31Aug99

IEEEIEEEStandards Association Standards Association

IEEE, ETSI, and Bluetooth MeetingAugust 31, 1999

Monarch Hotel Washington DC USA

Richard J. Holleman, IEEE-SA Standards Board Chairman

31Aug99

Meeting Goal & Agenda

Goal– The goal of the meeting would be to see to that there

is a possibility for the three of us (Bluetooth, ETSI and IEEE) to cooperate and to write down an action list.

Agenda 5:00pm to 8:00pm– Short update and participants goals– How could IEEE, ETSI and Bluetooth cooperate to

reach goals– What are the related next steps

31Aug99

IEEE: An Overview

IEEE Established in 1884 (AIEE & IRE) IEEE Dec98 Membership was 334,811; 66%

USA & 33% Non-USA IEEE produces 30 percent of the world's

published literature in electrical engineering, computers and control technology,

IEEE holds annually more than 300 major conferences and

IEEE has more than 800 active standards with 700 under development.

31Aug99

IEEE 802 Interfaces

31Aug99

IEEE 802 Organization

802.3CSMA/CD

Geoff Thompson

802.4TOKEN BUS

Paul Eastman

802.5TOKEN RING

Bob Love

802.6DQDB WAN

Jim Mollenauer

802.7BROADBAND(802.14 Res)

802.8FIBER TAG

Chip Benson

802.9ISLAN

Dhad. Vamen

802.10SECURITYKen Alonge

802.11WIRELESSVic Hayes

802.12DEMAND PRIORITY

Pat Thaler

802.14CABLE-TV

Robert Russell

802.1BRIDGING/ARCH

Bill Lidinsky

802.2LLC

Dave Carlson

WORKING GROUP CHAIRS

VICE CHAIRPaul Nikolich

RECORDING SECHoward Frazier

TREASURERBob Grow

EXECUTIVE SECBuzz Rigsbee

EXEC OFFICERSCHAIR

Jim Carlo

LMSC SPONSOR

Hibernation

Active

Active

802.15WPAN

Bob Heile

802.16BWA

Roger Marks

31Aug99

IEEE 802 Status (Aug1999)

802.1 VLAN Approved (802.1)Q 802.2 Hibernation 802.3 1000BASE-T Approved, 10G Study Group Underway 802.4 Hibernation 802.5 High Speed Token Ring 802.6 Hibernation 802.7 Hibernation 802.8 Fiber Guidelines Ballot 802.9 Hibernation 802.10 Hibernation 802.11 Higher Speed Activity Underway 802.12 Hibernation 802.14 WG Draft Ballot, Advanced PHY PAR 802.15 WPAN Task Group, Coexistence Study Group and Marketing Committee

Underway 802.16 Broadband Access Projects (LMDS). This will also have ETSI coordination

31Aug99

IEEE P802.15 Organization

A d visory C ore

C oexis ten ce S tu d y G rou p (S G )

S tu d y G rou p s

M an ag m en t E n tityL L C S u b layerM A C S u b layerP H Y L ayer

S u b Task G rou p s

Task G rou p 1 (TG 1 )

Task G rou p s

M arke tin g C om m ittee (M C )

C om m ittees

P 8 0 2 .1 5 W G

W G C h a ir

S p on sorIE E E 8 0 2

31Aug99

IEEE 802 Standards Process

You are here

31Aug99

Task Group 1 Update

Where What When

31Aug99

Where - TG1 is here

~Jun97 - Idea for standard Mar98 - Find Sponsor Feb99 - Submit PAR Mar99 - Approve PAR Jul99 - Organize working

group Sep99 - Develop draft

standard ? - Ballot draft standard ? - Approve draft standard ? - Publish approved

standard

You are here

31Aug99

What - TG1 is here

Write scope and purpose

Examine related standards and publications

Draft outline Fill in outline Revise, revise, revise Finalize document

You are here

31Aug99

When - TG1 done by Dec00

~Jun97 - Idea for standard Mar98 - Find Sponsor Feb99 - Submit PAR Mar99 - Approve PAR Jul99 - Organize working

group Sep99 - Develop draft

standard Nov99 - Ballot draft standard Mar00 - Approve draft

standard Dec00 - Publish approved

standardYou could be here

31Aug99

Participant Goals

“Do the right job at the right time." ETSI - IEEE-SA Co-operative Agreement 21Apr99– Annex1 b) IEEE-SA 802 (Radio LANs), number 3

