P&GKwU mgw^Z cqvm5g el 1g msLv 2014

1

P&mv`K

Avjvob Lxmv

mv`bv mnhvMx`xcb PvK&gv

cKvkKvjRvbyqvwi 2014

gy`Ycyb, 276 XvKv wekwe`vjq gvKU

KuvUveb, XvKv-1000|

hvMvhvMmj dvb : 01670 701209, B-gBj : alokhisa@gmail.com

www.chtbd.org

g~j50.0021

05mcv`Kxq06

AiY _K ARvj, ivOv gvwUi c_ _K ivRc_ : Avw`g AbZvi Rwgb Nyi `Lvckv wcyiv

17Avw`evmxfvlvq mvwnZPPv : GKwU Dcjwi Abyev`

nvwdR iwk` Lvb22

z` bZvwK RbMvx; Avgiv z` bB gvUBwdWj wW mvsgv

26PZbvi GbwRIKiYcvBwPsgs gvigv

31cvwK ^i `vZbvq DcwbewkK we`vn

iy` kvqK36

Rgm& Rbk wPivb Gi KweZv37

wngj wiwQj Gi KweZv39

cvnvwo mswZi fvOv mZyARj `Iqvb

46NyY aiv Ry Avw`evmx mgvRi wKQz K_v

GwWmb PvKgv56div

myga Zvcm PvK&gv

wkwki PvKgvi KweZv 58^vMZg PvKgvi KweZv 60

dvievb bv IqvORv-Gi KweZv 62Avjvob Lxmvi KweZv 65

my`x PvKgv wgKvWvi KweZv 67nMv PvK&gvi KweZv 70

3 42

mcv`Kxq

Aviv AvMB eibvi K_v wQjv P&i wK LvMovQwoi Z`s-G mvcwZKcwiKwZ mvc`vwqK nvgjv Zv Avi nZ `qwb| eiveii gZ GeviI Avgv`iZiY jLK Mvx nvZ nvZ eua KvR bg MQ, ZvB Avgv`i P&i eiZ`wi nq Mjv| vY msMni KvR Abvbevii gZ Gevi Zgb gmY wQjv bv,wewfb evav-wecw Avgv`i AuvKo aiwQjv| ZviciI Avgiv Avgv`i gZ KvRKi wMqwQ| mdjfve vY weiZiYmn AenwjZ wKQz Qv-QvxK mnhvMxZvKiZ ciwQ| Gevi KvMR cm Avmv hvK-P& c_g msLv 1g el hLb cuvPeQi AvM ei Kwi ZLb bvgi msvqb wbq wevwiZ wjLwQjvg, 2q msLvqmUv Avi Kiv nqwb| Gici AbKB Avgv`i ck KiQb P& gvb wK? GB5g el 1g msLvq Gm P&-Gi msvqb Avevi bZzbfve `qvi cqvRbxqZveva KiwQ hnZz AbKB Rvbb bv Gi gvb wK| P& GKwU PvKgv k, hviA_ wP| GB Awi Ges wef`c~Y mgq mZZv, mvwnZ Avi mgvRi cwZ`vqeZvi cwZ mPZbZv Avi fvjvevmv _KB Avgv`i GB cqvm, GB mgvRGes mvwnZ wPvi KvMR P&| Avgiv Avgv`i wP GB mgq dj hZ PvB,Avgiv wKQz KvR KiZ PvB hv Ab`i PvBZ Avjv`v| KviY Avgiv `LwQ,Avgv`i mvwnZ hZUv bv cmvwiZ nqQ ZviP ekx cfvweZ nqQ, Zv eySv hvqeZgvb mvwnZ KvMRjv cojB| Avgiv Zvi c bB| mivmwi ivRbxwZ vivmvwnZ cfvweZ gvbB njv mwU ewk ev Kg Ki njI mwU mB ivRbxwZiK_vB eje hvi viv m cfvweZ| Avgiv Kviv ivRbwZK cfve cfvweZ bB|Avgiv ejZ cvwi Avgv`i gbi K_vjv, Avgv`i AvgRbZvi K_vjv| wKGB K_vjv gvbyli KvQ Zv cuQvZ ne, ZvB Avgv`i wPvi mv_ Ab`iwPvi gjeb GB KvMR| Avgiv gb Kwi ay wjLB bq, Gi cmvi I cPviIAvgv`i `vwqZ AbK ZvB GB KvMRi jLKiv ayB wjLB v `b bv, ZvivmgvRi AbK BmyZ iZc~Y `vwqZI cvjb Ki _vKb| Avgiv gb Kwi AvgivGKB cwievii m`m Ges aygv wjLB h Avgv`i `vqgyw ne Zv Avgiv gbKwibv| Avi Avgv`i cKvkbv bvg KvgvZ bq, gvbyli gbRvMvZ, fvevZ|Avgiv wekvm Kwi, KD Avgv`i MvYvq wbK Avi bv wbK Avgiv gbi Mnxb Mni_KB KvR KiwQ, Zvobv _K KiwQ, Avgv`i mgvR I mvwnZi Rb|gvvK_vq GwU GKwU wjUj gvMvwRb| Avgiv Ryv mvwnZi APjc_v Avi GBeZgvb mgqi Awi ivRbwZK Aev wbq wKQz ejZ PvB| GB ejv wbicAevb _K, Kviv c bq, Kviv mvnvh bq| wK AvgivI wbic bB,Avgiv cMwZi c, GKZvi c|

5

AiY _K ARvj, ivOv gvwUi c_ _K ivRc_Avw`g AbZvi Rwgb Nyi `Lv

ckv wcyiv

AbZv GKwU cwZ-mvc wbgvY, GKwU ZZvi GK w`K, hvi AviK w`KnQ ^KxqZv ev Avcb mv| GB jLvZ AbZvK `Lv nqQ ki wkwZgawe evOvwj`i PvL w`q, h kwYK wNi- Zvi Dci, bxP I cvk- iqQKlK, kwgK, kvmKMvx, we`wk, Ggb wewfb eMi Abiv| GB cwZAvw`g AbZv wb`k Ki Avw`evmx`i Aevb, wkwZ kwYi evOvwj`i`wKvY _K hviv GKvavi Avw`g I Ab| DjL, h Kvb evsjv AwfavbDvjB Avw`evmx ki h A_ GLbv cvIqv hvq, Zv nj, Avw`g RvwZ evAwaevmx| GB Avw`g c`wUK LyuR cvIqv hvq gvUv `vM weivRgvb GKUvwefvRb iLvi GK cvk mgMvxq Abvb Aviv ek wKQz c`i KvZvi- hv`iga AvQ Amf, Rswj, eb, eei, DcRvwZ BZvw`- hwji wecixZ iqQmf, AvaywbK, RvwZ/iv BZvw`|

Dci DwjwLZ f`iLvjvi cwZ Avw`g AbZvi Rwgb ejZ GB wbemywbw`fve evSvbv nqQ evsjv`ki wk-mvwnZ Avw`evmx Rxebi Dcvcbvm^wjZ cwimiK, hwUK cvwLi PvL GK bRi `L bIqvi Pv Kiv nqQ kiwkwZ gawe evOvwj`i `wKvY _K| AvjvPbvi myweav_ ki wkwZ gaweeMwjK Avgiv AvtmcwKZ I mgic wnmveB ai be, Ges hme evOvwj wkx-mvwnwZK-jLK`i KvRi bgybv Avgiv `Le, gvUv `vM Zuv`iK Avgiv GB kwYiAfz wnmveB ai be, hw`I Zuv`i mevBK bv`wbK ev gZv`wkKfve G aibiKvb wbw ` ebxZ Ave Kiv hvq bv| GB mxgveZvi K_v gv_vq iLB Avgiv iKie GKUv D`vniY w`q- KvRx bRij Bmjvgi mvgev`x KweZvi AskweklhLvb evOvwj eMi GKUv cPwjZ mxgvbv PvL co:

Mvwn mvgi Mvb-hLvb Avwmqv GK nq MQ me evav-eeavb,hLvb wgkQ wn`y-e-gymwjg-xvb|

Mvwn mvgi Mvb!63

K Zzwg?- cvmx? Rb? B`x? muvIZvj, fxj, Mviv?Kb&dzwmqvm&? PvevK-Pjv? ej hvI, ejv Aviv!

Dcii DZvski ZZxq csw Avgv`i gb Kwiq `q evsjv`ki BwZnvm my-cwiwPZ GKwU mvMvbi K_v, evsjvi wn y`, evsjvi e, evsjvi gymjgvb, evsjviwLvb- Avgiv mevB evOvwj| Abw`K, kl `yB cswZ hme bvg iqQ,mjv evOvwj Mwi evBi : GKw`K cvmx, Rb, B`x, Kb&dzwmqvm, PvevK-PjvcfwZ agxq mc` vq; Abw`K muvIZvj, fxj I Mviv, GB wZbwU RvwZ, evOvwj`iKvQ hv`i c~ecwiwPwZ wQj Avw`evmx ev Avw`g wnmve| bRij Aek DwjwLZmKj RvwZ I agi gvbyli Awfb gvbeZvi DciB Rvi w`qwQjb| wK ZvuKRvZxq Kwe wnmve NvlYv Kiv evsjv`ki cavb RvZxqZvev`x avivjv AvewZZnqQ GKw`K evOvwjZi RqMvb, AviKw`K gymjgvb cwiPqK GwMq ivLvigvag| GB `ywU i KvbUvZB Avw`evmxiv wbR`iK LyuR cvq bv| GBavivevwnKZviB Ask wQj kvnevMi MYRvMiY g IVv mB weZwKZ mvMvb,Zzwg K, Avwg K? evOvwj, evOvwj|

wbei cvcU I KvVvgv wbq y`wU K_v ej bB| wkivbvgi c`wj- AiY,ARvj, ivOv gvwUi c_, ivRc_- Lye GKUv fe wP evQvB Kiv nq wb, Zegv_vq Ljv KiwQj 2013 mvji Avw`evmx w`emK mvgb iL GK bvMvo KqKUvjLvq nvZ w`Z wMq| DjL, Avw`evmx w`emK mvgb iL Pi RbI GKUvwKQz wjLe ej wVK Ki iLwQjvg AvMB| Ze Pi Rb wbavwiZ jLvZ nvZw`qwQjvg mevi kl| BQ wQj, mgq cj Pi Rb wfbagx wKQz jLvi PvKie, Pi AvMi msLvq h ck Avwg ZzjwQjvg- Avw`evmx Kwe ev KweZv ejwKQz AvQ wKbv- mB m~ ai evcKZi cwimi mswZi mxgvbv aibi Kvbwelq AvjvPbv Kie| G aibi GKUv AveQv aviYv gv_vq wbq AvM nvZ `Iqvwbewj jLvi mgq hme welq ev AbyQ` gb nwQj P&-Gi mv_ ewk hve,mjv mwiq ivLwQjvg| g~jZ GfveB AvKvi cqQ eZgvb wbewU|

eeZ c`wjK `Lv hZ cvi GK aibi LyuwU wnmve, hwji chvqwgKeenvii gvag (AiY, ivOv gvwUi c_, ivRc_ I ARvj) bxP Zzj aiv njGK bRi Avgvi `Lv Avw`g AbZvi Rwgbi iLvwP|

AiY

evOvwj gvbm Avw`evmx cwiPq Avi AiY wgk AvQ IZcvZfve| hgb, GKmgq evsjv`k MocoZv wkwZRb`i Rb Avw`evmx`i mcK Rvbvi cavb

7

Drm wQj Ave`ym mvvii jLv AviY Rbc`, AviY mswZ, AviY cgcfwZ eB| Avevi covkvbvi evw I MfxiZv iqQ, Ggb evOvwj`i gaAvw`evmx`i msMvg mcK mse`bkxjZvi cvV bIqvi GKwU cavb Drm njgnvkZv `exi AiYi AwaKvi| Aek evOvwj gvbm Avw`evmx ejZB AviYRbc` evSvjI, AiY gvbB h memgq Avw`evmx-AaywlZ fwg evSvq, Zvbq| hgb, iex `bv_ VvKzi Zvui mfZvi cwZ KweZvq h AiY diZ PqQb,mLvb iqQ Zcveb, MvPviY, mvgMvb cfwZ| h Kve-fwgi wejyw wbqKweii nvnvKvi, Zv hZUv bv AiY, Zvi PvBZI Avmj GKwU mvg Rbc`,hv AvhveZiB Ask, hLvb Kvb Abvh Avw`evmxi DcwwZ PvL co bv|

Avmj, m A_ Kvb gvbe mgvRB wVK AiY evm Ki bv| evBii gvbyl`iPvL AiYevmx, Ggb mgvRi jvKivI wbR`i ejvq GKUv f` iLv gbPj AiY Ges jvKvjqi ga| A_P Avw`evmx gvb cKwZi mvb, AiYiAwaevmx Ggb `wfwi aviK-evnK-ceviv mPivPi GB gwjK welqUv Rvbbbv ev Lqvj Kib bv| Guiv weePbvq wbq Avgiv ejZ cvwi, Rswj kibwZevPK ebv GovZ wMq KD hw` AiYPvix aibi c` eenvi Ki,ZvZI GB aviYvMZ AmwZUv iqB hvq| GLvb DjL Kiv AcvmwK ne bv,cveZ PMvg GK mgq Rji gvbyl K_vUv cvqB kvbv hZ vbxq gvbyl`igyL (wcyiviv ejZ ejswb eiK, PvKgviv Svieyqv), hv w`q evSvbv nZkvwevwnbxK! bxP Avwg Aviv `ywU D`vniY `e hv w`q eb ev AiYi mv_Avw`evmx`i AweQ` Ki `Lvi mgmvUv evSv hve|

c_g D`vniYUv nQ 13Zg wewmGm cixvi ck I mgvavb bvg ARvjcvIqv GKwU ck I Zvi Di| AvM ckUv, I mv_ `Iqv mve Diwj, `Lbqv hvK:

ebiv eb my`i,wkiv gvZvo G DwwUi cKZ Zvrch nQK. Avw`evmx gvbyl AiY Rbc` evm KiL. ebi c eb _vKZ fvjevmM. Rxe gvB ^vfvweK Aevb my`iN. cKwZi ic-m`h Avw` I AKwg

mwVK Di wnmve KvbUv `Lvbv nqQ, Zv Avgiv GKUz ci Rb be| ZviAvM Ab GKUv D`vniY `L bB| mUv nj, ebiv eb my`i wkivgvZvo, G welq Ag beg `kg kwYi wkv_x`i Rb `wbK BdvK(15 g, 2013) Avyjvn Avj gvgybi jLv GKwU fvemcmviY| bxP mLvb

84

_K Askwekl DZ Kiv nj:mwRMZ mewKQzB wbR wbR cwiek I cvwicvwkKZvq ^vfvweK m`hAbycgZv cvq| AiYPvix gvbyl AviYK RxebB cvq ^ZtZ ^vQ`|cwieki mv_ Lvc LvBq wbR^ cvq Zviv cKwZi mv_ Rxeb cwZ ImswZ Mo Zzj| Zv`i Rxeb mswZ Mo IV AviYK cwieki mv_hvMm~ I mwZ iL| AiYjvwjZ mnR-mij Abvo^i RxebB ZvivcwiZ| cvKwZK cwiekB Giv gvbvbmB|

Dcii DwZZ h ee `Iqv nqQ, gvUv `vM Zvi mv_ wgZ cKvkiKvb AeKvk bB| Ze AiYPvix gvbyl wVK Kviv, Kb ev wK A_ ZvivAiYjvwjZ mnR-mij Abvo^i Rxeb cwiZ, Zv evLvi `vwe ivL| G cmDjL, ebvj h gvbyliv evm Ki, y`B kZvwaK eQi ai Zv`iK wUK _vKZnQ wewfb aibi wnsmZvi mv_| GLvb Avgiv evN-fvjyKi K_v ejwQ bv, eisejwQ iv I evRvi bvgK gvbe BwZnvmi `yBwU wPwoqvi K_v, hjv cw_exime wKQz wMj LqB PjQ|

wewUk kvmbvgj _K cveZ PMvgi GK PZz_vsk fwg msiwZ ebvj wnmvewPwZ nq AvQ, hLvb vbxq Awaevmx`i cek `bxq Aciva| A_P ivwVKB ea-Aea wewea Dcvq GB ebwji webvk `L AvmQ| Abw`KAkwYfz ivxq eb bvg wPwZ cvnvwo fwgZ vbxq`i RygPvli AwaKvi_vKjI mRb cqvRbxq fwg Lye KgB GLb Zv`i wRvq iqQ| G AevqmnR-mij-Abvo^i Rxeb Af I cwiZ AiYPvix gvbyl cveZ PMvgKZRb AvQ, ejv gykwKj| (Dci wewmGm cixvi h ck `Iqv nqQ, ZvimwVK Di `Lvbv AvQ M|)

ivOv gvwUi c_iex `bv_ VvKzii GKwU Mvb MvgQvov h ivOv gvwUi c_ gb fzwjq `q, Zv KvbAvw`evmx cjxi mv_ hy wKbv evSvi Dcvq bB| Ze KvRx bRij BmjvgiGB ivOv gvwUi c_ jv Mvb hLb gv`j Avi evuwk eR IV, gqvi eb Puv`igvZvj nvwm jywUq co, ZLb Avgv`i eySZ evwK _vK bv h Avgiv GKUvAvw`evmx Rbc`- myc Ki ejj muvIZvj GjvKvq- AvwQ| bRij QvovIAviv ek wKQz eo gvci evOvwj Kwe-mvwnwZK-wkx muvIZvj`i RMZK eQwbqwQjb Zuv`i mRbkxjZvi ciYv, cUfwg ev welq wnmve| m m~ gv`jiZvj, euvwki myi Avi nvwoqvi gv`KZv mnhvM bZMxZ-Drme gZ _vKvmuvIZvj bvix cyil`i h~_e Rxebi GKUv ivgvwUK cwZQwe AbKi gvbmcU

9

Mfxi Qvc w`q AuvKv AvQ, hv Kviv KvQ Avw`g mviji cwZg~wZ, ev my`~iAZxZ dj Avmv Kvb c~eZb mv ev HwZni cwZQvqv| G aibi icvqYBwZnvmi Kvb cwZdjb bB, bB eve Rxebi elg, wbcxob ev cwZivaiKvb Qvc| hw` cwZivai wP KLbv DVI Avm, Zv mPivPi AvUK _vKHwZnvwmK vb-Kvj-cvi Da GKUv wPib QK|

wk ev mvwnZi Avw`evmxiv Zxi-abyK w`q hy Pvwjq hvq, hw`I eve Zv`imgKvjxb cwZwbwai AbKi nvZ GK-47-Gi gZ A `Lv MQ! A_vr wewfbgvag wkx`i wPvqb Avw`evmx Rxebi h Qwe Zzj aiv nq, eveZvi mv_Zvi Lye KgB wgj `Lv hvq| mswZi G aibi Dcvcbv cwiPvwjZ nQ evOvwjmgvR cwZwZ mswZ-msv wewfb avb-aviYvi AvjvK, h GKwUDjLhvM mshvRb wQj 2010 mvji z` bMvxi mvswZK cwZvb AvBb,hvi gvag ek wKQz cwZvbi mvBbevW DcRvZxq kwUi e`j em z`bMvx| GKB avivevwnKZvq 2011 mvj msweavbi c`k mskvabxZ hy nq23K aviv, hvi gvag DcRvwZ, z` RvwZMvx, bMvx I mc`vqi mswZI HwZni msiY I weKvki `vq ivi Dci Gm eZvq|

DwjwLZ `vq iv Kxfve gUvbvi D`vM wbqQ Zvi wKQz bgybv ^P `LviAwfZv Avgvi nqwQj RyjvB 2013-Z| bRiji Mvb b ivOv gvwUi c_ kvjwcqvj gqv ebi P`vjvwKZ gw`i cwiek gv`ji Zvj A XD IVv hAvw`evmx bvix Avgv`i Kbvq aiv co- GKUv Abyvb wMq `wL miKg bvixiwKQz be msiY wkKjv GKvWgxi wcP Xvjv ivvq bvPZ bvPZ cavb AwZw_I Ab`i eiY KiwQjb GKUv Abyvb| Avi bRiji Mvb h gv`j evRZ wbAvgiv, miKg wKQz ev`h, mv_ Zxi abyK, Avw`evmx bvix`i cwiaq- Gmew`q mvRvbv wQj D Abyvbi gvag DvwaZ nIqv z` bMvxi HwZnmsMnkvjv| wkivbvg z` bMvx AvQ, Ggb GKvwaK eBI wQj mLvb|Avw`evmx`i mswZ I HwZnK Gfve BwZnvm-wehy msMnkvjv, g, c`kbxgvV, Ges M eua djvi AvqvRb Avmj Pj AvmQ mB cvwKvb ev wewUkAvgj _KB| ck nj, z ` bMvxiv wK ay bvPe MvBe, Avi msMnkvjvq Zzj`e Zv`i mswZi wewfb DcKiY, bvwK Zviv fwg I ebi Dci Zv`i nvivbvAwaKviI wdi cve? klv welq msweavbi 23K aviv mc~Y bxie|

ivRc_HwZnvwmKfve mvg I JcwbewkK kvmb-kvlYi wei G`ki Avw`evmxiviL `uvwoqQ evievi| evsjv`ki gyw msMvgI Zv`i evcK AskMnY wQj|

