how is amd imaged? how: amd imaging · fundus autofluorescence peripheral faf findings seen in both...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Update On Imaging For AMD
Rishi P. Singh
Assistant Professor Of Ophthalmology
Medical Director, Clinical Systems Office
Staff Physician, Cleveland Clinic
Rishi P. Singh
Assistant Professor Of Ophthalmology
Medical Director, Clinical Systems Office
Staff Physician, Cleveland Clinic
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Agenda
● Discuss the imaging modalities routinely used and their role
● Highlight particular OCT enhancements which aide in the management of AMD patients
● Discuss some of the imaging findings from recent clinical trials
● Discuss the imaging modalities routinely used and their role
● Highlight particular OCT enhancements which aide in the management of AMD patients
● Discuss some of the imaging findings from recent clinical trials
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
How is AMD Imaged?
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
How: AMD Imaging
2
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Color Fundus Photography
● Role is uncertain except when interpreting FA
● Documenting activity such as hemorrhage may be useful to follow the patient
● Identification of fibrosis usually an exclusion for clinical trials
● Future ‘anti-fibrotic’ therapies may increase the relevance
● Role is uncertain except when interpreting FA
● Documenting activity such as hemorrhage may be useful to follow the patient
● Identification of fibrosis usually an exclusion for clinical trials
● Future ‘anti-fibrotic’ therapies may increase the relevance
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
How: AMD Imaging
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Fundus Autofluorescence
● FAF in AMD mainly used for tracking GA
● Helps explain to patients – Dark is Bad
● FAF in AMD mainly used for tracking GA
● Helps explain to patients – Dark is Bad
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Measuring Geographic Atrophy with RPE Subillumination -Correlation between OCT and FAF
• Comparison of areas designated as sub-RPE Illumination by the CIRRUS HD-OCT versus those designated as Geographic Atrophy on fundus autofluorescence (FAF).
• Strong correlation was found between the two modalities
• Comparison of areas designated as sub-RPE Illumination by the CIRRUS HD-OCT versus those designated as Geographic Atrophy on fundus autofluorescence (FAF).
• Strong correlation was found between the two modalities
Spectral domain optical coherence tomographic imaging of geographic atrophy.Lujan BJ, Rosenfeld PJ, Gregori G, Wang F, Knighton RW, Feuer WJ, Puliafito CA.Ophthalmic Surg Lasers Imaging. 2009 Mar-Apr;40(2):96-101.
3
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Fundus Autofluorescence
● Peripheral FAF findings seen in both neovascularand non neovascular AMD – 68.9% abnormal
● Classification
● Granular
● Nummular
● Mottled
● Peripheral FAF findings seen in both neovascularand non neovascular AMD – 68.9% abnormal
● Classification
● Granular
● Nummular
● Mottled
Colin S. Tan , Florian Heussen , SriniVas R. Sadda
Peripheral Autofluorescence and Clinical Findings in Neovascular and Non-neovascular Age-related Macular Degeneration
Ophthalmology, Volume 120, Issue 6, 2013, 1271 - 1277Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
How: AMD Imaging
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Fluorescein Angiography - Baseline
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Fluorescein Angiography
4
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Fluorescein Angiography – Follow-up
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
When: Fluorescein Angiography – Follow-up
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Fluorescein Angiography – Follow-up
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
How: AMD Imaging
5
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Indocyanine Green Angiography:
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Indocyanine Green Angiography
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
How: AMD Imaging
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
OCT Treatment Monitoring
6
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Improved acquisition times and more data:Time Domain vs Spectral Domain
Scanning strategies
512 X 6 = 3072 A-scans(7.7 seconds)
200 X 200 = 40,000 A-scans512 X 128 = 65,536 A-scans4096 X 5 = 20,480 A-scansTotal A-scans = 126,016 A-scans(4.7 seconds)
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
How is a cube scan made?
Axial scans (A-scans) make up a B-Scan
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
40,000 A-scans in 1.5 seconds
6mm
2mm
B-scans make up the 3-D dataset or SDOCT cube
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
The benefit of more B-scans
● An increase in the number of B-scans reduces the variability of measuring the central subfield thickness and macular volume.
● An increase in the number of B-scans reduces the variability of measuring the central subfield thickness and macular volume.