IEEE wants to comply to following statement from the Bluetooth SIG:– “Additionally the Bluetooth SIG is currently in discussions

with ETSI to develop a world-wide standard based on Bluetooth that covers the entire Bluetooth capabilities stack. If these discussions go forward, then the Bluetooth SIG would like ETSI and IEEE coordinates their efforts so that both standards interoperate.” Jim Kardach, 15Jul99

31Aug99

How to cooperate

Scenario Planning– Scenario 1

31Aug99

Scenario 1

Bluetooth v1.0 A Foundation Specification – L1-L7

Standard– ETSI L3-L7

– IEEE 802 L1-L2Physical Layer

(PHY)

Medium AccessControl (MAC)

Logical Link Control(LLC)

Physical

Data Link

Network

Transport

Session

Presentation

Application7

6

5

4

3

2

1

ISO OSILayers

IEEE 802Standards

Hardware

Software

Transport Control Protocol (TCP)

Internet Protocol (IP)

X.400 and X.500 EMAIL

{= ETSI/IEEE

Interface

31Aug99

Scenario 1 (cont.)

Issues– Prevent consumer and

user confusion that could result from non-interoperable specifications, and

– Provide a mechanism to test interoperability between Bluetooth, IEEE, and ETSI solutions by maintaining appropriate testing interfaces.

?

31Aug99

Scenario 1 (cont.)

Physical

Data Link

Network

Transport

Session

Presentation

Application

Physical

Data Link

Network

Transport

Session

Presentation

Application

=

Physical

Data Link

Network

Transport

Session

Presentation

Application

=

Specification Standards Development Standards

31Aug99

Scenario 1 (cont.)

Summary– The IEEE feels a cooperative arrangement

could be agreed to by both Standards Development Organizations.

– We would envision IEEE carrying the ETSI standard so users could get both and the same for ETSI by having them carry the IEEE standard.

31Aug99

Next Steps

Exchanging of information from the P802.15 e.g., Bluetooth/IEEE areas, Accessibility of Bluetooth/IEEE working documents and Bluetooth/IEEE

drafts, and The nomination of an observer from IEEE P802.15 Working Group to the

relevant ETSI technical body and vice-versa Sharing Bluetooth/IEEE agendas that contain items of mutual interest ETSI to commit to the conversion of IEEE P802.15 (OSI/ISO Layer 1 and

2) outputs into ETSI deliverables by a "to be" designated ETSI Technical Body and vice-versa

If this ETSI Technical Body is inclined then we welcome ETSI Editor assistance in drafting this IEEE P802.15 (OSI/ISO Layer 1 and 2) document(s)

Recruit ETSI Technical Body Members into IEEE P802.15 Identify ETSI role in the P802.15.1 Draft Comments

31Aug99

Draft Comments - ETSI’s Role?

31Aug99

IEEE: Contact Information

Richard J. Holleman - IEEE Standards Board Chairman– holleman@us.ibm.com– Tel: +1 914 765 4375

Donald N. Heirman, NCE, IEEE Standards Board Vice Chairman– d.heirman@worldnet.att.net– Tel: +1 732-741-7723

Susan Tatiner, Director Standards Publishing Programs– s.tatiner@ieee.org– Tel: +1 732 562 3830

Jerome T. Walker, Manager Business Development– j.t.walker@ieee.org– Tel: +1 732 562 3823

Ian C. Gifford - IEEE P802.15.1 Chair– giffordi@amp.com– Tel: +1 978 442 4650

Tom Siep - IEEE P802.15.1 Editor– siep@ti.com– Tel: +1 972 480 6786

31Aug99

IEEE: Additional Information

IEEE/ETSI 3 year cooperative agreement– http://standards.ieee.org/board/stdsbd/1998index.html

IEEE General– http://www.ieee.org/– http://standards.ieee.org/– http://standards.ieee.org/faqs/index.html

IEEE P802.15 WG– http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/15/