105

cieZxKvj BwZnvmi AwfNvZ Zv`i ga hviv fwg _K DrLvZ nq bMigyLxnqQ, nq kwgK-KgPvix wnmve, bZzev wkv_x A_ev evey kwYi Ask wnmve,ZvivI AbK wewfb mgq ivRc_ bg GmQ wewfb Abvqi cwZev` RvbvZ|wK Avw`evmx`i evcvi evOvwj mgvR cPwjZ eg~j wKQz aviYv GB ivRc_iAvw`evmx`iK wVKgZ Zzj aiv ev eyS IVvi GKUv evav wnmve KvRKi| G cm GKUv QvU D`vniY `e Avgvi ewMZ AwfZvi AvjvK|

ivOvgvwUi jsM`yZ 1989 mvji 4Vv g GKUv nZvKv msNwUZ nIqvi ci ZvicwZev` 21 g ZvwiL cvnvwo wkv_x`i GKUv AfZc~e cwZev` wgwQj AbywZnqwQj XvKvi ivRc_| mB wgwQj Ask bIqvi AwfZv AvgvK GZUvB bvovw`qwQj h, ZLb Avwg GKUv KweZv wjL djwQjvg, hv cieZxZ wbevwmZkgvjv bvg Qvcv nqQ| mwU i nqQ Gfve :

n Avgvi wbevwmZ kgvjv-wgwQji kZ kZ AvjvwoZ `q Zvgv`i WvK GmQ|kZvxi ebvi weviYvbyL vf ZvgivI nI kvwgj|

gRvi evcvi nj, ARvj NvUZ wMq KqKgvm AvM Avwg nVvr Avwevi Kijvg,Avgvi K_vwji mc~Y fzj evLv Ki em AvQb Gg G gvgb bvg GKRb, whwbc_g AvjvZ cKvwkZ Zuvi GK jLvq wbevwmZ kgvjv ejZ eySQbAvw`evmx`i wecb fvlv, Ges Avwg G wbq nvnvKvi KijI Zv h cKvk KiwQevsjvq, G K_v fe welY Avc cKvk KiQb : evsjvi Aev cw_exiAwaKvsk fvlvi Pq fvjv, AZ Avw`evmx fvlvjvi Pq Zv eUB, bZzevAvw`evmx Kwe Zvui gvZfvlv Qo evsjvq KweZvi PPv KiZb bv| ckv wcyivwbevwmZ kgvjvi Rb AvZbv` KiQb evsjvZB|

1989-Gi ci _K G`ki ki Avw`evmxiv wbqwgZB ivRc_ _KQ,KLbv Zv`i MvgxY ^Rb`i Dci msNwUZ wewfb AZvPvii cwZev`, KLbveni bvMwiK mgvRi MYZvwK Av`vjbi Ask wnmve| wK GB DcwwZ-wekl Ki klv aibi cwiw wZZ- mPivPi `wi AvovjB _K MQ wewfbMYgvag, Ges wk-mvwnZ Aviv ekx| cvi, wek Avw`evmx w`em RvZxqAbyvb, ev ivxq Abyvbvw`Z, Avw`evmxiv hLb HwZnevnx (Avw`/g) mvqnvwRi nq, Zv`i DcwwZ mevi bRi co, cksmv Kzovq| Gfve PjZ _vKvb-Kvj wbic fve wekl QuvP Rbcwimi Avw`evmx`i DcvwcZ nIqvi,ev ^-Dcvcbvi, aviv|

11

ARvjGLvb ARvj ejZ evSvbv nQ BUvibUK, hLvb mgvR ev iv we`gvbwewfb eveZvi cwZdjb `Lv hvq, Avevi AbK b~Zb ic wbR`i Qvqvmvev cwZmv Zwi KiQ| Avgv`i AvjvPbvi h Rwgb, Avw`g AbZv, ZvImLvb Zwi nQ b~Zb ic| Avi ARvj hgb Avw`evmx`i Rb nq DVQwbR`i Zzj aivi Ges cwZc`i gvKvejv Kivi b~Zb mxgv, Zgwb AbivIh hvi gZ Ki gvV iqQ Avw`g AbZvi Rwgb wbR`i cfve cwZvq, hvihvi gZv`wkK, eemvwqK ev Abvb ^v_i AbyKj| Gmei cwZ wKQz welqwekl gbvhvMi `vwe ivL| hgb, Avw`evmx`i mcK wewfb aibi AccPviARvj `Z I evcKfve Qwoq `Iqv nQ, hv gvKvejv KiZ necwiKwZfve, wewfb Kkj LvwUq| Avi G ARvj GKUv myhvM Kiw`qQ wek Ryo wgZv I mnhvwMZvi b~Zb mcKRvj Zwi KiZ| Ze Avwggb Kwi m myhvM wVKgZ KvR jvMvZ Mj Avw`evmx cwiPqK Avw`gAbZvi wbMo _K ei Ki wbq Gi mveRbxb Ave`bK mvgb wbq AvmZne, A_vr mgKvjxb cvcU Avw`evmx cwiPqK b~Zb A_ I gvv w`Z ne|welqUv Avwg GKUz evLv Kie Avgvi wbRi mvcwZK GKUv Dcjwi AvjvK|Avwg Avw`evmx kUv wbq QvU ejvq KLbv Lye ekx gv_v NvwgqwQjvg ejgb co bv| Ze wKkvi eqm jLv wbRi GKUv KweZvq Avwg GUv LyuRcqwQ| Icvi bvg GB KweZvi iUv GiKg :

GB gvVUvK nVvr, KvR KiZ KiZgb nj eo ewk duvKv, a~ a~-Pj Mjvg b`xUvi Icvk,IB cvii meyR eb, bxj cvnvo|

mLvb Avwg MZ w`bwjZdmj dwjqwQ,MZKvjI Avwg Avw`evmx wQjvgmLvb RygPvl KiwQ|[XvKv, 1979]

h mgq Avwg KweZvUv wjLwQjvg, ZLb Avgvi Rxebi j wQj Wvvi ev Bwwbqvi,GB `ywU fwgKvi ga GKwUK eQ bIqv, hfve mgq I cwicvk wVK Kiw`qwQj| m Abyhvqx DP gvawgK cvk Ki eyqU XzKjvg Zwor cKkjx nIqviwPvq| mLvb GKUv Qv msMVb hvM w`q mvgvRev`x`i wei vi Qvov, ivZRM cvvi jLv, BZvw` KgKv eQiLvbK RwoZ _vKvi ci nVvr Ki cqMjvg GKUv ew, ZvI Avevi Ggb GKUv `k, hwUi Kvjv nvZ uwoq `Iqvi K_v

126

ej vMvb w`Zvg! Avwg h `j KiZvg, mB `ji bZv, whwb GLb MvgUm KviL-vbvi gvwjK ej bwQ, G wbq fxlY zY nqwQjb| hvnvK, we`k cvwo w`jvgKwcDUvi wevbx nevi wPv Ki... wK AvU eQi ci wdi Gjvg Aac GKbwevbx wnmve| hvnvK, bwevb cov wQj Avgvi Rb AvZvbymvbi Ask, hv KiZwMq GK chvq Avwg i KiwQjvg wbRi AvZcwiPqi ciZjv Lvjvi KvR|ZvZ c_gB Avwevi Kijvg, hfve wbRK wPbZ wkLwQjvg, Zvi cQb iqQevOvwj evey kwYi AvivaRbiv- iex`bv_, bRij cgyL| mB ciZ LyjZ wMqAvwevi Kijvg cwgv`i- B Bwqv Kvcvwb _K i Ki evU ivmj,gv, dqW, KZ wK| mB DbvPbi cwqv GLbv PjQ!

Dci DZ wbRi KweZvUv hLb Avwg dmeyK w`qwQjvg MZ eQi Kvb GKmgq, AbKi KvQ _KB ek fvj mvov cqwQjvg, hv`i ga Awjqv _KKvbvWv- cw_exi wewfb cv Qwoq _vKv AbK ey wQjb- KD evOvwj, KDPvKgv, KDev wcyiv ev Mviv, BZvw`| Zvuiv wK KD wbRK Avw`evmx fveb?Awjqv ev KvbvWvZ cveZ PMvg _K hvIqv hme Avw`evmxiv AwfevmxnqQb, Zuv`i mv_ mme `ki- ev wbRi `ki- Avw`evmx`i PjgvbmsMvgi hyZv wK? huviv hy _vKZ Pvb, nZ Pvb, Zuv`i Rb Zv Kivi mevgDcvq wK? ARvj Avgv`i myhvM Ki w`qQ cw_exi wewfb cv Qwoq _vKve eyi mv_ Aii Rvjv, ck BZvw` fvMvfvwM Ki wbZ| Avgvi KvQ GgbwKQz ck nj, Avw`evmx cwiPqi Zvrch wK? Avw`evmx AwaKvii K_v AvgivhLb ewj, ZLb wbR`i K_v fe wK Zv Avgiv Kwi? Avi Avgiv hviv mvPvinB wewfb mgq- hgb hLb wb myRvZv ev mvMwi bvgi Avw`evmx bvix-wkalK`i nvZ cvY `q, Avi GB iv `vlx`i LyuR cvq bv- wKQz weewZ,gvbeeb, ev dmeyK KweZv cv Kiv, GmeB wK Avgv`i `vq kl? Avi`vqUv wK ay Avw`evmx`iB?

evwK K_vevOvwj gvbm Avw`g AbZvi Rwgb KZUv ev Av` Zzj aiZ ciwQ wKbv, ZvwePvii fvi cvVKi Dci Qo w`jvg| G cvVK`i ivq hvB nvK, Zuv`iKAbyiva Kie Avgvi jLvwUK GKUv AvjvPbvi m~cvZ wnmve `LZ| Zuv`iga KD hw` mUv Pvwjq hZ AvMnx nb, Zvnj Zv ne Avgvi Rb evowZcvIbv| G cm cvwLi PvL Avw`g AbZvi Rwgb `LZ wMq ay `~i _KBPvL coQ, Ggb wKQz cjweZ vbi K_v DjL KiwQ hjv Aviv KvQ _K`Lvi `iKvi AvQ| mme RvqMvq eo gvci MvQi gZ `uvwoq AvQbAvLZvivgvb Bwjqvm, mwjg Avj `xb, gvgybyi ikx` cgyL|

13

Bwjqvmi Rxekvq Avwg GKevi Zuvi evmvq wMqwQjvg, Zuvi mv_ K_v ejwQjvgAbKY, wK Zuvi PvKgv Dcbvm PvB ceUv Avgvi cov nq IV wb GLbv|Zuvi cZvkv wK nZ cvi, Ges Kb wZwb Zv DPviY Ki _vKZ cvib, m evcviAvgvi GKUv aviYv AvQ, Ze Zuvi jLvUv bv co Kvb ge Kiv wVK ne bv|ZvB m cm GLb _vK| GLvb Avwg eis Bwjqvm mcK dviK Iqvwmdi GKUvg~jvqb Zzj aiwQ, hv cvmwK: z `, ZzQ gvbyli Rxebi kw I m`h h Acvimvebv ai, ZvK wZwb mvwnZi ga wbgvnfve dwjq `Lvb| DZ evKiDci Avgvi PvL AvUK wMqwQj z` kUv `L, hUvi mv_ mvsweavwbKfveAvw`evmxiv euvav covi ci Zv GLb Zv`i AbKi KvQ nq DVQ Zv`i hveZxqebv, e`bv I vfi- Zv`i cwZ ivi I evOvwj wermgvRi Aevi - g~ZcZxK| AvLZvivgvb Bwjqvm euP _vKj wbq z` bvg AvLvwqZ GBgvbyl`i cvk wMq `uvovZb, G wbq Kjg aiZb| Avgvi wekvm, Zuvi PvLAvw`evmx`i msLvMZ z`Zv bq, eis Zvu`i Rxebv`ki gnB eo nq `Lvw`qwQj| evOvwj wermgvRi gvbwmK msKxYZv, ev z`Zv, Aek ZuvK wbqAevK KiZ bv, hw`Iev nqZ ew_Z KiZ, hnZz wZwb wbRI Gi Ask wQjb|

Avw`evmx`i Rb mvsweavwbKfve eivKZ Ab GKUv k nj bMvx, hvimv_ Rwoq AvQ mwjg Avj `xbi bvg| RvnvxibMi wekwe`vjq wZwb hwefvM covZb, mB wefvMi GKRb wkK AvgvK Mei mv_ ejwQjb,bMvx kUv bvwK Zuv`iB Dveb wQj| mwjg Avj `xb wQjb evsjv`k wbI-G_wbK w_qUvi- evsjvq be bMvx bvU- PPvi cw_Kr ev cev| Zvi gvbevsjv`ki Avw`evmxiv h z` bMvxi gZ GKUv LUgU bvgi mv_ euvavcoj, GUv Zuv`iB Ae`vb? mwjg Avj `xb GLbv euP _vKj Avwg ZuvKAekB ckUv KiZvg| gvigv icK_v, KivgZ gj, ebcvsj cfwZ bvUKimv, hwj Ryo AvQ Avw`evmx`i Rxeb, RMZ, ggwiZ fM AiYi fZiDPvwiZ iv Rbc`i cuvPvwj, wZwb wbq bZ cZb z` bMvx c`iga wgk _vKv evOvwj DbvwmKZvi myi? mnR evsjvq ejj z` bMvxi A_`uvovq QvU RvZi gvbyl ev QvU gvbyli RvZ- Gwj hw` AvcwKi nq ZeZrmg c`Uv Kb ne bv? Rswj kUv hv`i KvQ bwZevPK A_ enb Ki,Zv`i `wfw wK cv hve AiYevmx ev miKg Kvb k Pvjy Kiv nj?

AvLZvivgvb Bwjqvm ev mwjg Avj `xb euP bB, wK Avgv`i gvS AvQbgvgybyi ikx`| Zuvi ivpvs bvUKUv fvj Ki GLbv `Lv nq IV wb Avgvi, ZeGwUi mK bxPi K_vwj covi ci gb nQ, fwelZ GwU `Lvi evbvUKvii mv_ Avjvci myhvM cj Zv KvR jvMvZ ne :

147

ivpvs A_ RM IVvi Rb `~ivMZ gv`ji awb| Avw`evmxiv `~ivMZgv`ji awbB bQ eKvj ai| wK Zv`i gyw bB| fwgiAwaKvi ewZ GB Avw`evmxiv evi evi jovBq gZ DVQ| wKgyw cvqwb| bvPvj we`vn _K AvjdW mibi fwgi AwaKvijovB ch we Z Gi Kvwnbx| AvjdW mibi Dvb I wbzi nZvqGi cwimgvw|

AvjdW mibi gZz, ev ivpvs-Gi cwimgvw, wbq Avw`evmx`i msMvgi klK_v nZ cvi bv| GB msMvg PjQ, Pje| ck nQ, gvgybyi ikx`i bvUK, evAvcbvi Avgvi y`GKwU KweZv, ev gvbeeb- mjvi AvqvRb hZ AvwiKfveBKiv nvK, Gjv wK VwKq ivLZ cvie evsjv`ki gvwU _K Lywg`i bxiecvb, ev wekl Kvb DPevP Qvov PvK`i MvgQvov nIqv? GB NUbvjv hNUQ, evsjv`ki KqRb gvbyl Lei ivL? Kviv GB Lywg ev PvK? Zviv nj z ``iga z`Zg bMvx| gvbyl wnmve, bvMwiK wnmve, Kviv PvBZ Zv`i AwaKviKg bq| Ze Zvi evBiI Zv`i GKUv Avjv`v iZ AvQ| RvwZ-iv wnmveevsjv`ki DPZvi mevg cwigvcK wK nZ cvi? Avgvi KvQ Gi Di nj :Lywg, PvK ev gv`vB`i gZ RvwZ`i wUK _vKv bv _vKv, fvj _vKv bv _vKv-G`ki mvwnZ, wk, Ges gvwUZ|

Z_m~ I UxKv1. bRij iPbvejxi cKvwkZ-AcKvwkZ msKjb: k bRij| Ave`yj gvbvb mq`

msKwjZ I mcvw`Z| Aemi cKvkbv msv, XvKv, 1996|2. GB jLvwji ga wQj Avw`evmx aviYv wbq miKvwi Avcwi fZ Ges wek eQi AvMi

wKQz K_v, GKwU gvV, `yBwU MvjK I GKwU MvjKauvav: Avw`evmx w`emK wNi AvgviwKQz fvebv Ges AviY Rbc`i mxgvbv Qvwoq AvRvwZK mb`i QvqvZj: evsjv`kAvw`evmx cwiPq cybwbgvYi y`B `kK (1993-2013), hwj h_vg GKwU Zv QvmsMVbi msKjb, mvAv Rvbvj I evsjv`k Avw`evmx dvivgi msnwZZ cKvwkZnqQ| kli `yBwU wbe jLKi ewMZ eM cybtcKvwkZ nqQ : http://ptripura1.wordpress.com/

3. DjL, eZgvb wbei GKUv mswZi ic BZvga cKvwkZ nqQ GB jLKiewMZ eM, hwUi wVKvbv Dci `Iqv nqQ (2 bs UxKv `e)|

4. KweZvwU Avwg `L wbqwQ DBwKmsKjb (24/7/13-Z):5. http://bn.wikisource.org/wiki/ mfZvicwZ6. http://goo.gl/xxqOkR (RyjvB 26, 2013-Z bvgvbv)

http://goo.gl/PJIAiu (RyjvB 26, 2013-Z bvgvbv)7. bRiji ivOv gvwUi c_ jv MvbUvi myi I K_v _K GwU h muvIZvwj Nivbvi, G

evcvi Avgvi Abygvbi mg_b Avwg cqwQ Abyc mvw`i eM evsjv Mvb muvIZvwj myi15

(RyjvB 1, 2013) GKUv cv _K, http://goo.gl/fMqg5z, hvi mvb ARvj cvB24/7/13 ZvwiL|

8. G cm dmeyK Avwg GKUv bvU w`qwQjvg, miKvwi msMnkvjv wK nZ hvQAvw`evmx`i HwZni kl Me? wkivbvg (RyjvB 9, 2013), hv ci GKwU eM `IqvnqQ: http://chtbd.org/?p=2041

9. Gg G gvgb, RxweZ fvlvi giYhvv: e fvlvi evsjv`k, deqvwi 3, 2012,http://goo.gl/jupYrt (gvP 16, 2013-Z bvgvbv)

10. BUvibU-Gi cvwifvwlK evsjv cwZk ARvj ne bvwK AvRvj ne, G wbq GKUvweZK Pjgvb iqQ `Ljvg| Mj mvPi wfwZ c_gUvi w`KB cvjv fvix gb nq (3:1AbycvZ)| Avevi AbK AvQb, hvuiv KvbUvKB h_v_ ev evKiYmZ gb Kib bv|Avwg Gme hywZKi KvbUvi g~jvqb bv wMqB ARvj kUvK eQ wbqwQ, hviawbMZ `vZbv Avgvi cwZ mePq RyZmB gb nqQ|

11. PvKgv Dcbvm PvB bvgi jLvUv AvLZvivgvb Bwjqvmi ce msKjb mswZi fvOvmZzZ AvQ, hvi cKvkK gvIjv ev`vm|

12. kvwj bq GB iY eis cwZev` wnmveB MY nvK, dviK Iqvwmd (4 Rvbyqvwi 2010),http://nirmaaan.com/blog/faruk-wasif/5808

13. mvBgb RvKvwiqv (AvM 2008) evsjv`k wbI-G_wbK w_qUvi PPvi cw_Kr, http://goo.gl/PYPT3f

14. gvgybyi ikx`, bvUK mgM 3, bvj`v (2013) http://goo.gl/L1trZ3

168

Avw`evmxfvlvq mvwnZPPvGKwU Dcjwi Abyev`

nvwdR iwk` Lvb

gvZfvlv welq wKwr BwZecw_exi mvaviY-AmvaviY Kvbv gvbyliB PZbvq G welq we`ygv m`n evweZK _vKvi K_v bq h, cw_ex bvgK Mni cwZwU gvbyli Zvi gvZfvlvq ejv,jLv I wPvi Aeva ^vaxbZv iqQ| GKw`K _K ejj AvRKi w`bwU chZvB-B nq AvmQ| gvS-ga `yGKwU mgq I `ywbqv Kuvcvbv NUbv Qvov|gvZfvlvq Rxebhvcbi `vweZ wek kZKi cvk `kK AvRKi evsjv`k(ZrKvjxb c~e cvwKvb) Ges lvUi `kK fviZi eivK DcZKvi (AvmvgiwkjPi) evsjvfvlxiv Av`vjb-msMvg KiQ| AZtci Zviv AwacwZ cwZciivlvbj cvY wemRb w`q ^fvlv I ^RvZevai cwiPq DrKxY iLQBwZnvmi cvZvq| GKw`K _K G RvZxq NUbvK BwZnvmi ewZgx Awfcej kbv Kiv Pj| AbK HwZnvwmKI ZvB ejb| fvlvi AwaKvi ivievcviwU hLb wewfb Av_-mvgvwRK, mvswZK kvlY-wbcxobi cyxfZ Ae`gbiewntcKvk wnme ivRbwZK Zvrch wbq kvmK ev gZv-ZL&Zi cwZax nqIV, Zvi wePvi-weePbv nq wfbgvwK| hgb evsjv`k ivi Afz`qi cQbDcwbewkK cvwK vwb kvmKMvxi ewea ebv Avi wbcxobi cwicwZ RwoZwQj ivfvlv evsjvi Aegvbbvi wei Av`vjbwU|

mB GKB evsjv`k ivi eZgvb cwiek-cwiwwZ lvU-evlw eQii AvMKviZzjbvq AbK, AbK e`j MQ| ^vaxbZvc~e mgqi Pq GLbKvi evsjv`kimKj ii wkwZ, mPZb bvMwiK G`k my`~i HwZnvwmKKvj _K wewfbAvw`evmx RvwZmvi we`gvbZv welq AbK ewk Z_mg, mse`bkxj IcviwiK hvMvhvMcZvkx nq IVQ| cvwKvb Avgj h-welqwU wQj cv_yi`qvji gZv Af`, AcwiwPZ I AvMnnxbZvi AKvi wbgwZ| evsjv`kivi AwZi myev` m `qvj GLb AcmZ, AvjvwKZ I AbKLvwb cmvwiZejjI AZyw ne bv| MYgvagi mgqvchvMx DbwZ I we wZ, GKwesk kZK

