house democrats analysis of fy 2011-12 corbett budget

Upload: jmicek

Post on 08-Apr-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    1/59

    2011/12GovernorsExecutiveBudgetAnAnalysisofGovernorCorbettsBudgetProposal

    March22,2011

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    2/59

    TableofContents

    Summary........................................................................................................................................................ i

    The

    Commonwealth

    Operating

    Budget

    ........................................................................................................

    1

    GeneralFund................................................................................................................................................. 3

    Deposits.................................................................................................................................................... 6

    OutlookforTaxandNonTaxRevenue................................................................................................. 6

    FundingModifications.......................................................................................................................... 7

    Expenditures............................................................................................................................................. 9

    PensionContributions......................................................................................................................... 12

    PennsylvaniaEmployeeBenefitsTrustFund...................................................................................... 14

    CommonwealthDebt.......................................................................................................................... 14

    Agriculture.......................................................................................................................................... 14

    BoardofProbationandParole........................................................................................................... 15

    CommunityandEconomicDevelopment........................................................................................... 16

    ConservationandNaturalResources.................................................................................................. 19

    Corrections.......................................................................................................................................... 19

    Education............................................................................................................................................ 20

    PreKthrough12Education............................................................................................................ 20

    HigherEducation............................................................................................................................. 24

    EmergencyManagementAgency....................................................................................................... 25

    EnvironmentalProtection................................................................................................................... 25

    ExecutiveOffices................................................................................................................................. 26

    PennsylvaniaCommissiononCrimeandDelinquency................................................................... 26

    JuvenileCourtJudgesCommission................................................................................................. 27

    FishandBoatCommission.................................................................................................................. 27

    GeneralAssembly............................................................................................................................... 27

    GeneralServices.................................................................................................................................. 27

    Health.................................................................................................................................................. 28

    HousingFinanceAgency..................................................................................................................... 29

    InfrastructureInvestmentAuthority(PENNVEST).............................................................................. 29

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    3/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    TableofContents(continued)

    Insurance............................................................................................................................................. 29

    Judiciary.............................................................................................................................................. 29

    LaborandIndustry.............................................................................................................................. 30

    PublicWelfare..................................................................................................................................... 31

    MedicalAssistance.......................................................................................................................... 32

    DisabilityPrograms......................................................................................................................... 36

    IncomeMaintenance...................................................................................................................... 38

    OtherHumanServices.................................................................................................................... 38

    ChildDevelopment......................................................................................................................... 39

    MilitaryandVeteransAffairs............................................................................................................. 40

    State.................................................................................................................................................... 40

    StatePolice......................................................................................................................................... 40

    Transportation.................................................................................................................................... 41

    Treasury.............................................................................................................................................. 41

    MotorLicenseFund.................................................................................................................................... 41

    Highways&Bridges................................................................................................................................ 42

    LotteryFund:ProgramsforSeniorCitizens................................................................................................ 42

    TobaccoSettlementFund........................................................................................................................... 44

    PropertyTaxReliefFund............................................................................................................................. 46

    PublicTransportationTrustFund&PublicTransportationAssistanceFund............................................. 47

    MassandCommunityTransit................................................................................................................. 47

    ATTACHMENTAStateGeneralFundBudgetComparison.......................................................................... I

    ATTACHMENTBStateGeneralFundandFederalARRAFunds................................................................ III

    ATTACHMENTCRankedAgencySubtotalComparisontoPriorYear....................................................... IV

    ATTACHMENTDMotorLicenseFundOverview....................................................................................... VI

    ATTACHMENTEPennDOTMotorLicenseFundExpenditures................................................................ VII

    ATTACHMENTFTransitandRail............................................................................................................. VIII

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    4/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Summary

    On

    March

    8,

    2011,

    Governor

    Tom

    Corbett

    presented

    his

    2011/12

    budget

    proposal

    to

    the

    General

    Assembly. The Governors 2011/12 Executive Budget represents a total Commonwealth operating

    budgetof$63.6billioninstate(General,SpecialandOtherfunds)andfederalfunds.Thisrepresentsa

    decreaseof$3.3billion(4.9%)comparedtothe2010/11budgetof$66.8billion.AftertheGovernors

    proposedcuts tothe2010/11budget totaling$369million inGeneralandSpecialFunds,his2011/12

    budgetproposalreducestotalspendingby$2.9billion(4.3percent).

    The Governors 2011/12 Executive Budget proposes $27.331 billion in General Fund state

    expenditures.Incomparison,the2010/11enactedbudgetincluded$28.035billionintotalexpenditures

    fromstateandfederaloffsetfunds,adeclineof$866million. TheGovernorproposesmovingTobacco

    Settlement Funds and related appropriations to the General Fund for 2011/12. If these shifted

    appropriations are removed, spending actually declines by $1.2 billion dollars. This provides a moreaccurateanddirectcomparisonwiththecurrentyear.

    Gov.CorbettproposessignificantlyreducingoreliminatingmanyappropriationsintheGeneralFund.

    In addition, he proposes numerous cost containment measures in the Department of Public Welfare

    (DPW).Intotalthesecutsequal$2.6billion.Also,inadditiontofundingcuts,Gov.Corbettsproposal

    includesmajorbudget,programandpolicychangeswithintheDepartmentsofEducationandPublic

    Welfare.

    Gov. Corbetts budget proposes significant cuts to General Fund programs, eliminates 103 line

    item appropriations, eliminates over 1,500 state jobs, and consolidates 55 appropriations

    throughoutsixagencies.

    Gov.Corbettsproposalalso includesa $540.1 million increase in fund modifications to the General

    Fund.Note90percent($479million)ofthesefundmodificationsaretheresultoftheproposedtransfer

    ofTobaccoSettlementFundstotheGeneralFund.

    Whilestatespending isreducedandstatetaxesdonot increase,Gov. Corbetts proposal will impact

    the checkbooks of Pennsylvanians by directly shifting costs to citizens and local entities (such as

    countiesandschooldistricts).AspolicymakersconsiderCorbettsproposal,theymustcarefullyexamine

    theimpactitwillhaveontheirconstituents,includinglocaltaxincreases.

    The Governors proposal only increases funding in a handful of agencies largely reflecting the

    replacement of federal offset funds, necessary inflationary increases, and legally mandated

    requirements.

    Fordetailbyappropriation,pleasereferenceourspreadsheetdocumentGovernor'sProposed201112

    Budget:StateandFederalAppropriations(GeneralFund) March11,2011,availableonourwebsite

    (www.hacd.net). Fordetailbydepartmentsubtotal,pleasereferenceAttachmentsAandC.

    i

    http://www.hacd.net/http://www.hacd.net/
  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    5/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    TheCommonwealthOperatingBudget

    The

    Governors

    2011/12

    Executive

    Budget

    represents

    a

    total

    Commonwealth

    operating

    budget

    of

    $63.6billioninstateandfederalfunds.Thisrepresentsadecreaseofapproximately$3.3billionor4.9

    percentcomparedtotheupdatedfiscalyear2010/11budgetof$66.8billion.

    The Commonwealths operating budget includes the state General Fund, federal funds, the Motor

    License Fund, and other special funds (i.e., Lottery Fund and Tobacco Settlement Fund). Often,

    policymakers focus on state General Fund expenditure trends; however, since funding for major

    programs(suchasMedicalAssistance)canstraddlemultiplefunds,thefocusonanysinglefundinstead

    of total operating funds can significantly distort the facts. The importance of examining combined

    operatingfundsisexemplifiedinGovernorCorbettsbudgetrequestwiththedisappearanceoffederal

    offsetfunds,aswellastheproposedtransferoftheTobaccoSettlementFundandsomeofitsprograms

    totheGeneralFund.

    Thepiechartbelowshowsthedistributionofthe2011/12ExecutiveBudgetbyfund.Statefunds,ledby

    theGeneralFund,represent65percentoftotalspendingandfederalfundsaccountfor35percent.

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page1

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    6/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page2

    Comparedto2010/11,stateexpendituresfromallfundsincreasebyabout$1.5billionforthe2011/12

    budget year, or about 3.8 percent, and federal funds decrease by $4.8 billion or 17.8 percent. The

    reductioninfederalfundingreflectsthedisappearanceofmoniesmadeavailabletoPennsylvaniafrom

    the

    American

    Recovery

    and

    Reinvestment

    Act

    of

    2009

    (ARRA)

    and

    subsequent

    legislation

    enacted

    by

    Congress in 2010 which helped states address unprecedented budget deficits during the current

    economicdownturn.

    ARRA provided significant fiscal relief to the states by temporarily increasing the Federal Medical

    AssistancePercentage(FMAP)forstateMedicaidprogramsandbyallocatingFiscalStabilizationFunds

    whichstatesusedforeducationandotherpublicsafetyservices.AsauthorizedunderARRA,theFiscal

    Stabilization Funds were available through fiscal year 2010/11 and the enhanced FMAP through

    December2010.InAugust2010,CongresspassedlegislationthatextendedtheenhancedFMAPthrough

    June2011.ThissameactprovidednewEducation JobsFundstothestateswhich is intendedtobe

    usedforthe2010/11schoolyear.

    Overthepastthreefiscalyears,Pennsylvaniahasutilized these federal fundstooffsetexpenditures

    whichotherwisewouldhavebeenpaidforwithstateGeneralFunds.Whilestimulusfundswerenot

    enough to allow for normal growth in expenditures, Pennsylvania was able to mitigate some of the

    effectsofreducedrevenuesonprograms.

    FiscalStabilizationFundshavebeenusedtohelpfundtheagencybudgetsfortheDepartmentsofEducation,CorrectionsandGeneralServices.

    TheadditionalfederalreimbursementsearnedundertheARRAFMAPhavebeenappliedtoMedicalAssistanceandotherMedicaidrelatedprogramsthatserveindividualswith

    intellectualdisabilities,autism,andphysicaldisabilities.TheARRAFMAPreflectsstateMedicaid

    expenditures

    that

    are

    temporarily

    shifted

    to

    the

    federal

    government

    during

    the

    stimulus

    period.

