ilc global design effortbcbact/talks06/lcws india talk 03-0… · barish - snowmass plenary talk....

37
ILC Global Design Effort Barry Barish GDE 9-March-06

Upload: others

Post on 18-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

ILC Global Design Effort

Barry BarishGDE

9-March-06

Page 2: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 2

Global Design Effort (GDE)• On March 18, 2005, during the opening of LCWS05

workshop at Stanford University, I officially accepted the position of Director of the (yet to be formed) GDE

Page 3: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 3

Global Design Effort

– The Mission of the GDE • Produce a design for the ILC that includes a

detailed design concept, performance assessments, reliable international costing, an industrialization plan , siting analysis, as well as detector concepts and scope.

• Coordinate worldwide prioritized proposal driven R & D efforts (to demonstrate and improve the performance, reduce the costs, attain the required reliability, etc.)

Page 4: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 4

GDE Begins at Snowmass

GDE MembersAmericas 22 Europe 24 Asia 16

Page 5: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 5

Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk

Page 6: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6

main linacbunchcompressor

dampingring

source

pre-accelerator

collimation

final focus

IP

extraction& dump

KeV

few GeV

few GeVfew GeV

250-500 GeV

Designing a Linear Collider

Superconducting RF Main Linac

Page 7: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 7

Baseline Configuration Document

• Our ‘Deliverable’ by the end of 2005

• A structured electronic document– Documentation (reports, drawings etc)– Technical specs.– Parameter tables

Page 8: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 8

Structure of the BCD

Summary-like overview for those who want to understand the choice and the why

Technical documentationof the baseline, for engineers and acc. phys. making studies towards RDR

Page 9: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 9

Alternatives Section(s)

Note ACD is part of the BCD

Page 10: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 10

The Key Decisions

Critical choices: luminosity parameters & gradient

Page 11: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 11

Making Choices – The Tradeoffs

Many decisions are interrelated and require input from several WG/GG groups

Page 12: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 12

Parametric Approach

• A working space - optimize machine for cost/performance

Page 13: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 13

From Snowmass to a Baseline

August September October November December

2005Snowmass

WW/GG summaries

Response to list of 40+ decisions

All documented ‘recommendations available on ILC Website (request community feedback)

Review by BCD EC BCD EC publishes‘strawman’ BCD

PublicReview Frascati

GDE meeting

BCD Executive Committee:BarishDugan, Foster, Takasaki Raubenheimer, Yokoya, Walker

Page 14: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 14

The Baseline Machine (500GeV)

not to scale

~30 km

e+ undulator @ 150 GeV (~1.2km)x2R = 955m

E = 5 GeV

RTML ~1.6kmML ~10km (G = 31.5MV/m)20mr

2mr BDS 5km

Page 15: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 15

Electron Source

Positron-style room-temperature

accelerating section

diagnostics section

standard ILC SCRF modules

sub-harmonic bunchers + solenoids

laser E=70-100 MeV

• DC Guns incorporating photocathode illuminated by a Ti: Sapphiredrive laser.

• Long electron microbunches (~2 ns) are bunched in a bunching section

• Accelerated in a room temperature linac to about 100 MeV and SRF linac to 5 GeV.

DC gun(s)

Page 16: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 16

Positron Source

Primary e-

source

e-

DR

Target e-

Dump

Photon Beam Dump

e+

DR

Auxiliary e-

Source

Photon Collimators

Adiabatic Matching

Device

e+ pre-accelerator

~5GeV

150 GeV 100 GeVHelical

UndulatorIn By-Pass

Line

PhotonTarget

250 GeVPositron Linac

IP

Beam Delivery System

Keep Alive: This source would have all bunches filled to 10% of nominal intensity.

Helical Undulator Based Positron Source with Keep Alive System

Page 17: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 17

ILC Small Damping Ring

Multi-Bunch Trains with inter-train gaps

Page 18: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 18

ILC Damping Ring: Baseline Design

• Positrons:– Two rings of ~6 km circumference in

a single tunnel.

– Two rings are needed to reduce e-cloud effects unless significantprogress can be made withmitigation techniques.

– Preferred to 17 km dogbone due to:• Space-charge effects • Acceptance • Tunnel layout (commissioning time,stray fields)

• Electrons:– One 6 km ring.

Page 19: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 19

Main Linac: SRF Cavity Gradient

Cavity type

Qualifiedgradient

Operational gradient

Length* energy

TESLA

LL

MV/m MV/m Km

initial 35 31.5 10.6 250

upgrade

GeV

40 36.0 +9.3 500

* assuming 75% fill factorTotal length of one 500 GeV linac ≈ 20km

Page 20: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 20

Cavity: R&D

• Material R&D: Fine, Large, Single Crystal• Fabrication

– A number of minor modifications and improvements could be implemented without impact to the basic cavity design.

