housing diversity in the new economy - hamilton county, iowa · most efficient way to grow •...

37

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jun-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long
Page 2: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Agenda

• Process

• Findings

• Directions Forward

Page 3: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Process

Page 4: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings

Page 5: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Market Survey

Page 6: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Market Survey

Page 7: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Market Survey

Page 8: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Workforce Survey

Page 9: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Themes

• Regional Benefits

• Rental Availability

• Affordability for All

• Inappropriate Regulations

• Support for Action

Page 10: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Market Analysis

Page 11: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Market Analysis

Page 12: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Market Analysis

Page 13: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Market Analysis

Page 14: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Market Analysis

Page 15: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Future Demand

Page 16: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Community Observations

Page 17: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Findings: Community Observations

Page 18: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Directions Forward

Page 19: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Accessible to metro activity centers

• Strong employment opportunities

• Respected schools and high quality of life

• Strong existing housing stock in many communities

• Collaborative partners

Directions Forward: Assets

Page 20: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Low rental condition, options, construction

• Lack of housing variety

• Undervalued housing market

• Population stability

• Contractors for rehabilitation of existing homes

• Growing smart

Directions Forward: Challenges

Page 21: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Find ways to share risk (a cascading goal)

• Increase housing variety

– Increase rental quality and supply

– Create options for seniors

• Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

• Invest in the existing housing stock

• Leverage existing lots and infrastructure

• Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

• Offer desirable communities for all age groups

Directions Forward: Strategic Goals

Page 22: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

G.1 Find ways to share risk

• This is a cascading goal because so many other goals depend upon it.

• Risk sharing includes cities, financial institutions, economic development agencies, and even employers to find new ways to address gaps in the private market.

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

Page 23: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• This may include:

– Some way of pooling funding:

• Lending consortium/housing trust fund

– Partnerships

• Employers providing rent guarantees

– Incentives

• Employers providing incentives to live in the community – signing bonuses, etc.

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.1 Find ways to share risk

Page 24: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Housing variety should bring more rentals and housing appealing to retirees to the market.

• Rental housing must serve all income levels, right now the majority of units serve middle to lower incomes. This also means quality and cost should match.

– New rentals are needed along with improvements to existing stock

– Rental housing needs to lessen its dependence on low value single-family homes

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.2 Increase housing variety

Page 25: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Retiree housing can be one of the simplest ways to free up housing stock in a community.

– A community should allow a resident to transition through several homes in accordance with their lifecycle – from an affordable rental, to a family home, and eventually to a downsize option for their empty-nester years.

– Historically we’ve only built one type of unit.

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.2 Increase housing variety

Page 26: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• This may involve:

– Establish a not-for-profit developer that can leverage funding and take greater risk on new housing products.

– Establish a demonstration project in one community. But don’t forget:

• Scale, location, design – don’t sacrifice quality for getting a project done.

• Consider the long term consequences to a community’s infrastructure

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.2 Increase housing variety

Page 27: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Issue for both owner and renter market

– Owner: homes can’t be appraised at cost

– Rental: low rental rates can’t support new construction.

• Need to elevate overall values and demonstrate that some higher rents can be absorbed

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.3 Fill Gaps in Undervalued Markets

Page 28: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• For owner occupancy this may involve:

– Bringing down the initial costs:

• Infrastructure, lot development, TIF, etc.

– Not-for-profit developer that can leverage funding sources

– Gap financing through lending consortiums

– Securing the lowest value homes: not-for-profit, land trust or land bank that acquires the properties

– Demonstration Project

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.3 Fill Gaps in Undervalued Markets

Page 29: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• For rental occupancy this may involve:

– Bringing down the initial costs:

– Not-for-profit developer that can leverage funding sources

– Gap financing through lending consortiums

– Securing lowest value homes, rather then converting to rentals

– Demonstration Project: some higher rents can likely be support, market just needs to be proven

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.3 Fill Gaps in Undervalued Markets

Page 30: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Housing is a community’s largest capital investment

• Overall good stock of housing

• Demand for move-in ready and lack of contractors

• The rehabilitation of homes is essential to providing quality entry level housing in any community and continual maintenance and rehabilitation is a high priority.

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.4 Invest in Existing Housing

Page 31: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• This may involve:

– Property maintenance codes and enforcement of those codes. Communities should share resources

– Training of next generation contractors, sweat equity training

– Energy programs and emergency repair programs

– Rehab programs for both owner and renter

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.4 Invest in Existing Housing

Page 32: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Existing lots and infrastructure are the most efficient way to grow

• Allows for greater variety in the housing market – smaller homes and lots

• Long term costs for maintenance on new streets and infrastructure

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.5 Leverage Existing Lots & Infrastructure

Page 33: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• May involve:

– Demonstration project

– Shared risk with local builder or developer

– Acquiring lots, dilapidated housing, and site prep to create affordable lots

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.5 Leverage Existing Lots & Infrastructure

Page 34: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Regulations should not create barriers such as making the majority of a community’s lots non-conforming.

• Review all codes for:

– “Suburban” style site requirements

– Building codes that do not apply to older structures

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.6 Eliminate Unnecessary Barriers

Page 35: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Don’t forget:

– Life safety

– Pedestrian access, circulation, parking, and landscaping

– Avoid short-term savings (use of cheaper materials or delaying of infrastructure like streets)

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.6 Eliminate Unnecessary Barriers

Page 36: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

• Invest in quality of life amenities:

– Parks & Rec

– Trails

– Schools

• Invest in basic infrastructure – streets, sidewalk

• Maintain city property to a level you want residents to maintain personal property

1. Find ways to share risk

2. Increase housing variety

3. Fill gaps created by an undervalued market

4. Invest in the existing housing stock

5. Leverage existing lots & infrastructure

6. Eliminate unnecessary regulatory barriers

7. Offer desirable communities for all age groups

G.7 Offer Desirable Communities

Page 37: Housing Diversity in the New Economy - Hamilton County, Iowa · most efficient way to grow • Allows for greater variety in the housing market –smaller homes and lots • Long

Questions?

Thank you!