17

Z_fvvii AevwiZ wegyw, mevcwi, ^`k Avw`evmx RbMvxi geagvbmPZbZvewi eveZv I Zv`i Rxebavivi ewP msiYi AvIqvR GKvjibvMwiKK wbtm`n fvevq| `kR gvbemvmg~ni HKZvb gvwjK iv MVbDy I DxweZ Ki| Avgvi aviYv, evsjv`ki Afy`q GB njv GK jngvqAbKjv cvwi hvMdji GKwU Dj mgxKiY|

h Kvbv cvwB AviI ej cvwi cvUvZb Zwi Ki| Zwi efvOv AviI AMmic`PviYvi ciYv wbq Avm| AvZ-Dcjwi w`M cmvwiZ I Dby Ki `q|bZzbZi Rxeb wbgvY I mvebvi cwZ AvMn RvwMq Zvj AviI| G meiKvbvUvB AzZvZK, AbmwMK wKsev Agvbexq ^fve-Pwi bq| G Zv RxebiBMwZ, hvcbiB AMZ Drmvi| G wbwiLB evsjv`ki Avw`evmx Rbgvbyli fZiGmQ c_v I jvKvPvi, mswZ I RxebvPvi welq wbR^ wPvPZbvi cmvi, mmei cwZ iYvZK `wfw ev `vqeZv| G cm GI iY Kiv `iKvi,DwjwLZ PZbvgw_Z welqjvi Dbl NU cvwZvwbK DPwkv I cvwicvwkKDbZZi mswZ ev Rxebhvcbi wg_wqvq| Ab_vq IB cmsMjv wKQznvgvbei wPiKvji Ae`wgZ A_P fvweZ wejvc chewmZ nq Kvji AZjMf nvwiq hZ| Avw`evmx mgvRi i-i, cvnvo I cv_ii Mvq nqZv ZvDrKxY nq AvQ AvRI hvi cvVvvi Kvbv KvjB Avi me ne bv nqZv|wK hvi ik iq hvq h_ AePZbvi fZi AjB| KvRB AvRKi m^y,mgKvjxb fveSoi NvZ-cwZNvZ Pj Avw`evmx ZiY-hyev wKsev Zv`i AMRivhLb Avcb mvswZK DivwaKvi wnme Zv`i gvZRevb, cvnvo I wSwi-SibviAven awbZ-cwZawbZ Zv`i jvK^iK becvY`vb DxweZ nq IV, ZLbZv mgqi ^fveK cwZnZ Ki bv| eis ZvZ exY Gfve cvw_Z nq h, Gnjv bZzb Kvji AvPiY, bZzb cw_ex I be Z_cevni msM AwfhvRbiHKvwK Dvmb|

Di-KvVvgvev`xiv (cv vKPvivwj) ejQb, GKwU eo Kvbv kvwgqvbviwbP mKj gvbylK GKxfZ Ki ivLvi wesk kZKxq wKsev Zvi c~eKvi `viAvi Kvbv KvhKvwiZv GLb Avi bB| G cZqi fZi gvbyli ga cvemKj ewki cwZ hwK ccvZ c`kb Kiv nqQ| hLvb RvwZZvwK,bZvwK, fvwlK, mvswZK Ggb wK vwbK ^vZi K_vI Aby _vK bv|meZ IB `vkwbK AwfNvZi Av`jB wdwjcvBb, fviZ, evsjv`k I AviIKqKwU iv mme `kwZ Avw`evmx`i m mxwZ I mnv` ivi ZvwM`bvbv cwicwZi Pzw ev mgSvZvi evZveiY Zwi nqQ|

189

PvKgvfvlv I mvwnZwVK GB RvqMvwUZ `uvwoq Avw`evmx mgvRi AvjvwKZ Ask hLb wbR`igvZfvlvq mvwnZPPvi K_v ej, Zv Avi Zgb wem`k VK bv| cveZ PMvgicmsMUvB AvcvZZ GLvb evaMgZvi LvwZi Dc vcb Kiv hvq| ILvbKvi PvKgvmgvR B`vbxb mgq Zv`i mvwnZ mswZwfwK fvebvjvK Zv`i wbR^fvlvq gyw`Z I cKvwkZ KiZ AvMnx| agxq, mvgvwRK wK mvswZK ZrciZvqwewfb QvU QvU gyw`Z AwfewZ Zv`i Dchy Awfcvqi cwiPq cvIqv hvq|KweZv M bvUK BZvw` mRbkxj D`vM-AvqvRb QvovI wewfb HwZnvwmKwelqI PvKgv fvlvq wbqwgZ Qc eiQ ivOvgwU wKsev LvMovQwo _K| GiKg KqKwU mvwnZci bvg cmsMg DjL Kiv hvq, hgb: iO (AvIqvRev awb); KvRjx (Abyiva); ivbRywb (isaby); iMv (mZzeb); P (wP) cfwZ|G KvMRjv QvovI PvKgv fvlvq `xcsKi kxvb PvKgvi KveM cv`viOKvPcvbv (meyRvf fvjvevmv); my` PvKgvi evMx (ngwK cvwL); KweZvPvKgvi Rwj b Dwag wKB (Rj DVev bv Kb); gwKv PvKgvi GvsKzi(cybivq); gN mi gvbv PzK (gNcvnvo) cKvwkZ nqQ|

PvKgv fvlvi KvweK ~wZ I ebvi mvgvb LvuR wbZ GLvb wkwki PvKgviGKwU KweZvi DwZ w`wQ| evsjv nid gyw`Z PvKgv DPviYfw mg KweZvwUiwkivbvg wPZ& gb Avi b wfR (`q Avi ckvw bB) :

aeaev Rybvcn&i gb gyiv wfwS hvqwfwR hvq KjM Av`vg,SiZ wfP cMv mvb, eM cSivZzq Kvi `yb`yM bB|Rybv cnii m`P AvjvOezb wbP& Avgwj|m Rybvcn&i wPZ&gb Avi b wfR|

h gb gyivZ BvKz`yg-wkOvi cvjyAveywS iBqb gvw` Kvgi, wcwizb wcwiRyg Ryg eoqvb, jvOji ca ivOqvbQov_yg gv`qvb gjvbx cv`vi b fvSqvb,GP m gb gyiv Khvb AwPb AwPbwekvPnviv mw`fvOv wgj `MAv`j Av`j PvMwcwS wiwb Pvq,mB gb gyivZ wPZ&gb Avi b wfR|

cww`b c Avgj cMv KvjKvwjZNyg fvwO hvq

19

Ka cM Mx` Mvb, Ka cM nP myM Dwo eovbBiK eb Ni Kevi gwjjD`vbZ BRviZ gb gyiv KjMZ_j fzBqvZ QovQwo Mvs cvoZevbv Kev SvK, LviLvR AvevR AbmyiG LviLvR AvevRZ wPZ&gb Avi b wfR

[Avjvob Lxmv mvw`Z P& Gwcj 2013 msLv _K, c. 68]

Zey hLvb Rvi w`Z PvBKweZvwUi wbivfiY A_P e`bvgw_Z cevn PvKgvfvlv Rvbv cvVKi gb h-AbyiYb mw nq, Zv wbq Mfxi Abyavebi| KweZvwUZ AZxZgyZvi AvQbZvhgb AvQ, mB AZxZi mbZv nvwiq wiZvi wejvcI AvQ| cvkvcvwkeni cvVKi msM mshvM vcbi KweZvwUZ bMvxMZ fvlvimxgveZvI DuwK `q gb eo Ki| mvwnZi h-Kvbv mvg hB nvK bv Kbv,eni cwimi Gme fvlvi Mwe AvKvi-AvKwZ mse`x cvVKi bRi coB|Abw`K PvKgv gvigv wcyiv ZbPsMv gv Lywg eg wLqvs PvK cvsLv jymvB ev AbAvw`evmx fvlvmg~ni wjwLZ mvwnZi AwZ cvq `~iexwYK| Avevi Gmefvlvfvlx`i ga wbR`i fvlvq iwPZ mvwnZ cvVKi msLv GKeviB AZ|Z`ycwi iqQ Ajf`i DPviY wevUi Rvj Rwoq ee welqwUi weZwKZI KzqvkvQb nq IVvi mg~n AvksKv| G KwVb eveZvK mvgb iL nvZiKvQ _vKv Kvbv c~Y weKwkZ gvbfvlv wkvi AvjvK`x Avw`evmx mvwnZeZx`iKvQ MnYxq nq IVvUv Lye Riwi ej gb nq| nvRvi eQii kZ gbxlvi `xNwPb I Abykxjb-Abyavebvq Mo IVv memg^qx evsjv fvlv nZ cvi mB gvag,hv KvwU-KvwU gvbyli evaMgZvi mwVK PovwU k KiZ mg AbvqvmB|

G cmsM bvejRqx K_vmvwnwZK wPbyqv AvPei Rxebi GKwU NUbvi K_v gbcoQ| BsiwR fvlvq mvwnZPPvi KviY wZwb ckwe nwQjb evievi h, ZuviK_vmvwnZi wekvj fzeb AwZ mgyj m`h bvBRixq Mvxq Rxeb`kb,mgvRexY, cyivKvji BwZK_v, AZxZ nq hvIqv wbRi wKkviKvji cwZgyZv KZv mvejxjfve wPwZ nQ, A_P IB GKB welq wZwb wbRi MvfvlvqKb cKvk KiQb bv| iY Kiv `iKvi, wPbyqv AvPe wQjb bvBRixq mgvRiBMey Mvi mvb Avi m Mvi ciiv _K ciivq cPwjZ fvlvi bvg-Bey| Zv DwZ IB cki Reve wPbyqv AvvPe BsiwR fvlvi gnvmvMixqaviYgZvi K_v DjL Ki cKvivi Mvfvlvi DwjwLZ mxgveZvi w`KBBwZ KiQb| ZvB wZwb AvwdKxq Rxebavivi ebv m`h Ae`gb kh Djvm

2010

ZvrwYKZvi cwZ NviZi Avmw Avi ewkMZ Abvb mKj w`K wekevmxi`ievi Dcvcb Ki MQb BsiwR fvlvi `Z, AbbmvaviY KzkjZvq| GBDcvcbvq Zuvi AvwdKxq AvBWbwUwU gvUB a~mivf bq eis Zv DjZi|Gfve wPiewZ, wZwgivQb AvwdKvi A`i I Aignji AkZ evYxi e`bvZuvi myev` (AviI AbKi Ae`vbi K_v gb iLI) wek weeKi y`qvii KovboQ RvivjfveB| Zuvi Mvxq `vqeZv, mB m~ ewMZ ewkK cwiwPwZGKB cvUvZb Mw_Z nq MQ wPiKvji Rb|

GB `v evsjv fvlvi IRw^Zv I AmvaviY bgbxq cKvkmgZvK KvR jvMvZGwMq Gj Avw`evmx Rxebi cKZ cvcU AviI eo cUfg wewZi cwimiLuyR cve ej Avgvi aviYv| Kbbv wekevcx ^xKZ gvbweK mKj AbyfwZicKvkmg fvlvjvi AbZg evsjv| Gi kixi Z_vKw_Z agxq, Mvxq evRvZcvZ wKsev eYev`x Kvbv ZK&gv jvMvbv bB| G fvwlKm` ew cwZfvK,mB m~ Avw`evmx`i Mvxq ev h_ K^ii `vZbvK wekKvb cuQ w`ZD`Mxe nq AvQ| G m`i menvi GwMq Avmv `iKvi Avgv`i mgqiAvw`evmx mvwnZeZx`i| Avgvi gb Kb hb ZvB ej evievi|

21

z` bZvwK RbMvx; Avgiv z` bB gvUBwdWj wW mvsgv

me cvwLi gZv KvwKjI cvwL| A_P me cvwLi Y I`i ga bB; hgb- IivwbRiv evmv Zwi KiZ cvi bv| Abi evmvq wWg cvo| ejvB evj- wWgZv `Iqv, evPv dzwUq ggZv w`q mvb jvjbcvjb Kiv I`i fvM RvU bv|Abvb cvwLi gZv Zv`iI Rb, gZy, fvlv, AveM, AyZ gvZvj Kiv myi AvQ|wK I`i GB myi gvbyli KvQ MnYhvM `viYfve, ivgvwUKZvq fiv| cKwZigvS emK RvwMq Zvj, cgK evO&gq Ki Zvj, gvbyli `qKAv`vwjZ Ki GB KvwKji myi| Avw`evmxivI gvbyl| GKB mwKZvi m Rxe;mevi gZvB igvsm Mov| wbR^ cwievi-cwiRb, mgvR-mswZ, Rb-gZy,fvlv-ag-Kg Zv`iI AvQ; AvQ AveM-Abyf~wZ cKvk Kivi Rb Avb`, nvwm-Kvbv, gvb-Awfgvb me| Ze Giv gvbyl cRvwZi njI Avjv`v Kvb RvwZ bq;DcRvwZ (RvwZi Avevi Dc nq wK Ki; GB bvg `bIqvjvivB fvjv evLv w`Zcvieb)| B`vbxs DcRvwZ bvgUvK AvaywbKxKiY Ki bvg w`qQb- z ` bZvwKRbMvx| G RbMvxi jvKiv Avevi wbR`i Avw`evmx ejj Lywk nb| evn!bvgi wK evnvi! Avw`evmx RbMvxi `wnK ewk njv- GB me gvbyl gvjx-qvb, wbMvqU, KKwkqU Ges AvjqW RvwZi Afy (evvjxi gZv 4wURvwZi mswgkY Zix msKi/ cuvPwgkvjx| nvBweW RvwZ bq|) G`i bvK LvUv,evuPv Ges PvL QvU| ZvB ej LvUv, euvPv bvK w`q wbkvm Kg wbZ cvib GesQvU PvL w`q Kg `Lb ej Kvb wPwKrmK ev wevbx cgvY w`Z cvib wb|eis RbkwZ AvQ- evvjx`i Zyjbvq G`i kixi bvwK ivM cwZiva gZvewk| evsjv`k Mviv, PvKgv, gvgv, ivLvBb, mvbZvj, ZsMv, wcyiv, DovuI,PvK&, KvP, egb, L, Lvwoqv, Lywg, Lvwm, wLqvs, Anwgqv/Avmvg, M, Lv, Wvjy,cvsLy, cvnvwoqv, cvnvb, cv, evbvB, evMw`, wew`qv, gv, gwbcyix, gyv, Zyix,gvnvZv, gymni, gwiqvi, gvnvjx, gvjv ivReskx, KgKvi, Kvj, wq, ivB,ivRyqvi, jymvuB, wms I nvRs BZvw` gvU 45wU RvwZmv evm Ki|

Avgv`i `k GLb ewUk bq, fviZI bq, bq cvwKvb| AvR evsjv`k ^vaxbnqQ 42 eQi| evsjv`k nIqvi AvMB (cvwKvb Avgj) Avgvi Rb| Zvnj

2211

AvgvK wK ejeb, Avwg cvwKvbx? wKsev evsjv`ki mKj bvMwiK cvwKvbx?wbqB bv| hvB nvK, evvjx`i AvM ev ci G `k (evsjv`k) K, KLbAvmjv Mjv Gi Dci wfw Ki Avw`evmxi msv `Iqv nq bv, DwPZI bv| GRvwZmvi gvbyl bvMwiK wnme AekB evsjv`wk, wK RvwZ wnmeKvbvfveB evvjx bq| G `ki bvMwiK wnme cwiwPwZi Rb eoRvi G`ievsjv`wk Mviv, evsjv`wk PvKgv, evsjv`wk gvgv, evsjv`wk ivLvBb, ejv hZcvi; Ze AvRvwZKfve cwiwPwZi Rb evsjv`wk K_vwU hvM Kiv wbqvRb|evvjx hgb ayB evvjx, Zgwb PvKgv, gvigv, ivLvBbI ayB PvKgv, Mviv,gvigv, ivLvBb| Gi mv_ RvwZ, DcRvwZ, z` bZvwK RbMvx wKsev mc`vqRvZxq weklY jvMvbvi Kvb cqvRb `wLbv- Ggb wK Avw`evmx kwUI bq|evsjv`k emevmKZ G msLvjNy RvwZiv wbR`i Avw`evmx wnme ^xKwZi`vwe Ki AvmjI AvRI m cvq wb Ges Lye mnR ^xKwZ cvIqvi Kvb mvebvI`Lv hvq bv| A_P Avw`evmx msv hyw/msv AvRvwZKfve ^xKZ| MeAvgvi eyK dzj hvq, Avgv`i HwZnvwmK Amxg mvnwmKZvi K_v, Avgv`i Aw ZRwoq _vKv, PZbvq wgk _vKv cwZev`i fvlvi K_v| BwZnvmi Aavq AavqAvgv`i G RvwZi msMvgx c~ecyilivB G fviZel we`kx kvmK`i wei 1gwe`vn i KiwQj| euP _vKvi ciYv cvB hLb fvwe, mbvmx we`vn (1760-1800), Mviv we `vn (1775-1802, 1825-27, 1832-33, 1837-82), PvKgvwe`vn (1780-1800), Lvwmqv we`vn (1783), gqgbwmsni KlK we`vn(1812-1830), muvIZvj we`vn (1855-1857), gyv we`vn (1857), ZfvMvwe `vn (1946-1947), UsK we `vn, bvPvj we `vni K_v| A_P G `ki eniRbMvx evvjx evsjv`k miKvi G exi mvnmx RvwZi bvg w`jb z` bZvwKRbMvx| `ki bvMwiK wnmve msLvq Avgiv Kg nZ cvwi, wK Avgiv z`bB; Avgv`i gb, gvbwmKZv, Av`k, g~jeva, ^c, mva Kvbw`bI z` wQj bv,z` GLbI bq|

Avgv`i gb, gvbwmKZv, Av`k, g~jeva, ^c, mva z` bv nIqv mI gvSgvS nZvkI nq ciwQ; hLb fvwe, Avgv`i G `kB ccvwL`i Rb weklw`em D`&hvwcZ nq; wevcb, vMvb, cvvi, wjd&jU, evbvi, mvBbevW,wejevW nq, wK Avw`evmxiv gvbyl njI Zv`i Rb Kvb w`em D &`hvcb KivZv~`ii K_v; AvgivI h G Rbf~wgi gvbyl, G `ki bvMwiK; GUvB ^xKvi Kiv nqbv| Zv nj ck Gm hvq, `ki 17 KvwU RbMY Ges 13 KvwU fvUvi wKAvgv`i ev` w`q? G `ki Av_-mvgvwRK Dbqb, jvKR-mswZi ewPAvbqb wK Avgv`i KvbB Ae`vb bB? evsjv`ki ^vaxbZv hy Avgv`i

23

AskMnYi wK Kvb g~j bB? `k-mgvR-mswZi ewP kxew KijI,^vaxbZv hy AskMnY Ki KD KD Rxeb w`jI, eZgvb miKvix `j cwZgx,wewfb miKvix emiKvix ms vq wewfb chvqi Avmb `vwqZcvjb Z_v `k MVbGes Dbqb cwiKbvq Ae`vbi Askx`vi njI `ki 45wU RvwZMvxi GAe`vbi Kvb ^xKwZ wgjwb; h KviY Avw`evmx`i eyK RgvU euvav `ytL-K,`vwe, Av`vjb| evN, fvjyK, wmsniv c RvwZi; Zgwb `vqj, gqbv, gqyi`iIcvwL RvZxq ejZ ev ^xKwZ w`Z Kvivi wav-Amyweav bB, wK evsjv`kiMviv, PvKgv, eg, wcyiv Ggb 45wU RvwZMvxi RvwZ ^xKwZ w`ZB hZ wav,ZZwaK Avcw| ZvZ wK? eoK_v nQ, AvgivI igvsm, AveM-Abyf~wZZmevi gZB AvgivI gvbyl| Avgiv mvb Rb w`j Kvb wk Mi-QvMj nq Rbbqwb Zv|

Ke hb AbjvBb cwKv evsjv`kwbDR24.Kg-G GKw`b cowQjvg, Avw`evmx-welqK msm`xq KKvmi D`vM Avw`evmxi gvbevwaKvi I AvBGjI Kbfbkb169:AvZcwiPqi AwaKvi I mvsweavwbK ^xKwZ welqK GK AvjvPbv mfvqcveZ PMvg AvwjK cwil`i Pqvigvb RvwZwi` evwawcq jvigv (mjvigv) nZvkv e Ki ejQb, G miKvi Avw`evmx`i mvsweavwbK ^xKwZ`e Zv wekvm KiZ cviwQ bv| MZ 39 eQi ai `LwQ, kvmKMvx MYZvwKwPvavivi AwaKvix nZ cvibwb, mv`vwqK iq MQb| kvmKMvx GLbvcMwZkxj wPvi AwaKvix nZ cvibwb| m jvigv ejb, 13 eQi AvM eZgvbcavbgx kL nvwmbvi bZZvaxb miKvii D`vMB kvwPzw nqwQj| wKPywi ci 13 eQi cwiq MjI Zv evevqb KD GwMq Avmb wb| eZgvbAvIqvgx jxM miKvi Gevi gZvq GmI PywwU evevqb GKwU c`cI bbwb| miKvi Pyw evevqb mPZb ejI gb nq bv ej wZwb AwfhvM Kib|

