how congress works - mrs. savino mulcahy's course website experiment skills/how congre… ·...
TRANSCRIPT
How Congress Works
Who’s in Congress?
Demographic Profile of the 111th Congress
Age Groups
Source: http://www.congress.org/congressorg/directory/demographics.tt
Party
Gender Ethnicity
House-Senate Differences
House
435 members; 2 yr terms
Low turnover
Speaker bill referral hard to challenge
Scheduling/rules controlled by majority party with powerful Rules Committee (controls time of debate, amends., etc)
Senate
100 members; 6 yr
terms
Moderate turnover
Referral decisions
easily challenged
Scheduling/rules
agreed to by majority &
minority leaders
House-Senate Differences
House
Debate limited to 1 hour
Members policy specialists
Emphasizes tax & revenue policy
More formal & impersonal
Senate
Unlimited debate unless cloture invoked
Members policy generalists
Emphasizes foreign policy
More informal & personal
Strength of Party Structure?
• Measure of party strength:
1. Ability of leaders to control party rules
and organization
2. Extent to which party members vote
together in the House and Senate
• Senate: less party-centered and leader
oriented
CAUCUSES
• Groups (may be bipartisan) meeting to pursue
common legislative objectives
• Rivals to parties in policy formulation
• Examples: Democratic Study Group,
Congressional Black Caucus, Tuesday Lunch
Bunch, Human Rights, Congressional Caucus for
Women’s Issues, Out of Iraq Caucus,
Rural Caucus, Travel & Tourism Caucus, House
Caucus on Missing and Exploited Children
Legislative Committees:
Function and Purpose
Legislative Committees:Function & Purpose
1. Consider bills (a.k.a. “mark-up” bills)
A bill with a member’s mark-up notes
Legislative Committees:Function & Purpose
2. Maintain oversight of executive agencies
Secretary Donald Rumsfeld testifies before a Senate Appropriations
Committee hearing re: the Department of Defense Budget (May, 2006)
Legislative Committees:Function & Purpose
3. Conduct investigations
New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin testified before the Senate Homeland Security
and Governmental Affairs Committee on Hurricane Katrina (Feb., 2006
Types of Committees
Standing Committees - permanent panel with full legislative functions and oversight responsibilities
• Subcommittees – formed to tackle very specific tasks within the jurisdiction of the full committees
Select or Special Committees - groups appointed for a limited purpose and limited duration
Joint Committees - includes members of both chambers to conduct studies or perform housekeeping tasks
Conference Committee - includes members of House & Senate to work out differences between similar bills
Standing Committees
House Standing Committees
Agriculture
Appropriations
Armed Services
Budget
Education & Workforce
Energy & Commerce
Financial Services
Government Reform
House Admin.
International Relations
Judiciary
Resources
Rules
Science
Small Business
Standards of Official Conduct
Transportation & Infrastructure
Veterans Affairs
Ways & Means
Senate Standing Committees
Agriculture, Nutrition, &
Forestry
Appropriations
Armed Services
Banking, Housing, & Urban
Affairs
Budget
Commerce, Science,
Transportation
Energy & Natural Resources
Environment and Public
Works
Finance
Foreign Relations
Governmental Affairs
Health, Education, Labor
& Pensions
Judiciary
Rules and Administration
Small Business and
Entrepreneurship
Veterans Affairs
Special, Select Committees
• House Select Committee on Energy Independence & Global Warming
• Senate Select Committee on Ethics
• House & Senate Select Committees on Intelligence
Gen. Michael Hayden is sworn in during a full
committee hearing of the Senate Select
Intelligence Committee on his nomination to be
director of the Central Intelligence Agency.
Joint Committees
• Joint Economic Committee
• Joint Committee on Printing
• Joint Committee on Taxation
Joint Committee on
Taxation hearing
Title: Resolution Artist: Bob Gorrell
Date: 12/28/06 Source: http://www.gorrellart.com/
Artist: R.J. Matson, New
York Observer & Roll Call
Date: 1/18/07
Source:
http://www.cagle.com
How Congress Works
A Bill v. A Law
Bill - a proposed new law introduced within a legislature that has not yet been passed, enacted or adopted
A Bill v. A Law
Law - a bill or act passed by a legislative body
Types of Bills
• public bill – proposed legislative bill that deals with matters of general concern and application
• private bill – a proposed legislative bill that deals with specific private, personal, or local matters rather than general affairs
• appropriation bill – legislative motion authorizing the government to spend money
Types of Resolutions
• simple resolution – measure dealing with “house-keeping” or procedural matters that only affect one house
• joint resolution – measure when approved by both houses and the president carries the force of law
• concurrent resolution – legislative motion that must be approved by both houses, but does not have the force of law
resolution - a measure expressing
opinions on policies or issues
Legislator Representative
Committee
Member
Partisan
Politician
How should I
vote? My
constituents
first or my
country???
