human rights watch - report on arakan situation - totally wrong!

7/30/2019 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH - report on Arakan situation - totally wrong!

1/13

!"#$% '()*+, -$+.*

"##$%& ' ()%*+,-. "/ 0*,"12 34562 7-1%&

8/00 12" 3$% 42 (, 56$79

!"#$ &'( )("* +(,-..-., #/ &'-0 "(1#"& 2 &'( 3#)(" 2 &'-0 "(1#"& -0 ,"#004* 567(89

:;"# ,%*+,- "# 1"+,@'7+/2 /+ ,%1%F'/C%2 '/& /+ "@*+,-'/C%

C+/C%,/"/JT

5U :;% 5VW3 L'$/J&'B L'##'C,% O -;% +/1= @'##'C,% "/ -;"# C+/X"C- -;'- Y$'1"Z%# '# '

[%/+C"&%2 B;%,% -;% L$#1"@# -;% /%B J+F%,/@%/-2 B;+

B%,% #%/- -+ -'1< -+ -;% L$#1"@ 1%'&%,# B%,% @$,&%,%& G= -;%

;+#-# '- -;% B%1C+@% &"//%, -'G1%H

1
http://www.scribd.com/doc/137695956/Human-Rights-Watch-UNHCR-spreading-massive-misinformation-outright-lieshttp://www.scribd.com/doc/137695956/Human-Rights-Watch-UNHCR-spreading-massive-misinformation-outright-lies


2/13

6U :;% >+,@'7+/ +> ' L$^';"& ',@= "/ 5VW\2 B;"C; B'J%& J$%,,"11' B',2 C+/7/$"/J -+ -;%

*,%#%/-2 '/& ;'# ;'& -,'"/"/J '/& >$/&"/J >,+@ N'$&" 0,'G"'2 0>J;'/"#-'/2 R' ' *%+*1% -;'- "# #-,"F"/J -+ 1"F% "/ *%'C% B"-; -;% M$&&;"#-#2

G$- ,'-;%, ' *%+*1% B;+ ;'F% /+ Y$'1@# 'G+$- %1"@"/'7/J -;% /+/OL$#1"@# G= '/= @%'/#*+##"G1%UH

WU:;% 5Vaa 'b%@*- -+ &%#-'G"1"E% -;% B;+1% C+$/-,= '/& #%"E%

0,'


3/13

\U :;% ;',& &,"F%# >+$/& &$,"/J -;% C'*-$,% '/& f#'@' G"/O_'&%/2 #;+B"/J '/&

*,+F"/J -,'"/"/J '/& 1"/ 0,'


