ��� "#� C ý�ü � �#@ ò l ú,�S* � ��� ����� ú,"{ý%�Aüz T}Q |�| T �� � ö"õ � 8%8�� ò#T ý"ùF" � üVú,� � �/��ú � �]ú � C ��û���ý � ò z;÷ T ÷ Q ú/�&k�ú � únþ ò�Q ú/�&k�ú � únþ òT ��� �('�ý%� � � �?÷

ú �#� ��û ò =?÷K�����¬� �S* �3� APú � ò �G÷F� ô ö�8%�%� òFÈ ³�´h�1.�450SG�2�¾D�1-NÁ$�iÉ� Ùî1�I.¬b�¤H0S��¤# �-N.&GI4�¤H�SÉÊ � -N4�´\4��iGI-�45�I¤ËGI¤HÉ È ��¤�2�4�¤f�&G�.�Ì�Í1³�G�-N45��¤#  ò*ÿ �Xú � ü �m�]ú W ����� òqP �#@%� ú,ª&ýµý � T � � û òp ÷�=?÷

� ó

Page 37: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

ý � ûVý � ò ¥÷���÷ ò V �&��ùDú�û ò �G÷ V ÷w�����Î? ú,ª���û ò =?÷ V ÷q� ô ö"ö ô � ò ¥�� " � �^ûAú ú � üVú � û���ý � ûGüVýü *?ú g ý%�Aü&� ��� Q � û��m� ? � � ú � ��ø ��@ ú,A#� �E��� A#"#�Xý @ � � ùDû,+ ò ðOLw¾Ï¿#. GI¤� 1G%01-�45�I¤� D�I¤¾MG�-5Á��1´hGI-�450SGI21ïf�AîS-NÂoG�. ��Ð#6 ò 9"õ��I·�9 7 �?÷

ý �#@%� � � � ò =f÷f����� � * ��� úCþ ò �G÷ T ÷�� ô ö"ö"õ%� ò ø � ûVú/�^û/+ @�� � � ú¯üVý ü&*?ú¢A ��� �Cû ò l ú,�S* � ��� ���� ú/"Pý��Vü T � � ö"õ � 9�8 ô�ò z�� � C ú,�Xû � üiþ�ý�' l ú �#� únûXûVúCú ò Y � ý �$C � ��� ú ò l ú �#� únûXûAúnú ò z�� ø ÷

ý �#@%� � � � ò =f÷�=?÷f� ô ö�ö%9%� òZÿ ú/� '�ý��Xù ��� �]ú*ý�' CI� �&��ý � ûo�Cý�ùF" � üXú/�^û � û � ��@ ûAü ���3�#� � �F� � � ú � �����@ ú/A�� � ûAý�' ü°ª � �Vú ò l ú,�S* � ��� ���h� ú,"{ý%�Aü T � � 8�ö � 8Zõ ò z�� � C ú,�Xû � üiþáý�' l ú �#� únûXûAúnú òY � ý ��C � ��� ú ò l ú �#� únûXûVúCú ò z:� ø ÷

ý �#@%� � � � ò =?÷­=f÷f����� V �Xý"ûXûVú ò­P ÷�� ô ö�8 £ � ò ¥� ��ûiü&� ��A � ü&��ý � ý�' ù � ü *fúCù � ü&��� ��� ûAý�' ü°ª � �VúC � � ú � ú,�]ü �Xý � �m� ù � � � + ò L~�I´\´FÑ�ðOLw¾Å¶3Ä òÞó n%��· ó n £ ÷

ý �#@%� � � � ò =f÷D=?÷ ò �� T �Xý�U ò =?÷ ò ��� ò�� ÷M�Y÷M����� W � ùDù � � � � �#@ ò �Y÷�� ô ö�ö�n�� ò¥ ø ��@ ý��&� ü&*?ù 7$£ ö?÷�� ûVú]ü ý�' ? ú C ú ��� Q � û �m� ? � � ú � � ø ��@ ú/A#� ���$� A�"#�Vý @ � � ù û ÷ + ò ðOLw¾¿�. G�¤# /G�0/-�45�I¤# O��¤¨¾DGI-NÁ$�/´FG�-N450SG�2�ï­�iîS-�ÂoGI. ��Ð$Ò ò�ô · ô�£ ÷