Floor vote
on the
Energy
Bill!
A Congressman’s Balancing Act
Navigating the Legislative
Obstacle Course
Step 1: An Idea for a Bill
Sources:
Step 2: Writing & Introduction of Bill
Senate:
• Bill formerly read aloud on floor
• Bill then given to clerk
• Referred to committee by Steering Committee
House:
• Bill dropped in
hopper
• Referred to
committee by the
Speaker
Sen. Smith introduces bill on the Senate floor
~ Mr. Smith Goes to Washington
Step 3: Committee Action
• House & Senate committees conduct
public hearings
• Experts testify
• Markup of bills
• Committee vote:
report favorably,
unfavorably,
or table billHouse Armed Services Committee
Step 4: Floor Action - Senate
• Party leaders schedule bills for floor debate on the calendar
• Unlimited debate
• Filibuster - member(s) keep talking to block debate on a bill
• Cloture vote by 3/5 of Senators (60) can end filibuster
• Floor vote: Roll Call, Standing, Voice Senator Strum Thurman still holds the record for the longest
filibuster - 24 hrs 18 min. on the 1957 Civil Rights Act
Step 4: Floor Action - House
• Rules Committee schedules bills on calendar &
decides whether amendments may be added
• Limited debate
• Floor vote:
Recorded,
Standing,
Voice
Step 5: Approved Bill
Crosses Over to Other House
• Approved bill
must pass each
chamber by a
simple majority
Step 6: Conference Committee
• Members from each chamber meet to
reconcile differences in the two bills
Senate-House Conference Committee works out details of the
2003 Healthy Forest Restoration Act
Step 7: Both Chambers Vote on Final
Version of the Bill
Step 8: President Considers Bill
President can:
1. sign the bill
into law
2. veto bill
3. pocket veto
Note: Congress can override veto with 2/3 vote in each house; only 4% of vetoes have been overridden
Title: Imagine there’s no Congress Artist: Joe Heller, Green Bay Press-Gazette
Date: 6/06/07 Source: http://www.politicalcartoons.com/
Title: Breaking the Filibuster is not Enough
Source: http://www.republicanvoices.org/may_2005_newsletter.html
Artist: RJ Matson
Date: 6/14/07
Source:
http://themoderatevoice.co
m/category/politics/politic
al-cartoons/
Source: http://bigpicture.typepad.com/ Date: 5/6/06
Congressional Earmarks
Should We Bring Home the Bacon?
Who Likes Bacon?
Who likes bacon?
Is bacon always good for you?
What are some alternatives for bacon?
What would happen if you ate bacon all day, everyday?
What recommendations would you make to people who are considering adding bacon to their diets?
Pork Barrel Spending
Earmark- a congressional provision that
directs sets aside funds to be spent on
specific projects within a member’s district.
•From hog slaughtering houses.
•Distinguishes the pigs selected for
specific purposes.
•Is a notch in the pigs ear.
Pork Barrel- legislation that allows
representatives to bring home the bacon to their
districts in the form of public works programs,
military bases, or other programs designed to
directly benefit their districts.
Pork BarrelSpending cont.
•From early American history
•Slaves were given a barrel of salt port as a
reward
•Slaves competed amongst themselves for
the handout
Pork Barrel Spending
The “Prince of Pork”
Due to his position on the
Senate Appropriations
Committee and his
leadership as President
Pro Tempore of the
Senate, Robert Byrd (D-
WV) is known as the
“Prince of Pork” for his
ability to bring home the
bacon in the form of
public works projects to
West Virginia.
Bringing Home the Bacon?
Who is the pig? Why is he happy?
What does the pot-o-gold represent?
Why is the leprechaungressman lucky?
What is the artist saying about congressional spending? How do you know?
Should congressman bring home the bacon?