    Gov.CorbettproposestousethenewEducationJobsFundstopayforbasiceducationin2010/11.

    ThebargraphonthefollowingpageillustratesfederalfiscalrelieffundsusedtosupportGeneralFund

    budgetsfrom2008/09through2010/11.AsproposedbyGov.Corbett,thesefundsarenolonger

    availableafterJune30,2011.Foramoredetailedlookattheapplicationoffederalfundstooffsetstate

    expenditures,pleaseseeAttachmentB.

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    7/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    $1.239B

    $2.698B$3.005B

    $0.00

    $0.50

    $1.00

    $1.50

    $2.00

    $2.50

    $3.00

    2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12

    FederalFiscalReliefDisappears(DollarsinBillions)

    ARRA FMAP ARRA FiscalStabilizationFund Education JobsFund

    GeneralFund

    TheGeneralFundisthemajoroperatingfundoftheCommonwealth,representingthelargestportionof

    state and federal spending. It also is the fund over which policymakers have the most influence on

    expenditures.

    Governor Corbetts 2011/12 state General Fund budget request is $27.3 billion. The budget year

    reductionstospendingaredeepandaclearunderstandingofacomparisonbetweenthebudgetyear

    andcurrentyeariscomplicatedbyproposedfundtransfersandfederaloffsetfunds.Consequently,an

    analysisoftheproposedexpenditurechangesisexaminedunderthesubsectiononExpenditureslater

    inthissection.

    TheExecutive Budget assumes $27.3 billion instate GeneralFunds available to spend in 2011/12, an

    increase of nearly $1.8 billion compared to 2010/11. These available state funds reflect the Corbett

    Administrationsupwardrevisiontothe2010/11revenueestimateandproposedchangestotaxesand

    otherfundingsourcesintheupcomingyear.

    The financial statement on the following page provides an overview of Governor Corbetts revenue

    assumptions and expenditure recommendations. A detailed discussion of General Fund revenues and

    expendituresimmediatelyisprovidedlaterinthissection.

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page3

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    8/59

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    9/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    intergovernmentaltransferfundsstillheldinreserveandavailabletouseinlieuofstate

    GeneralFunds.

    o Anoffsettingreductionof$87millioninfederalARRAFMAPfunds. Also on the expenditure side, the Governor proposes a $178 million cut in 2010/11 state

    appropriations(reportedascurrentyearlapsesonthefinancialstatement).Thisincludeshis

    proposal to use the new federal Education Job Funds to offset a reduction of $388 million in

    2010/11stateexpendituresforbasiceducation.

    On the revenue side, Governor Corbett assumes 2010/11 revenue collections will exceedestimateby$78millionanduses$180millionofadditionalrevenuesassociatedwithunspent

    fundsfromprioryearbudgets(reportedasprioryearlapsesonthefinancialstatement).

    Disappearingfederalfiscalreliefcombinedwiththe lossofonetimerevenuesourcesused in2010/11

    ledtoa2011/12budgetgapthatweestimatedwouldexceed$4billion.Toaddressthisproblem,Gov.

    Corbettsproposalprimarilyreducesexpenditures incombinationwithproposalstomodifyGeneral

    Fundsourceswithoutadditionaltaxes. OuranalysisoftheExecutiveBudgetrevealsthefollowing:

    Expenditures are cut $2.6 billion. This includes only those state appropriations that wereeliminatedorreduced,aswellascostcontainment initiativeswithintheDepartmentofPublic

    Welfarebudget.

    Newfundsavailabletospendtotal$1.4billion.Thisincludesthe$586millionbalancecarriedover from 2010/11, projected growth in revenue receipts of $615 million, $9.1 million in

    changestotaxcreditprograms,andproposedfundmodificationsforanadditional$215million

    (weonlycountthatpartofthetobaccorevenuesthataretransferredtotheGeneralFundand

    notearmarkedforaspecificpurpose).

    Pensioncosts,whilereducedsignificantlybyAct20of2010,continuetorisebyapproximately$294million.

    Numerousbudgetdriversimpactthe2011/12budget:

    Over$3billioninfederaloffsetfundsincluding$2.7billionofARRAfundsand$388millionofEducationJobFundsarenolongeravailabletocoverGeneralFundexpenditures.

    Anadditional$250millioninfederalfiscalreliefwasprovidedtoPennsylvaniain2010/11viaareductioninthemonthlyMedicarePartDpaymentsowedtothefederalgovernmentandis

    nolongeravailable.

    $869millioninonetimefundingsourcesusedin2010/11arenolongeravailablein2011/12.This includes the $121 million redirected from the Tobacco Settlement Fund to help cover

    pensioncostswhichwouldhaveotherwisebeenpaidwithGeneralFunds.

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page5

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    10/59

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    11/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    $20.56 $20.06$21.31

    $22.83 $24.31

    $25.85

    $27.45 $27.93

    $25.53

    $27.65 $26.79$27.95

    $0

    $4

    $8

    $12

    $16

    $20

    $24

    $28

    GeneralFundRevenues(DollarsinBillions)

    NonTax Tax

    ThebargraphalsoshowstheGeneralFunduseofnonrecurringrevenues(largelytransfersfromother

    funds)tohelpbalancebudgetsinrecentyears.ThisisillustratedbythenontaxportionofGeneralFund

    revenues.WhiletheExecutiveBudgetanticipatescontinuedgrowthintaxcollectionsthrough2011/12,

    itdoesnotexpecttheserecurringGeneralFundrevenuestofullyreboundtotheir2007/08peaklevelof

    $25.37billion.

    FundingModifications

    Although Gov. Corbett does not propose any new taxes or depend on onetime funds from liquor

    storeprivatization, the2011/12budgetdoescontainproposals fornewrevenuegeneratedthrough

    cutstocurrentlyslatedtaxcreditprograms.GeneralFundrevenuesalsoareproposedtobebolstered

    primarily by transfers from other funds, especially the Tobacco Settlement Fund. The Governors

    proposedGeneralFundrevenuemodificationstotal$540.1million.

    Netproposedchangesof$9.1milliontotaxcreditprogramsareasfollows:

    Adecreaseof$15million inthecapoftheFilmTaxCreditwhich isexpectedtoresult in$5.1millionofadditionalrevenuein2011/12.

    Adecreaseof$12.4millioninthecapoftheJobCreationTaxCreditwhichisexpectedtoresultinanadditional$4.2millionin2011/12.

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page7

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    12/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page8

    An increase of $15 million in the cap of the Research and Development Tax Credit which isexpectedtoresultinarevenuelossof$200,000in2011/12.

    Gov.Corbettsproposalincludesalmost$531millioninnontaxrevenuetransferstotheGeneralFund.

    Thesetransfersareasfollows:

    $8.3millionfromthePennsylvaniaHigherEducationAssistanceAgencythroughthetransferofunusedfundsfrom2010/11.

    $44.0millionfromthecontinuedredirectionofmovingviolationsurchargesauthorizedbytheCatastrophic Loss Benefits Continuation Fund, traditionally deposited in the Medical Care

    AvailabilityandReductionofError(MCARE)Fund.

    $478.6millionfromtheproposaltomovetheTobaccoSettlementFundintotheGeneralFund.Thiswouldincludea$140milliontransferoftheremainingbalanceaswellas$338.6millionin

    revenues from the Master Settlement Agreement that would accrue to the General Fund in

    2011/12.Notethat$324million inTobaccoSettlementFundexpenditureswouldalsotransfer

    totheGeneralFundleavinganetincreaseinnewstateGeneralFundsof$154million.

    This budget provides a tax benefit this year to corporations worth roughly $200 million over the

    currentandbudgetyearbyallowing100percentbonusdepreciation.Corporationsthatpurchasenew

    equipmentcandepreciatethefullvalueinthecurrentyear,asopposedtodepreciatingitoveraperiod.

    This lowers the tax liability of corporations in the shortterm; however, offsetting tax liability in

    subsequent years is then higher. This bonus already has been granted to corporations via a policy

    decisionissuedbytheDepartmentofRevenueinFebruary2011andappliestothelastquarterof2010

    through 2011. The policy decision resulted from the federal Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance

    ReauthorizationandJobCreationActof2010,whichallowsforbonusdepreciationonthefederallevel.

    Statelawisambiguousinrelationtofederaltaxlawonthispoint.

    The GovernorsBudgetreferences severalotherchanges to tax rates and taxcredits;however, it is

    importanttonotethatthesechanges,listedbelow,arealreadyscheduledtotakeplaceassetforthin

    currentstatute.

    Gov.Corbettassumesareinstatementof thecapitalstock and franchise taxphaseout,a taxreductionworthroughly$70million in thebudgetyear.Thisbudgetproposal isbasedon the

    currentlyscheduledphaseoutset instatutebyAct48of2009.Theratesetforcalendaryear

    2011 is 2.89 mills; 2012 at 1.89 mills; 2013 at 0.89 mills; and is scheduled to be completely

    phasedoutbeginningin2014.

    TheGovernorsproposalclaimstoincreasetheEducationalImprovementTaxCredit;howeverthe proposal is commensurate with existing law which increases the program cap from $60

    millionto$75millionassetforthinAct48of2009andAct46of2010.

    AccordingtotheGovernorsExecutiveBudgetdocument,thisbudgetprovidessignificanttaxcreditsfor

    jobcreatorshoweverthesetaxcreditprogramsarealreadysetinstatuteatthefollowingidentified

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    13/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    levels:NeighborhoodAssistanceTaxCredit($18million);CoalWasteRemovalandUltraCleanFuels

    Tax Credit ($18 million); and Resource Enhancement and Protection Tax Credit ($10 million). He

    proposes to reduce the Film Production Tax Credit ($60 million) and Job Creation Tax Credit ($10

    million).

    Expenditures

    The Executive Budget proposes $27.3 billion in state General Fund expenditures for 2011/12.This

    requestincludes$324millioninprogramexpendituresthatwerefundedpreviouslyundertheTobacco

    SettlementFund(thisispartofGovernorCorbettstobaccofundsinitiativewhichisdescribedunderthe

    TobaccoSettlementFundsectionofthisdocument).ThefollowingpiechartshowshowtheGovernors

    2011/12spendingproposalisdistributedamongmajorprogramareas.

