il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina...

47
IL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA REFRATTARIA IL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA REFRATTARIA IL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA REFRATTARIA IL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA REFRATTARIA MEDIANTE UTILIZZO DI ONDE D’URTO: MEDIANTE UTILIZZO DI ONDE D’URTO: UN ANNO DI ESPERIENZA UN ANNO DI ESPERIENZA G ALUNNI G ALUNNI G. ALUNNI G. ALUNNI Cardiologia 2 Cardiologia 2 S. Giovanni Battista S. Giovanni Battista Molinette Molinette S. Giovanni Battista S. Giovanni Battista Molinette Molinette Torino Torino Italy Italy

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jul-2020

10 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

IL TRATTAMENTO DELL’ANGINA REFRATTARIAIL TRATTAMENTO DELL’ANGINA REFRATTARIAIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA REFRATTARIA IL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA REFRATTARIA MEDIANTE UTILIZZO DI ONDE D’URTO:MEDIANTE UTILIZZO DI ONDE D’URTO:

UN ANNO DI ESPERIENZAUN ANNO DI ESPERIENZAG ALUNNIG ALUNNIG. ALUNNI G. ALUNNI

Cardiologia 2Cardiologia 2S. Giovanni BattistaS. Giovanni Battista ––MolinetteMolinetteS. Giovanni Battista S. Giovanni Battista MolinetteMolinette

TorinoTorinoItalyItaly

Page 2: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria
Page 3: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria
Page 4: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria
Page 5: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria
Page 6: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

ESMR TherapyESMR TherapyExtracorporeal Shockwave Extracorporeal Shockwave

Myocardial RevascularizationMyocardial Revascularization• Shockwaves are special acoustics waves

that can be targeted and focused non-invasively to a selected area inside the patient body.

• Shock wave therapy have been used in the last decades in Urology (kidney stone lithotripsy) and Orthopedics (plantar facilities) applications.

• In-vitro and animal data show an increase of angiogenic factors and neo-vascularization after treatment of low intensity shock waves (1/10 of the energy of lithotripsy).

• Therapeutic effect is localized, precise (<2 mm precision) and controlled.

Page 7: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

AimAimAimAim

Treatment for patients with no longer benefit from current revascularization methods inducing Local Angiogenesis at Myocardial Ischemic Areas UsingAngiogenesis at Myocardial Ischemic Areas Using Low Intensity, Non Invasive, Focused Shockwaves

Angioplasty CABG ESMR

Page 8: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Main Physiological EffectsMain Physiological EffectsMain Physiological EffectsMain Physiological Effects

Short TermEffectEffect

Local Vasodilatation

Long Term Effect

Angiogenesis

Page 9: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

ESMR TherapyESMR TherapyExtracorporeal Shockwave Myocardial RevascularizationExtracorporeal Shockwave Myocardial RevascularizationExtracorporeal Shockwave Myocardial RevascularizationExtracorporeal Shockwave Myocardial Revascularization

Short treatment time due to large treatment zone• Short treatment time due to large treatment zone (~20 minutes)

• Out-patient settings (no need for hospitalization)

E h di h id d• Echocardiography guided

(non-invasive revascularization)(non invasive revascularization)

• Low intensity shockwaves – 1/10 of lithotripsy)

Page 10: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

11 medical centers 175 patients:Reduction in CCS classReduction in CCS class

11 medical centers, 175 patients:

%

36.8% Mean improvement

Page 11: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Dynamics of main indicators with SW treatmentsDynamics of main indicators with SW treatmentsR h N Nit t QOL St EF P f iResearch N Nitrates QOL Stress

toleranceEF Perfusion

Caspari GH, 1999 9 + (70%) + (91%) +Gutersohn A, 2005 23 + (60%)Fukumoto Y, 2006 9 94% + (25%) +Schmid J 2006 8 + (16%) + (17%)Schmid J., 2006 8 + (16%) + (17%)

Gutersohn A, 2006 14 + (43%) + (70%)Naber C, 2006 25 +(64%) +К. Lyadov, 2006 13 + (33%) +(60%) +A. Khattab, 2007 10 +(75%)I Кoltunov 2008 20 + +I. Кoltunov, 2008 20 + +Faber L., 2008 16 + (23%) + (63%)

V i J 2008 8 79% + (75%)Vainer J., 2008 8 79% + (75%)

Zuoziene G., 2009 10 94% +

Y. Vasyuk, 2009 26 64% + + (21%) + + (55%)

Page 12: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

ESMR TherapyESMR TherapyExtracorporeal Shockwave Extracorporeal Shockwave

Myocardial RevascularizationMyocardial RevascularizationMyocardial RevascularizationMyocardial Revascularization

OUR EXPERIENCEOUR EXPERIENCE

Page 13: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

ESMR Therapy ESMR Therapy pypyPROTOCOL (1)

I l i it iInclusion criteria• Reversible ischemia and/or hibernation to SPECT e e s b e sc e a a d/o be at o to S C

• CCS Class II-IV

• PCI / CABG not applicable.