• Cavity Preparation • Buffer Chemical Processing• Cavity Processing (strong R&D needed)

– Electro-polishing (EP) System– High Pressure Rinsing (HPR)– Assembly Procedure

Page 21: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 21

Superconducting RF Cavities

High Gradient Accelerator35 MV/meter -- 40 km linear collider

Page 22: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 22

Improved ProcessingElectropolishing

Chemical Polish

Electro Polish

Page 23: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 23

RF Power: ModulatorBaseline

Alternate

The Bouncer Compensated Pulse Transformer Style Modulator

Operation: an array of capacitors is charged in parallel, discharged in series. (~2m)

Will test full prototype in 2006

Page 24: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 24

RF Power: Baseline Klystrons

Thales CPI Toshiba

Specification:

10MW MBK

1.5ms pulse

65% efficiency

Page 25: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 25

Increasediameter beyond X-FEL

Increasediameter beyond X-FEL

Review 2-phase pipe size and effect of slope

ILC Cryomodule

Page 26: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 26

ILC Beam Delivery System

• Baseline – two BDSs, 20/2mrad, 2 detectors, 2 longitudinally separated IR

halls• Alternative 1

– two BDSs, 20/2mrad, 2 detectors in single IR hall @ Z=0• Alternative 2

– single IR/BDS, collider hall long enough for two push-pull detectors

Page 27: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 27

ILC Siting and Conventional Facilities

• The design is intimately tied to the features of the site– 1 tunnels or 2 tunnels?– Deep or shallow?– Laser straight linac or follow earth’s curvature in

segments?

• GDE ILC Design will be done to samples sites in the three regions

Page 28: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 28

The GDE after Six Months

• How have we done?– We are on track – BCD produced by end of 2005

as promised. It will provide a sound basis for entering into a reference design effort, globally coordinate R&D program, begin industrialization, determine costs, etc. next year

• What’s Next?– Undertaking Design/Cost effort toward Reference

Design Report (RDR)– Assessing present R&D program to begin to

provide global guidance in the future.

Page 29: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 29

Next Goal – Reference Design

• Reorganized the GDE toward Design / Cost Effort • A global effort to design / cost the ILC is

underway and working• Configuration Control; International Costing;

Industrialization; Siting--------------------------

• A sound design must be established with convincing and affordable costing.

• Global R&D program to demonstrate the ILC, improve over the baseline and reduce costs.

Page 30: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 30

ICFA FALC

FALC Resource Board

ILCSC

GDEDirectorate

GDEExecutive Committee

GlobalR&D Program

RDR Design Matrix

GDER & D Board

GDEChange Control Board

GDEDesign Cost Board

GDE RDR / R&D Organization

Page 31: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 31

ICFA FALC

FALC Resource Board

ILCSC

GDEDirectorate

GDEExecutive Committee

GlobalR&D Program

RDR Design Matrix

GDER & D Board

GDEChange Control Board

GDEDesign Cost Board

GDE RDR / R&D Organization

Reporting

resourcestechnical

Page 32: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 32

ICFA FALC

FALC Resource Board

ILCSC

GDEDirectorate

GDEExecutive Committee

GlobalR&D Program

RDR Design Matrix

GDER & D Board

GDEChange Control Board

GDEDesign Cost Board

GDE RDR / R&D Organization

GDE

Page 33: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 33

ICFA FALC

FALC Resource Board

ILCSC

GDEDirectorate

GDEExecutive Committee

GlobalR&D Program

RDR Design Matrix

GDER & D Board

GDEChange Control Board

GDEDesign Cost Board

GDE RDR / R&D Organization

ILCDesignEffort

ILCR&D

Program

Page 34: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 34

Technical SystemsVacuum systemsMagnet systemsCryomoduleCavity PackageRF Power

InstrumentationDumps and CollimatorsAccelerator Physics

Global SystemsCommissioning, Operations & ReliabilityControl SystemCryogenicsCF&SInstallation

Area Systems e- e+ damping RTML main BDSsource source rings linac

Cost Roll-ups

Page 35: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 35

From Baseline to a RDRJan July Dec

2006

Freeze ConfigurationOrganize for RDR

Bangalore

Review Design/Cost Methodology

Review InitialDesign / Cost Review Final

Design / CostRDR Document

Design and Costing PreliminaryRDR

Released

Frascati Vancouver Valencia

Page 36: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

Internationl Linear Collider Timeline

2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

Global Design Effort Project

Baseline configuration

Reference Design

ILC R&D Program

Technical Design

Expression of Interest to Host

International Mgmt

Page 37: ILC Global Design EffortBCBAct/talks06/LCWS India Talk 03-0… · Barish - Snowmass Plenary Talk. 9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 6 bunch main linac compressor damping ring source pre-accelerator

9-March-06 LCWS06 Bangalore 37

Conclusions

• The baseline configuration for the ILC has been established and is document in the BCD (a 700+ page electronic document)

• We have put the BCD under configuration control and are evolving it now in a controlled manner

• The BCD also defines alternatives and the combination of the baseline and alternative will give good guidance for the ILC R&D program

• The BCD is now being used as the reference and basis for the reference design / cost effort this year. This is a much tougher job!