^vaxbZvi 40 eQi ciI evvjx ^vaxbZvi Kx ^v` Zv cwivi eySZ cviwb|y`bxwZi kxl Ae vbKvix GB `k evsjv`k FYgy nZ cvij bv; Kvbw`b cvieejI gb nq bv| wePvi eevq Awbqgi KviY RvZxq, mvgvwRK, cvwievwiKI ew Kjn Aev _KI Kvbw`b gy nZ cviQb bv RbmvaviY| AvBbksLjv evwnbx mKj gvbyli Rvb-gvji c~Y wbivcv w`ZI Pig e_; Ggb AvivKZ Kx mgmv! hLvb ay GKUv RvwZ (evvjx)-i gwjK gvbweK Pvwn`v c~iYiwbqZv I gvbyli Rvb-gvji c~Y wbivcv w`Z hLvb e_ mLvb Aviv 45wURvwZ hvM nj m e_Zvi `vqfvi eo hve, GUvB ^vfvweK| `ki cwZwUgvbyl my-kvwZ _vK Zv cgvb w`Z bv cvij bvej, kvw cyivii gZAvRvwZK gvbmb cyivi, wWwM ARb hLvb me ne bv, AvRvwZK gnj

2412

mybvg zyY ne| mLvb Aviv 45wU RvwZ hvM nj m e_Zvi `vqfvi bIqviKvb hyw _vK wK? nqZev GKviYB G `ki miKvi Kvb w`b GB 45wU RvwZi^xKwZ `e bv, Zv wbevPbi AvM `jxq BkZnvi wcwQq _vKv GB AenwjZRvwZi Rb AwZ jvfbxq my`i my`i Dbqb cwiKbv I evevqbi cwZkwZwKsev RvwZ ^xKwZ `Iqvi gZ hZ hvB ejv nvK|

evsjv`ki GB 45wU RvwZMvxi fvB-evb`i ewj, Avgiv Kb ay mvsweavwbKRvwZ ^xKwZi Avkvq gv_v VyKwQ? wK ne RvwZ ^xKwZ w`q? `ki msweavbwU`ki cwZwU RbMYi `bw`b Rxeb hvcbi Rb KZUyKy KvR jvM? `kiAwaKvsk RbMY GLbv GKw`b niZvj ciiw`b Abvnvi w`b KvUvq| wbRi`iLv`, e, wPwKrmvi eev wbR`iB KiZ nq| Avi GUvI fveybZv Avgv`i^RvwZ Mviv, PvKgv, gvigv, wcyivivI wK GB `k wKsev cvkeZx `k, c`keZgvb miKvwi I weivax `j, wewfb miKvwi emiKvwi msvq wewfb chvqiDjLhvM DP Avmb `vwqZ cvjb KiQ bv? Zvnj Avgiv wcwQq _vKev Kb?wKmi, Kvi Avkv fimvq?

Z_m~1. MYZ I mykvmb Ges Avw`evmx`i AwaKvi- mxe `s2. gnvKveI AMwZ KweZv : gywhy Avw`evmx RvwZMvx Pvi nK3. evsjv`ki Mviv Avw`evmx myfvl RsPvg4. evsjv`ki wecb Avw`evmx mxe `s|5. RvwZmsN I AvBGjI KZK NvwlZ NvlYvc|6. bKvbvi Av`vjb : Mviv we`vn7. DBwKwcwWqv, gyKvl

25

PZbvi GbwRIKiYcvBwPsgs gvigv

cveZ PMvg AvkwZ nIqvi gZ h evcvijv NUQ Zv nj z` RbRvwZmg~ni (Avwg GLvb Ry bvg DjL KiZ PvB) ^vwaKvi Av`vjb GLb fvZNvZxnvbvnvwbZ wech | wkwZ gawe mgvR I ZiY-Qv hyeKiv ivRbxwZwegyL| hZiY mgvRi Abvqi wei jovB Kivi K_v Zviv bvK-gyL Wzweq AvQfvMev`x b`gvq, AvZKw`K Rxebevai e mgvR-RxebwegyL myL-wejvmiAvKvvq| AbK wkwZ mvZK Ry ZiY GbwRI-Z XzKQ| GLvb hyw nZcvi GbwRI-Z PvKwi Kiv Lvivc wKbv? ev cvnvo Kgmsvbi myhvM hLvbbB ejjB Pj mLvb GbwRI-jv evcKmsLK Kgmsvbi myhvM Kiw`qQ, Zwi Ki w`qQ| GLvb Avwg ejZ PvB Avwg Kgms vbi wecbB| wK GbwRI-Z PvKwii dj mgvR GKUv mgvR gbb Mo IV hv Avgv`iRy mgvR hLvb Avgiv Aw Zi jovBq jowQ, Zvi wZ nq| GKUv NUbv w`qewj- Avgv`i QvU KvMRi Rb XvKv wekwe`vjqi GKRb QvK Avgiv GKUvweklYagx jLv w`Z ewj (m GKRb Ry Prominent Qv) m Avgv`iRvwbqwQjv Avgv`i cKvkbvi Rb wekl Ki Avw`evmx BmyZ cKvkbvi bvgAvgiv hw` GbwRI`i KvQ _K wKQz dvI hvMvo KiZ cvwi hv w`q GKRbjLKi cvwikwgK w`Z cvwi|

mgmvUv GLvbB| GKRb Xv.we.-Gi Ry Qv mvgvwRK `vqeva _K wjLZ Pvqbv, m GbwRIi Incentive wbq wjLZ AvMnx| GKBfve Avw`evmx`i mvsweavwbK^xKwZ, Ry mswZ iv Z_v weKvk, GgbwK cveZ Pzwi evevqb ch Avgv`iRxebi iZi Kvb Bmy hb AvRKvj GbwRI-`i mvnvh Qvov nq Pvq bv|Avgv`i AvZcwiPqi Z-Zvjvk, AvZ^xKwZ GgbwK Avgv`i Aw Zivi `vqfviAvgiv GbwRI-`i Dci bv KiwQ| Gi djvdj wK ne? euvPvimsMvg,AvZwbqvwaKvii msMvg, AwZivi msMvg gvbyli mnRvZ| wavwefRy RbMYi GB msMvg AvR wef-wev| GKw`K Aw Z ivi Rw jovB hgbMo DVQ bv, Abw`K Ry`i wkwZ Aski gMR wKb wbqQ GbwRIjv|

2613

dj GBme BmyZ hv nQ Zv nvj, MvjUwej eVK, mwgbvi-wmcvwRqvg|MYwewQbfve gawe mykxj-eywRxex`i Z-Z_ PvjvPvwji gvag we`wk dvikv nZ cvi, bcysmK Kgm~wP nZ cvi wK AwaKvi cwZv nZ cvi bv|AvZwbqbvwaKvii PZbvi mv_ AvZghv`v evai ck AvwKfve RwoZ|fviZeli cLvZ gvKmev`x wPvbvqK KgiW wke`vm Nvl GB cm ejb- gvbylzavZ ejB jovB Kie GgbUv bq, AvZghv`veva mcb gvbyl zav gUvbviRb Rxeb-msMvg Kie hvi AvZghv`veva bB m wfv ev Pzwi Kie|

AwaKvinviv AwaKvievamcb gvbyl ZLbB jovB Kie hw` Zvi AvZghv`vevaAUzU _vK| Zv bv _vKj m wejvc Kie| Aciw`K AwaKvijv hw` myhvMwnme eySvbv/ wekvm Kivbv hvq ZLb Zv Aviv fqsKi| gvbyl Zvi KcvjZiAmnvqZ gb GKejv DwQ bvK-gyL Wzweq _vK| myweav cvIqv gvbyl ZLbAviv myhvMmvbx ^fve Afve gUvq| mgvRi AwaKvsk gvbyl ZLb jycbPwii nq| Zv`i w`q DV `uvovbvi msMvg, ghv`v cwZvi msMvg Ame|

cveZ Pzw cieZx mgq cveZ PMvg we`wk dvi mnRjf cevn AbKGbwRI Mo DVwQjv, wewfb cR `wLq mB dvi UvKv h_Qfve bq-QqKiv nqQ| D`viv AbKB wekvjx nqQb| UNDPi gvUv eZb I wewfbmyhvM myweav cvIqv AbK Ggb GK KzjxbkwYi gvbyl nqQb, hviv Avi mvaviYRy`i ga cob bv Avi Zviv wbRivI Zv fveZ Pvb bv|

cveZ PMvgi mgmvjv ckvZxZfve ivRbwZK mgmv, Av_-mvgvwRKmgmv| cyuwRev`x ivi nvZ hLvb Avcv`gK mwq| G cm fviZi cLvZjwLKv AiwZ ivq ejb h - NGOs give the impression that they arefilling a vacuum created by a retreating state, And they are, but in amaterially inconsequential way. Their real contribution is that theydefuse political anger and dole out as aid or benevolence what peopleought to have by right.NGOs alter the public psyche .They turn peopleinto dependent victims and bluntpolitical resistance. NGOs form abuffer between sorkar and public

AiwZ ivqi klv K_vwj Lye iZc~Y| GbwRIiv RbMYi gbbKvVvgviGKUv cwieZb NUvq| zavZ gvbyl vf dU coZ cvi wK hw` ZvK DwQLvBq euvwPq ivLv hvq ZvZ Zvi evaK Abw`K Nvivbvi Rb AvQ eyRvqvwgwWqv Ges GbwRI`i wbR^ cPviYv I Dbqb aviYv| GbwRIiv ivRbwZKBmyjvK AivRbwZK c`vq XvK| Zviv Zv`i KvRjvK AivRbwZK^Qvmev wnme c` kb Ki| wK Kvb mvgvwRK mgmv wK ivRbxwZ gy? hZzK,

27

wj elg, BfwUwRs, dZvqvevwR, gjev`, Awkv, `vwi`, eKviZ BZvw` hw`ivRbwZK mgmv bv nq Zvnj ivRbwZK mgmv KvbUv? Lye mnR hywZ AvgivRvwb mgvR-iv Pvjvq miKvi| miKvi cwiPvwjZ nq ivRbwZK `ji ivRbwZK`kb| miKvii bvixbxwZ, wkvbxwZ, wkbxwZ BZvw` bxwZK miKvii kwY`kbI ivRbwZK `kbi cwZdjb NU| ivRbwZK mgmvi mgvavb ivRbwZKfveBme| myZivs GB ck GbwRI`i wewfb gvm-KvcBb, GWfvKwm,GgcvIqvigU, WfjcgU BZvw` cR w`q GBme mvgvwRK mgmv gUvbvKvbfveB me bq| G cm AiwZ ivqi jLv _K Zzj aiwQ :

It turns confrontation to negotiation. It depoliticizes resistance. Itinterferes with local peoples movement that have traditionally beenself reliant. NGOs have funds that can employ local people whomight other wise be activist in resistance movements, but now canfeel they are doing some immediate, creating good (and earning aliving while theyre at it ) charity offers instant gratification to thegiver, as well as the receiver, but its side effects can be dangerous.Real political resistance offers no such short cuts. The NGO-isationsof politics theaters to turn resistance into well-mannered, reasonable,salaried 9 to 5pm JOB with a few perks throw in. Real resistance hasreal consequences and no salary.

AiwZ ivqi G K_vjvi mv_ Avgiv Gevi cveZ PMvgi eZgvb cwiwwZiw`K `w w`B| Avw`evmx wnme mvsweavwbK ^xKwZi `vweZ hZ Kgm~wP cvwjZ nqZvi ewkifvMB GbwRI g``cy| GB BmyZ GKwU Rw Av`vjb Mo DVZcviZv, Zv nqwb KviY, wKQz bvMwiK gawe Ges eywRxex mykxjivB GB ivvqbvg| eQi GKevi Avw`evmx w`em gnvbMii ZiY-ZiYxiv ^Kxq cvlvK ci(Zviv mvaviYZ GUv cib bv) ivvq ivjx Kib| A-bvMwiK evZ mvaviY Ryivhviv cvnvoi Mnxb AvRv Ryg Pvl Ki euP AvQb Zuviv G welq wKQz Rvbb bv|Zuviv Rvbb bv Avw`evmx wK Avi z` b-Mvx ev z`-RvwZmv wK| `yejv LveviLq wbRi wfU gvwUZ _vKZ cvijB Zviv Lywk| Ry`i kKo g~j msKUUvAwZi msKU| wbcxoK iv mUjvi`i mvgb Vj, mvgwiK g`` wbwlZKiQ Ry`i| wdwjwwb`i Dci Bmivqjx`i AvMvmbi gZvB GB ivAvMvmb| dj Ry`i GB jovB Ry`i AwaKvi ck ivbxwZ Z_v iv eeviwei| Ryiv HwZnMZfve msMvgx| BwZnvm GB cgvY `q h, Ryiv hyM hyMjovB KiQ gvNj`i wei, ewUki wei, cvwKvwb`i wei| evsjv`kiivkw mUjvi-Avwg w`qI AvR ch `gvZ cviwb Ry`i| wK Ry`i eni

2814

HKi wfZi NyYcvKv nq Kzo Kzo LvQ `jMZ wefw| AwaKvi Av`vqimeevcx Av`vjb Mo bv IVvi Rb Ggwciv cZ bq, civfve `vqx|ivRbxwZi GbwRIKiYi djvdj ZvrwYK bq, AvLi Gi dj my`~icmvix GesgvivZK|

cvwKvbx _K evOvwj nIqvi Rb evOvwji GbwRI jvMwb| A_P Ry`iAvw`evmx nIqvi Rb GbwRI jvM, mvsweavwbK ^xKwZi Rb GbwRI jvM|UNDP-mn AbK GbwRI cveZ PMvg ``vim UvKv XvjQ| wekwe`vjqiAbK mvZK ZiY-ZiYx mLvb PvKwi KiQ| cveZ PMvgi mgmv h g~jZivRbwZK mgmv Zv Avovj Ki mvb nvK ev Avb GbwRI`i DbqbcvcvMvv ev evqb KiQ| cveZ PMvgi nvRvi nvRvi GKi Rwg hLb miKvwi-emiKvwi nc e`Lj nq hvq ZLb GB BmyZ MYAv`vjb Mo IV bv|A_P GB Av`vjb wkwZ ZiY-ZiYx`i bZZ `Iqvi K_v| ZiY`i GBgav GKB BmyZ GbwRI`i cR evevqb eeZ nQ| hviv GKmgq PCP(cvnvox Qv cwil`) KiZb Zviv AbKB GLb GbwRI Kib ev wbRivBGbwRI LyjQb| A_P Zv`iB AvR Ry`i bZZ `qvi K_v wQjv| dj hLbfwg e`Lj nq ZLb mLvb GKRb ivRbwZK Kgx cwZiva Av`vjb Mo ZzjZcvi wK GKRb GbwRIKgx GB BmyZ wKfve Rehabilitation, Legal Aid,People empowerment, Victim support-Gi bvg we`wk dv hvMvo KiviK_v fveb| hw` m cvb ivRbwZK Kgx nq Zvnj evcviUv Aviv fqsKi nq|KviY ZLb m ivRbwZK BmyK mvb ivRbwZK fvlv eenvi Ki gvbyli`y`kvK wbq av`vevwR i Ki| G AviK aibi cwiwwZ KvR Ki|QvRxeb hviv ivRbxwZ KiZb Zviv gawe Uvbvcob _K GKUv PvKwi eQbb| G GbwRI-i PvKwiUv wKQzUv Avcvmi wnme wgj hvq| GKw`KmgvRi Rb wKQz Kivi `vqeva Abw`K cUi `vq GB y`qi gvSLvb GbwRIiPvKwi GKUv BUFFER wnme KvR Ki| Kbbv GbwRIiv mgvRi fvjv KiviK_v ej| myZivs GbwRI Lyj ev cwZwZ GbwRIZ XzK Indigenous Rights,Human Rights, Community Development , Community Empowerment,cwiek iv, kvw iv BZvw` ej Project-Gi gvag mgvRi wKQz fvjv Kivmv_ RxweKv wbevn Kivi GKUv Qv-cvlv RvovZvwj fvebv _K AbK GLvbXvK| GKB aibi K_v AbK wkwZ ZiY-ZiYxi LvU hviv QvivRbxwZKibwb, wK Ry RvwZi Rb wKQz KiZ Pvb| wecyj msLK wkwZ ZiY hyeK`iGB mgvRi Rb wKQz Kivi gvag GbwRI`i GRv ev evqb Kivi dj AvLifvjv ne bv| iv hLvb gvbylK AwaKvi ewZ Ki, wbcxob Ki, we`wk`i`qv-`vwYi UvKvq Zvi wZc~iY nZ cvi bv| wbcxobi cwZKvi Avi AwaKvi

29

Av`vq ay jovB KiB cvIqv me| wK gykwKjUv nQ AwaKvi Av`vqi `vweZRy RbZvK GKwZ Kivi KvRUv mwVK Av`wkK kwZ ejxqvb ivRbwZK `jiKivi K_v| mUv cveZ PMvg GLb Avi bB| Ry`i cwZwbwaZkxj `jjvwbRi`i ga cvvcvw nvgjvq wech| Ry`i RvZxq Rxeb ZvB weivRKiQ wevw, AvZKw`KZv, wbwqZv, ivRbxwZwegyLZv| GKwU cwZkwZkxjivRbwZK `ji cwZiva-msMvg I cMwZkxj Av`vjb _vKj GB wecyjmsLKwkwZ RyivI GB Av`vjb hy nZv| GB ivRbwZK Av`vjbi cwic~iKmvswZK Av`vjbI Mo Zvjv me, hvi gvag mgvRi cwZ `vwqZkxj MYgyLxmvswZK, gbbkxjZvi PPv Kiv hvq| G aibi ivRbwZK-mvswZK Av`vjb bv_vKvZ mLvb GbwRIiv evmv euaQ| dj Avgiv PZbvi GbwRIKiYi wkKvinwQ|

mUjvi-Avwg`i viv msNwUZ nZv, wbhvZb, `Lj, jyUcvU, alYi wei hvivGKmgq kvMvb kvMvb ivRc_ KuvwcqQb Zviv GLb mykxj, GbwRI`iMvjUwej Pj MQb| KD eyRvqv ivRbxwZi m Rwoq wbcxoK eevi Asknq MQb| GUv LyeB y`tLRbK| GbwRI Kgm~wPi bwZevPK cfveUv nQ Zv jovKzRj PZbvq Rj Xj `q Ges ivRc_i jovB I AiYi cwZiva msMvgKAvcvm-gxgvsmvi MvjUwej wbq hvq| AwaKvi Av`vqi msMvgK kvwc~Y `b-`ievii gZv welq wnme cwZwZ KiZ Pvq| AwaKvi `b-`ievi Ki, `iKlvKwl Ki cvIqv hvq bv| hviv GbwRIZ `kUv-cuvPUv Awdm Ki Ry`iAwaKvii K_v ejQb Zv`iK ewj, AwaKvii PvKwi Ki AwaKvi cvIqv hvq bv|AwaKvi ARb Ki wbZ nq| AwaKvi jo, Ko wbZ nq| ivRbwZK BmyjvKGbwRIKiYi A_ ivRbxwZi GbwRIKiY| hvi dj ivRbxwZi weivRbxwZKiYNUQ| wkwZ Ry`i ga ivRbwZK fvebv I mwqZv AcmZ nQ| AvMvgx `keQi ci Ry`i fvM Zvnj wK NUe? ZZw`b cvnvoi nvRvi nvRvi GKi RwgmUjvi, mvgwiK-emvgwiK Avgjv, miKvwi-emiKvwi ZrciZvq e`Lj nq hve|ZZw`b Aviv kZvwaK Ry Rbc` nvgjv, MYnZv, AwMmshvM, alY, Lybi NUbvNUe| ZLbv wK cveZ PMvgi GbwRIiv Victimized, Merginalized ethnicentity life support/reservation Project-Gi bvg Doner-Gi KvQ mvnvh PqLqivwZ Kie? ZZw`b Avgiv Aek LqivwZZ Af nq hvev| mw`b wKJSS/UPDF/ JSS (MN LARMA) _vKe bvwK vZNvZx nvbvnvwbZ wejy nq hve?mw`b wK Avgiv _vKev bvwK wejy nq hvev? nqZv mw`bI Avgiv wejy nIqvVKvZ Kvb Project Paper wjL Doner Gi KvQ FUND PvBev!?