ý �#@%� � � � ò =f÷H=f÷ ò ��� òH� ÷­�Y÷ ò � ý��Xú � ûVú � ò ¥÷ T ÷H�����¨CI���M� ú/�:©Lý��^ûiü ò3W ÷ ø ÷w� ô ö�ö ô G,� òïf�I2(Ó,4�¤$� ^ 4�¤H�SGI.�ïHÔ� �-º�/´¢ ��I¤Õ3�S01-µ�I.�G�¤HÉDï3Á$G�. �SÉF¾D�1´h�I.�ÔDLu��´ � ³�-º�/.S  ò � � ø � òÿ *#� ���%� ú � "#*#� �?÷ ý �#@%� � � � ò =f÷�=f÷ ò �¨� þ�ú�û òZÿ ÷����3�h����� �m� � ü � � � Q �Xý�UCý � ý ò V ÷3� ô ö�ö ô � � ò ?]� " � �Sk�ª½ý��&k$� �#@

� ýüXú 9�8 y l *?ú �°Q �Ö� � � T � þÞûiüXúCù | 7 n�n�n������×� � � ú � � ����@ ú/A#� � ý�"Pú/� � ü ��ý � û òl úi�S* � �m� ���a� ú/"Pý��Vü T � � ö ô � ô �%n ò z�� � C ú/�^û � üiþ ý�' l ú ��� únûXûAúnú ÷

��� òE� ÷X�Y÷D� ô ö"ö 7 � ò � " � �^ûAú �$� ùDú/�&��� ���¨� � � ú � � ����@ ú/A�� � y � ���Xú,�]üÆù�úCü *?ý � û �����"#�Vúi�]ý ��� ��ü ��ý � � �#@ ò l ú,�S* � ��� ���D� ú,"{ý%�Aü � ø ? ö 7 � n ó�£µò ��� ü *fú/� '�ý�� � ø�"#" � ú]üXý �?]� APý�� � üXý��Xþ ÷ ø � ûAý T}P � g ø T ��� ú/"Pý��Vü l�� � ÿ ø�� ö 7 � 9�9?÷

��� ò$� ÷$��÷%���3�>� ú/� � ò =?÷ Y ÷3� ô ö�8%�%� ò ¥�l *?ú)ù ��� ü&�(')�Xý � ü ��� ûVý ��� ü ��ý � ý�'a� �3� ú1¯ � � üXúIû " � �^ûAúûAþµùDùDú]ü �&�m� � � � ú � �¯ûVþµûAüVúnù û/+ ò ðOLw¾Ö¿#. GI¤� 1G%01-�45�I¤� ��I¤�¾MG�-5Á��1´hGI-�450SGI2&ïf�AîS-NÂoG�. �Ø9ò �%n%9�·$�%9"õÞ÷

��� ò�� ÷��Y÷I���3�¢� ú,� � ò =f÷ Y ÷�� ô ö%8 ó � ò ¥ l *fú ù ��� ü&�(')�Xý � ü ��� ûAý ��� ü&��ý � ý�' �#� ûVþZùDùDú]ü&� �m�½ûAúCüXûý�' � � � ú � ��ûVþÞûiüXúCù û,+ ò ï�ÙVð�¾ÛÚ#�I³�.�¤fGI2o�I¤Wïf0/45�1¤3-N4 Ü}0>GI¤fÉÙï3-µGI-�4m �-N450SG�2�Lu��´ � ³�-N4�¤$�» ò�7 ���I· 7ó{ô ÷

��� ò�� ÷��Y÷ ò V �&��ùDú�û ò �G÷ V ÷������>? ú/ª���û ò =?÷ V ÷­� ô ö�ö%9%� ò z ûVú/�^û/+ @�� � � ú�'�ý�� ü&*?ú W � �&ª½ú ��� �Q ýµú,� �#@ û�" � �XûVú*ù � ü&� � � �Cý ��� úi�=ü ��ý �M�N� ú � ú � ûAú � � ò l ú,�S* � ��� ���H� ú/"Pý��Vü � ø ?�ö%9 � n%8 7?ò��� ü *fú/� '�ý�� � ø�"#" � ú]üXý �¨?]� A{ý%� � üVý��Xþ ÷

��� òa� ÷a�Y÷ ò �¨� � �Xý � ú ò �K÷ ò ����� �m� � ü � ò V ÷a����� ©�� üVüVý � � ò�T ÷~� ô ö�ö"õ%� ò ø ûAúCü ý�' ? ú C ú �u�Q � û��m� ? � � ú � �Gø ��@ ú/A�� �[�$� A#"��Vý @ � � ù û�'�ý��Gû�" � �^ûAú�ù � ü �&�m�]únû ò l ú,�S* � ��� ���~� ú,"{ý%�Aül�� � � ø ? � ö"õ � n ó ö ò � ø ? ÷