• Angina pectoris (dyspnea) > 3 months g p ( y p )

• Stable dosage of medication used to treat angina for at least 6 weeks prior to enrollment.p

Page 14: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

ESMR Therapy ESMR Therapy PROTOCOL (2)

E l i it iExclusion criteria• Acute MI < 3 months prior to treatment

• Patient with intraventricular thrombus

• Severe COPD• Severe COPD

• Patient has active endocarditis, myocarditis or pericarditispericarditis.

• Pregnancy

• Malignancy

Page 15: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Primary and Secondary End-Points3-6 months post baseline

P i E d P i t• Primary End-Point:– CCS class (3M – 6M)– SPECT perfusion (6 M)

• Secondary End-Points:Secondary End Points:– EF ECHO

NTG up take– NTG up-take– Re ACS/AMI

R H it li ti– Re-Hospitalization– Death

Page 16: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Treatment ProtocolTreatment ProtocolTreatment ProtocolTreatment Protocol

W k 1 W k 2 W k 3Week 1 Week 2 Week 3

Week 4 Week 5 Week 6

Week 7 Week 8 Week 9

3 treatments per week at 5-10 ischemic zones 100 shocks per zone 0 09 mj/mm23 treatments per week at 5-10 ischemic zones, 100 shocks per zone, 0.09 mj/mm

Page 17: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Locating ROI (Region of Interest)Locating ROI (Region of Interest)Locating ROI (Region of Interest)Locating ROI (Region of Interest)SPECT

Page 18: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Dividing ROI according to weeksDividing ROI according to weeksg gg g

SPECT ECHOSPECT ECHO

Page 19: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Identifying treatment zonesIdentifying treatment zonesIdentifying treatment zonesIdentifying treatment zones

ECHOECHO

- Week 1

ECHOECHO

Week 9- Week 5- Week 9

For 3 days, same area at the same week

1 2- 1 cm2

Page 20: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria
Page 21: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

ESMR Therapy ESMR Therapy PURPOSE

F t f 20 ti t

PURPOSE

• Forecast of 20 patients

C l t d t t t t 15 ti t• Completed to treatment 15 patients

• 5 patients going to treat

• AGE 72 ± 5,6 (58-84)

• 80% M, 20% F

Page 22: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

GENERAL POPULATIONCV HISTORY - CRF

Page 23: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

GENERAL POPULATIONCV HISTORY

Page 24: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

CORONARY ANATOMYCORONARY ANATOMY

Page 25: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

GENERAL POPULATIONTHERAPY

Page 26: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

ESMR Therapy ESMR Therapy RESULTS

• 15 patients treated

• 11 patients underwent SPECT after the treatment

• 4 patient waiting for to SPECT in april

• 5 patients waiting for to treatment

• No side effects

Page 27: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

RESULTSSECONDARY END-POINTS

6 M3 M 6 M

++ 7%

P=0.00061M 1 HOSP (0,06%) p ns3 M 1 HOSP (0,06%) p ns

1M 2 TNT (0,13%) p ns3 M 1 TNT (0,06%) p ns

Page 28: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

RESULTSPRIMARY END-POINTS 3-6 MPRIMARY END POINTS 3 6 M

CCS

-40%P=0.0001

-54%

3 M 6 MPRE

P=0.0001

Page 29: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

PRIMARY END-POINTS 6 M TOTAL LV ANALISIS TO SPECT

A l i th dAnalysis method

• SPECT study performed during Rest and Stress pre and post treatment (4 studies for patient)

• 17 segments model

0 5 grading for perfusion for each• 0-5 grading for perfusion for each segment at Rest and at Stress– Class 0 : normal perfusion– Class 5 : no perfusionClass 5 : no perfusion

