how many rungs?: social change and the engagement ladder

52
How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi George Weiner (@georgecaweiner) DoSomething.org Laura Cochran (@wplauracochran) Gannett Patty Huber (@Patty360) Groupon.com Tom Dawkins (@tomjd) HopeLab & StartSomeGood Moderator: Robert J. Rosenthal (@VolMatch) VolunteerMatch.org How Many Rungs? Social Change & the Engagement Ladder SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Upload: volunteermatch

Post on 29-Oct-2014

10 views

Category:

Technology


0 download

DESCRIPTION

When it comes to giving, slacktivism versus “real” engagement is a false dichotomy. Critics need to get used to the idea that we live in a time of innovative new ways for people to get involved – including things that might not have qualified as “volunteering” or “donating” once upon a time. In volunteering, particularly, there are still many questions about how these new forms of online helping actually relate to traditional engagement. Does the ladder of engagement, which seeks to move folks in an orderly fashion from bystanders to committed movement leaders, still make sense in a crowd-sourced, free-agent, sharing-enabled, microvolunteering world? Not only are the rungs becoming blurry, it may be that “ladder” is the wrong metaphor completely. At the 2011 SXSW conference in Austin, panel moderator Robert Rosenthal from the popular volunteer network VolunteerMatch (www.volunteermatch.org) discussed this with four technologists who are also creating innovative tools to engage audiences in social good. How can their tools live beside other innovative, non-technical forms of volunteering -- such as pro bono and skilled models? What are the right business models for social enterprises that are involved in these technologies? Most importantly, how can SXSW audience members make sense of these emerging technologies so their own online social change campaigns can be as engaging as possible?With:George Weiner, DoSomethingLaura Cochran, GannettPatty Huber, Groupon.comTom Dawkins, HopeLab & StartSomeGood.com

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

• George Weiner (@georgecaweiner)DoSomething.org

• Laura Cochran (@wplauracochran)Gannett

• Patty Huber (@Patty360)Groupon.com

• Tom Dawkins (@tomjd)HopeLab & StartSomeGood

Moderator:

• Robert J. Rosenthal (@VolMatch) VolunteerMatch.org

How Many Rungs? Social Change & the Engagement LadderSXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 2: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

When it comes to online engagement for offline social good, how much do traditional notions of the Ladder of Engagement still apply?

Three Big Questions:

With so many options, what are the key things you should keep in mind if you’re planning to deploy an online campaign to engage audiences in social good?

How do you balance business needs with your desire for social impact?

Page 3: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

My Story

Me, volunteering.

(Alcatraz Historic Gardens)

Page 4: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

VolunteerMatchVolunteer

Shopping

Jobs

Travel Services

Volunteering

Apply emerging technology to create a more efficient and sustainable marketplace for volunteer engagement.

My Story

Page 5: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

My Story

Page 6: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

“Social Good” at Google

2006 2011

Page 7: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Online Social Actions Chaos

Page 8: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

The Ladder

Source: Wiser Earth

Page 9: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

The Ladder

Source: Beth Kanter

Page 10: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

The Ladder

Source: Site Logic

Page 11: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Why Not?

Page 12: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 13: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Do SomethingWho We Are

Largest national organizations for young people and social change

We believe young people have the power to make a difference right now

Our 3 Rules:

1. No Money – We never fundraise from young people

2. No Car – We go where they already are3. No Adults – We never require a parent, teacher

or mentor

Page 14: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Action

Page 15: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Engagement

Page 16: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Outreach1. TV + Radio

– :30 Public Service Announcements with celebrity spokespersons

– Audio PSA airs on ClearChannel radio stations

2. Mobile– Text DoSomething to 30644 for campaign updates– Cha Cha advertising

3. Entertainment– Outreach for PSA play in movie theaters, theme parks, and

fast food restaurants

4. School-Based– 2000+ Do Something Clubs

5. Aggressive PR Campaign– Estimated 50 MM media impressions

6. Website + Social Media 600k unique/month 130k Facebook, 380k Twitter

7. Email

Page 17: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Teens For Jeans

Page 18: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Partners

Page 19: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 20: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 21: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Find Your Team

Page 22: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Feed It

Page 23: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Audience First: How We Engage

Activation → Motivation → Selection → Engagement   

Events EmotionDirect Giving Ease of Entry

   Experience Faith "Well Lit" Experiential   Trauma Connection Sustaining Technology   

Religion IntelligenceResults Driven Social

   Family/Upbringing       Exposure            

TechnologyTechnology

Page 24: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

The Indianapolis Star

Page 25: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 26: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 27: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 28: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 29: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

My name’s Tom. A little about me:

Then:Founded non-profits in high school and universityCEO Vibewire Youth Inc 2000-2008Social Media Director Ashoka 2008-2010Now:Manager of Emerging Media HopeLabCo-founder StartSomeGood

Hi!

Page 30: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

The new medium could be “the most wonderful communications system imaginable, a gigantic system of channels… capable not only of

transmitting but receiving, not of isolating the user but connecting them.”

Page 31: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Users of this technology could “leap around the world and wipe out for all time the age-old barriers of race and language and distance.”

Government would become “a living thing to its citizens”, creating “a new kind of statesman and a new kind of voter.”

Page 32: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 33: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Potted history of my online organizing

2000/1:

Page 34: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

2002:

Page 35: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

2004:

Page 36: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

2008/9:

Page 37: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

2010:

Page 38: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Ladder of Engagement…

How many rungs?

What’s our goal?

Does it require:•Intentionality?•Consistency?•Progression?

Page 39: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

From The Networked Nonprofit by Beth Kanter and Alison Fine.

Page 40: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Relationships

Page 41: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 42: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi 42

Cancer Knowledge

Baseline Follow-up

Inte

rven

tion

-targ

ete

d

kn

ow

led

ge (

% c

orr

ect)

Control

Re-Mission

55

60

65

70

Self-Efficacy

Can

cer-

sp

ecifi

c s

elf

-effi

cacy

(1-7

scale

)5.6

5.8

6.0

6.2

Baseline Follow-up

Control

Re-Mission

p = .034 p = .027

Kato, P.M., Cole, S.W., Bradlyn, A.S., Pollock, B.H. (2008). A Video Game Improves Behavioral Outcomes in Adolescents and Young Adults With Cancer: A Randomized Trial. Pediatrics, 122: e305-e317.

RESEARCH

RE-MISSION WORKS

42

Page 43: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

The online rewards program for teens

powered by physical activity

KEY FEATURES

•Website: rewards, self-selected incentives

•Activity meter: optimized measurements

SUPPORTING TRENDS

• Lifestyle tracking

• Social gaming

• Virtual economies

• Customer reward programs

Page 44: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 45: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 46: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Instigator/Changemaker

Page 47: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Online Engagement = Games You Can Play

Goal = Creating changemakers

(knowledge, understanding, connections, self-efficacy)

Page 48: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 49: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Page 50: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Instigator/Changemaker

Page 51: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

Online Engagement = Games You Can Play

Goal = Creating changemakers

(knowledge, understanding, connections, self-efficacy)

Page 52: How Many Rungs?: Social Change and the Engagement Ladder

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi

• George Weiner (@georgecaweiner)DoSomething.org

• Laura Cochran (@wplauracochran)Gannett

• Patty Huber (@Patty360)Groupon.com

• Tom Dawkins (@tomjd)HopeLab & StartSomeGood

Moderator:

• Robert J. Rosenthal (@VolMatch) VolunteerMatch.org

Do Some Good!

How Many Rungs? | SXSW 2011 | #HowManyRungs #SXSWi