    *Includes$324.1millionoftobaccofundedprogramsthattheExecutiveBudgetproposestomovetotheGeneral

    Fundin2011/12.

    Comparing2011/12GeneralFundexpenditureswiththecurrent2010/11fiscalyearisnotsoclearcut

    andrequiresabriefexplanation.Amajordifficultyisthatthefederaloffsetfunds($3.055billion)usedin

    2010/11 and the proposed transfer of Tobacco Settlement Fund expenditures ($324 million) to the

    GeneralFundinthebudgetyearmasksastraightforwardunderstandingofthefinancialstatement.

    Typically, expenditures reported on the financial statement only would refer to state General Fund

    appropriations.However,duringthefederalstimulusperiod,budgetmakershaverationalizedthatthe

    appropriationnumbershouldalsoincludefederaloffsetfundsusedtosupporttheGeneralFundbudget

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page9

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    14/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page10

    in order to maintain perspective on state spending trends. The table below illustrates alternative

    approaches tounderstandingCorbetts proposed changes to General Fundbudget year expenditures:

    thefirstapproachexaminestotalappropriations(includingfederaloffsetfunds)andthesecondfocuses

    only

    on

    state

    General

    Fund

    appropriations.

    Each

    method

    is

    appropriate

    and

    provides

    different

    but

    helpfulinformation.

    Additionally,foreachapproach,thetableshowsthebudgetyearexpenditurenumberswithandwithout

    the proposed transfer of Tobacco Settlement Fund expenditures to the General Fund. Yeartoyear

    comparisonsaresignificantlydistortedwhenexpendituresnewtotheGeneralFundinthebudgetyear

    arespent fromadifferent fund in theprioryear.BecausetheTobaccoSettlementFundexpenditures

    werenotpartofthe2010/11GeneralFundBudget,theirinclusioninthebudgetyearexaggeratesthe

    growth inGeneralFundexpendituresby$324million.Removingtheseexpendituresfacilitatesamore

    appropriatecomparisonbetweenthetwofiscalyears.

    Proposed

    General

    Fund

    Expenditures

    Analysis

    2011/12Governor'sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    (inmillionsofdollars)

    2010/11

    Updated

    2011/12WithTobacco

    FundExpenditures

    2011/12Without

    TobaccoFund

    Expenditures

    $'s $'s Change $'s Change

    Appropriations* $28,035 $27,331 $27,007

    Plus:SupplementalAppropriations $163 $0 $0

    Expenditures $28,198 $27,331 $867 $27,007 $1,191

    Less:FederalOffsetFunds $3,055 $0 $0

    Subtotal StateAppropriationsOnly $25,143 $27,331 $2,188 $27,007 $1,864

    TheGovernorsBudgetHighlightsshowhisproposedGeneralFundbudgetdecliningby$866million

    from $28.198 billion in the current year to $27.331 billion in 2011/12. The decline represents a

    comparison between the spending request for 2011/12, which includes the transfer of Tobacco

    SettlementFundexpenditures,andanupdated2010/11spendingnumberthat includesfederaloffset

    funds ($3.055 billion) and supplemental appropriations ($163 million). This approach provides an

    understanding that accounts for the disappearance of federal offset funds and is the approach

    referenced in the Governors literature. The more appropriate comparison, after accounting for the

    shift of Tobacco Settlement Fund expenditures into the General Fund, shows spending actually

    declines by $1.2 billion dollars this is the approach used in Attachment C which compares stateappropriationsplusfederaloffsets,byagency,forfiscalyears2009/10through2011/12.

    To understand what is happening with stateonly funds in the General Fund, a further adjustment is

    made to 2010/11 expenditures to remove federal offset funds and focus on the state appropriations

    only. Under this approach, state spending in the Governors 2011/12 budget proposal increases by

    nearly $2.2 billion, instead of declining $866 million. Stateonly spending increases by $1.9 billion

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    15/59

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    16/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    The pie chart that follows shows how the $2.6 billion in state General Fund cuts are distributed by

    programarea.Aswehadanticipated,thevastmajorityofthecutsfallwithintheareasofeducationand

    publicwelfare.Educationwouldbe cutby$1.86billion, representing71percentof total cuts.Public

    Welfare

    would

    be

    cut

    by

    $519

    million,

    representing

    of

    20

    percent

    of

    total

    cuts.

    The

    remaining

    cuts

    are

    distributedthroughoutotheragenciesandprograms.

    The following sectionsdiscussGeneral Fundbudget issues aswell as significantbudget andpolicy

    changesbyagency(inalphabeticalorder).AsmoredetailsemergeregardingGov.Corbettsproposed

    budgetandpolicychanges,ourofficewillcontinuetoprovideuptodate,detailedanalyses.Again,for

    detailonexpenditure levelsfor individualappropriations,pleasereferenceourspreadsheetdocument

    Governor'sProposed2011/12Budget:StateandFederalAppropriations(GeneralFund)March11,2011,availableonourwebsite(www.hacd.net).

    PensionContributionsPrior to the enactment of Act 120 of 2010, both the Public School Employees Retirement System(PSERS)andtheStateEmployeesRetirementSystem(SERS)facedadramaticcontributionratespikein

    2012/13.Withoutthislegislativeaction,combinedtotalemployercontributions(baseduponpercentage

    ofpayroll)wouldhave risen toapproximately$5.8 billion ($4.2billion forPSERSand$1.7 billion for

    SERS).TheGeneralFundportionofthistotalcostwouldhavebeen$3.1billion.

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page12

    http://www.hacd.net/http://www.hacd.net/
  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    17/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page13

    ForPSERS,theemployercontributionratewouldhaveincreasedfrom10.22percentin2011/12tomore

    than 28.71 percent in 2012/13, equating to additional contributions of $2.7 billion, affecting school

    districtsandtheCommonwealth.ForSERS,theemployercontributionratewouldhaveincreasedfrom8

    percent

    in

    2011/12

    to

    more

    than

    26

    percent

    in

    2012/13,

    equating

    to

    additional

    contributions

    of

    more

    than $1.2 billion. The General Fund only portion of this combined increase in 2012/13 would have

    been$2.1billionandlocalschooldistrictswouldhaveexperiencedanincreasedcostof$1.2billion.

    Act 120 of 2010 (House Bill 2497), tempered this dramatic rate spike by instituting changes to the

    actuarialmethodology,reducingbenefitsforfutureemployees,andapplyingcontributionratecollars

    tosmooththeimpactofthespike.AsaresultofAct120,theGeneralFundwillrealizeareductionof

    retirementexpendituresofapproximately$122million in2011/12,$1.8billion in2012/13and$1.6

    billionin2013/14,comparedtopreviousprojections.Thechartbelowcomparesemployercontribution

    ratesandtheGeneralFundportionofexpectedcostswithandwithouttheenactmentofAct120.This

    charthasbeenupdatedtoreflectPSERScurrentactuarialvaluationdata.

    Fiscal

    Year

    TotalEstimatedCostpriorto

    Act120of2010

    TotalEstimatedCostasaresultof

    Act120of2010 GENERAL

    FUND

    SAVINGS

    (inmillions)

    Employer

    Contribution

    Rate

    GeneralFund

    StateShare

    (inmillions)

    Employer

    Contribution

    Rate

    GeneralFund

    StateShare*

    (inmillions)

    PSERS SERS PSERS SERS PSERS SERS PSERS SERS

    PSERS+

    SERS

    201011 5.64% 5.00% $419.1 $148.5 5.64% 5.00% $419.1 $148.5 $0

    201112 10.22% 8.00% $793.2 $245.5 8.65% 8.00% $671.6 $245.5 $122

    201213 28.71% 26.71% $2,299.9 $846.0 12.19% 11.50% $976.8 $364.0 $1,805

    201314 31.20% 29.27% $2,579.3 $957.5 16.69% 16.00% $1,380.0 $523.5 $1,633

    201415 32.35% 27.77% $2,762.8 $938.5 21.18% 20.50% $1,809.0 $693.0 $1,199

    201516 31.66% 27.51% $2,796.2 $960.5 23.66% 25.00% $2,089.5 $873.0 $794

    201617 31.13% 27.14% $2,846.3 $978.5 24.50% 28.25% $2,240.2 $1,018.5 $566

    201718 30.47% 26.69% $2,886.8 $994.5 25.27% 27.79% $2,394.2 $1,035.5 $452

    NOTE: Governor'sproposedbudgetprovides$615,086,000forPSERSGeneralFundstatesharein2011/12. Thisdecreaseis

    attributedtothequarterlaginthestatespayment.

    *Generalfundstateshareassumes55%oftotalforPSERSand50%oftotalforSERS

    PSERSquarterlagisnotpartofcalculations

    Gov.Corbetts2011/12proposedbudget accounts for thecontributionratesset forth inAct120of

    2010. A quarter lag in Commonwealth payments accounts for the difference between the proposed

    budgets$615millionandtheabovechartsprojectionof$672million.

    In2010/11, theTobaccoSettlementFundsubsidized$121 million of the General Fund portionof the

    school employers pension contribution amount. For 2011/12, the budget proposal assumes full

    paymentofthesecostsfromtheGeneralFundSchoolEmployeesRetirementappropriationunderthe

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    18/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page14

    DepartmentofEducation.Noteaportionoftheemployercontributionamountpaysforthehealthcare

    costs,keepinginlinewiththetraditionofTobaccoSettlementFundsbeinglinkedtohealthcarerelated

    expenditures.

    PennsylvaniaEmployeeBenefitsTrustFund

    The Pennsylvania Employees Benefits Trust Fund (PEBTF) was created as the result of a collective

    bargainingagreementbetweentheCommonwealthofPennsylvaniaandCouncil13oftheAmerican

    FederationofState,CountyandMunicipalEmployees(AFSCME).Thecompanyadministershealthcare

    insurance benefits to approximately 84,000 eligible state employees and their dependents, 60,000

    retireesandtheirdependents,aswellasadditionalemployergroups,suchasactiveemployeesatthe

    Public School Employees Retirement System (PSERS) and the State Employees Retirement System

    (SERS).