* jLvwU Avgv`i eM mvBU cKvwkZ, www.chtbd.org

3015

cvwK ^i `vZbvq DcwbewkK we`vniy` kvqK

Rxeb kl nq wPnxb we`yZ, c_ klnxb, c_iwP _vK, Zix nq bZzb Ni, bZzb Rvbvjv

-gCb Payixce msMn c-211

fvlvi ga Avgiv ay RbB wb bvB| Avgiv kvwmZ I AZvPvwiZ nqwQ| msMvgKiwQ fvlvKw`K `gb wbcxob _K gvbweK fevaK evwni KiZ| GKBfvlvi fZi Aevb KiI ^vwaKvii cqvm _vK Aviv AbK ^ii gZvKvVvgvi wei hv mvgvwRK mvswZK jovB|

h_vhvM ggvcjw KijB m`hK DcfvM Kiv me nq| AbyfwZi cvKewK I Avw`g i (Pre-Rationaland Primative level of feeling)cqvMev`x DBwjqvg Rgm ejQb- I am against bigness and greatness inall their forms. Kvb mvgvwRK msMVb hZB eng nZ _vK ZZB Zv nq coAviI k~bMf Ges cvqkB hb Zv nq IV ewK wbgg wblbi h|mgZwji KweZvi GKNqwgi gvS cvnvox z` b-Mvxi KweZv cPj c_vqAcPj ewK ksLj wbq wbR^ ^i`Zbvq Zwi KiQ Kve cvivWvBg, hvmgKvjxb eiwLK exYi Askx`vwiZK wbwZ Ki AvjvwKZ KiQ KweZvgci APbv cwqv|

Kej mvnmx ^vaxb, BQvkwZ mg, AvZkwZ gvb exivwPZ gbvfvevcbivBG GKvKx mdj nZ cvi| wK ew ^v_ c~iY KiZ wMqI Kvb ewZvi mvsMVwbK, Mvx wKsev cwZvbi Rb weklZ GKv ^v_K cvqB DcvKi| GgbB weij Kvb z` b-Mvxi nqZv Zvi RvZxqZvev`x wKsev mswZicwZwbwaZ Kivi `vwqZ wbq wbRi Kvevb fvviK Lyj w`e, h cqvm cPvcvnvwo z ` b-Mvxi ga jYxq| Zv`i bvbv aibi cKvkbvi gaI mvwnZiAevb `p| hv Dcwbek Di mgqi Pjgvb MwZK KiQ mgAS Interest grows more disciplined and Concentrated thought becomesmore vigorous and more definitely Proposive

31

Stadies in Huamnism Pa- 12F.C.S Sechiller.

gvbylB njv Kej Zvi ev e mvi wbgvZv| ev e mv q njB Kej Gi ^icwbaviY Kiv hvq| wK Kwe wbgvY Ki ^c h mB ^ci dwiIqvjv| hvi `wb`bPvL GwMq _vK mgqi KznK _K| KviY gvbemv ev Rxeb wbRB GK gnv^ci bvg, evsjv`k bvgK e-xci f-mswZ GKiwLK bq| bvbv ag-eY IRvwZi mswgkY webvwmZ eiwLK mswZ| cvnvwo y` b-Mvxjvi gaBeqQ AmsnwZ (inconsistency) ZvB msklwYK weKwZ (Synthetic Statement)me bq| KviY cf`K Dcjw Kiv hvq| GKxfZ Kiv hvq bv| ZvBAvZwelqxMZv (Intersubjectivity) PPvi gvag vbZvwK hvMvhvM me| ZeAbK B Zvi mvgvwRK gvv _vKe nqZv, eenvi hvMZv AbKLvwbnvive| cvnvwo b-Mvxjvi fvlv mswZ, Rxebeva ^KxqZv Lye axi MwZZcv hvQ, wgk hvQ K`xq PvZvj| Lv` cvnvoB Zv`i hvwcZ Rxeb kLjI wbR^ ewkK Avjv`v Ki wPwZ Kivi welqwU b-ZvwK MelYvi cvVg nqDVQ| K`xq fvlvi mvsMVwbK nRgwbZ nvivQ Zv`i fvlv-eY| fvlv jvjbmsMn I PPvB nq DVQ weij| K `xq fvlvi A_bwZK g~j I wkv gvagi g~jDcRxe nIqvB Gi AbZg KviY| elwqK Rxeb Zv`i eva KiQ wKsev Zvivmgqi wbcyY wkKvi nq cv hvQ wKsev e`j w`Q f-mswZi wWmKvmjv|

AvaywbK mgvR ee vi K `xq ceYZvB envZ KiQ Di AvaywbK mgvR ee viAbb ewk| e ivwqZ mvgvwRK I mvswZK webvm KvVvgv|

mgq AvR wbRB wbRi nviK| vbKvi kvLvq PvL LyjjB `wL mgq wbRBwbRK ck KiQ? z` gxgvsmv bqZv mnR weK c vb| wbR^ RMZi AhvwPZAf`K f` Ki PvBQ gyw| mvgvwRK gvbeeva I AvR `uvwoq bB AvMiRvqMvq| MwZ I fvebvi nQ `ZZi| Pjvi c_i mB ^i `vZbv AvRKweZv| LZv wPiw`b wQj, AvQ, _vKe wK MwZi `vq mB fvbK cwiqhvIqv| mgKvjxb mgvR fvebvq GLb wewfb RvwZmvi ewZgagx mswZicwiPq g~jvqY cvQ| GKB mv_ HwZnK f cybtwbgvYi vi Lyj w`qQgbbkxj wekexv| wevb I chyw Zvi cvRi Lyj K`i mv_ cvi mg^qI mshvM vcb KiQ| hvi ^ic mvbB DcRxe| KwlwfwK Av_-mvgvwRKMvgxY KvVvgv jvK-mswZ I AvwjK ^i cwicyw jvf KiQ ewkK mgqPZbvq| GKB mv_ gnvbvMwiK Rxeb msNvZ Zwi nQ gd^jxq kke IbvMwiK hebi Uvbvcob| wZ-wewZ, g~jeva Avi HwZni evSvcoviUvbvcobB mgqi RwUjZvq wUK _vKvi b~bZg g~jevai RvsRvwi ivL gbbPZbvq| hyM ecixZ wbRKB wbqY mgqi k cKkj|

3216

cvwK z` b-Mvxi KweZvKgxiv hw` KweZvq GKwU bZzb mgq I fvlvi mwKiZ cvi, ZvnjB mgKvjxb eiwLK mvgvwRK webvm i wbR`iAswk`vixZK cgvY Ki RvwZ I iv ^Kxq f~-mswZ ivq Ae`vb ivLZcvie| GiB mv_ iLZ cvie AvMvmx cjvfbK|

cwZwU `vZbvB mvgwqK I AvcwK| wPvm~ ev cvwifvwlK cvVKwZi ga w`qAwRZ `vZbv Aviv cwikxwjZ nq _vK| Avevi H cybtcixwZ I cybwRZ`vZbv GKB cwqvi Rb `q| GB wbiewQb cwic~iYi AvqvRb A_iaviYvK Avg~j cv `q, w`Q| Zv Kej ewK RMZ bq| Avgv`i mvgvwRK-mvswZK-ivRbwZK cwimiI NU PjQ Anin| q `vZbv AwfvbKDcwwZ I AvZDcwwZi wbwiL wePvi Ki| Gme AvZDcwwZ me`v AvM_KB cv_Kevai viv weP~wYZ| wg_vi cMjf wbwgwZ AvwacZev`x eMi`vwK PvZzh hZ AevwiZ nvK bv Kb AvR, cvwK I evZRbB nq DVQ h_v_cMwZi Avqya| DcwbewkK gbb kvwgqvbvi wbP Kv_vI hb `xN vqx Aw Z bB|Avgv`i fZiI bB evwniI bB| hv AvQ Zv Kej AbeiZ cwieZb| vbiAnsKvi KiZ Avgiv Af | A_P Kvb mvK KLbv Rvwb bv, GgbwK wbRKIbq| mg AwZ Kej AwZi cvVKwZ fveKi MvjK auvav nq _vKe? bv,wbq Zv bq Framework of differences G aviYvi mvnvh wbiewQbZvrchcy Zwi Ki Kvb evqexq Aevb bIqv me nq bv| wbibAvZwRvmvq cvqvwMK Awfew MnY KivB mePq Riywi| GKB mv_ K `gyLxwciK kbv Ki hywi c_ iPbv KiZ ne| h c_ Ab Kej evcK D`vgiy KivB cZq| KD KD c_wP AuvKZ AuvKZ nvwiq hve, KD ne wePzZAvevi evievi evcK D`vg mshvM NUve cwZavi mvnmx ZiyYiv|

AvcvZZ eqvb mijZv _vKjI K`xq fvlvq G cvevmx ZiY AvMvmx cjvfbwePwjZ, Ag Avvk Lyb nq wbRi eva RvMiYi gbbiLvq| wfZi h~_enevi Zvobv Abyfe Kib| `qvj wcV VK Mj gvbyl wbRi Aw Z Rvbvb `eviZvobvq giY Kvgo `q| GgbB GK `kK AwZ nQ Zvi gRvRi gvR`vq|

GB nQ Avgvi meyR cvnvoi RxebhLvb cvnvo _K cvnvo cwZawbZ nqKvi gZ kZ bvixi AvZwPrKviAvgvi meyR cvnvo\

-Ryqj PvKgvRyg-2009|

meyR cvnvo wnsmvi Sbv aviv en hvq, DcwbewkK gvbwmKZvi exR gbb wbqB|K`xq RbMY mv`v Pvgov KZK kvwmZ I kvwlZ nIqvi GKB mv_ va

33

Abw`K cf~Zi mv`v Pvgovi cwZ jvf GB aibi AhvwPZ eva wMj LvQ hviweKZ cqvM cvnvwo bvix`i alY| hv gvbweK mfZvi weeKK KiQ ckwe|

`qi hveZxq q wZ Avi Zhw` mi hvq AKcY Zvgvq mevq

-msvw\ gswmsTvRyg-2009

Z Zv wKq hvq Lye ewk `wiZ njI| `vM iq hvq `n| ay Kviv KvivAvPiY gb co hvq| GB me Z mi Mj mB me AvPiY fyj ^`k mevqgbvwbek KiZ AwePj cZq`x G Kwe|

wdi Avm c`v Riywi AevqAvi GKevi GB c_ w`q nuU hveiO _K iOPUv nq hvevi AvMB

`w mi bv| cvbwR emvK-mgyj myevZvm- 2011|

wbg cvwLi WvK cvnvwoqv mij Rxebi wg_ hv cvwLi WvK f jYi| njyw`qvwbg cvwLi WvKi fZi w`q Kwe wecb Rbc` kvwi evZv eq w`Z Pvb|

Avgvi `xNkvmi KviY Rvb RqwbZvh KvjKI Avgvi mv_ ^M ZviY DVZ ivwR wQj bv,AvRK m Avgvi nvZ ai civQ fqi gyg~ly AmyL-kibv_xKvj| Avjvob Lxmv, P- 2013

wbcxwoZ RvwZmvi cwZwU `qB IqvwKenvj Zvi `xNkvmi mgxKiY wbq| ZeyIcvkvcvwk fvjvevmvevwm Zv Avi PvBjB nq bv| gvbyl ZeyI hyi gvV, AhvwPZiYf~g mefyj nvZ ai joZ, iv KiZ, euvPZ euvPvZ Pvq wbRi f~wgUzKz|Dcwbek kl nIqv Avi Dcwbekvi PZvbvi weKvk GK bq| wPvi eKj I wekLjv evcK| ewYK ^v_i GKK-K` egyLx ^v_i ga ZwjqMwQ| Zey G MuvovKj _K ewiq Avmvi c_ LyuR wbZ ne cvevmx b-MvxK| e cwiwai gaB RxebK mxgve ivLjB Pje bv| mbvZb Rxeb AvignvbvMwiK Rxebi ga mg^q Ki vbZvwK Rxeb mKvwqZ Kiv hvq GesKiZ ne| Rxebi m cwiPq nq eU wK vbi weqi m cwiPq KwiqwbZ nq| gvbylK wewQb Ki, Rxe RMZK wewQb Ki, mvwnZ KejgvevwbK ev m`hZvwK cwZ AuvKv AbwZK|

gvbyli AvQ bvbvwea dw`-wdwKi, AveiY cwZfv, Zvi Avkq cKiY Abb|Kej evwfUv bq, AvQ AmsL KvUi, AbK Avovj iPbv, fvlv GgbB GK

3417

gv_v MuvRvi VuvB, mB VuvB hb wbwZ nq y` b-Mvxi Rxeb webvm| ZvBGKB mv_ cqvRb fvlvi A_Kvix AwbevhZv I mvwnZi mywecyj iZfvvi| hviPbv KiZ ne cvfvwl b-MvxKB, wbR^ fvlvq, RvZ Awfgvb| evK cPwjZk mK fO w`q GK c_K KvweK cvivWvBg iPbv KiZ ne| hbAveiYi cwiwPZ mgvRZvwK kZ duvm nq hvq|

35

Rgm& Rbk wPivb-Gi KweZv

Dchcywi alYGLvbv wfb`kx nvbv`vi Avmcv_ii ARynvZ cvnvo KvUD`vbi ARynvZ wbzi KivZ Pvjvq

jvwjZ cvPxb eAvw`evmx KweZvi mZxZ _vK bv|

eov `qvnxb kveYx AvKvkAbeiZ ewZ am cojv cvnvoAvgvi b-RvZxq Pnviv cv MjvBKvcvK ev chUb wk hvZbvqbMixi wk mevq Zvi GZv Dchcywi

AbeiZ alYeYbvZxZ AmfZv|

cvnvox kvex bvwqKv giI giZ cvi bvAv`vjZ gvgjv `q bv wbzi bvix wbhvZbiGwMq Avm bv Rbwcq gvbevwaKvi

msvi cavb|

3618

wngj wiwQj-Gi KweZvKwe I Ki b`x(kq Kwe gZ` gvbwLb-Gi `q ev GK Ki b`x KweZvwU co )

G Kgb GKUv Af Amgq Avwefve Kwe Avgv`i?`qe Ki b`x _g _vKmLvb mvZ bB, ^c bB, mxZ bBmvov bB, k bB, cviwiK evSvcov bB|

euvKv PvL, euvKv gyL, euvKv Afw wKeyS ew_Z Kwei kgmva KweZvi fvlv?eyS wK Kwei b w`bi K Anwbk?eyS bv| eyS bv Zviv kkwgK Kwe wKsev KweZvi Kx g~j!

nvRviv Ki Mvb Mq evaK Gm `uvovjIwjL PjQb AMwYZ bZzb KweZv, ewZ gvbyli K_vnvRviv nvRvwiKv nq Avcwb Avgv`i wbq hvebelgwenxb bZzb kZvxi gvbeZvi Mvb|

eYgvjv cwiPq

^c Avwg cvqB ZvgvK mvRvB^ieY wKsev ebeY w`q^i-Av, n^-B, G A_ev JeY eY mvRvbv A K_vi eD|

Zzwg ejv- AcvY-gnvcvY awbmgw w`qAvgvi GB cvYLvwb hLb RyovjNvl-ANvl eYgvjv w`q Avgvq hLb ek-B Ki ivLjZe meKUv kawbB ZvgvK w`jvgAvgvi Rb ay wkm& awbUzKz ivLjvgA eYjv _vKzK Avgv`i `yRbi gvSLvb|

Avwg ewj- Kvj Avevi GmvP`we`yi Puv` wKsev eMxI R-Gi RvQbvme Zvjv iBj Kej Zvgvi Rb|

37

^vevb KweZv

GKwU ^vevb KweZv cRbbwe Rj Rxeb PvBZg DPviY cwgKvi mvnPh PvB kvejxi mZZ mgvMg PvB|

KweZv cvV PvB, Zvi cvVvvi PvB^c PvB, Kbv PvB, Avkv-AvKvvi wewZ PvBmyL I `ytLi GK we`yZ wgjb nIqv PvBkg-mvabv-mgqi h_ mw PvB|

`vwe-`vIqvi hw` mvac~iY NU, hw` cwikvwaZ nqZe GB bvI GKwU ^vevb KweZv|

3819

cvnvwo mswZi fvOv mZyARj `Iqvb

bvg `L AbK nqZv wfiwg LZ cvib| hviv mvwnZ ev ivRbxwZi mv_Awei hy Zv`i KvQ bvgwU cwiwPZ VKZ cvi| Zv`i AbygvbB mwZ,bvgwU wbqwQ Avgvi wcq mvwnwZK AvLZvivgvb Bwjqvmi GKgv ceM_K| Zuvi cewU evg ivRbxwZ ev hviv menviv ivRbxwZi mv_ hy Zv`i GKwUAvewkK cvVwelq| KviY, menviv mswZ ev KlK-gRyi`i mswZ ejZ hvevSvq Zvi mv_ GKRb gawexq ZiY hvi PvL gvbegywi AvKvv, wkKjfvOvi Mvb, Zvi GKvZ nIqvi gvag `ki mePq cMwZkxj Ask menviv`imv_ GKvZ nIqvi GKUv c_ `wLq w`qQb Bwjqvm| gawe cwievimvswZK ejqi ga eo nIqv GKRb ZiYi menviv mswZi mv_ gawexqmswZi GK hvMm~ GB eBqi mvigg| Avwg Avevi bZyb Ki m welqwUAejvKb KiZ PvwQ bv| Avwg eis Zuvi GB cei wKQy AvBwWqv ev conceptK KvR jvwMq cvnvwo RbMYi Dci cqvMi wKQy e_v Pv KiwQ gv|Bwjqvmi gZ mvwnwZK ev wPvkxj jLK nIqvi gZ wPv `yt^cI Avm bv|Ze, Zuvi wPvi m~ Avgv`i wbR`i Rxeb-mswZi Dci cqvMi wKQy e_v PvKij Aek KD wKQy gb Kieb bv|

evsjv`k cvq 45 wUi Dci Avw`evmx Mvx iqQ| cvnvoB iqQ cvq 11 wUigZv| G`i ga PvKgv, gvigv, wcyiviv Abvb RbMvxi Pq GKUy ewk|AZxZ GB Mvxjvi ga fvj GKUv mve `Lv MjI eZgvb Zvi ikGKUy Kg| Gi wcQb wK iqQ Avmyb GKUy chvjvPbv Ki Avwm|

ivvgvwUi Zyjbvq LvMovQwo Ges ev`ievb gvigv`i msLv GKUy ewk| AvMPvKgv Avi gvigv`i ga fvj GKUv mK _vKjI eZgvb GUv hb GKUy wSwgqcoQ| PvKgviv cviZc Pvq bv gvigv`i DbwZ Avi gvigvivI PvKgv`i wbqGZUv DQwmZ bq| cvivwiK Awekvm`i `qvj Av Av Ki fvM Ki w`qQGB `yB enr RbMvxK| Pywc~e mgq kvwevwnbx Ges cvnvwo Qv cwil` GKUv

39

mgq PvKgv Ges gvigv Qv`i wekvj AskMnY wQj| Gme msMVb PvKgv`icfve wQj ewk Ges bZZchvqI wQj PvKgviv| gvigviv PvKgv`i Pq wKQyUvwcwQq wQj ZvB Zviv wkv-`xvq wbR`i DbZ Kivi Pv KiZB PvKgv`iga wKQyUv gbzYZvi cfve `Lv hvq| KviY, Zviv gb KiZ h, PCP evRGmGm Kivi gvag Zviv Zv aygv PvKgv bq, eis cvnvoi cwZwU RbMvxiAwaKvi Av`vqi Rb KvR KiQ| Zviv gvigv`i GB cPvK fvj PvL bv `LviKviY gvigv`i gaI Av Ki GB weli exR ecY nq hvq| ZvivI gbKiZ i Ki h, PvKgviv Kviv DbwZ `LZ cvi bv| Zviv gb Ki, gvigvivwbR`i DbwZ KiZ cvij Zviv axi axi PvKgv`i vb `Lj KiZ cvi GBfq PvKgv`i ga KvR Ki| Gfve i nq hvq cviwiK Awekvm|

wcyivivI cvq GKBfve wbR`i Avjv`v fveZ i KiQ| Zviv gb KiwbRiv hw` wbR`i cqvRbxq ^v_K KvR jvwMq RvwZi GKUy mgw NUvZcvi Ze Zv `vli Kvb evcvi bq| dj ZvivI AvR wbR`i weePbv KiQcvnvo gvqi GK egvq mvb wnme|

eZgvb gvigviv wbR`i Mov gvigv yWU KvDwj Ges wcyiviv wcyiv Qvmsm`, Zb&POviv Ki Zb&POv msm` Avi PvKgviv Zv`i wbR^ bvg w`q ZwiKZwKQy f~uBdvo mwgwZ ev RvqMvf` Qv msMVb Ki| G`i ga hviv GKUy fvjivRbxwZ evS ev KiZ Pvq Zviv PCP Ki| Avevi eZgvb RvZxq ivRbxwZZIAskMnY Kivi ceYZv Lye cej gvvq `Lv hvQ| AbK evgcx ivRbxwZ Kivigvag ^xq RvwZ Z_v mgM kvwlZkwYi gyw PvBQ Avevi AbK eZgvb eyRvqv`jjvi mv_ hyZvi gvag wKQzUv gZvi ^v` cZ PvBQ| Abw`K, eZgvbcRbi wekvj GKUv Ask ivRbxwZ _K `~i Aevb Kivi gvag mvgvwRK-mvswZK msMVb Kivi ga w`q wbR`i KqKRbi gvS GKZv ivLvi PvKi| gvS gvS vacation-Gi mgq Zviv cvnvoi cZ Aj Mixe cvnvwowkv_x`i webvg~j wkv`vb Kivi gvag mgvRi cwZ Zv`i `vqeZv cKvkKi| mvswZK gvbi cvq GKB `k| KqKRb wgj GKUv mvswZKmsMVb Kivi gvag we`kx ev wbR^ mswZi PPv Kivi GKUv ceYZv B`vwbsj Kiv hvq| cyuwRev`x mgvR Aevb Kivi KviY GKw`K hgb fvMev`xceYZv Zy DVQ Gi wecixZ w`K gk iv KZK wbcxobi dj wbR`iga Mo DVQ RvZxq GK PZbveva| GB PZbveva aygv ^xq RvwZi cwZ,cvkvcvwk KD wbcxwoZ nQ wKbv Zv `Lvi mgq cvIqv hvq bv| cuywRev`xmgvReevq mgq bv cvIqvUvB ^vfvweK| GB fvMev`x ceYZv I RvZxqPZbvevai MuvovKj AvR mgM cvnvoi eZgvb cRb| cRbi ga GKw`K

4020

vbcyZi I Aciw`K bemwi mvebv Zwi nQ| Zviv PvBQ bZyb wKQy mwiRb, bZyb wKQy Ki `Lvbvi AvKvv Zv`i PvL| iv KZK wbcxob Zv`iKfveZ eva KiQ wfb wKQy Kivi Avevi mvebvK AbK fvMi wejvm fvwmqw`Q| mKjB Zv`i wbR^ AvZwbqYvaxKvi wbq gbvK fvM|

dj, Kvb AvNvZ AvmjB Avgiv wbR`i Ry Ry ej mB AvNvZK cwZivaKiZ PvB| wK, GB Ry kUvI GLb AbKUv PvKgviv wbR`i Ki wbqQ|cvnvoi AwaKvsk Qjgq hviv evBi covkvbv Ki Zviv GB aviYv cvlY Kih, Ry kUv GLb aygv PvKgv`i Rb| mLvb gvigv, wcyiv, PvK, Zb&POv`ivb bB| Kb, GB aviYv? cvnvwo ki gaI Avevi wefvRb j Kiv hvq|AbK gb Ki cvnvwo kUvi gvS GKUy backwardness Gi M AvQ| RykUvI w`b w`b ccvwZZ nq hvQ| Avevi Avw`evmx wnme cwiPqi Pq cvn-vwoUvB AbK ewk cvavb `q| Zvnj wK Avgiv `ki GB Aji mgMRbMvx ev RvwZmvmg~nK wfb wfb bvg wPwZ Kiev? bvwK Avgiv PvBe AvM_K cPwjZ ev nq Avmv bvg cvnvwo ev Ry GB bvgB cwiwPZ nZ?

