icu beds: do bed numbers drive care? · potential admissions… accepted refused 56 yo m, liver...

30
Hannah Wunsch, MD MSc Herbert Irving Assistant Professor of Anesthesiology & Epidemiology Department of Anesthesiology, College of Physicians & Surgeons Department of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health Columbia University ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care?

Upload: others

Post on 09-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Hannah Wunsch, MD MSc Herbert Irving Assistant Professor of Anesthesiology & Epidemiology

Department of Anesthesiology, College of Physicians & Surgeons Department of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health

Columbia University

ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care?

Page 2: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

COI/Funding

• No Conflicts of Interest

• Grant funding from NIA/NIH, Columbia University

Page 3: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Yes

Page 4: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Not going to talk about…

Individual bed in an individual ICU

Page 5: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

ICU beds driving care at the individual level…

Stelfox et al Arch Int Med 2012

Page 6: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Stepping back…

Page 7: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Many aspects of ‘bed numbers’

• ICU beds as an absolute number

• ICU beds per capita

• ICU beds as a percentage of hospital beds

• Distribution of beds (across a region)

• Types of beds

Page 8: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Many aspects of ‘bed numbers’

• ICU beds as an absolute number

• ICU beds per capita

• ICU beds as a percentage of hospital beds

•Distribution of beds (across a region)

•Types of beds

Page 9: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

How many beds do we have?

Page 10: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Bed numbers (per capita)

Wunsch et al CCM 2008 Wunsch et al CCM 2008

Page 11: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

The question of “definition”

• ICU

• CCU

• Intermediate ICU

• PACU

Page 12: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Difference in beds

United Kingdom

United States

Page 13: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

UK and US ICU

UK: • Level 3: 1:1 nurse to patient ratio, ability to provide

mechanical ventilation

• Level 2: 1:2 nurse to patient ratio, ability to provide single organ support (except mechanical ventilation)

US: • Mostly 1:2 nurse to patient ratio, ability to provide

mechanical ventilation

Page 14: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

How does care differ?

Page 15: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Who gets admitted?

Page 16: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Occupancy across 97 US ICUs

0

20

40

60

80

100

2005 2006 2007

Year

% IC

U b

ed

oc

cu

pa

nc

y

ICU patients

Mechanically ventilated ICU patients

168 per. Mov. Avg. (ICU patients)

168 per. Mov. Avg. (Mechanically ventilated

ICU patients)

Wunsch et al, CCM 2013

Page 17: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

VA System

Chen et al Arch Int Med 2012

53.2% of patients admitted to the ICU from the ER had a predicted mortality of <2%

Page 18: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Triage decisions:

Wunsch et al AJRCCM, 2011

No MV

Page 19: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Severity of illness of patients in the ICU

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55

APACHE II score

% o

f p

ati

en

ts

US

UK

Wunsch et al, AJRCCM 2011

UK US

Page 20: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

‘Delays’ in admission

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

All

Hem

orrh

agic

shoc

k

Res

pirat

ory in

fect

ion

Pos

t car

diac

arre

st

Pul

monar

y em

bolism

Toxic

or ch

emic

al p

oisonin

g

Ane

urysm

/PVD

Neu

rolo

gical

hem

orrhag

e

GI b

leed

Sei

zure

s

Alle

rgic

reac

tion

Dia

betic

ket

oaci

dosi

s

Hea

d trau

ma

Ove

rdose

Traum

a

% a

dm

itte

d d

ire

ctl

y f

rom

ER

US - no MV

US - MV

UK - no MV

UK - MV

Wunsch et al AJRCCM 2011

GI Bleeds Post CPR

Page 21: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

‘Risk’ adjusted hospital mortality for ICU patients

Adjusted Odds Ratio for hospital mortality (UK compared with US)

0.1 1 10

Whole cohort*

MV only

MV and admit from ER

Wunsch et al AJRCCM 2011

Page 22: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

RCT data

>70% of deaths occurred without intubation &

mechanical ventilation

Page 23: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

ICU use among hospital deaths

Wunsch et al AJRCCM 2009

Page 24: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Back to this…

Page 25: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Death in England?

“Kingsley [Amis] has ‘the old man’s friend’: pneumonia. He is on morphine and antibiotics. When pneumonia recurs, which it will, the morphine will remain but the antibiotics will go. This is the English way…” - Martin Amis

Page 26: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Braintree Hospital, 1949

Page 27: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

ICU use among hospital deaths

Wunsch et al AJRCCM 2009

Page 28: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Potential admissions…

Accepted Refused

56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

66 yo M, metastatic cholangiocarcinoma, septic shock on floor from drain change, pH 6.9, lactate 15, bicarbonate 5

103 yo M, in OR for hip pinning for fractured femur, briefly bradycardic to HR of 30s prior to induction,

surgery cancelled

72 yo F, cancelled whipple due to metastatic disease, 2 days later with ARDS, 100% O2 with 88% O2 sat

58 yo M, in OR for whipple. Minimal blood loss, no complications

87 yo F, severe dementia, negative ex lap for possible SBO, urosepsis, no vasopressors

Page 29: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Conclusions

• ICU beds do drive care

• Cannot dis-entangle this from the cultural acceptance/preferences that also drive care

– Currently, this driver only goes one-way over time

• Individual ICU/hospital variation may shift you one direction or the other

(probably less than you think)

Page 30: ICU beds: Do bed numbers drive care? · Potential admissions… Accepted Refused 56 yo M, liver transplant 4 days prior, large GI bleed on the general ward, hypotensive, tachycardic

Thank you!

[email protected]