    Inordertoavoidrollingfurloughsofemployees,GovernorRendellandunionrepresentativesagreedto

    a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) in 2009. Because the PEBTF fund had a significant reservebalance,theCommonwealthpayments toPEBTFwere temporarilyreducedby20percentovera15

    month period (April 2009 through June 2010), resulting in a savings to the Commonwealth of

    approximately$177million.Repaymentofthisloanwassettobegininthefallof2010.

    Currently, the Corbett Administration is engaged in talks with union representatives regarding PEBTF

    payment assumptions in 2010/11 and 2011/12. Note the numbers assumed for both years in the

    ExecutiveBudgetdocumentreflectmaintainingareducedpaymentof$400peremployee,asunderthe

    aforementionedMOUagreement.Theseassumptionsresultinasavingsofanadditional$7075million

    in2010/11andasavingsofnearly$82millionin2011/12.

    CommonwealthDebt

    TheGovernorsExecutiveBudgetcallsfor increasedstateappropriationstotheTreasury.The increase

    largely is driven by General Obligation debt service costs. The General Obligation debt service

    appropriation under Treasury has increased by $81.5 million over the prior years levels, to $1.056

    billion.

    Even with the increases in debt service, Pennsylvanias debt levels are very manageable. The

    Commonwealth currently enjoys solid bond ratings. Pennsylvanias ratings are Aa1 from Moodys

    InvestorService,AAfromStandardandPoorsRatingServiceandAA+fromFitchInvestors.Accordingto

    Standard&Poorscriteria,debtasapercentofpersonal incomebelow threepercent isconsidereda

    lowdebtburden.Pennsylvaniasratioiscurrently2.3percent.

    Agriculture

    UndertheGovernorsbudgetproposalfor2011/12,theDepartmentofAgriculturereceivesanumber

    of cuts, many carrying forward budgetary freezes from the 2010/11 budget. The following programs

    wouldbeeliminated:AgriculturalExcellence,AgricultureResearch,AgriculturePromotion,Education

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    19/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    and Exports, Hardwoods Research and Promotion,Animal Indemnities, Livestock Show,Open Dairy

    Show,FoodMarketingandResearch,CropInsurance,andFarmSchoolNutrition.

    Asinotheragencies,Gov.Corbettproposestheconsolidationofnumerouslinesinthedepartment.

    Agency/ExistingProgram ProposedProgram

    Agriculture

    Governor'sAdvisoryCouncilonRural

    AffairsGeneralGovernmentOperations

    AgriculturalConservationEasement

    Administration

    NutrientManagementAdministration

    JuniorDairyShows YouthShows

    4HClubShows

    FutureFarmers

    The proposal includes an increase for the Weights and Administration (through the Motor License

    Fund)tocoversixadditionalpositions.

    This budget proposal transfers the appropriation for the University of Pennsylvanias Veterinary

    Activities fromEducation toAgriculture (VeterinaryActivitiesandCenter for InfectiousDisease). Gov.

    CorbettsproposalalsotransferstheGovernorsAdvisoryCouncilonRuralAffairsfromtheExecutive

    OfficestotheDepartmentofAgriculture.

    BoardofProbationandParole

    TheGovernors2011/12budgetproposes$128.1millionforthePennsylvaniaBoardofProbationand

    Parole(PBPP).Thisisa6.3percentincreaseor$7.5millionmorethan2010/11.TheGovernorindicates

    thatthisincreaseisforadditionalparoleofficers(53)andinvestigators(2)todealwiththebacklogof

    inmates eligible for parole. Inmates cost the Commonwealth approximately $35,000 per year to

    superviseundertheDepartmentofCorrectionsversus$3,000peryearforsupervisionunderProbation

    andParole.

    While PBPPs General Government Operations appropriation and the Sexual Offenders Assessment

    Board will receive increases in funding, funding for Improvement of Adult Probation Services is cut

    nearlytwopercent.Thisreductionwillaffectcountyreimbursements.

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page15

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    20/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page16

    CommunityandEconomicDevelopment

    The overall budget for the Department of Community and Economic Development (DCED) has been

    reducedby32percent,orapproximately$106million.Similarly,127programsfundedinFY10/11have

    beenreducedto57programsintheGovernorsproposal.

    Ofequal importance,regulatory reforms advanced by Corbetts budget will significantly expand the

    authorityoftheDCEDSecretarytoexpediteanypermitoractionpendinginanyagencywherethe

    creationofjobsmaybeimpacted.

    Gov.CorbettsbudgetproposesasignificantredesignofDCEDthroughtheelimination,reduction,and

    consolidationofmultipleprograms.

    Gov. Corbetts budget proposes a restructure of DCED programs aimed to foster opportunities for

    business and communities based upon three core principles: forging partnerships with the private

    sector, advancing performance based initiatives, and increasing the level of competition for state

    resources.

    Gov.CorbettsproposalprovidesfortheLibertyLoanFundAuthorityandLibertyLoanFund(LLF),a$2

    billion fund overseen by a new authority. This program is intended to pool existing economic

    development financing resources for purposes of leveraging private investment for economic

    development opportunities. Importantly, the Governors proposal would dissolve the existing

    CommonwealthFinanceAuthority (CFA)andPennsylvania IndustrialDevelopmentAuthority (PIDA).

    Inaddition,theproposalwoulduse$220million inTobaccoSettlementFunds, traditionallyusedfor

    healthrelatedpurposesforthisnewLibertyLoanFund. Furtherdiscussioncanbefoundinthesection

    entitledTobaccoSettlementFundlaterinthisdocument.

    Thetableonthefollowingpageprovidesalistingoftheprograms/fundsincorporatedintotheLLF.

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    21/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Agency/ExistingProgram ProposedProgram

    Community&EconomicDevelopment

    AlternativeandCleanEnergyProgram

    LibertyLoanFund(LLF)

    BuildingPA

    BusinessinOurSitesGrantsandLoans

    CommunityEconomicDevelopment

    LoanProgram

    CommonwealthFinancingAuthority

    FirstIndustriesAgriculture

    FirstIndustriesTourism

    H2OPrograms(FloodControl,High

    HazardUnsafeDamProjects,Water

    Supply,SanitarySewerandStorm

    WaterProjects)

    HighPerformanceBuildingProgram

    PennsylvaniaIndustrialDevelopment

    Authority

    MachineryandEquipmentLoanFund

    PennsylvaniaMinorityBusiness

    DevelopmentAuthority

    PennsylvaniaPollutionPrevention

    AssistanceProgram

    RenewableEnergyProgram

    GeothermalandWindProjects

    SecondStateLoanProgram

    SolarEnergyProgram

    TaxIncrementFinancingProgram

    Water

    Supply

    and

    Wastewater

    InfrastructureProgram

    SmallBusinessFirstFund

    TobaccoSettlementFundInvestments

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page17

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    22/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Gov.Corbettalsoincludestheconsolidationoftheappropriationsdetailedinthefollowingtable:

    Agency/ExistingProgram ProposedProgram

    Community&EconomicDevelopment

    MarketingtoAttractTourists MarketingtoAttractTourists

    TouristPromotionAssistance

    PennPortOperations

    PennPORTS

    PortofPittsburgh

    PortofErie

    PhiladelphiaRegionalPortAuthority

    Operations

    NavigationalSystem

    GoodsMovementandIntermodal

    Coordination

    OpportunityGrantProgram

    PennsylvaniaFirstCustomizedJobTraining

    InfrastructureDevelopment

    SharedMunicipalServices

    MunicipalAssistanceProgramLandUsePlanningandTechnical

    AssistanceProgram

    FloodPlainManagement

    AccessibleHousing

    KeystoneCommunities

    Housing&RedevelopmentAssistance

    NewCommunities*(includesEnterprise

    ZoneProgram,MainStreetProgram,Elm

    StreetProgram)

    IndustrialDevelopmentAssistance

    PartnershipsforRegionalEconomic

    Performance

    LocalDevelopmentDistricts

    SmallBusinessCenters

    IndustrialResourcecenters

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page18

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    23/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page19

    Gov.Corbettsbudgetproposalincludes$10millionforDiscoveredinPA,DevelopedinPA.According

    to the proposal, this new program will help small businesses identify and access the appropriate

    services and financing to help them be more competitive and grow their operations in the

    Commonwealth.

    Corbettsproposalalsoprovides$6.3millionforWorldTrade PAtopromotePennsylvaniagoodsand

    services in key international markets. The proposed budget continues funding to the Ben Franklin

    Technology Development Authority ($14.6 million) to advance technologybased and technology

    intensive industries in Pennsylvania. Lastly, Gov. Corbett continues funding for the Life Sciences

    Greenhouses,historicallyfundedthroughtheTobaccoSettlementFund.

    ConservationandNaturalResources

    Gov.Corbettsbudgetproposaldrasticallyreduces overallstateGeneralFundsfortheDepartment of

    ConservationandNaturalResourcesby$24.1million(29.3percent)fromthecurrentyearfundingof

    $58.3 million. This reduction reflects decreases from the current year funding of $18.6 million (39.9percent)toStateParkOperations,$4.1(34.1percent)toStateForestOperations,and$1.2million(6.3

    percent)fromGeneralGovernmentOperations.

    Thesedecreasesareoffsetbyanincreaseof$32.9millionfromotherstatecashfundsandaugmented

    revenues. This includes $16.5 million from the Oil and Gas Lease Fund and $15.4 million from the

    KeystoneRecreation,ParkandConservationFund.