4/13

S/ *+J,+@# 'J'"/#- -;% M$&&;"#-# "/ 5VW32 5VW\2 5Vd32 -;% 5Ve4#2 5Va4#2 5V\\2 5VV52 34452

'/& 3453 -;% L$#1"@# G$,/%& ;$/&,% +> M$&&;"#-# F"11'J%# '/& *',7C$1',1= -',J%-%& '/&

&%#-,+=%& M$&&;"#- -%@*1%# '/& @+/'#-%,"%#H J'-0 -0 7'6& (&'.-3 34(6.0-., -0H

0/& '11 +> -;"# B'# "/ -;% 1'/& -;'- B'# /%',1= 544j M$&&;"#- >+, @'/= @'/= C%/-$,"%#H

:;% M$&&;"#- &"& /+- O /+B2 '/& &"& /+- ;"#-+,"C'11= O J+ "/-+ -;% L$#1"@ 1'/ '/& -,= -+

C+/Z#C'-% -;%", 1'/& '/& -,= -+ "/7@"&'-% '/& %1"@"/'-% -;% L$#1"@#H M$-2 -;'- "# B;'- -;%

L$#1"@# ;'F% &+/% O '/& -;%= -;"/< -;%= ',% %/7-1%& -+ -;% M$&&;"#-# 1'/&2 '/& -;%= +/1= ;'F%

C+/-%@*- >+, -;% M$&&;"#- *%+*1% '/& ,%1"J"+/ O G%C'$#% -;%", +B/ ,%1"J"+/ -%'C;%# -;%@ -+

/+- ,%#*%C- -;% /+/OL$#1"@# C$1-$,% '/& ,%1"J"+/2 '/& -+ +, J%P/J ,"& +> "/Z&%1# "/ '/= B'=

0/&2 -+ -;% L$#1"@#2 ?"/&$# '/& M$&&;"#-# ',% %F%/ B+,#% -;'/ I;,"#7'/ '/& A%B# O G%C'$#%

>$/&'@%/-'1 -+ S#1'@ "# -;% G%1"%> "/ +/% [+&2 '/& +/1= +/% O '/& -;%,% #;+$1& G% /+

,%*,%#%/-'7+/ +> ;"@ O /+ #-'-$%#2 /+ *'"/7/J#2 /+ *;+-+#H

K#L 7( M.#7 2 N;0& /"#$ &'( OP 7#"80 #. &'( 3#)(" &'6& &'-0 7-44 +( 0-3M(.-.,4* #.(20-8(89

C#7L Q(&E0 #1(. &'( ';,(4* 567(8 >"(1#"&E9 RSE$ ;0-., &'( 0'#"& )("0-#. 2 OO 16,(0T

@.E)B =!8= +9 =!B N*B#.*=O =!B*B +( 9BCB* 89K /B9E.9 .D =!B ;8P!+9B Q7--!+(=( +9 8 #.(+ECB &8K

: =!BK 8*B 8F&8K( #.*=*8KB- 8( =!B BC+FR ,+


5/13

J'( "(1#"& 06*0T FD"( !/)-3(* &G&/@1 2(*( &B&4+1) H-"4+B8& &+. I&7&+ J=1%47 /-77=+4>(1

&+. 2(*( -*B&+4C(.' 4+/4)(.' &+. /-774G(. 38 %-/&% $*&@&+(1( 0-%4>/&% 0&*)8 -0(*&>5(1' )"(

?=.."41) 7-+@"--.' &+. -*.4+&*8 $*&@&+(1(' &) >7(1 .4*(/)%8 1=00-*)(. 38 1)&)( 1(/=*4)8

A-*/(1:K

:;"# #-'-%@%/- "# #+ @"#1%'&"/J O "- -,"%# -+ @'+, -;% Z,%# -;'- &%#-,+=%& ' L$#1"@ *',- +> -;% C"-= O 'k%, L$#1"@# #-',-%& Z,%#

B;"C; -,'F%11%& -;% +**+#"-% B'= -;%/ -;% L$#1"@# "/-%/&%&T

!"#$%%&&&'()*+,-')./%-.)%0X0Y53L40%Z[V?Z:J6[?:T*7=!:+(:@.=:\,C+.7(

0/& ,%'& @+,% -.&(")-(70B"-; M$&&;"#- @+/,'@%,#2 -%'C;%,# %-CT

!"#$%%&&&'()*+,-')./%-.)%0152Y0G25%]9=B*C+B&(:^+.FB9)B

!"#$%%&&&'()*+,-')./%-.)%0152Y0G33%]9=B*C+B&(:_B8*

!"#$%%&&&'()*+,-')./%-.)%0152Y0G3L%]9=B*C+B&(:I.9P(:TBFF:.D:6.**.*(

!"#$%%&&&'()*+,-')./%-.)%0152Y0G2G%]9=B*C+B&(:;8P!+9B:^+B&(:.D:QB9%-C; Z,%B++&2 B'-%, '/& #$**1"%#2 G%C'$#% @%/ B%,% G%"/J '@G$#;%& '/& 'b'C &%'-; '/& &%#-,$C7+/H 0# +/% 'k%, '/+-;%, M$&&;"#-

F"11'J% B'# G$,/%& -;% @%/ B+$1& ;'F% -+ -'


6/13

VT f/ *'J%# \ '/& V -;%,% ',% *;+-+# +> C'*-$,%& )+;"/J=' C,"@"/'1# '/& @'/= @'/= @+,% +> -;%#% (G,'"/B'#;%& G= S#1'@. >'/'7C2

;%',-1%##2 @"/&1%## E+@G"%#H

WT :;% +$-G,%'< +> F"+1%/C% +/ A$/% \2 34532 "/ L'$/J&'B2 #;+$1& /+- G% &%#C,"G%& '# -;"# O

FL4-%(+/( 3()2((+ $*&@&+(1( ?=.."41)1 &+. H-"4+B8& 4+)(+14 L$#1"@# *+$, +$- +> -;% G"J C%/-,'1 @+#Y$% "/ L'$/J&'B '/& #B',@ $*

-;% #-,%%-#2 &%#-,+="/J '/&


7/13

YT f/ *'J% 5d "- ,%>%,# -+ -;% >'C- -;'- -;% M$&&;"#-# &"#1"'C- -;'- /$@%,+$# nD '/& +-;%, 'J%/C"%# *%,#+//%1 ;'F%