Avwg cvnvoi Awaevmx`i GLbv cvnvwo wnmeB m^vab Kwi Ges evwK AskIGB bvgB Avwg DjL Kie|

cvnvwoiv GLbv A_bwZK wfwi Dci `uvwoq bB| cvnvwoiv nq GKevigawe hviv PvKwi Ki ev wbR`i RvqMv-Rwg ev evMvbevwo AvQ A_ev nqGKevi menviv| Giv Abi Rwg Pvl Kivi gvag DcvRb Ki wbRi IQjgq-eK LvIqvq| gvU K_v, cvnvwo`i ga eyRvqv kwY ev cuywRcwZiPnviv GLbv `Lv hvq wb| ZvQvovI, Avgiv Avgv`i A_bxwZK GK AwbYqKvb iL w`qwQ| Avgiv hgb cuywRev`x ivK LvRbv `qvi gvag `ki mgMcuywRee vi mv_ Lvc LvBq wbwQ Avevi `Lv hvq h, Avgv`i mvgxq cfy hgbPvKgv ivRv, gvigv ivRv, evgvs ivRv`i LvRbv `qvi gvag Zuv`i ivRZI^xKvi Ki wbwQ| mvgwMK `ki cvcU weePbv Kij Avgiv cuywRev`i GKUvchvqB AvwQ| cvnvwo gaweiv cuywRev`i kvlY wbwlZ nIqvi gvagwbR`i Rxeb msMvg Pvjvb| cvnvoi cwievijvZ gawexq KvjPvi cvKwUmKiv nq| wkwZ cwievijvZ Mvb-bvPI kLvbv nq|

gawexq gv-eveviv Rbi ciciB mvb`i GB wkv `b h, wbRK cwiek evwmgi mv_ Lvc LvBq bqvi Rb| Gici m eo nIqvi ci Avkcvkicwiek A `kfve Ae vb Kiv mvc`vwqKZvi welevi dj Av Av Ki fvMKiZ i Ki cvnvwo-evOvwj GB aviYv| hZB m eo nZ _vK ZZB m Zvi wbRmgMvxq ey`i mv_ GKvZ nZ _vK| Lye A msLK PvKgv Qj AvQ hv`i

41

GKgv Nwb ey gvigv ev wcyiv| gvigv ev wcyiv`i I GB K_vwU mwZ|Avgiv KD Gi ewZg bB| Kb GB fvM-wefvRb? Kb GB RvwZmvMZ weivM?

Bwjqvm hgb evsjv`ki gawexqkwYi mv_ menviv kwYi ga h cv_K`wLqQb GKB cv_K GB I cqvM Kiv hvq| mgRvwZmv eyi mv_ Avgivh mswZ-HwZn w`q wgk GKvZ nZ cvwi Ab RvwZmvmg~ni ey`i mv_Zv me nq IV bv| `ywU RvwZi gvS Ggb Kvb mswZ GLbv ch Mo IVwb hv `yB RvwZKB GKB wfwi Dci `uvo Kive| ZvQvovI, Zgb Kvb Av`kIGLvb KvR Ki bv| KviY, Av`kK K` Ki Mo IVv mswZ wfb RvwZmvigvbylK GK Ki w`Z cvi| ZvB, GLvbB Avm mswZi cv_Ki ic|

cvnvoi cwZwU RvwZi wbR^ AvPvi, HwZn I mswZ AvQ| Avwg wbRI PvKgvQj weavq PvKgv Mvb, PvKgv KweZv ev PvKgv wdj `Lvi GKUv ceYZv AvQ|wK, Avgvi ga Kb gvigv Mvb ev KweZvi cwZ mB AbyivM cvlY Kwi bv?AbK nqZv ejZ cvib fvlvMZ `~iZi KviY kvbv, `Lv nq bv| Zv`iDk ejZ PvB, Mvsbvg vBj Mvbi cwZwU jvBb KqRb evS GKgvKvwiqvb ev`? wbRi hw` mw`Qv _vK Ze fvlvMZ `~iZ Kvb welq nZ cvibv| hLvb, Avgiv nvRvi gvBj `~i AewZ GKUv wfb`ki fvlvK i KivicvYcY Pvq iZ _vwK mLvb cvkeZx cvovi GK PvKgv, gvigv, wcyiv fvlvKKb mB wfb`kxq fvlvi gZ i Kivi Pv Kwi bv?

PvKgv Qj gqiv hLb GKwZ nq ZLb mLvb PvKgv fvlvmn PvKgv Mvbicvavb _vK, GUvB ^vfvweK| wK mLvb GKRb gvigv ev wcyiv Qj wK^vfvweK eva Kie? ZLb m AekB Zvi mvswZK ~`iZfve cvlY KiZ eva|ZLb Zvi gvS RvZwfgvYx KvR Ki| wbRK nvwiq m LyuRZ Pvq wK Zviw`kv bv cq m Zvi mgMvxq ey`i LuvR Ges mLvb Zvi mvswZK PPvUvKai ivLZ Pv Ki|

AvRKvj Qj-gqiv wnw` _K i Ki BsiwR Mvb, wdji cwZ AvKlY evaKi Zviv mUv eySyK Avi bvB eySyK| Zviv IBjvK standard wnme ai wbqwbR`iK mBfve Dcvcb KiZ Pvq| GUvK Avgiv eje AcmswZicfve| mB mv_ RvwZMZ wblYi KviYB nvK Avi RvwZi cwZ UvbiKviYB nvK Zviv wbR`i mswZiI PPv Ki| wK, cvkvcvwk Ab RvwZmg~nhvivI iv KZK wbcxwoZ Zv`i mswZK Rvbvi ev PPv Kivi ceYZv AbycwZKviY mLvb _K kLvi ev PPvi Kvb myhvM bB| hLvb wnw` fvlvK Rvbvigvag Zv`i Mvb ev mswZK aviY Kivi GKUv ceYZv _vK mLvb PvKgv,gvigv, wcyiv Mvbi Zv bB|

4221

gvigv`i mswZi ga GUv mevi Rvbv mUv nj cvwb Ljv| wK Gi wcQbiBwZnvm wK mevi Rvbv AvQ? Zv`i mswZ h jvKMxwZZ mg mUv AvgivKZRb Lqvj ivwL? A_P hvi hvi mswZi cwZ Avgv`i AbyivM cP|PvKgv`iI Ggb wKQy AvPvi-mswZ AvQ hv gvigv ev wcyiviv wK Rvb? GfveBmvswZK `~iZi gvag Av Av i nq ^RvwZKw`KZv hv ivRbwZKI `~iZ mw Ki|

Kvb GKwU ivRbwZK `ji gvS hLb cvkvcvwk y`B mnKgx ev bZv-Kgxi gvSwekvm I cviwiK kveva nvwiq hvq ZLb mLvb Avm fvOb, Avm wefw|AbK mgq mUv Av`wkK I nZ cvi| cyivbv RGmGm fO bZzbRGmGm (Gg. Gb jvigv) Gi Dvbi wcQb hwU KvR KiQ mwU njvAv`wkK| hLbB `ji ga wekvm I cvivwiK kveva nvwiq Mj ZLbBAv Av Ki gvigviv mi hZ _vK PCP _K| GLb Lye Kg msLK gvigvGes wcyiv Qj PCP Ki| Zviv eZgvb ivRbxwZ _K `~i mi wMq wewfbiKg mvgvwRK Kvhgi mv_ hy _vKZ cQ` Ki| Zviv gb Ki GfvegvMZ wbR`iK DbwZi w`K wbq hZ cvij mUv AvLi Zv`i Ges ^xqRvwZi DbwZ mvwaZ ne|

gZvqbi w`K hw` GKUy `wcvZ Kwi Zvnj `LZ cvev h, eZgvb PvKgvivgk wbR`i AwZ LuyR wdiQ| LvMovQwoi K_vB aiv hvK, GLvbKvi Ggwc,Rjv cwil` Pqvigvb wcyiv nIqvUv PvKgv Avi gvigv`i Rb GKUy gb KyUKyUKivi welq| wK, Zviv GUv `L bv GB Ggwc, Pqvigvbiv RvwZ^v_i PqkwY^v_KB ewk cvavb `b| Zv`i KvQ PvKgv, gvigv, wcyiv mevB mgvb|nqZv `Lv hve h GB Avgjviv Zv`i vwZfvB ev AvZxqK `ybxwZi gvagKvb PvKwi ev KvR cZ mvnvh KiQ Ges GwUKB ZLb weePbv Kiv nQZvi RvwZfvB`i m DbwZi wkLi cuQ w`Q| GB `wfwwU aviY Kiv fyj|KviY, Avgjv wcyiv ej m mgM wcyiv RvwZmvi Rb KvR KiQ bv Zvi wKQyAvZxq ev`| ZvB, RvwZMZ weivMfvRb _K GwUK wePvi bv Ki kwYMZ`wKvY _K wePvi Kiv DwPZ|

Gevi Avwm ivRbwZK `jjvi w`K| ivRbwZK `j ejZ AvM cvnvoGKwUgv msMVb wQj mwU RbmsnwZ mwgwZ| wbR`i AwaKvi Av`vqi RbGB `ji bZviv Zuv`i heb, msmvi wemRb w`q `ki AvMvmx mbvevwnbximv_ hy KiwQjb| ZLb GZ PvKgv, gvigv, wcyiv`i AskMnY wQj PvLcovi gZB hw`I PvKgv`i msLv wQj cvq mi fvMi gZ| Gici Av AvKi wSwgq coZ i Ki GB `ji Kvhg| `jxq Kv`ji dj wbnZ nb

43

Gg.Gb jvigv, Gici GK chvq PvevB gMI wbnZ nb AvZbvgv`i nvZ|Gfve gv^q PvKgv I gvigv`i gvS `~iZ mw nq| Zviv GK GK `j ZvMKiZ _vK| cieZxZ 89 mvj Gm cwZwZ nq cvnvwo Qv cwil` Ges G`imivmwi ivRc_ Av`vjbi mv_ hy nIqvi dj AwaKvi Av`vqi Av`vjbAviv eMevb nq| miKvii Dci Pvc mw nq axi axi| miKvi Zvi Aevb_K mi Gm eva nq cveZ Pyw KiZ| Gici Zv BDwcwWGd-Gi mw, hvivPqwQjv ^vqkvmb| Zviv Pyw weivaxZvi gvag eZgvb ch Zv`iivRbwZK KgKv Pvwjq hvQ| hw`I GLb Pzw welq Zv`i Aevb bgbxqchvq| Aviv GKUv welq jYxq h, cvnvoi ivRbwZK `jjvi wewfbAmsMVb AvQ, Ze mLvb mvswZK AmsMVb AbycwZ| dj, ivRbwZK`jjvi mvswZK gvb, PPv wKfve weKwkZ nQ mUv Avgvi evaMg nQbv| ivRbwZK `jjvi Kvhg mgM cveZ PMvg Ryo| Zviv cvnvoi cwZwUgvbyli kvlY-wbcxob _K gywi Rb Ges GKwU kvlYnxb mgvR cwZvij KvR Ki hvQ A_P, mvswZK PPvi `jjv co AvQewwewQbZvi RvqMvq| GKwU Av`kK mvgb iL jovB-msMvg cwiPvjbvi GB wewQbZveva evav mw KiQ evievi| Gfve, mvgwMK A_ Zviv mKjRvwZmvK GK m~ Muv_Z e_ nqQ|

GKUv mgq h RGmGm I BDwcwWGd G mevi AskMnY wQj AvR Kb mB`jjvZ bZ nQ PvKgv`i `j ej? gvigv I wcyiviv Kb GB `jjvimv_ wbR`i GKvZZv cvlY KiZ cvi bv? GUv wK Zv`i `vl? bvwK`jjvi KvhgB cwiYZ KiQ Zv`i GB gZ cvlY KiZ? Avgvi GK eofvB GKevi ejwQjb, LvMovQwoi cvbLvBqv cvovq bvwK BDwcwWGd Zvi KvhgPvjvZB cvi bv| GLvb DjL h, cvbLvBqv cvov nQ gvigv AaywlZ cvov|Zviv Dfq `jKB weePbv Ki PvKgv`i `j ej| ivRbwZK `jjv GUv wbqKvbw`b wPv KiQ Kx? Kb Zv`i wei GB Acev` `qv nQ mB ckiDi Zviv LuyR `LQb wKbv Avgvi Av` Rvbv bB| gvigv, wcyivmn Aviv cvq8wU RvwZi Aevb cvnvo| GB 10wU RvwZi wPv-PZbv ivRbwZK `jjviga w`q weKwkZ bv nIqvi KviYB G cavb| GQvovI, ivRbwZK `jjvigvS gvMZ weev`-msNvZ G wKQyUv njI cfveKi f~wgKv cvjb KiQ|

cwZwU RvwZiB DwPZ Zvi wbR^ mvwnZ-mswZ, AvPvi-HwZni cvkvcvwk wkv-wevb GwMq hvIqv| Gi mv_ mv_ cvnvoi mKj RvwZmvi ga mvswZKGKUv gjeb NUvbv| Ggb wKQy Avgiv wK KiZ ciwQ? wbR`i wbq e_vKv Qvov Avi wKQyB Kiv nq IV wb| `ki gawexq Rxebeevi mv_cvnvwoivI AvR Mv fvwmq w`qQ| cuywRev`x mgvReevq ew^vaxbZv _K

4422

ew^vZeva Ges Zv axi axi ewwewQbZveva cwiYZ nIqv gvbweKwqyZv Avgv`i Mvm KiQ| GKUv cev` AvQ h, cvnvwoiv wbR`i fvjvwbRiv mn KiZ cvi bv| GwU Ggwb Ggwb Zv Avm wb| mvswZi `~iZicfve kl ch cvnvwo`i wbq hve asmi vicv|

mekl ivi K_vB ejev| iv KZK `gb-cxob Zv mB ^vaxbZvi AvM _KjM AvQB, bZyb Ki wKQy ejvi bB| Ze, GLvb GKUv welq jYxq h, 1989mvji Rjv cwil` wbevPb nq Ges hLb mviv `ki Rjv cwil`jv evwZj Kivnq aygv cveZ Rjvjv ev`, mB wbevPbi gvag Gikv` miKvi PvKgv`imv_ Abvb RvwZmvjvi gvS wefvRb cwqv Zivw^Z KiZ mg nq, hw`ImB wbevPb eqKUi WvK w`qwQj RGmGm| Rjv cwil`jvZ Avmb msLvPvKgviv Kg cvq Ges PvKgviv Abvb RvwZmvi Pq wkv, mvgvwRK, ivRbwZKI Avw_K w`K _K GwMq wQj ZvB GB NUbvi dj Abvb RvwZ hviv GKUy wcwQqwQj Zv`iK miKvi KvQ UvbZ mg nq| Gfve, iv axi axi Zvi Dkwmw KiZ _vK| AvM GKUv mgq wQj hLb Gikv` gZvq ZLb cvnvwo`iga hviv gwUK ev BUvi cvk KiZ Zv`iK LuyR LuyR PvKwi `qv nZ| GfveBgvMZ miKvii `vmvby`vm Kivi gvag cvnvwo`i AwaKvi Av`vqi Av`vjbKwwgZ KiZ PvBj miKvi| dj, cvnvwo mgvR mw nq Mj wekvj GKgawekwY, hviv mKvj DV Awdm hvq Avi mvq evwo wdi Gm Lvevi LqNywgq co| gawe KywUjZv Qvov G`i Avi wKQy bB| Giv cyuwRev`x mgvRAe vb KiI mvgxq wPvavivq GLbv cfvweZ Ges cMwZkxjZvi Kvb Qvc G`igvS LuyR cvIqv hvq bv| GQvovI, Gi cfve cvnvwo cuywRI Zgb mw nZcviwb| cvnvwo`i A_bxwZI AvRv co AvQ AbK wcQb|

cvnvwo`i AwaKvi Av`vqi c_ KLbv gmY wQj bv| bv wQj mUv Pywc~e mgqbv eZgvb mgqI| GLbv Avgv`i AbK c_ cvwo w`Z ne| ivRbwZKfvewbR`i AwaKvi Av`vqi Rb mevi AvM cqvRb cvnvoi mg RvwZmviga mvswZK mZyeb Zwi Kiv| gvigv`i wewfb msMVb hgb, BMSC A_evcgvmvm hviv wbR`i mvgvwRK I AivRbwZK msMVb wnme `vwe Ki Zv`iKmn Aviv wewfb msMVbjvK GB Av`vjb m Kivi Rb GKUv KgbcvUdig MVb Kiv LyeB Riwi| PCP-K nqZv GB Kgb cvUdig wnme MnYKivi GKUv mvebv wQj wK Zv AyiB web nq wMqQ| ZvB mKj ivRbwZK,mvgvwRK msMVbjvi DwPZ wbR`i Kvhgi cvkvcvwk Av_mvgvwRK cvcUKvR Kivi gvag cvnvoi 11wU RvwZmvmn `ki 45wU Avw`evmx RvwZi gamvswZK GK gjeb Zwii D`vM bqv|

45

NyY aiv Ry Avw`evmx mgvRi wKQz K_vGwWmb PvKgv

qj qj Avgv `R gvb-gyovb,qj qj Avgv `R Svivwb,ivOv ivOv gvbRvi gbvwb//evbyev`tmeyR meyR Avgv`i `ki cvnvo-ceZ,meyR meyR Avgv`i `ki eb,ivOv ivOv gvbyli gb//

Rbwcq GB PvKgv Mvbi gZB wbfRvj Avi my`i wQj cveZ PMvgigvbyljvi gb| Mswj MxZi gZB mij wQj gvbyli Rxeb-hvcb| wK AvRmB gb aiQ cPb| Pviw`K fvMev`x PZbv Avi ivh KZK AvMvmb RyAvw`evmx mgvRi ga aiQ fqven cPb| GB cPb iva Kie K?