    Corrections

    The Governors 2011/12 budget proposes nearly $1.9 billion in state funds for the Department of

    Corrections (DOC), an increase of $186.5 million or 11 percent over last year. Remember, the

    Commonwealth used $173 million in federal offset funds for Corrections during the 2009/10 and

    2010/11fiscalyears.WhiletheGeneralGovernmentOperationsappropriationforDOCwillseeaone

    percent decrease in funding, the proposed budget increases Medical Care (0.4 percent), Inmate

    Education and Training (0.4 percent), and the State Correctional Institution (13.5 percent)

    appropriations.Thisproposaleliminates23positionsunderGeneralGovernmentOperations.Notethat

    theCommonwealthisconstitutionallyobligatedtoprovideinmatemedicalcare.

    As of December 2010, there were 51,321 inmates, a decrease of 50 inmates from January 2010.

    PennsylvaniasStateCorrectional Institutionsatfullcapacityhold43,584 inmates.Therearecurrently

    2,180 inmateshoused inprisons inMichiganandVirginiawhoGov.Corbettproposestoreturntothe

    Commonwealth.Inaddition,thisbudgetproposalprovides1,260newbedswithinexistinginstitutions

    andcommunitycorrectionscenters.

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    24/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Education

    Pre Kthrough12Education

    Gov.

    Corbett

    proposes

    more

    than

    $1.1

    billion

    in

    spending

    cuts

    for

    Pre

    K

    through

    12

    education

    programs in the Department of Education (PDE). When including increases in mandatory

    reimbursement line items such as Pupil Transportation and School Employees Retirement, the

    proposedbudgetshowsanetreductionofnearly$819million,or8.2percent.

    Corbettsbudgetproposalincludesareductioninthetotalbasiceducationsubsidyof$550million,or

    9.5percent,from$5.8billionin2010/11to$5.2billionin2011/12.Thisproposedfundingrepresentsa

    rollbacktothe2008/09level.

    The spreadsheet posted on Department of Educations website, as of March 22, 2011, reflects

    onlythestatefundingthatschooldistrictsreceivedin2010/11.Whencomparingonlystatefunds

    for2010/11,itappearsthatfundingincreasedformanyschools.Infact,schooldistrictsreceived

    anadditional$654millioninfederalARRAfundsaspartoftheirbasiceducationsubsidypayment

    for 2010/11. Comparing the total basic education subsidy payments from 2010/11 to 2011/12,

    basiceducationfundingforschooldistrictsiscutby$550million.

    Gov.Corbettsproposaleliminatesthecurrentbasiceducationsubsidyfundingformula,resultingfrom

    theGeneralAssemblyspassageoftheCostingOutStudyandusedinthepastthreefiscalyears.Corbett

    proposesanewfundingformulathatprovidesdistrictswiththestateshareonlyfrom2010/11,abase

    supplementof$100perstudent,andotherallocationsbaseduponcalculationsusingtheconcentration

    of English Language Learner (ELL) students, district poverty level, and district size. The amount of

    funding received depends upon a districts relative wealth and tax effort. Gov. Corbetts proposed

    funding formula does not calculate adequate and equitable spending using a calculation of each

    districtsactualspendingasdidtheCostingOutStudyformula.

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page20

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    25/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page21

    Gov.CorbetthasproposedeliminatinganumberofprogramswithinPDE,showninthefollowingtable.

    EliminatedProgramsinEducation(PreKthrough12)

    (inthousands)

    Program 2010/11Amount

    ReimbursementofCharterSchools $224,000

    PennsylvaniaAccountabilityBlockGrants $259,000

    EducationAssistanceProgram $47,600

    IntermediateUnits(IU)1 $4,800

    DualEnrollment2 $7,000

    Science:ItsElementary $6,900

    HighSchoolReform $1,800

    1ThegovernorsproposalsuggeststhatsomefundingremainsintheGGOtoassistsomeIUs.Additionally,IUswouldstillreceive

    fundingfromlinessuchasspecialeducation,earlyintervention,andnonpublicschoolservices.

    2For Dual Enrollment payments, the proposed budget indicates that students will be able to utilize a portion of their basic

    education funding for dual enrollment. The governor has stated that students in their final years of high school should have

    opportunities toacquirepostsecondarycreditsandthatschooldistrictsshouldconsidermodifyingtheir resourceallocations to

    providestudentswiththisopportunity.

    Inadditiontothebasiceducationsubsidy,Gov.Corbettproposesthereductionofnumerousprograms

    inPDE,asseeninthetablethatfollows.

    ReducedProgramsinEducation(PreKthrough12)

    (inthousands)

    Program

    $Cut

    from

    2010/11

    %Cut

    from

    2010/11

    StateLibrary ($164) 7.3%

    PreKCounts ($1,600) 1.9%

    TeacherProfessionalDevelopment ($14,300) 66.0%

    AdultandFamilyLiteracy ($2,500) 17.0%

    EducationofMigrantLaborersChildren ($181) 17.0%

    ServicestoNonpublicSchools ($1,100) 1.2%

    Textbooks,MaterialsandEquipmentforNonpublicschools ($477) 1.8%

    PublicLibrarySubsidy ($1,000) 1.9%

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    26/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page22

    Gov.CorbettalsodecreasesthemandatedSchoolEmployeesSocialSecuritypaymentbymorethan

    $21 million under the 2010/11 payment. The Governor proposes changing the formula for the

    Commonwealthssocialsecurityreimbursementpayment.UnderAct29of1994,anequitycomponent

    was

    introduced

    for

    the

    Commonwealths

    portion

    of

    social

    security

    and

    retirement

    reimbursement

    for

    schools.Foremployeeshiredafter1994,schoolswerereimbursedforthegreateroftheiraidratioor50

    percent of the employers share. This means school districts with aid ratios less than 0.5 were

    reimbursedatthe50percentrate.TheGovernorproposesreimbursingschooldistrictsattheaidratio

    level for each district. For 158 districts, this reimbursement level will be less than 50 percent. This

    changeisactuallyasavingstothestate(butacosttoschooldistricts)ofapproximately$40millionof

    whattheCommonwealthwouldhavepaidfor2011/12underthecurrentformula.Becausethisformula

    isinstatute,legislationwillberequiredforthischangetotakeeffect.

    InadditiontomandatedincreasesinappropriationssuchasPupilTransportationandSchoolEmployees

    Retirement,theproposedbudgetincludessomediscretionaryincreases.

    IncreasedDiscretionaryProgramsinEducation(PreKthrough12)

    (inthousands)

    Program

    $Incfrom

    2010/11

    %Incfrom

    2010/11

    InformationandTechnologyImprovement $1,800 70.0%

    PAAssessment $4,000 12.2%

    SchoolNutritionIncentiveProgram1 $451 15.7%

    EarlyIntervention2 $16,000 8.8%

    1FormerlyRxforPASchoolFoodServices

    2Forprogramexpansion

    Gov. Corbetts budget proposal also includes $2.2 million for a new Safe School Initiative. This is

    requiredduetothepassageAct104of2010 (amendingtheschoolcode),whichcreatesaPDEbased

    OfficeforSafeSchools.

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    27/59

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    28/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page24

    HigherEducation

    GovernorCorbettdrasticallyreducesfundingforhighereducation.FederalARRAfundswereusedto

    fund institutionsofhighereducationover thepast threefiscalyears.The2010/11budgetused$93.2

    million inARRAfundingwhich isno longeravailable. Inaddition, largereductions instatedollarsalso

    have been proposed in the executive budget. Funding for community colleges, the State System of

    Higher Education, Thaddeus Stevens College of Technology and the staterelated universities are

    detailedinthefollowingtable.

    HigherEducation:StateandARRAFunds

    2009/10 2010/11 2010/12 NetChange %Change

    CommunityColleges $235,741 $235,741 $212,167 ($23,574) 10.0%

    State $214,217 $214,217 $212,167 ($2,050)

    ARRA $21,524 $21,524 $0 ($21,524)

    StateSystemofHigherEducation $503,355 $503,355 $232,599 ($270,756)

    53.8%State $465,197 $465,197 $232,599 ($232,598)

    ARRA $38,158 $38,158 $0 ($38,158)

    PennsylvaniaStateUniversity $333,863 $333,863 $165,094 ($168,769) 50.6%

    State $318,072 $318,072 $165,094 ($152,978)

    ARRA $15,791 $15,791 $0 ($15,791)

    UniversityofPittsburgh $167,995 $167,995 $80,245 ($87,750) 52.2%

    State $160,490 $160,490 $80,245 ($80,245)

    ARRA $7,505 $7,505 $0 ($7,505)

    TempleUniversity $172,737 $172,737 $82,487 ($90,250) 52.2%

    State $164,974 $164,974 $82,487 ($82,487)

    ARRA $7,763 $7,763 $0 ($7,763)

    LincolnUniversity $13,782 $13,782 $6,812 ($6,970) 50.6%

    State $13,623 $13,623 $6,812 ($6,811)

    ARRA $159 $159 $0 ($159)

    ThaddeusStevensCollegeofTechnology $10,876 $10,876 $9,788 ($1,088) 10.0%

    State $8,550 $8,550 $9,788 $1,238

    ARRA $2,326 $2,326 $0 ($2,326)

    Gov.Corbetteliminatesthefollowinghighereducation line itemsunderthePennsylvaniaDepartment

    of Education: Regional Community College Services, Higher Education Assistance, Community

    EducationCouncilsandMedicalCollegeinNortheastPA.

    UnderthePennsylvaniaHigherEducationAssistanceAgency(PHEAA),Gov.CorbettcutstheGrantsto

    Studentslineitemby$7.3millionor1.9percent,to$380.9million.TheInstitutionalAssistanceGrants

    programwouldbereducedby50percentor$15million.

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    29/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page25

    In addition, Gov. Corbett eliminates additional programs under PHEAA: the BondHill Scholarships,

    Agricultural Loan Forgiveness,SciTech and TechnologyScholarships,CheneyKeystone Academyand

    theNursingShortageInitiative.

    Also, note two appropriations have been moved from the Department of Education to PHEAA in the

    Governors proposal (Higher Education for the Disadvantaged and Higher Education of Blind or Deaf

    Students).Bothappropriationsarereducedby1.9percent.