P �&*?ú � ò =?÷ ò l � � þ ��� � � ò ø ÷������ ©�� � � � û � � ò �Ô÷>� ô ö�ö ô � ò ¥ ø � ú � únù�ú � ü��ºAZþ��Oú � úCùDú � ü"#�Vúi�]ý ��� ��ü ��ý � ú � �]ý ��Ý°�#@%� üVú @ � �%� ��ú � ü�ùDú]ü *fý � ��ùF" � úCùDú � üXú � ý �²�ÞC ú,�=üXý���]ý�ùF" � üVú/�i+ ò _�GI.&GI2�2��/2oL~�I´ � ³�-�4�¤��>Ð�6 ò�ô nZõ ô · ô n 7 õ?÷

�"õ

Page 38: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

P û k�ýIª ò�P ÷\�����ß� �S* ��� A{ú � ò �G÷ Q ÷!� ô ö�ö ô G,� ò ¥ ø ��@ ý%� ��ü *fù 7 ö"õ y � ý�' ü°ª � �Vú±'�ý%� �� ú/ª ùDý � �(¯fú � �S*?ý � únû kµþF' � �=üXý��&��U � ü&��ý � + ò ðOLw¾À¿�.&GI¤# /G%01-�45�I¤� O�I¤¨¾DGI-NÁ$�/´hGI-�450&G�2ïf�iîS-�ÂoGI.&�KÐ#6 ò �%n 7 ·�� ô 9Þ÷

P û k�ýIª ò�P ÷������F� �S* ��� A{ú � ò �G÷ Q ÷�� ô ö�ö ô ��� ò ¥ ø � ú/ª�ù�ý � ��¯fú � �S*?ý � ú�û�kµþK' � �=üXý��&��U � ü ��ý � + òï$ÙVð�¾àÚ���³�.�¤HG�2]�I¤�ï­0145�/¤�-�4 Ü<0\GI¤fÉDïH-ºG�-N4m �-�450&G�2~L~�I´ � ³�-�4�¤��>Ð3Ð ò�ô�ô � 7 · ô�ô õ�8?÷V ����� � CI��� ò Y ÷ ò =���� Aµþ ò�� ÷������h� ú/��ú/� ò z¯÷H� ô ö%8 £ � ò ¥�l *?ú � ûVú*ý�'­A �m� û � � �h� � � ú � � ����@ ú,A#� �ý ��� " � � ����� ú � "#�Xý$�CúnûXûAý%�Oª���ü * � *���ú,� � �&�S*#�m� ��� ùDúnù�ý%�Vþf+ ò ï$ÙXð:¾áÚ#Ñ)ïf0/45Ññï3-µGI-µÑ

Lu��´ � ³�-ºÑfâ ò�ô n £ ö�· ô n%8 ó ÷�l ��ùDú � þ��Cý�ùDù �#� ��� � ü ��ý � û ÷V ����� � CI��� ò Y ÷ ò =%��� Aµþ òI� ÷ ò � ú,��ú,� ò z¯÷������\��� ùDú,* ò ø ÷3� ô ö%8�8�� ò ¥ � ùF" � �=ü ý�'�*#��ú/� � �S�S*#��� ���ù�únùDý��XþËûVþµûAüVúnù ûÛý �ã� � � ú � � ����@ ú/A#� �®����@ ý��&��ü *?ù � únû � @%� + ò Ù�¤3-�Ú#�I³�.�¤fGI2M�iîï3³ � �1. 0S��´ � ³�-º�/.ñð ��� 2�450SGI-�45�I¤� �Ã]� ô � ò�ô 9i· ó 8?÷V � ��� ò1ÿ ÷H�����¸�[� � � � þ òf� ÷u� ô ö £}ó � ò ¥ p ú/ª üXý � �Uüiþ$"{ú�ùDú]ü&*?ý � û:'�ý�� �#� �Cý � ûAü � � � � ú �¸�����

� � � ú � � � þ±�]ý � ûiü&� � � � ú � ý�"?ü ��ù\��U � ü ��ý � + ò ¾DG�-5Á��1´hGI-�450SGI2�_}. �&��.&GI´\´O4�¤$�EÃ3â ò � ô�ô ·�"õ�nf÷