1908 mvj kx mZxkP` Nvl PvKgv RvwZ : BwZnvm I BwZe eBq jLb,wK Kb Rvwb bv, PvKgvw`Mi Pwi mshgi GKv Afve| AwZ mnR ah PzwZNU| zjQv`i gaI `wLqvwQ, PvKgv evjKi AbK nBZ AsK KwlZQ,wK c_g Pv wedj nBZB b cvwig ewjqv dwjqv ivwLj| evanq mshgiBAfve PvKgvw`Mi ga wgZeqxZv GKeviB bvB| bZzev Bnviv hic cwikgxGes DcvRbg, ek myL ^Q` msmvihvv wbevn Kwiqv hvBZ cvi| wKfwelr wPv Bnvw`MK AwZ mvgvbB AvNvZ Ki, Zvnviv DcwZ myL-mvMwbZv eM nq| wkwZ`i ga Kn Kn mvvZ wejvZdiZ evey, Pjv wdivIAbKUv Be`jmZ| Bnv Qvov, mvaviY PvKgvw`Mi gaI GZ ~`i wejvm BQvcek KwiqvQ h, Kn Kn `vKvb Dcw Z nBqv c_g ivRv h Kvco cibmB cvlvK Abymvb Ki| wZwb hw` mKj Ry`i wbq wjLZb Zvnj AekBGB gewU mKj Ry Avw`evmx`i RbB KiZb| kx mZxkP ` Nvl 1908 mvjhB K_vwU Abyaveb KiQb mB K_vwU Avgiv AvRI Abyaveb KiZ cvwiwb|ZvBZv fvMev`x PZbvq AvK wbgwZ _K Avgiv fzjZ emwQ AwaKvi wKwRwbm, Kxfve AwaKvi Av`vq KiZ nq|

GB fvMev`x PZbv AvM GZ cwigvY cKU wQj bv, wK ivh Lye m~ KkjGB PZbvK KvR jvwMq Dby AvKvk mswZi gvag MvUv Ry Avw`evmx

4623

mgvRK KiQ AwaKvi mcK AmPZb, Av`vjb wegyL, fvMev`x Avi Ry hyemgvRK KiQ Uw, dvkbej, bkv I Ryqvq AvK wbgwZ Avi Ry igYxivvi cvm, vi Rjmvi wmwiqvj evS wK cveZ PMvg mbvevwnbx KZKmsNwUZ 13wU MYnZvi K_v evS bv, Ag kwYi Qvx ZygvwPs gvigv, Kvk dviiQvx myRvZv PvKgvK hLb alYi ci nZv Kiv nq ZLb Zv`i AvZwPrKvi RyigYx`i `q ck Ki bv| wK GLbI Zvnviv Bnv wkwLZ gbvhvM w`Q bv|cvq wek ermi c~e A ivvgvwU MfbgU we`vjqi Z`vbxb nWgvvi eZgvbcbkbcv kxhy ivgKgj `vm gnv`q GB zji kvLv ^ic MfbgU eqKzKvi, KgKvi I m~ai wbhy Kwiqv GKwU wkwe`vjq LywjqvwQjb| wK vbxqKwZcq mv jvKi J`vmxb AwPi Zvnvi AwZ wejy nq| nvq! Zvnv GZw`bRxweZ _vwKj AbK fdj c`vb KiZv| RvZxq bZeMi GB wUi wbwgmgvRK AviI eKvj K cvBZ nBe (Z_m~t PvKgv RvwZ : BwZnvm IBwZe)| kx mZxkP` Nvl 1908 mvj ge Ki wMqwQjb eKvj GB wUidj fvM KiZ ne| mB dj h kZ eQiI kl ne bv, Zv hw` wZwb AbygvbKiZ cviZb Zvnj cyiv Ry RvwZK gv_vq Mvei fiv ej` Qvov Ab wKQzge KiZb ej Avgvi gb nq bv| Ry`i wbZcqvRbxq eenvh mvgMxi ga`v, ewU BZvw` AbZg| A_P Avgv`iK AvRI evOvwj`i vi nZ nq GB memvgMx q Kivi Rb| h RvwZ Ab RvwZi gyLvcx, wbR^ Drcv`b ee vnxb mBRvwZ cw_exZ ewkw`b wUKZ cvi bv| GLb cveZ PMvg emevmKvix RyAvw`evmx`i Rxebgvb Dbqb KvR KiQ AbKjv GbwRI, Zv`i gaI RyKvgvi, Kzgvi Zwii evcvi Zgb Kvb AvMn `Lv hvq bv| ZvQvov, Ry`i gahviv mykxj mgvRi cwZwbwa I Avw_Kfve mQj Zv`i gaI Zgb Kvb jY`Lv hvq bv GB mgmvwUi evcvi wPv KiZ| bv Rvwb, mvaviY Ry`iK AvivKZeQi mB AvMiKvi weevb`i Kiv fzji gvj bZ ne! Gikv` miKviimgq wZwb wkwZ Ry Avw`evmx`iK PvKwi bvgK GK euvab Ave KiwQjb,hvZ GB wkwZ kwY kvwevwnbxZ hvM w`Z bv cvi, hvZ gawe kwY bvgmyweavev`x GKwU kwY Zwi nq| wZwb Abyaveb KiwQjb wkwZ Ry`iK PvKwiieb hZ ewk cwigvY Ave Kiv hve ZZ ewk cwigvY fvMev`xZv G`i gacek Kivbv hve| gawe kwY bv cvi mBZ Avi bv cvi Av`vjb, cwZev`KiZ| Giv memgq Pv Ki Svgjv Gwoq Pjvi| Abvqi cwZev` KivUvKIGB kwY gb Ki Svgjvi Ask| Gikv`i Avgj mB i nqwQjv hv AvRvcevngvb| eZgvb wkwZ Ry Avw`evmx kwY GLb `ovQ PvKwi bvgK mvbvinwiYi wcQ| wkKZv ckv GKwU gnvb I mvbxq ckv| Gg. Gb. jvigv cveZ

47

PMvg wece i KiwQjb c_g wkKZv ckv w`q| wZwb eySZ ciwQjbRyiv hw` wkwZ bv nq Zvnj wPiw`bB AwaKvi mcK AmPZb _K hve; AviMZvbyMwZK wkvi viv mB mPZbZv Kvbw`bB Avme bv| ZvB wZwb cveZPMvg wkvi Avjv Rvjvbvi Dk nvZ Zzj wbqwQjb wkv we vii gkvj|Gg. Gb. jvigv I Zvi mnPi`i nvZ wkv cvIqv Qv-Qvxiv nqwQj AwaKvimcK mPZb, cieZxZ Zv`i ga AbKB hvM w`qwQjb kvwevwnbxZ|ZvBZv Gg. Gb. jvigvi nvZ ai i nIqv mB wecei Ab Avi GKUv bvg nqwMqwQj wUPvm ifyjkb ev wkK wece| wK eZgvb Ry`i KvQ wkKZv Avickv bq, Ab `kUv PvKwii gZ GKUv PvKwi| eZgvb Ry Qv-Qvx`i ga GgbKvDK LuyR cvIqv hve bv hvi fwelZ j wkK nIqv| Zvi e`j Zv`i j_vK Kxfve Wvvi ne, Kxfve Bwwbqvi ne, Kxfve DcRvwZ KvUvq KvUvew`nq wewmGm KvWvi ne, Kxfve `yB nvZ UvKv Kvgve, Mvwo-evwo, evsK evjigvwjK ne| ZviciI Ry`i ga AbKB wkKZv KiQb| wK Kviv KiQb?GKUvB Di : hviv Ab PvKwi RyUvZ cvib wb ZvivB wkKZv KiQb| GLb we.G., Gg. G. cvk Kiv Ry`i jB _vK Kxfve dzW Awdm PvKwi cve, KxfvewWwm Awdm PvKwi cve, Kxfve evsKi gvbRvii c`wU evwMq be GB RvZxqwPv-fvebv| KviY, GBme PvKwiZ Nyl AvQ h! wkKZv ckvq Zv Nyl bB,eZb Kg| wK KD Avi eySvi Pv Kibv wkKZvi gZ gnvb I mvbi ckvcw_exZ Avi wZxqwU bB| Avgvi Avkcvki AbKRbKB `LwQ hviv cvBgvwizji wkKi PvKwi cvIqvi ci `yMg GjvKvq zj nIqvi KviY wVKgZ zjhvb bv| Zvi e`j mfb-GBU cvk KvDK gvwmK wKQz UvKvi wewbgq wkKZviPvKwi eMv w`q `b| A_P mKvj njB bgt bgt mv nj bgt bgt| zj wVKgZbv cwoq gvm kl em em eZb ZvjvUv Zv`i KvQ cvc ej gb nq bv,wbRi `vwqZ wVKgZ cvjb bv Ki `ybxwZ Ki gvm kl eZb ZvjvUv Zv`iKvQ Aciva ej gb nq bv| Giv `ybxwZi gvag Avq Kiv cvci UvKv agxqcwZvb `vb Ki, agi cjc w`q `ybxwZUvK nvjvj Kivi Rb| Avi Zv`i`L jvKRbI evnev `q, Avn! KZ eo avwgK! G`i GB aibi KvhKjvc `Lgb nq `ybxwZi gvag Avq Kiv cvci UvKvK RvqR Kivi Rb agxq cwZvbNyl w`Q| A_P G`i `vwqZ nj Qv-Qvx`iK jLvcov wkwLq gvbyli gZgvbyl wnme Zwi Kiv| wkKZvi gZ gnvb ckvi mv_ RwoZ`iB hw` GBAev nq Zvnj mB RvwZ DbZ ne Kxfve? gvbyljv AwaKvi mPZbB ev neKxfve? GBme wkKi viv wkv cvIqv Qv-QvxjvI Kvbw`bB mywkv cvebv, wkvi bvg hv cve Zv nj mvwUdKU me^ wkv| wkvi Dk nj vb

4824

ARb, Avi wkKi KvR GKRb wkv_xK vbvRb mvnvh Kiv| wK eZgvbRy Avw`evmx`i KvQ wkvi A_ nj gvUv gvUv bv^vi hvM wKQz mvwUwdKUhvMvo Kiv hvZ cieZxZ gvUv eZbi GKUv PvKwi hvMvo Kiv hvq| wkK`iKvRI hb, vbvRb mvnvh Kiv bq, wkv_x`iK cvVeB gyL Kwiq cixviLvZvq DMo w`Z mvnvh Kiv| vbvRb bq, mvwUwdKU ARbB GLb g~j K_v|eZgvb Ry Avw`evmx mgvRi KvQ nvRvi nvRvi eB co vb ARb Kiv GKRbiPq aygv cvVeB co mvwUwdKU ARb Kiv GKRb ej`i g~j AbK ewk|ZvB mevB QzUQ imi Nvovi gZ, PvKwi bvgK mvbvi nwiYi wcQb| h KvbAv`vjbi mv_B A_ bvgK kwU IZcvZfve RwoZ| aygv AveM Avi cgw`q Kvb Av`vjb mdjZv cZ cvi bv| Avcwb mk wece ev ivRc_iAv`vjb hB c_B nuvUb bv Kb mB Av`vjb wedj hZ cvi aygv chvA_ bv _vKvi KviY| fviZ, gvqvbgvi, AvgwiKv, Pxb, ivwkqv, cvwK vb hB `kBAvcbvK mvnvh KiK bv Kb wbt^v_fve KDB AvcbvK mvnvh Kie bv| A_,A hv w`qB mvnvh KiK bv Kb, Avcwb cwiYZ neb Zv`i xobK, KiZne Zv`i ^v_i ev evqb| ZLb Avcbvi Av`vjb Pje Zv`i AvOzji Bkvivq|AvcbvK euvq njZ ejj euvq njZ ne Avi Wvb njZ ejj Wvb njZne| wK Avcbvi hw` Av`vjb Pvwjq hvIqvi Rb chv A_ _vK ZLb AvcbvimvnvhKvix eyi hgb Afve ne bv, Zgwb AiI Afve ne bv| mB RbcqvRb Ry`i A_bwZK wfw gReyZ Kiv| A_bwZK wfw gReyZ Kivi RbcqvRb PvKwii cvkvcvwk Ry eemvqx kwY mw Kiv| Ry`i ga _K h meeemvqx iqQb Zv`i msLvI AwZ bMY| eZgvb wkwZ kwY eemvi K_v ejj,ej cyuwR bB| Avgiv zj-KjR co Avmv wkvK Rxeb KvR jvMvB bv, AvimvwUwdKU me^ wkwZ nIqvi KviY fzj hvB, QvU QvU evjyKYv, we`y we`yRj, Mo Zvj gnv`k, mvMi AZj| Avgvi GK eyK ejwQjvg, weG cvk KieKvi em AvwQm Kb? eemvq bg ci| hw` cuvP nvRvi UvKv cyuwR _vK Zv mBcuvP nvRvi UvKv w`q eemvq bg ci| cqvRb gwiPi eemv i Ki| AvgvimB eywU Di w`qwQj, weG cvk KiwQ wK gwiP eemv Kivi Rb? Avgiv GKjvd MvQ DVZ PvB, hvi KviY eemvi cwZ Avgv`i GB gvbwmKZv| Zvgvi hw`cuvPk UvKv cyuwR _vK Zvnj mB cuvPk UvKv w`q eemvq bg ci| Ggb GKUveemv LyuR ei Ki hB eemvUv cuvPk UvKv w`qI i Kiv hvq, Av Av eonZ `vl Kv_vq? eZgvb evsjv`ki hZ eo eo wkcwZ iqQb Zv`i mevBk~b _K Av Av AvKvk QuzqQb| PvLi mvgbB iqQ Ggb AbK D`vniY|qvi Mci gvwjK cqvZ mvgmb GBP Payix Jlai eemv i KiwQjb gv

49

KqK nvRvi UvKv w`q, A_P AvR Zvi KvwU KvwU UvKvi eemv| Aveyj LvqiMci gvwjK wewo evwbq Nyi Nyi wew KiZb, A_P AvR Zvi bvg kvn wmgU,Aveyj Lvqi wjmn AbKjv eemv| AvRv` cvWvi gvwjK Zvi eemv iKiwQjb gv AvU UvKv w`q| gvjv m, vDb wmgUi gvwjK LweiDwb gvjvZvi eemv i KiwQjb KvMRi VvOv evwbq| weAviwe Kvej I wKqvg gUvjigvwjK gRby wgTv Zvi eemv i KiwQjb GKUv fvOvwii `vKvb _K| AvwKRMci gvwjK Zvi eemv ii c_g w`K nvZ w`q wewo evwbq wew KiZb, A_PAvR AvwKR dzW, AvwKR wmgUmn AbKjv eemvi gvwjK| Ggb Aviv AbKD`vniY iqQ PvLi mvgb, ZeyI Kb cyuwR wbq wPv? cveZ PMvgi mUjvievOvwjiv GKUv gv evwjk Avi Quov K^j wbq GmwQj, A_P eemv Ki AvRZv`i AbKB KvwUcwZ| Zvnj Avgiv Ry Avw`evmxiv GB cveZ PMvgifwgR mvb nqI Kb eemv Ki mydj cvev bv? Gi Di LyuR wbZ neAvgv`iKB| cveZ PMvgi ga iqQ Acvi cvKwZK mc`| euvk, KvVihB eemvUv iqQ mB eemvUvI wVKgZ aiZ cvwiwb Avgiv| Rj _K evN-fvjyKi AvgY, mvc-gkvi Kvgo Dcv Ki euvk, KvV KU wbq Gm hBjvKwU wew KiQ m GKRb Ry| KU wbq Gm wew Kiv mB RywUi KvQ_K wKb wbQ Aci GKRb gamfvMx Ry Avw`evmx eemvqx; Zvici mBeemvqxwU wew KiQ GKRb evOvwj eemvqxi KvQ; Avi mB evOvwj eemvqxwUKg `vg wKb XvKv, PMvg wbq wMq Pov `vg wew KiQ| dj cveZ PMvgicvKwZK mc` w`q eemv Ki UvKvi cvnvo Mo ZzjQ mUjvi evOvwjiv| AviRy eemvqx`iK gamfvMx eemvqx nqB Zz _vKZ nqQ me mgq| aygveuvk-KvVi eemvq bq, Svo, KuvVvj, Avbvim, Av`v, njy`i eemvi I GKBK_v cRvh| GLb ck nj mUjvi evOvwjiv cvij Avgiv Kb cviwQ bv? KviYnj eemvi cwZ Ry`i gvbwmKZv, mUjvi`i cwZ ivhi mnvqK fwgKv AviRy Avw`evmx`i PvKwii cQb `uovbv| hB me gamfvMx Ry eemvqxiqQb Zv`i ewki fvMB AwkwZ; dj XvKv ev PMvg wMq eemv KivUvZv`i c me nq IV bv| XvKv ev PMvgi eemvqx kwY msLvi evOvwjmc`vqi jvK nIqvi KviY Ry eemvqx`i XvKv ev PMvg Zv`i fvKvxevOvwj ey-eve bv _vKvi KviY Zv`i c me nq bv cveZ PMvgi Mwcwiq XvKv ev PMvg wMq eemv Kiv| Abw`K Ry mgvRi ga weqi evRviPvKwiIqvjv RvgvB`i K`i ewk nIqvi KviY wkwZ hye mgvRi jB _vKgvUv eZbi GKUv PvKwi hvMvo Kiv| ZvQvov eemv mcK chv aviYv bv _vKvAvi mvwUwdKUi hvMZv Abyhvqx cQ`gZ eemvq bg civi gZ cyuwRi AfveI

5025

wkwZ Ry`i ga _K eemvqx Zwi nQ bv| A_P nuvm-gyiwMi Lvgvi, MigvUv-ZvRvKiY, QvMji Lvgvi BZvw`i gvagI Ry eemvqx kwY Zwi nZcviZ| wK Ryiv jLvcov wkL gvbyl bv nq dzjevey nIqvi KviY eemv KivigZ wkwZ Ry Avw`evmx eemvqx kwY Zwi nQ bv|

PjwZ gvMvwRbi mcv`K mvne AvgvK evi evi ejwQjb Avwg hb agiwelq bv wjwL, KviY GwU LyeB ckKvZi Bmy| wK AvgvK h wjLZB ne, nZne mZi gyLvgywL| KviY NyY aiv Ry Avw`evmx mgvRi K_v ejZ Mj agiK_vwUI Avme AeavwiZfveB| cveZ PMvgi Ry Avw`evmx`i ewkifvMBe agi Abymvix| dj e agi K_vwUB Avme c_g| eZgvb cw_exi gahZjv ag AvQ Zvi ga AbZg wbixn Avi kvwi ag nj e ag| hw`I e`kb Avi e agi ga AbK Zdvr| AbKi gZ ey Kvb ag cPvi Kibwb,wZwb `kb cPvi KiwQjb hv cieZxZ ag icvi Kiv nq| e `kb ey g~wZic~Rv, AvZv BZvw` AjwKK welqK A^xKvi Kiv nqQ| Avi ag AbKAjwKK evcvi mg_b `vb Ki| e `kb gZ eyi g~j wmv PviwU

1. CkiK A^xKvi Kiv; Ab_vq gvbyl ^qs wbRi cfz GB wmviweivwaZv Kiv nq|

2. AvZvK wbZ ^xKvi bv Kiv, Ab_vq wbZ GKim gvbj Zvi cwiw Gesgywi Kvbv ckB IV bv|

3. Kvbv MK ^Ztwm cgvY wnme ^xKvi bv Kiv, Ab_vq eywew GesAwfZv g~jnxb nq co|

4. RxebcevnK GB kixii gaB mxwgZ gb Kiv, Ab_vq Rxeb Ges Zvibvbv ewP Kvh-KviY cwqvi gvag Drcb bv nq md GK AvKwKNUbv ic cwZfvZ ne (Z_m~ : e `kb)|

e agi g~jg nj, Awnsmv cig ag| wbqg-bxwZi ga iqQ cvYx nZvgnvcvc, cvYx eemv Kiv gnvcvc| KD hw` Zvgvi GK Mvj Po jvMvq ZvnjcwZev`-cwZiva Kie bv, cqvRb Ab MvjwUI GwMq `vI Po gvivi Rb|Nvov`o cwZhvwMZvq wmv_ MZg wbR wRZj `e`i mv_ kZv evoeej wZwb `e`K wRwZq w`q wbR ni hvb| kZvi viv kZvi Dckg nqbv, GKgv gxZvi vivB kZvi Dckg me| mwnsm nqv bv, gxfve cvlYKi Ggb wkvq cvwQ wmv_ MZgi Rxebx _K| ZvB AvgivI ne Awnsmvi GKGKRb g~Z cZxK; mUjvi evOvwjiv RevB KijI eje- gx, gx, gx|mUjviiv evwo my cyiv cvovwU Rvwjq w`jI eje- gx, gx, gx| Avkv Ki

51

_vKe mUjviiv Zv`i KZKgi kvw AekB cve| BnRbg bv njI ciRbAekB cve| Avi Avgv`i Gic gvbwmKZv `L kvmKMvx nvZZvwj `q, ej,mvevm Ry RbZv; GB gxfveUvK ai ivL, Aviv ewk ewk gxfve cvlYKi, hvZ Zvgv`iK asm KiZ Avgvi ewk eM cZ bv nq| gymwjg kvmKBL&wZqviDwb gynv` web eKwZqvi LjwR hLb fviZel AvgY Kib ZLb eagvbymvixiv mB AvgY cwZnZ Kivi Pv Kiwb Avi e wfzivI ey g~wZimvgb wQj avb gM| hvi dj BL&wZqvii Kvb mgmv nqwb kZ kZ e wfziwkiQ` KiZ| cieZxZ hviv euP wQj Zviv eva nq Bmjvg ag MnY AvievwKiv wgk hvq wn`y agi mv_ (Z_m~ : fviZ e agi Dvb Avi cZb)|

cveZ PMvgI Ry Avw`evmx RbMvxi Rb Ggb Kvb g~Z aq AvmQ bvZv? gx wbq ci _vKv e agvbymvix Ry`i KvQ ckwU Zvjv iBj| eZgvbe agvbymvix wKQz wKQz Ry`i ga gxfve GZB cej h, Giv gvbe `niRb wZKviK gkvwUI ch gvi bv| Ggb gxfve cvlYKvix GKRbi KvQcwZev`, cwZiva, cwZkva Avkv KivUv wbq evKvwgi cwiPvq| hLb KDZvgvi Ni-evwo Rvwjq w`Q, Zvgvi evbwUK alY KiQ ZLbI Ggb gxwbq ci _vKv bcysmKZvi cwiPq Qvov AbwKQz nZ cvi bv|

fviZel Aviv AbK AvM wewUk`i civaxbZv _K gy nZ cviZ; cviwbGKgv Awnsmvi gyLvkavix gnvZv Mvxi KviY| wZwb wQjb myweavev`x, wewUk`imvj GRU| hLb mviv fviZel Ryo wecex`i nvZ wewUkiv gvi LZ LZchy` wVK ZLbB Awnsmvi evYx wbq Avwefve NU gnvZv Mvxi| hvi KviYAv`vjb ci fvUv, nq hvq wwgZ| Mvx wewUk`i GRU wQjb ejBfviZeli ^vaxbZv msMvgi m~hmvb bZvwR myfvl P` emy, gvvi`v m~hmb,zw`ivgi gZ exi mbvbx`i AvLvwqZ KiwQjb mvmx wnme| ci RbMYAv Av dzum DVQ `L wewUkiv ZwoNwo Ki fviZel Qo Pj hvq AviMvxI nq IVb Awnsm Av`vjbi GK Ab bvg| fviZel ^vaxb nIqvi cQbMvxi Awnsm Av`vjb bq, g~j KviY wQj RbMYi gb `vbv evav AbK w`bivf (Z_m~ : MvxwRi AcKg)| eZgvb cveZ PMvg GKw`K Kicxgymwjg RbMvxi Dvb Avi Abw`K eb fv, b`cvj fv, DQvjv fv BZvw`fvi msck Gm Ry RbMvxi ga gxgq e agi wevi| dj RyAvw`evmxiv Av`vjb, msMvgi w`K bv SzuK, ewk SzuKQ e gw`i wMq cv_bvKivi w`K| GZ jvf nQ KZUzKz Zv Avgv`iK AekB fe `LZ ne|

eZgvb PvKgv ivRv evwivi `evkxl ivq GKevi ee w`Z wMq ejwQjb, cveZPMvg Adzi cvKwZK mc` bv _vKZ cvi wK hv AvQ mB mc`i h_vh_eenvi hw` Avgiv wbwZ KiZ cvwi Zvnj cveZ PMvgK weki DbZ knijvi