7
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Applications for the cube scan
SDOCT Cube
Sub‐RPE Illumination Prior Current Difference % Change
Area in 5 mm Circle (mm2) 10.2 12.1 1.90 18.6%
Closest distance to Fovea (mm) 0.6 0.0 ‐0.60 ‐100.0%
RPE Elevations Prior Current Difference % Change
Area in 3 mm Circle (mm2) 3.2 3.9 0.7 21.9%
Area in 5 mm Circle (mm2) 3.7 4.7 1.0 27.0%
Volume in 3 mm Circle (mm3) 0.32 0.53 0.21 65.6%
Volume in 5 mm Circle (mm3) 0.34 0.58 0.24 70.6%
RPE Elevations Sub-RPE Illumination
RPS1
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Advanced RPE Analysis
Sub‐RPE Illumination Prior Current Difference % Change
Area in 5 mm Circle (mm2) 10.2 12.1 1.90 18.6%
Closest distance to Fovea (mm) 0.6 0.0 ‐0.60 ‐100.0%
RPE Elevations Prior Current Difference % Change
Area in 3 mm Circle (mm2) 3.2 3.9 0.7 21.9%
Area in 5 mm Circle (mm2) 3.7 4.7 1.0 27.0%
Volume in 3 mm Circle (mm3) 0.32 0.53 0.21 65.6%
Volume in 5 mm Circle (mm3) 0.34 0.58 0.24 70.6%
RPE Elevations Sub-RPE Illumination
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Advanced RPE AnalysisScreen 1
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Advanced RPE AnalysisScreen 2
Slide 25
RPS1 Cube scan only, not the picutre to the left. Rishi Singh, 8/21/2013
8
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Measuring Geographic Atrophy with RPE Subillumination -Correlation between OCT and FAF
• Comparison of areas designated as sub-RPE Illumination by the CIRRUS HD-OCT versus those designated as Geographic Atrophy on fundus autofluorescence (FAF).
• Strong correlation was found between the two modalities
• Comparison of areas designated as sub-RPE Illumination by the CIRRUS HD-OCT versus those designated as Geographic Atrophy on fundus autofluorescence (FAF).
• Strong correlation was found between the two modalities
Spectral domain optical coherence tomographic imaging of geographic atrophy.Lujan BJ, Rosenfeld PJ, Gregori G, Wang F, Knighton RW, Feuer WJ, Puliafito CA.Ophthalmic Surg Lasers Imaging. 2009 Mar-Apr;40(2):96-101.
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Case example – RPE elevation analysis
● 63 y/o woman with neovascular AMD
● Decreased vision for 2 months, 20/100
● 63 y/o woman with neovascular AMD
● Decreased vision for 2 months, 20/100
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Area: 14.896 mm2
Volume: 7.242 mm3
Intravitreal Lucentis Injected
9
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
BaselineVA: 20/1007.242 mm3
Lucentis #1
1 m s/p L #1VA: 20/402.031 mm3
Lucentis #2
1 m s/p L #2VA: 20/301.472 mm3
Lucentis #3
Area: 15 mm2→13 mm2 (-13%)Volume: 7.2 mm3 →1.5 mm3 (-79%)
Case example – RPE elevation analysis
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
OCT Artifacts
● Not uncommon even with SDOCT
● Can affect both quantitative and qualitative interpretations
● Artifacts can result from
● Software errors
● Patient factors
● User errors
● Not uncommon even with SDOCT
● Can affect both quantitative and qualitative interpretations
● Artifacts can result from
● Software errors
● Patient factors
● User errors
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Most common artifacts seen
● Misalignment
● Blink or motion
● Shadowing
● Software error
● Misalignment
● Blink or motion
● Shadowing
● Software error
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Automatic Fovea Finder
• OCT software identifies the fovea location automatically by finding the reduced reflectivity below the retina.
• OCT software identifies the fovea location automatically by finding the reduced reflectivity below the retina.
10
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Macula Thickness Report
• Fully automated analysis
• Fovea Finder™ automates ETDRS grid placement
• Layer maps highlight abnormalities
• Normative data
• Fully automated analysis
• Fovea Finder™ automates ETDRS grid placement
• Layer maps highlight abnormalities
• Normative data
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Case Example – Fovea Finder
OSODMacula Thickness : Macular Cube 512x128
Normativedata is notavailable.Patient age< 18.
Overlay: ILM - RPE Transparency: 50 %
ILM-RPE Thickness (µm)
ILM - RPE
ILM
RPE
28410.2319ILM - RPE
CubeAverage
Thickness(µm)
CubeVolume(mm³)
CentralSubfield
Thickness(µm)
Fovea: Not found
OSODMacula Thickness : Macular Cube 512x128
Normativedata is notavailable.Patient age< 18.
Overlay: ILM - RPE Transparency: 50 %
ILM-RPE Thickness (µm)
ILM - RPE
ILM
RPE
2759.9259ILM - RPE
CubeAverage
Thickness(µm)
CubeVolume(mm³)
CentralSubfield
Thickness(µm)
Fovea: 294, 67
Fovea Finder OFFCentral subfield = 319
Fovea Finder ONCentral subfield = 259
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Eye Tracking Software
● Allows for improved image acquisition in cases of patient cooperation and eye movement.