    EmergencyManagementAgency

    ThebudgetproposalreducesoverallstateGeneralFundsforthePennsylvaniaEmergencyManagement

    Agency (PEMA) by $3.2 million (24.6 percent) from the current year funding of $12.8 million. This

    reductionreflects theeliminationoffunding forregional events security($3million)and for theRed

    CrossExtendedCareProgram($200,000).

    EnvironmentalProtection

    IntheDepartmentofEnvironmentalProtection(DEP),theGovernorsproposalreducesstatefunding

    by $7.3 million (5 percent) from the current year funding of $45.5 million (excluding funding for the

    EnvironmentalHearingBoard).Thisreductionreflects theelimination of Flood Control Projects ($3.5

    million)andthereductionof$2.1millionfromGeneralGovernmentOperations.

    TotalfundingtotheDepartment isdrasticallydecreasedby$160.0million(19.1percent)fromcurrent

    yearfundingof$839.3million.Thisdecreaselargelyreflectstheeliminationof$128.9millionfromthe

    American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) of 2009 for: energy conservation and efficiency

    planning;surveystudies;waterqualitymanagementplanninggrants;andproviding correctiveactions

    fortheaboveandundergroundstorageleaks.

    TheGovernorsproposaldecreasestheagencystotalcomplementby69fulltimeequivalentpositions

    (FTE). These reductions will come from environmental protection operations (30 FTE), environmental

    programmanagement(20FTE),floodcontrolprojects(14FTE),andGeneralGovernmentOperations(5

    FTE).

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    30/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    ExecutiveOffices

    TheGovernorproposestoconsolidateseveralcommissionswithintheExecutiveOffices.

    Agency/ExistingProgram ProposedProgram

    ExecutiveOffices Commissions

    OfficeofPublicLiaison

    LatinoAffairsCommission

    CommissionforWomen

    AfricanAmericanAffairsCommission

    AsianAmericanAffairsCommission

    PennsylvaniaCommissiononCrimeandDelinquency

    Gov.

    Corbetts

    2011/12

    budget

    proposal

    cuts

    General

    Government

    Operations

    for

    the

    Commission

    on

    Crime and Delinquency (PCCD) by $150,000. In addition, his proposal consolidates many PCCD

    programs.

    Agency/ExistingProgram ProposedProgram

    ExecutiveOffices PublicSafety

    ViolencePreventionPrograms

    EvidenceBasedPreventionand

    Intervention

    ResearchBasedViolencePrevention

    IntermediatePunishmentPrograms IntermediatePunishmentTreatment

    ProgramsIntermediateDrugandAlcohol

    Treatment

    ImprovementofJuvenileProbation

    Services JuvenileProbationServices

    SpecializedProbationServices

    TheIntermediatePunishmentprograms listedabovearealternativestocounty jailandaremorecost

    effectivefornonviolentoffenders.

    CorbetteliminatestheVictimsofJuvenileCrimeappropriation.

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page26

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    31/59

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    32/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    DuringhiscampaignforGovernor,Corbettclaimedhewouldreducethestateautomotivefleetbyupto

    20percent.Notably,inMarchActingSecretaryoftheDepartmentofGeneralServicesstatedasfollows:

    At DGS, we have already begun working on the Governors reform plan, setting ambitious

    attainable goals. The Bureau of Vehicle Management is conducting an audit of the states

    vehiclestodeterminethemostcosteffectivesizeanduseoftheautomotivefleet.Thisincludes

    reviewing employee mileage reimbursements to ensure they are utilizing the least expensive

    modeoftravel.

    Health

    Gov.Corbetts2011/12budgetreducesoverallstateGeneralFundsfortheDepartmentofHealth(DOH)

    byover$12millionor5.4percent(whenexcludingTobaccoSettlementFundprogramstransferredto

    the General Fund). The proposed budget does increase funding for Quality Assurance by nearly $1.7

    million, including funds for increased inspections. This appropriation funds the inspections of health

    facilities, including abortion clinics. Gov. Corbetts proposal notes that these clinics will be inspectedannually,witharandomsamplebeinginspectedmorethanonceayear.

    Additionally, Gov. Corbetts proposal creates a new Tactical Emergency Medical Support (TEMS)

    ProgramwithinDOH.TheproposalstatesthatTEMSproviderswillbesworninpoliceofficersattached

    totacticalteams,withatleastanEmergencyMedicalTechnicianParamediccertification,andtrainedin

    lawenforcementandemergencymedicine.Theseofficerswillhavetheabilitytoassessmedicalthreats,

    render immediate medical care in hazardous environments, and provide logistical support that will

    furtherthehealthandsafetyoflawenforcementpersonnelandreducetheincidencesofinjury,illness,

    disability and death associated with training and tactical operations. The Executive Budget is unclear

    regardinghowthisprogramwillbefunded.

    As in many agencies, Gov. Corbett significantly reduces, eliminates and consolidates most

    appropriationsinDOH.Thefollowingtabledetailsappropriationconsolidationinthedepartment.

    Agency/ExistingProgram ProposedProgram

    DepartmentofHealth

    ExpandedCervicalCancerScreening

    CancerScreeningServicesCancerControlProgram

    BreastandCervicalCancerScreening

    Services

    for

    Children

    with

    Special

    Needs

    SpecialMedicalPrograms

    AdultCysticFibrosis

    Cooley'sAnemia

    Hemophilia

    SickleCell

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page28

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    33/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page29

    Act50of2010createdtheDepartmentofDrug&AlcoholProgramsandtransferredexistingfundingfor

    theseprogramsfromtheDepartmentofHealthtothenewdepartment.Gov.Corbettsproposalwould

    maintaintheprogramwithintheDepartmentofHealth.

    HousingFinanceAgency

    The Governors proposed budget eliminates funding for the Homeowners Emergency Mortgage

    Assistance program (HEMAP). This program provides loans to homeowners who, through no fault of

    theirown,fallbehindontheirmortgagepayments.InadditiontoappropriationsfromtheGeneralFund,

    theprogramisfundedbyloanrepayments.Inrecentyears,loanrepaymentswereinsufficienttosustain

    theprogram.Inalllikelihood,unlessmajoradjustmentsaremadetotheprogram,theeliminationofthis

    appropriationwillresultintheterminationoftheprogram.

    Outside of the Homeowners Emergency Mortgage Assistance Program, the Pennsylvania Housing

    FinanceAgencyisanindependentagencythatreceivesnoappropriationsfromtheGeneralFundforits

    operationsandprograms.

    InfrastructureInvestmentAuthority(PENNVEST)

    The budget proposal reduces overall funding for the provision of lowinterest loans and grants to

    municipalitiesfortheconstructionofdrinkingwater,wastewater,stormwater,andbrownfieldsprojects

    by$339.47million(34.7percent).Thisdecreaselargelyreflectstheeliminationof$126millionfromthe

    American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA)of2009 for sewage and drinking water projects, as

    wellas$40millioninfederalawardreductionsforothersimilarprojects.

    Insurance

    Gov.Corbetts2011/12budget reducesoverallstateGeneralFundsfor the Insurance Departmentby

    over $781,000 or 0.6 percent. Funding for the Childrens Health Insurance Program remains level

    fundedwith2010/11.

    TheproposaldoesnotincludefundingfortheGeneralFundrepaymentofaloanfromtheUnderground

    StorageTankIndemnificationFund(USTIF).Aspartoftheonetimefixesinthe2002/03GeneralFund

    Budget, (USTIF) loaned$100million totheGeneralFund.Perstatute, the loanmustberepaid,with

    interest,afteratenyearperiod.UndertheUSTIFLoanRepaymentappropriation,loanrepaymentbegan

    in2004/05.DuetotheneedtoreduceGeneralFundspendinginrecentyears,thisappropriationhas

    beenunderfundedornotfundedatall.Repaymenttodatehasbarelycoveredtheinterestowed.

    Judiciary

    The Governors2011/12budget proposes flat funding for all appropriations within the Judiciary for a

    total General Fund cost of $276.9 million. The Judiciarys budget request is $328.3 million or $51.4

    millionmore than inGov.Corbettsproposal.The Judiciaryrequest isbased on the courtsbringing in

    $24.1millioninrevenuefromsurchargesunderAct49of2009in2011/12.TheAct49surchargesexpire

    onJanuary7,2012.

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    34/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    As in other areas, Gov. Corbetts proposal includes the consolidation of appropriations within the

    Judiciary.

    Agency/ExistingProgram ProposedProgram

    Judiciary

    RulesCommittees

    CivilProceduralRulesCommittee

    Appellate/OrphansRulesCommittee

    RulesofEvidenceCommittee

    MinorCourtRulesCommittee

    CriminalProceduralRulesCommittee

    DomesticRelationsCommittee

    JuvenileCourtRulesCommittee

    CountyCourtReimbursement

    DomesticViolenceServices

    GunCourtReimbursement

    CourtConsolidation

    LawClerks

    Labor

    and

    Industry

    ThebulkoffundingfortheDepartmentofLaborandIndustryiscomprisedoffederal,special,andother

    funds.StateGeneralFundsareusedtosupportGeneralGovernmentOperations(GGO).Thesefunctions

    includethePennsylvaniaLaborRelationsBoard,theOfficefortheDeafandHardofHearing,andLabor

    LawCompliance.Gov.CorbettreducestheGGOappropriationby1.2percent.Aseparateappropriation

    forOccupationalandIndustrialSafetywasreducedby4.5percent.Thisappropriationprovidesfunding

    for enforcement of many of the commonwealths safety laws, including elevator inspections, the

    FlammableandCombustibleLiquidsActandahostofconsumersafetylaws.

    In addition, the Governors budget eliminates several programs under the Departments purview,

    includingthePennsylvaniaConservationCorpswhichfundsconservationprojectsonpublic landsand

    facilities involving economically disadvantaged youth. Gov. Corbett also eliminates the Training

    Activities line item (funding incumbent worker training grants in conjunction with the Industry

    Partnership program) and New Choices/New Options (funding individualized career, education and

    personalservicesforsingleparents,displacedhomemakersandsinglepregnantwomen).