5226

gZ kwkvjx A_bwZK wfwi GKwU GjvKvq cwiYZ KiZ ewk w`b mgq jvMebv| nuv, Avgiv hw` Avgv`i cvKwZK mc`i h_vh_ eenvi wbwZ KiZ cvwiZvnj AekB ewk w`b mgq jvMe bv cveZ PMvgK GKwU kwkvjx A_bwZKwfwi GKwU GjvKvq cwiYZ KiZ| djR evMvb, Jlwa MvQi evMvb, kvK-mewRiZ KiZ ne| Kvb Rwg hb cwZZ bv _vK mB w`K bRi w`Z ne| hBRwgZ hv DchvMx Zv Pvl KiZ ne| cveZ PMvg h cvnvo, eb iqQ mLvbNvmi h_ cvPzhZv iqQ| Nvmi GB cvPzhZvK KvR jvwMq Avgiv Mi, QvMjiLvgvi cwZv KiI gv KqK eQii ga cyiv cveZ PMvgi Pnviv cvwq w`Zcvwi| wK GLvbI ev` maQ e ag| fviv ejQb, cvYx eemv gnvcvc| ageuvPj RvZ euvPe| ZvB Avgiv Mi, QvMj, nuvm, gyiwM cvjb Kie bv| wcR, agKAb cvk mwiq ivLyb| ag euvPj KLbvB RvZ euvP bv, RvZ euvPjB bv Ze agcvjb Kivi gvbyl _vKe| Avi RvZB hw` bv euvP Zvnj agUv cvjb Kie K?fviZ cej civg cwZv cvIqv e agi `xc AvR Kb wbfz wbfz mB BwZnvm_K wkv wbZ ne Avgv`i| Zv bvnj Ry RvwZi asm Awbevh| RvwZi AwZivi cqvRbB Avgv`iK Gjv KiZ ne|

AvR Aewa Ry`i gvS Zgb Kvb D`vv eemvqx mw nq wb| Ry`i gvSD`vv eemvqxiv u`vZi gvRbi Mw AvR Aw civZ cviwb| eemvq bvgviAvM `wL Kvb eemvUv eZgvb evRvi PjQ ewk; hvPvB evPvB Ki Avgiv mBeemvq Svc gvwi| wbRi gav Avi eyw LvwUq Avgiv bZzb Kvb eemv DvebKiZ cvwi bv; ZvB D`vv mw _K hvq AaivB| AvM G`ki KD wPvIKiwb cvwb wew nZ cvi| A_P wgbvij IqvUvii evZj AvR Avgv`iwbZmx| AvM G`ki KD wPvI Kiwb gvbyli Pzji wewKwKwb nZ cvi|A_P AvR Pzj w`q ciPzjv Zwi Ki we`k ivwb nQ| AvM G`ki KDwPvI Kiwb `LjB Mv wNbwNb Kiv KuPvi eemv nZ cvi| A_P AvR KuPvieemv Ki Lyjbvi GKRb KuPv Pvlx jvL UvKvi gvwjK| AvM G`ki KDwPvI Kiwb KPz jwZ we`k ivwb Ki KvwU UvKv Avq Kiv me| A_P GLbcwZ eQi we`k KPz jwZ ivwb Ki KvwU UvKv e`wkK gy`v Avq nQ| AvMG`ki KD wPvI Kiwb ivbvi ci dj `Iqv QvB wew nZ cvi| A_PAvR XvKvq MvgxY QvBqi cvKU KwR `i wew nQ ``vim| Zvnj Avgv`iRy`i ga Kb D`vv mw ne bv? wPvI Kib, gv_vUvK KvR jvMvb| GgbGKUv eemv Dveb Kib hv evRvi Pje fvj A_P AvR Aw mB eemvZ KDnvZ `qwb| ebcvYx msib AvBbi GKwU wewaZ nwiYi evwYwRK Lvgvivcbi K_v ejv nqQ| ebcvYx msiY AvBbi wewa gvZveK Pj evsjv`kmiKvii KvQ _K jvBm wbq nwiYi Lvgvi vcb Kiv hvq wKbv hvPvB Ki

53

`Lyb| mg Avjy (Kvmvfv) w`q Ab Kvb wKQz cZ Kiv hvq wKbv fveyb|Kii gvsm cwqvRvZ Ki we`k ivwb Kiv hvq wKbv hvPvB Kib| cwZ eQimsiYvMvii Afve cPzi cwigvY Avg, KuvVvj, Avbvim b nq hvq| ZvB cveZPMvg GKwU msiYvMvi vcb Kivi K_v weePbv Kib| cveZ PMvgi b`xAvi Qivwj nvBWv-BjKwUK cvIqvi cvU vcbi c AZ DchvMx| ZvBGBme LimvZv Qivq QvU AvKvii nvBWv-BjKwUK cvIqvi cvU emvbvi K_vwPv Kib| gvUK_v D`vM wbb, Dvv nvb| A_bwZK gyw Qvov Av`vjbhgb MwZ cve bv, Zgwb mvnvhKvix kwi ejq _K ewoq AvmvI me nebv| Avgiv Ryiv Pviw`K AbK AbyciYvi M wb, cwo Avi AbycvwYZI nBwK mB AbyciYvi Mwj eve Rxeb KvR bv jvMvB bv dj eemvZ bvgvi^c ^cB _K hvq| Avgv`iK GBme AbyciYvi M _K wkv wbq evegvV bvgZ ne, KiZ ne ^ci mv_K evevqb| wbgi RvZKwU AbKBcoQb, nqZv GLbv AbKB cob wb| hviv cyuwR wbq wPv KiQb, hviveemvZ bvgeb ej wPv KiQb Zv`i AbyciYvi Drm nvK wbPi GBRvZKwU; RvZKwU cvVKi Rb msw AvKvi Zzj aijvg|

Pzjkx RvZKcyivKvj e` ivRvi mgq evwam GK kx cwievi RbMnY Kib| ZLbwZwb Pzjkx Dcvwa cvb| wZwb cig wevb I eywgvb wQjb Ges Mn bi Ae vb`L MYbv KiZ cviZb| GKw`b ivR`kb KiZ hvIqvi mgq c_ GKwU gZBu y`i `L ej DVjb, hw` Kvb meskRvZ ew GB gZ Bu`yi Zzj wbq hvqZvnj m eemvq DbwZ Kie| GB mgq f ` eski GK wbt^ hyeK evwami GBK_v b gZ Bu y`iwU Zzj wbjb| GB mgq GK `vKvb`vi Zvi cvlv weovji RbLvevi LyuRwQj| m GK cqmv `vg w`q hyeKi KvQ _K Bu`yiwU wKbj| hyeK ZLbGK cqmvi o wKb Avi GK Kjwm Rj wbq h c_ gvjvKviiv eb nZ dzj Zzjdi mB c_ em iBjb| gvjvKviiv Kvfve mLvb Gm emj hyeKwU Zv`icZKK GKcv Rj I GKUz Ki o LZ w`j| Zv Lq Z nq gvjvKviivcZK GK gyVv Ki dzj w`j| hyeKwU ZLb mB dzj wew Ki Aviv ewk owKb ciw`b evRvi wMq gvjvKvi`iK o I Rj LvIqvj| gvjvKviiv ZLbZvK KZwj dzU dzji MvQ w`j| GBfve dzj I dzji MvQ wew Ki Pviw`bigaB Zvi AvU UvKv cyuwR nj| Zvici GKw`b Lye So-ew nj ivRvi evMvbiAbK MvQi Wvjcvjv fO cij| evMvbi gvjx mBme Wvjcvjv GKv cwiviKiZ cviwQj bv| Zvici hyeK gvjxi KvQ wMq ejj, Zzwg hw` AvgvK webvg~jGBme Wvjcvjv w`q `vI Zvnj Avwg evMvb cwivi Ki `e| gvjx ZvZ ivwRnq Mj| hyeK ZLb cvovi Qj`i GKUz Ki o LZ w`q ejj, Zvgiv Avgvi

5427

m Gm, evMvbUv cwivi Ki w`B| Qjiv Lywk nq hyeKi m Wvjcvjv cwiviKi ivvq Gb Rov Ki ivLj| KzKviiv KvVi Afve nuvwo-Kjwm cyoZcviwQj bv| Zviv bM` lvj UvKv I wKQz nuvwoi wewbgq Wvjcvjvwj wKb wbj|mg LiP ev` w`q hyeKi ZLb Pwek UvKv nvZ iBj| ZLb evivYmxZ cuvPkNmi evm KiZ| Nmoiv cwZw`b Nvm KvUZ hZ| GKw`b Nmoviv NvmKvUZ wMq wccvmvZ nq cij hyeK Zv`iK Rj LvIqvj| Nmoviv ejj, fvBZzwg Avgv`i GZ DcKvi KiQ, ej Avgiv Zvgvi wK DcKvi KiZ cvwi? hyeKejj, GLb bq, cqvRb nj eje| Gi ga hyeKi m GK jc_ ewYK I GKRjc_ ewYKi eyZ nq| GKw`b jc_ ewYK hyeKK Rvbvj, Kvj GK AkweZvbMi cuvPk Ak wbq Avme| GB K_v b hyeK Nmo`i KvQ wMq ejj,fvBme Zvgiv Kvj cZK AvgvK GK AuvwU Ki Nvm `e Avi Avgvi Nvm wewkl bv nj Zvgiv KD Nvm wew Kie bv| Nmoviv hyeKi K_vgZ KvR Kij|Ak eemvqx Kv_vI Nvm bv cq hyeKi KvQ _K GK nvRvi UvKv `vg w`qcuvPk AuvwU Nvm wKb wbj| GKw`b Rjc_ ewYK Rvbvj, AvMvgxKvj GKwU eoRvnvR gvjc wbq e`i Avme| hyeK ZLb w`b fvovq GKwU Mvwo wbq ZvZPo e`i wMq DcwZ nj| mLvb m RvnvRi me gvjci `vg wVK KiwbRi bvgvwZ AvswU w`q evqbv Kij| A_vr mB RvnvRi Kvb gvjvgvj wKbZnj Zvi KvQ _KB wKbZ ne| hyeKwU Gevi e`i Zuvey LvwUq wkwei KiKqKRb AbyPi wbq _vKZ jvMj| m Zvi AbyPi`i ej w`j, Kvb ewYK Zvimv_ `Lv KiZ Avmj hb GKRb GKRb Ki wZbRb Av`vwj m wbq wfZiAvbv nq| Gw`K e`i eo RvnvR GmQ b cvq GKkv ewYK e`i GmDcw Z nq| wK Gm bj Kvb GK gnvRb GKvB mg gvjvgvj evqbv KiQb|ZLb Zviv LuvR wbq hyeKi wkwei Gm DcwZ nj| ewYKiv hyeKi wkweiGm wkweii NUv Avi Av `vwji QovQwo `L fvej, GB hyeK wbq AZzj mc`iAwaKvix| Zviv GK GKRb Ki hyeKi mv_ `Lv Kij Ges gvji GK GK Askcvevi Rb GK nvRvi UvKv jvf w`Z ivwR nj| Zvici hyeKi wbRi h Ask wQjmB AskI GK j UvKv jvf wew Ki w`j| hyeK `yBj UvKv jvf KievivYmxZ wdi Mj| Gfve mB hyeK GKwU giv Bu`yi w`q eemv i Ki gvPvi gvmi ga wecyj ab jvf Kij| ci mB hyeK evivYmxi gnvkxi LZveARb Kib (Z_m~ : RvZK mgM)|

55

divmyga Zvcm PvK&gv

evev nA&gj NiZ Ge? (evev evwo Avmwe Ke?)

gvi Kvgj Mjv dvbi Icvk _K Ai Ai PvL wfwRq `q| eQiLvbKbvwK ewk? H `~i cvnvokwY cwiq evwo hvIqv nqbv KZw`b? A wbRI fzjMQ|

Ai gb Avevi bZzb Ki Awi nq IV| Dd! Nii `iRvq Kw`b cv cowb!Avnv H meyR cvnvomvwi `Lv nq bv Kw`b ai, nvBwKs nq bv ey`i mv_| eb-cvnvoi DuPzwbPz ivvq nuU Mvg hvIqvi w`bjv Ai PvL fvm| A QzUQNii A`~i ivRwb evci evMvb, Zvov KiQ Qv gy-Bw_Kv-eMviv| kv kvevZvm fm AvmQ Avgi M| A AvgMvQi wbP u`vwoq _vK| Sov evZvmAvav Auvavi Uzc Uzc Ki Avg co Avi m BQgZ Kzovq| Kzobv kl njivRwb evci wfUq BU gi fv-`o `q ARvbvi Dk...

fvi mKvj fvix Kzqvkvi ga nuvUv Ii cyibv Afvm| evk gyL nuvUZ nuvUZm GKjv Pj hvq Pwek gvBj| GB GjvKvUv AbK ~`i| wbRb GKwU Piv vigvo| GLvb em A wKQzY wekvg bq Avi Acv Ki w`bi c_g evmiRb| cKwZ kv| gvS gvS `~i `yGKUv PbvRvbv cvwL WK IV| GB WvKAi wPiPbv; vb nIqvi ci _K GB WvKjv cwZw`b kvbv nq| hb cigcwZekx GB cvYxjv!

gvoi Wvbcvk GK wekvj wUjvi Dci AvgW cywjk evUvwjqb Kvc evm KiMvUv `kK wmcvnx| wUjvi AbK wbP gvoi mgZj GK cyKzi| `k ^vaxbnqQ PwjkiI AvM| A eySZ cvi bv AvRI Pwjk eQi ci GB AR cvov-Muvq wewUk Avgji H Kvc Kb iLQ miKvi! GLvb PzwiPvgvwi bB WvKvwZiAvkvI bB| GLvb _K _vbv m`i Lye `~i h ZvI bq| ZviciI Ggb GKUvGjvKvq AvavmvgwiK cywjki jvj Wm Kb? ePviv`i Ni`vi AbK `~i,C`i QzwUZI evwoi gyL `Lv hvq bv| Kvc em gvwQ gviv Kvb KvR bB| cvwbAvbZ Mj evbvbv wmuwoi 267 avc eq bvgZ nq| GZ LvwUq gi AKRb

5628

jvKK eveyivg miKvi GLvb ivLjv Kb? Mj eQi GK eyov mcvB Ri giMj| eyovi mv_ Ai A^ LvwZiI wQj| `ki evwoi M kvbvZ AK,cvnvo cievmx eyovi gyL mgZji M| ePviv kl Rxeb KvcB gi Mj!Ai e K jvM jvKUvi K_v gb coj|

elvKvj evwoi mvgb aevi cvwb Gm nWgvvi`i wekvj Z Wze wej nqhvq| A muvZvi Rvb bv| wKkvi A Wze givi fq fzj bKv wbq GKvB bvgkvcjv-WvUvi c MoZ| H WvUvi ^v` fvjv, fvRj Kjwgi PqI gRvi| Afvjv bvI evBZ Rvb| `Z m WvUv Kzwoq PvivB wUci BwZ Ub cevcibKv NvU wfovq| cevc RvZ-wkKvwi Ges RvZ-gvZvj `yUvB| B` (duv`)cZ eMv aiZ GjvKvq Zuvi mgK KD bB| Zuvi bvI Pzwi Ki dvI wUc giavjvB Lvqwb Ggb fvjv Kcvj Amn Aviv wUKqK QvKivi AvQ!

elvi evwK mgqUv QzwUZ m GK bvbvi evwoZ KvUvq| cvnvoi AbK fZii`yMg bvbvi evwoZ we`yr bB| Pxi Rj Mwoq mB Mvgi cvk w`q eqAbK `~i wgkQ KvvBqi Avavi| b`x GLvb mvMii gZv| gvS QvU QvUxc| mLvb AbK bKv, AbK xc| xc xc Ni, xc xc `vKvbcvU-zj| muvZvivbk~b Ai fq Ki bv| bvbvi bKv wbq m GKK xc Nyieovq GKv GKv| Kv_vI GK `vKvb kKj euvav evbi wbq evPv`i cejAvMn PvL co| Kv_vI GKwU wUjvi Ni _K fm Avm g` I g`cvqxiRovbv Mjvi Avjvc| A Kv_vI bvg bv, bKv eq mvgb PjZ _vK| GBb`xi ivvq GK Qv xc Kvb Ni bB| Kej AvQ wbRb QvUeb Avi `wLbvnvIqvi b| A hve mLvbB, mB wbRb ivR| Qv eb Kvb kiAZvPvi bB evK bB ay evZvm Avi cKwZi Mvbi gMZv| A Wze hvq mBMvb Qo RMZi me Avjqvq...

H nvjv wK nBj Zvi? PvPxi dvb bvwK? evmvq hvBZvQm ZvBj?

hv GZY Kv_vq cowQjvg! eyi wZb ck dvkevK _K A di eve|AvRB evmi wUKU KvUZ ne| Ni hvIqv nQ, AbKw`b ci...

57

wkwki PvKgvi KweZvKP D aye wmeyw`

PvZ gvP `vOv hBq Rygi AvivPvM wbAvjwS KvRB aeaevevRMi cg jvweqw` Sii bvbBq gvw`` eKzqvP _OKzP`gZzj Div KvjP gNi nvivPvwb bvLvP MvwiRyex bs b bs nv`i evOwi Sbvr Sbvr MvwiKvwej nv&` evevq KzigvZ, RjRvj mbviO exRavb gvw` D`b PbO PbOeywb hvq GMg AvISi Avev ^ebi Ryg fyB|

G qj RygLZ, KvRvq KvRvq c`bv eb, jKjv R`bv MvP&, jjg cv`vRvOvj kvK, eyKcvw` wbwMjgv _yi, cvMvbv wmw`iZ wmgcyK, ARvi eyMZmy`vnjv dzj, nj Z`K SvK, mbviO dz m`iMZ wbjvR ZOZOvwi Avcvcwi wbP bvP|

G Ryg gi, B`vi _yiZ Ryg, ^ebZ Ryg, G gvw` qj Svi giG Qov MvO KjM jvOj gievwh _vbv G RygZ givbvI G RygZ bq` Kb GK KjMZ bq` Kb GK jvOjZ|

LvwjK ^ebvwb BiK KvRKvevP wc`vji iOi AviK mvSwbP gqvjvB gviBqv ^ebvwb Zc cvP qj KP& D gyivDbi KvbRvevZevwi LB LB iMvwb Aq|

Pvzbi civw` Kgj qj gyivDbyb qj KP Dw` cyi D AjvKcivb civb evb, Rv` Rv` evb, POB gqvwb KvRjO `RKzj evb,G wLP evb wQwb hB ejejvZ mw` fvOv wQbKz`vK P`i wgjvi AviK dzw` D|

^ebvwb fv` Avwhb gvP wQbK Kz`vK fyjs dzjv`M mv`vOv GKcvj`wMbevqi Dwo hvq,g KweZv wjwMevi AvMgywjg iPj, miOKvwb Av mRc`ivwb Avvq Ki e`g KweZv wjwMevi wZivPvwb AB Da cvjO avP fvP& wgjvi mZcv ewbRPgKweZv wjwMevi Z^vi AvIPvwb AB Da kvgyK wmjvbi PMjvzb KP D ayewmeyw`|

5829

kvgyKi Lvjm _K ewiq Avmv Pzb

P gvm cvnvoi eb cywoq Avev`i Rb Zwi Ryg cvnvoekvLi c_g Soi big gvwUZ DrmyK gvbyli c`wPDii eix KvjP gNi Ljv Dcv Ki Rywgqv igYxi Kvgj nvZi QvqvKvgoi Kzig, Zvi big nvZi k PbPwbq IV Kzig iwZ mvbviOavbexR, Gfve eyb hvq