● Improves registration capabilities
● Allows for improved image acquisition in cases of patient cooperation and eye movement.
● Improves registration capabilities
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Case Example
Good cooperationNo Fast Trac
Patient blinkingFast Trac OFF
Patient blinkingFast Trac ON
11
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
● Enhanced Depth Imaging
● Improves visualization of the choroid
● Enhanced understanding of disease pathophysiology
● Various protocols based on device utilized
● Enhanced Depth Imaging
● Improves visualization of the choroid
● Enhanced understanding of disease pathophysiology
● Various protocols based on device utilized
EDI‐OCT: Imaging the Choroid
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Outer Retinal Tubulation (ORT)
● Preservation of photoreceptors
● Loss of outer segment interdigitation with RPE
● Disconnect from lateral photoreceptors
● Preservation of photoreceptors
● Loss of outer segment interdigitation with RPE
● Disconnect from lateral photoreceptors
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
CNV
CNV
May not indicate neovascular activity
Outer Retinal Tubulation (ORT)
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Outer Retinal Tubulation
(ORT)
Curved C-scan Imaging
Cirrus
12
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Why does this all matter?
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Comparison of AMD Treatments Trials (CATT): Anatomic Results
Supported by Cooperative Agreements from the National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health,
DHHS
Supported by Cooperative Agreements from the National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health,
DHHS46
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
-250
-200
-150
-100
-50
0
0 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40 44 48 52
Lucentis Monthly
Avastin Monthly
Lucentis PRN
Avastin PRN
47
All Groups
Mean Change in Total Retinal Thickness Over Time
µm
Week
-168-164-152
-196
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
OCT of Typical Eye at Baseline
460u
13
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Lucentis Monthly Thinner Than Normal
Lucentis Monthly Avastin Monthly Lucentis PRN Avastin PRN
Baseline 251u 254u 247u 252u
Week 52 152u 172u 166u 173u
Lucentis Monthly Avastin Monthly Lucentis PRN Avastin PRN
Baseline 251u 254u 247u 252u
Week 52 152u 172u 166u 173u
49 Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute50
Percent with No Fluid at 1 Year
43.7%
26.0% 23.9%19.2%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
Pe
rce
nta
ge
of
Pa
tie
nts
Lucentis Monthly (n=284)
Avastin Monthly (n=265)
Lucentis PRN (n=285)
Avastin PRN (n=271) P < 0.001
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Residual Fluid
Small amounts of residual fluid have minimal effect on VA
unless intraretinal and in center of fovea
Small amounts of residual fluid have minimal effect on VA
unless intraretinal and in center of fovea
51
Jaffe GJ, Martin DF, Toth CA, et al. Macular morphology and visual acuity in the Comparison of Age-related Macular Degeneration Treatments Trials (CATT). Ophthalmology 2013
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
SD-OCT vs TD-OCT
14
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Discrepant Treatment?
● Reading Center says fluid: no Rx
● Reading Center says no fluid: yes Rx
● Reading Center says fluid: no Rx
● Reading Center says no fluid: yes Rx
53 Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Discrepant Treatment
● Lucentis PRN 29%
● Avastin PRN 25%
● Lucentis PRN 29%
● Avastin PRN 25%
54
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Conclusions
● Multiple modalities to pick from for imaging AMD
● Each has their own role
● Fundus – research, correlating angiography
● AF – patient education, dry AMD progression
● FA – Initially and only in cases of poor response
● ICG – Only in cases of poor response
● OCT – every visit, still limitations of technology
● Multiple modalities to pick from for imaging AMD
● Each has their own role
● Fundus – research, correlating angiography
● AF – patient education, dry AMD progression
● FA – Initially and only in cases of poor response
● ICG – Only in cases of poor response
● OCT – every visit, still limitations of technology
Cole Eye InstituteCole Eye Institute
Conclusions
● Variety of OCT technologies have increased our ability to care for AMD patients
● Eye Tracking
● Fovea finder
● Sub RPE illumination and RPE depression
● Higher resolution to find fluid and pathology
● Despite this, outcomes with TDOCT were good.
● Intraretinal fluid with in the fovea was the biggest predictor of acuity
● Variety of OCT technologies have increased our ability to care for AMD patients
● Eye Tracking
● Fovea finder
● Sub RPE illumination and RPE depression
● Higher resolution to find fluid and pathology
● Despite this, outcomes with TDOCT were good.
● Intraretinal fluid with in the fovea was the biggest predictor of acuity