    Gov.Corbettsproposalalsoincludesreductionsinthefollowingprograms:

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page30

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    35/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page31

    The Industry Partnership program by 1.9 percent, which funds worker training for groups ofemployerswithinasingleindustry

    AssistiveTechnologyby24percent,whichsupportstheStatewideAssistiveTechnologyLendingLibrary, providing Pennsylvanians with disabilities an opportunity to try expensive assistivetechnologydevicesandequipmentbeforemakingapurchasingdecision.

    Supported Employment by 1.9 percent, which helps severely disabled individuals who needextensivesupporttostayinlongtermemploymentafterplacementandtraininghasoccurred.

    CentersforIndependentLiving(CILs)by1.9percent,whichallowstheninestatefundedCILstoprovidecommunitybasedsupportsforcitizenswithdisabilities.

    The Governors Executive Budget does not propose any solution for Unemployment Compensation

    TrustFundsolvency issues.Becauseofthedepthoftherecession,theCommonwealthexhausted the

    balance of the fund and must borrow from the Federal Unemployment Account to pay for

    unemploymentbenefits.TheamountoftheloanfromtheFederalGovernmentexceeds$3billion,and

    hasbeguntoaccrue interest.Whileautomaticsolvencymeasures instatutehavetakeneffecttohelp

    repay the loan, the department has estimated that the fund will continue to be insolvent for the

    foreseeable future, absent any changes. It is important to note that this issue is separate from the

    GeneralFund.

    PublicWelfare

    Governor Corbetts 2011/12 Executive Budget requests $11.2 billion in state General Funds for the

    Department of Public Welfare (DPW). This represents an increase of $2.35 billion from FY 2010/11,

    whichincludesa$250millionstatesupplementalrequest.Thesupplementalrequestisrequiredlargely

    toadjustforlessthananticipatedfederalMedicaidmatchingfundsthatPennsylvaniawillreceiveforthe

    periodJanuary2011throughJune2011astheresultofthescaleddownARRAFMAPextensionpassed

    byCongresslastAugust.

    The $2.35 billion increase in state appropriations reflects the impact of four factors which must be

    taken intoconsiderationtomakean appropriate comparison betweenFY 2011/12andFY2010/11:

    ARRAFMAP;clawbacksavings;tobaccofunds;andprioryearfederalfunds.Forthemostpart,these

    arebudgetaryfactorswhichrepresentashifttotheGeneralFundofexistingDPWexpendituresanddo

    not reflect new or increased spending in the agency. In fact, a much leaner budget emerges after

    accountingforthesefactors,withDPWstatespendingdecliningnearly$5million.

    Expiration of ARRA FMAP ($1.745 billion). Historically, the federal government has paidapproximately 55 percent of Pennsylvanias Medicaid expenditures in accordance with the

    federalMedicaidmatchingrate(orFMAP)whichisbasedonaformulainfederallaw.Duringthe

    33month federal stimulus period, October 2008 through June 2011, the federal share has

    averaged approximately 65 percent due to provisions in ARRA that temporarily increased the

    FMAP.For2010/11,theadditionalfederalMedicaidreimbursementsthatPennsylvaniareceived

    under the ARRA FMAPs reduced the state spending requirement for Medical Assistance and

    other Medicaidrelated programs (including communitybased waiver programs for disabled

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    36/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page32

    individuals) by $1.745 billion. Pennsylvanias share of program costs will increase when the

    ARRAFMAPexpiresafterJune30,2011andthefederalMedicaidreimbursementratereturnsto

    approximately55percentforthe2011/12budget.

    ClawbackPaymentSavings($250million).TheclawbackpaymentisthemonthlypaymentPennsylvaniamustmaketothefederalgovernmentforcertainPennsylvanians(personsdually

    eligibleforMedicareandMedicaid)enrolledintheMedicarePartDdrugprogram.Theamount

    of the monthly payment is based on a formula in federal law, and each month the federal

    governmentsendsDPWaninvoicefortheamountowedbytheCommonwealth.Pennsylvanias

    payments were significantly reduced in 2010/11 as the result of the Obama Administrations

    decision last February to grant additional relief to states by applying the ARRA FMAPs to the

    monthlypaymentcalculation.TheseonetimesavingsdisappearwhentheARRAFMAPexpires

    andtheclawbackpaymentcalculationwillonceagainbebasedontheregularFMAP.

    Tobacco Programs transferred to General Fund ($247.2 million). Beginning in 2011/12, theCorbettAdministrationproposestotransferalltobaccorevenuesandtobaccofundedprograms

    totheGeneralFund.Consequently,DPWs2011/12GeneralFundbudgetincludes$247million

    in program expenses that were funded in previous budgets through the Tobacco Settlement

    Fund. This includes funding for the Medical Assistance for Workers with Disabilities (MAWD)

    program($63million),theUncompensatedCarehospitalpaymentprogram($31.5million)and

    MedicalAssistanceLongTermCare($153million).Withoutthisproposedshiftinfunding,state

    appropriationswouldbe$247millionlowerin2011/12.

    Prior Year Federal Funds ($115 million). These are onetime federal funds that Pennsylvaniareceives for state expenditures made in prior years and later determined to be eligible for

    federalreimbursement. The2010/11budgetused prior year federal funds to pay forMedical

    Assistancemanagedcare($100million)andMentalHealthServices($15million).Withoutthese

    federal funds, an additional $115 million of state General Funds would have been needed in

    2010/11forthesetwoprograms.

    TomitigatetheneedforadditionalstateGeneralFunds,Gov.Corbettsbudgetproposalreducesstate

    spendingby$519million in2011/12 throughacombinationofcostcontainment initiativesand the

    reduction in line items, including the elimination of 11 DPW line items. The cost containment

    initiatives impact Medical Assistance, disability programs, child welfare, and employment/ training

    programs for lowincome individuals.Theeliminatedappropriationscut fundingforhospitals,medical

    schools,andhumanservices.

    MedicalAssistance

    The largest component of DPWs budget is the Medical Assistance (MA) program, which provides

    health care and long term care services to more than 2.1 million Pennsylvanians. Managed care is

    funded through the Capitation appropriation, and the feeforservice program is funded through the

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    37/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page33

    OutpatientandInpatientappropriations.Nursingfacilityandhomeandcommunitybasedservices(for

    elderlyMArecipients)arefundedthroughtheLongTermCareappropriation.

    The2011/12ExecutiveBudgetrequests$6.24billioninstateGeneralFundsforthefivemajorMedical

    Assistance (MA) appropriations: Outpatient, Inpatient,Capitation, LongTerm Care, and Payment to

    theFederalGovernmentfortheMedicareDrugProgram.Thisrepresentsa$2.13billionincreaseover

    2010/11,mostofwhichcanbeattributedtotheexpirationoftheARRAFMAPafterJune30,2011.The

    tablebelowshowsthe2011/12GeneralFundsrequestedforeachoftheseMAlineitemappropriations

    andcomparestherespectivestatefundincreaseswiththeamountoffederalMedicaidreimbursements

    earnedundertheARRAFMAPin2010/11.

    DPWMedicalAssistanceAppropriations

    (DollarsinMillions)

    StateGeneralFunds ARRA

    2011/12 Changefrom FMAP

    LineItemAppropriation Budget 2010/11 2010/11

    Outpatient $694.8 $233.7 $204.9

    Inpatient $363.7 $113.9 $106.1

    Capitation $3,443.9 $965.4 $795.5

    LongTermCare* $1,260.4 $546.5 $363.0

    SUBTOTAL $5,762.6 $1,859.5 $1,469.4

    MedicareDrugPayment $481.1 $271.1

    MATOTAL $6,243.7 $2,130.6 $1,469.4

    *The2011/12appropriationisimpactedbytheTobaccoSettlementinitiative.

    The$2.1billionstateGeneralFundincreaseforMAreflectsthecombinedimpactofthreeelements:

    the

    budgetary

    factors

    described

    above

    which

    largely

    represent

    a

    funding

    shift

    for

    existing

    expenditures($1.97billion);thecostdriversthatincreaseMAprogramexpenditures($388million);and

    the proposed cost containment measures that reduce the need for additional state funds ($245

    million).Eachoftheseisaddressedbelow.

    Budgetary Factors.The followingaccount for$1.97billion(ornearly93percent)of thestatefunds

    increaseforMA:

    $1.469 billion replaces the additional federal Medicaid reimbursements earned in 2010/11undertheARRAFMAPs;

    $250millionisduetothelossofonetimeclawbacksavingsrealizedin2010/11; $152millionreflectstheproposedswapofGeneralFundstoreplaceTobaccoSettlementFunds

    previouslyusedtohelppayforMALongTermCare;and

    $100millionreplacesprioryearfederalfundsusedin2010/11forCapitation.

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    38/59

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    39/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page35

    Nursing home rateswouldbe cut 2 percent through the implementationofarevised budgetadjustment factor for 2011/12. This requires an amendment to the Public Welfare Code to

    extendthebudgetadjustmentfactorwhichsunsetsafterJune30,2011.

    Behavioralhealthreinvestmentfundskeptbycountieswouldbecappedat4percent. The nursing facility audit program would be expanded to recover excess payments made to

    nursinghomes.