G%%/ C'$J;- '/& ',,%#-%& '/& &%*+,-%& >+, 'C-$'11= ;%1*"/J -;% )+;"/J=' B"-; J%P/J

B%'*+/# '/&o+, *1'//"/J 'b'C '11 /+/OL$#1"@# O B;"C; ;'# G%%/ -;%", &%C1',%& J+'1 >+, +F%, d4 =%',#2 #"/C%

M$,@'.# "/&%*%/&%/C%H

ZT 0- -;% %/& +> *'J% 5d -;% ,%*+,- @%/7+/# -;% *%,"+& +> 7@% ',+$/& -;% 3/&Q+,1& Q',2

IBJ :HSJK J?G IS[[GKJ SCFS\GCJ ASJ? J?G ?S[?GKJ CBHIG@ :! \GDJ?K J?DJ ?DK

?D]]GCG\ IGJAGGC J?G HBKQSHK DC\ IB\\?SKJKH J# 8(4-+("6&(4* 4(6)( &'-0 #;& -0 60

6+0;"8 60 -/ 0#$(#.( 7"#&( 6 "(1#"& 6+#;& :06$6 +-.2Q68(. &'6& 8#(0.E& $(.

L$#1"@# "@@"J,'/-# J,%'-1= "/C,%'#%& O '/& -;"# ',%'2 B;"C; ;'& ' #-,+/J M$&&;"#- "&%/7-=

>+, C%/-$,"%# ]%F"&%/C%& G= /$@%,+$# ,+C< C',F%& M$&&;"#- C'F% -%@*1%# "/ -;% @+$/-'"/#2

7


8/13

'/& 1',J% ,$"/%& C'*"-'1# +> M$&&;"#- M$&&;"#- "/ ' F%,=

#;+,- 7@%2 '/& G%C'@% /%',1= %/7,%1= L$#1"@ O '/& B"-; *1'/# -+ -'%,# -+ -;% 5Va\ (D'J'@"/. +*%,'7+/2 G$- -;% ,%*+,- >'"1%& -+ %F%/ @%/7+/ -;'-

-;% (D'J'@"/. C'@*'"J/ B'# 1'$/C;%& ,"J;- 'k%, -;"#T

S/ 5Vaa2 L$^';"& ,%G%1# '/& C+@@'/&%,# +> L$#1"@ @"1"7'# 1%& G= N$1-'/ L';@$&2 #%/-

#%1%C- @%@G%,# -+ _"G=' '/& @%- B"-; _"G='/ 1%'&%, I+1+/%1 `'&&'ZH ]`'&&'Z -;+$J;- +>

;"@#%1> '# -;% 1%'&%, +> -;% 0,'G L$#1"@# '/& "/ ;"# @%J'1+@'/"' ;% *,+^%C-%& ;"@#%1> '# -;%

1%'&%, +> L$#1"@# ',+$/& -;% B+,1&HU N$1-'/ L';@$&.# J,+$* %c*1'"/%& -;%", "/-%/7+/ B'# -+

-,'/#>+,@ 0,' ',,%#- +,

;',@ "/ @'/= M%/J'1" L$#1"@#2 '/& @'/= X%& G'C< -+ M'/J1'&%#;H

bT :;% ,%*+,- ,%>%,# -+ C"7E%/#;"* +/ *'J% 5eH

[-)-., &'( >@#'-.,*6E 3- *%+*1% B;+ ;'F% @+#-1= C+@%

"11%J'11=2 "/ ,%C%/- &%C'&%#2 '/& ',% 'C7F%1= *1+P/J 'J'"/#- -;% ;+#- C+$/-,=2 '/& %/J'J"/J "/

@"1"-',= '/& -%,,+,"#- -,'"/"/J -+ #%"E% -%,,"-+,= B"-; >+,C% -+ &%C1',% '# -;%", +B/ O '/& -;%=

;+*% -+ C+/F"/C% +-;%, L$#1"@ C+$/-,"%# -+ #%/& '/ S#1'@"C ',@= -+ ;%1* -;%@ '//";"1'-% -;%

M$&&;"#-#H :;% )+;"/J='2 '# ' C+11%C7F% %/7-=2 B'/- C"7E%/#;"*2 G$- qf Df: B'/- -+ 1"F% "/ -;%

J'-0 -0 d;#&(8 /"#$ 6 I"-


9/13

C+$/-,= +> M$,@'oL='/@', B;"C; "# J+F%,/%& '/& &+@"/'-%& G= "/Z&%1#H :;% )+;"/J=' B'/-

C"7E%/#;"*2 G$- Df: #+ -;%= C'/ ;'**"1= 1"F% B"-; +-;%, ,%1"J"+/# '/& %-;/"C"7%# ',+$/& -;%@2

'/& Df: #+ -;%= C'/ %/^+= '/& *',7C"*'-% "/ -;% +-;%, *%+*1%# >%#7F'1# '/& -,'&"7+/#H :;%=

B'/- C"7E%/#;"* #+ -;'- -;%= C'/ -;%/ qKL0Dq -;%", +B/ L$#1"@ N-'-% ]B;"C; B"11 Y$"C L$#1"@# -+ *$,">= -;%", 1'/& G= &,"F"/J -;% "/Z&%1# +$-2 '/& &%#-,+="/J -;%