Page 30: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

RESULTSPRIMARY END-POINTS 6 M

TOTAL LV ANALISIS TO SPECT - REST0 Normal perfusion,

no disturbance

1 Minimal perfusion P=0.021+ 17 %

1 defect

2 Mild perfusion defect

3 Moderate perfusion defectdefect

4 Severe perfusion defect

5 No perfusion

16 %-16 %- 75%

Page 31: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

RESULTSPRIMARY END-POINTS 6 M

TOTAL LV ANALISIS TO SPECT - STRESS0 Normal perfusion,

no disturbance

1 Minimal perfusion 74%

PRE POST+20%

1 defect

2 Mild perfusion defect

3 Moderate perfusion defect

59%

74%

P=0.0009defect

4 Severe perfusion defect

5 No perfusion

15%8%9% 7%

-54% -75%

0 1 2 3 4 5

6% 6% 8% 6%3%9% 7%

2% 5%

0 1 2 3 4 5

Page 32: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria
Page 33: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

O C anni 83O.C. anni 83

Page 34: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

O C anni 83O.C. anni 83

Page 35: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

O.C. anni 83O.C. anni 83

PRE ESMR POST ESMR

Page 36: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

SPECT PRE ESMR

Page 37: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

SPECT POST ESMRSPECT POST ESMR

Page 38: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

RESULTS

• CCS%improvement at three months: 40%

improvement at six months: 54%

• TOTAL LV ANALISI SPECT REST :Improvement: 17% normal perfusion (Class 0)Improvement: 17% normal perfusion (Class 0)Reduction: 16% minimal perfusion (Class 1)Reduction: 75% medial perfusion defect (Class 2)

• TOTAL LV ANALISIS SPECT STRESS:Improvement: + 20% normal perfusion (Class 0)Reduction: 54% moderate perfusione defect (class 3) Reduction: 75 % severe perfusion defect (Class 4)Reduction: 75 % severe perfusion defect (Class 4)

Page 39: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

CONCLUSIONSOUR EXSPERIENCEOUR EXSPERIENCE

• No side effectsI t CCS• Improvement CCS: - 40% 3M; -54% 6M

• Improvement perfusion to SPECT- 75% medial perfusion defect (REST)- 54% moderate perfusione defect (STRESS) - 75 % severe perfusion defect (STRESS)

• No adverse events (3-6 M)• IMA-ACS• Re-PCI

• wait for new results

Page 40: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

GRAZIEGRAZIE

FOLLIA E’ FARE SEMPRE LA STESSA COSA EDFOLLIA E FARE SEMPRE LA STESSA COSA ED ASPETTARSI RISULTATI DIVERSI

Albert Einstein

Page 41: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Treatment StrategyTreatment StrategyTreatment StrategyTreatment Strategy

At each treatment session shock a es sho ld be deli ered to theAt each treatment session shock waves should be delivered to theborder of the ischemic area triggering the viable tissue forangiogenesisangiogenesis

Week 1 Week 5 Week 9Wee Wee 5 Week 9

Page 42: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

Cardiospec System ComponentsCardiospec System ComponentsCardiospec System ComponentsCardiospec System Components

Ultra-Sound

ECG Monitor

ControlPanel

(US) system

Shock Wave

US probe

Applicator (SWA)

Patient

Shock Wave Unit

Page 43: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

O C anni 83O.C. anni 83PRE ESMR POST ESMR

Page 44: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

O.C. anni 83O.C. anni 83

PRE ESMR POST ESMRPRE ESMR POST ESMR

Page 45: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

GENERAL POPULATIONCRF

Page 46: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

GENERAL POPULATIONCV HISTORY

Page 47: IL TRATTAMENTO DELLIL TRATTAMENTO DELL ANGINA’ANGINA ...deart.s3.amazonaws.com/dreamsas/2011/Alunni.pdf · il trattamento dellil trattamento dell angina’angina refrattaria refrattaria

ESMR TherapyESMR TherapyExtracorporeal Shockwave Myocardial RevascularizationExtracorporeal Shockwave Myocardial RevascularizationExtracorporeal Shockwave Myocardial RevascularizationExtracorporeal Shockwave Myocardial Revascularization

-- ConclusionsConclusions

• Safe– No arrhythmias

No cardiac enzyme rise– No cardiac enzyme rise– No device related side effects were reported

• Improvement in the following prameters :– CCS class score– Exercise Tolerance Time – Angina threshold at exercise

Myocardial perfusion shown by SPECT– Myocardial perfusion shown by SPECT – Local contractility shown by Stress-echo – Quality of life shown by SAQy y