    Feeforserviceaudits,claimsreview,andrecoveryeffortswouldbeexpanded.ProposedMACostContainment

    (dollarsinmillions)

    State

    Savings

    MABenefits/Services

    Reduceoptionalpharmacyanddentalbenefits;increasepriorauthorizationforcertainprescriptiondrugs

    $55.9

    Utilizeevidencebasedbehavioralhealthservices (relatedto

    residentialtreatmentfacilities)forchildrenandyouth$10.0

    Changecommunitybasedwaiverservicesforseniors $18.2

    MAProviderPayments:

    Reducestheamountofhospitalsupplementalpayments $86.7

    ReducemanagedcarePayforPerformancepayments

    (reducesphysicalhealthP4PandeliminatesskillednursingP4P)$20.9

    Nomidyearrateadjustmentforbehavioralhealth

    managedcare$11.5

    Reducenursinghomesrates2% $22.9

    OtherMAInitiatives

    Capcountyuseofbehavioralhealthreinvestmentfunds $11.0

    Expandnursingfacilityrecoveryauditprogram $5.4

    Expandprovideraudits,claimsreviewandrecoveryefforts

    infeeforservicesystem$3.3

    TotalMACostContainment $245.7

    In addition to these MA measures, Gov. Corbetts budget proposal recommends elimination of the

    followinghospitalpaymentswhicharefundedthroughseparatelineitemappropriations:

    TraumaCenterpaymentsmadetoPennsylvaniasaccreditedtraumacenters,improvingaccesstotraumacareforthemostcriticallyinjuredpatients;

    CriticalAccessHospitalpaymentsmadetohospitalsthatmeetMedicare'sdefinitionfor"criticalaccess"hospitals,assuringaccesstocareinunderservedareasofPennsylvania;

    HospitalBasedBurnCenterpaymentsmadetocertifiedburncenters;and

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    40/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page36

    Obstetric and Neonatal Service payments made to qualifying hospitals that provide obstetricand neonatal services to MA recipients. Rural hospitals receive 15 percent of funds and

    urban/nonruralhospitalsreceive85percentoffunds.

    TheExecutiveBudgetalsoproposestoterminatemedicalschoolfundingbyeliminatingthefollowing

    appropriations:

    Academic Medical Centers, which funds the medical schools at Temple, Penn State (HersheyMedicalCenter),andUniversityofPittsburgh.

    Physician Practice Plans, which funds the medical schools at Drexel, Thomas Jefferson, andUniversityofPennsylvania.

    DisabilityPrograms

    Gov. Corbetts proposed 2011/12 budget requests a total of $2.3 billion in state General Funds for

    programs

    that

    serve

    individuals

    with

    intellectual

    disabilities

    or

    ID

    (previously

    referred

    to

    as

    mental

    retardation),personswithmentalhealthdisorders,and individualswithseverephysicaldisabilities.

    This isa$284million increase instatefunds;however,mostofthis isrelatedtotheexpirationofthe

    ARRAFMAP,whichreducedtheneedforstatefundsby$260millionin2010/11.Thetablebelowshows

    the2011/12GeneralFundsrequestedforeachofthedisabilitylineitemappropriationsandcompares

    therespectivestatefundincreaseswiththeamountoffederalMedicaidreimbursementsearnedunder

    theARRAFMAPin2010/11.

    DPWIntellectualDisabilityAppropriations

    (DollarsinMillions)

    StateGeneralFunds ARRA

    Program

    Area

    /

    2011/12 Change

    from

    FMAPLineItemAppropriation Budget 2010/11 2010/11

    IntellectualDisabilities(ID) $1,278.7 $245.1 $217.5

    ID StateCenters 107.4 25.7 27.5

    ID IntermediateCareFacilities 145.3 34.8 33.1

    ID CommunityBaseProgram 166.5 10.6 1.9

    ID CommunityWaiverProgram 846.0 173.6 153.2

    AutismInterventionandServices 13.5 0.4 1.8

    MentalHealth $769.9 $21.3 $0.0

    MentalHealthServices 717.7 22.3

    BehavioralHealthServices 52.2 1.0

    PhysicalDisabilities $239.1 $17.3 $42.8ServicestoPersonswithDisabilities 135.7 20.0 28.6

    AttendantCare 103.5 2.7 14.2

    TOTAL DISABILITYPROGRAMS $2,287.7 $283.6 $260.2

    In response to litigation regarding the inappropriate and unnecessary institutionalization of

    Pennsylvanians,theproposedbudgetincludesadditionalstatefundingtomoveindividualsfromthe

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    41/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page37

    state centers and state hospitals and to place them in the community. Specifically, the 2011/12

    proposed budget requests a total of $8.6 million in state funds for additional community services as

    follows:

    $4.95millionintheMentalHealthServicesappropriationtoprovidecommunityservicesfor90individualscurrentlyresidinginstatehospitalsinresponsetotheFrederickL.v.Departmentof

    PublicWelfarelawsuitsettlementagreement.

    $2.45 million in the ID Community Waiver Program appropriation to provide communityservicesto35personswithdualdiagnosisofmentalillnessandintellectualdisabilitieswhoare

    currentlyresidinginstatehospitalsinresponsetotheJimmiev.DepartmentofPublicWelfare

    lawsuit.

    $1.2millionintheIDCommunityWaiverProgramappropriationtoprovidecommunityservicesfor50individualwithintellectualdisabilitiescurrentlyresidinginstatecentersinresponseto

    the

    Benjamin

    v.

    Department

    of

    Public

    Welfare

    lawsuit

    settlement

    agreement.

    Theproposedbudgethasnofundingtoreducethecountywaitinglistforindividualswithintellectual

    disabilitieswho need community services. Nor does thebudget include funding to provideadditional

    communityservicestoindividualswithphysicaldisabilities.

    Thecostcontainment initiatives inDPWsbudget includechangestocommunityservicesfordisabled

    individuals,whichareexpectedtosavethestate$68.8millionin2011/12asfollows:

    $38millioninIDCommunityWaiverProgramsbyrevisingservicedefinitions($11million)andlimitingstatereimbursementtogrouphomeprovidersforfederally ineligibleroomandboard

    costs($27million).

    $17.2million inServices toPersonswith Disabilitiesthroughavarietyofunspecifiedreformsthat include improved service coordination, revised reimbursement rates and reporting

    requirements,andexpandedconsumerdirectedcare.

    $13.6millioninAttendantCarethroughavarietyofunspecifiedreformsthatincludeimprovedservice coordination, revised reimbursement rates and reporting requirements, expanded

    consumerdirectedcare,andincreasedfederalfunds.

    Additionally,Gov.Corbettsbudgetproposestoprivatizetheoperationoftheforensicpsychiatricunits

    at Torrance and Norristown state hospitals, generating estimated net savings of $3 million in the

    Mental Health Services appropriation. The forensic units provide psychiatric treatment and/or

    psychiatric evaluation to persons involved with the countybased judicial/corrections systems.

    Approximately 400 state jobs would be eliminated under the privatization proposal, but DPW

    anticipatesthatmostofthepositionswouldbepickedupundertheprivatecontract.

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    42/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page38

    IncomeMaintenance

    Under the program area of Income Maintenance, DPW operates a variety of programs designed to

    provide temporary support to families in transition from government dependency to economic self

    sufficiency.Supportmayincludeeducation,jobtrainingandplacementassistance,transportation,other

    supportservicesandcashassistance.

    Gov.Corbetts2011/12proposedbudgetreducesstateGeneralFundexpendituresintheprogramarea

    of Income Maintenance by nearly $54.7 million or seven percent. This decrease largely represents

    anticipatedsavings instateGeneralFundsresultingfroman initiative torightsizeemployment and

    trainingcontracts.ThisinitiativespanstheCountyAssistanceOffices,NewDirections,andCashGrants

    appropriations. Under the initiative, part of the state fund reduction will be replaced with federal

    TemporaryAssistanceforNeedyFamilies(TANF)blockgrantfunds.Additionaldetailsonthis initiative

    areforthcoming.

    The proposed budget assumes increased caseloads in the areas of cash assistance and state

    supplemental grants. The Cash Grants appropriation funds monthly cash payments and supportive

    servicesallowances (transportation, clothing,etc.) torecipients ofTANF, General Assistance (GA) and

    StateBlindPension(SBP).TheSupplementalGrantsappropriationprovidesstatefundingtosupplement

    federal benefits paid to aged, blind, and disabled recipients under the Supplemental Security Income

    program.TheSocialSecurityAdministration(SSA)establishedthefederalSupplementalSecurityIncome

    (SSI) Program in 1974. States were given the option of providing supplementary cash payments to

    augmentfederalbenefits.

    OtherHumanServices

    Under the program area of Human Services and Support, the Department of Public Welfare (DPW)

    operatesavarietyofprogramsdesignedtoprovidesupportiveservicestopeoplewhiletheyovercome

    anadversebehaviororcircumstancethathasaffectedtheirlives.

    Under the Youth Development Institutions and Forestry Camps appropriation, DPW oversees

    residentialprogramsforcommitteddelinquentswhoareages12to18.Thecourtmaysentenceyouth

    toeithertheYouthDevelopmentCenterandYouthForestryCamp(YDC/YFC)systemoraprivatefacility.

    The YDC/YFC system is presently comprised of seven facilities located throughout the state. The

    Commonwealth operates six facilities and one facility is operated by a private agency under contract

    with DPW. Gov. Corbetts 2011/12 budget proposal assumes $6 million in state savings from the

    consolidationofunitsattheNewCastleYDCfacility.

    As

    required

    in

    the

    County

    Code

    and

    the

    Public

    Welfare

    Code,

    the

    County

    Child

    Welfare

    appropriation

    undertheDepartmentofPublicWelfare(DPW)providesstateandfederalfundstosupportcounty

    administered social services programs for children and youth in each of the Commonwealths 67

    counties.Childwelfareprogramsarefundedthroughacombinationofstate,federalandcountydollars.

    ThemajorityoffundingisfromstateAct148(GeneralFund),federalTitleIVE,andcountyfunds.Based

  • 8/7/2019 House Democrats Analysis of FY 2011-12 Corbett Budget

    43/59

    HouseAppropriationsCommittee(D) March22,2011

    Analysis 2011/12Gov.sExecutiveBudgetProposal

    Page39

    onthetypeofservicesdelivered,varying levelsofstatereimbursement(rangingfrom50100%)are

    providedtocounties.ThisisoftenreferredtoasacountymatchonstateAct148dollars.

    Eachyear,theproposedfundinglevelforchildwelfareservicesisbuiltfromtheNeedsBasedPlanand

    Budget (NBB) process. Article VII of the Public Welfare Code establishes child welfare services as an

    entitlementservicethatisthejointresponsibilityofDPWandcountygovernment.DPWadministersthe

    funds and regulates the services, while the counties provide the services to fam