,%@/'/-# +> -;% "/Z&%1 ;"#-+,=H 0/&2 "- #%%@# ?$@'/ )"J;-# Q'-C; B+$1& 1%- -;"# ;'**%/2 '/&

%F%/ %/'G1% -;% L$#1"@# -+ &%#-,+= ' ,%C+J/"E%& '/& ;"#-+,"C'1 M$&&;"#- *%+*1% '/& C$1-$,%2

'/& B+,1& C1'## ;"#-+,"C'1 #"-%#2 #$C; '# L,'$< nH

_T f/ *'J% 5a -;% ,%*+,- ,%>%,# -+ -;% ,%C%/- F"+1%/C% "/ L',C; +> 34562 #-',7/J "/ L%",+@ G%;"/& B"-; ' #B+,& '/& ;% >%11 +m -;% G'C< +> -;%

@+-+,G" ;"#

;%'&H ?% B'# #711 '1"F% '- -;'- *+"/-H q%#*"-% &%#*%,'-% *1%'# >+, @%,C= -;% L$#1"@# *$11%& ;"#

M$&&;"#- ,+G% +m '/& G,$-'11= &,'JJ%& -;% &%#*%,'-%1=OB+$/&%& M$&&;"#- @+/< "/-+ -;%

/%',G= L=+O@' L+#Y$%H f/C% "/#"&% -;% @+#Y$% -;%= -+,-$,%& ;"@ >$,-;%,2 '/& -;%= %F%/

%/C+$,'J%& #+@% +> -;% =+$/J L$#1"@


10/13

i+, M$&&;"#-#2 -+ ;',@ ' @+/,+@

-;% M$&&;"#-#H 0/& -;"# '"-; +> -;% L$#1"@# ;'# '/= #*","-$'1

Y$'1"7%# '- '112 +, "# "- ' >+,C% -;'- "# J+"/J -+ &%#-,+= -;% M$,@%#% C$1-$,%2 1'/& '/& *%+*1%H

:;"# "# ;+B @'/= M$,@%#% *%+*1% >%%1H

D+B2 1%- @% ,%@',< ;%,%T "> =+$ $J%%# X%%"/J >,+@ -;% ,%C%/-

F"+1%/C% '/& $/,%#- "/ )' -;% >'G,"C +> -;% /'7+/H

:;% M$,@%#% M$&&;"#-# %c*,%## -;'- -;% M%/J'1"OL$#1"@# ]'1#+ ,+@ )',+@ N'$&" 0,'G"' -;%=

;'F% G%C+@% -;% C+@@%,C"'11= &+@"/'/- J,+$* "/ L%" +-;%,#U '/& -;% #C;++1#

',% @+#- +k%/ %#-'G1"#;%& B"-; @+/%= '/& 'J%/&' >,+@ R'