V � ��� òPÿ ÷ ò �[� �&� � þ ò�� ÷3����� � �&� @ *Zü ò �K÷�� ô ö�8 ô � ò _}. G�0/-�450&G�2 Ê � -�4�´\4��,G�-N45��¤ ò ø�� ��� únù\�m�ÿ �XúnûXû ò ? ý ��� ý �!����� p ú/ª« ý��&k ÷V � ��ú/ª ��� k ò ø ÷������äl ý�� � ü òDÿ ÷:? ÷\� ô ö%8%9�� òFZ � ü&*?ú ��� �]ý � ûiü&� � � � ú � ý%"Þü ��ùF��U � ü ��ý �ý�'¸" � �Vü � ����� þ ûVú/" � � � A � úå' �#� �=ü ��ý � û ò 4�¤ß�Ô÷�=f÷>¥÷ ÿ ýIª&ú ��� ò ú ��÷ ò ¥ p ý �#� � � ú � �

Z "Þü ��ùF��U � ü ��ý � + ò ø�� �%� úCùF�m� ÿ �Vú�ûVû ò ? ý ��� ý �[���3� p ú/ª« ý��&k ÷W ��?Ë� ô ö�ö 7 � ò JOGI.�Âo�/2�2Lï3³3�1. �I³�-�4�¤H� ^ 4N��.&GI.�Ô�Ñ ðæL~GI-µGI2��&��³��X�Aî¯ïH³3��.&�I³�-�4�¤H�1 ��)���/2��SG� /�

çIè ¡ ò ø P ø l úi�S* � ý � ý @ þ ò:W � � ª½ú ���K?]� APý�� � üXý��Xþ òKZ � '�ý%� � û�*#���Xú ò�P �#@��m���3��÷ g ý��� � '�ý%�Vù � ü ��ý � �]ý � �]ú/� � � �#@ W ��? �Cý � ü � �=ü y � � �CýüVü � ý�APú/�VüXû ò ø P ø l úi�S* � ý � ý @ þ òõ�õ�9 W � � ª½ú ��� ò � � �Cýü ò�Z � ý � Z�¹¯ô"ô n%� ø ò~P �#@��m������ üXú � y¨éIó"ó � ô 9��Zõ � ó � ó$£µônó?ò' �I� y<éIó�ó � ô 9��"õ � ó � ó{ô � 7?ò úCù � � � y � �CýüVü ÷ � ý�APú/�VüXû�ê � ú � ü ÷ �]ý ÷ � k �]÷

W �#@ *?únû ò l�÷�=f÷��G÷ òKg ú/�Xú � �1U ò �G÷��Ô÷������ W ����� Æ � � ü^û ò =f÷ Z ÷�� ô ö%8 £ � ò ¥�?]� � @ ú1��û � ��� úC ú,�]üVý%� ��UCú � ��ùF" � ���/� üO� ��� � �#�m� ü&��ý � ûK� � ûAý � � � ùDú,�S* ��� �m�CûGý �E� T � øw« ¹ � � ÿ | ó 8� ü � � ��U/� �#@ PoQqP "#�Vúi�]ý ��� ��ü ��ý � ú � �]ý �IÝ°�#@�� üVú @ � ��� ��ú � ü^û/+ ò L~�I´ � ³�-µGI-�45�I¤HG�2�¾D�1-NÁ$�iÉ� 4�¤Ùð �%� 2�45�SÉ>¾D�&01Á$G�¤�4501 \GI¤fÉOÌ}¤$��4�¤f�S�1.�4�¤$�¢Ò]Ð ò 9 ô õi·#9 ó 8?÷

W �#@ *?únû ò l�÷�=?÷��G÷ ò ? ú C ��ü ò:� ÷����3� � � �#@ úCü ò =f÷�� ô ö%8���� ò ¥ ø � ú � únù�ú � ü��ºAZþ��Oú � úCùDú � üûAý ��� ü&��ý �Û����@ ý��&� ü&*?ù '�ý%�ë"#�Vý%A � úCù ûâý�' ûAü � � �=ü � � ���{����� ûVý � � � ùDú,�S* ��� ���nû/+ òLu��´ � ³�-N³�-µGI-�45�I¤fGI2f¾D�/-5Á��,ÉI �4�¤Âð ��� 2�45�SÉF¾D�S0�Á�GI¤�4501 OGI¤fÉ�Ì}¤���4�¤H�S�/.�4�¤��K¶HÒ ò 9 ófô ·9�õ ó ÷

