illegitimate mothers: discursive renegotiation of the unlawful, the...

34
Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the Misbegotten, and the Misbehaving Dr. Teresa Winterhalter Armstrong Atlantic State University Dr. Beth Howells Armstrong Atlantic State University Mr. Benjamin Winterhalter Boston College Law School

Upload: others

Post on 12-Jul-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the Misbegotten, and the Misbehaving

Dr. Teresa WinterhalterArmstrong Atlantic State UniversityDr. Beth HowellsArmstrong Atlantic State UniversityMr. Benjamin WinterhalterBoston College Law School

Page 2: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

“Mothers don’t write, they are written.”

Helene Deutsch

Page 3: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

“Thou ill-formed offspring of my feeble brain,Who after birth didst by my side remain,Till snatched from thence by friends, less wise than true,Who thee abroad, exposed to public view…”

Anne Bradstreetfrom “The Author to Her Bookcirca 1687

“…my hideous progeny…”Mary Shelleyfrom “The Preface” to Frankenstein1837 edition

Page 4: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Caravaggio, The Sacrifice of Isaac, 1603Oil on canvas, 41 x 53

Page 5: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Rafaello Sanzio, The Judgment of Solomon, 1518

Fresco, The Vatican

Page 6: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

She put her head in her hands. Then she reached in and, focusing as well as she could with one hand, the baby slapping at her through the bars, wheezing with laughter, she found one cool bare thigh, the rosy tightness of it, and pinched it with three fingers, kept pinching hard, till she got that angry uvula again, and a good bit of very wet tongue. Through the magnifier it was spiny as some plant, some sponge maybe, under the sea.

Rosellen Brown

Page 7: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Rocking the Cradle and Rocking the Boat: The Complicated

Community of “Mommy Blogs”

Page 8: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Kate Daniels, “In My Office at Bennington”

But then I hear the voices of my children…

Page 9: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Kate Daniels, “In My Office at Bennington”

And I’m paper torn in half,

Page 10: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Kate Daniels, “In My Office at Bennington”

the poem that didn’t work,the wrong words, sour sounds, ruptured rhythms, the confusionas to what was meant, what I actuallydesired besides those three small facesraised to my open window, callingmy name over and over, Mama?

Page 11: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

NYT, Review of Books, AO Scott 2006

Page 12: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Mommy Blogs

Page 13: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Infertility

Page 14: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Boredom/Confessional

Page 15: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Graphic Irreverance

Page 16: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Humor/Survival of Child Abuse

Page 17: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Single Parents

Page 18: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Blogging as a radical act

Page 19: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

Dooce

Page 20: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation

The Bathroom Redo

Page 21: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 22: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 23: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 24: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 25: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 26: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 27: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 28: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 29: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 30: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 31: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 32: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 33: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation
Page 34: Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation of the Unlawful, the …mediaserv.law.du.edu/flashvideo/specialevents... · 2010-03-23 · Illegitimate Mothers: Discursive Renegotiation