11/13

:;% M$,@%#% M$&&;"#-# ',% '//+=%& G= -;% @+#Y$%# "/ @'/= *1'C%# O /+"#= 1+$& #*%'$/&%& #$*%,

@+#Y$%# G$"1- -+ -+B%, +F%, -;% Y$"%- '/& *%'C%>$1 M$&&;"#- -%@*1%# '/& @+/'#-%,"%#2

#-+C'C- -;'- @+#Y$%#

',% C1+#%& -+ /+/OL$#1"@# B;"C; "# #+ &"m%,%/- -;%/ -;% +*%/ &++,# +> -;% M$&&;"#-

-%@*1%#H:;'- "# B;'- @'/= M$,@%#% *%+*1% >%%1 'G+$- @+#Y$%#H

S 0&6.8 +* 7'6& S 7-44 06* '("(=?$@'/ )"J;-# Q'-C; "# &%1"G%,'-%1= -,="/J -+ C+F%, -;% -,$-;2

;"&% -;% ;"#-+,=2 '/& "# #;'*"/J -;% *$G1"C -+ #%% /+-;"/J J++& 'G+$- -;% )' *++, ,%#%',C; @%-;+ >+, ,%1="/J +/

rB"-/%##%# B;+#% #-+,"%# C'//+- G% F%,"Z%& '/& B;+ @'= -%#7>= >+, *+1"7C'1 '&F'/-'J% +,

G%C'$#% -;%= >%', ,%-'1"'7+/ >,+@ -;%", +B/ ,$1%,#H ?% >$,-;%, #-'-%#2 k?;$6. @-,'&0 A6&3' '6

4#0& 3"-,+@ ?$@'/ )"J;-# Q'-C; B'#

,%C%/-1= "/ N'$&" 0,'G"'H :+ "/F%#7J'-% -;% @"#-,%'-@%/- +> B+@%/ $/&%, N'$&" _'Bs :+

C'@*'"J/ >+, -;% ,"J;-# +> ;+@+#%c$'1#2 #$G^%C- -+ -;% &%'-; *%/'1-= "/ N'$&" 0,'G"'s :+ *,+-%#

-;% 1'C< +> ,%1"J"+$# >,%%&+@ "/ -;% N'$&" l"/J&+@s :+ "##$% ' ,%*+,- +/ N'$&" *+1"7C'1

*,"#+/%,#s D+2 /+2 /+2 '/& /+H :;% &%1%J'7+/ ',,"F%& -+ ,'"#% @+/%=2 '# -;%= ;'F% G%%/ &+"/J

>+, =%',#H9 ?)Q "# #-,+/J1= C,"7C"E%& >+, /+- ,%1%'#"/J -;% /'@%# +> "-# N'$&" &+/+,#H

f-;%, C,"7C# *+"/- +$-2 kD ';$6. "-,'&0 #",6.-c6'$1-= @%-;+&+1+J=r2 r@"#,%*,%#%/7/J "/-%,/'7+/'1 1'Br2 '/&

l+(-., ;.7-44-., #" ;.6+4( 1("3(-)( &'"(6&0 1#0(8 +* "68-364 S046$m9


12/13

And Human Rights Watch thinks it can judge whatshappening in Arakan?

Their false, manipulative, deceptive, demonizing report is causing death and destruction.

HRW should be put before International Courts and charged with malicious deceit and

conspiracy to cause harm resulting in death to innocent civilians.

I would be happy to testify against them.

Rick Heizman, San Francisco, May 12, 2013

A2#: #26: B(9:2, +2 ,::@

A young Rakhine girl tells of escaping while others, including her family were beaten to death:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QvLLJo2C3jM&feature=BFa&list=PL43A5C1DC4DAEE467

2 Rakhine boys tell of the horrors of the Rohingya killing the Buddhist:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0DGG8L3i9Y&feature=BFa&list=PL43A5C1DC4DAEE467

An old monk tells of he, monks, and laypeople trying to escaping the huge gangs of muslims, surrounded byarmed muslims the monk had to fight for the first time in his life as he saw the mobs killing Buddhist peopleincluding women and kids:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yc3y43gUF_8&feature=related

Fake videos and pictures try to show the Rohingya as the victims - easily proven false:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TCXOMBgFno&feature=relmfu

Fake Media part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xn2IXY9FNd0&feature=channel&list=UL

A Muslim woman School Teacher tells of the killings she saw committed by the 'Bangali Muslims' (Rohingya).She is Kaman Muslim (local Muslim, not Rohingya), and she tells of the fanatic hatred the Rohingya have, evenagainst the Kaman muslims, she also had to escape or they would kill her. She says (in her words) theRohingya have a terrible evil in them and it will not change - they do not know compassion or tolerance -andthey intend to kill or push away ALL Buddhist, Hindus, and others around them.This brings up the point that Kaman Muslims are recognized as a minority group in Rakhine State and in therest of Burma, and they are generally accepted because they live peacefully and are an integrated part of theculture.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FspYrhXTegE&feature=endscreen

Rakhine School Teacher tells of the slaughter of the Buddhist in June 2012http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GxaF2WRDRBk

A Burmese man, speaking good English, who founded an organization called Youth Development Association,in Maungdaw describes Friday June 8, 2012 when hundreds and hundreds of 'Bangali Muslims' (Rohingya)poured out of the mosques, armed with weapons, and surged down the main streets killing any Buddhist theycould catch - including women and children - and burning the homes and shops and the Buddhistmonasteries.When his father was young Maungdaw was almost all Buddhist. After many massacres it is now 95% Muslim,and the leaders and imams of the muslims are inciting the killing of the 30,000 remaining Buddhist in thetownship, and the destruction of their homes, temples and monasteries.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Cv62cx7mX8&feature=related

R1%'#% #%% ' ,%C%/- *'*%, S B,+-% 'G+$- ?$@'/ )"J;-# Q'-C;T >?;$6. @-,'&0 A6&3' and

B.-&(8 C6


13/13

human rights watch - report on arakan situation - totally wrong!

Documents