Y¨ì��@ ûAü ��íý�ù òqQ ÷ ò ? � ��@ ò)ÿ ÷<�����±? ý ��� ò�T ÷ © ÷�� ô ö�ö���� ò*ÿ ý��Vü � A � ú¨*#� @ *±"{ú,��'�ý%�Vù ��� �]úV P �M� �ºA � ûAú �:? ú C ú � � � Q ? ø � ò 4�¤K¥ ÿ �Xý��]úCú � � �#@ ûYý�'"ü&*?ú � � � ü * � � ø � T ý � '�ú,�Vú � �]úý � ÿ � � ����� ú � ÿ �Vý��CúnûXû�� �#@ '�ý�� � �/��ú � ü&�(¯H� T ý�ùF" � ü&� �#@ + ò � � ø � ò "�" ÷����"ö�·�� ó%7 ÷

� 7

Page 39: Home - STFC Computational Mathematics Group · 2018. 10. 29. · ¦I ¬ ® ¬,® ~b~ ® ¬ ~b~ ® ¶ ®o · ] ¬ ~ ® ¬ = « =} «

? + P � �]ú ��� ú � ü ò =f÷ « ÷­� ô ö�ö"õ%� ò z ü&� � ��û � ü&��ý �!� ú�"#� ;úi�]ý �3� � ü&��ý �#� ú � �Xû ;ú �1;úCùDú � ü ��" � � � ;ú �1;úCùDú � ü"{ý � � �m� � ;ú�ûAý ��� ü ��ý �K� úo"��Vý%A �NîúCùDúnû � + ý%"Þü ��ùF��û � ü&��ý �¢� ú @ � ����� úLü � � ��� ú òÿ * ü *fúnû ��û ò�°pñÿ l � Pop � PoPo�°W l�÷

Z �Aü&��U ò �Ô÷ òGÿ � � û kZþ ò ÿ ÷��K÷������×l�� þ � ý�� ò �G÷�? ÷�� ô ö�8���� ò ¥ z�� �]ý ��� ��ü ��ý ������� þÇûAü � A � úú � úCùDú � ü��ºAµþ��Uú � únù�ú � ü ����@ ý��&� ü&*?ù û!'�ý�� � þ �3� ùF���§"#�Xý�A � únùDû,+ ò Lu��´ � ³�-N³�-µGI-�45�I¤fGI2¾M�/-NÁ$�iÉ� �4�¤Ùð ��� 2�45�SÉh¾D�S0�Á�GI¤3450� \G�¤HÉ\Ì}¤���4�¤H�S�/.�4�¤��¢¶HÒ ò 9�9��I·�9���ö?÷

� �S* � ���Sk ò l�÷#� ô ö�ö%�%� ò ¥�� ý � ��¯fú � T *?ý � únû kµþ:' � �=üXý��&��U � ü&��ý � ûa'�ý%�Lû�" � �XûVúo"��Vúi�]ý �3� � ü&��ý � ú/�^û,+ òï$ÙVð�¾àÚ���³�.�¤HG�2]�I¤�ï­0145�/¤�-�4 Ü<0\GI¤fÉDïH-ºG�-N4m �-�450&G�2~L~�I´ � ³�-�4�¤��>Ð�ï òÞó 9 ó · ó"ó õ?÷� �S* ��� A{ú � ò �G÷ Q ÷ ò Y�ýµý � ü&U ò =f÷ P ÷~����� � ú/��ûVû ò<Q ÷ P ÷�� ô ö�8Zõ�� ò ¥ ø ùDý ���#�m� � ûVþµûAüVúnùý�' ����@ ý��&� ü&*?ù û�'�ý%� �#� �]ý � ûiü&� � � � ú � ùF� � ��ùF��U � ü ��ý � + ò ðOLw¾ ¿�. G�¤# /G�0/-�45�I¤# Ë�I¤

¾MG�-5Á��1´hGI-�450SGI21ïf�AîS-NÂoG�. ��ÐHÐ ò?ó{ô öI· ó�ó n?÷� � ü *?ú � ò ø ÷q=f÷:� ô ö%8�ö%� ò ¥ ø ����3��� þµû ��û ý�'¯ûVý�ùDú�ú � únù�ú � ü��ºAZþ��Oú � úCùDú � üÂüVú,�S* � ��Æ � ú�û/+ ò

Lu��´ � ³�-ºG�-N45��¤HG�2q¾M�/-NÁ$�iÉ� X4�¤Ðð ��� 2�45�Sɧ¾D�&01Á$G�¤�4501 ¨G�¤HɨÌ}¤$��4�¤f�&�/.�4�¤��M6�ï ò 9 £µô ·9�8 £ ÷

� £