how to argue the existence of god
DESCRIPTION
How to Argue the Existence of God. A biblically sound, philosophically coherent, and scientifically faithful methodology for defending Christianity and the existence of God. Why Do Apologetics?. What do you mean by ‘argument?’ What is your goal in apologetics? - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
A B I B L I C A L LY S O U N D , P H I L O S O P H I C A L LY C O H E R E N T , A N D S C I E N T I F I C A L LY FA I T H F U L M E T H O D O L O G Y F O R
D E F E N D I N G C H R I S T I A N I T Y A N D T H E E X I S T E N C E O F G O D .
HOW TO ARGUE THE EXISTENCE OF GOD
WHY DO APOLOGETICS?
• What do you mean by ‘argument?’• What is your goal in apologetics?
1. Giving a rational defense for what you believe2. Win the person, not the argument3. Edification of the Saints
a. Know your faith to be true & Show your faith to be true4. Love, love, love
METHODOLOGY
• Fideism• Presuppositionalism• Classical Apologetics• Cumulative Case•Offensive Apologetics v. Defensive Apologetics
THE ARGUMENTSTHE COSMOLOGICAL ARGUMENT
1. What we observe and experience in our universe is contingent.
2. A network of causally dependent contingent things cannot be infinite.
3. A network of causally dependent contingent things must be finite.
4. Therefore, there must be a first cause in the network of contingent causes
THE ARGUMENTSTHE FINE-TUNING ARGUMENT
1. Given the fine-tuning evidence, a life permitting universe (LPU) is very, very unlikely under the non-existence of a fine-tuner (~FT)that is, P(LPM|~FT & k’) ≪ 1.
2. Given the fine-tuning evidence, LPU is not unlikely under FT (Fine-Tuner): that is, ~P(LPM|FT & k’) ≪ 1.
3. Therefore, LPU strongly supports FT over ~FT.
THE FINE-TUNING OF THELAWS OF NATURE
• Electromagnetic Force• Different atomic bonds and thus complex
molecules needed for life could not form.• No light, no life!
THE FINE-TUNING OF THELAWS OF NATURE
• Strong Nuclear Force• The force that holds the atomic nucleus together. After all,
protons are positively charged and like charges repel each other. Thus, shouldn’t the nucleus fly apart?
• If stronger, no hydrogen, an essential element of life.• If weaker, only hydrogen.
THE FINE-TUNING OF THELAWS OF NATURE
• Weak Nuclear Force• If stronger, insufficient helium to generate heavy elements
in stars.• If weaker, stars burn out too quickly and supernova
explosions could not scatter heavy elements across the universe.
THE FINE-TUNING OF THELAWS OF NATURE
• Principle of Quantization• Proposed by Niels Bohr in 1910• Without it, an electron would be sucked into the nucleus of
an atom.• No atoms, no life!• Pauli Exclusion Principle (Wolfgang Pauli, 1925), all
electrons would fall into lowest orbital (no complex chemistry).
THE FINE-TUNING OF THECONSTANTS OF NATURE
• Gravitational Constant• Determines the strength of gravity via Newton’s Law of
Gravity
F = Gm1m2/r2
• Actual value of G is 6.67 x 10-11 Nm2/kg2
m1
m2
r
THE FINE-TUNING OF THECONSTANTS OF NATURE
G0 = Current Strength of Gravity
Strength of Weak Force: 1031G0
Strength of Electromagnetism: 1037G0
Strength of Strong Force: 1040G0
1040G0 = ten thousand, billion, billion, billion, billion times the strength of gravity
THE ARGUMENTSTHE MORAL ARGUMENT
1. There are objective axiological/moral facts that obtain.
2. Either the world alone or the world and a perfectly moral person best explain these facts.
3. It is the case that the world and a perfectly moral person best explain these facts.
4. Therefore, the world and a perfectly moral person best explain these facts.
CONCLUDING THE CUMULATIVE CASE
1. Spaceless2. Timeless3. Transcendent4. Uncaused5. Very intelligent6. Morally Perfect Person
KNOW WHO/WHAT YOU’REARGUING AGAINST
• What’s the topic of the discussion?• Does God exist?• Semantic quibbles?• Science and Religion?• Evolution?• The Age of the Earth?• Inerrancy?
• Pick your battles• Stay on course, don’t fish for red herrings
WHAT TO AVOID
• Don’t get emotional• Go after the argument and not the person• Stay calm
• Dealing with “Internet Atheists”• You may offend them without even knowing it